(RMP) Malaysia by Shamsul
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Use of Choice Modelling in Assessing Tourists Destinations: A Case Study of Redang Marine Park (RMP) Malaysia by Shamsul Bahrain Rawi BSc. Economics, San Jose State University, California MSc. Economics and Social Policy Analysis, University of York A thesis submitted to the Newcastle University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Architecture, Planning and Landscape June 2012 ABSTRACT This study employs the Choice Modelling (CM) Technique, in particular the Contingent Ranking (CR) method, to measure the economic value of the Redang Marine Park (RMP) system in Malaysia. The reason for using CR is to understand which islands in the RMP system the tourists prefer. Knowing the islands’ ranking is crucial for the planning and development of this particular island as a tourism product and destination, and at the same time, for maintaining the islands’ ecosystem as a protected area. The study is divided into three major components. The first investigates destination choices amongst tourists. In this component, the attributes of interest include choices of island, types of accommodation available at the destination, facilities provided at the place of accommodation, distance of accommodation sites to the beach, and types of transportation used to reach the destination. These attributes are measured using the 3-day/2-night (3D2N) package prices offered as holiday packages to tourists. The second component measures the importance of environmental attributes, namely the status of available fish and coral species, the numbers of nesting turtles and the degree of congestion that the tourists experience while participating in water activities such as snorkelling and diving. These attributes are measured through the conservation fees collected by the park authority from tourists visiting RMP. The final part of this study is concerned with the members of local community on the island. Their perceptions towards tourism, their readiness to participate in tourism activities and their attitudes towards MP development are issues explored in this study. A total of 189 local tourists and 94 foreign tourists were interviewed in this CR study, while 200 local residents were interviewed in the community study. This study finds that, in terms of the choice of destination, different islands do matter and are statistically significant for both local and foreign tourists. In terms of overall ranking, both local and foreign tourists rank Kapas as their first choice, while Tenggol ranks last. The main attributes in the destination choice are statistically significant for local and foreign tourists, except for facilities provided at the sites of accommodation. WTP for almost all attributes concerned are higher for local tourists than for foreign ones, except for the reduction in distance between the accommodation sites and the beach. Specifically, the improvement in terms of types of accommodation ranges from RM113.33 to RM205.50 for local tourists and RM136.50 to RM169.71 for foreign tourists. WTP for improved travel time from the mainland to the island ranges from RM0.43 to RM1.75 for the domestic tourists, as opposed to the values given by foreign tourists, ranging from RM0.29 to RM1.50. WTP for the option of accommodation situated closer to beach areas ranges from RM3.14 to RM11.25 for local tourists. These values are lower than WTP given by foreign tourists, which range from RM10.55 to RM15.57. Further analyses on marginal WTP are also discussed. Regarding environmental issues, this study finds that all attributes are statistically significant for both local and foreign tourists. The local tourists’ WTP for changes in the number of fish and coral species ranges between RM4.31 to RM6.70, while foreign tourists’ WTP ranges between RM3.50 to RM6.73. As for the number of nesting turtles, locals are willing to pay between RM3.78 and RM4.76 while foreign tourists are willing to pay between RM2.28 and RM4.14 for different attribute levels. Finally to avoid congestion while participating in the water activities, WTP by locals ranges between RM2.80 to RM13.37, and WTP amongst i foreign tourists ranges from RM1.99 to RM11.37. Similar to the destination choice, further analyses on marginal WTP are also discussed. Regarding the local community, this study deduces that community members perceive the tourism industry positively and are willing to participate in tourism-related activities. However, they have some reservations surrounding the presence of tourists in their village, based on social and religious grounds. Their attitudes toward the development of the MP are also positive. Finally this study highlights the economic potentials that players in the tourism industry may tap and capitalize upon, mainly through practising pricing mechanisms in selling and promoting holiday packages in RMP. To the park managers and local authorities, this study may suggest some guidelines for future development processes. Such processes should consider selective development as an option while safeguarding the natural beauty of RMP. The possibility of revising the current conservation fee to resemble tourists’ WTP is also highlighted in this study. Finally, the study recommends the implementation of price discrimination and peak-load pricing in charging and collecting conservation fees as methods, not only for the purposes of increasing revenue but also for acting as tools to monitor and control the number of tourists to RMP. Keywords: Economic Valuation, Stated Preferences Technique, Contingent Ranking Method, Ordinal Regression, Marine Parks, Sustainable Development. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Completing this thesis would not have been possible without a number of people who throughout the period of this research offered their unfailing support. I would like to express my gratitude to Prof. K.G. Willis for his excellent supervision and guidance, encouragement and faith in me in completing the thesis. My special thanks to Mr. Abdul Rahim Gor Yaman and the staffs at the Department of Marine Park Malaysia for all their helps in providing data, technical information and logistic support at RMP throughout the study. I also wish to thank all my friends especially Muszafarshah, Dr. Bakti and Dr. Nor Azam for sharing their constructive advices and comments. To others not mentioned here, thank you for your support and encouragement. Thanks also go to Marian Kyte and Carole Allan for your assistance with University bureaucracy. I would also like to extend my thanks to the Government of Malaysia and Universiti Utara Malaysia for providing funding and opportunity to do this research. To my loving wife, Hamimi Omar, thank you so much for your patience, support, encouragement and understanding in enduring this journey together. Although throughout these past years, you were also working on your doctorate, you were always there when most needed. You have made it possible for all of us to sustain the hardships and difficulties throughout the whole period. You are the best. My hugs and kisses to my children, Anis Farhana, Anis Fatini and Amirul Bahrain, who braced themselves with all the challenges abroad. May this piece of work be the inspiration for your knowledge quest in the future. Finally, to my parents, Hj. Rawi Abdul Rahman and Hjh. Zubaidah Dahlan, brothers and sisters, thank you for your continuous prayers and support. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iii TABLE OF CONTENTS iv LIST OF TABLES x LIST OF FIGURES xv LIST OF MAPS xv LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xvi Chapter 1: Introduction 1 1.0 Background 1 1.1 Issues Surrounding MPA and MP and Island Tourism in Malaysia 3 1.2 Purpose of the Study 6 1.3 Significance of the Study 8 1.4 Limitation of the Study 10 1.5 Organization of the Study 11 Chapter 2: Marine Park And Conservation 14 2.0 Introduction 14 2.1 Marine Conservation in General 14 2.2 Definition and Objectives of MPAs 16 2.3 Historical Perspective 19 2.4 The Benefits of MPA 21 2.5 Tourism Development and Conservation Conflict 22 2.5.1 Pricing strategy - price discrimination and consumer surplus 25 2.6 Development of Marine Parks in Malaysia 27 2.6.1 Fisheries protected area 27 2.6.2 Marine park order 28 2.7 Definition and Objectives of MPs 30 2.8 MPs Administration and Management 31 2.9 Sustainable Tourism Development in MP 36 2.10 Conclusion 38 iv Chapter 3: Redang Marine Park 39 3.0 Introduction 39 3.1 Geography 39 3.2 Establishment of RMP 42 3.3 Local Community in Pulau Redang 45 3.4 Infrastructure 46 3.5 Natural Resources of RMP 48 3.6 Tourism at RMP 50 3.7 Environmental Quality and Threats 53 3.8 Current Issues in RMP 57 3.9 Conclusion 59 Chapter 4: Valuation Of The Non-Market Goods 60 4.0 Introduction 60 4.1 The Need for Environmental Valuation 60 4.2 Economic Value 61 4.3 Approaches to Valuation 66 4.4 Stated Preference Techniques 67 4.5 Some Related Studies using CR 70 4.6 Applications of CR in Malaysia 71 4.7 Conclusion 72 Chapter 5: Contingent Ranking - Theory And Methodology 73 5.0 Introduction 73 5.1 Theories in Contingent Ranking 73 5.2 Some Issues in Contingent Ranking 77 5.3 Empirical Specification 81 5.3.1 Destination choice 82 5.3.2 Environmental concerns 85 5.4 Analyzing CR Data 86 5.5 Conclusion 89 Chapter 6: Sampling, Questionnaire Design And Surveys 90 6.0 Introduction 90 6.1 Population and Sample 90 v 6.1.1 Population 90 6.1.2 Sample 91 6.1.3 Location 91 6.1.4 Survey modes 92 6.2 Questionnaire Design 93 6.2.1 Validity 97 6.2.2 Reliability 99 6.3 Survey Instruments 100 6.4 The Survey Process 109 6.4.1 Pilot study 109 6.4.2 First phase