Gansu Roads Development Project External Monitoring Report on Land Acquisition and Resettlement (IV)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Social Monitoring Report Project Number: 33470 February 2008 PRC: Gansu Roads Development Project External Monitoring Report on Land Acquisition and Resettlement (IV) Prepared by: School of Economic and Management, Tongji University, People’s Republic of China For Gansu Changda Highway Co., Ltd. This report has been submitted to ADB by Gansu Changda Highway Co., Ltd. and is made publicly available in accordance with ADB’s public communications policy (2005). It does not necessarily reflect the views of ADB. SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT GANSU ROADS DEVELOPMENT PROJECT FINANCED BY ADB (LOAN NO.:2125-PRC) February 2008 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT ON RESETTLEMENT (NO. 4) GANSU ROADS DEVELOPMENT PROJECT FINANCED BY ADB (LOAN NO.:2125-PRC) By School of Economics and Management Tongji University February 2008 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT Report Director: Wu Zongfa Report Co-compiler: Wu Zongfa, Hao Zhujie, Yang Wei, Hu Xiaobo E-mail: [email protected] SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT CONTENTS 1 SCOPE AND APPROACH OF THE FOURTH SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION........... 1 2RESETTLEMENT FUND AND PROGRESS ........................................................................ 1 3 LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT IN JINGCHUAN COUNTY.......................... 1 4 LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT IN KONGTONG COUNTY.......................... 3 5 LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT IN JINGNING COUNTY.............................. 6 6 LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT IN HUINING COUNTY................................ 9 7 LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT IN ANDING COUNTY............................... 12 8 PER CAPITA INCOME CHANGE IN SAMPLE VILLAGE.................................................. 15 9 CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION ................................................................................. 16 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT I. 1 SCOPE AND APPROACH OF THE FOURTH SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION The fourth supervision and evaluation was taken between December, 2007 by the supervision and evaluation team. The main approaches are data research, keyman interview, field survey, and so on. The emphases of this report are the resettlement progress, resettlement fund distribution, resettlement policy, institutional arrangement of the resettlement, and to evaluate the resettlement effect by interviewing affected people and resettlement cadres and field survey. II. 2RESETTLEMENT FUND AND PROGRESS Resettlement of Gansu Luoding expressway project had been completed in the mass by December 31th, 2007 .Project construction is under way and orderly. Gansu Land&Resource Department would distribute the land acquisition fee to each county. Then affected people get their land compensation from each county according to related policy. Resettlement fund payment met this project’s demand. Because the fragmentary land acquisition is ongoing uninterruptedly in the progress of the construction, so the land acquiristion compensation and the quantity of land occupied changes continually. Changda Road Co., Ltd of Gansu Transportation Department has signed implementation agreement with each affected county’s people government about compensation for demolished houses and other attachments. Each county distributes compensation fee for demolished houses and other attachments to affected households. Resettlement fund of 736,221,200RMB has been distributed. Information about resettlement fund is shown in table 1. Land acquisition had been completed by Janauary 31. 18,799 mu land has been acquired, the status of land acquisition and new house construction progress is shown in table 2. Comment: Resettlement fund payment satisfied this project’s demand. The progress of land acquisition and house demolishing can basically satisfy this project’s demand for construction land. 1 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT Table 1 Resettlement Compensation Fund(By December 31, 2007) Unit:10,000 RMB Jingchuan County Kongtong County Jingning County Reality/Pla Reality/P Reality/ Subject Plan Reality Plan Reality Plan Reality n lan Plan 5946.95 10321.3 1.0573 6183.3 6980.4 1.1289 1 Permanent Land Acquisition 6634.34 1.1492 10912.3 1 2 Temporary Construction Land 0 0 3 House Compensation 740.1 1606.1575 2.1702 1588.5 3747.4413 2.3591 591.4 960.87 1.6247 4 Appendage Compensation 319.5 1.3053 685.7 0.7557 255.3 0.0000 5 Demolishing Compensation 7 0 0 9.56 0.0000 4.96 0.0000 6 Tree Compensation 50.5 619.7802 12.2729 108.4 2123.3673 19.5883 40.4 1141.41 27.1142 7 Affected Facility Compensation 8 Local Road 9 Supervision and Evaluation 10 Vulnerable Group Surport 11 Preparation Fee 12 Administration Fee 70.6 237.8 3.3683 127.1 411 3.2337 70.75 200.46 2.9251 13 Cultivating Fee 14 Woodland Restoration Fee 7134.65 1.3421 1.3011 9305.7777 1.3042 12840.5 17234.1086 7146.13 9298.13 Subtotal 1 2 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT Extend Table 1 Resettlement Compensation Fund(By December 31, 2007) Unit:10,000 RMB Huining County Anding County Subtobal Reality/Pl Subject Plan Reality Reality/Plan Plan Reality Reality/Plan Plan Reality an 1 Permanent Land Acquisition 6824.9 7976.48 1.1687 5318.1136 6199.76 1.1658 34594.6 38903.28 1.1245 2 Temporary Construction Land 90.8 0 0 3 House Compensation 917.6 3074.4036 3.3505 281.8 699.2698 2.4814 4119.4 10088.14 2.4489 4 Appendage Compensation 396.1 0.0000 121.6 0.0000 1778.1 10227.1 6.0329 5 Demolishing Compensation 10.32 0.0000 3.16 0.0000 35.04 7 0.1998 6 Tree Compensation 62.6 132.7 2.2000 19.2 146.0312 7.6058 281.1 4163.2887 14.8107 7 Affected Facility Compensation 635.48 1055.02 1.6602 8 Local Road 2802 0 0.0000 9 Supervision and Evaluation 443.01 9 0.0203 10 Vulnerable Group Support 443.01 0 0.0000 11 Preparation Fee 4430.1 0 0.0000 12 Administration Fee 82.1 290.4 3.5371 57.4 172.22 3.0003 1329 1318.37 0.992 13 Cultivating Fee 10547 8421.9392 0.7985 14 Woodland Restoration Fee 632.5 1.3834 1.2188 62161.1 1.1801 8293.6 11473.98 5801.2736 7070.461 736.12 Subtotal 1 Appendage includes all of the power, telecommunication, water and other facilities from east and west sections of the Pingding Expressway Project. 3 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT Table 2 Resettlement Progress(By December 31th, 2007) Unit: Household House Demolishing Land Acquistion NO. County Town Village Plan Reality Reality/Plan Resettled Plan Reality Reality/Plan 1 Jingchuan Wenquan Hejiaping 0 0 0 36 56 1.56 2 Jingchuan Wenquan Jiangjia 00 089891 3 Jingchuan Wenquan Ganjiagou 0 0 0 140 190 1.357 Subtotal 0 0 0 265 335 1.264 4 Jingchuan Wangcun Wangcun 30 33 1.1 33 68 158 2.324 5 Jingchuan Wangcun Xiangming 9 10 1.11 10 50 150 3 6 Jingchuan Wangcun Leiling 00 55 1 7 Jingchuan Wangcun Duitai 12 14 1.17 14 80 180 22.5 8 Jingchuan Wangcun Baiquan 5 4 0.8 0 81 320 3.951 9 Jingchuan Wangcun Guangming 1 1 1 1 52 52 1 10 Jingchuan Wangcun Ershilipu 00 048481 11 Jingchuan Wangcun Liangzhongchang 12 12 1 12 1 1 1 Subtotal 69 82 82 385 914 2.374 12 Jingchuan Luohandong Wangjiagou 3 3 1 3 129 159 1.233 13 Jingchuan Luohandong Luohandong 8 8 1 8 15 130 8.667 14 Jingchuan Luohandong Zhangbasi 00 012121 15 Jingchuan Luohandong Tuzhanao 7101.431011 1 16 Jingchuan Luohandong Sanshanzi 6 8 1.33 6 8 8 1 Subtotal 24 29 29 218 380 1.743 17 Jingchuan Jingming Shandixia 43 54 1.26 54 218 380 1.743 18 Jingchuan Jingming Gomenqian 2 2 1 2 16 210 13.125 19 Jingchuan Jingming Diaopuzi 00 03186 20 Jingchuan Jingming Changwucheng 00 05204 Subtotal 45 56 56 242 628 2.595 21 Jingchuan Chengguan Lanjiashan 0 0 0 101 221 2.188 4 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT House Demolishing Land Acquistion NO. County Town Village Plan Reality Reality/Plan Resettled Plan Reality Reality/Plan 22 Jingchuan Chengguan Gongchi 0 0 0 110 110 1 23 Jingchuan Chengguan Tuwozi 00 077 1 24 Jingchuan Chengguan Wujiashuiquan 00 012121 25 Jingchuan Chengguan Dong’an 00 011 1 26 Jingchuan Chengguan Xingou 00 06305 27 Jingchuan Chengguan Shuiquan 00 055551 28 Jingchuan Chengguan Yanfeng 00 014141 29 Jingchuan Chengguan Wulipu 38 60 1.58 60 57 322 5.649 30 Jingchuan Chengguan Yangpo 00 066 1 31 Jingchuan Chengguan Other 00 055551 Subtotal 38 60 1.58 60 424 833 1.965 County Subtotal 176 227 227 1480 3020 2.041 32 Kongtong Sishilipu Shangwan 0 137 137 1 33 Kongtong Sishilipu Mayukou 088881 34 Kongtong Sishilipu Ershilipu 0 103 103 1 35 Kongtong Sishilipu Qingjie 6 14 2.33 14 132 155 1.174 36 Kongtong Sishilipu Miaodixia 016161 37 Kongtong Sishilipu Junzhang 0 274 276 1.007 38 Kongtong Sishilipu Meixian 27 60 2.22 60 159 233 1.465 39 Kongtong Sishilipu Luzhai 2 18 9 18 152 165 1.086 40 Kongtong Sishilipu Yanwu 72 83 11.53 83 53 147 2.774 41 Kongtong Sishilipu Wuyue 0 80 76 0.95 42 Kongtong Sishilipu Shangjia 0 129 133 1.031 43 Kongtong Sishilipu Mijiawan 15 29 1.93 29 231 278 1.203 44 Kongtong Sishilipu Xiajia 0 209 216 1.033 Subtotal 95 205 205 1765 2023 1.146 45 Kongtong Liuhu Tuba 0 67 114 1.701 46 Kongtong Liuhu Baofeng 1 4 4 4 92 139 1.511 5 SUPERVISION AND EVALUATION REPORT House Demolishing Land Acquistion NO. County Town Village Plan Reality Reality/Plan Resettled Plan Reality Reality/Plan 47 Kongtong Liuhu Wangping 52 65 1.25 65 106 167 1.575 48 Kongtong Liuhu Nantai 2 2 1 2 171 190 1.111 Subtotal 55 71 71 436 610 1.399 49 Kongtong Kongtong Gaoling 0 0 18 18 1 50 Kongtong Kongtong Jiaju 0 0 27 27 1 51 Kongtong Kongtong Xigou 33 54 1.64 54 142 330 2.324 52 Kongtong Kongtong Hanjiagou 29 53 1.83 53 100 176 1.76 53 Kongtong Kongtong Jiangjiagou 10 22 2.2 22 197 232 1.178 54 Kongtong Kongtong Qianzijie 0 0 190 204 1.074 55 Kongtong Kongtong Taitong 5 5 1 5