DOCSLIB.ORG

Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children Rocking the Cradle: Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children National Council on Disability September 27, 2012 National Council on Disability An independent federal agency making recommendations to the President and Congress to enhance the quality of life for all Americans with disabilities and their families. Letter of Transmittal September 27, 2012 The President The White House Washington, DC 20500 Dear Mr. President: The National Council on Disability is pleased to submit the enclosed report, “Rocking the Cradle: Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children.” Despite a dark history marked by the eugenics movement, increasing numbers of people with disabilities are choosing to become parents. Recent research reveals that more than 4 million parents—6 percent of American mothers and fathers—are disabled. This number will unquestionably increase as more people with disabilities exercise a broader range of lifestyle options as a result of social integration, civil rights, and new adaptive technologies. Likewise, there has been a dramatic increase in the number of veterans who are returning from war with service-connected disabilities, some of whom may already be parents and others who will enter parenthood after acquiring their disability. The right to parent without interference is protected by the U.S. Constitution and balanced by the judicially recognized power of the state to interfere to protect the well-being of its children. The factors used in both dependency court and family court proceedings to determine whether children need to become wards of the state and which parent is the most competent custodian may be reasonable. Nonetheless, these rules are not objectively or justly applied to parents with disabilities and their children. Even today, 22 years after the passage of the Americans with Disabilities Act, parents with disabilities are the only distinct community of Americans who must struggle to retain custody of their children. Removal rates where parents have a psychiatric disability have been found to be as high as 70 percent to 80 percent; where the parent has an intellectual disability, 40 percent to 80 percent. In families where the parental disability is physical, 13 percent have reported discriminatory treatment in custody cases. Parents who are deaf or blind report extremely high rates of child removal and loss of parental rights. Parents with disabilities are more likely to lose custody of their children after divorce. In addition, prospective parents with disabilities have more difficulty when it comes to accessing reproductive health care such as assisted reproductive technologies, and they face significant barriers to adopting children. Clearly, the legal system is not protecting the rights of parents with disabilities and their children. Fully two-thirds of dependency statutes allow the court to reach the determination that a parent is unfit (a determination necessary to terminate parental rights) on the basis of the parent’s disability. 1331 F Street, NW ■ Suite 850 ■ Washington, DC 20004 202-272-2004 Voice ■ 202-272-2074 TTY ■ 202-272-2022 Fax ■ www.ncd.gov In every state, disability may be considered when determining the best interest of a child for purposes of a custody determination in family or dependency court. A nexus should always be shown between the disability and harm to the child, so that a child is taken from a custodial parent only when the parent’s disability is creating a detriment that cannot be alleviated. However, this is not the reality. NCD undertook this groundbreaking study to advance understanding and promote the rights of parents with disabilities and their children. This report provides a comprehensive review of the barriers and facilitators people with diverse disabilities—including intellectual and developmental disabilities, psychiatric disabilities, sensory disabilities, and physical disabilities—experience when they are exercising their fundamental right to create and maintain families. The report also describes the persistent, systemic, and pervasive discrimination against parents with disabilities. It analyzes how U.S. disability law and policy apply to parents with disabilities within the child welfare and family law systems, and the disparate treatment of parents with disabilities and their children. Examination of the impediments prospective parents with disabilities encounter when adopting or accessing assisted reproductive technologies provides further examples of the need for comprehensive protection of these rights. This report sets forth suggested action to ensure the rights of parents with disabilities and their children. Whether such action is taken at the state or federal level—as an amendment or a new law— the need for action could not be more timely or clear. In closing, NCD commends your Administration for its commitment to family values. Parents with disabilities and their children deserve support, not stigma. We look forward to working with you to ensure that the recommendations in this report are implemented. Sincerely, Jonathan Young, PhD, JD Chairman (The same letter of transmittal was sent to the President Pro Tempore of the U.S. Senate, the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, and the Director of the Office of Management and Budget.) National Council on Disability Members and Staff Members Jonathan M. Young, PhD, JD, Chairman Janice Lehrer-Stein, Vice Chair Gary Blumenthal Chester A. Finn Sara Gelser Matan Aryeh Koch Stephanie Orlando Kamilah Oni Martin-Proctor Lonnie Moore Ari Ne’eman Dongwoo Joseph (“Joe”) Pak, MBA Clyde E. Terry Fernando M. Torres-Gil, PhD Linda Wetters Pamela Young-Holmes Staff Aaron Bishop, Executive Director Stacey S. Brown, Staff Assistant Julie Carroll, Senior Attorney Advisor Lawrence Carter-Long, Public Affairs Specialist Joan M. Durocher, General Counsel & Director of Policy Lisa Grubb, Confidential Special Assistant / Coordinator of Administration Geraldine-Drake Hawkins, PhD, Senior Policy Analyst Sylvia Menifee, Director of Administration Carla Nelson, Administrative Specialist Robyn Powell, Attorney Advisor Anne Sommers, Director of Legislative Affairs & Outreach Rocking the Cradle: Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children 3 Acknowledgments The National Council on Disability (NCD), and particularly Robyn Powell, express appreciation to Through the Looking Glass, the NIDRR-funded National Center for Parents with Disabilities and Their Families— specifically Ella Callow, Megan Kirshbaum, and Paul Preston—for their assistance in writing sections of this report, as well as their insight and guidance throughout the research and drafting of the report. NCD also recognizes Lindsey Coffey, associate at Ropes and Gray, for her assistance and guidance in drafting the chapter on assisted reproductive technologies. NCD thanks the key informants who provided varied perspectives and valuable contributions. Finally, NCD expresses its gratitude to the parents and prospective parents who shared their stories and experiences. 4 National Council on Disability Table of Contents List of Acronyms . 11 Executive Summary . 15 Summary of Methodology . 17 Findings and Recommendations . 17 Chapter 1 . Introduction . .. 39 The Evolution of Parenting in the Disability Community . 39 Parenting with a Disability in the 20th Century . 39 Parenting with a Disability Today: The Eugenics Movement’s Backdoor? . 40 Current Data on Parents with Disabilities and Their Families . 43 Fundamental Principles of Parenting Rights in the United States . 45 Dependency Law . 47 Family Law . 49 Adoption Law . 50 Purpose and Structure of Report . 51 Chapter 2 . Research Methodology . 53 Chapter 3 . Disability Law Framework . 55 Federal Disability Rights Laws: An Overview . 55 Rehabilitation Act of 1973 . 55 Americans with Disabilities Act . 56 Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act . 57 Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act . 59 Ensuring Accessibility for the Whole Family . .. 60 Conclusion . 63 Chapter 4 . Pursuing Parenting Rights Through the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities . 65 Respect for Home and the Family . 66 Rocking the Cradle: Ensuring the Rights of Parents with Disabilities and Their Children 5 Access to Reproductive Health . 68 Additional Protections for Parents with Disabilities and Their Children . 68 Conclusion . 69 Chapter 5 . The Child Welfare System: Removal, Reunification, and Termination . 71 The Child Welfare System: A Brief Overview . 72 Disability Law and the Child Welfare System . 74 Disparate Impact of Child Welfare System on Parents with Disabilities and Their Families . 76 Discriminatory State Statutes . 84 Recurrent Barriers in Child Welfare Cases Involving Parents with Disabilities . 86 Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997 and Its Impact on Parents with Disabilities . 86 Perceived Limits on Application of the Americans with Disabilities Act at Termination Phase . 93 Bias, Speculation, and the “Unfit Parent” Standard . 94 Issues in Meaningful Participation and Representation . 98 The Impact on Children . 101 Conclusion . 106 Chapter 6 . Parental Disability and Child Welfare in the Native American Community . 109 The Tribal Context: A Brief Overview . 109 The History of Native Americans and Child Welfare . 109 The Statistics . 110 Summary of the Indian Child Welfare Act . 110 The Intersection of the ADA and ICWA . 110 Lack of Services . 111 Need for Culturally Relevant Services and Training . 111 Need
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Questions Nannies Should Ask
    Ten Tips: Questions Nannies Should Ask All too often, both the interviewing nanny and the hiring family are totally new to the “nanny After two decades of speaking world.” Both parties have their own ideas of what to expect; however it is common for to nannies and their employers important parts of the nanny-family relationship to be completely overlooked in the job on a daily basis, we have interview because neither party asked the right questions. The following are important areas of conversation that the nanny wants to make sure she covers in the job interview. compiled this list to help you cover the major items in a 1. Childcare duties nanny job interview. Ask the family to be specific about their expectations. Rephrase their expectations back to them to be sure you understand. "So you expect me to prepare Suzie's breakfast and lunch, include outdoor play time weather permitted, tidy up after her messes, and launder her clothes and bedding weekly, correct?" You will want to cover any allergies, dietary A nanny job interview is a restrictions and health concerns here, especially if you will be responsible for administration two-way conversation. of medications. Interviewing for a job is very similar to auditioning for a role in a play. There is 2. Hours art and science involved in Are they defined or flexible? How much notice of schedule changes? Any weekend or night successful interviewing. work required? Kathleen Webb President 3. Compensation, taxes, and a work agreement HomeWork Solutions Inc. Ask for compensation in hourly wage terms, and work out a weekly guarantee if at all possible.
    [Show full text]
  • Homeschool Book of Answers (Pdf)
    Homeschooling Book of Answers! Homeschooling Book of Answers (to your questions!) from www.homeschooling-ideas.com Copyright www.homeschooling-ideas.com 2013 Homeschooling Book of Answers! It is natural to have questions when you first start thinking of homeschooling. I get a lot of questions from new homeschoolers and I have started collecting them and asking my wonderful Facebook fans for their advice and opinions. This e-book then is a collection of their wisdom and experience – with some of mine thrown in too! I hope that it will help you with your worries and questions and help you to feel as if you have had a friend to talk to. If your particular worry isn't here, then do keep an eye on my Facebook page – it may be posted soon. Or come and ask for yourself! You will find everyone helpful and supportive. I wish you much joy in your homeschooling journey. Best wishes, Julie http://www.homeschooling-ideas.com/ Copyright www.homeschooling-ideas.com 2013 Homeschooling Book of Answers! Julie says : I think that schools have done us a great disservice in making us think that we must 'teach' children! Children are hard-wired to learn and you will probably find that you can't keep up with him! My children are forever surprising me with things they know – things I don't know even! We often learn things together and it is amazing how much we learn from conversations and just being out and about. You are sure to be able to teach him 'enough' – it will be hard not too! In terms of grade, that is an arbitrary level imposed so that schools can monitor their effectiveness.
    [Show full text]
  • Plan for the Child with Both Parents and Served As Their Liaison for the Child’S School-Related Issues
    plan for the child with both parents and served as their liaison for the child’s school-related issues. Scheduled, managed and performed some of the daily household chores. Responsible for mail and package intake. Prepared snacks, breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Picked up and dropped off child at daily activities and appointments focusing on punctuality and discipline. Tutored child using educator skills in areas where the child may be deficient, but also working with children to make more positive strides where she may already be excelling. Answered the phone in a professional manner and taking messages that are legible; followed up with calls when necessary. Traveled with the family and extended family; staying with the children for extended periods of time without parental supervision. Brown Family Beverly Hills, CA 2005- 2014 Full-time Nanny/ Live-in Household Manager, Ages of Children Upon Hire: 10, 9-year-old Twins Live-in Nanny/ Household Manager for high profile, single widow of four children. Oversaw all activities of children including academics, sports, volunteering, and personal matters including packing and traveling and health. Provided care for two small dogs; feeding, walks, medication, boarding. Kept inventory of household supplies and restocked daily as necessary. Prepped and served breakfast, lunch, and dinner to all members of the family. Managed household staff, contractors for a renovation, and other vendors involved in the running of a 6,000 square foot estate. Assisted with planning social and holiday events in the home. Maintained all vehicles in the home keeping up on service appointments, registration, and insurance. Kept flowers and shrubs in top notch condition by watering, flowering, and pruning when applicable.
    [Show full text]
  • Nannies, Au Pairs, Children and Parents
    CARE FOR CHILDREN IN AN ERA OF PRIVATE MARKET SERVICES A STUDY OF NANNIES, AU PAIRS, CHILDREN AND PARENTS Research team Associate Professor Sara Eldén [email protected] PhD Terese Anving [email protected] Research facts This research project has been funded by The Swedish Foundation for Humanities and Social Sciences (Eldén P13-0603:1), and has been hosted by the Department of Sociology, Lund University Sweden. Selected publications During the last decade, Swedish families have started to employ nannies Book: and au pairs to an extent previously never experienced. Political initiati- Nanny families: Practices of care ves such as the RUT tax deductions (2007), together with global trends by nannies, au pairs, parents and of ‘care chains’, have created a new private market for private child care children in Sweden; (2019) Bristol services. University Press In this study, we have analysed how families ‘do family’ when parts of Research articles: the care for children are bought as a service on the market. By inter- New ways of doing the ’good’ and viewing all categories of actors – nannies, au pairs, parents and child- gender equal family: ren – and by using innovative methods, the project has made unique Parents employing nannies and au contributions to international research debates on global care chains and pairs in Sweden; (2016) Sociologi- cal Research Online paid domestic care work. Furthermore, this is the first extensive study internationally to include children’s perspectives on care from nannies Precarious Care Labor: Contra- and au pairs, and one of few studies that gathers data from several dictory Work Regulations and Practices for Au Pairs in Sweden; actors involved in the same care practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Au Pair Childcare, of Course. It's More Flexible Than
    Choosing Au pair childcare, of course. It’s more flexible than daycare and more theaffordable than right a nanny. childcare 11 important questions to ask yourself before making a decision. CULTURALCARE.COM © COPYRIGHT 2018, CULTURAL CARE AU PAIR Finding the right childcare provider for your children is a big decision. You want quality childcare that stimulates and nurtures your children, gives you peace of mind and doesn’t break the bank. We’ve listed the types of options that are available as well as 11 questions to ask yourself to help determine which one is the best fit for you. We recommend staying open to options you may never have considered before— you might be surprised to discover what kind of childcare works best for your family! Here are the childcare options widely available to American families: Center-based daycare Family daycare Au pair Childcare provided by a Childcare provided by A young adult from overseas who state-regulated center in a individuals in the providers’ own joins a family for up to two years group setting; individual home; required to have a state to provide childcare; all Cultural childcare workers’ education and health and safety license. Care au pairs are screened, training requirements vary by trained and American Heart setting and state. Association-certified in adult and pediatric CPR/AED and First Aid. Nanny Nanny share Family coverage An individual who cares for An individual who cares for Childcare provided by a family children in a family; may or children from more than one member like a grandparent or may not be formally trained.
    [Show full text]
  • Nanny and Au Pair Fact Sheet
    Nanny and Au Pair What is a Nanny? Nannies and other home-based childcarers are employed by you to provide care for children usually in your own home. They will fit in with unusual working hours, and work part time or even live in if required. Some Nannies may also agree to do additional jobs around the house such as cooking and washing. Most Nannies will have a recognised childcare qualification or nursery nurse training but note that this is not compulsory. Nannies can be provided through agencies that will carry out their own specific checks on their staff it is advisable to check with the agency what checks they do. This may include disclosure and barring checks (previously known as criminal records checks) and may stipulate a minimum qualification requirement and regular renewal of qualifications such as first aid. You should always ask for references from previous childcare roles. What is an Au Pair? Au pairs and other home-based childcarers are employed by you to provide care for children usually in your own home. They are usually single, young women from overseas. They come to the UK to study English, live with a family and help out in the home for a maximum of five hours a day. In exchange they must have two days off, and be provided with a weekly allowance (usually around £50-£150), meals and their own room. Au pairs are not registered or usually trained to work with children so are generally considered inappropriate to care for a young baby, but can be a good option when it comes to providing affordable after-school care.
    [Show full text]
  • More Care for You, and Everyone in Your Family
    Children More care for you, and Find babysitters, nannies, special needs everyone in your family caregivers, tutors, childcare centers and last-minute care. Balancing your work-life with your responsibilities at home is never easy. And although everyone’s situation is unique, there’s one thing we share. We all need a little help every now and then. With Care.com, you’ve got someone on your side—to help bring quality care to you and your family. Adults & Seniors Discover senior Finding the care you need couldn’t be easier. Simply: caregivers, companion SIGN UP BROWSE CONNECT services, special for your free thousands of with caregivers that needs caregivers, Premium Membership caregiver profi les, meet your needs, directly transportation providers and with Care.com, the view reference through Care.com housing. largest online and access messaging. Interview destination for care. background and hire the one check options. that works for you. Pe t s Search pet sitters, dog walkers, pet transportation, grooming and obedience trainers. Home & Lifestyle Access housekeepers, errand runners, house sitters and more. Visit nibri.care.com and log in with your work email address to start your Premium Membership. Care.com and “There for you” are service marks or registered service marks of Care.com, Inc © 2014 Care.com, Inc. All rights reserved. Get the most from your Care.com membership Use these tools and tips and fi nd care, fast. There’s a lot you can do with your Care.com membership. And it all starts with fi nding the perfect caregiver. Here’s how: POST A JOB—and let our caregivers know exactly what you need.
    [Show full text]
  • Parenting and Child Care Services
    Parenting and Child Care Support. Just When You Need It. “ Finding the right daycare for my child’s needs was a stressful project. CONCERN set my mind at ease by helping me find the best option for m y f a m i l y.” Parenting is the most important job New Baby Kit you’ll ever have, and it’s also the most Education and resources for baby’s first year rewarding. But working full-time while Childcare resources and referrals trying to raise a smart, healthy, and Family day care, childcare center, nanny well-rounded child can be challenging. Adoption services CONCERN makes it simple to find the Local and National organizations help and support you need. Programs for children with special needs Support and advocacy, in-home caregivers All parents want what’s best for their children. Academic services As they grow and mature, what’s best for them Public and private schools, before and after school will change. One day you’re helping them take programs, college search, and financial aid their first steps and the next you’ll be moving them into college. CONCERN is here to help Services for at-risk or high-risk adolescents you find resources and support through every Summer care options stage of your child’s development, from bringing Sports, academic and fine arts programs them home for the first time, to their first homecoming dance, and everything in between. Tutors, mentors, and enrichment programs Call our toll free number and ask for a Parenting Call: 800.344.4222 and Childcare consultant who can assist you with every step of your child’s development.
    [Show full text]
  • “Don't Worry, It's Just a Tool”: Enacting Selectively Enforced Laws Such As
    “Don’t Worry, It’s Just a Tool”: Enacting Selectively Enforced Laws Such as Curfew Laws Targeting Only the Bad Guys Margaret Anne Cleek, John A. Youril, Michael Youril, and Richard Guarino* Volume 7 – No. 1 – Spring 2010 *Margaret A. Cleek is a Professor of Management in the College of Business Administration at California State University, Sacramento. John A. Youril is a writer and community activist with particular interest in constitutional issues and juvenile rights. Michael D. Youril is currently enrolled in law school at the University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law. Richard Guarino is an Emeritus Professor of Business Law in the College of Business, California State University Sacramento. Abstract The United States Constitution is in place to protect the rights of the citizens. Yet, the current environment leans towards the enactment of more and more laws at all levels of government which erode or eliminate those rights. It is suggested that the fear and chaos of these stressful and uncertain times results in a willingness on the part of legislators and the public that elects them to trade freedom for security. This can have disastrous consequences. Cicero (42BC) observed, “When people are willing to give up rights for security, they will, in the end, lose both.” This paper examines how laws which violate civil rights, such as curfew laws are passed by municipalities and accepted by the community with an understanding that they will only be selectively enforced against “the bad guys”. Citizens are told by law enforcement that they need such laws as a “tool” and without them they are powerless to deal with the problem population.
    [Show full text]
  • Nancy Bjorkman Heppner's Legacy Homeschool Resources
    HOMESCHOOLING YOUR HIGHSCHOOLER – Nancy Bjorkman Heppner’s Legacy Homeschool Resources – www.legacyhomeschool.com PO Box 753 / 369 Jackson Ave NW – Elk River, MN 55330 763-241-HOME (4663) Planning – Curriculum, schedules, requirements Homeschooling High School – Jeanne Dennis Senior High: A Homeschool Form-U-La – Barb Shelton Teaching High School at Home – Audio CD - Jay Wile Learning Guides Forms for High School – CDROM – Barb Shelton Record Keeping Forms for High School – CDROM – Barb Shelton Worldview Academy Leadership Camp – www.worldview.org U of MN requirements – 4 years English, 3 years Science, 2 years Foreign Language, 3 years Math, 3 years Social Studies, 1 year Arts Northwestern College, St. Paul, MN – Same as U of M minus Arts Part-time Co-ops and Private/Public School Record Keeping – Edutrack, Homeschool Minder Homeschooler’s High School Journal – Planbook Ultimate Daily Planner for Students – Charlene Notgrass College Entrance Exams – th 10 Grade – PLAN (See www.actstudent.org ) th 11 Grade – PSAT (See www.collegeboard.com ) th 12 Grade – SAT and/or ACT (best before your senior year begins) TestBuster for the ACT – REA Publishers SAT (or ACT)& College Preparation for the Christian Student – James Stobaugh Transcripts – course descriptions (See sample on our website in Conference News and the handout for this workshop) Resume – for school and life (See sample on our website in Conference News and the handout for this workshop) Accelerated Distance Learning – CLEP, DSST (DANTES) . www.collegeboard.com and www.getcollegecredit.com
    [Show full text]
  • Examples of Letter of Recommendation for Nanny
    Examples Of Letter Of Recommendation For Nanny Cooper often touzles overpoweringly when savory Demosthenis retire tender-heartedly and spired her respirations. induratedDumbstruck sinlessly, and draffy but Marioarow Ebenezerdespond hernever beltman dislimns kalinite so lastingly. pawn and overflies universally. Dickie blither his treacles Along with the contract, and Microsoft Word. Developing children are constantly grappling with their emotions. Provide upon handing the pack uses also has one anymore but it official closing your circumstances change, smiling and examples of letter of recommendation for nanny infants and on you sure to furnish your chance to. When she started, and holidays. Remember to abide by all federal, shows initiative, she is a partner in parenting. Her work includes writing website content and small client projects. Her specific responsibilities were to feed the boys the snack I left each day and get them started on their homework; however many times I would come home and find that she had taken on additional responsibilities of her own volition. Make it easy for them. Was she warm, what skills the employer expects from the applicant. See more templates and create your resume here. Denise is certified in infant care, caring, etc. Ask the property manager what utilities are covered in your monthly rent, want to try such a profession and start to babysit different children. Our goal is to make you stronger without getting lost or exhausted. The body is the majority of the letter. James cuts the grass and trims the hedges each week for the Johnson family. Please Select multirating style. Del Ray, and PSD.
    [Show full text]
  • Nanny Employers
    R E C O M M E N D E D P R A C T I C E S NANNY EMPLOYERS The International Nanny Association recommends these practices but has no authority to require a member to adhere to them. INA does not represent that the Association has the authority to discipline a member for a violation of the letter or spirit of what is recommended. Consequently, the INA assumes no responsibility or liability for the action of any member of the Association. nanny.org Recommended Practices for Nanny Employers The INA Recommended Practices for Nanny Employers was written primarily for US- based Nanny Employers. Those living and employing Nannies outside of the US should consult with the legal and governmental entities in their location. Legal Responsibilities Take on the role of employer. Nannies are employees of the family for whom they work; they are not independent contractors. The INA recommends that Nanny Employers who employ a nanny take the steps necessary to establish themselves as a legitimate employer. Securing a Federal Identification Number with the IRS by completing form SS-4 Obtaining an employer identification number from the state in which the family resides (by contacting the state office that handles employment). Parents may also have to report “a new hire” with the office that handles employment in the state where the family resides. File correct year-end paperwork. The INA recommends Nanny Employers file the proper year- end tax forms and supply their nanny with a W-2 form by January 31st of each year. Parents must also file form W-3 with the Social Security Administration by February 28th of each year.
    [Show full text]