Origins and Comparative Performance of the Composite Bow
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Origins and Comparative Performance of the Composite Bow by Karl Chandler Randall IV Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF LITERATURE AND PHILOSOPHY in the subject of CLASSICAL STUDIES at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA Promoters: Doctor Martine De Marre and Doctor Barry Molloy February 2016 1 Student Number: 50786806 I declare that Origins and Comparative Performance of the Composite Bow is my own work and that all the sources used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references. 2 SUMMARY This thesis shall identify the date origin of the composite bow within Mesopotamia and Elam. and both identify and quantify the design factors which lead to increased performance possible with composite construction. To accomplish this, the thesis begins by summarizing the problems and flaws that currently exist in the field of history as it applies specifically to archery and bow use. With problems identified, the thesis will then introduce the reader to the basics of bow mechanics, thereby laying the basis for physical testing. This in turn will empirically demonstrate flaws in the current iconographical method of bow identification. The thesis will then devise a new method for iconographic identification of composite construction that has greater proven accuracy, based upon proportional length, which will link extant artifacts with both physical test results and iconographic evidence. The reader shall then be led through a complete reevaluation of iconographical evidence for Mesopotamia and Elam starting at the beginning of the second millennium BCE and working backwards using this new method of iconographic evaluation to determine the point at which composite bow technology first appears in the ancient Near East. The thesis will finish with an overview of the above accomplishments and their potential impact on the study of ancient and military history. KEY TERMS Ancient History, Military History, Archery, Bow, Composite, Experimental Archaeology, Egypt, Mesopotamia, Elam, Arrow 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF FIGURES 5 LIST OF TABLES 13 ABBREVIATIONS 15 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 16 PREFACE 17 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION 20 CURRENT STATE OF KNOWLEDGE 22 TOPICAL IMPORT 24 METHODOLOGY AND CHAPTER PROGRESSION 26 CONCLUSION 35 CHAPTER TWO: NOMENCLATURE AND LITERATURE REVIEW 36 NOMENCLATURE 37 HISTORICAL CONSTRUCTION TERMINOLOGY 37 PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION TERMINOLOGY 42 HISTORICAL PROFILE TERMINOLOGY 43 PROPOSED PROFILE TERMINOLOGY 44 WEAPON CAPABILITIES 45 THE ADVANTAGE OF COMPOSITE CONSTRUCTION 49 EXPERIMENTAL ARCHAEOLOGY 51 DATING THE INCEPTION OF COMPOSITE BOW TECHNOLOGY 55 CONCLUSION 58 CHAPTER THREE: ANCIENT SOURCES 60 ARTIFACTS 60 EGYPT 61 SIBERIA 62 MESOPOTAMIA AND ELAM 63 EUROPE 63 TEXTUAL SOURCES 65 MYCENAE, GREECE AND ROME 65 EGYPT 66 MESOPOTAMIA AND ELAM 67 ICONOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE 68 EGYPT 72 EUROPE 76 MESOPOTAMIA AND ELAM 80 CONCLUSION 86 CHAPTER FOUR: BOW MECHANICS 88 ENERGY INPUT FACTORS 89 DRAW WEIGHT 89 DRAW LENGTH 92 BRACE HEIGHT 93 UNSTRUNG BOW PROFILE 95 THE DRAW-FORCE CURVE 97 FACTORS INFLUENCING ENERGY OUTPUT (INEFFICIENCIES) 102 ELASTIC HYSTERESIS 102 BOW LIMB MASS 104 4 STRING MASS 104 STRING STRETCH 105 NOCK FRICTION 105 OTHER SOURCES OF INEFFICIENCY 105 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSTRAINTS 106 CONCLUSION 107 CHAPTER FIVE: EXAMINATION OF BOW/CHARIOT RAILING INTERFERENCE 109 CHARIOT TESTING 115 BOW CONSTRUCTION 115 CHARIOT DESIGN 118 CHARIOT CONSTRUCTION 120 TESTING 122 TEST RESULTS 124 CONCLUSION 127 CHAPTER SIX: PHYSICAL TESTING 128 MATERIAL TESTING 130 TEST DESIGN 130 INITIAL BOW CONSTRUCTION 131 SINEW BACKING 133 CONTROL TESTING: WOOD BELLY SLATS 137 HORN BELLY 137 TEST RESULTS 139 MATERIALS TESTING: CONCLUSION 144 PROFILE TESTING 147 TEST DESIGN 147 DRAW-FORCE CURVES 148 PROFILE TESTING: CONCLUSION 158 MASS TESTING 160 TEST DESIGN 160 TESTING 162 TEST RESULTS 165 MASS TESTING: CONCLUSION 172 CONCLUSION 174 CHAPTER SEVEN: ICONOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS 178 METHODOLOGY FOR THE ICONOGRAPHIC IDENTIFICATION OF COMPOSITE CONSTRUCTION 179 ICONOGRAPHIC CONVENTIONS IN EARLY MESOPOTAMIA AND ELAM 182 QUESTIONS OF CONSISTENCY 188 ICONOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS 194 ANGULAR PROFILE: 2300-1850 BCE 194 DOUBLE-CONCAVE PROFILE: WORKING RECURVE DESIGN, 2400-1900 BCE 198 DOUBLE-CONCAVE PROFILE: STATIC RECURVE DESIGN, 3800-2400 BCE 205 CONCLUSION 214 CHAPTER EIGHT: CONCLUSION 216 CONCLUSION 231 APPENDIX A: PHYSICAL TEST DATA 233 BIBLIOGRAPHY 257 5 LIST OF FIGURES Fig. 2.1 Anadaman Bow Archery, 1894 40 Fig. 2.2 Pellet Bow Traditional Archery from Six Continents, 2007 40 Fig 2.3 Double Bow Composite Bows from the Tomb of Tut.ankam.um, 1970 43 Fig. 2.4 Double Bow Bows of the World, 2002 43 Fig. 2.5 Double-Concave Self Bow The Traditional Bowyer's Bible, Vol. 3, 1994 57 Fig 2.6 Composite Bow North American Bows, Arrows and Quivers an Illustrated History,2007 57 Fig. 2.7 Self Bow Encyclopedia of Native American Bows Arrows and Quivers, 1999 57 Fig. 3.1 Composite Bow, Siberia The Neolithic Age in Eastern Siberia, 1958 63 Fig 3.2 Grave Goods Bow, Poland A Late Neolithic Composite Bow, 1987 64 Fig. 3.3 Overly Long Bowstring Korean Games and Sports: Modern and Traditional, 2011 70 Fig. 3.4 Loose Bowstring The Ancient Assyrians, 1991 70 Fig. 3.5 Archery Training The Art of War in Biblical Lands, 1963 73 Fig. 3.6 Decorative Chest Lid The Art of War in Biblical Lands, 1963 74 Fig. 3.7 Chariot Archery The Art of War in Biblical Lands, 1963 74 Fig. 3.8 Funerary Stele The Art of War in Biblical Lands, 1963 75 Fig. 3.9 Nubian Archers http://condor.depaul.edu/sbucking/soldiers.jpg 75 Fig. 3.10 Siege Warfare Beni-Hasan, Part 1, 1893 75 Fig. 3.11 Rock Carving, Russia Les gravures rupestres des bords du lac Onégo et de La Mer Blache, 1938 77 Fig. 3.12 Rock Carving, Russia Les gravures rupestres des bords du lac Onégo et de La Mer Blache, 1938 77 Fig. 3.13 Rock Carving, Russia Les gravures rupestres des bords du lac Onégo et de La Mer Blache, 1938 77 Fig. 3.14 Stone Stele, Poland A Late Neolithic Composite Bow, 1987 77 Fig. 3.15 Rock Carving, Germany A Late Neolithic Composite Bow, 1987 79 Fig. 3.16 Rock Painting, Spanish Levant Les Peintures Rupestres du Levant Espangnol, 1984 79 6 Fig. 3.17 Seal Impression, Sippar First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 81 Fig. 3.18 Adda Seal Impression Art of the First Cities: The Third Millennium BC from the Mediterranean to the Indus, 2003 81 Fig. 3.19 Seal Impression, Akkad Art of the First Cities: The Third Millennium BC from the Mediterranean to the Indus, 2003 81 Fig. 3.20 Seal Impression, Kish First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 81 Fig. 3.21 Seal Impression First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 82 Fig. 3.22 Seal Impression First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 82 Fig. 3.23 Darband-i-Gawr Bas Relief http://www.panoramio.com/photo/10914487 83 Fig. 3.24 Naram-Sin Stele 5000 Years of the Art of Mesopotamia, 1964 83 Fig. 3.25 Seal Sketch, Susa First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 84 Fig. 3.26 Lion-Hunt Stele, Uruk 5000 Years of the Art of Mesopotamia, 1964 84 Fig. 3.27 Seal Impression, Uruk Art of the First Cities: The Third Millennium BC from the Mediterranean to the Indus, 2003 84 Fig. 3.28 Seal Sketch, Uruk First Impressions: Cylinder Seals in the Ancient Near East, 2005 84 Fig. 3.29 Potsherd, Tepe Jowi Art of the Ancient Near East, 1980 85 Fig. 3.30 Potsherd, Arpachiya Hunting and Shooting, 1983. 85 Fig. 4.1 Bow Draw Curvature Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 94 Fig. 4.2 Reversed Limb The Bowyer's Bible, Vol. 2, 1993 96 Fig. 4.3 Korean Bow Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 96 Fig. 4.4 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 98 Fig. 4.5 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 99 Fig. 4.6 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 99 Fig. 4.7 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 100 * Unpublished photo taken by the author or one of the author's assistants during the course of research. 7 Fig. 4.8 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 100 Fig. 4.9 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 101 Fig. 4.10 Draw-force Curve Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 103 Fig. 5.1 Ahmose I https://peripluscd.wordpress.com/tag/pelusium/ 114 Fig. 5.2 Thutmose IV The Tomb of Thoutmôsis IV, 1904 114 Fig. 5.3 Thutmose IV The Tomb of Thoutmôsis IV, 1904 115 Fig. 5.4 Amunhotep II War in Ancient Egypt, 2009 115 Fig. 5.5 PVC Molding Jig - Tip Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 116 Fig. 5.6 PVC Molding Jig - Set Screw Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2013* 116 Fig. 5.7 PVC and Heating Torch Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2009* 117 Fig. 5.8 Arrow with Field Point Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2009* 117 Fig. 5.9 Safety Tip Construction Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 117 Fig. 5.10 Complete Safety Tip Arrow Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 117 Fig. 5.11 Florence Chariot http://900090724.weebly.com/evolution.html 120 Fig. 5.12 Yuya-Thaya Chariot, Top View Transport in Ancient Egypt, 1996 120 Fig. 5.13 Chariot Build, Cab Base Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 121 Fig. 5.14 Chariot Build, Railing Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 121 Fig. 5.15 Chariot Build, Complete Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 122 Fig. 5.16 Chariot Build, Wheel Rim Unpublished Photo by Karl Randall, 2012* 122 Fig.