DOCSLIB.ORG

Rage Againts the Machine: How Indymedia's Radical Project Is Working to Create the New Public Sphere

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rage Againts the Machine: How Indymedia's Radical Project Is Working to Create the New Public Sphere Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2009 Rage Against the Machine: How Indymedia's Radical Project Is Working to Create the New Public Sphere Richard E. Templin Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF COMMUNICATION RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE: HOW INDYMEDIA’S RADICAL PROJECT IS WORKING TO CREATE THE NEW PUBLIC SPHERE By RICHARD E. TEMPLIN, III A Dissertation submitted to the Department of Communication in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Spring Semester, 2009 2009 Richard E. Templin, III The members of the Committee approve the Dissertation of Richard E. Templin III Defended on December 12, 2008. ______________________________ Andrew Opel Professor Directing Dissertation ______________________________ Doug Schrock Outside Committee Member __________________________________ Stephen C. McDowell Committee Member ______________________________ Donna Marie Nudd Committee Member Approved: _________________________________________________ Stephen C. McDowell, Chair, Department of Communication _________________________________________________ John Mayo, Dean, College of Communication The Graduate School has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii IN MEMORIUM Mary P. Priest – Beloved Mother – 1938-2009 O.D. Priest Jr. – Beloved Father – 1923-2007 This dissertation is dedicated to my parents, my wife Grace Frances my daughter Aster Mary and all of my cherished friends. This project would not been possible without the guidance, patience and inspiration of my teachers, mentors and friends Drs. Andy Opel, Donna Nudd, Steve McDowell, Marilyn Young, Harry Dahms, Gary Heald and James Young. A very special thank you to my fellow IMCistas, both those who participated in this project and those who have given so much to create and nurture Indymedia around the world. Thanks to all radical media makers everywhere; keep up the fight—another world is possible. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Tables ................................................................................................................................ vii Abstract........................................................................................................................................ viii INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................................1 1. FROM THE JUNGLES OF CHIAPAS TO THE STREETS OF SEATTLE: THE RISE OF THE INDEPENDENT MEDIA CENTER ......................................................................................8 What is the IMC? A Primer .................................................................................................8 History of the Independent Media Center..........................................................................12 The Electronic Fabric of Struggle begins in Chiapas ............................................13 The Battle for Seattle .............................................................................................18 Building the Network.............................................................................................25 2. THE BIRTH OF THE OLIGOPOLY........................................................................................29 The Media Oligopoly.........................................................................................................30 The Telecommunications Act of 1996...................................................................32 Merger Mania.........................................................................................................35 Deregulation Continues .........................................................................................43 The Movement for Media Reform.....................................................................................51 Organizations for Media Reform...........................................................................52 Conclusions........................................................................................................................57 3. RADICAL ALTERNATIVE MEDIA.......................................................................................60 The Radical Media of John D. H. Downing ......................................................................65 Mass, Popular and Oppositional Culture ...............................................................66 Hegemony and Counter-Hegemony ......................................................................69 Communities and Social Movements ....................................................................74 Radical Media Organization ..................................................................................81 Repressive Radical Media?....................................................................................84 Conclusions............................................................................................................87 The Alternative Media of Chris Atton...............................................................................90 New Modes of Production .....................................................................................95 Transforming the Roles..........................................................................................97 New Social Movements .......................................................................................100 Alternative Media and New Technologies ..........................................................101 Conclusions..........................................................................................................105 iv 4. THE RADICAL NATURE OF INDYMEDIA: POLICIES AND PRACTICES OF THE GLOBAL NETWORK ................................................................................................................108 General Process and Communication ..............................................................................110 Webs & Wikis......................................................................................................110 Global Communication........................................................................................116 10 Principles of Unity and Membership Criteria.............................................................120 The 10 Principles .................................................................................................120 Criteria for New IMCs.........................................................................................128 5. COFFEE SHOPS TO CYBERSPACE: THE INTERNET AND PUBLIC SPHERE.............131 The Power of the Internet?...............................................................................................133 Autonomist Marxism ...........................................................................................134 Turning the Tables ...............................................................................................137 Radical Media = Radical Public?.....................................................................................142 The Habermasian Public Sphere......................................................................................142 Critiques...........................................................................................................................158 From Strategic Communication to Communicative Action ............................................161 Critical Methodology...........................................................................................161 Universal Pragmatics ...........................................................................................164 Theory of Communicative Action .......................................................................167 Conclusions..........................................................................................................172 6. RESEARCHING THE IMC ....................................................................................................176 Don’t Trust Anyone Over 30 ...........................................................................................179 Just Because I’m Paranoid Doesn’t Mean They’re Not Out to Get Me ..........................190 Police Violence ....................................................................................................190 Legal Challenges..................................................................................................194 Compromises on the Horizon?.........................................................................................195 7. INDYMEDIA IN NORTH AMERICA...................................................................................200 Why a Census ..................................................................................................................200 The Census.......................................................................................................................203 Results..............................................................................................................................209 Conclusions......................................................................................................................226 8. THE TALLAHASSEE-REDHILLS INDEPENDENT MEDIA CENTER ............................233 The Rise and Fall of the Tallahassee-RedHills IMC
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Movements of Diverse Inquiries As Critical Teaching Practices Among Charros, Tlacuaches and Mapaches Stephen T
    University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Open Access Dissertations 9-2012 Movements of Diverse Inquiries as Critical Teaching Practices Among Charros, Tlacuaches and Mapaches Stephen T. Sadlier University of Massachusetts Amherst, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/open_access_dissertations Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Sadlier, Stephen T., "Movements of Diverse Inquiries as Critical Teaching Practices Among Charros, Tlacuaches and Mapaches" (2012). Open Access Dissertations. 664. https://scholarworks.umass.edu/open_access_dissertations/664 This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Open Access Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected]. MOVEMENTS OF DIVERSE INQUIRIES AS CRITICAL TEACHING PRACTICES AMONG CHARROS, TLACUACHES AND MAPACHES A Dissertation Presented by STEPHEN T. SADLIER Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION September 2012 School of Education Language, Literacy, and Culture © Copyright by Stephen T. Sadlier 2012 All Rights Reserved MOVEMENTS OF DIVERSE INQUIRIES AS CRITICAL TEACHING PRACTICES AMONG CHARROS,1 TLACUACHES2 AND MAPACHES3 A Dissertation Presented By STEPHEN T. SADLIER Approved as to style and content
    [Show full text]
  • Assessing the Radical Democracy of Indymedia: Discursive, Technical, and Institutional Constructions
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Departmental Papers (ASC) Annenberg School for Communication 8-22-2006 Assessing the Radical Democracy of Indymedia: Discursive, Technical, and Institutional Constructions Victor Pickard University of Pennsylvania, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/asc_papers Part of the Communication Commons Recommended Citation Pickard, V. (2006). Assessing the Radical Democracy of Indymedia: Discursive, Technical, and Institutional Constructions. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 23 (1), 19-38. https://doi.org/10.1080/ 07393180600570691 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/asc_papers/445 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Assessing the Radical Democracy of Indymedia: Discursive, Technical, and Institutional Constructions Abstract This study examines the radical democratic principles manifest in Indymedia’s discursive, technical, and institutional practices. By focusing on a case study of the Seattle Independent Media Center and contextualizing it within theories and critiques of radical democracy, this article fleshes out strengths, weaknesses, and recurring tensions endemic to Indymedia’s internet-based activism. These findings have important implications for alternative media making and radical politics in general. Keywords alternative media, cyberactivism, democratic theory, independent media centers, indymedia, networks, radical democracy, social movements Disciplines Communication
    [Show full text]
  • 200312.Cover
    UPCOMING EVENTS A GOOD TIME FOR A GOOD CAUSE The Public i,a project of the Urbana-Cham- Dance Party with the Noisy Gators paign Independent Media Center, is an (cajun/zydeco dance band with Tom Turino) independent, collectively-run, community- With winter pressing in there’s no better time for a Dance Party with great food and oriented publication that provides a forum friends. On Saturday, December 13th AWARE will host the Noisy Gators (one of C-U’s for topics underreported and voices under- best local dance bands). There will be lots of space to dance, food, drinks, and friends. And represented in the dominant media. All best of all, the proceeds from the Benefit will all be donated to help those who’ve been hurt contributors to the paper are volunteers. by war - both here at home and in Iraq. Hope to see you there! Everyone is welcome and encouraged to sub- Where: The Offices of On the Job Consulting (OJC), 115 West Main, 2F in downtown mit articles or story ideas to the editorial col- Urbana (across from Cinema Gallery) lective. We prefer, but do not necessarily When: Saturday, December 13th, 8-11pm restrict ourselves to, articles on issues of local Sliding Scale donation: $5 - $20+ Dec-Jan 2003-4 • V3 #10 impact written by authors with local ties. All Proceeds benefit Oxfam Iraq (humanitarian aid to Iraqis) and the Red Cross Armed Forces FREE! EDITORS/FACILITATORS: Emergency Services Fund (help for veterans and military families). Xian Barrett Sponsored by AWARE (Anti-War Anti-Racism Effort) Lisa Chason Darrin Drda EDUCATION OR INCARCERATION? ZINE SLAM WITH IMPROV MUSIC Jeremy Engels SCHOOLS AND PRISONS IN A Linda Evans PUNISHING DEMOCRACY Belden Fields Saturday, December 13 6:30 PM Meghan Krausch An Interdisciplinary Conference hosted by at the IMC, 218 W.
    [Show full text]
  • Regional Development in Russia, an Issue Which Is Widely Discussed Due to the Size and Diversity of the World’S Largest Country
    Summer 2015 Regional development With AEB updates on: regional HR trends, leasing market, corporate banking... and more AEB SPONSORS 2015 Allianz IC OJSC MERCK LLC Alstom Messe Frankfurt Rus Atos MetLife Bank Credit Suisse (Moscow) METRO GROUP BP Michelin BSH Group MOL Plc Cargill Enterprises Inc. Novartis Group Clifford Chance OBI Russia Continental Tires RUS LLC Oriflame Crocus International Procter & Gamble Deloitte PwC DuPont Science & Technologies Raiffeisenbank AO E.ON Russia ROCA Enel Russia OJSC Shell Exploration & Production Services (RF) B.V. ENGIE Statoil ASA Eni S.p.A. Telenor Russia AS EY TMF Group HeidelbergCement Total E&P Russie ING Commercial Banking Volkswagen Group Rus OOO John Deere Agricultural Holdings Inc. Volvo Cars LLC KPMG YIT Rakennus Representative Office LEROY MERLIN Russia YOKOHAMA RUSSIA LLC Mercedes-Benz Russia | Introduction AEB Business Quarterly | Summer 2015 Dear reader, I am glad to welcome you to the 2nd issue of the AEB Business Quarterly in 2015. It is devoted to regional development in Russia, an issue which is widely discussed due to the size and diversity of the world’s largest country. Starting business in Russia is not always as easy as in other countries, but success is possible. Many factors influence this, but one of the key issues is to choose the right place for development. However, the current crisis enforces companies to optimise their structures. Despite this, many persevere and see opportunities especially in the regions. Cost efficiency, easy management, logistics, market opportunities are all, of course, very important for any development. But the direction of the business also strongly depends on the region: an area may be suitable for one kind of entrepreneur- ship but not necessarily for another.
    [Show full text]
  • The C-Suite Guide to Video for Business
    The C-Suite Guide to Video for Business Video eBook Written by Brian Overson Phone: 952-829-9091 [email protected] storytellermn.com e Brian Overson is the Marketing Associate at StoryTeller Media + Communications in Bloomington, Minnesota. StoryTeller is an inbound marketing and video production agency, earning three Midwest Regional Emmy awards for video storytelling. Other titles by Brian Overson: Business Blogging: Te C-Suite Guide to Producing Written Content, Part I Copyright © 2015, Brian Overson, StoryTeller Media + Communications Table of Contents Introduction............................................................................4 Where Do I Start?........................................................................7 Content.................................................................................13 Production.........................................................................19 SEO.......................................................................................26 How Do I Use It?........................................................................29 Conclusion...........................................................................33 Resources............................................................................35 CHAPTER 1 Introduction “When it’s done well, video can take you somewhere. It can make you feel like you were at that place, or with that person.” – Gregg Litman Brand Content Manager StoryTeller Media + Communications Emmy Award-winning Video Producer INTRODUCTION Welcome
    [Show full text]
  • Chris Riddell Hans Christian Andersen Awards 2016 UK Illustrator Nomination PHOTO : JO RIDDELL PHOTO
    Chris Riddell Hans Christian Andersen Awards 2016 UK Illustrator Nomination PHOTO : JO RIDDELL PHOTO 1 Chris Riddell Biography Chris Riddell A Critical Appreciation Chris Riddell was born in South Africa. His father Richard Platt. This book and the earlier Castle Diary Chris Riddell is highly regarded in the UK and well as young readers’ chapter books, he addresses was an Anglican clergyman and his parents were involved him in detailed historical research, which internationally as a visual commentator and an audience that is often neglected: readers active in the anti-apartheid movement. His family he deployed in typically boisterous, characterful narrator; an artist and illustrator in command of who are still young enough to enjoy illustrations returned to Britain when Chris was a year old and and humorous style. Perhaps his most demanding a range of forms and genres varying from political supporting a narrative, but also old enough to he spent his childhood moving from parish to illustration project to date followed in 2004 with satire and cartoon to picture books, graphic novels engage with more sophisticated subject matter. parish. His interest in drawing began then and was his illustrations to Martin Jenkins’ adaptation of and cross-over forms. His broad understanding of Chris Riddell’s biggest virtue, however, is not that encouraged at secondary school. He remembers, Gulliver’s Travels, a classic whose combination visual communication, coupled with his classical he satisfies the expectations of theoretical analysis, “I had a wonderfully idiosyncratic art teacher, Jack of satire and fantasy played to his strengths as drawing ability and extended frame of reference, but that he can do so whilst communicating with Johnson, a painter who’d also been a newspaper an illustrator and earned him the second Kate has earned him the respect of broad and diverse and convincingly addressing his audience.
    [Show full text]
  • Inkwell Management London 2017
    InkWell Management London 2017 TABLE OF CONTENTS Fiction Peter Blauner .................................................. Proving Ground ........................................................................ 9 Mary Clyde ..................................................... No Morning Sun ....................................................................... 10 Rene Denfeld .................................................. The Child Finder ...................................................................... 11 Owen Egerton ................................................ Hollow ....................................................................................... 12 Katherine Heiny ............................................. Standard Deviation ................................................................... 13 Elin Hilderbrand ............................................ The Identicals ............................................................................ 14 Lia Hills ........................................................... The Crying Place ....................................................................... 15 Eloisa James .................................................... Wilde in Love............................................................................. 16 Wendy James .................................................. The Golden Child ....................................................................... 17 Jarett Kobek .................................................... The Future Won’t Be Long .......................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Sustaining Contributors
    The Public i, a project of the Urbana-Cham- paign Independent Media Center, is an independent, collectively-run, community- oriented publication that provides a forum for topics underreported and voices under- represented in the dominant media. All contributors to the paper are volunteers. Everyone is welcome and encouraged to submit articles or story ideas to the editorial May 2008 collective. We prefer, but do not necessarily restrict ourselves to, articles on issues of local V8, #5 impact written by authors with local ties. The opinions are those of the authors and do not reflect the views of the IMC as a whole. EDITORS/FACILITATORS: Antonia Darder Brian Dolinar davep Shara Esbenshade Belden Fields Bob Illyes Paul Mueth Marcia Zumbahlen THE PUBLIC I Urbana-Champaign IMC 202 South Broadway Urbana, IL, 61801 217-344-8820 www.ucimc.org SUSTAINING CONTRIBUTORS Get Involved with the Public i The Public i wishes to express its deep appreciation to the following sustaining contrib- You don’t need a degree in journalism utors for their financial and material support: to be a citizen journalist. We are all SocialistForum: An Open Discussion and Jerusalem Cafe experts in something, and we have the Action Group, Meets 3rd Saturdays of the 601 S. Wright St, Champaign; 398-9022 ability to share our information and month, 3-5 pm, at IMC, Broadway & Elm. (U) The AFL-CIO of Champaign County knowledge with others. The Public i is World Harvest International always looking for writers and story That’s Rentertainment and Gourmet Foods ideas. We invite you to submit ideas or 516 E.
    [Show full text]
  • Brad Will Presente! by MARK READ Enough; He Was Charming As Hell, After All, and Funny, and Police
    ART Tiffany Holmes BOOKS John Duvernoy, Elizabeth Treadwell FEATURES Fulton Fish Market’s Last Days POETRY Kish Song Bear, Shanxing Wang BOOG CITY POLITICS Collins and Durand on Brad Will A COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER FROM A GROUP OF ARTISTS AND WRITERS BASED IN AND AROUND NEW YORK CITY’S EAST VILLAGE ISSUE 38 FREE Brad Will Presente! BY MARK READ enough; he was charming as hell, after all, and funny, and police. They were trashing the Zocalo. They had “no sense of hard not to like. But they were a bit, I don’t know, startled by aesthetics.” They “cared nothing for the artistic heritage of the Y FRIEND BRAD WILL, AN his more hobo-ish qualities, his patches and his scraggly beard, his funkily repaired city of Oaxaca,” he said. They just pumped out this “tired rhetoric from the 1970s,” he INDEPENDENT JOURNALIST glasses, and his equally funky smell. added. AND ACTIVIST, HAS BEEN There was more than “Yes, the same old M one casual, comical, rhetoric,” I thought to MURDERED IN OAXACA, MEXICO BY patronizing remark myself. “Yes, lacking subtlety.” But I couldn’t GOVERNMENT-BACKED PARAMILITARIES. about one of these qualities during help thinking that not There was a vigil held immediately for him at the Mexican much has changed consulate that Saturday night and a protest about the ongoing his stay with me. Meanwhile, Brad since the ’70s. I mean, violence in Oaxaca on the following Monday. it’s been the same That Saturday night one of my oldest friends, Buck, was either didn’t notice that Buck and Beth fight more or less, having his birthday party.
    [Show full text]
  • Hello, Dear Enemy! Picture Books for Peace and Tolerance: an International Selection
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 460 339 CS 013 281 AUTHOR Scharioth, Barbara, Ed.; Weber, Jochen, Ed. TITLE Hello, Dear Enemy! Picture Books for Peace and Tolerance: An International Selection. INSTITUTION International Youth Library, Munich (Germany). PUB DATE 1998-03-00 NOTE 36p.; In cooperation with International Board on Books for Young People (IBBY). Supported by the German Federal Ministry for Family, Senior Citizens, Women, and Youth, the Bavarian Ministry of Education, Culture, Science, and Arts, the City of Munich, and'the Association of the Friends of the International Youth Library. PUB TYPE Reference Materials Bibliographies (131) EDRS PRICE MF01/PCO2 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Annotated Bibliographies; *Childrens Literature; Elementary Education; Foreign Countries; Global Approach; *Peace; *Picture Books; *Reading Material Selection; Stranger Reactions; Violence; *War; World Problems IDENTIFIERS Peace Education; *Tolerance ABSTRACT This catalog presents descriptions of over 41 children's picture books from 19 countries that formed an exhibition sent worldwide to promote and help maintain peace. The majority of the books do not deal directly with the horrors of war but rather deal with its preconditions: intolerance, xenophobia, prejudice against being different, misuse of power, oppression, and violence against people and property. Titles are arranged alphabetically by illustrator and the books are listed under their country of origin. (Contains author and illustrator name and subject indexes.) (RS) Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made from the original document. !he 11c9 dear enemy! Picture Books for Peace nd 'Mem c PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE AND DISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL HAS A erratkm al Selection BEEN GRANTED BY U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCAIION Office o4 Educational Research and Improvement EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) (1104document has been reproduced as TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES received from the person or organization INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC) originating it.
    [Show full text]
  • Landon Cat.PM
    VIDEO UNIVERSITY HOW TO START OR EXPAND A SUCCESSFUL HOME-BASED BUSINESS PRODUCING CORPORATE VIDEOS ■#77 PROFESSIONAL VIDEO PRODUCER - A Comprehensive Course If you love making videos as much as I do, you know it’s an expensive hobby. That’s why I produce videos for others. So they can help pay for my equipment. For the last 12 years I’ve been producing corporate videos, having been in the film and video business for over 20 years. And over those years I have learned a lot! NEW VIDEO What they don’t teach you in college College courses costing hundreds of dollars are great for learning the theory of visual communication, but they don’t teach you how to build a profitable business and support BUSINESSES ARE yourself. That’s why I wrote Professional Video Producer to show you the real world of video business from people who actually run successful production companies. In this HOTTER unique home study course you’ll discover the techniques and strategies used by large and small video production companies who’ve learned the most important lesson of all - how THAN EVER… to make a profit in this $8 BILLION business. But before we explore that, let me tell you the FOUR THINGS I LOVE about this work: ARE YOU 1. Variety Since I started producing corporate videos, I've been paid to learn about and produce GETTING YOUR videos on subjects ranging from dock building, lipstick manufacturing, electronic surveying, furniture sales training, computer programs, architecture, nursing, interstate highway SHARE? building, sexual harassment, waterfront reconstruction, book printing, food preparation and many more.
    [Show full text]
  • Representation and Materiality in Coetzee, Ellis, Cooper
    VIOLENCE, IMMEDIATELY: REPRESENTATION AND MATERIALITY IN COETZEE, ELLIS, COOPER, BECKETT, GODARD, AND NOÉ BY AMY NEDA VEGARI A.B., HARVARD UNIVERSITY, 2002 A.M., BROWN UNIVERSITY, 2005 A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN THE DEPARTMENT OF COMPARATIVE LITERATURE AT BROWN UNIVERSITY PROVIDENCE, RHODE ISLAND MAY, 2008 © Copyright 2008 by Amy Neda Vegari “Do your politics fit between the headlines? Are they written in newsprint? Are they distant? Mine are crossing an empty parking lot; They are a woman walking home at night, alone— They are six strings that sing and wood that hums against my hipbone.” -Ani DiFranco This dissertation by Amy Neda Vegari is accepted in its present form by the Department of Comparative Literature as satisfying the dissertation requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Date _________________ ___________________________________ Timothy Bewes, Director Date _________________ ___________________________________ Rey Chow, Director Recommended to the Graduate Council Date _________________ ___________________________________ Kevin McLaughlin, Reader Approved by the Graduate Council Date _________________ ___________________________________ Sheila Bonde, Dean of the Graduate School iv CURRICULUM VITAE Amy Neda Vegari was born on May 15, 1981 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. After graduating from The Episcopal Academy in Merion, Pennsylvania in 1998, she attended Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts. She graduated magna cum laude
    [Show full text]