Dr. Ahmadieh's Views and Experiences on Melancholy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Quarterly of the Horizon of Medical Sciences Volume 21, Special Issue, 2015 Pages: 43-50 Type: Systematic Review Dr. Ahmadieh’s Views and Experiences on Melancholy Treatment; a Comprehensive Narrative Review Mohammadzadeh-Moghadam H.1 MD, PhD, Kamalinejad M.* MSc, Nazari S.M.1 MD, PhD, Khajavi A.2 MD, PhD, Akbari A.3 MD, Mohammadpour A.4 PhD *Pharmacognosy Department, Pharmacy School, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran 1Persian Traditional Medicine Department, Persian Traditional Medicine School, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran 2Community Medicine Department, Medicine School, Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran 3Psychiatry Department, Medicine School, Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran 4“Social Determinants of Health Research Center" and "Internal Surgery Nursing Department, Nursing & Midwifery Faculty”, Gonabad University of Medical Sciences, Gonabad, Iran Abstract Aims: 10 millennium history of Iranian traditional medicine has been ignored in the recent 150 years. Nevertheless, the tradition has been noticed by some physicians such as Dr. Ahmadieh who used it to heal different diseases including melancholia. The aim of the comprehensive review was to investigate the viewpoints and experiences of Dr. Ahmadieh about melancholia and their matching with the Iranian traditional medicine texts. Documents & Methods: The books written by Dr. Ahmadieh and the Iranian traditional medicine text books were studied through comprehensive searching strategy. Then, searching was done on 8 English and Persian data-bases including Google Scholar, Scopus, Medline, IRANDOC, Magiran, Medlib, and ISC, without any limitations. Related studies were identified and recovered after screening, and then a list of resources were searched. Finally, data having been extracted, all the results were narratively composed in line with the targets. Findings: As a very ancient word used in the psychology history, melancholia had been used instead of depression. Based on the Iranian traditional medicine, its cause was, according to the viewpoints of Dr. Ahmadieh, either the excess of soda in the body or unnatural soda. General treatment of melancholia was based on six health strategies (especially, nasal irritation and loss and constipation elimination). In addition, its specific treatments were based on the groups and were with different causes. Conclusion: The experiences of Dr. Ahmadieh about melancholia treatment are based on the Iranian traditional medicine, classical medicine, folklore medicine, and his personal innovations. Then, his experiences can be noticed by the researchers, clinical experts, and health-care policy-makers as either complementary or alternative care. Keywords: Melancholia; Depressive Disorder; Ahmadieh; Medicine, Traditional; Review *Corresponding Author Tel: +982188200118 Fax: +982188200118 Address: Pharmacy School, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Vali Asr Street, Tehran, Iran. Postal Code: 1991953381 [email protected] Received: December 21, 2015 Accepted: April 19, 2016 ePublished: June 7, 2016 # <*8 ;$ '9:'9 : // :/$# #) : // : #) * [email protected] :; ; MD, PhD * MSc () *+,& ! "# $% & %' & ' (!# %!"#$ ) /'/ 0 /1 (2 / ! "-,. MD, PhD 2 % 0 34 5%6 ! ! <0!"& =0 .[] 70"8& ( 90 : "-0 ;2 ! ?/"9 @)& ("-; ;6 %& MD, PhD A " . !"B %A" ! ! $" /! & & *+ ! 5 (C %' ("&0 708& MD /?/"9 % E'& ! /! (/0"# " ) /D% & & ,# F0 <0 0 GH =0 IJ ! 7+ Ph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`% ((a ) FN (!0) *'L ( @" + C;: M1< . ,9 B+J &K (0 / )"& ! %4%4 /Y" ! () "b ( @" !B- . ,9 2 B-6 *$9>0 + ( " $: X3Y K =0 . D ;K,& + 4 * O &: + #: ! N. E =N! (=8N0/ E % .B67 M$3 A+ P: MI<3 :& ( $. : ,. KH. (9 D ! D % KH. ; $>& ! # .B 6 # 7>6 *0 # B %J ! D- L & "/ ! S " 1;L *$ $ *( ) B/K ! (%R E .[] L ; ! S ! !" + SJ: ?+) I 'Q : $. /# . & cVN 2 5TY L , ) 3 * + $ (B$; 26 + ! MJ: T ! %% & X3Y d/ ! % O L %) ! .B M+ ) ; + +7 > ! -/ (L "4 " P& Q $. # 89: : Y "0 KH. D% =0 "O .[] *+ . M + $/$6 !SI# ! " %I/ 4 `% =KN ( D 0$: $ '0 E& $K # B6 + ( " ( " ( .7 BI , 7B + . !'Q+?" : ! " #$% & r " Hf &%6 L ;6Y " ! " ( " L ! +L 23 h! + L ! D" "f& oH & % .[] D- D C =0 "4 N%+N D 34 =I/ .[ (] 0 D"& ! F0& "W "0 N "4Y % " ! L ! s^ % % ( %& (%, ;L " 2 "'/ N% (% O "68 d/ (76! =0 .[] % ;0)& ( D"/ "-0 01 ;WVNb9 %3N ! . " E'& ! D40 " t !" =0 6 KH. 2" K0 % L _. ! ! "0 ")8 % L l)i& ! N%+N % " ! " & %3N DSM DSM- :) =0"OL) =0% KH.! L 20: ;- ! 8) e0& % .% (5 " .[] %f, F& ! A": (S2&! E ! %O ) N E'& /E =0 ! .% ", 1+& 0! "& t !" F0 "BY 8Ni 0 /D%L ! "0 gH '4 +L . $' $4 t %!2 u&" %4%4 &K ! . D "R 4%O O / " H"& " 2+ % ! =0 " ! 20"- :3& ! K& D40 ) % D 9"8 =I/ ! N%+N ! ! ! EW ! .[] S0R ! 0 F) 0 FH. .9"4 "R " ! D" 0 %O Y h" & %O (%R ; ")8 % ;6Y <0 ($! $4 5R $& ( / " =I/ .! i (S0 ! E) h" (WN; (/,%O D"O1 0 j% '0 0 %) S D %O (=% SKY 3V& (0!TH+ (=8N0 / (") (0 H / k%WO ! /PH4 ." (oVN f ()iN j"^ (VN6 =0"R (0!Tl0 :Y = ! / , !" ! 0 ()R 0 .90 l)i& iN 9 H%N ! I%R =0 K0 . D% l9% %& ;R H / t %!2 u&" ! $% $4 N%+N (D" L 8 5H4 / ! A%.%K ("NK ;4%4 ; D D-0. %!2 .[ (] (“Melancholia” /Da! D3 =0T KH.! e0& 5Yi6 =0"&0R K0 N%+N "& ! “Depressive Disorder” 0 “Melancholy” Em"8 N%+N .[] ! 4"29 “Alternative (“Medicine, Traditional” v/Da! ! D 8 Melanos " ! Melancholia &T “Iranian Traditional (“Ahmadiyeh” (Medicine” N%+N H +/ fN .[] nO 8 Chole “Persian Traditional Medicine” 0 Medicine” 34 ! NY ! (%) D nO 8 D /D-0. %!2 $J $4 .9"4 5%6 0\/ ! S/%& ()!H (4"29 J "9 L % v D-0. ! N ("- (w"0 9 K!"KN D D%O S =0 ( !% j" =0 'L ! D% 0 /Da! "& N%+N Da! $ $ 0N%+N oH !2 !% oH Y .[] C0H9 %# .90 =0H-0 0 ;K ( ! %4,0". 4" 0KY 8 24 .[] D" (n)&" 58Ni 0 Y C0H9 ! %!2 2Y 8 *+, ! D D N%O H "".O 2- ! 9 S D /D-0. & %!2 N%O ! (Hf) ^ L ! N%O = @)& ;0R h" ! 0!V 0!V %-I/ ! .[] b K,O ! -O% %8 _M ! "-N"^ D 0 58Ni . $' 8Ni (%! (N%+N (!% A%! =0! "0 J "/ 8 %# =I/ "-,/!u. 0 t) %& -%0 ! % (;: @O (8) A%! (A%! $% $4 D0 t /_"9 R (%!2 ", (N%+N 70"8& l) .[] =0 " NT . "R %& % H ] % D)& ;: ! D 8) "' " K9 ! %q A " "\Nx%9 /$4 %!2 <0 (0 $4 KY D% /! ! "& ! C0 ,/ .[ 3 %V ;V& l0" 0! "& % !" d/ =O% 8)"^ % 0 % 0 L .9"4 "R + 0 D"& nO =0 2 % ;6Y @O "0 Q Horizon Med Sci Volume 21, Special Issue, 2015 y" D3 "-0 /! ! // `% ; 0/%'8 ! 3R g :& $0 0 \4 P%4 ,. %N ( %!2 <0 (t %!2 u&" 1+& S^" :& _. ( y9"4 %O (F0) l 0 (FN3) 2- ! 9 K!"KN /D-0. ,/!u. 5T: "4 ,. ( y %9 " H D0" " (; !V ( n)&" 0Y " D% ! L " H" 4)2J NY ! ,^L D",Y S K0J.) |01 t, ! "0 5' -/ % [] N: 0 D dK !& ;V _M ! !& & \4 ([] ;V& <0 (C+ =0 .90 , "R %+ (b 0 !& ;V ! D% b ;V K0 0 (34 C. D 0 5T: S (t %!2 %V Hf $% & " 0'& D _. %+ ! ! % C+ %\ t "0 ! [] " .[] 0 3 ! D oO Y =0 &80 (0Y " ) ; %B% NR (/P! ! Hf) ^ / 9 x3& / H `% ("0 ! / %6 3W& _. ,. % % (! ! EW (DSM-5 L :)i& 20: ! "0 N%+N x ;: " %'8 ($% t9 ! $T /! oH 9"8 ! N%+N ! D!"4 6WO (N%+N %-0 % i0" =0 ! $% / `% ! . D 0 ! .[] % D, =0!" P! / : =0 " " : % &'( )& "#" $ S^" \N (2 %4%4 t0) %! ;0R !" KH. :9% n%& N%+N =N! :DSM-5 rY 2% 5 D. D"24 /9",. kO % ! KH.! !"9 (=0"0 KH. A " NY 0 "&" -\4 " ( D 0 -%0 FH. ! C&Y 0N%+N H ! ! =0" ! D% 5!3 /8) " H ! _. S2:& =0 ! [] S2:& D!"4 .[ ] "0\. $' "/ 8) l9% 6WO 0 .[ (] D D!L % "-0 =0 " ! "0 9"4 $N " ) ( N%2 " H $& (%) D nO ! D!"4 (D DL $% "/ !" % li ! % W Hf % @O =0 5+ _. ! S '0 %O % %9 ". ! ;)& /D! ? ! "^T L 5 ! % r 0 ! F oV ! 78B (8)) D"m ! 9 D%R L ) 2Y " L 0H 5 ! L / ;0 & 8) F 0 8) $O ) .% $! D!"4 . 4LC. L =0" 5!3 0 ! F =0" =0 .% `9 R %O $& % S0 R9 ! b %O ) ! b"3 ! x" H ! D $% t9 9" ) N%+N $% D!"4 . S,J ! D"J ? 4"& ! R q3Y 0 " D! ! ! D! D $% t9 9" 0 :0 0 D8 !% nO L R" 0 HJ "/ !" ! .[] L 5+ ! H" (x36 D". O 0T) x" 0 V %& 2+ .O". D-L ! 9"4 "# %& .% !" % ! b ! D W ! )W 8B! %& ($! y oH N ! P%4 D- H " n%& N%+N 4 S2:& =0 L ! `% %& ($% y 23 5TY $& ! D!"4 ) .[] D "4 0 =I/ " . 0K `% =0"&"iOS ! % ! D% *+, % S0 ( /F&% L D3 0 E!"K %! S0 R9 ( b ) $! D!"4 y L ! ! =0" oH z% ) "4 N! O". L /, ! S,J ! D"J ? 4"& ! $& % .[] "0 /P! " ) ! Y! i: D"O (S0 A%! (0 O ! "K9 L ! N%+N $% D!"4 y L `% =0"& ! D% D"J 4K& 6O ;R O C %6 =0 : 0 V (:0 (D8 !% nO L R" O 0"4 ! D! ! S^ 5TY ( : 2&) ! b ! D W L 5+ ! H" x" $% t9 r % F0"V& 5V"& PH0 ! $ (0 P"& /b!L L 5 ! % % ! ! O d"V C0 %& ( y% ! E1 -"4 ( ! = ! SK e3 (\^ ; Ss/ % " %O ")6 ( yO $"4" "-0 .