Speaker and Authority in Old Norse Wisdom Poetry Brittany
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Apollo ‘How Can His Word Be Trusted?’: Speaker and Authority in Old Norse Wisdom Poetry Brittany Erin Schorn Corpus Christi College University of Cambridge This dissertation is submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Declarations This dissertation is the result of my own work and includes nothing which is the outcome of work done in collaboration except where specifically indicated in the text. The dissertation does not exceed the regulation length, including footnotes and references, but excluding the bibliography. This dissertation is written in conformance with the ASNC style-sheet. Brittany Erin Schorn Brittany Erin Schorn ‘How Can His Word Be Trusted?’: Speaker and Authority in Old Norse Wisdom Poetry ABSTRACT In the eddic poem Hávamál, the god Óðinn gives advice, including a warning about the fickleness of human, and divine, nature. He cites his own flagrant deception of giants who trusted him in order to win the mead of poetry as evidence for this deep-seated capacity for deceit, asking of himself: ‘how can his word be trusted?’ This is an intriguing question to ask in a poem purporting to relate the wisdom of Óðinn, and it is a concern repeatedly voiced in regard to him and other speakers in the elaborate narrative frames of the Old Norse wisdom poems. The exchange of wisdom in poetic texts such as this is no simple matter. Wisdom is conceived of as a body of knowledge, experience and observation that binds together all aspects of human life, the natural world and the supernatural realms. But its application depended heavily on the way in which it was passed on and interpreted. This dissertation examines the ways that these poems reflect on the interpretation and value of their own contents as a function of the particular speaker and circumstances of each wisdom exchange. The texts which form the foundation of this enquiry are the so-called eddic poems: alliterative verses largely preserved within a single manuscript of the thirteenth century, though many are arguably of much earlier date. About a dozen of the surviving poems might be classed, however tentatively, as concerning wisdom, though the route to this classification is not straightforward. Definition of this corpus, and of the genre of wisdom literature more widely, is thus the principal aim of the introductory Chapter I, while Chapter II expands on the question of material and methodology by scrutinizing the idea of wisdom in general within Old Norse. Crucial here is an examination of the terms used for wisdom and associated concepts, which suggest an antagonistic view of how knowledge might pass from one person to another. Close readings of the text and sensitivity to the manuscript context of each poem, as well as consideration of the significance of their potential oral prehistory and awareness of comparable literatures from other contexts, are established here as the dominant mode of analysis. Observations derived from the interpretation of comparable literatures also inform my approach. With a grounding in wisdom literature more generally and with the salient concepts relating to knowledge transfer thus established, I go on to examine specific points and groups within the body of eddic wisdom poetry which shed light on the evolving interpretation of wisdom exchange. An important case-study analyzed in this way in Chapter III is perhaps the most complex: Hávamál itself, a famous but notoriously problematic text probably reflecting multiple layers of composition. It is at the heart of the question of how mankind relates to supernatural beings – a relationship which could be particularly fraught where the transmission of wisdom occurred. Thus this chapter also contains analysis of terminology for men, gods and other supernatural beings which sheds light on the relationships between the human and the divine. Chapter IV expands on these issues to consider three paradigms of mythological wisdom instruction which bridge different worlds, human and supernatural, or between different supernatural domains: poems in which Óðinn dispenses wisdom; those in which he acquires it from a contest with another living being; and those in which he acquires it from the dead through sacrifice and magical ability. These chapters establish the ‘traditional’ form of wisdom exchange as defined through eddic verses that adopt a broadly pre- or non-Christian setting. Yet eddic verse-forms did not die out with conversion, and in some cases were exploited for new compositions written from an explicitly Christian perspective or with parodic intent. These poems, discussed in Chapter V, cast an important sidelight onto the associations of eddic verse as a medium for conveying information of complicated or questionable authority. The concluding Chapter VI then addresses questions of what we may deduce from the preceding chapters about evolving cultural attitudes towards wisdom, authority and truth in medieval Iceland. CONTENTS Declarations i Summary ii Contents iii List of Tables v Acknowledgements vi Chapter I: Introduction 1 Wisdom and Wisdom Literature 1 Scholarship and Definition of Corpus 6 Aims and Methodology 13 Chapter II: Gáttir allar, áðr gangi fram, um scoðask scyli: Approaching Wisdom in Eddic Poetry 15 Defining Wisdom in Old Norse 15 The Genres of Eddic Poetry 18 The Genre of Eddic Wisdom Poetry 26 The Expression of Wisdom in Eddic Poetry 29 Conclusion 33 Chapter III: Mankind and the Gods in Eddic Verse 34 Introduction: the Old Norse Gods in Context 34 Words for Men, Gods and Others 37 The treatment of mythological figures in eddic diction 38 The treatment of mythological figures in skaldic diction 47 The treatment of the Christian God in skaldic diction 52 Case-Study: Hávamál 57 Arrangement and interpretation 57 Speaker and identity in Hávamál 61 The first person 64 The second person 68 Odinic discourse and the unity of Hávamál 73 Conclusion 77 Chapter IV: Speaker and Situation in the Mythological Frames of Wisdom Poetry 80 Óðinn and the Acquisition of Wisdom 81 Acquiring Wisdom from the Dead 90 Óðinn Dispensing Wisdom 97 Conclusion 109 Chapter V: Traditional Forms and Christian Authority 110 Introduction 110 Wisdom and Romance: Málsháttakvæði 113 Sólarljóð 117 Hugsvinnsmál 126 Alvíssmál and Svipdagsmál 134 Conclusion 139 Chapter VI: Conclusion 141 The Uses of Wisdom in Eddic Verse 142 The re-use of wisdom 143 The Limits of the Eddic Wisdom Genre 145 Oral and literate features of eddic wisdom poetry 148 Narration and prose 150 Wisdom beyond the Edda, and Situational Authority beyond Wisdom 153 Wisdom and skaldic verse 155 Eddic memorial poems 156 Myth and narrative in Þórsdrápa 159 The Authority and Subjectivity of Wisdom 160 Abbreviations 165 Bibliography 166 iv List of Tables Table 1: Distribution of first- and second-person pronouns in Hávamál. 63 Table 2: Riddle Solutions in the H and R redactions of Hervarar saga. 107 v Acknowledgements I have been fortunate over the course of preparing this dissertation, and indeed the whole of my university career during the last eight years, to be working in the supportive and stimulating environment of the Department of Anglo-Saxon, Norse and Celtic. First and foremost, I owe the deepest debt to Judy Quinn, who has been an inspiring teacher and a patient and encouraging supervisor. Richard Dance and Elizabeth Ashman Rowe have aided my work through their comments on seminar papers and particular sections of the dissertation, as well as many useful conversations. I have also received helpful advice from Máire Ní Mhaonaigh and Simon Keynes, who served as examiners for my registration as a PhD candidate; and Fiona Edmonds, my PhD advisor. Alongside the senior members of the department, my fellow postgraduate students have given me a stimulating and congenial environment in which to work, as well as important feedback on and discussion of particular sections of my work. These include in particular Eleanor Barraclough, Debbie Potts and Matthias Ammon, who have provided valuable comments on aspects of my work presented as papers; and Jennie Doolan and Jeff Love, who have allowed me access to their own doctoral dissertations. Beyond the department, my work has also benefitted tremendously from the counsel and comments of Chris Abram, and especially Carolyne Larrington and Bernt Øyvind Thorvaldsen, who have both allowed me access to unpublished material. I am also indebted to Erin Goeres for allowing me to read her doctoral dissertation. Corpus Christi College has provided me with a lively scholarly community and a home, as well as financial support to facilitate my research. My work has also been financially aided by the Cambridge Overseas Trusts, the Scandinavian Studies fund and the English Faculty of the University of Cambridge. It is a cliché to say that I have received great support and that all remaining mistakes herein are entirely my own, but I feel that no one has ever meant it more honestly and earnestly than I do here. Equally obvious and utterly true is that in this, as in all things, my greatest and most indispensible support has come from my husband, Rory Naismith. I Introduction This dissertation concerns the presentation of compilations of wisdom in Old Norse eddic poetry: how it was that the dozen poems one might classify, however tentatively, as wisdom poetry legitimized and put across their content. The poems include diverse scenes of interaction between men, gods and other supernatural beings, often of an antagonistic or confrontational nature, inviting the question of how audiences satisfied themselves of the answer to the speaker‘s own challenge: ‗how can his word be trusted?‘ WISDOM AND WISDOM LITERATURE The impulse to collect wisdom – the crystallized, condensed knowledge of life, the universe and everything employed by numerous societies to pass on and validate valued information – appears to be virtually universal.