Core 1..31 Journal (PRISM::Advent3b2 7.00)

Home , Art Hanger, Belinda Stronach, Carol Skelton, Greg Thompson, James Bezan, Jason Kenney

HOUSE OF COMMONS OF CANADA CHAMBRE DES COMMUNES DU CANADA 38th PARLIAMENT, 1st SESSION 38e LÉGISLATURE, 1re SESSION

Journals Journaux No. 4 No 4 Thursday, October 7, 2004 Le jeudi 7 octobre 2004 10:00 a.m. 10 heures

PRAYERS PRIÈRE

DEPUTY CHAIR OF COMMITTEES OF THE WHOLE VICE-PRÉSIDENT DES COMITÉS PLÉNIERS Pursuant to Order made Tuesday, October 5, 2004, the Speaker Conformément à l’ordre adopté le mardi 5 octobre 2004, le proposed that Mr. Proulx (Hull—Aylmer) be the candidate for the Président propose que M. Proulx (Hull—Aylmer) soit le candidat position of Deputy Chair of Committees of the Whole. au poste de vice-président des comités pléniers. Accordingly, the motion “That Mr. Proulx (Hull—Aylmer) be En conséquence, la motion « Que M. Proulx (Hull—Aylmer) appointed Deputy Chair of Committees of the Whole” was deemed soit nommé vice-président des comités pléniers » est réputée to have been moved and seconded. proposée et appuyée. The question was put on the motion and it was agreed to. La motion, mise aux voix, est agréée.

ASSISTANT DEPUTY CHAIR OF COMMITTEES OF THE VICE-PRÉSIDENT ADJOINT DES COMITÉS PLÉNIERS WHOLE Pursuant to Order made Tuesday, October 5, 2004, the Speaker Conformément à l’ordre adopté le mardi 5 octobre 2004, le proposed that Ms. Augustine (Etobicoke—Lakeshore) be the Président propose que Mme Augustine (Etobicoke—Lakeshore) candidate for the position of Assistant Deputy Chair of soit la candidate au poste de vice-présidente adjointe des comités Committees of the Whole. pléniers. Accordingly, the motion “That Ms. Augustine (Etobicoke— En conséquence, la motion « Que Mme Augustine (Etobicoke Lakeshore) be appointed Assistant Deputy Chair of Committees of —Lakeshore) soit nommée vice-présidente adjointe des comités the Whole” was deemed to have been moved and seconded. pléniers » est réputée proposée et appuyée. The question was put on the motion and it was agreed to. La motion, mise aux voix, est agréée.

DAILY ROUTINE OF BUSINESS AFFAIRES COURANTES ORDINAIRES

TABLING OF DOCUMENTS DÉPÔT DE DOCUMENTS Pursuant to Standing Order 32(2), the Prime Minister laid upon Conformément à l'article 32(2) du Règlement, le Premier the Table, — Document entitled “Conflict of Interest and Post- ministre dépose sur le Bureau, — Document intitulé « Code employment Code for Public Office Holders”. — Sessional Paper régissant la conduite des titulaires de charge publique en ce qui No. 8525-381-02. concerne les conflits d'intérêts et l'après-mandat ». — Document parlementaire no 8525-381-02.

INTRODUCTION OF PRIVATE MEMBERS'BILLS DÉPÔT DE PROJETS DE LOI ÉMANANT DES DÉPUTÉS Pursuant to Standing Orders 68(2) and 69(1), on motion of Mr. Conformément aux articles 68(2) et 69(1) du Règlement, sur Martin (Winnipeg Centre), seconded by Mr. Broadbent (Ottawa motion de M. Martin (Winnipeg-Centre), appuyé par M. Broadbent Centre), Bill C-201, An Act to amend the Access to Information (Ottawa-Centre), le projet de loi C-201, Loi modifiant la Loi sur 32 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Act and to make amendments to other Acts, was introduced, read l'accès à l'information et d'autres lois en conséquence, est déposé, the first time, ordered to be printed and ordered for a second lu une première fois, l'impression en est ordonnée et la deuxième reading at the next sitting of the House. lecture en est fixée à la prochaine séance de la Chambre.

PRESENTING PETITIONS PRÉSENTATION DE PÉTITIONS Pursuant to Standing Order 36, a petition certified correct by the Conformément à l'article 36 du Règlement, une pétition Clerk of Petitions was presented as follows: certifiée correcte par le greffier des pétitions est présentée : — by Mr. Williams (Edmonton—St. Albert), one concerning the — par M. Williams (Edmonton—St. Albert), une au sujet de income tax system (No. 381-0003). l'impôt sur le revenu (no 381-0003).

ADDRESS IN REPLY TO THE SPEECH FROM THE THRONE ADRESSE EN RÉPONSE AU DISCOURS DU TRÔNE The House resumed consideration of the motion of Mr. Silva La Chambre reprend l’étude de la motion de M. Silva (Davenport), seconded by Ms. Boivin (Gatineau), — That the (Davenport), appuyé par Mme Boivin (Gatineau), — Que following Address be presented to Her Excellency the Governor l'Adresse, dont le texte suit, soit présentée à Son Excellence la General: Gouverneure générale : To Her Excellency the Right Honourable Adrienne À Son Excellence la très honorable Adrienne Clarkson, Clarkson, Chancellor and Principal Companion of the Order Chancelière et Compagnon principal de l'Ordre du Canada, of Canada, Chancellor and Commander of the Order of Chancelière et Commandeur de l'Ordre du mérite militaire, Military Merit, Chancellor and Commander of the Order of Chancelière et Commandeur de l'Ordre du mérite des corps Merit of the Police Forces, Governor General and policiers, Gouverneure générale et Commandante en chef du Commander-in-Chief of Canada. Canada. MAY IT PLEASE YOUR EXCELLENCY: QU'IL PLAISE À VOTRE EXCELLENCE : We, Her Majesty's most loyal and dutiful subjects, the Nous, sujets très dévoués et fidèles de Sa Majesté, la House of Commons of Canada, in Parliament assembled, Chambre des communes du Canada, assemblée en beg leave to offer our humble thanks to Your Excellency for Parlement, prions respectueusement Votre Excellence the gracious Speech which Your Excellency has addressed d'agréer nos humbles remerciements pour le gracieux to both Houses of Parliament; discours qu'Elle a adressé aux deux Chambres du Parlement; And of the amendment of Mr. Harper (Calgary Southwest), Et de l’amendement de M. Harper (Calgary-Sud-Ouest), appuyé seconded by Mr. MacKay (Central Nova), — That the motion be par M. MacKay (Nova-Centre), — Que la motion soit modifiée par amended by adding the following: adjonction de ce qui suit : “and we urge Your Excellency’s advisors, when implementing « et nous exhortons les conseillers de Votre Excellence, lors de the details of their proposals, to review the Employment la mise en œuvre des détails de leurs propositions, à revoir le Insurance program to ensure that it remains well-suited to the programme d’assurance-emploi pour s’assurer qu’il demeure needs of Canada’s workforce, to reduce and improve the bien adapté aux besoins de la main-d’œuvre canadienne, à fairness of taxes, to be unwavering in the application of fiscal réduire les impôts et les rendre plus équitables, à appliquer sans discipline, to examine the need and options for reform of our compromis la discipline financière, à s’interroger sur la democratic institutions, including electoral reform, and to rise nécessité et la manière de réformer nos institutions above partisanship to address the public interest; démocratiques, y compris le système électoral pour s'élever au-dessus de la partisanerie pour servir l’intérêt public; That Your Excellency’s advisors consider the inclusion of the Que les conseillers de Votre Excellence considère d'inclure ce following: qui suit : 1. the establishment of an arm’s-length, but not privatized, 1. l’établissement d’une commission tripartite autonome, tri-party commission to ensure Employment Insurance mais non privatisée, pour veiller à ce que les cotisations premiums are used only for workers' benefits; d’assurance-emploi ne servent qu’à verser des avantages aux travailleurs; 2. the reduction of taxes for low and modest income 2. la réduction des impôts pour les familles à revenu faible et families; moyen; 3. the creation of an independent Parliamentary Budget 3. la création d’un service parlementaire indépendant du Office to give regular advice on the fiscal forecasts of the budget chargé de fournir régulièrement des avis sur les government of Canada; prévisions financières du gouvernement du Canada; 4. the establishment of a non-partisan, independent Citizens’ 4. l’établissement d’une assemblée de citoyens non partisane Assembly to examine changes to the electoral system, et indépendante afin d’examiner les modifications à apporter including proportional representation; and au système électoral, notamment la représentation proportionnelle; October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 33

5. measures to ensure that there be a vote in the House of 5. des mesures garantissant la tenue à la Chambre des Commons on any proposed continental missile defence communes d’un vote sur tout projet de traité de défense treaty.”; antimissile continental. »; And of the subamendment of Mr. Duceppe (Laurier—Sainte- Et du sous-amendement de M. Duceppe (Laurier—Sainte- Marie), seconded by Mr. Gauthier (Roberval—Lac-Saint-Jean), — Marie), appuyé par M. Gauthier (Roberval—Lac-Saint-Jean), — That the amendment be amended by adding after the word “treaty” Que l'amendement soit modifié par adjonction, après le mot the following: « continental », de ce qui suit : “and we ask Your Excellency’s advisors to ensure that all « et nous demandons aux conseillers de Votre Excellence de measures brought forward to implement the Speech from the prévoir que dans toutes les mesures visant à mettre en œuvre le Throne, including those referred to above, fully respect the discours du Trône, y compris dans celles ci-haut mentionnées, provinces’ areas of jurisdiction and that the financial pressures les compétences des provinces soient intégralement respectées the provinces are suffering as a consequence of the fiscal et que les pressions financières qu’elles subissent en raison du imbalance be alleviated, as demanded by the Premier of déséquilibre fiscal soient allégées, tel que réclamé par le Quebec.”. premier ministre du Québec. ». The debate continued. Le débat se poursuit.

MOTIONS MOTIONS By unanimous consent, it was ordered, — That the debate on Du consentement unanime, il est ordonné, — Que le débat de bovine spongiform encephalopathy this evening be interrupted, ce soir sur l’encéphalopathie bovine spongiforme soit interrompu, rather than terminated, at midnight, and that it be resumed at 7:00 plutôt que conclu, à minuit, et que le débat reprenne à 19 heures le p.m. on Tuesday, October 12, 2004, and concluded when no mardi 12 octobre 2004 et se termine lorsqu’aucun député ne member rises to speak or at 6:00 a.m. on Wednesday, October 13, prendra la parole ou à 6 heures le mercredi 13 octobre, selon la 2004, whichever is earlier. première éventualité.

MOTIONS MOTIONS By unanimous consent, it was ordered, — That this House Du consentement unanime, il est ordonné, — Que la Chambre demand that the prime minister instruct all federal government enjoigne au premier ministre de demander à tous les immeubles buildings immediately to lower all Canadian flags to half-mast to fédéraux de mettre le drapeau canadien en berne en mémoire du recognize the tragic death of Lieutenant (Navy) Chris Saunders lieutenant de vaisseau Chris Saunders, décédé tragiquement hier yesterday on HMCS Chicoutimi. sur le sous-marin NCSM Chicoutimi.

STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS DÉCLARATIONS DE DÉPUTÉS Pursuant to Standing Order 31, Members made statements. Conformément à l'article 31 du Règlement, des députés font des déclarations.

ORAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS ORALES Pursuant to Standing Order 30(5), the House proceeded to Oral Conformément à l'article 30(5) du Règlement, la Chambre Questions. procède à la période de questions orales.

MOTIONS MOTIONS By unanimous consent, it was ordered, — That, during the take- Du consentement unanime, il est ordonné, — Que, durant le note debate on bovine spongiform encephalopathy, any member débat exploratoire sur l’encéphalopathie bovine spongiforme, tout may, after notifying the Chair, divide his or her speaking time. député puisse, après avoir avisé la Présidence, diviser son temps de parole.

MOTIONS MOTIONS By unanimous consent, it was ordered, — That the First Report Du consentement unanime, il est ordonné, — Que le premier of the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs be rapport du Comité permanent de la procédure et des affaires de la deemed tabled and concurred in. Chambre soit réputé déposé et adopté. Accordingly, Mr. Boudria (Glengarry—Prescott—Russell), En conséquence, M. Boudria (Glengarry—Prescott—Russell), from the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs, du Comité permanent de la procédure et des affaires de la presented the First Report of the Committee, which was as follows: Chambre, présente le premier rapport de ce Comité, dont voici le texte : The Committee recommends, pursuant to Standing Orders Le Comité recommande, conformément au mandat que lui 104 and 114, that the list of members and associate members for confèrent les articles 104 et 114 du Règlement, que la liste des Standing Committees of this House be as follows: membres et membres associés des comités permanents de la Chambre figure comme suit : October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 35

Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Affaires autochtones et développement du Grand Nord Members (12) Membres (12) Sue Barnes Pat Martin Sue Barnes Pat Martin André Bellavance Jim Prentice André Bellavance Jim Prentice Bernard Cleary Carol Skelton Bernard Cleary Carol Skelton Jeremy Harrison David Smith Jeremy Harrison David Smith Nancy Karetak-Lindell Lloyd St. Amand Nancy Karetak-Lindell Lloyd St. Amand Gary Lunn Roger Valley Gary Lunn Roger Valley Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Jason Kenney Jim Abbott Jason Kenney Diane Ablonczy Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Ed Komarnicki Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Marc Lemay Rob Anders Marc Lemay David Anderson Yvon Lévesque David Anderson Yvon Lévesque Charlie Angus Tom Lukiwski Charlie Angus Tom Lukiwski Gérard Asselin James Lunney Gérard Asselin James Lunney Larry Bagnell Peter MacKay Larry Bagnell Peter MacKay Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark James Bezan Tony Martin James Bezan Tony Martin Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Colin Carrie Larry Miller Colin Carrie Larry Miller Bill Casey Bob Mills Bill Casey Bob Mills Rick Casson James Moore Rick Casson James Moore David Chatters Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Moore Michael Chong Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Rob Nicholson Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai Nathan Cullen Gordon O'Connor Nathan Cullen Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Bev Oda John Cummins Bev Oda Rodger Cuzner Brian Pallister Rodger Cuzner Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Bev Desjarlais Pierre Poilievre Bev Desjarlais Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Joe Preston Barry Devolin Joe Preston Norman Doyle James Rajotte Norman Doyle James Rajotte John Duncan Scott Reid John Duncan Scott Reid Ken Epp John Reynolds Ken Epp John Reynolds Diane Finley Lee Richardson Diane Finley Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Andrew Scheer Steven Fletcher Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Gary Schellenberger Paul Forseth Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Joy Smith Peter Goldring Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Kevin Sorenson Jim Gouk Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Helena Guergis Greg Thompson Helena Guergis Greg Thompson Art Hanger Myron Thompson Art Hanger Myron Thompson Stephen Harper David Tilson Stephen Harper David Tilson Richard Harris Vic Toews Richard Harris Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Bradley Trost Loyola Hearn Bradley Trost Russ Hiebert Merv Tweed Russ Hiebert Merv Tweed Jay Hill Peter Van Loan Jay Hill Peter Van Loan Betty Hinton Maurice Vellacott Betty Hinton Maurice Vellacott Charles Hubbard Mark Warawa Charles Hubbard Mark Warawa Rahim Jaffer Jeff Watson Rahim Jaffer Jeff Watson Brian Jean Brian Jean 36 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Dale Johnston Randy White Dale Johnston Randy White Randy Kamp John Williams Randy Kamp John Williams Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich

Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics Accès à l'information, protection des renseignements personnels et éthique Members (12) Membres (12) Navdeep Bains Marlene Jennings Navdeep Bains Marlene Jennings Ed Broadbent Mario Laframboise Ed Broadbent Mario Laframboise David Chatters Derek Lee David Chatters Derek Lee Johanne Deschamps Carolyn Parrish Johanne Deschamps Carolyn Parrish Art Hanger Michael Savage Art Hanger Michael Savage Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Jack Layton Jim Abbott Jack Layton Diane Ablonczy Tom Lukiwski Diane Ablonczy Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Gary Lunn Dean Allison Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rob Anders Peter MacKay Rob Anders Peter MacKay David Anderson Dave MacKenzie David Anderson Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Inky Mark Dave Batters Inky Mark Leon Benoit Pat Martin Leon Benoit Pat Martin James Bezan Ted Menzies James Bezan Ted Menzies Marc Boulianne Rob Merrifield Marc Boulianne Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Gord Brown Bob Mills Gord Brown Bob Mills Colin Carrie James Moore Colin Carrie James Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Rick Casson Anita Neville Rick Casson Anita Neville Michael Chong Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Rob Nicholson Joe Comartin Deepak Obhrai Joe Comartin Deepak Obhrai Paul Crête Gordon O'Connor Paul Crête Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Bev Oda John Cummins Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Pauline Picard Norman Doyle Pauline Picard John Duncan Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Pierre Poilievre Ken Epp Jim Prentice Ken Epp Jim Prentice Diane Finley Joe Preston Diane Finley Joe Preston Brian Fitzpatrick James Rajotte Brian Fitzpatrick James Rajotte Steven Fletcher Scott Reid Steven Fletcher Scott Reid Paul Forseth John Reynolds Paul Forseth John Reynolds Cheryl Gallant Lee Richardson Cheryl Gallant Lee Richardson Michel Gauthier Gerry Ritz Michel Gauthier Gerry Ritz Yvon Godin Andrew Scheer Yvon Godin Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Werner Schmidt Gary Goodyear Werner Schmidt Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Michel Guimond Darrel Stinson Michel Guimond Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Greg Thompson Richard Harris Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Jay Hill Bradley Trost Jay Hill Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 37

Dale Johnston Tom Wappel Dale Johnston Tom Wappel Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Jason Kenney Randy White Jason Kenney Randy White Ed Komarnicki John Williams Ed Komarnicki John Williams Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich Guy Lauzon Guy Lauzon

Agriculture and Agri-Food Agriculture et agroalimentaire

Members (12) Membres (12) David Anderson David Kilgour David Anderson David Kilgour Charlie Angus Larry Miller Charlie Angus Larry Miller James Bezan Denise Poirier- James Bezan Denise Poirier- Claude Drouin Rivard Claude Drouin Rivard Wayne Easter Gerry Ritz Wayne Easter Gerry Ritz Roger Gaudet Paul Steckle Roger Gaudet Paul Steckle Rose-Marie Ur Rose-Marie Ur Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Peter Adams Guy Lauzon Peter Adams Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rob Anders James Lunney Rob Anders James Lunney Dave Batters Peter MacKay Dave Batters Peter MacKay André Bellavance Dave MacKenzie André Bellavance Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Colin Carrie Bob Mills Colin Carrie Bob Mills Bill Casey James Moore Bill Casey James Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Joe Comartin Gordon O'Connor Joe Comartin Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Bev Oda John Cummins Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Johanne Deschamps Pierre Paquette Johanne Deschamps Pierre Paquette Bev Desjarlais Charlie Penson Bev Desjarlais Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Jim Prentice John Duncan Joe Preston John Duncan Joe Preston Ken Epp James Rajotte Ken Epp James Rajotte Diane Finley Scott Reid Diane Finley Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Yvon Godin Werner Schmidt Yvon Godin Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Peter Stoffer Helena Guergis Peter Stoffer Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews 38 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Canadian Heritage Patrimoine canadien Members (12) Membres (12) Charlie Angus Marc Lemay Charlie Angus Marc Lemay Gord Brown Deepak Obhrai Gord Brown Deepak Obhrai Sarmite Bulte Pablo Rodriguez Sarmite Bulte Pablo Rodriguez Marlene Catterall Gary Schellenberger Marlene Catterall Gary Schellenberger Wajid Khan Scott Simms Wajid Khan Scott Simms Maka Kotto Merv Tweed Maka Kotto Merv Tweed Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott David Kilgour Jim Abbott David Kilgour Diane Ablonczy Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Ed Komarnicki Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Gary Lunn David Anderson Gary Lunn Guy André James Lunney Guy André James Lunney Dave Batters Peter MacKay Dave Batters Peter MacKay Don Bell Dave MacKenzie Don Bell Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark Stéphane Bergeron Ted Menzies Stéphane Bergeron Ted Menzies James Bezan Rob Merrifield James Bezan Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Colin Carrie Bob Mills Colin Carrie Bob Mills Bill Casey James Moore Bill Casey James Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Jean Crowder Bev Oda Jean Crowder Bev Oda Nathan Cullen Brian Pallister Nathan Cullen Brian Pallister John Cummins Charlie Penson John Cummins Charlie Penson Libby Davies Louis Plamondon Libby Davies Louis Plamondon Stockwell Day Pierre Poilievre Stockwell Day Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Jim Prentice Barry Devolin Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Joe Preston Norman Doyle Joe Preston John Duncan James Rajotte John Duncan James Rajotte Ken Epp Scott Reid Ken Epp Scott Reid Diane Finley John Reynolds Diane Finley John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Peter Stoffer Helena Guergis Peter Stoffer Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 39

Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Jay Hill Peter Van Loan Jay Hill Peter Van Loan Betty Hinton Maurice Vellacott Betty Hinton Maurice Vellacott Rahim Jaffer Mark Warawa Rahim Jaffer Mark Warawa Brian Jean Jeff Watson Brian Jean Jeff Watson Dale Johnston Randy White Dale Johnston Randy White Randy Kamp John Williams Randy Kamp John Williams Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Jason Kenney Jason Kenney

Citizenship and Immigration Citoyenneté et immigration Members (12) Membres (12) Diane Ablonczy Rahim Jaffer Diane Ablonczy Rahim Jaffer David Anderson Inky Mark David Anderson Inky Mark Roger Clavet Bill Siksay Roger Clavet Bill Siksay Meili Faille Mario Silva Meili Faille Mario Silva Hedy Fry Andrew Telegdi Hedy Fry Andrew Telegdi Helena Guergis Lui Temelkovski Helena Guergis Lui Temelkovski

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Francine Lalonde Dean Allison Francine Lalonde Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Jack Layton Rob Anders Jack Layton David Anderson Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Tom Lukiwski Guy André Gary Lunn Guy André Gary Lunn Dave Batters James Lunney Dave Batters James Lunney Colleen Beaumier Peter MacKay Colleen Beaumier Peter MacKay Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Pat Martin James Bezan Pat Martin Diane Bourgeois Brian Masse Diane Bourgeois Brian Masse Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Colin Carrie Larry Miller Colin Carrie Larry Miller Bill Casey Bob Mills Bill Casey Bob Mills Rick Casson James Moore Rick Casson James Moore David Chatters Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Moore Michael Chong Anita Neville Michael Chong Anita Neville David Christopherson Rob Nicholson David Christopherson Rob Nicholson Joe Comartin Deepak Obhrai Joe Comartin Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Gordon O'Connor Libby Davies Bev Oda Libby Davies Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Odina Desrochers Charlie Penson Odina Desrochers Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Claude Drouin Joe Preston Claude Drouin Joe Preston John Duncan James Rajotte John Duncan James Rajotte Ken Epp Scott Reid Ken Epp Scott Reid Diane Finley John Reynolds Diane Finley John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Raymonde Folco Andrew Scheer Raymonde Folco Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Gary Schellenberger Paul Forseth Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson 40 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Jay Hill Merv Tweed Jay Hill Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Peter Julian Judy Wasylycia-Leis Peter Julian Judy Wasylycia-Leis Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich

Environment and Sustainable Development Environnement et développement durable Members (12) Membres (12) Bernard Bigras Yasmin Ratansi Bernard Bigras Yasmin Ratansi Nathan Cullen Lee Richardson Nathan Cullen Lee Richardson Brian Jean Christian Simard Brian Jean Christian Simard David McGuinty Alan Tonks David McGuinty Alan Tonks Bob Mills Jeff Watson Bob Mills Jeff Watson Denis Paradis Bryon Wilfert Denis Paradis Bryon Wilfert Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Jack Layton Rona Ambrose Jack Layton Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Gary Lunn David Anderson Gary Lunn Gérard Asselin James Lunney Gérard Asselin James Lunney Dave Batters Peter MacKay Dave Batters Peter MacKay Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Inky Mark James Bezan Inky Mark Marc Boulianne Ted Menzies Marc Boulianne Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Serge Cardin Maria Minna Serge Cardin Maria Minna Colin Carrie James Moore Colin Carrie James Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Nicholson Rick Casson Rob Nicholson David Chatters Deepak Obhrai David Chatters Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Joe Comartin Bev Oda Joe Comartin Bev Oda Paul Crête Brian Pallister Paul Crête Brian Pallister Jean Crowder Charlie Penson Jean Crowder Charlie Penson John Cummins Pierre Poilievre John Cummins Pierre Poilievre Stockwell Day Russ Powers Stockwell Day Russ Powers Barry Devolin Jim Prentice Barry Devolin Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Joe Preston Norman Doyle Joe Preston John Duncan James Rajotte John Duncan James Rajotte Ken Epp Scott Reid Ken Epp Scott Reid Diane Finley John Reynolds Diane Finley John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Francis Scarpaleggia Steven Fletcher Francis Scarpaleggia Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 41

Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Joy Smith Jim Gouk Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Peter Stoffer Art Hanger Peter Stoffer Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Paul Szabo Richard Harris Paul Szabo Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Jay Hill Vic Toews Jay Hill Vic Toews Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Mark Holland Merv Tweed Mark Holland Merv Tweed Charles Hubbard Peter Van Loan Charles Hubbard Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Maurice Vellacott Rahim Jaffer Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Peter Julian Randy White Peter Julian Randy White Randy Kamp John Williams Randy Kamp John Williams Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Jason Kenney Jason Kenney

Finance Finances

Members (12) Membres (12) Rona Ambrose Maria Minna Rona Ambrose Maria Minna Don Bell Massimo Pacetti Don Bell Massimo Pacetti Guy Côté Brian Pallister Guy Côté Brian Pallister Charles Hubbard Charlie Penson Charles Hubbard Charlie Penson Yvan Loubier Monte Solberg Yvan Loubier Monte Solberg John McKay Judy Wasylycia-Leis John McKay Judy Wasylycia-Leis Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Mario Laframboise Diane Ablonczy Mario Laframboise Dean Allison Réal Lapierre Dean Allison Réal Lapierre Rob Anders Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Guy Lauzon David Anderson Jack Layton David Anderson Jack Layton Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Leon Benoit Gary Lunn Leon Benoit Gary Lunn James Bezan James Lunney James Bezan James Lunney Robert Bouchard Peter MacKay Robert Bouchard Peter MacKay Garry Breitkreuz Dave MacKenzie Garry Breitkreuz Dave MacKenzie Gord Brown Inky Mark Gord Brown Inky Mark Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Bill Casey Rob Merrifield Bill Casey Rob Merrifield Rick Casson Larry Miller Rick Casson Larry Miller David Chatters Bob Mills David Chatters Bob Mills Michael Chong James Moore Michael Chong James Moore David Christopherson Rob Moore David Christopherson Rob Moore Jean Crowder Rob Nicholson Jean Crowder Rob Nicholson John Cummins Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Deepak Obhrai Stockwell Day Gordon O'Connor Stockwell Day Gordon O'Connor Johanne Deschamps Bev Oda Johanne Deschamps Bev Oda Bev Desjarlais Pierre Paquette Bev Desjarlais Pierre Paquette Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Jim Prentice John Duncan Joe Preston John Duncan Joe Preston Ken Epp James Rajotte Ken Epp James Rajotte Diane Finley Scott Reid Diane Finley Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson 42 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Benoît Sauvageau Cheryl Gallant Benoît Sauvageau Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Gurmant Grewal Bill Siksay Gurmant Grewal Bill Siksay Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Helena Guergis Joy Smith Helena Guergis Joy Smith Art Hanger Kevin Sorenson Art Hanger Kevin Sorenson Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Jay Hill Vic Toews Jay Hill Vic Toews Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Peter Julian Mark Warawa Peter Julian Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich

Fisheries and Oceans Pêches et océans Members (12) Membres (12) Larry Bagnell Bill Matthews Larry Bagnell Bill Matthews Raynald Blais Shawn Murphy Raynald Blais Shawn Murphy John Cummins Jean-Yves Roy John Cummins Jean-Yves Roy Rodger Cuzner Peter Stoffer Rodger Cuzner Peter Stoffer Loyola Hearn Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Greg Thompson Gerald Keddy Tom Wappel Gerald Keddy Tom Wappel Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Gary Lunn Rob Anders Gary Lunn David Anderson James Lunney David Anderson James Lunney Gérard Asselin Peter MacKay Gérard Asselin Peter MacKay Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark James Bezan Ted Menzies James Bezan Ted Menzies Marc Boulianne Rob Merrifield Marc Boulianne Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Gord Brown Bob Mills Gord Brown Bob Mills Serge Cardin James Moore Serge Cardin James Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Robert Carrier Rob Nicholson Robert Carrier Rob Nicholson Bill Casey Deepak Obhrai Bill Casey Deepak Obhrai Rick Casson Gordon O'Connor Rick Casson Gordon O'Connor David Chatters Bev Oda David Chatters Bev Oda Michael Chong Brian Pallister Michael Chong Brian Pallister Paul Crête Charlie Penson Paul Crête Charlie Penson Jean Crowder Pierre Poilievre Jean Crowder Pierre Poilievre Nathan Cullen Jim Prentice Nathan Cullen Jim Prentice Stockwell Day Joe Preston Stockwell Day Joe Preston Barry Devolin James Rajotte Barry Devolin James Rajotte Norman Doyle Scott Reid Norman Doyle Scott Reid October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 43

John Duncan John Reynolds John Duncan John Reynolds Ken Epp Lee Richardson Ken Epp Lee Richardson Diane Finley Gerry Ritz Diane Finley Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Andrew Scheer Brian Fitzpatrick Andrew Scheer Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Carol Skelton Cheryl Gallant Carol Skelton Yvon Godin Joy Smith Yvon Godin Joy Smith Peter Goldring Monte Solberg Peter Goldring Monte Solberg Gary Goodyear Kevin Sorenson Gary Goodyear Kevin Sorenson Jim Gouk Caroline St-Hilaire Jim Gouk Caroline St-Hilaire Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Helena Guergis Myron Thompson Helena Guergis Myron Thompson Art Hanger David Tilson Art Hanger David Tilson Stephen Harper Vic Toews Stephen Harper Vic Toews Richard Harris Bradley Trost Richard Harris Bradley Trost Jeremy Harrison Merv Tweed Jeremy Harrison Merv Tweed Russ Hiebert Peter Van Loan Russ Hiebert Peter Van Loan Jay Hill Maurice Vellacott Jay Hill Maurice Vellacott Betty Hinton Mark Warawa Betty Hinton Mark Warawa Rahim Jaffer Jeff Watson Rahim Jaffer Jeff Watson Brian Jean Randy White Brian Jean Randy White Dale Johnston John Williams Dale Johnston John Williams Randy Kamp Lynne Yelich Randy Kamp Lynne Yelich Jason Kenney Jason Kenney

Foreign Affairs and International Trade Affaires étrangères et commerce international Members (12) Membres (12) Maurizio Bevilacqua Ted Menzies Maurizio Bevilacqua Ted Menzies Stockwell Day Pierre Paquette Stockwell Day Pierre Paquette Francine Lalonde Bernard Patry Francine Lalonde Bernard Patry Lawrence MacAulay Beth Phinney Lawrence MacAulay Beth Phinney Alexa McDonough Kevin Sorenson Alexa McDonough Kevin Sorenson Dan McTeague Belinda Stronach Dan McTeague Belinda Stronach

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Peter Julian Jim Abbott Peter Julian Diane Ablonczy Randy Kamp Diane Ablonczy Randy Kamp Dean Allison Gerald Keddy Dean Allison Gerald Keddy Rona Ambrose Jason Kenney Rona Ambrose Jason Kenney Rob Anders David Kilgour Rob Anders David Kilgour David Anderson Ed Komarnicki David Anderson Ed Komarnicki David Anderson Daryl Kramp David Anderson Daryl Kramp Guy André Guy Lauzon Guy André Guy Lauzon Claude Bachand Jack Layton Claude Bachand Jack Layton Navdeep Bains Tom Lukiwski Navdeep Bains Tom Lukiwski Dave Batters Gary Lunn Dave Batters Gary Lunn Don Bell James Lunney Don Bell James Lunney André Bellavance Peter MacKay André Bellavance Peter MacKay Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Inky Mark James Bezan Inky Mark Diane Bourgeois Brian Masse Diane Bourgeois Brian Masse Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Sarmite Bulte Bob Mills Sarmite Bulte Bob Mills John Cannis Maria Minna John Cannis Maria Minna Colin Carrie James Moore Colin Carrie James Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Nicholson Rick Casson Rob Nicholson David Chatters Deepak Obhrai David Chatters Deepak Obhrai 44 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Roger Clavet Bev Oda Roger Clavet Bev Oda John Cummins Brian Pallister John Cummins Brian Pallister Johanne Deschamps Charlie Penson Johanne Deschamps Charlie Penson Bev Desjarlais Pierre Poilievre Bev Desjarlais Pierre Poilievre Odina Desrochers Jim Prentice Odina Desrochers Jim Prentice Barry Devolin Joe Preston Barry Devolin Joe Preston Norman Doyle James Rajotte Norman Doyle James Rajotte John Duncan Scott Reid John Duncan Scott Reid Ken Epp John Reynolds Ken Epp John Reynolds Mark Eyking Lee Richardson Mark Eyking Lee Richardson Diane Finley Gerry Ritz Diane Finley Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Andrew Scheer Brian Fitzpatrick Andrew Scheer Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Carol Skelton Cheryl Gallant Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Joy Smith Peter Goldring Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Darrel Stinson Jim Gouk Darrel Stinson Gurmant Grewal Greg Thompson Gurmant Grewal Greg Thompson Nina Grewal Myron Thompson Nina Grewal Myron Thompson Helena Guergis David Tilson Helena Guergis David Tilson Art Hanger Vic Toews Art Hanger Vic Toews Stephen Harper Paddy Torsney Stephen Harper Paddy Torsney Richard Harris Bradley Trost Richard Harris Bradley Trost Jeremy Harrison Merv Tweed Jeremy Harrison Merv Tweed Loyola Hearn Peter Van Loan Loyola Hearn Peter Van Loan Russ Hiebert Maurice Vellacott Russ Hiebert Maurice Vellacott Jay Hill Mark Warawa Jay Hill Mark Warawa Betty Hinton Jeff Watson Betty Hinton Jeff Watson Rahim Jaffer Randy White Rahim Jaffer Randy White Brian Jean John Williams Brian Jean John Williams Marlene Jennings Lynne Yelich Marlene Jennings Lynne Yelich Dale Johnston Dale Johnston

Government Operations and Estimates Opérations gouvernementales et prévisions budgétaires Members (12) Membres (12) Leon Benoit Russ Powers Leon Benoit Russ Powers Ken Boshcoff Joe Preston Ken Boshcoff Joe Preston Marcel Gagnon Francis Scarpaleggia Marcel Gagnon Francis Scarpaleggia Diane Marleau Paul Szabo Diane Marleau Paul Szabo Pat Martin Louise Thibault Pat Martin Louise Thibault James Moore Randy White James Moore Randy White Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Walt Lastewka Diane Ablonczy Walt Lastewka Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Yvan Loubier Rona Ambrose Yvan Loubier Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Gary Lunn David Anderson Gary Lunn Dave Batters James Lunney Dave Batters James Lunney Stéphane Bergeron Peter MacKay Stéphane Bergeron Peter MacKay James Bezan Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Dave MacKenzie Garry Breitkreuz Inky Mark Garry Breitkreuz Inky Mark Gord Brown David McGuinty Gord Brown David McGuinty Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Bill Casey Rob Merrifield Bill Casey Rob Merrifield Rick Casson Larry Miller Rick Casson Larry Miller David Chatters Bob Mills David Chatters Bob Mills October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 45

Michael Chong Rob Moore Michael Chong Rob Moore David Christopherson Rob Nicholson David Christopherson Rob Nicholson Guy Côté Deepak Obhrai Guy Côté Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Gordon O'Connor Stockwell Day Bev Oda Stockwell Day Bev Oda Bev Desjarlais Brian Pallister Bev Desjarlais Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Jim Prentice John Duncan Jim Prentice Ken Epp James Rajotte Ken Epp James Rajotte Diane Finley Scott Reid Diane Finley Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Benoît Sauvageau Cheryl Gallant Benoît Sauvageau Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Gurmant Grewal Carol Skelton Gurmant Grewal Carol Skelton Nina Grewal Joy Smith Nina Grewal Joy Smith Helena Guergis Monte Solberg Helena Guergis Monte Solberg Art Hanger Kevin Sorenson Art Hanger Kevin Sorenson Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Jay Hill Vic Toews Jay Hill Vic Toews Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Peter Julian Mark Warawa Peter Julian Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Judy Wasylycia-Leis Randy Kamp Judy Wasylycia-Leis Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich

Health Santé Members (12) Membres (12) Colleen Beaumier Ruby Dhalla Colleen Beaumier Ruby Dhalla Bill Blaikie Steven Fletcher Bill Blaikie Steven Fletcher Bonnie Brown James Lunney Bonnie Brown James Lunney Colin Carrie Réal Ménard Colin Carrie Réal Ménard Brenda Chamberlain Rob Merrifield Brenda Chamberlain Rob Merrifield Nicole Demers Robert Thibault Nicole Demers Robert Thibault

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Diane Ablonczy Jack Layton Diane Ablonczy Jack Layton Dean Allison Yvan Loubier Dean Allison Yvan Loubier Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Gary Lunn Rob Anders Gary Lunn David Anderson Peter MacKay David Anderson Peter MacKay Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark Stéphane Bergeron Brian Masse Stéphane Bergeron Brian Masse James Bezan Alexa McDonough James Bezan Alexa McDonough Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Paule Brunelle Bob Mills Paule Brunelle Bob Mills 46 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Bill Casey James Moore Bill Casey James Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Guy Côté Gordon O'Connor Guy Côté Gordon O'Connor Nathan Cullen Bev Oda Nathan Cullen Bev Oda John Cummins Brian Pallister John Cummins Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Jim Prentice John Duncan Joe Preston John Duncan Joe Preston Ken Epp James Rajotte Ken Epp James Rajotte Diane Finley Scott Reid Diane Finley Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Raymonde Folco Lee Richardson Raymonde Folco Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Werner Schmidt Gary Goodyear Werner Schmidt Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Greg Thompson Richard Harris Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Russ Hiebert Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Vic Toews Jay Hill Bradley Trost Jay Hill Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Peter Julian Judy Wasylycia-Leis Peter Julian Judy Wasylycia-Leis Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Daryl Kramp Daryl Kramp

Human Resources, Skills Development, Social Développement des ressources humaines, Development and the Status of Persons with développement des compétences, développement Disabilities social et condition des personnes handicapées Members (12) Membres (12) Peter Adams Christiane Gagnon Peter Adams Christiane Gagnon Eleni Bakopanos Ed Komarnicki Eleni Bakopanos Ed Komarnicki Jean-Claude D'Amours Yves Lessard Jean-Claude D'Amours Yves Lessard Barry Devolin Gurbax Malhi Barry Devolin Gurbax Malhi Raymonde Folco Tony Martin Raymonde Folco Tony Martin Paul Forseth Peter Van Loan Paul Forseth Peter Van Loan Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Gerald Keddy Jim Abbott Gerald Keddy Diane Ablonczy Jason Kenney Diane Ablonczy Jason Kenney Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Carole Lavallée Rob Anders Carole Lavallée David Anderson Judi Longfield David Anderson Judi Longfield Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Don Bell Gary Lunn Don Bell Gary Lunn October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 47

Leon Benoit James Lunney Leon Benoit James Lunney Stéphane Bergeron Peter MacKay Stéphane Bergeron Peter MacKay James Bezan Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Dave MacKenzie Alain Boire Inky Mark Alain Boire Inky Mark France Bonsant Alexa McDonough France Bonsant Alexa McDonough Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Ed Broadbent Rob Merrifield Ed Broadbent Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Paule Brunelle Bob Mills Paule Brunelle Bob Mills Colin Carrie James Moore Colin Carrie James Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Rick Casson Anita Neville Rick Casson Anita Neville David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai David Christopherson Gordon O'Connor David Christopherson Gordon O'Connor Jean Crowder Bev Oda Jean Crowder Bev Oda Nathan Cullen Brian Pallister Nathan Cullen Brian Pallister John Cummins Charlie Penson John Cummins Charlie Penson Libby Davies Pierre Poilievre Libby Davies Pierre Poilievre Stockwell Day Jim Prentice Stockwell Day Jim Prentice Nicole Demers Joe Preston Nicole Demers Joe Preston Norman Doyle James Rajotte Norman Doyle James Rajotte John Duncan Scott Reid John Duncan Scott Reid Ken Epp John Reynolds Ken Epp John Reynolds Diane Finley Lee Richardson Diane Finley Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Andrew Scheer Steven Fletcher Andrew Scheer Hedy Fry Gary Schellenberger Hedy Fry Gary Schellenberger Marcel Gagnon Werner Schmidt Marcel Gagnon Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Christian Simard Cheryl Gallant Christian Simard Yvon Godin Carol Skelton Yvon Godin Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Joy Smith Peter Goldring Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Gary Goodyear Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Kevin Sorenson Jim Gouk Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Gurmant Grewal Darrel Stinson Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Nina Grewal Belinda Stronach Helena Guergis Greg Thompson Helena Guergis Greg Thompson Art Hanger Myron Thompson Art Hanger Myron Thompson Stephen Harper David Tilson Stephen Harper David Tilson Richard Harris Vic Toews Richard Harris Vic Toews Jeremy Harrison Bradley Trost Jeremy Harrison Bradley Trost Loyola Hearn Merv Tweed Loyola Hearn Merv Tweed Russ Hiebert Maurice Vellacott Russ Hiebert Maurice Vellacott Jay Hill Robert Vincent Jay Hill Robert Vincent Betty Hinton Mark Warawa Betty Hinton Mark Warawa Rahim Jaffer Judy Wasylycia-Leis Rahim Jaffer Judy Wasylycia-Leis Brian Jean Jeff Watson Brian Jean Jeff Watson Dale Johnston Randy White Dale Johnston Randy White Peter Julian John Williams Peter Julian John Williams Randy Kamp Lynne Yelich Randy Kamp Lynne Yelich

Industry, Natural Resources, Science and Technology Industrie, ressources naturelles, sciences et technologie

Members (12) Membres (12) Serge Cardin Lynn Myers Serge Cardin Lynn Myers Michael Chong Jerry Pickard Michael Chong Jerry Pickard Denis Coderre Andy Savoy Denis Coderre Andy Savoy Paul Crête Werner Schmidt Paul Crête Werner Schmidt John Duncan Brent St. Denis John Duncan Brent St. Denis Brian Masse Bradley Trost Brian Masse Bradley Trost 48 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Mario Laframboise Dean Allison Mario Laframboise Rona Ambrose Réal Lapierre Rona Ambrose Réal Lapierre Rob Anders Guy Lauzon Rob Anders Guy Lauzon David Anderson Jack Layton David Anderson Jack Layton Gérard Asselin Yvon Lévesque Gérard Asselin Yvon Lévesque Larry Bagnell Yvan Loubier Larry Bagnell Yvan Loubier Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Dave Batters Tom Lukiwski Don Bell Gary Lunn Don Bell Gary Lunn Leon Benoit James Lunney Leon Benoit James Lunney James Bezan Peter MacKay James Bezan Peter MacKay Bernard Bigras Dave MacKenzie Bernard Bigras Dave MacKenzie Marc Boulianne Inky Mark Marc Boulianne Inky Mark Garry Breitkreuz Tony Martin Garry Breitkreuz Tony Martin Gord Brown David McGuinty Gord Brown David McGuinty Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Colin Carrie Ted Menzies Robert Carrier Rob Merrifield Robert Carrier Rob Merrifield Bill Casey Larry Miller Bill Casey Larry Miller Rick Casson Bob Mills Rick Casson Bob Mills David Chatters James Moore David Chatters James Moore David Christopherson Rob Moore David Christopherson Rob Moore Guy Côté Rob Nicholson Guy Côté Rob Nicholson Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Gordon O'Connor Libby Davies Bev Oda Libby Davies Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Beth Phinney Norman Doyle Beth Phinney Ken Epp Pierre Poilievre Ken Epp Pierre Poilievre Diane Finley Jim Prentice Diane Finley Jim Prentice Brian Fitzpatrick Joe Preston Brian Fitzpatrick Joe Preston Steven Fletcher James Rajotte Steven Fletcher James Rajotte Paul Forseth Scott Reid Paul Forseth Scott Reid Hedy Fry John Reynolds Hedy Fry John Reynolds Sébastien Gagnon Lee Richardson Sébastien Gagnon Lee Richardson Cheryl Gallant Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Gerry Ritz Yvon Godin Andrew Scheer Yvon Godin Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Bill Siksay Gary Goodyear Bill Siksay Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Kevin Sorenson Art Hanger Caroline St-Hilaire Art Hanger Caroline St-Hilaire Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Darrel Stinson Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Jay Hill Vic Toews Jay Hill Vic Toews Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Marlene Jennings Mark Warawa Marlene Jennings Mark Warawa Dale Johnston Jeff Watson Dale Johnston Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Randy White Randy Kamp Randy White Gerald Keddy John Williams Gerald Keddy John Williams Jason Kenney Lynne Yelich Jason Kenney Lynne Yelich October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 49

Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Justice, droits de la personne, sécurité publique et Preparedness protection civile Members (12) Membres (12) Diane Bourgeois Richard Marceau Diane Bourgeois Richard Marceau Garry Breitkreuz Anita Neville Garry Breitkreuz Anita Neville Joe Comartin Myron Thompson Joe Comartin Myron Thompson Paul DeVillers Vic Toews Paul DeVillers Vic Toews Paul Harold Macklin Mark Warawa Paul Harold Macklin Mark Warawa John Maloney Paul Zed John Maloney Paul Zed Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Mario Laframboise Diane Ablonczy Mario Laframboise Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Derek Lee Rona Ambrose Derek Lee Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Gary Lunn David Anderson Gary Lunn Dave Batters James Lunney Dave Batters James Lunney Leon Benoit Peter MacKay Leon Benoit Peter MacKay James Bezan Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Dave MacKenzie Bill Blaikie Inky Mark Bill Blaikie Inky Mark Gord Brown Serge Ménard Gord Brown Serge Ménard Paule Brunelle Ted Menzies Paule Brunelle Ted Menzies Colin Carrie Rob Merrifield Colin Carrie Rob Merrifield Bill Casey Larry Miller Bill Casey Larry Miller Rick Casson Bob Mills Rick Casson Bob Mills David Chatters James Moore David Chatters James Moore Michael Chong Rob Moore Michael Chong Rob Moore John Cummins Rob Nicholson John Cummins Rob Nicholson Stockwell Day Deepak Obhrai Stockwell Day Deepak Obhrai Barry Devolin Gordon O'Connor Barry Devolin Gordon O'Connor Norman Doyle Bev Oda Norman Doyle Bev Oda John Duncan Brian Pallister John Duncan Brian Pallister Ken Epp Charlie Penson Ken Epp Charlie Penson Diane Finley Pierre Poilievre Diane Finley Pierre Poilievre Brian Fitzpatrick Jim Prentice Brian Fitzpatrick Jim Prentice Steven Fletcher Joe Preston Steven Fletcher Joe Preston Paul Forseth James Rajotte Paul Forseth James Rajotte Hedy Fry Scott Reid Hedy Fry Scott Reid Cheryl Gallant John Reynolds Cheryl Gallant John Reynolds Peter Goldring Lee Richardson Peter Goldring Lee Richardson Gary Goodyear Gerry Ritz Gary Goodyear Gerry Ritz Jim Gouk Andrew Scheer Jim Gouk Andrew Scheer Gurmant Grewal Gary Schellenberger Gurmant Grewal Gary Schellenberger Nina Grewal Werner Schmidt Nina Grewal Werner Schmidt Helena Guergis Bill Siksay Helena Guergis Bill Siksay Art Hanger Carol Skelton Art Hanger Carol Skelton Stephen Harper Joy Smith Stephen Harper Joy Smith Richard Harris Monte Solberg Richard Harris Monte Solberg Jeremy Harrison Kevin Sorenson Jeremy Harrison Kevin Sorenson Loyola Hearn Darrel Stinson Loyola Hearn Darrel Stinson Russ Hiebert Belinda Stronach Russ Hiebert Belinda Stronach Jay Hill Greg Thompson Jay Hill Greg Thompson Betty Hinton David Tilson Betty Hinton David Tilson Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Brian Jean Merv Tweed Brian Jean Merv Tweed Marlene Jennings Peter Van Loan Marlene Jennings Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson 50 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich

National Defence and Veterans Affairs Défense nationale et anciens combattants

Members (12) Membres (12) Claude Bachand Keith Martin Claude Bachand Keith Martin Bill Blaikie Lawrence O'Brien Bill Blaikie Lawrence O'Brien Rick Casson Pat O'Brien Rick Casson Pat O'Brien Betty Hinton Gordon O'Connor Betty Hinton Gordon O'Connor Judi Longfield Gilles-A. Perron Judi Longfield Gilles-A. Perron Dave MacKenzie Anthony Rota Dave MacKenzie Anthony Rota

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Francine Lalonde Jim Abbott Francine Lalonde Diane Ablonczy Guy Lauzon Diane Ablonczy Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rob Anders James Lunney Rob Anders James Lunney David Anderson Peter MacKay David Anderson Peter MacKay Dave Batters Inky Mark Dave Batters Inky Mark Leon Benoit Ted Menzies Leon Benoit Ted Menzies James Bezan Rob Merrifield James Bezan Rob Merrifield Bernard Bigras Larry Miller Bernard Bigras Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Gord Brown James Moore Gord Brown James Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Robert Carrier Anita Neville Robert Carrier Anita Neville Bill Casey Rob Nicholson Bill Casey Rob Nicholson David Chatters Deepak Obhrai David Chatters Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Bev Oda Michael Chong Bev Oda Roger Clavet Brian Pallister Roger Clavet Brian Pallister John Cummins Charlie Penson John Cummins Charlie Penson Stockwell Day Pierre Poilievre Stockwell Day Pierre Poilievre Odina Desrochers Jim Prentice Odina Desrochers Jim Prentice Barry Devolin Joe Preston Barry Devolin Joe Preston Norman Doyle Marcel Proulx Norman Doyle Marcel Proulx John Duncan James Rajotte John Duncan James Rajotte Ken Epp Scott Reid Ken Epp Scott Reid Diane Finley John Reynolds Diane Finley John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Joy Smith Jim Gouk Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Caroline St-Hilaire Helena Guergis Caroline St-Hilaire Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Peter Stoffer Stephen Harper Peter Stoffer Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Russ Hiebert David Tilson Jay Hill Vic Toews Jay Hill Vic Toews Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Brian Jean Merv Tweed Brian Jean Merv Tweed Dale Johnston Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Peter Van Loan Peter Julian Maurice Vellacott Peter Julian Maurice Vellacott October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 51

Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Jason Kenney Randy White Jason Kenney Randy White Ed Komarnicki John Williams Ed Komarnicki John Williams Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich

Official Languages Langues officielles Members (12) Membres (12) Guy André Guy Lauzon Guy André Guy Lauzon Françoise Boivin Pierre Poilievre Françoise Boivin Pierre Poilievre Roy Cullen Pablo Rodriguez Roy Cullen Pablo Rodriguez Odina Desrochers Andrew Scheer Odina Desrochers Andrew Scheer Marc Godbout Raymond Simard Marc Godbout Raymond Simard Yvon Godin Maurice Vellacott Yvon Godin Maurice Vellacott Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Jim Abbott Ed Komarnicki Diane Ablonczy Maka Kotto Diane Ablonczy Maka Kotto Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Rona Ambrose Jack Layton Rona Ambrose Jack Layton Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Tom Lukiwski David Anderson Gary Lunn David Anderson Gary Lunn Dave Batters James Lunney Dave Batters James Lunney Leon Benoit Peter MacKay Leon Benoit Peter MacKay Stéphane Bergeron Dave MacKenzie Stéphane Bergeron Dave MacKenzie James Bezan Inky Mark James Bezan Inky Mark Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Ted Menzies Ed Broadbent Rob Merrifield Ed Broadbent Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Colin Carrie Bob Mills Colin Carrie Bob Mills Bill Casey James Moore Bill Casey James Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Joe Comartin Gordon O'Connor Joe Comartin Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Bev Oda John Cummins Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Jim Prentice John Duncan Joe Preston John Duncan Joe Preston Ken Epp James Rajotte Ken Epp James Rajotte Diane Finley Scott Reid Diane Finley Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick John Reynolds Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Joy Smith Jim Gouk Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Jay Hill Merv Tweed Jay Hill Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Mark Warawa Rahim Jaffer Mark Warawa 52 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Brian Jean Judy Wasylycia-Leis Brian Jean Judy Wasylycia-Leis Dale Johnston Jeff Watson Dale Johnston Jeff Watson Peter Julian Randy White Peter Julian Randy White Randy Kamp John Williams Randy Kamp John Williams Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Gerald Keddy Lynne Yelich Jason Kenney Jason Kenney

Public Accounts Comptes publics

Members (12) Membres (12) Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Dean Allison Daryl Kramp Gary Carr Walt Lastewka Gary Carr Walt Lastewka David Christopherson Shawn Murphy David Christopherson Shawn Murphy Brian Fitzpatrick Benoît Sauvageau Brian Fitzpatrick Benoît Sauvageau Sébastien Gagnon John Williams Sébastien Gagnon John Williams Mark Holland Borys Wrzesnewskyj Mark Holland Borys Wrzesnewskyj Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Tom Lukiwski Jim Abbott Tom Lukiwski Diane Ablonczy Gary Lunn Diane Ablonczy Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rob Anders Peter MacKay Rob Anders Peter MacKay David Anderson Dave MacKenzie David Anderson Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Inky Mark Dave Batters Inky Mark Leon Benoit Diane Marleau Leon Benoit Diane Marleau James Bezan Pat Martin James Bezan Pat Martin Robert Bouchard Ted Menzies Robert Bouchard Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Colin Carrie Bob Mills Colin Carrie Bob Mills Bill Casey James Moore Bill Casey James Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Nicholson David Chatters Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Gordon O'Connor Stockwell Day Bev Oda Stockwell Day Bev Oda Bev Desjarlais Brian Pallister Bev Desjarlais Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Jim Prentice John Duncan Jim Prentice Ken Epp Joe Preston Ken Epp Joe Preston Diane Finley James Rajotte Diane Finley James Rajotte Steven Fletcher Scott Reid Steven Fletcher Scott Reid Paul Forseth John Reynolds Paul Forseth John Reynolds Cheryl Gallant Lee Richardson Cheryl Gallant Lee Richardson Peter Goldring Gerry Ritz Peter Goldring Gerry Ritz Gary Goodyear Andrew Scheer Gary Goodyear Andrew Scheer Jim Gouk Gary Schellenberger Jim Gouk Gary Schellenberger Gurmant Grewal Werner Schmidt Gurmant Grewal Werner Schmidt Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Helena Guergis Joy Smith Helena Guergis Joy Smith Art Hanger Monte Solberg Art Hanger Monte Solberg Stephen Harper Kevin Sorenson Stephen Harper Kevin Sorenson Richard Harris Darrel Stinson Richard Harris Darrel Stinson Jeremy Harrison Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Belinda Stronach Loyola Hearn Louise Thibault Loyola Hearn Louise Thibault Russ Hiebert Greg Thompson Russ Hiebert Greg Thompson Jay Hill Myron Thompson Jay Hill Myron Thompson Betty Hinton David Tilson Betty Hinton David Tilson Rahim Jaffer Vic Toews Rahim Jaffer Vic Toews Brian Jean Bradley Trost Brian Jean Bradley Trost Dale Johnston Merv Tweed Dale Johnston Merv Tweed October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 53

Peter Julian Peter Van Loan Peter Julian Peter Van Loan Randy Kamp Maurice Vellacott Randy Kamp Maurice Vellacott Gerald Keddy Mark Warawa Gerald Keddy Mark Warawa Jason Kenney Judy Wasylycia-Leis Jason Kenney Judy Wasylycia-Leis Ed Komarnicki Jeff Watson Ed Komarnicki Jeff Watson Guy Lauzon Randy White Guy Lauzon Randy White Jack Layton Lynne Yelich Jack Layton Lynne Yelich

Status of Women Condition féminine

Members (12) Membres (12) France Bonsant Susan Kadis France Bonsant Susan Kadis Paule Brunelle Anita Neville Paule Brunelle Anita Neville Jean Crowder Beth Phinney Jean Crowder Beth Phinney Nina Grewal Russ Powers Nina Grewal Russ Powers Helena Guergis Paddy Torsney Helena Guergis Paddy Torsney Betty Hinton Lynne Yelich Betty Hinton Lynne Yelich

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Diane Ablonczy Jack Layton Diane Ablonczy Jack Layton Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rob Anders James Lunney Rob Anders James Lunney David Anderson Peter MacKay David Anderson Peter MacKay Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark James Bezan Alexa McDonough James Bezan Alexa McDonough Diane Bourgeois Ted Menzies Diane Bourgeois Ted Menzies Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Larry Miller Gord Brown Larry Miller Colin Carrie Bob Mills Colin Carrie Bob Mills Bill Casey Maria Minna Bill Casey Maria Minna Rick Casson James Moore Rick Casson James Moore David Chatters Rob Moore David Chatters Rob Moore Michael Chong Rob Nicholson Michael Chong Rob Nicholson John Cummins Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Deepak Obhrai Libby Davies Gordon O'Connor Libby Davies Gordon O'Connor Stockwell Day Bev Oda Stockwell Day Bev Oda Nicole Demers Brian Pallister Nicole Demers Brian Pallister Bev Desjarlais Charlie Penson Bev Desjarlais Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Barry Devolin Pierre Poilievre Ruby Dhalla Jim Prentice Ruby Dhalla Jim Prentice Norman Doyle Joe Preston Norman Doyle Joe Preston John Duncan James Rajotte John Duncan James Rajotte Ken Epp Scott Reid Ken Epp Scott Reid Diane Finley John Reynolds Diane Finley John Reynolds Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Paul Forseth Andrew Scheer Christiane Gagnon Gary Schellenberger Christiane Gagnon Gary Schellenberger Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Jim Gouk Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Gurmant Grewal Kevin Sorenson Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Darrel Stinson Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Greg Thompson Richard Harris Greg Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Russ Hiebert Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Vic Toews 54 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Jay Hill Bradley Trost Jay Hill Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Merv Tweed Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Maurice Vellacott Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Gerald Keddy Judy Wasylycia-Leis Gerald Keddy Judy Wasylycia-Leis Jason Kenney Jeff Watson Jason Kenney Jeff Watson Ed Komarnicki Randy White Ed Komarnicki Randy White Daryl Kramp John Williams Daryl Kramp John Williams

Transport Transports Members (12) Membres (12) Dave Batters Jim Gouk Dave Batters Jim Gouk Raymond Bonin Jim Karygiannis Raymond Bonin Jim Karygiannis John Cannis Rob Nicholson John Cannis Rob Nicholson Robert Carrier Marcel Proulx Robert Carrier Marcel Proulx Bev Desjarlais Andrew Scheer Bev Desjarlais Andrew Scheer Roger Gallaway Caroline St-Hilaire Roger Gallaway Caroline St-Hilaire Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Mario Laframboise Jim Abbott Mario Laframboise Diane Ablonczy Réal Lapierre Diane Ablonczy Réal Lapierre Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Guy Lauzon Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Tom Lukiwski Rob Anders Gary Lunn Rob Anders Gary Lunn David Anderson James Lunney David Anderson James Lunney Colleen Beaumier Peter MacKay Colleen Beaumier Peter MacKay Don Bell Dave MacKenzie Don Bell Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Inky Mark Leon Benoit Inky Mark James Bezan Brian Masse James Bezan Brian Masse Bernard Bigras Ted Menzies Bernard Bigras Ted Menzies Françoise Boivin Rob Merrifield Françoise Boivin Rob Merrifield Marc Boulianne Larry Miller Marc Boulianne Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Gord Brown James Moore Gord Brown James Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Bill Casey Deepak Obhrai Bill Casey Deepak Obhrai Rick Casson Gordon O'Connor Rick Casson Gordon O'Connor David Chatters Bev Oda David Chatters Bev Oda Michael Chong Brian Pallister Michael Chong Brian Pallister Joe Comartin Charlie Penson Joe Comartin Charlie Penson Paul Crête Pierre Poilievre Paul Crête Pierre Poilievre John Cummins Jim Prentice John Cummins Jim Prentice Stockwell Day Joe Preston Stockwell Day Joe Preston Barry Devolin James Rajotte Barry Devolin James Rajotte Norman Doyle Yasmin Ratansi Norman Doyle Yasmin Ratansi John Duncan Scott Reid John Duncan Scott Reid Ken Epp John Reynolds Ken Epp John Reynolds Diane Finley Lee Richardson Diane Finley Lee Richardson Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Brian Fitzpatrick Gerry Ritz Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Steven Fletcher Gary Schellenberger Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Paul Forseth Werner Schmidt Cheryl Gallant Christian Simard Cheryl Gallant Christian Simard Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Peter Goldring Carol Skelton Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gary Goodyear Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Gurmant Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Nina Grewal Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Peter Stoffer Art Hanger Peter Stoffer Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Belinda Stronach Richard Harris Greg Thompson Richard Harris Greg Thompson October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 55

Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison Myron Thompson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Loyola Hearn David Tilson Russ Hiebert Vic Toews Russ Hiebert Vic Toews Jay Hill Bradley Trost Jay Hill Bradley Trost Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Merv Tweed Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Peter Van Loan Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Maurice Vellacott Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Dale Johnston Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Daryl Kramp Daryl Kramp The Committee further recommends, pursuant to Standing Le Comité recommande de plus, conformément au mandat Order 104(4), that the list of associate members for the Standing que lui confère l’article 104(4) du Règlement, que la liste des Committee on Procedure and House Affairs be as follows: membres associés du Comité permanent de la procédure et des affaires de la Chambre figure comme suit :

Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Jim Abbott Daryl Kramp Diane Ablonczy Guy Lauzon Diane Ablonczy Guy Lauzon Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Tom Lukiwski Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose Gary Lunn Rob Anders James Lunney Rob Anders James Lunney David Anderson Peter MacKay David Anderson Peter MacKay Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Dave Batters Dave MacKenzie Leon Benoit Richard Marceau Leon Benoit Richard Marceau James Bezan Inky Mark James Bezan Inky Mark Garry Breitkreuz Réal Ménard Garry Breitkreuz Réal Ménard Ed Broadbent Ted Menzies Ed Broadbent Ted Menzies Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Gord Brown Rob Merrifield Colin Carrie Larry Miller Colin Carrie Larry Miller Rick Casson Bob Mills Rick Casson Bob Mills David Chatters James Moore David Chatters James Moore Michael Chong Rob Moore Michael Chong Rob Moore Joe Comartin Rob Nicholson Joe Comartin Rob Nicholson Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai Jean Crowder Deepak Obhrai John Cummins Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Gordon O'Connor Libby Davies Bev Oda Libby Davies Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Jim Prentice John Duncan Jim Prentice Ken Epp Joe Preston Ken Epp Joe Preston Diane Finley Marcel Proulx Diane Finley Marcel Proulx Brian Fitzpatrick James Rajotte Brian Fitzpatrick James Rajotte Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Steven Fletcher Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Paul Forseth Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Andrew Scheer Cheryl Gallant Andrew Scheer Michel Gauthier Gary Schellenberger Michel Gauthier Gary Schellenberger Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Peter Goldring Werner Schmidt Gary Goodyear Raymond Simard Gary Goodyear Raymond Simard Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Jim Gouk Carol Skelton Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Gurmant Grewal Joy Smith Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Nina Grewal Monte Solberg Monique Guay Kevin Sorenson Monique Guay Kevin Sorenson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Helena Guergis Darrel Stinson Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Art Hanger Belinda Stronach Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Stephen Harper Greg Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Richard Harris Myron Thompson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Jeremy Harrison David Tilson Loyola Hearn Vic Toews Loyola Hearn Vic Toews 56 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Russ Hiebert Bradley Trost Jay Hill Merv Tweed Jay Hill Merv Tweed Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Betty Hinton Peter Van Loan Rahim Jaffer Maurice Vellacott Rahim Jaffer Maurice Vellacott Brian Jean Mark Warawa Brian Jean Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Randy Kamp Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Randy White Gerald Keddy Randy White Jason Kenney John Williams Jason Kenney John Williams Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich Ed Komarnicki Lynne Yelich The Committee further recommends, pursuant to Standing Le Comité recommande de plus, conformément au mandat Orders 104(3) and (4), that the list of members and associate que lui confèrent les articles 104(3) et (4) du Règlement, que la members for Standing Joint Committees of this House be as liste des membres et membres associés des comités mixtes follows: permanents de la Chambre figure comme suit :

Library of Parliament Bibliothèque du Parlement Members (12) Membres (12) Charlie Angus Susan Kadis Charlie Angus Susan Kadis Marc Boulianne Réal Lapierre Marc Boulianne Réal Lapierre Gerry Byrne Dominic LeBlanc Gerry Byrne Dominic LeBlanc Mark Eyking Raymond Simard Mark Eyking Raymond Simard Cheryl Gallant Darrel Stinson Cheryl Gallant Darrel Stinson Peter Goldring Maurice Vellacott Peter Goldring Maurice Vellacott Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Jim Abbott Guy Lauzon Diane Ablonczy Tom Lukiwski Diane Ablonczy Tom Lukiwski Dean Allison Gary Lunn Dean Allison Gary Lunn Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rona Ambrose James Lunney Rob Anders Peter MacKay Rob Anders Peter MacKay David Anderson Dave MacKenzie David Anderson Dave MacKenzie Guy André Inky Mark Guy André Inky Mark Dave Batters Ted Menzies Dave Batters Ted Menzies Leon Benoit Rob Merrifield Leon Benoit Rob Merrifield James Bezan Larry Miller James Bezan Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Garry Breitkreuz Bob Mills Gord Brown James Moore Gord Brown James Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Colin Carrie Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Nicholson Bill Casey Rob Nicholson Rick Casson Deepak Obhrai Rick Casson Deepak Obhrai David Chatters Gordon O'Connor David Chatters Gordon O'Connor Michael Chong Bev Oda Michael Chong Bev Oda John Cummins Brian Pallister John Cummins Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Stockwell Day Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Louis Plamondon Barry Devolin Louis Plamondon Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Jim Prentice John Duncan Jim Prentice Ken Epp Joe Preston Ken Epp Joe Preston Diane Finley James Rajotte Diane Finley James Rajotte Brian Fitzpatrick Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick Scott Reid Steven Fletcher John Reynolds Steven Fletcher John Reynolds Paul Forseth Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Lee Richardson Gary Goodyear Gerry Ritz Gary Goodyear Gerry Ritz Jim Gouk Andrew Scheer Jim Gouk Andrew Scheer Gurmant Grewal Gary Schellenberger Gurmant Grewal Gary Schellenberger Nina Grewal Werner Schmidt Nina Grewal Werner Schmidt Helena Guergis Carol Skelton Helena Guergis Carol Skelton Art Hanger Joy Smith Art Hanger Joy Smith Stephen Harper Monte Solberg Stephen Harper Monte Solberg Richard Harris Kevin Sorenson Richard Harris Kevin Sorenson Jeremy Harrison Belinda Stronach Jeremy Harrison Belinda Stronach October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 57

Loyola Hearn Greg Thompson Loyola Hearn Greg Thompson Russ Hiebert Myron Thompson Russ Hiebert Myron Thompson Jay Hill David Tilson Jay Hill David Tilson Betty Hinton Vic Toews Betty Hinton Vic Toews Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Rahim Jaffer Bradley Trost Brian Jean Merv Tweed Brian Jean Merv Tweed Dale Johnston Peter Van Loan Dale Johnston Peter Van Loan Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Randy Kamp Mark Warawa Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Gerald Keddy Jeff Watson Jason Kenney Randy White Jason Kenney Randy White Ed Komarnicki John Williams Ed Komarnicki John Williams Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich Daryl Kramp Lynne Yelich

Scrutiny of Regulations Examen de la réglementation Members (12) Membres (12) Rob Anders Randy Kamp Rob Anders Randy Kamp Maurizio Bevilacqua Derek Lee Maurizio Bevilacqua Derek Lee Robert Bouchard Paul Harold Macklin Robert Bouchard Paul Harold Macklin Gurmant Grewal Lynn Myers Gurmant Grewal Lynn Myers Monique Guay Tom Wappel Monique Guay Tom Wappel Art Hanger Judy Wasylycia-Leis Art Hanger Judy Wasylycia-Leis Associate Members Membres associés Jim Abbott James Lunney Jim Abbott James Lunney Diane Ablonczy Peter MacKay Diane Ablonczy Peter MacKay Dean Allison Dave MacKenzie Dean Allison Dave MacKenzie Rona Ambrose Richard Marceau Rona Ambrose Richard Marceau David Anderson Inky Mark David Anderson Inky Mark Dave Batters Serge Ménard Dave Batters Serge Ménard Leon Benoit Ted Menzies Leon Benoit Ted Menzies James Bezan Rob Merrifield James Bezan Rob Merrifield Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Garry Breitkreuz Larry Miller Gord Brown Bob Mills Gord Brown Bob Mills Colin Carrie James Moore Colin Carrie James Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Bill Casey Rob Moore Rick Casson Rob Nicholson Rick Casson Rob Nicholson David Chatters Deepak Obhrai David Chatters Deepak Obhrai Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor Michael Chong Gordon O'Connor John Cummins Bev Oda John Cummins Bev Oda Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Stockwell Day Brian Pallister Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Barry Devolin Charlie Penson Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre Norman Doyle Pierre Poilievre John Duncan Jim Prentice John Duncan Jim Prentice Ken Epp Joe Preston Ken Epp Joe Preston Diane Finley James Rajotte Diane Finley James Rajotte Brian Fitzpatrick Scott Reid Brian Fitzpatrick Scott Reid Steven Fletcher John Reynolds Steven Fletcher John Reynolds Paul Forseth Lee Richardson Paul Forseth Lee Richardson Cheryl Gallant Gerry Ritz Cheryl Gallant Gerry Ritz Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Peter Goldring Andrew Scheer Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Gary Goodyear Gary Schellenberger Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Jim Gouk Werner Schmidt Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Nina Grewal Carol Skelton Helena Guergis Joy Smith Helena Guergis Joy Smith Stephen Harper Monte Solberg Stephen Harper Monte Solberg Richard Harris Kevin Sorenson Richard Harris Kevin Sorenson Jeremy Harrison Darrel Stinson Jeremy Harrison Darrel Stinson Loyola Hearn Belinda Stronach Loyola Hearn Belinda Stronach Russ Hiebert Greg Thompson Russ Hiebert Greg Thompson Jay Hill Myron Thompson Jay Hill Myron Thompson Betty Hinton David Tilson Betty Hinton David Tilson 58 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

Rahim Jaffer Vic Toews Rahim Jaffer Vic Toews Brian Jean Bradley Trost Brian Jean Bradley Trost Dale Johnston Merv Tweed Dale Johnston Merv Tweed Gerald Keddy Peter Van Loan Gerald Keddy Peter Van Loan Jason Kenney Maurice Vellacott Jason Kenney Maurice Vellacott Ed Komarnicki Mark Warawa Ed Komarnicki Mark Warawa Daryl Kramp Jeff Watson Daryl Kramp Jeff Watson Mario Laframboise Randy White Mario Laframboise Randy White Guy Lauzon John Williams Guy Lauzon John Williams Tom Lukiwski Lynne Yelich Tom Lukiwski Lynne Yelich Gary Lunn Gary Lunn It is further recommended that a message be sent to the Il est en outre recommandé qu'un message soit transmis au Senate to acquaint their Honours of the names of the members Sénat afin d'informer les honorables sénateurs des noms des to serve on behalf of this House on the standing joint députés qui représenteront la Chambre au sein des comités committees. mixtes permanents. A copy of the relevant Minutes of Proceedings (Meeting No. Un exemplaire des procès-verbaux pertinents (réunion no 1) 1) is tabled. est déposé.

INTERRUPTION INTERRUPTION At 6:20 p.m., the sitting was suspended. À 18 h 20, la séance est suspendue. At 7:00 p.m., the sitting resumed. À 19 heures, la séance reprend.

GOVERNMENT ORDERS ORDRES ÉMANANT DU GOUVERNEMENT At 7:00 p.m., pursuant to Order made Tuesday, October 5, À 19 heures, conformément à l'ordre adopté le mardi 5 octobre 2004, the House resolved itself into a Committee of the Whole for 2004, la Chambre se forme en comité plénier pour étudier la the consideration of the following motion, — That this Committee motion suivante, — Que le comité prenne note de take note of bovine spongiform encephalopathy. (Government l'encéphalopathie bovine spongiforme. (Affaires émanant du Business No. 2) gouvernement no 2) October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 59

At midnight, the Committee reported that progress had been À minuit, le comité fait rapport de l’état de la question. made. Pursuant to Order made earlier today, the Committee will Conformément à l’ordre adopté plus tôt aujourd’hui, le comité consider the motion again on Tuesday, October 12, 2004, at 7:00 p. reprendra l’étude de la motion le mardi 12 octobre 2004, à 19 m. heures.

RETURNS AND REPORTS DEPOSITED WITH THE CLERK ÉTATS ET RAPPORTS DÉPOSÉS AUPRÈS DU GREFFIER DE OF THE HOUSE LA CHAMBRE Pursuant to Standing Order 32(1), papers deposited with the Conformément à l'article 32(1) du Règlement, des documents Clerk of the House were laid upon the Table as follows: remis au Greffier de la Chambre sont déposés sur le Bureau de la Chambre comme suit : — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Report of the Social — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Rapport du Conseil Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, together de recherches en sciences humaines du Canada, ainsi que le rapport with the Auditor General's Report, for the fiscal year ended March du Vérificateur général y afférent, pour l'exercice terminé le 31 31, 2004, pursuant to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research mars 2004, conformément à la Loi sur le Conseil de recherches en Council Act, R.S. 1985, c. S-12, sbs. 20(2). — Sessional Paper No. sciences humaines du Canada, L.R. 1985, ch. S-12, par. 20(2). — 8560-381-36-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently Document parlementaire no 8560-381-36-01. (Conformément à referred to the Standing Committee on Industry, Natural l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité Ressources, Science and Technology) permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Copy of the Rules — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Copie des Règles amending the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Rules (JUS-602370), modifiant les Règles générales sur la faillite et l'insolvabilité (JUS- pursuant to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S. 1985, c. B-3, 602370), conformément à la Loi sur la faillite, L.R. 1985, ch. B-3, sbs. 209(2). — Sessional Paper No. 8560-381-284-01. (Pursuant par. 209(2). — Document parlementaire no 8560-381-284-01. to Standing Order 32(5), permanently referred to the Standing (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en Committee on Industry, Natural Resources, Science and permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources Technology) naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Report of the — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Rapport de la Copyright Board for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2004, Commission du droit d'auteur pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars pursuant to the Copyright Act, R.S. 1985 (4th Supp.), c. 10 , s. 12. 2004, conformément à la Loi sur le droit d'auteur, L.R. 1985 (4e — Sessional Paper No. 8560-381-555-01. (Pursuant to Standing suppl.), ch. 10, art. 12. — Document parlementaire no 8560-381- Order 32(5), permanently referred to the Standing Committee on 555-01. (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en Industry, Natural Resources, Science and Technology) permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Reports of the — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Rapports de la Copyright Board for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2004, Commission du droit d'auteur pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars pursuant to the Access to Information Act and to the Privacy Act, 2004, conformément à la Loi sur l'accès à l'information et à la Loi R.S. 1985, c. A-1 and P-21, sbs. 72(2). — Sessional Paper No. sur la protection des renseignements personnels, L.R. 1985, ch. A- 8561-381-546-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently 1 et P-21, par. 72(2). — Document parlementaire no 8561-381- referred to the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, 546-01. (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) permanence au Comité permanent de la justice, des droits de la personne, de la sécurité publique et de la protection civile) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Reports of the — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Rapports du Conseil National Research Council for the fiscal year ended March 31, national de recherches pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars 2004, 2004, pursuant to the Access to Information Act and to the Privacy conformément à la Loi sur l'accès à l'information et à la Loi sur la Act, R. S. 1985, c. A-1 and P-21, sbs. 72(2). — Sessional Paper protection des renseignements personnels, L. R. 1985, ch. A-1 et P- No. 8561-381-639-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), 21, par. 72(2). — Document parlementaire no 8561-381-639-01. permanently referred to the Standing Committee on Justice, (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) permanence au Comité permanent de la justice, des droits de la personne, de la sécurité publique et de la protection civile) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Reports of the — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Rapports du Conseil Standards Council of Canada for the fiscal year ended March 31, canadien des normes pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars 2004, 2004, pursuant to the Access to Information Act and to the Privacy conformément à la Loi sur l'accès à l'information et à la Loi sur la Act, R. S. 1985, c. A-1 and P-21, sbs. 72(2). — Sessional Paper protection des renseignements personnels, L. R. 1985, ch. A-1 et P- No. 8561-381-642-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), 21, par. 72(2). — Document parlementaire no 8561-381-642-01. permanently referred to the Standing Committee on Justice, Human Rights, Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) 60 October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004

(Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent de la justice, des droits de la personne, de la sécurité publique et de la protection civile) — by Mr. Emerson (Minister of Industry) — Summary of the — par M. Emerson (ministre de l'Industrie) — Sommaire du plan Corporate Plan for 2005-2009 of the Business Development Bank d'entreprise de 2005-2009 de la Banque de développement du of Canada, pursuant to the Financial Administration Act, R. S. Canada, conformément à la Loi sur la gestion des finances 1985, c. F-11, sbs. 125(4). — Sessional Paper No. 8562-381-833- publiques, L. R. 1985, ch. F-11, par. 125(4). — Document 01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently referred to the parlementaire no 8562-381-833-01. (Conformément à l'article 32 Standing Committee on Industry, Natural Resources, Science and (5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent de Technology) l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. Goodale (Minister of Finance) — Report of the Office of — par M. Goodale (ministre des Finances) — Rapport du Bureau the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, together with the du surintendant des institutions financières, ainsi que le rapport du Auditor General's Report, for the fiscal year ended March 31, Vérificateur général y afférent, pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars 2004, pursuant to the Financial Institutions and Deposit Insurance 2004, conformément à la Loi sur les institutions financières et System Amendment Act, R.S. 1985, c. 18 (3rd Supp.), s. 25. — modifiant le système d'assurance-dépôts, L.R. 1985, ch. 18 (3e Sessional Paper No. 8560-381-535-01. (Pursuant to Standing suppl.), art. 25. — Document parlementaire no 8560-381-535-01. Order 32(5), permanently referred to the Standing Committee on (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en Finance) permanence au Comité permanent des finances) — by Mr. Goodale (Minister of Finance) — Report of the — par M. Goodale (ministre des Finances) — Rapport de l'Agence Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, together with the Auditor de la consommation en matière financière du Canada, ainsi que le General's Report, for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2004, rapport du Vérificateur général y afférent, pour l'exercice terminé le pursuant to the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada Act, S.C. 31 mars 2004, conformément à la Loi sur l'Agence de la 2001, c. 9, s. 34. — Sessional Paper No. 8560-381-797-01. consommation en matière financière du Canada, L.C. 2001, ch. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently referred to the 9, par. 34. — Document parlementaire no 8560-381-797-01. Standing Committee on Finance) (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent des finances) — by Mr. McGuire (Minister of the Atlantic Canada Opportunities — par M. McGuire (ministre de l'Agence de promotion Agency) — Report of the Enterprise Cape Breton Corporation, économique du Canada atlantique) — Rapport de la Société together with the Auditor General's Report, for the fiscal year d'expansion du Cap-Breton, ainsi que le rapport du Vérificateur ended March 31, 2004, pursuant to the Financial Administration général y afférent, pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars 2004, Act, R. S. 1985, c. F-11, sbs. 150(1). — Sessional Paper No. 8560- conformément à la Loi sur la gestion des finances publiques, L. R. 381-575-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently 1985, ch. F-11, par. 150(1). — Document parlementaire no 8560- referred to the Standing Committee on Industry, Natural 381-575-01. (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi Resources, Science and Technology) en permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. McGuire (Minister of the Atlantic Canada Opportunities — par M. McGuire (ministre de l'Agence de promotion Agency) — Report of the Cape Breton Growth Fund Corporation, économique du Canada atlantique) — Rapport de la Corporation together with the Auditor General's Report, for the fiscal year Fonds d'investissement du Cap-Breton, ainsi que le rapport du ended March 31, 2004, pursuant to the Financial Administration Vérificateur général y afférent, pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars Act, R.S. 1985, c. F-11, sbs. 150(1). — Sessional Paper No. 8560- 2004, conformément à la Loi sur la gestion des finances publiques, 381-778-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently L.R. 1985, ch. F-11, par. 150(1). — Document parlementaire referred to the Standing Committee on Industry, Natural no 8560-381-778-01. (Conformément à l'article 32(5) du Resources, Science and Technology) Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. McGuire (Minister of the Atlantic Canada Opportunities — par M. McGuire (ministre de l'Agence de promotion Agency) — Summaries of the Corporate Plan for 2004-2005 to économique du Canada atlantique) — Sommaires du plan 2008-2009 of the Cape Breton Growth Fund and of the Operating d'entreprise de 2004-2005 à 2008-2009 de la Société du Fonds and Capital budgets for 2004-2005, pursuant to the Financial d'investissement du Cap-Breton et des budgets de fonctionnement Administration Act, R.S. 1985, c. F-11, sbs. 125(4). — Sessional et des immobilisations de 2004-2005, conformément à la Loi sur la Paper No. 8562-381-827-02. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), gestion des finances publiques, L.R. 1985, ch. F-11, par. 125(4). — permanently referred to the Standing Committee on Industry, Document parlementaire no 8562-381-827-02. (Conformément à Natural Resources, Science and Technology) l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. McGuire (Minister of the Atlantic Canada Opportunities — par M. McGuire (ministre de l'Agence de promotion Agency) — Summaries of the Corporate Plan for 2004-2005 to économique du Canada atlantique) — Sommaires du plan 2008-2009 and of the Capital and Operating Budgets for 2004- d'entreprise de 2004-2005 à 2008-2009 et des budgets de October 7, 2004 Le 7 octobre 2004 61

2005 of the Enterprise Cape Breton Corporation, pursuant to the fonctionnement et d'immobilisation de 2004-2005 de la Société Financial Administration Act, R. S. 1985, c. F-11, sbs. 125(4). — d'expansion du Cap-Breton, conformément à la Loi sur la gestion Sessional Paper No. 8562-381-855-01. (Pursuant to Standing des finances publiques, L. R. 1985, ch. F-11, par. 125(4). — Order 32(5), permanently referred to the Standing Committee on Document parlementaire no 8562-381-855-01. (Conformément à Industry, Natural Resources, Science and Technology) l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent de l'industrie, des ressources naturelles, des sciences et de la technologie) — by Mr. Regan (Minister of Fisheries and Oceans) — Report of — par M. Regan (ministre des Pêches et des Océans) — Rapport the operations under the Fisheries Development Act for the fiscal des travaux effectués en vertu de la Loi sur le développement de la year ended March 31, 2004, pursuant to the Fisheries Development pêche pour l'exercice terminé le 31 mars 2004, conformément à la Act, R.S. 1985, c. F-21, s. 10. — Sessional Paper No. 8560-381- Loi sur le développement de la pêche, L.R. 1985, ch. F-21, art. 10. 292-01. (Pursuant to Standing Order 32(5), permanently referred — Document parlementaire no 8560-381-292-01. (Conformément to the Standing Committee on Fisheries and Oceans) à l'article 32(5) du Règlement, renvoi en permanence au Comité permanent des pêches et des océans)

ADJOURNMENT AJOURNEMENT At 12:02 a.m., the Speaker adjourned the House until later À 0 h 2, le Président ajourne la Chambre jusqu'à plus tard today at 10:00 a.m., pursuant to Standing Order 24(1). aujourd'hui, à 10 heures, conformément à l'article 24(1) du Règlement.