Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
If you have issues viewing or accessing this file contact us at NCJRS.gov. Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System May 1994 Office of the State Court Administrator Oregon Judicial Department An act passed by the Oregon territorial legislature in 1849 provided: ~ tBiff to prevent Nf,groes anti 9YluCatioes to come to or reside in Oregon. whereas, situatei as the peopfe of Oreg(Jft are, in the mUfst of an Imfian popuCation, it 'UJouU be hig{y iangerous to a{{o'UJ free negroes ani muCattoes to resUfe in the territory or to intermb( with the ltuiians! instiffing into their mitufs feefings of hostifity against tft.e white race, therefore: 'Be it enactei by the .Legis{ati'lJe .9lssemE{y ofthe territory of Oreg(Jft, that it sha{{ not be Cawfu{ for any negroe or muCattoe to come into or resUfe within the fimits of this territory ... Source: Office of the Secretary of State, Archives Division, Territorial Document #3666, pp. 181-82 153720 u.s. Department of JusticE' National Institute of Justice This document has been reproduced exactly as received from the person or organization originating it. Points of view or opinions stated in :IJ this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent ;teD the offiCial position or policies of the National Institute of Justice. tJ)\l Permission to reploduce this copyrighted material has been graf£i:ce of the State Court ~O o """t Adminjstrato~/Oregon Judicial Dept. _. 0 0 85 to the National Criminal Justice Reference Service (NCJRS). " ... On :I-C-toa "1 (t) Further reproduction outSide of the NCJRS system requires permission of the copyright owner. ... n ..... ~ ~ ::rCD:T ~E} CD 0 CD = (t) ~rn c...:'lO ~ t"+ o..~ ~ s::: ..,.. -= ..... (t) \l) C,.JJ(D ....~ ·0 '< -- m (Q -&. <0 ~.Q) n_. 0 e?-8 <0 ~~ ~ _Sl):l ro ~p..> en -......... (/) S '-< m c: e+~ ...... (fj ..... -C a 8. Ji;:. ....::r1lilllC m Ul .~ ""--j ~;- .'::::3- ... 4"'~ CD 2. CD q- ..' ~ <"'!l eot-~= r?~ :'-~1 c-t , - n o 3 3 t; G CD t-) -(J) :·.5 en o :.~~ r:: o CD c: " f.n - ......~ uJv" --.J 9-J o LI ____ _ - - --------------------------------------- The Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System Chair Honorable Edwin e.T. Peterson Vice Chair M. Khalil Zonoozy Members Kathleen Bogan Honorable Nancy W. Campbell r Kathryn H. Clarke Honorable Mercedes F. Deiz Marco A. Hernandez Douglas Hutchinson Corinne J. Lai Honorable Jack L. Landau Angel Lopez Yvonne Martinez Jeffrey B. Millner Jack L. Morris Liliana E. Olberding William A. Olsen N argess Shadbeh H. Adunni Warren Abbreviations used in this report: ABA American Bar Association ABE Adult Basic Education CSD Children's Services Division DRI Disproportionate Representation Index F2d Federal Reporter Second Edition FED Forcible Entry and Detainer LJ Law Joumal LRev Law Review MHRC Multnomah Human Relations Commission Or Oregon Reports-Supreme Court OrApp Oregon Reports-Court of Appeals ORCP Oregon Rules of Civil Procedure ORS Oregon Revised Statutes OSCI Oregon State Correctional Institution OSP Oregon State Penitentiary P2d Pacific Reporter Second Edition SCt Supreme Court Reporter US United States Supreme Court Reports UTCR Uniform Trial Court Rules Edited by: Mary Bauman and Mark Ottenad OJD Publications Section Designed by: Mark Ottenad OJD Publications Section Printed by: Office of the State Court Administrator Oregon Judicial Department Salem, Oregon This document has no copyright and may be reproduced. ___ 1 -------------------------------------- Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System May 1994 The Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on RaciaVEthnic Issues in the Judicial System is available to the public: PUBLICATION PRICE EACH • Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on $ 3.00 RaciaVEthnic Issues in the Judicial System (this document) • Appendices to the Report of the Oregon Supreme Court $10.00 Task Force on RaciallEthnic Issues in the Judicial System (The Appendices are composed of: Results of the Survey of RaciallEthnic Issues in the Judicial System; Oregon Judicial Department AffIrmative Action Plan; Survey Questionnaires; 1993 Oregon Laws, Chapter 687; Order Creating the Task Force.) To obtain the publications, send a request indicating the quantity and name of the publication{s) desired, enclose a check made payable to the State Court Administrator for the appropriate amount, and mail to: Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on RacialJEthnic Issues in the Judicial System Oregon Judicial Department Supreme Court Building 1163 State Street Salem, Oregon 97310 Telephone: (503) 378-6046 An order form for your convenience is available on the last page of the report. Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System Table of Contents Introduction: Forenote to Nonminority Readers .................................................. v Chapter 1: Overview of Task Force Report ...................................................... 1 Recommendation....................................................................................... 2 Conclusions of the Task Force Report.... .................. ............. ..... ....... ....... 3 Overview of the Task Force ...................................................................... 4 How the Task Force Gathered Information............................................. 6 Public Hearings.................................................................................. 6 Survey of Oregon Legal Community...... ..... ... ....... .......... ............ ...... 6 Chapter 2: Interpreters .a •••••••• II ............................. Ill ........ a ........ /1 ••••••••••• ".11................. 9 Interpreters and the Judicial System .... .... .... .... ..... .................. ............... 10 Interpreters, Minorities and the Courts .................................................. 14 Findings.............................................................................................. 14 Recommendations .............................................................................. 15 Chapter 3: Minorities Working in Oregon Courts ............................................ 19 Importance of Having a Diverse Work Force ........................................... 19 The Judicial Department AtTrrmative Action Plan ................................. 21 Employment of Minorities in the Courts ......... ....... ................ ................. 22 Findings.............................................................................................. 22 Recommendations .............................................................................. 25 Chapter 4: Minorities in Criminal Courts .......................................................... 31 Arrest and Detention ................................................................................ 31 Findings ... ' .. ,............................................... , ................................ 1...... 31 Recommendations.............................................................................. 33 Charging Decisions.................................................................................... 34 Findings.............................................................................................. 34 Recommendations .............................................................................. 35 -i- ii Report of the Oregon Supreme Court Task Force on Racial/Ethnic Issues in the Judicial System Chapter 4: Minorities in Criminal Courts (continued) Pretrial Release ......................................................................................... 36 Findings.............................................................................................. 36 Recommendations .............................................................................. 37 Plea Negotiations ...................................................................................... 38 Findings .................... ,......................................................................... 38 Conduct of Trial......................................................................................... 39 Findings.............................................................................................. 39 Recommendation.... ... .............. ...... .... .......... ....... .... .......... .... ........... ... 40 Sentencing ................................................................................................. 40 Findings .......................................................... ,................................... 40 Recommendations .............................................................................. 44 Imprisonment, Parole and Probation.......... ............ ...... ........................... 45 Findings .............................................................................................. 45 Recommendations ......................................................... .................... 50 Bibliography .............................................................................................. 54 Chapter 5: The Juvenile Justice System .......................................................... 55 A Brief Description of the System........... .......... ....... ............. .......... ......... 55 Studies of Minorities in the Juvenile Justice System ............................. 57 1. The 1982 Multnomah County Juvenile Court Monitoring Study .......................................................................