Cluster Approach to Organization of Special Economic Zones in Russia and Kazakhstan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
R-ECONOMY, 2019, 5(2), 71–78 doi: 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 Original Paper doi 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 Cluster approach to organization of special economic zones in Russia and Kazakhstan I. D. Turgel1, L. L. Bozhko2 , E. G. Zinovieva3 1 Ural Federal University, Ekaterinburg, Russia 2 Rudny Industrial Institute, Rudny, Kazakhstan; e-mail: [email protected] 3 Magnitogorsk State Technical University n.a. G. I. Nosov, Magnitogorsk, Russia ABSTRACT KEYWORDS The article aims to study the theoretical and empirical foundations of combin- economic regulation, special ing free economic zones with industrial clusters. The theoretical foundation is economic zones, cluster approach, provided by the concept of a cumulative and circular process and the theory of industrial cluster, Kazakhstan, “new economic geography”. The empirical part deals with the creation of clus- Russia ter-type economic zones in Russia and Kazakhstan. The symbiosis of special economic zones (SEZs) and clusters is expected to enhance export potential and act as a powerful catalyst for national innovative development. Establish- ment of clusters within the framework of the existing SEZs can bring to these zones highly efficient projects for manufacturing export-oriented products. Methodologically, the research relies on systemic and structural-functional approaches, the logical method and the method of formalization as well as on FOR CITATION the comparative and grouping methods applied to analyze SEZs. The study also Turgel, I. D., Bozhko, L. L., & provides a general overview of the SEZs and clusters operating in Russia and Zinovieva, E. G. (2019) Kazakhstan and indicates their main types and characteristics. The practical Cluster approach to organization significance of this research is that its findings can be used to devise recom- of special economic zones mendations for improving economic performance of both countries, attracting in Russia and Kazakhstan. new technologies and investments and addressing social and economic prob- R-economy, 5(2), 71–78. lems of the regions. doi: 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 Кластерный подход к организации особых экономических зон в России и Казахстане И. Д. Тургель1, Л. Л. Божко2 , Е. Г. Зиновьева3 1 Уральский федеральный университет, Екатеринбург, Россия 2 Рудненский индустриальный институт, Рудный, Казахстан; e-mail: [email protected] 3 Магнитогорский государственный технический университет им. Г. И. Носова, Магнитогорск, Россия АННОТАЦИЯ КЛЮЧЕВЫЕ СЛОВА Целью статьи является изучение теоретических и эмпирических основ экономическое регулирование, объединения свободных экономических зон с промышленными класте- особые экономические рами. Теоретическая основа обеспечивается концепцией кумулятивного зоны, кластерный подход, и кругового процесса и теорией «новой экономической географии». Эм- промышленный кластер, пирическая часть посвящена созданию экономических зон кластерного Казахстан, Россия типа в России и Казахстане. Ожидается, что симбиоз особых экономиче- ских зон (ОЭЗ) и кластеров усилит экспортный потенциал и станет мощ- ным катализатором национального инновационного развития. Создание кластеров в рамках существующих ОЭЗ может принести в эти зоны вы- сокоэффективные проекты по производству экспортно-ориентирован- ной продукции. Методологически исследование опирается на системный и структурно-функциональный подходы, логический метод и метод фор- ДЛЯ ЦИТИРОВАНИЯ мализации, а также на сравнительный и групповой методы, применяемые для анализа ОЭЗ. В исследовании также приводится общий обзор ОЭЗ Turgel, I. D., Bozhko, L. L., & и кластеров, фунционирующих в России и Казахстане, и указываются их Zinovieva, E. G. (2019) основные типы и характеристики. Практическая значимость этого иссле- Cluster approach to organization дования заключается в том, что его результаты могут быть использованы of special economic zones для разработки рекомендаций по улучшению экономических показателей in Russia and Kazakhstan. обеих стран, привлечению новых технологий и инвестиций и решению R-economy, 5(2), 71–78. социальных и экономических проблем регионов. doi: 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 © I. D. Turgel, L. L. Bozhko, E. G. Zinovieva, 2019 71 www.r-economy.ru Online ISSN 2412-0731 R-ECONOMY, 2019, 5(2), 71–78 doi: 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 Introduction Methodology The Russian Federation and the Republic of Most studies of the available international Kazakhstan are united by a common history, con- experience of SEZs and the possibilities of their ditions of economic development, cultural tradi- use in Russia and Kazakhstan were conducted af- tions and geographical boundaries. Similarity of ter 1990 [1–10]. The cluster approach, which has initial characteristics of the national socio-eco- been actively developing since the 1990s, offers nomic and political systems determines the com- considerable opportunities of modernizing SEZs. monality of the key tasks both countries have to The cluster theory was introduced and popular- address. One of the main priorities for both coun- ized by Nobel laureate Michael Porter, who iden- tries is diversification of economy, stimulation of tified such key features of clusters as territorial innovations and attraction of investments. In his specialization, competition and cooperation [11]. message to the Federal Assembly in 2018, Russian Alfred Marshall laid the foundations of the President Vladimir Putin pointed out that to en- geographical clustering theory of firms [12]. Ac- sure a further structural change of national econ- cording to Marshall, the geographical proximity omy and to enhance its competitiveness it is nec- of firms (“industrial district”) creates external essary to use the available “sources of growth” at a effects (“benefits of agglomeration (or localiza- fundamentally different level. These include labor tion)”), which stem from the unification of the la- productivity, increased investment and develop- bor market, flow of knowledge, and specialization. ment of non-commodity exports1. The message of Firms within Marshallian industrial districts gain President Nursultan Nazarbayev to the people of advantages in the form of access to specialized hu- Kazakhstan emphasizes that the fourth industrial man resources and skills, lower costs, knowledge revolution requires profound technological, eco- transfer and increased productivity. Porter em- nomic and social changes as well as new manage- phasizes the role of these advantages in increas- ment tools2. ing productivity and competitiveness of firms, Therefore, in both countries, there is a need regions and countries in their theory of industrial for full support of regional development and clus- clusters. Porter puts the main emphasis on “com- ter initiatives in the form of various legislative, ad- petitiveness” (of firms, industries, regions and ministrative, managerial and financial-economic countries) in global economy. Openness of firms measures. In this respect, the key institutional and industries to foreign competition is consid- link between these measures may become zones ered as a driving force for formation and develop- with special conditions for economic activity or ment of the cluster. The concept of SEZs has much special economic zones (SEZs). Such zones make in common with Porter’s concept of clusters. it possible, on the one hand, to make the econo- Theoretical foundations of the cluster ap- my more open, guarantee economic security and proach in organization of SEZs are described stimulate economic growth on the regional level. by D. Peter [13], M. Amiti, B. S. Javorcik [14], On the other hand, it gives new impulses to ter- J. A. Mathews [15], and P. R. Krugman [16] (see ritorial economic systems, activates development Table 1). potential of territorial clusters and enables the The heterodox approach ignores the role of government to launch new large-scale projects agglomeration savings, suggesting that free eco- using positive effects of scale. nomic zones themselves provide a platform for Taking into account the above-mentioned attracting export-oriented foreign direct invest- considerations, in this article we are going to com- ment, creating a favorable investment climate. pare the experience of creating and SEZs in Russia Therefore, there is no need to combine it with and Kazakhstan, including the peculiar character- clusters. istics of such zones and mechanisms of their op- SEZs are, in fact, geographically concentrated, eration. state-supported agglomerations of internationally We compared zones with special conditions competitive enterprises. They have a number of of economic activity by applying the cluster ap- advantages such as efficient infrastructure, favor- proach and providing recommendations as to able business environment, few regulatory restric- how adjust the priorities for SEZs in order to fos- tions and a minimum of bureaucracy. The role of ter knowledge-intensive economy and to stimu- SEZs in shaping the savings from agglomeration late the development of high-tech industries and and its advantages is ignored in the existing lit- services. erature largely due to the assumption that SEZs 72 www.r-economy.ru Online ISSN 2412-0731 R-ECONOMY, 2019, 5(2), 71–78 doi: 10.15826/recon.2019.5.2.008 Table 1 Theoretical foundations of the cluster approach in organization of special economic zones Approaches, concepts and theories Description Heterodox approach The heterodox approach ignores the role of agglomeration savings, suggesting that (M. Amiti, B. S. Javorcik) the free economic zones provide a platform for attracting