Naturally Occurring Arsenic in the Miocene Hawthorn Group, Southwestern Florida: Potential Implication for Phosphate Mining
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Applied Geochemistry Applied Geochemistry 22 (2007) 953–973 www.elsevier.com/locate/apgeochem Naturally occurring arsenic in the Miocene Hawthorn Group, southwestern Florida: Potential implication for phosphate mining Olesya Lazareva, Thomas Pichler * Department of Geology, University of South Florida, Tampa, FL, USA Received 20 February 2006; accepted 11 December 2006 Editorial handling by R. Fuge Available online 20 February 2007 Abstract To understand the mineralogical association, concentration, and distribution of arsenic (As) in the Hawthorn Group, the chemical and mineralogical composition of 362 samples that were collected from 16 cores in southwestern Florida were examined in detail. In the study area, the Hawthorn Group consisted primarily of a basal carbonate unit (the Arcadia For- mation) and an upper siliciclastic unit (The Peace River Formation). The Peace River Formation contains appreciable amounts of phosphate and is currently being exploited for phosphate ore. Samples were taken from cores of each forma- tion at intervals of 7.5 m. In addition, to the interval samples, sections likely to have high As concentrations, such as zones with pyrite crystals, hydrous ferric oxides, green clays, and organic material, were collected and analyzed. Bulk As concen- trations were determined by hydride generation-atomic fluorescence spectrometry (HG-AFS) after digestion with aqua regia (3:1 HCl and HNO3). The elements Fe, Al, Si, Mg, Ca, S, and P were measured on the same solutions by inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES). The identification of discrete minerals was aided by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and chemical compositions within the sample matrix and in individual minerals were obtained by electron-probe microanalysis (EMPA). This detailed mineralogical and geochemical study demonstrated that: (1) As in the Hawthorn Group varied from for- mation to formation and was mostly concentrated in trace minerals, such as pyrite; (2) average As concentrations signif- icantly changed from 8.8 mg/kg (r = 8.6 mg/kg) in the Peace River Formation to 3.0 mg/kg (r = 3.7 mg/kg) in the Tampa Member of the Arcadia Formation. Arsenic concentrations for all Hawthorn samples varied from 0.1 to 69.0 mg/kg; (3) pyrite, with one exception, occurred as framboids and was unevenly distributed throughout the Hawthorn Group; (4) pyr- ite framboids were located inside a francolite (carbonate fluorapatite) matrix with As concentrations as high as 3730 mg/kg and as a trace mineral in the sediment matrix concentrations varying from <1 to 8260 mg/kg; (5) hydrous ferric oxides (HFO) contained As concentrations as high as 540 mg/kg; (6) francolite, organic material, and clays contained substan- tially less As than pyrite; (7) thus, the release of As from pyrite could pose a potential problem for the phosphate industry. Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. * Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 813 974 0321; fax: +1 813 974 2654. E-mail address: [email protected] (T. Pichler). 0883-2927/$ - see front matter Ó 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.apgeochem.2006.12.021 954 O. Lazareva, T. Pichler / Applied Geochemistry 22 (2007) 953–973 1. Introduction study. Because P and As are chemically closely related, they often co-occur in nature (Shields, Southwestern Florida hosts several large phos- 2002). In addition, the highly open crystal structure phate mines that exploit the Oligocene- to Miocene- of carbonate fluorapatite (francolite) shows a ten- aged Hawthorn Group sediments (Blakey, 1973). dency to accumulate such elements as As, Mo, Se, Currently, Florida supplies about one-quarter of Y, Zn and the Rare Earth Elements (REE) during the world’s and three-quarters of the United States diagenesis (Shields, 2002). This may pose problems domestic phosphate needs (Hodges et al., 2001). for phosphate mining, such as (1) high As values in Arsenic concentrations of up to 54.1 mg/kg were the phosphate-bearing rock has a negative effect on recently reported for samples from the Oligocene- ore processing (benefication) and the quality of the aged Suwannee Limestone in Florida (Price and final product; and (2) mine-induced changes in Pichler, 2006). The Suwannee Limestone directly ground water physico-chemical conditions may underlies the Hawthorn Group, which triggered this cause the release of As present in the subsurface, Fig. 1. Map of the research area including the Regional Observation Monitor Well Program (ROMP) locations, numbers, and names of the 16 cores that were sampled. Note: the sample labels correspond to drill ‘well number’ – ‘sample depth’. O. Lazareva, T. Pichler / Applied Geochemistry 22 (2007) 953–973 955 causing increased values in public and private supply between Tampa and Port Charlotte (Fig. 1). Here wells relative to existing drinking water standards. the hydrogeological framework can be subdivided The potential for this scenario was clearly demon- into 3 discrete units, the Floridan Aquifer System strated by release of high-As water from Coronet (FAS), the Intermediate Aquifer System (IAS) or Industries processing plant in Plant City, Hillsbor- Intermediate Confining Unit, and the Surficial ough County, where levels were in excess of Aquifer System (SAS) (Fig. 2)(Miller, 1986). 100 lg/L (Hammett, 2002). The new Maximum The Miocene Hawthorn Group is the strati- Contaminant Level (MCL) for As in drinking water, graphic unit that contains the Intermediate aquifer established by the U. S. Environmental Protection system. It is subdivided into a lower section compris- Agency (US EPA) in 2001 and which took effect on ing the undifferentiated Arcadia Formation, Tampa January 23, 2006, is 10 lg/L (Walsh, 2001). More- and Nocatee Members of the Arcadia Formation over, there have been several occurrences of swine (Fig. 2) and the upper section of the Peace River For- fatalities due to As contaminated phosphate feed mation (Scott, 1988, 1990). The Arcadia Formation supplements (El Bahri and Romdane, 1991). unconformably overlies the Oligocene Suwannee Limestone. Its maximum thickness within the study 1.1. Geology and hydrogeology of the study area area is approximately 183 m (600 ft) in the Okeecho- bee Basin (Scott, 1988). Throughout the research The research area is located in the Southwest area the undifferentiated Arcadia Formation is prin- Florida Water Management District (SWFWMD) cipally composed of variable amount of siliciclastics Fig. 2. Lithostratigraphic and hydrogeologic units of the study area (Modified from Miller, 1986). 956 O. Lazareva, T. Pichler / Applied Geochemistry 22 (2007) 953–973 such as quartz sands, greenish gray clays, chert and concentration (following chemical analyses), francolite within a carbonate matrix (Scott, 1990). approximately 60 samples were selected for further The lithology of the Tampa Member of the Arcadia study. Polished thin sections were made for those Formation varies from yellow-gray marine wacke- samples and they were examined using a polarizing stone to packestone containing variable amounts of microscope with reflected and transmitted light. dolostone, clay, quartz sand and minor occurrences To determine bulk chemical composition samples of francolite (Wingard et al., 1993; Scott, 1988). were powdered (homogenized) in an agate mortar. The Nocatee Member forms the base of the Arcadia To avoid cross-contamination, the mortar and pes- Formation (Fig. 2) in the much of the southern por- tle were cleaned with pure silica sand and deionised tion of SWFWMD. Scott (1988) reported that the water between samples. A dilute HNO3 solution was Nocatee Member contains the highest amount of used after powdering soft greenish clays. Approxi- siliciclastic material found within the entire Arcadia mately 0.5 ± 0.001 g of powdered sample was Formation. weighed into a digestion vessel and 10 mL of a 3:1 The Peace River Formation, currently being mixture of HCl and HNO3 was added. The diges- exploited for the phosphate ore, unconformably tion vessel was immediately capped with a reflux overlies the Arcadia Formation (Fig. 2) and, within cup to trap any arsine gas. The sample was heated the study area, reaches a maximum thickness of 46– to a temperature of 95 °C for 30 min. After diges- 61 m (150–200 ft) in the Okeechobee Basin (Scott, tion, the solution was cooled, diluted to 50 mL 1990). In the study area, the Peace River Formation (5:1) with DI water, centrifuged for 15 min to consists of greenish gray sandy clays, and carbon- remove non-soluble particles, and filtered. ates with variable amounts of francolite, sand and Calcium, Fe, Mg, Mn, S, P, Si and Al were gravel (Green et al., 1995). The carbonates are com- determined on a Perkin Elmer Optima 2000 DV prised of interbedded limestones, dolostones, and a inductively coupled plasma – optical emission spec- siliciclastic component dominates the Peace River trometer (ICP-OES). Bulk As concentrations were Formation (Scott, 1988). measured by hydride generation-atomic fluorescence spectrometry using a PSA 10.055 Millenium Excali- 2. Methods bur instrument (HG-AFS) at the Center for Water Analysis, University of South Florida. The accuracy A combination of petrographic and geochemical and precision of the measurements and acid digestion techniques was used to evaluate the abundance and was verified by analysis of the JGS JLs-1 reference mineralogical association of As in 362 samples from material and sample duplicates, which indicated a 16 Hawthorn Group cores in proximity to current precision of better than 5%. Reagent-acid blanks and future phosphate mining. The cores were origi- were tested and showed no detectable As. Back- nally collected as part of the Regional Observation ground signal drift was consistently less than 1%. Monitor Well Program (ROMP) by SWFWMD, Based on the bulk concentrations, samples with and stored at the Florida Geological Survey high As levels were selected for a more focused min- (FGS) in Tallahassee. Each core was sampled at eralogical analysis using a Hitachi S-3500N scan- an even spacing of approximately 7.5 m to ensure ning electron microscope (SEM) at the College of representation of the entire Hawthorn interval.