DOCSLIB.ORG

Befehl Ist Befehl

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Befehl Ist Befehl Faculteit Rechtsgeleerdheid Universiteit Gent Academiejaar 2013-2014 BEFEHL IST BEFEHL THE ‘SUPERIOR ORDERS’ DEFENCE Masterproef van de opleiding: ‘Master in de rechten’ Ingediend door Evy Bauwens (00605549) Promotor: Professor A.Cliquet Commissaris: C. Vandewoude 2 Befehl ist Befehl, the ‘superior orders’ defence TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................ 2 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 5 2. Research Question ....................................................................................................................... 7 3. History and debate .................................................................................................................... 11 1. 1. The First World War .................................................................................................................. 12 1.1.1. General Overview ................................................................................................................ 12 1.1.2. The First International Tribunal ........................................................................................... 17 1.1.3. The Leipzich Trials ............................................................................................................... 18 Robert Neumann’s case ........................................................................................................................... 19 Dover Castle case ..................................................................................................................................... 19 The Llandovery castle case ....................................................................................................................... 20 Stenger and Crusius case .......................................................................................................................... 21 1.1.4. the Fryatt trial ...................................................................................................................... 21 1.1.5. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................... 22 1.2.The Second World War ................................................................................................................ 24 1.2.1. General Overview ................................................................................................................ 24 1.2.2. The Nuremberg Trials .......................................................................................................... 28 1.2.3. The Tokyo Tribunal .............................................................................................................. 32 1.2.4. Allied Tribunals after the Second World War ...................................................................... 33 Dachau trials ............................................................................................................................................. 33 Hauptsturmführer Oscar Hans case ......................................................................................................... 36 Yoshino case-Singapore cases. ................................................................................................................. 37 The Einsatzgruppen case .......................................................................................................................... 38 1.2.5. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................... 40 1.3. The Cold War .............................................................................................................................. 41 1.3.1. General Overview ................................................................................................................ 41 1.3.2. A New World Order ............................................................................................................. 42 1.3.3.The Adorno and Asch experiments ...................................................................................... 43 1.3.4. The Korean War ................................................................................................................... 45 1.3.5. Eichmann and the Kapo trials .............................................................................................. 50 2 3 Befehl ist Befehl, the ‘superior orders’ defence 1.3.6. The wave, Zimbardo and Milgram experiments. ................................................................. 55 1.3.7. The Vietnam War ................................................................................................................ 57 The Calley Case ......................................................................................................................................... 60 1.4. Nazi Trials in the last decades: Demjanjuk, BarBie, Finta ........................................................... 65 Klaus Barbie .............................................................................................................................................. 65 Demjanjuk ................................................................................................................................................ 66 R.v. Finta, 1994 ......................................................................................................................................... 67 1.5. International Criminal TriBunal For the Former Yugoslavia ......................................................... 69 1.5.1. General Overview ................................................................................................................ 69 1.5.2. A Mitigation of Punishment ................................................................................................ 71 The Keraterm Camp case ......................................................................................................................... 72 Ivika Rajić .................................................................................................................................................. 73 Darko Mrđa, Vlašić Mountain case .......................................................................................................... 73 1.5.3. Link with duress ................................................................................................................... 74 1.5.4. Influence from psychological experiments? ........................................................................ 75 1.6. International Criminal TriBunal For Rwanda ............................................................................... 78 1.6.1. General Overview ................................................................................................................ 78 1.6.2. Link with Command Responsibility ..................................................................................... 82 1.6.3. Influence from psychological experiments? ........................................................................ 83 1.6.4. A Mitigation of Punishment ................................................................................................ 83 Bagosora, Kabilgi, Ntabakuze en Nsengiyumva case ................................................................................ 84 2. Analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 87 2.1. Link with Duress and SuPerior Orders ......................................................................................... 87 Link with Duress ....................................................................................................................................... 87 Link with Command Responsibility .......................................................................................................... 89 2.2. Interdisciplinary InFluence .......................................................................................................... 91 2.2.1. Influence from psychological and sociological research ..................................................... 91 2.2.2. Influence from history ......................................................................................................... 94 2.3. SuPerior Orders today ................................................................................................................ 96 2.3.1. The ICC – debate ................................................................................................................. 96 2.3.2. The person was under a legal obligation ............................................................................. 98 2.3.3. The person did not know that the order was unlawful ..................................................... 105 Ought to know? ...................................................................................................................................... 105 3 4 Befehl ist Befehl, the ‘superior orders’ defence The role of media as prevention of war crimes ...................................................................................... 107 2.3.4.The order was not Manifestly unlawful ............................................................................. 109 2.3.5. A breach
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A War Crime Against an Ally's Civilians: the No Gun Ri Massacre
    A WAR CRIME AGAINST AN ALLY'S CIVILIANS: THE NO GUN RI MASSACRE TAE-UNG BAIK* TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................ 456 I. THE ANATOMY OF THE No GUN Ri CASE ............ 461 A. Summary of the Incident ......................... 461 1. The Korean War (1950-1953) .............. 461 2. Three Night and Four Day Massacre ....... 463 * Research Intern, Human Rights Watch, Asia Division; Notre Dame Law School, LL.M, 2000, cum laude, Notre Dame Law Fellow, 1999-2001; Seoul National University, LL.B., 1990; Columnist, HANGYORE DAILY NEWSPAPER, 1999; Editor, FIDES, Seoul National University College of Law, 1982-1984. Publi- cations: A Dfferent View on the Kwangju Democracy Movement in 1980, THE MONTHLY OF LABOR LIBERATION LrrERATuRE, Seoul, Korea, May 1990. Former prisonerof conscience adopted by Amnesty International in 1992; released in 1998, after six years of solitary confinement. This article is a revised version of my LL.M. thesis. I dedicate this article to the people who helped me to come out of the prison. I would like to thank my academic adviser, Professor Juan E. Mendez, Director of the Center for Civil and Human Rights, for his time and invaluable advice in the course of writing this thesis. I am also greatly indebted to Associate Director Garth Meintjes, for his assistance and emotional support during my study in the Program. I would like to thank Dr. Ada Verloren Themaat and her husband for supplying me with various reading materials and suggesting the title of this work; Professor Dinah Shelton for her lessons and class discussions, which created the theoreti- cal basis for this thesis; and Ms.
    [Show full text]
  • Archival Documentation, Historical Perception, and the No Gun Ri Massacre in the Korean War
    RECORDS AND THE UNDERSTANDING OF VIOLENT EVENTS: ARCHIVAL DOCUMENTATION, HISTORICAL PERCEPTION, AND THE NO GUN RI MASSACRE IN THE KOREAN WAR by Donghee Sinn B.A., Chung-Ang University, 1993 M.A., Chung-Ang University, 1996 Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The Department of Library and Information Science School of Information Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2007 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH DEPARTMENT OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION SCIENCE SCHOOL OF INFORMATION SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Donghee Sinn It was defended on July 9, 2007 and approved by Richard J. Cox, Ph.D., DLIS, Advisor Karen F. Gracy, Ph.D., DLIS Ellen G. Detlefsen, Ph.D., DLIS Jeannette A. Bastian, Ph.D., Simmons College Dissertation Director: Richard J. Cox, Ph.D., Advisor ii Copyright © by Donghee Sinn 2007 iii RECORDS AND THE UNDERSTANDING OF VIOLENT EVENTS: ARCHIVAL DOCUMENTATION, HISTORICAL PERCEPTION, AND THE NO GUN RI MASSACRE IN THE KOREAN WAR Donghee Sinn, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2007 The archival community has long shown an interest in documenting history, and it has been assumed that archival materials are one of the major sources of historical research. However, little is known about how much impact archival holdings actually have on historical research, what role they play in building public knowledge about a historical event and how they contribute to the process of recording history. The case of the No Gun Ri incident provides a good example of how archival materials play a role in historical discussions and a good opportunity to look at archival contributions.
    [Show full text]
  • Korean War Timeline America's Forgotten War by Kallie Szczepanski, About.Com Guide
    Korean War Timeline America's Forgotten War By Kallie Szczepanski, About.com Guide At the close of World War II, the victorious Allied Powers did not know what to do with the Korean Peninsula. Korea had been a Japanese colony since the late nineteenth century, so westerners thought the country incapable of self-rule. The Korean people, however, were eager to re-establish an independent nation of Korea. Background to the Korean War: July 1945 - June 1950 Library of Congress Potsdam Conference, Russians invade Manchuria and Korea, US accepts Japanese surrender, North Korean People's Army activated, U.S. withdraws from Korea, Republic of Korea founded, North Korea claims entire peninsula, Secretary of State Acheson puts Korea outside U.S. security cordon, North Korea fires on South, North Korea declares war July 24, 1945- President Truman asks for Russian aid against Japan, Potsdam Aug. 8, 1945- 120,000 Russian troops invade Manchuria and Korea Sept. 9, 1945- U.S. accept surrender of Japanese south of 38th Parallel Feb. 8, 1948- North Korean People's Army (NKA) activated April 8, 1948- U.S. troops withdraw from Korea Aug. 15, 1948- Republic of Korea founded. Syngman Rhee elected president. Sept. 9, 1948- Democratic People's Republic (N. Korea) claims entire peninsula Jan. 12, 1950- Sec. of State Acheson says Korea is outside US security cordon June 25, 1950- 4 am, North Korea opens fire on South Korea over 38th Parallel June 25, 1950- 11 am, North Korea declares war on South Korea North Korea's Ground Assault Begins: June - July 1950 Department of Defense / National Archives UN Security Council calls for ceasefire, South Korean President flees Seoul, UN Security Council pledges military help for South Korea, U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Depictions of the Korean War: Picasso to North Korean Propaganda
    Depictions of the Korean War: Picasso to North Korean Propaganda Spanning from the early to mid-twentieth century, Korea was subject to the colonial rule of Japan. Following the defeat of the Axis powers in the Second World War, Korea was liberated from the colonial era that racked its people for thirty-five-years (“Massacre at Nogun-ri"). In Japan’s place, the United States and the Soviet Union moved in and occupied, respectively, the South and North Korean territories, which were divided along an arbitrary boundary at the 38th parallel (Williams). The world’s superpowers similarly divided defeated Germany and the United States would go on to promote a two-state solution in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The divisions of Korea and Germany, results of the ideological clash between the democratic United States and the communist Soviet Union, set the stage for the ensuing Cold War. On the 25th of June in 1950, North Korean forces, with support from the Soviet Union, invaded South Korea, initiating the Korean, or “Forgotten,” War. Warfare continued until 1953, when an armistice was signed between Chinese and North Korean military commanders and the U.S.-led United Nations Command (Williams). Notably, South Korea was not a signatory of the armistice; South Korea’s exclusion highlights the unusual circumstance that the people of Korea, a people with a shared history, were divided by the United States and the Soviet Union and incited by the super powers to fight amongst themselves in a proxy war between democracy and communism (Young-na Kim). Though depictions of the Korean War are inextricably tied to the political and social ideologies that launched the peninsula into conflict, no matter an artist’s background, his work imparts upon the viewer the indiscriminate ruination the war brought to the people of Korea.
    [Show full text]
  • No Gun Ri Massacre and the Battle of Changjin Reservoir: the Korean War in Lark and Termite and the Coldest Night
    【연구논문】 No Gun Ri Massacre and The Battle of Changjin Reservoir: The Korean War in Lark and Termite and The Coldest Night Jae Eun Yoo (Hanyang University) A few days after the 9/11 terrorist attack, scholars of history noted, with much concern, a fierce revival of the Cold War rhetoric. This was first observed in President Bush’s speeches and then quickly spread to official government discourses, media, and popular culture. In various studies of the post-9/11 America, historians such as Mary Dudziak, Marilyn Young, Amy Kaplan, Elaine Tyler May, and Bruce Cumings argue that the striking similarity between the rhetoric employed by the Bush administration and the cold war propaganda of the 1950s testify to the strength of the Cold War legacies. In other words, official and popular responses to 9/11 in the U.S. closely followed the protocols and beliefs formed and practiced in the earlier era of crisis. For instance, May points out that it was “during the cold war” that “the apparatus of wartime” became “a permanent feature of American life” 162 Jae Eun Yoo not only as rhetorical, but as a societal structuring principle” (9/11 220). If, as Jodi Kim argues, the Cold War has produceda hermeneutics peculiar to its social and international conditions, the same paradigm continues to shape the U.S. and its international relations today. The return of the Cold War’s political and cultural paradigm in the days following 9/11 manifests the often unnoticed fact that the legacies of the Cold War continues to exert their power at present; the recognition of such lasting influences of the Cold War era appears to have triggered a renewed interest in re-interpreting the historical period that has been popularly considered as terminated in triumph.
    [Show full text]
  • The Bible and Empire in the Divided Korean Peninsula in Search for a Theological Imagination for Just Peace
    University of Dublin Trinity College The Bible and Empire in the Divided Korean Peninsula In Search for a Theological Imagination for Just Peace A Dissertation Submitted For the Degree of DOCTOR of PHILOSOPHY By Youngseop Lim Irish School of Ecumenics February 2021 Declaration I declare that this thesis has not been submitted as an exercise for a degree at this or any other university and it is entirely my own work. I agree to deposit this thesis in the University’s open access institutional repository or allow the Library to do so on my behalf, subject to Irish Copyright Legislation and Trinity College Library conditions of use and acknowledgement. Signed: _____________________________________ Date: _______________________________________ iii Summary The major objective of this thesis is to examine the relationship between biblical interpretation and imperialism in the context of the Korean conflict. This study takes its starting point in the questions of what caused the Korean conflict, and what role the Bible has played in the divided Korean church and society. In order to find answers to these questions, this study is carried out in several steps. The first step is to explore just peace and imperial peace in the Bible as a conceptual framework. The second step seeks to reconstruct the history of Korean Christianity, the relationship between church and state, and the impact of American church and politics from postcolonial perspective. As the third step, this study focuses on the homiletical discourses of Korean megachurches in terms of their relation to the dominant ideologies, such as anticommunism, national security, pro-Americanism, and economic prosperity.
    [Show full text]
  • Looking Back While Moving Forward: the Evolution of Truth Commissions in Korea
    Looking Back While Moving Forward: The Evolution of Truth Commissions in Korea Andrew Wolman* I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................... 27 II. HISTORICAL ANTECEDENTS ................................................................ 30 A. 1945-1987: Authoritarianism and Failed Commissions ............. 33 B. 1987-2003: Democratic Transition and the First Truth Commissions .............................................................................. 35 C. 2003-2008: Roh Moo Hyun and a Full Embrace of Truth Commissions .............................................................................. 38 1. Commissions Dealing with the Japanese Colonial Era and Earlier .................................................................................. 39 2. Commissions dealing with the Authoritarian Era ............... 41 III. TRUTH AND RECONCILIATION COMMISSION OF KOREA ...................... 43 A. Mandate ...................................................................................... 44 B. Composition ............................................................................... 45 C. Functions and Powers ................................................................. 46 D. Findings ...................................................................................... 47 E. Recommendations ...................................................................... 48 IV. TRUTH COMMISSIONS UNDER LEE MYUNG BAK (2008-2011) ............ 49 V. CHARACTERISTICS OF KOREAN TRUTH COMMISSIONS
    [Show full text]
  • An Analysis of Selected Fiction, Non-Fiction, And
    "PLUNGED BACK WITH REDOUBLED FORCE": AN ANALYSIS OF SELECTED FICTION, NON-FICTION, AND POETRY OF THE KOREAN WAR A Thesis Presented to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Akron In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts John Tierney May, 2014 "PLUNGED BACK WITH REDOUBLED FORCE": AN ANALYSIS OF SELECTED FICTION, NON-FICTION, AND POETRY OF THE KOREAN WAR John Tierney Thesis Approved: Accepted: _______________________________________ _____________________________________ Faculty Advisor Dean of the College Dr. Mary Biddinger Dr. Chand Midha _______________________________________ _____________________________________ Faculty Reader Dean of the Graduate School Dr. Patrick Chura Dr. George R. Newkome _______________________________________ _____________________________________ Department Coordinator Date Dr. Joseph F. Ceccio _______________________________________ Department Chair Dr. William Thelin ii DEDICATION To Jonas and his grand empathy iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thanks to Ji Young for her support and patience these three years. Veronica and Patrick for the diversions. Thanks also to Dr. Mary Biddinger for her advice and encouragement with the writing process, to Dr. Patrick Chura for his time and vote of confidence, to Dr. Joseph Ceccio for his time and advice, and to Dr. Hillary Nunn for her seminar in literary criticism and for her help with editing. A million thanks to Craig Blais, Colleen Tierney, and everyone else who listened to my ideas at the conception of this project. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Page CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………………………..1 II. IMPERIAL AMERICA AND THE PREDOMINANCE IN MILITARY POWER IN THE KOREAN WAR……………………………………………………………………..........8 Background…………………………………………………………………………........10 Military Readiness…………………………………………………………………….15 Demeanor and Performance………………..…………………………….............18 Brutal Methods…...……………………………………………………………………..20 III. CHAOS IN THE FATHERLAND……………………………………………………………….30 Background.………………………………………………………………………………31 IV.
    [Show full text]
  • Tracing the Korean Orphan and Adoptee Through South Korean and American National Narratives
    Orphan, Adoptee, Nation: Tracing the Korean Orphan and Adoptee through South Korean and American National Narratives By Kira Ann Donnell A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnic Studies in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Elaine H. Kim, Chair Professor Catherine Ceniza Choy Professor Jinsoo An Professor Grace J. Yoo Fall 2019 Abstract Orphan, Adoptee, Nation: Tracing the Korean Orphan and Adoptee through South Korean and American National Narratives by Kira Ann Donnell Doctor of Philosophy in Ethnic Studies University of California, Berkeley Professor Elaine H. Kim, Chair The transnational adoption industrial complex established between South Korea and the United States following the Korean War initiated what is sometimes called the “Quiet Migration.” Since then, over 200,000 Korean children have been sent abroad, and the transnational, transracial adoption industry has operations set up in dozens of developing countries worldwide which takes thousands of children annually from their natal homes and places them in adoptive families in Western countries. For the past seventy years, the figures of the Korean orphan and adoptee have held significant meaning in the imaginations of by South Korean and American citizens. The sentimental figure of the Korean orphan became the conduit through which both South Koreans and Americans defined their experiences in the Korean War. The transnational Korean adoptee has become an icon of the United States’ commitment to humanitarianism and diversity and South Korea’s modern branding as a sophisticated and internationally-networked nation. This dissertation explores how United States and South Korean culture and society have used the figures of the Korean orphan and Korean adoptee to construct national identities that reflect its citizens as virtuous, cosmopolitan, and unified.
    [Show full text]
  • Descriptive Metadata Framework and Taxonomy to Organize Topic- Specific Collections: Text-Mining for No Gun Ri Collections
    Descriptive Metadata Framework and Taxonomy to Organize Topic- Specific Collections: Text-mining for No Gun Ri Collections Donghee Sinn (University at Albany) SAA Research Forum, Aug. 23 2011 Topic-Specific Collections • Various types of resources that are pertinent to a topic • A typical descriptive metadata standard (MARC, Dublin Core) may not be useful. • Topical approach to collect information ▫ Library pathfinders ▫ Digital libraries ▫ Individual web sites No Gun Ri • No Gun Ri Massacre during the Korea War (July 1950) ▫ Mass killing of South Korean refugees under a railroad overpass at No Gun Ri ▫ By 7th Regiment soldiers in 1st Cavalry Division ▫ Harsh refugee policies appeared in military documents from neighbor army units (25th Infantry, etc) ▫ First reported in the US by AP in 1999 ▫ Controversies over testimonies of veterans (Edward Daily) and US No Gun Ri Review NGR Collection • Materials from survivors’ community, archival documents, journalistic publications, academic research studies, legal documents, government reports, media broadcasting, etc. • A variety of types in format and nature ▫ Hard to organize effectively, using an existing descriptive standard Text-Mining • Finding representative patterns from unstructured textual data • Analyzing the contents in the collection to find how the contents represent the collection itself • Text analysis tool: TAPoR (Text Analysis Portal for Research) ▫ Keywords Finder top 20 words; top 10 word pairs; and top 10 word triplets recommended keywords/phrases Text-Analysis for NGR Collection
    [Show full text]
  • Military History Anniversaries 0716 Thru 073116
    Military History Anniversaries 16 thru 31 July Events in History over the next 15 day period that had U.S. military involvement or impacted in some way on U.S military operations or American interests Jul 16 1779 – American Revolution: Light infantry of the Continental Army seize a fortified British Army position in a midnight bayonet attack at the Battle of Stony Point. Casualties and losses: US 98 – Great Britain 624. Jul 16 1861 – Civil War: At the order of President Abraham Lincoln, Union troops begin a 25 mile march into Virginia for what will become The First Battle of Bull Run, the first major land battle of the war. Jul 16 1927 – Nicaragua: Augusto César Sandino leads a raid on U.S. Marines and Nicaraguan Guardia Nacional that had been sent to apprehend him in the village of Ocotal, but is repulsed by one of the first dive–bombing attacks in history. Jul 16 1945 – Manhattan Project: The Atomic Age begins when the United States successfully detonates a plutonium–based test nuclear weapon at the Trinity site near Alamogordo, New Mexico Jul 16 1945 – WW2: The Heavy Cruiser USS Indianapolis (CA–35) leaves San Francisco with parts for the atomic bomb "Little Boy" bound for Tinian Island. This would be the last time the Indianapolis would be seen by the Mainland as she would be torpedoed by the Japanese Submarine I– 58 on July 30 and sink with 880 out of 1,196 crewmen. Jul 16 1945 – WW2: the leaders of the three Allied nations, Winston Churchill, Harry S.
    [Show full text]
  • Mayors for Peace News Flash (November 2014) No.59
    Mayors for Peace News Flash (November 2014) No.59 Dear member cities and supporters of Mayors for Peace, Thank you for your ongoing support. Below is recent news related to our activities. If your city has any news it wishes to share with others, please feel free to contact us! *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*. Mayors for Peace member cities as of November 1, 2014 6,374 cities in 160 countries/regions with 52 new members *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*. <<Table of Contents >> ************** - Mayors for Peace awarded the 7th No Gun Ri Peace Prize/Human Rights Prize - Protest against new type of nuclear tests conducted by the US - The 4th Japanese Member Cities Meeting - DVD Rental for Screenings in Mayors for Peace Member Cities launched - Article contributed by Mayor Thore Vestby of Frogn, Norway, Vice President of Mayors for Peace, to ‘Cities Today’ -<<New Series>> “Peace News from Hiroshima” - Contributed by the Hiroshima Peace Media Center - Member City Activities (Manchester [UK], and Des Moines [USA]) - Mayors for Peace A-bomb Poster Exhibition - A plea to support the petition drive for a nuclear weapons convention - Financial contributions from member cities to the 2020 Vision Campaign - Update for October 2014 - Visitors to the President of Mayors for Peace last month - Mayors for Peace member cities - 6,374 cities in 160 countries/regions ************** *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*. Please also check our website and Facebook page: URL: http://www.mayorsforpeace.org/english/index.html
    [Show full text]