Central Administrative Tribunal Hyderabad Bench Hyderabad
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL HYDERABAD BENCH HYDERABAD OA/20/1162/2013 & MA/20/181/2014, OA/20/233/2018 & MA/20/319/2018, OA/20/274/2018 & MAs 291 & 309/2018, OA/20/303/2018, OA/20/323/2018, OA/21/395/2018, OA/21/434/2018 & MA/21/863/2018, OA/20/885/2018, OA/21/921/2018 & MA 618/2018, OA/21/68/2017& MA 327/2017, OA/21/170/2017,OA/20/230/2017, OA/20/588/2017 & MA/20/696/2017, OA/20/607/2017 & MAs 635/2017 & 159/2018, OA/21/610/2017, OA/21/621/2017, OA/20/638/2017, OA/21/685/2017, OA/21/716/2017, OA/20/740/2017, OA/21/742/2017, OA/20/816/2017, OA/20/892/2017, OA/20/966/2017, OA/20/1032/2017, OA/20/1034/2017, OA/20/1047/2017, OA/21/1093/2017, OA/20/1138/2017, MA/21/1/2016 (OASR 7778/ 2015), OA/20/59/2016, MAs 1083 & 878/2016, OA/21/61/2016 & MAs 69, 88, 1072 & 1154/2016, OA/21/62/2016, OA/21/63/2016, OA/21/64/2016, OA/21/65/2016, OA/21/66/2016, OA/21/67/2016, OA/21/68/2016, OA/21/69/2016, OA/21/70/2016, OA/21/71/2016, OA/21/72/2016, OA/21/73/2016, OA/21/74/2016, OA/20/91/2016 & MA/20/183/2016, OA/20/92/2016, OA/20/144/2016 & MA/21/1071/2016, OA/21/173/2016 & MAs 883/2016 & 732/2017, MA/20/254/2016 in OASR 1295/2016, OA/20/291/2016 & MA 167/2017, OA/20/361/2016 & MA/20/978/2016, OA/21/440/2016, OA/20/538/2016, OA/20/596/2016 & MA 628/2017, OA/20/606/2016 & MA 488/2017, OA/20/644/2016, OA/20/645/2016 & MA 534/2017, OA/20/840/2016, OA/20/1119/2016, OA/20/1123/2016, OA/21/24/2015 & MAs 389/2016 & 107/2017, OA/21/25/2015 & MAs 392/2016, 106/2017, OA/21/30/2015 & MA 108/2017, OA/20/54/2015, OA/21/64/2015, OA/21/65/2015 & MAs 394/2016 & 109/2017, OA/20/251/2015, OA/21/405/2015 & MAs 456/2016, 633/2015 & 35/2015, OA/20/462/2015 &MA 281/2016, OA/21/512/2015 & MAs1095, 1093, 1094, 882/2016 & 629/2015, OA/21/640/2015 & MA/21//474/2016, OA/20/828/2015 & MA/20/824/2015, OA/20/936/2015, OA/20/954/2015 & MA 282/2016, OA/21/959/2015, OA/21/1048/2015, OA/20/1059/2015 & MAs 510/2016, 916, 917 & 744/2015, OA/20/1163/2015 & MA 509/2015, OA/21/1197/2015, OA/20/1219/2015 & MAs 1064, 501 & 894/2016, OA/20/1349/2015, OA/20/1359/2015, OA/20/1391/2015, OA/20/1472/2015, OA/20/1660/2015, OA/20/1661/2015, OA/20/1662/2015, OA/20/1663/2015, OA/20/1664/2015, OA/20/1665/2015, OA/20/1763/2015 & MA 180/2016, OA/20/1764/2015, OA/20/1765/2015, OA/20/1766/2015, OA/20/1767/2015, OA/20/1768/2015, OA/20/1769/2015, OA/20/1849/2015 & MA 241/2016, OA/20/1850/2015, OA/20/1851/2015, OA/20/301/2014, OA/20/447/2014, OA/20/518/2014 & MA 482/2017,OA/20/521/2014 & MA 630/2014, OA/20/891/2014 & MA 815/2015, OA/20/1261/2014,OA/20/1432/2014,OA/20/277/2013,OA/21/1210/2013,OA/20/1246/2013, OA/20/1342/2013, OA/20/1400/2013 & MAs 245 & 244/2014,OA/20/1499/2013, OA/20/612/2012 & MA 263/2013, OA/20/614/2012 & OA/20/741/2011 Orders Reserved On: 27/12/2018 & 01/01/2019 Date of Order : 11.01.2019 Between: OA/20/1162/2013 1. Sunkara Radhakrishna, S/o. S. Prabhakar, aged 35 years 2. Katuri Ramesh Babu, S/o. K. Sivaiah, aged 28 years 3. K. Venkat Rao, S/o. K. Satyam Naidu, aged 39 years 4. P. Shankar, S/o. Venkateswarlu, aged 33 years 5. R.V. Sridhar Kumar, S/o. R. Srinivasa Rao, aged 39 years 6. Reddy Ramakrishna, S/o. Reddy Suryanarayana, aged 29 years 7. Bandaru Panduranga Rao, S/o. Nageswara Rao, aged 31 years 8. Siva Prasad Jampani, S/o. J. Subbaiah, aged 27 years ... Applicants (All the applicants are working as Senior Assistant Loco Pilots under the control of the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada R.S) And 1. Union of India rep. by the Secretary (Establishment), Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhavan, Railway Board, New Delhi. 2. The General Manager, South Central Railway, Rail Nilayam, Secunderabad. 3. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, South Central Railway, Vijayawada Division,Vijayawada. 4. K. Mohan Raju, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada. 5. Bhukya Srinivasa Rao, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada. 6. P. Vijaya Raju, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada. 7. G. Vijayaratnam, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Rajahmundry. 8. Sindhe Hari Kishore, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada. 9. Ravi Peravali, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Vijayawada. 10.V. Kishore Babu, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Rajahmundry. 11.Allam Anjaneyulu, Occ: Sr. Asst. Loco Pilot, O/o the Chief Crew Controller, South Central Railway, Bitragunta. ... Respondents Counsel for the applicants ... Mr. K.R.K.V. Prasad Counsel for the respondents ... Mrs. Vijaya Sagi, SC for Railways Mrs. S. Siva Kumari for private respondents O.A.No.020 / 233 of 2018 1. V.V.Uday Kumar, S/o late V.S.Narayana, Aged 43 years, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 2. H.Visweswara Rao, S/o late Nandaiah, Aged 43 years, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 3. K.Srinivasa Rao, S/o late K.Satyam, Aged 46 years, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 4. V.Satyanarayana, S/o Sanyasaiah, Aged 45 years, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 5. B.V.S.S.N.Murthy, S/o late B.Janaki Rama Rao, Aged 47 years, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. …Applicants And 1. Union of India represented by The Chairman, Ministry of Railways, Railway Board, Rail Bhavan, New Delhi. 2. The General Manager, East Coast Railway, Rail Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar-751 017. 3. The Chief Personnel Officer (Administration), East Coast Railway, Rail Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar-751 017. 4. The Divisional Railway Manager, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Visakhapatnam. 5. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Visakhapatnam. 6. Mukesh Chand Meena, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Rayagada R.S., Orissa State. 7. G.Pundarikakasha, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Rayagada R.S., Orissa State. 8. T.Ravi Kumar, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 9. R.Vara Prasad Rao, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 10. G.Venkata Rao, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 11. S.Venkata Rao, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. 12. G.Appala Swamy, Occ: Senior Passenger Guard, O/o The Chief Station Manager, Waltair Marshalling Yard, East Coast Railway, Visakhapatnam R.S. …Respondents Counsel for the applicants ... Mr. K.R.K.V. Prasad Counsel for the respondents ... Mr. S.M. Patnaik, SC for Rlys. Mr. G. Jaya Prakash Babu O.A.No.020 / 274 of 2018 1. C.Srinivas Achary, S/o C.Appa Rao Achary, Aged 49 years, Occ: Loco Pilot (Goods), O/o The Chief Traction Crew Controller, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Behind DLS, DYD Yard, Visakhapatnam. 2. Ch.Jagadish, S/o Ch.Appa Rao, Aged 49 years, Occ: Loco Pilot (Goods), O/o The Chief Traction Crew Controller, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Behind DLS, DYD Yard, Visakhapatnam. 3. Xavier, S/o A.D.Vareed, aged 48 years, Occ: Loco Pilot (Goods), O/o The Chief Traction Crew Controller, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Behind DLS, DYD Yard, Visakhapatnam. 4. U.Ramesh, S/o Prabhakar Rao, Aged 49 years, Occ: Loco Pilot (Goods), O/o The Chief Traction Crew Controller, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Behind DLS, DYD Yard, Visakhapatnam. …Applicants And 1. Union of India represented by The Chairman, Ministry of Railways, Railway Board, Rail Bhavan, New Delhi. 2. The General Manager, East Coast Railway, Rail Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar-751 017. 3. The Chief Personnel Officer (Administration), East Coast Railway, Rail Sadan, Chandrasekharpur, Bhubaneswar-751 017. 4. The Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, East Coast Railway, Waltair Division, Visakhapatnam.