Analysis of Combat Sports Players' Injuries According to Playing Style
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
J. Phys. Ther. Sci. Original Article 27: 2425–2430, 2015 Analysis of combat sports players’ injuries according to playing style for sports physiotherapy research JI-WOONG NOH, PT, MS1)a, BYOUNG-SUN PARK, PT, MS1)a, MEE-YOUNG KIM, PT, PhD1), LIM-KYU LEE, PT, MS1, 2), SEUNG-MIN YANG, PT, MS1), WON-DEOK LEE, PT, MS1), YONG-SUB SHIN, PT, MS1), JU-HYUN KIM, PT, PhD3), JEONG-UK LEE, PT, PhD4), TAEK-YONG KWAK, PhD5), TAE-HYUN LEE, PhD6), JU-YOUNG KIM, PhD6), JAEHONG PARK, PhD7), JUNGHWAN KIM, PT, PhD8)* 1) Laboratory of Health Science and Nanophysiotherapy, Department of Physical Therapy, Graduate School, Yongin University, Republic of Korea 2) Commercializations Promotion Agency for R&D Outcomes, Republic of Korea 3) Department of Physical Therapy, College of Health Welfare, Wonkwang Health Science University, Republic of Korea 4) Department of Physical Therapy, College of Health Science, Honam University, Republic of Korea 5) Department of Taekwondo Instructor Education, College of Martial Arts, Yongin University, Republic of Korea 6) Department of Combative Martial Arts Training, College of Martial Arts, Yongin University, Republic of Korea 7) Department of Social Welfare, College of Public Health and Welfare, Yongin University, Republic of Korea 8) Department of Physical Therapy, College of Public Health and Welfare, Yongin University: 470 Samga-dong, Cheoin-gu, Yongin-si, Gyeonggi-do 449-714, Republic of Korea Abstract. [Purpose] This study describes the characteristics of injuries in strike and non-strike combat sports, and the results are intended for use in the area of sports physiotherapy research. [Subjects and Methods] The study was conducted on 159 athletes involved in a variety of combat sports. The participants included elite college players of the following sports: judo (47), ssireum (19), wrestling (13), kendo (30), boxing (16), and taekwondo (34). Of the participants, 133 were male and 26 were female. In the case of ssireum and boxing, all of the athletes were male. [Results] In the case of the combat sports, the types of injury and injured regions differed according to playing style. Dislocation and injuries to the neck, shoulders, and elbows were more frequent in the non-strike sports, while injuries to the wrists and hands were more frequent in the strike sports. There was a high incidence of sprains, strains, bruises, and injuries to the lower limbs in both groups. [Conclusion] We suggest that the characteristics of injuries in combat sports differ according to playing style, and our study will therefore provide physical therapists and researchers with information that can be used to prevent injury. Key words: Combat sports, Injury, Sports physiotherapy research (This article was submitted Mar. 10, 2015, and was accepted Apr. 24, 2015) INTRODUCTION closely linked with the risk of injury2, 3). A sports injury is defined as damage to part of the body resulting in inability Combat sports are popular enough to account for 25% of to practice or compete normally4). Because combat sports all Olympic medals1). The term “combat sports” describes a frequently involve striking, throwing, or immobilizing group of sports whose competitive essence consists of direct an opponent, some researchers suggest that they are more combat between two competing athletes2, 3). Most sports are dangerous for athletes than other sports5). Almost all injuries involved in combat sports are caused by mechanical energy, a)The first 2 authors (Noh JW and Park BS) contributed and this manifests as musculoskeletal injuries. Musculo- equally to this work. skeletal injuries usually occur when the body experiences 5, 6) *Corresponding author. Junghwan Kim (E-mail: overload through accident or overuse . Many sporting [email protected]) events in Korea revolve around combat sports such as judo, ©2015 The Society of Physical Therapy Science. Published by IPEC Inc. wrestling, kendo, boxing, taekwondo, and ssireum. Ssireum, This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Cre- also called Korean wrestling, is a form of Korean martial ative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives (by-nc- arts in which two athletes use strength and various skills to nd) License <http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/>. throw their opponent to the ground7). Combat sports can be 2426 J. Phys. Ther. Sci. Vol. 27, No. 8, 2015 classified into two types: strike and non-strike (throwing or (when the injury occurred, when the athlete returned to immobilizing an opponent). Strike sports involve striking exercise, recurrence of the injury, side effects, psycho- an opponent directly by kicking or punching or by using a logical reaction after the injury) weapon. Taekwondo, boxing, and kendo are examples of In the case of queries 1 and 2, more than one response strike sports. The rules of taekwondo, or rather gyorugi, state was permitted in order to cover all injuries experienced that a competitor can only score by striking his opponent in by the athletes. “Injury” in this study was defined as any the chest using only his fists or by kicking his opponent’s head bodily damage that interfered with competition or training. and torso using only the part of the foot below the ankle8, 9). No multiple choice questions were included in the question- Boxing is a contest that involves striking the body or head naire. Statistical analyses were conducted using the PASW of an opponent by means of a punch10). The rules of kendo Statistics software (version 18.0) to calculate averages and state that the head, wrist, waist, or throat of an opponent can standard deviations. Data relating to the general character- be struck with a bamboo sword11–13). Athletes who pursue istics of the athletes were expressed as the mean ± standard strike sports wear protective equipment. Taekwondo athletes error (SE), and these data were assessed using the Student’s wear a guard on the head, torso, arms, legs, and groin, while t-test. The significance level was set to α=0.05. We also kendo athletes are equipped with protective armor on the analyzed the frequency of injury in each sport, and crosstabs head, torso, and forearms. Boxers use gloves to reduce the were created for each question using a χ2 test and Fisher’s risk of injury to their opponents8, 10–13). Conversely, direct exact test. In accordance with the terms of Resolution 5-1- striking is not permitted in non-strike sports, so players do 20, December 2006, the protocol for the study was approved not generally wear protective equipment. Different rules ap- by the Committee of Ethics in Research of the University ply in judo, wrestling, and ssireum, and the common goal of of Yongin. Furthermore, all volunteers provided informed these sports is to overpower an opponent through force and consent for participation in the study7, 8, 10). skill7, 14–16). Every combat sports event has physical or injury characteristics based on the combat method, rules, and skills RESULTS used. Even within the same sport, there are differences ac- cording to playing style17–20). Combat sports are the focus The general characteristics of the participants are de- of much attention worldwide, and for this reason, there is a scribed in Table 1. All combat athletes had experienced mus- wealth of research available regarding the injuries sustained culoskeletal injuries except for one kendo athlete (Table 2). by combat athletes in various competitions. These data are Skin injuries were most frequent among wrestlers in the case typically classified according to event, injured body part, of non-strike sports and among boxers in the case of strike and the epidemiology of the injury. However, little research sports. There was a high incidence of nerve injuries such as has been carried out on the playing style of combat athletes, neuralgia among the non-strike athletes; however, this was especially in strike and non-strike sports. Our study aims not statistically significant (Table 2). Tooth injuries were the to describe the characteristics of injuries sustained in strike most infrequent type in both groups. The order of frequency and non-strike combat sports so that the data can be used in with regard to injury types was musculoskeletal injuries fol- sports physiotherapy. lowed by skin, nerve, and tooth injuries in both groups (Table 2). In terms of musculoskeletal injuries, dislocation was the SUBJECTS AND METHODS most frequent injury in non-strike athletes, and the differ- ence between the groups was significant. Fracture was most This study was conducted on 159 athletes in various common in the taekwondo athletes, followed by the boxers combat sports. The participants included elite college play- and judo athletes (Table 3). There was a higher incidence of ers of the following sports: judo (47), ssireum (19), wrestling ligament rupture among the ssireum athletes than among ath- (13), kendo (30), boxing (16), and taekwondo (34). Of the letes of any other sport. Judo athletes were the second most participants, 133 were male and 26 were female. In the case affected group, followed by taekwondo athletes. Although of ssireum and boxing, all of the athletes were male. The the non-strike sports showed a higher incidence of ligament volunteers had no physical or psychological conditions, and rupture than the strike sports, the difference was not statisti- all of them provided informed written consent to participa- cally significant (Table 2). Muscle injury frequency was tion in this study. For the purposes of the study, we divided highest in the taekwondo athletes. Over half of all the athletes the participants into two groups according to playing style: had experienced sprains, strains, and bruising, and most of strike sports and non-strike sports. Kendo, boxing, and tae- the wrestlers had been injured in this way. The incidence of kwondo are strike sports, while judo, ssireum, and wrestling bruising was high in both the strike and the non-strike sports.