Pulling Abundance out of Thin Air: the Role of Camelid Pastoralism at 3000 B.P
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pulling Abundance Out of Thin Air: The Role of Camelid Pastoralism at 3000 B.P. The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Weber, Sadie Louise. 2019. Pulling Abundance Out of Thin Air: The Role of Camelid Pastoralism at 3000 B.P.. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:42013079 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Pulling Abundance out of Thin Air: The Role of Camelid Pastoralism at 3000 B.P. A Dissertation Presented by Sadie Louise Weber in partial fulfillment for the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of Anthropology Harvard University Cambridge, Massachusetts August 2019 Sadie Louise Weber All rights reserved. Dissertation Advisor: Richard H. Meadow Sadie Louise Weber Pulling Abundance out of Thin Air: The Role of Camelid Pastoralism at 3000 B.P. Abstract The goal of this dissertation is to investigate the effects of intensified and specialized camelid pastoralism on Andean societies, with specific focus on the Chavín culture, ca. 3,000 B.P. This research explores the hypothesis that the intensification of camelid pastoralism changed the lifeways of people living in the vicinity of monumental centers by increasing their access to a broader range of resources than were previously available, thus changing the nature of their economic base and increasing interregional interaction. I specifically look for the presence of intensified pastoral and agropastoral systems that may have initially been organized at the household level. Such intensification would have changed regional economies and led to the increasing spread of ideas and culture in the Central Andes. The Chavín culture is a well-known phenomenon in the Andes that resulted from a coalescence of previously established subsistence economies, innovations, architectural styles, iconographies, and ideologies. In essence, it was actually nothing new; what was “new” was its pervasiveness across ecologically diverse regions. The mechanism for this Andean cultural florescence, however, remains unclear. The pastoral economy in the Andes is multifaceted; llamas are used for meat, bone, sinews, and traction while alpacas are used for meat, bone, sinews, and fleece. Llama caravan trade once was the primary mode of transporting goods across the varying horizontal and vertical environmental zones of the Andes. This broad network allowed for increased interregional communication and interaction as networks grew in complexity and depth. I argue that intensive camelid pastoral economies produced the conditions necessary for the rapid and far-reaching spread of Chavín and that the broad, multi-faceted and multi-site study presented here will add to our understanding of the causes and processes of changes that took place during this time period. iii I explore zooarchaeological, archaeobotanical, and stable isotope data from Chavín de Huántar, and a contemporaneous albeit smaller site, Atalla, to measure intensification and integration of domesticated camelid pastoralism into early Andean societies. I use data from previously excavated 3,000 B.P. sites to 1) identify plant food resources and thus the regions involved in interregional trade; 2) determine regional interconnectedness; 3) reconstruct pastoral mobility patterns; and 4) determine the role camelid pastoralism played in the exchange of culture across the region while Chavín de Huántar was an active civic-ceremonial center. iv Table of Contents List of Figures ................................................................................................................................... viii List of Tables ...................................................................................................................................... ix Chapter 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 1 Structure of the Dissertation ..................................................................................................................... 4 2. Exchange and Interregional Interaction in the Central Andean Region.................................................... 9 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 9 Contexts for Exchange and Interaction: Ecozones and Environmental Variability .................................. 9 Ancient and Current Ecozones ................................................................................................................ 14 Archaeology of Exchange ....................................................................................................................... 16 Exchange and Interregional Interaction in the Andes ............................................................................. 16 Exchange and Interaction at 3,000 B.P. .................................................................................................. 20 Chapter 3: South American Camelid Pastoralism 24 Broad Views of Pastoralism .................................................................................................................... 24 Camelid Ecology and Behavior .............................................................................................................. 25 Defining and Describing Domestication ................................................................................................. 27 Camelid Domestication ........................................................................................................................... 31 Further Developments ............................................................................................................................. 33 Pastoralism and Social Complexity ........................................................................................................ 34 Camelids from El Yaral: A Cautionary Note .......................................................................................... 38 Ethnoarchaeology of Pastoralism............................................................................................................ 41 Agropastoralism .................................................................................................................................. 42 Fleece Production ................................................................................................................................ 43 Caravans .............................................................................................................................................. 43 Camelids and Ritual ................................................................................................................................ 45 Summary and Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 46 Chapter 4. Chavín de Huántar, Atalla, and their Predecessors ................................................................... 49 Chavín de Huántar .................................................................................................................................. 50 Geographic Setting .............................................................................................................................. 50 Chavín Art ........................................................................................................................................... 54 Past and Current Research at Chavín de Huántar ............................................................................... 56 La Banda: A Domestic Area at Chavín de Huántar ............................................................................ 60 Chavín Period Pastoral Economy ....................................................................................................... 61 v Atalla ....................................................................................................................................................... 62 Geographic and Cultural Context ....................................................................................................... 62 Current Research ................................................................................................................................. 64 Huancavelica Cinnabar and Interregional Interaction at Atalla .......................................................... 66 Interregional Interaction – “Chavín” within and beyond Chavín de Huántar. ........................................ 67 Antecedents ............................................................................................................................................. 68 Peopling of South America and Initial Developments ........................................................................ 69 Beginnings of Monumentality ............................................................................................................ 70 Chavín Contemporaries: Ceramics, Monumentality, and Interregional Interaction ........................... 74 Chapter 5. Zooarchaeology