September 3, 2019

SENT VIA E-MAIL AND FIRST-CLASS U.S. MAIL

The Honorable Martha L. Walters Chief Justice, Oregon Supreme Court 1163 State Street Salem, OR 97301

Re: Chief Justice Order Prohibiting ICE Enforcement Activity in Oregon State Courthouses

Dear Chief Justice Walters:

As members of the Oregon State Bar, we are writing to voice our support for a court rule to stop Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) intrusions into Oregon state courthouses. Since 2017, ICE enforcement activity in Oregon courthouses has skyrocketed. The highly public nature of these courthouse arrests, along with concerns about racial profiling, has caused widespread fear in many communities. Victims refuse to seek protection from the courts, witnesses are afraid to appear, and courtrooms and court hallways are no longer safe and trusted spaces.

Communities, judges, and elected officials in Oregon have condemned ICE enforcement activity in Oregon courthouses, but it continues unabated. This practice offends Oregon’s sovereignty and the constitutional requirement of our courts to administer justice. It is also contrary to deeply rooted principles of Oregon law that protect individuals against civil arrests when going to, or returning from, court. See generally Wemme v. Hurlburt, 133 Or 460, 462, 289 P 372 (1930) (describing the common-law privilege against civil arrest). We understand that this common-law privilege authorizes a court rule, issued through a Chief Justice Order, prohibiting civil immigration arrests without a judicial warrant in or around Oregon courthouses. We also understand that a similar rule was recently issued by the courts in New York.

We join a growing chorus of voices asking you to help end ICE courthouse arrests in Oregon. It is in the public interest to ensure that all members of our communities, regardless of immigration status, may pursue their constitutional rights to defend themselves in court or a make a trip to the courthouse to seek protection without fear that such actions might result in permanent separation from their families and communities. ICE courthouse arrests harm the fair and equal administration of justice in Oregon, impede access to courthouses, and erode trust in the justice system.

The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

We call on you to use everything in your power to ensure that our courthouses remain safe and welcoming for all Oregon residents.

Sincerely,

A. Elizabeth Esfeld, OSB 192517 A.C. Figueroa-Estacio, OSB 181270 Aaron C. Courtney, OSB 935252 Aaron D. Reichenberger, OSB 144147 Abbey Hendricks, OSB 175108 Abby Wool Landon OSB 913501 Abigail Molina, OSB 176383 Adam Lowney, OSB 053124 Adam Rose, OSB 973850 Adam S. Gamboa, OSB 052609 Adele J. Ridenour, OSB 061556 Adrian Brown, OSB 050206 Adrienne H. Garcia, OSB 143227 Aja Hicks, OSB 074034 Alan J. Galloway, OSB 083290 Alejandra Torres, OSB 135056 Alena (Leni) Tupper, OSB 111869 Alex Gund, OSB 114067 Alexander Meggitt, OSB 174131 Alexander C. Spinks, OSB 134950 Alexandra Schneider, OSB 104974 Alice D Ellis Gaut, OSB 802183 Alicia LeDuc, OSB 173963 Alisha L. Kormondy, OSB 173916 Aliza B Kaplan, OSB 135523 Allen Eraut, OSB 992565 Alletta Brenner, OSB 142844 Amanda Caffall, OSB 122578 Amanda K Hoffman, OSB 040732 Amanda Alvarez Thibeault, OSB 132913 Amber Beyer, OSB 173045 Amelia Andersen, OSB 153070 Amie T Wexler, OSB 993951 Amy Adams, OSB 172892 Amy Bruning, OSB 175811 Amy E. Bilyeu, OSB 011651 Amy Edwards, OSB 012492 Amy J. Cross, OSB 050467 Amy Joseph Pederson, OSB 853958 Amy N Velazquez, OSB 044413

2 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Anaiah Palmer, OSB 134040 Andrew Altschul, OSB 980302 Andrew Freeman, OSB 153364 Andrew H. Solomon, OSB 014208 Andrew M. Rich, OSB 773189 Andrew MacKendrick, OSB 141022 Andrew Mason, OSB 111590 Andrew T. Ho, OSB 185047 Andria Seo, OSB 162984 Anit Jindal, OSB 171086 Ann Fisher, OSB 840459 Anna Ciesielski, OSB 062967 Anna Jones, OSB 192108 Anna M. Vujovic, OSB 181611 Annalise Oetken, OSB 151341 Annan Finch Stephens, OSB 163794 Anne C. Steiner, OSB 066891 Anne E. Koch, OSB 01319 Annie Borton, OSB 155631 Anthony Li, OSB 183966 Anuradha Sawkar, OSB 181564 Apolinar Montero-Sánchez, OSB 181872 Ari D. Halpern, OSB 045230 Ariel Stavitsky, OSB 175907 Aruna Masih, OSB 973241 Ashley Allison Marton, OSB 171584 Ashley J McDonald, OSB 153862 Ashley Marton, OSB 171584 Ashley R. White, OSB 116889 Aurelia Erickson, OSB 126170 Aurora Levinson, OSB 135705 B. B. Bouneff, OSB 590102 Barbara J. Diamond, OSB 850398 Barbara Long, OSB 122428 Bear Wilner-Nugent, OSB 044549 Benjamin Cox, OSB 080601 Benjamin Leedy, OSB 053084 Benjamin Walters, OSB 853546 Beth Creighton, OSB 972440 Bethany A. Bacci, OSB 015031 Bill Sharp, OSB 783745 Blair Townsend, OSB 112281 Bob L. O'Halloran, Jr., OSB 134437 Brad Stanford, OSB 854119 Bradley F. Tellam, OSB 841290

3 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Brady Mertz, OSB 970814 Brandon L. Thornburg, OSB 184618 Brenda Bradley, OSB 060453 Brenda L. Meltebeke, OSB 923988 Brenna Legaard, OSB 001658 Brett Allin, OSB 142719 Brett Applegate, OSB 132944 Bridget Donegan, OSB 103753 Brie Bridegum, OSB 122862 Brittany Berkey, OSB 035361 Brittney Plesser, OSB 154030 Brook Reinhard, OSB 094823 Bruce Cahn, OSB 93545 Bryson E. Davis, OSB 145082 C. Robert Steringer, OSB 983514 C.J. Graves, OSB 136087 Caitlin Mitchell, OSB 123964 Caitlin Upshaw, OSB 095317 Carleigh Anable, OSB 166017 Carlita Marchitto, OSB 180217 Carol L. Hepburn, OSB 032110 Caroline Moore, OSB 165888 Carolyn Rasche, OSB 125583 Carson Bowler, OSB 95183 Cassandra Snelling, OSB 174678 Catherine Highet, OSB 071306 Catherine Petrecca, OSB 064689 Cecilia Anguiano, OSB 185370 Chanpone Sinlapasai, OSB 071740 Charles F. Hinkle, OSB 710839 Charles Harms, OSB 772126 Charles R. Williamson, OSB 701612 Charles Vincent. OSB 941511 Charley Gee, OSB 111014 Charlie Harris OSB 72113 Cheryl Coon, OSB 87109 Chris Thomas, OSB 124759 Christa Obold Eshleman, OSB 043801 Christian Carl Christensen II, OSB 160567 Christina Stephenson, OSB 102287 Christine Moore, OSB 060270 Christine Shank, OSB 001024 Christopher Anders, OSB 051860 Christopher B. Rounds, OSB 86269 Christopher Erickson, OSB 012518

4 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Christopher T. Hill, OSB 972837 Cindy del Rosario, OSB 143052 Claudia Groberg, OSB 041835 Clifford S. Davidson, OSB 125378 Cody Hoesly, OSB 052860 Cole West Enabnit, OSB 143148 Colette M. Cameron, OSB 971694 Colin Folawn, OSB 112298 Colin O'Brien, OSB 174274 Colleen Scott, OSB 084780 Conner Bottomly, OSB 183135 Corin La Pointe-Aitchison, OSB 180841 Corrinna Spencer-Scheurich, OSB 130147 Cozette Tran-Caffee, OSB 125662 Craig J. Dorsay OSB 79031 Cruz Turcott, OSB 165531 Crystal Reeves, OSB 084496 Crystal S. Chase, OSB 093104 Cynthia Danforth, OSB 972820 Dallas DeLuca, OSB 072992 Dan Grinfas, OSB 943265 Dan Skerritt, OSB 681519 Dana Scheele, OSB 003781 Daniel Belknap Bartz, OSB 113226 Daniel Bennett, OSB 073304 Daniel K. Le Roux, OSB 085510 Daniel M. Galpern, OSB 061950 Daniela Holgate, OSB 183665 Danielle R. Miller, OSB 174155 Danielle Ramos, OSB 105087 Danny Kim, OSB 172196 Darcy M. Norville, OSB 900976 David Axelrod, OSB 75023 David Bean, OSB 012027 David D. Park, OSB 803358 David Ellis, OSB 831913 David Hori, OSB 191654 David J Malcolm, OSB 990789 David M. Merryman, OSB 181785 David Petersen, OSB 034220 David T. McDonald, OSB 862430 David W. Haskett, OSB 180754 Dawn Winalski, OSB 095514 Dean P. Land, OSB 973109 Debra Kolodny, Inactive

5 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Derek Swanson OSB 171442 Derily Bechthold, OSB 072337 Desmond J Kidney, OSB 131558 Devin N Robinson, OSB 064879 Dexter J. Pearce, OSB 164564 Diana Winther, OSB 151627 Diane Henkels, OSB 000523 Diane Sykes, OSB 980990 Dirk Wesley Schouten 115153 Dona Marie Hippert, OSB 040725 Doug Hageman, OSB 173654 Douglas Green, OSB 012675 Dylan Potter, OSB 104855 Dylan R Lawrence, OSB 011794 E. Walter Van Valkenburg, OSB 784150 Edna Gutierrez, OSB 181968 Edward Dean, OSB 165895 Edward J. Hill, OSB 941987 Edward J. Reeves, OSB 833040 Edward Kroll, OSB 074303 Edwin C. Perry, OSB 843227 Elaine N. Hamm, OSB 870087 Elden Rosenthal, OSB 722174 Elena Stross, OSB 171427 Elizabeth C. Woodard, OSB 075667 Elizabeth Elkington, OSB 173418 Elizabeth J. Inayoshi, OSB 133929 Elizabeth Jessop, OSB 123545 Elizabeth Levi, OSB 993217 Elizabeth N. Wakefield, OSB 974233 Elizabeth Rhode Motley, OSB 009762 Elizabeth Savage, OSB 141157 Elizabeth Welch, OSB 061373 Emilie N Junge, OSB 192764 Emily Brown-Sitnick, OSB 142876 Emily Bynum, OSB 163557 Emily Clark Cuellar, OSB 145960 Emily Johnson, OSB 183791 Emily Simon, OSB 79395 Emily Teplin Fox, OSB 121720 Emily V. Karr, OSB 901667 Eric E. Meyer, OSB 990811 Eric Kearney, OSB 063927 Erica B. Askin, OSB 175606 Erica P Valli, OSB 162225

6 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Erick Widman, OSB 151792 Erin L. McKee, OSB 114565 Erin M. Forbes, OSB 190993 Erin N. Biencourt, OSB 131669 Erin Severe, OSB 095127 Erin White, OSB 085109 Etta L Wilborn, OSB 873686 Eva Marcotrigiano, OSB 071463 Faith Marie Morse, OSB 104562 Frank C. Rote, III, OSB 893898 Frank Wall, OSB 733160 Gabriel Chase, OSB 142948 Gabriela Sanchez, OSB 03605 Garrett H. Stephenson, OSB 136356 Garrett R. Sharp, OSB 154728 Garrett Wright, OSB 163184 Gary M. Berne, OSB 774077 Gene Mechanic, OSB 770547 Geoffrey B. Tichenor, OSB 050958 Gerald Lunn, OSB 153768 Ginger Fitch, OSB 982260 Glenn Wallace Robles, OSB 013975 Gloria Hatrick, Inactive Gordon Gannicott, OSB 842307 Graham Fisher, OSB 063253 Grant Hartley, OSB 143353 Greg Corbin, OSB 000333 Greg Hartman, OSB 74128 Greg Scholl, OSB 954039 Gregory A. Chaimov, OSB 822180 Gregory W. Woods, OSB 142132 Gretchen Gunn Merrill, OSB 87300 Gretchen Mandekor, OSB 001246 Gretel M. Ness, OSB 981340 Guillermo Ramos, OSB 104870 Guy J. Thompson, OSB 171481 Gwyndolyn Styarfyr, OSB 164872 Haley Morrison, OSB 154972 Hansary Laforest, OSB 182698 Harold B. Scoggins, III, OSB 914217 Heather Bowman, OSB 073257 Heather Decker, OSB 962589 Henry J. Kaplan, OSB 830559 Henry Rodriguez, OSB 192811 Holger Uhl, OSB 950143

7 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Holly Hayman, OSB 114146 Holly Pettit, OSB 003506 Hopi Costello Ruplin, OSB 185940 Ian James Griswold, OSB 111053 Iayesha Smith, OSB 044190 Ilene M. Munk, OSB 103025 J. Ashlee Albies, OSB 051846 J. Michael Harris, OSB 043080 J. Nicole DeFever, OSB 030929 J. Nicole Rose, OSB 124434 J.Alejandro Villacorta, OSB 061327 Jaime Langton, OSB 096839 Jamee Asher, OSB 132952 James A. King, OSB 094088 James Arneson, OSB 770980 James D Meiers, OSB 165484 James E Oliver Jr, OSB 943992 James E. Geringer, OSB 951783 James E. McCandlish, OSB 75246-9 James L. Casteel, OSB 712013 James S. Coon, OSB 771450 Jamie Trinkle, OSB 192463 Jane Fox, OSB 950190 Jane Moisan, OSB 181864 Jane Paulson, OSB 91180 Janet E Neuman, OSB 813258 Janice R. Morgan, OSB 990850, Executive Director, on behalf of Legal Aid Services of Oregon Janis Puracal, OSB 132288 Janna Giesbrecht-McKee, OSB 143259 Jason A Skelton, OSB 014150 Jason A. Wrubleski, OSB 120524 Jeanne Sinnott, OSB 075151 Jeannie Salyer, OSB 003742 Jeff Jorgensen, OSB 123592 Jeffrey S. Matthews, OSB 820849 Jennelle Gonzales, OSB 123967 Jennifer E Nicholls, OSB 114731 Jennifer Harrington, OSB 902910 Jennifer Herbst, OSB 114178 Jennifer McGowan, OSB 033980 Jennifer Middleton, OSB 071510 Jennifer Peckham, OSB 094697 Jennifer M. Rotman, OSB 041344 Jennifer Wagner, OSB 024470 Jennifer Yeh, OSB 142433

8 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Jeremy D. Sacks, OSB 994262 Jesse A. Buss, OSB 122919 Jesse M Calm, OSB 106885 Jesse Neilson, OSB 143947 Jessica A Schuh, OSB 164778 Jessica Boell, OSB 020220 Jessica Mindlin, OSB 911456 Jia Feng, OSB 161130 Jill Weygandt, OSB 095481 Joan P. Snyder, OSB 862938 Jocelyn Pease, OSB 102065 Joe Di Bartolomeo, OSB 902483 Joe Muldavin, OSB 185474 Joel Kaplan, OSB 79285 Joel Leonard, OSB 960810 Joel Overlund, OSB 873149 Joel Shapiro, OSB 003814 John B. Dudrey, OSB 083085 John C. Rothermich, OSB 071685 John Clarke, OSB 153245 John F. Neupert, OSB 783168 John Gear, OSB 073810 John J. Dooney, III, OBS 106839 John L. Barlow, OSB 811590 John Schlosser, OSB 104959 Jollee Patterson, OSB 975081 Jon Friedman, OSB 84225 Jon P. Stride, OSB 903887 Jon Zbinden, OSB 824368 Jon Zunkel-deCoursey, OSB 165018 Jonah Sandford, OSB 154711 Jonathan Strauhull, OSB 106094 Jordan Barbeau, OSB 176312 Jordan Cunnings, OSB 182928 Jordan R. Silk, OSB 105031 Jordan Schoonover, OSB 145050 Jordon Huppert, OSB 111124 Joseph A. Urbanski, OSB 154427 Joseph Justin Rollin, OSB 080325 Joseph M Connelly, OSB 932373 Joseph S. Voboril, OSB 733106 Josh Ewing, OSB 152934 Josh Ross, OSB 03438 Josh Stellmon, OSB 075183 Joshua B. Lay-Perez, OSB 162312

9 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Joshua McCain, OSB 181406 Josie Sustaire, OSB 144416 Jovanna Patrick, OSB 111339 Jovita Wang, OSB 105356 Jud Wesnousky, OSB 174883 Judith Rosenberg, OSB 984545 Judith Swinney, OSB 960011 Juhi S. Aggarwal, OSB 130764 Julia M. Hagan, OSB 850477 Julia Manela, OSB 023771 Julia Markley, OSB 00079 Julie R Vacura, OSB 84369 Julie Sugano O'Reilly, OSB 192771 June M. Wiyrick Flores, OSB 974390 Justin D. Leonard, OSB 033736 Justin Howe, OSB 142339 K. Bruce Knivila, OSB 923576 Kachelle Baxter, OSB 120659 Kacy Anne Jones, OSB 180121 Kali Montague, OSB 094482 Kami White, OSB 014523 Kara Backus, OSB 111876 Karen A Steele, OSB 873529 Karen Stolzberg, OSB 830921 Kasia Rutledge, OSB 084590 Kassim Ferris, OSB 965260 Kate A Wilkinson, OSB 001705 Kate Boyd, OSB 140695 Kate D'Ambrosio, OSB 161907 Kate Suisman, OSB 136435 Katelyn S. Oldham, OSB 024115 Katharine Edwards, OSB 173393 Katharine Martin, OSB 062981 Katherine A. McDowell, OSB 089087 Kathleen Mahoney, Pending Kathleen O’Brien, OSB 830717 Kathryn Bourn, OSB 952166 Kathryn H. Clarke, OSB 791890 Kathryn Olney, OSB 873117 Kathryn Smith Root, OSB 850230 Katie H. Haraguchi, OSB 083537 Kay Teague, OSB 161621 Keil Mueller, OSB 085535 Keith Dubanevich, OSB 975200 Kelci Paiva, OSB 146153

10 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Kellie A. Furr, OSB 123197 Kelly D. Jones, OSB 074217 Kelly Fisher, OSB 065878 Kelly Knivila, OSB 923583 Kelly Lusk, OSB 136277 Kelly M. Evans, OSB 992572 Kelly Simon, OSB 154213 Kelsey Benedick, OSB 173038 Kelsey R. Jones, OSB 143511 Ken Lerner, OSB 794841 (inactive) Kendra M Matthews, OSB 965672 Kenneth M Elliott, OSB 802176 Kennon Scott, OSB 144280 Kevin Brague, OSB 050428 Kevin Díaz, OSB 970480 Kevin Hupy, OSB 164073 Kevin S. Crosman, OSB 173282 Kimberly Mason, OSB 076365 Kimberly McCullough, OSB 134223 Kirk H. Gibson, OSB 851222 Kirkland T. Roberts, OSB 814415 Krista D. Mancuso, OSB 143796 Krista Le Roux, OSB 152981 Kristen A. Chambers, OSB 130882 Kristen Edwards, OSB 093397 Kristen G. Hilton, OSB 151950 Kristin Sterling, OSB 003996 Kristina Holm, OSB 112607 Kristina Knittel, OSB 183887 Kyle B. Dukelow, OSB 932570 Kyle Krohn, OSB 104301 Lake James Perriguey, OSB 983213 Lake Perriguey, OSB 983213 Lane Toensmeier, OSB 105300 Laney B. Ellisor, OSB 173425 Laura Burgee-Soran, OSB 122886 Laura E. Rosenbaum, OSB 110061 Laura Kerr, OSB 143582 Laura Koistinen, OSB 175123 Laura Larson, OSB 951325 Laurie E Craghead, OSB 922663 Lawrence Matasar, OSB 742092 Lee Wyatt, OSB 983808 Leland Baxter-Neal, OSB 155347 Leland R. Berger, OSB 830201

11 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Leslie W O'Leary, OSB 990908 Linda Eyerman, OSB 761306 Linda J. Larkin, OSB 792954 Lindsay E. Landstrom, OSB 135697 Lindsay Jonasson, Pending Lindsay Soto, OSB 024613 Lindsey Burrows, OSB 113431 Lisa Almasy Miller, OSB 832865 Lisa D. Hardie, OSB 080783 Lisa D. Wright, 125021 Lisa Kenn, OSB 151208 Lisa Maxfield, OSB 844337 Lisa Newman Eckstein, OSB 932603 Lisa Rackner, OSB 873844 Lisa Shevlin, OSB 145185 Liza Jane Langford, OSB 882509 Lois O. Rosenbaum, OSB 773250 Lori Coukoulis, OSB 902397 Lori Hymowitz, OSB 191685 Louis A. Frohman, OSB 133667 Lourdes Sanchez Marte, OSB 974795 Luis Garcia, OSB 093627 Lydia Anderson-Dana, OSB 166167 Lynn-Marie Crider, OSB 831074 M. Scott Sorensen-Jolink, OSB 774188 Madison Kaplan, OSB 171901 Maggie Biondi, OSB 922309 Malia Bennett, OSB 122790 Malori M. Maloney, OSB 175899 Marc Beck, OSB 180651 Marc Schworm, OSB 076752 Marcus J. Swift, OSB 144431 Margaret E. Schroeder, OSB 025748 Margaret K Melvin, OSB 890909 Margaret S Olney, OSB 881359 Margaret Vining, OSB 081546 Maria E. Andrade OSB 96163 Maria Witt, OSB 145573 Marie Weiskopf, OSB 115897 Marilyn Heiken, OSB 923308 Mario F. Riquelme, OSB 024409 MariRuth Petzing, OSB 135412 Marisa Moneyhun, OSB 074500 Marissa Zarate, OSB 140252 Inactive Marjorie A Speirs, OSB 783888

12 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Mark A Manulik, OSB 880730 Mark J. Ginsberg, OSB 952743 Mark J. Wilk, OSB 814218 Mark Long, OSB 82325 Marlene E Findling, OSB 85202 Martin Dolan, OSB 872053 Martin Reeves, OSB 813462 Mary Bruington, OSB 984520 Mary Ellen Page Farr, OSB 822539 Mary Kane, OSB 982665 Mary L. Lang, OSB 104333 Mathew dos Santos, OSB 155766 Mathew J. Riberdy, OSB 184292 Matt Tripp, OSB 154394 Matthew D. Kaplan, OSB 980699 Matthew D. Larson, OSB 033689 Matthew J. Steven, OSB 181699 Matthew Kehoe, OSB 903103 Matthew Merritt, OSB 122206 Matthew P. Goldman, OSB 183468 Matthew S. Denney, OSB 155814 Mavel Morales, OSB 060969 May Low, OSB 132629 Maya Crawford Peacock, OSB 032966 Mayra Ledesma, OSB 183942 Megan Dolan, OSB 066275 Megan I. Livermore, OSB 054789 Melanie Kebler, OSB 083798 Melina LaMorticella, OSB 104325 Melissa Bobadilla, OSB 05202 Melissa Bushnick, OSB 140704 Melissa Chinn, OSB 173228 Melissa Haggerty, OSB 125132 Meredith McMurray, OSB 175179 Merril Keane, OSB 063910 Mia Butzbaugh, OSB 021118 Michael A Yates, OSB 833549 Michael A. Cohen, OSB 965776 Michael Althouse, OSB 150793 Michael J. Beilstein, OSB 163407 Michael Brian, OSB 710309 Michael Dale, OSB 771507 Michael E. Rose, OSB 75322 Michael Fuller, OSB 093570 Michael Hajarizadeh, OSB 166199

13 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Michael J. Fearl, OSB 962779 Michael J. Morris, OSB 772839 Michael Tooley, OSB 115350 Michaela Gore, OSB 185252 Michel Marie Rose, OSB 185348 Michelle (Micky) Ryan, OSB 793700 Michelle E. Wasson, OSB 061359 Michelle Freed, OSB 042880 Michelle Ryan, OSB 973882 Mike Sargetakis, OSB 174607 Miranda Summet, OSB 074937 Moloy K. Good, OSB 012636 Monica Goracke, OSB 060650, Executive Director on behalf of Oregon Law Center Monica Martinez, OSB 132636 Morris J Galen, OSB 500400 N David Shamloo, OSB 934221 N. Robert Stoll, OSB 69155 Nadia Dahab, OSB 125630 Nancy Hartung Segal, OSB 085400 Nathan Morales, OSB 145763 Neda D Soofi, OSB 014673 Neil W Jackson, OSB 782563 Nelson R. Hall, OSB 852221 Nicholas Pyle, OSB 165175 Nicole H. Nelson, OSB 975343 Noah Bishop, OSB 092871 Noah Warman, OSB 172513 Nora Coon, OSB 163644 Nora J. Broker, OSB 164739 Norah Van Dusen, OSB 180114 Olivia Schneider Grabacki, OSB 173615 Owen Blank, OSB 730345 P.K. Runkles-Pearson, OSB 061911 Paloma Dale, OSB 186231 Paloma Norris-York, OSB 965680 Pamela J. Paluga, OSB 094672 Patricia Chor, OSB 922577 Patricia Dost, OSB 902530 Patricia Ferrell-French, OSB 911280 Patricia L Nelson, OSB 932990 Paul E. Levy, OSB 872852 Paul S. Bovarnick, OSB 791654 Peggy A Bond, OSB 902136 Peggy Hennessy, OSB 872505 Penny Serrurier, OSB 915112

14 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Percy Wise, OSB 095847 Peter A. Parnickis, OSB 85072 Peter A. Werner, OSB 091722 Peter C. Diamond, OSB 922814 Peter Evalds, OSB 140807 Peter Straumfjord, OSB 105159 Peter Tran, OSB 135064 Peyton Lee, OSB 164224 Phil Goldsmith, OSB 782230 Philip Smith, OSB 98103 Phylis Myles, OSB 921048 Pramela Reddi, OSB 120104 Priscilla L. Seaborg, OSB 901176 Prof. Gilbert Paul Carrasco, Willamette University Law Quinn Kuranz, OSB 114375 Rachel Lynn Staines, OSB 154269 Rachel N Marshall, OSB 035687 Rachel Nies, OSB 085360 Rachel Philips, OSB 053489 Ralph Wilborn, OSB 841046 Randy Elmer OSB 831920 Randy Oetken, OSB 930880 Rebecca Boyette, OSB 135024 Rebecca Cambreleng, OSB 133209 Rebecca Gandy, OSB 010487 Rebecca Morgan, OSB 143890 Rhett Garrett Fraser, OSB 091080 Richard A. Carlson, OSB 750643 Richard A. Cremer, OSB 750833 Richard Myers, OSB 131264 Rick Glantz, OSB 083386 Rima Ghandour, OSB 020513 Robert A. Weppner, OSB 810021 Robert G Dolton, OSB 812116 Robert L Sepp, OSB 020932 Robert M. Gregg, OSB 812488 Robert W. Ickes, OSB 052917 Robyn Stein, OSB 993682 Rod Underhill, OSB 883246 Román D. Hernández, OSB 011730 Ronald J. Rubino, OSB 894249 Ronn Elzinga, OSB 912606, President Oregon Trial Lawyers Association Ronnee S. Kliewer, OSB 933319 Rose Francis, OSB 123158 Ross C. Sutherland, OSB 160281

15 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Ross Denison, OSB 175835 Ruth Pekelder, OSB 840799 Ryan E. Gibb, OSB 972693 Ryan N Strauss, OSB 163232 Ryan Newby, OSB 114724 S. Caitlin Dolan, OSB 066282 Sam Kuzma, OSB 066773 Sam Oliver, OSB 034119 Samantha MacBeth, OSB 164310 Samantha Ratcliffe, OSB 165516 Samantha Sondag, OSB 154244 Samuel R. Walton, OSB 135870 Sandra A Hansberger, OSB 83044 Sandra P. Naranjo, OSB 053314 Sara Angeletti, OSB 010161 Sara Cotton, OSB 085986 Sara Kobak, OSB 023495 Sara L Gabin, OSB 812345 Sara L. Butcher, OSB 99166 Sara Mader, OSB 120057 Sara Mulroy, OSB 084274 Sarah Carlin Ames, OSB 163350 Sarah Denner, OSB 100914 Sarah E. Feldman, OSB 141458 Sarah Einowski, OSB 093412 Sarah Petersen, OSB 084418 Saskia de Boer, OSB 035670 Scott Aldworth, OSB 113123 Scott Culpepper, OSB 173299 Scott D. Franke, OSB 920207 Scott Lee Sharp, OSB 031437 Scott O Pratt, OSB 813423 Scott Sell, OSB 144297 Sean Glinka, OSB 082971 Selby J. Abraham, OSB 160868 Serena Liss, OSB 154799 Seth White, OSB 075635 Shannon Garcia, OSB 162178 Shannon Hall, OSB 114107 Shari L. Lane, OSB 022440 Shaun McCrea, OSB 832826, Executive Director, Oregon Criminal Defense Lawyers Association Sheeba Roberts, OSB 151531 Sheila Maloney Blackford, OSB 002062 Shelby C. Smith, OSB 184550

16 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Shelby Woehlk, OSB 191930 Shelley L. Fuller, OBS 982332 Shenoa Payne, OSB 084392 Shizuko Hashimoto, OSB 165405 Shoshana Baird, OSB 170790 Simeon D. Rapoport, OSB 874194 Sonya Fischer, OSB 030982, Clackamas County Commissioner Spencer Aldrich, OSB 092699 Stacey Reding, OSB 072226 Stephanie Corey Holmberg, OSB 082925 Stephanie Davidson, OSB 145074 Stephanie Engelsman, OSB 050546 Stephen D. Osborne, OSB 034158 Stephen H. Galloway, OSB 093602 Stephen J. Mathieu, OSB 980033 Stephen W Manning, OSB 01337 Steve Eberlein, OSB 093372 Steve Larson, OSB 863540 Steven Berman, OSB 951769 Steven C Burke OSB 002198 Steven Goldberg, OSB 751341 Steven J. Boender, OSB 120358 Steven Wilker, OSB 911882 Steven Y. Lovett, OSB 910701 Susan Elizabeth Reese, Newport, OSB 732454 Susan G. Steinman, OSB106918 Susan Jewell, OSB 023384 Susan M. Muzik, OSB 852894 Susan Pitchford, OSB 98091 Sydney Montanaro, OSB 145139 Tara Hervel, OSB 070418 Teresa A. Statler, OSB 914407 Terisa Page Gault, OSB 121278 Terrence Pancoast, OSB 681232 Tess Hellgren, OSB 191622 Thalia Sady, OSB 094941 Theodore Erde-Wollheim OSB 183333 Theresa L. Wright, OSB 814289 Theresa M. Kohlhoff, OSB 80398 Thomas C. Sand, OSB 773322 Thomas E. Kim, OSB 183855 Thomas J. Payne, OSB 165168 Thomas M. Sheridan, OSB 833248 Thomas Melville, OSB 971282 Thomas P. Walsh, OSB 904055

17 The Honorable Martha L. Waters September 3, 2019

Thomas Stenson, OSB 152894 Tiffany A. Elkins, OSB 033110 Tim Cunningham, OSB 100906 Tim L. Eblen, OSB 050252 Timothy DeJong, OSB 94066 Timothy L. McMahan, OSB 984624 Timothy P. Nicholson, OSB 164460 Timothy P. Walsh, OSB 144574 Todd A. Hanchett, OSB 992787 Todd L. Friedman, OSB 113882 Tom Adams, OSB 116588 Tomas Hernandez, OSB 133840 Tony Kullen, OSB 090218 Valentina De Fex, OSB 184958 Valerie Sasaki, OSB 014032 W. Eugene Hallman, OSB 741237 Walter F Fonseca, OSB 136349 Walter Meier, OSB 025121 Wayne Landsverk, OSB 731763 Wendi Warren H. Binford, OSB 062319 Wendy Levy, OSB 101224 Whitney A. Phelps, Immigration Attorney Licensed in NY State Whitney P. Boise, OSB 851570 Whitney Stark, OSB 090350 Willa B. Perlmutter, OSB 170689 William A. Drew, OSB 952539 William J. Macke, OSB 091793 William Keith Dozier, OSB 012478 Willow Hillman, OSB 153514 Yesenia Gutierrez, OSB 077128 Z. Hanah Riley, OSB 121340 Zac Hlavaty, OSB 153522 Zachary S. Davis, OSB 152831 Zachary Stern, OSB 134967 Zack Duffly, OSB 143109 Zara Lukens, OSB 153751

18