The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History Volume 9 Issue 2 Article 5 11-2019 The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 Stephen Wong University of Toronto, Canada Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/aujh Part of the History Commons Recommended Citation Wong, Stephen (2019) "The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939," Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History: Vol. 9 : Iss. 2 , Article 5. DOI: 10.20429/aujh.2019.090205 Available at: https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/aujh/vol9/iss2/5 This article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Digital Commons@Georgia Southern. It has been accepted for inclusion in Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons@Georgia Southern. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Wong: The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 Stephen Wong University of Toronto (Toronto, Canada) The word besprizornye meant abandoned and orphans in Soviet Russia. From 1918 to 1939, the massive number of orphans was one of the social problems the Soviet Union was facing. The history of orphans during the interwar period can be categorized into two periods: the first wave from 1918, the establishment of the Soviet Union throughout the civil war, to 1922, the beginning of the New Economic Policy (NEP) period. This first wave were orphaned due to the disasters caused by the civil war and famine. The Soviet government, saw the large number of orphans as a chance to initiate its Soviet experiment. By employing various policies including opening orphanages, they were able to transform their young population into new citizens of the socialist state. With the coming of NEP, the government achieved mixed results in this Soviet experiment. The second wave of orphans appeared from 1930 to 1939, and this wave was caused by Stalin’s policies on collectivization, forced industrialization and terror. The Stalinist government employed a similar strategy as in the NEP period to accommodate these orphans to continue the Soviet experiment. However, Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2019 1 Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History, Vol. 9 [2019], Iss. 2, Art. 5 Stalin’s government lacked adequate resources, and there was a shifting of the political environment in the 1930s. Orphans tended to be mistreated by the authorities, and the orphanages only became a temporary solution that could not relieve orphans of their misery. Eventually, they became victims of political terror under Stalin’s government in the 1930s. This essay will be divided into two parts: the first part will examine the first wave of orphans in the Soviet Union that lived outside the state welfare system from 1918 to 1922 and the government’s attitude toward and response to accommodating this large number of orphans. The second part will examine the second wave of orphans generated by Stalin’s terror who remained outside the state welfare system and how the government responded to this wave of orphans. Through comparison of the Soviet government’s attitude and policy on orphans in the two different periods, it becomes clear that the shifting of the political environment into a more conservative atmosphere in the 1930s victimized children and orphans in the Soviet Union. Eventually the Stalinist government failed in its Soviet experiment, which aimed to transform children into Soviet citizens. In the 1920s, Soviet cities and towns were filled with abandoned children. Children in the early Soviet period became orphans due to war and famine. The large continuous wave of orphans began in pre-Revolutionery times. When the Russian Empire entered World War One, the imperial government began to conscript adult males into the army. This included https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/aujh/vol9/iss2/5 DOI: 10.20429/aujh.2019.090205 2 Wong: The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 many fathers, and families lost their main source of income.1 As the German and Austrian armies pushed toward the east in 1916, the Russian government began to evacuate the eastern front, and many families abandoned their children, as they had lost their shelter. With the establishment of a new government and the end of World War One, the economy worsened. Many families had to abandon their children because they lost their sources of income and their homes, so these children had to live on the streets.2 However, the end of World War One brought the six-year Civil War beginning in 1917 that introduced epidemics and famine to the newly established Soviet Union. By the end of the Civil War in 1922, there had been eight years of continuous war from World War One to the Civil War. The number of orphans reached its peak in 1921-1922 with the Volga Famine, which pushed the number of orphans to approximately seven million across the Soviet Union.3 These orphans were deprived of adult care and had to survive on their own in the streets of urban areas. With political turmoil and war beginning in 1918, and continuing to 1922, the Soviet government was not able to accommodate this sudden wave of orphans and abandoned children. Many orphans had to live outside the state welfare system throughout the early 1920s. They had to rely on their own abilities to survive living on the streets. The majority of orphans were living in urban areas and tended to cluster around train stations, restaurants and 1 Ronald Grigor. Suny, “The Soviet Experiment: Russia, the USSR, and the Successor States” (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011), 94. 2 Ibid. 3 Alan M Ball, And Now My Soul Is Hardened: Abandoned Children in Soviet Russia, 1918-1930 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996), introduction, e-book. Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2019 3 Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History, Vol. 9 [2019], Iss. 2, Art. 5 garbage sites.4 They used different methods ranging from passive to criminal behavior to survive. Gender and age also had an influence on their choices. Younger orphans tended to portray themselves as innocent and seek help from adults. Many of them chose begging as a way to earn their living. Some orphans also worked alongside adults on the street to beg more effectively.5 Usually, the adult would keep all the revenue of the day but would provide shelter and food for the young orphans.6 Besides begging, another peaceful way to earn a living on the street was to provide entertainment. Orphans would form temporary music groups for a day, as members could come and go freely and provide entertainment at various public locations.7 Orphans would sing together at train stations to attract passengers to give them money or perform concerts in markets, courtyards and streets.8Some orphans also simply danced in the street to earn a living. During the NEP, the economic state was more liberalized, and they could obtain a license to sell quite easily.9 Some orphans chose to sell hand-made goods or their own clothing in exchange for food. Although many orphans chose to survive on the street peacefully, some orphans, particularly older orphans, chose to become criminals and engaged in various illegal activities. Stealing was one of the most common activities, but if they got caught, they would 4 Alan M Ball, "Survival in the Street World of Soviet Russia's ‘besprizornye’," Jahrbücher Für Geschichte Osteuropas, Neue Folge, 39, no. 1 (1991): 34, https://www.jstor.org/stable/41048535. 5 Ibid, 35 6 Ibid, 35 7 Ibid, 36 8 Ibid. 9 Ibid, 39 https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/aujh/vol9/iss2/5 DOI: 10.20429/aujh.2019.090205 4 Wong: The Failure of Soviet Orphan Policies, 1918-1939 depend on the mercy of the victims. They were often beaten badly before being handed in to police.10 The police also did not receive adequate training in handling juveniles and tended to mistreat them by locking them up together with adult criminals.11 Some orphans preferred more aggressive methods. They worked in groups and knocked down people who walked by or chased single people walking in the street and took away their belongings.12 Orphans also conducted burglaries, targeting windows or doors of apartments and houses that were open so they could slip in.13 For girls, many of them chose to become prostitutes.14 Many of the girls would try begging or other non-criminal activities, but after a few months, due to failure or being raped by passers-by, they chose to become prostitutes.15 In a survey in the 1920s, of the 55 percent of the participants under the age of 15, 88 percent had turned to prostitution.16 These prostitutes usually worked at train stations or near market locations in urban areas. No matter what criminal act they engaged in, orphans who were attracted to criminal activities or decided to conduct a trade usually formed groups to survive living on the streets. Orphans who decided to enter into commercial or criminal activities tended to form groups to protect themselves from fellow competitors, including adults, and to give them protection from police prosecution. For commercial activities, orphans formed guild-like 10 Ibid, 40. 11 Ball ,And Now My Soul Is Hardened: Abandoned Children in Soviets, chap. 2. 12 Ibid. 13 Ball, “Survival in the Street World of Soviet Russia's ‘Besprizornye’,” 48. 14 Ibid, 40. 15 Ibid, 41. 16 Ibid, 42. Published by Digital Commons@Georgia Southern, 2019 5 Armstrong Undergraduate Journal of History, Vol. 9 [2019], Iss. 2, Art. 5 groups which not only acted as an early warning mechanism for competitors but also for police prosecution of illegal sellers.
Recommended publications
  • Questions Nannies Should Ask
    Ten Tips: Questions Nannies Should Ask All too often, both the interviewing nanny and the hiring family are totally new to the “nanny After two decades of speaking world.” Both parties have their own ideas of what to expect; however it is common for to nannies and their employers important parts of the nanny-family relationship to be completely overlooked in the job on a daily basis, we have interview because neither party asked the right questions. The following are important areas of conversation that the nanny wants to make sure she covers in the job interview. compiled this list to help you cover the major items in a 1. Childcare duties nanny job interview. Ask the family to be specific about their expectations. Rephrase their expectations back to them to be sure you understand. "So you expect me to prepare Suzie's breakfast and lunch, include outdoor play time weather permitted, tidy up after her messes, and launder her clothes and bedding weekly, correct?" You will want to cover any allergies, dietary A nanny job interview is a restrictions and health concerns here, especially if you will be responsible for administration two-way conversation. of medications. Interviewing for a job is very similar to auditioning for a role in a play. There is 2. Hours art and science involved in Are they defined or flexible? How much notice of schedule changes? Any weekend or night successful interviewing. work required? Kathleen Webb President 3. Compensation, taxes, and a work agreement HomeWork Solutions Inc. Ask for compensation in hourly wage terms, and work out a weekly guarantee if at all possible.
    [Show full text]
  • Homeschool Book of Answers (Pdf)
    Homeschooling Book of Answers! Homeschooling Book of Answers (to your questions!) from www.homeschooling-ideas.com Copyright www.homeschooling-ideas.com 2013 Homeschooling Book of Answers! It is natural to have questions when you first start thinking of homeschooling. I get a lot of questions from new homeschoolers and I have started collecting them and asking my wonderful Facebook fans for their advice and opinions. This e-book then is a collection of their wisdom and experience – with some of mine thrown in too! I hope that it will help you with your worries and questions and help you to feel as if you have had a friend to talk to. If your particular worry isn't here, then do keep an eye on my Facebook page – it may be posted soon. Or come and ask for yourself! You will find everyone helpful and supportive. I wish you much joy in your homeschooling journey. Best wishes, Julie http://www.homeschooling-ideas.com/ Copyright www.homeschooling-ideas.com 2013 Homeschooling Book of Answers! Julie says : I think that schools have done us a great disservice in making us think that we must 'teach' children! Children are hard-wired to learn and you will probably find that you can't keep up with him! My children are forever surprising me with things they know – things I don't know even! We often learn things together and it is amazing how much we learn from conversations and just being out and about. You are sure to be able to teach him 'enough' – it will be hard not too! In terms of grade, that is an arbitrary level imposed so that schools can monitor their effectiveness.
    [Show full text]
  • Plan for the Child with Both Parents and Served As Their Liaison for the Child’S School-Related Issues
    plan for the child with both parents and served as their liaison for the child’s school-related issues. Scheduled, managed and performed some of the daily household chores. Responsible for mail and package intake. Prepared snacks, breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Picked up and dropped off child at daily activities and appointments focusing on punctuality and discipline. Tutored child using educator skills in areas where the child may be deficient, but also working with children to make more positive strides where she may already be excelling. Answered the phone in a professional manner and taking messages that are legible; followed up with calls when necessary. Traveled with the family and extended family; staying with the children for extended periods of time without parental supervision. Brown Family Beverly Hills, CA 2005- 2014 Full-time Nanny/ Live-in Household Manager, Ages of Children Upon Hire: 10, 9-year-old Twins Live-in Nanny/ Household Manager for high profile, single widow of four children. Oversaw all activities of children including academics, sports, volunteering, and personal matters including packing and traveling and health. Provided care for two small dogs; feeding, walks, medication, boarding. Kept inventory of household supplies and restocked daily as necessary. Prepped and served breakfast, lunch, and dinner to all members of the family. Managed household staff, contractors for a renovation, and other vendors involved in the running of a 6,000 square foot estate. Assisted with planning social and holiday events in the home. Maintained all vehicles in the home keeping up on service appointments, registration, and insurance. Kept flowers and shrubs in top notch condition by watering, flowering, and pruning when applicable.
    [Show full text]
  • Nannies, Au Pairs, Children and Parents
    CARE FOR CHILDREN IN AN ERA OF PRIVATE MARKET SERVICES A STUDY OF NANNIES, AU PAIRS, CHILDREN AND PARENTS Research team Associate Professor Sara Eldén [email protected] PhD Terese Anving [email protected] Research facts This research project has been funded by The Swedish Foundation for Humanities and Social Sciences (Eldén P13-0603:1), and has been hosted by the Department of Sociology, Lund University Sweden. Selected publications During the last decade, Swedish families have started to employ nannies Book: and au pairs to an extent previously never experienced. Political initiati- Nanny families: Practices of care ves such as the RUT tax deductions (2007), together with global trends by nannies, au pairs, parents and of ‘care chains’, have created a new private market for private child care children in Sweden; (2019) Bristol services. University Press In this study, we have analysed how families ‘do family’ when parts of Research articles: the care for children are bought as a service on the market. By inter- New ways of doing the ’good’ and viewing all categories of actors – nannies, au pairs, parents and child- gender equal family: ren – and by using innovative methods, the project has made unique Parents employing nannies and au contributions to international research debates on global care chains and pairs in Sweden; (2016) Sociologi- cal Research Online paid domestic care work. Furthermore, this is the first extensive study internationally to include children’s perspectives on care from nannies Precarious Care Labor: Contra- and au pairs, and one of few studies that gathers data from several dictory Work Regulations and Practices for Au Pairs in Sweden; actors involved in the same care practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Form I-600, Petition to Classify Orphan As an Immediate Relative, to Determine Whether a Child Who Has Been Or Will Be Adopted by a U.S
    Instructions for Petition to Classify Orphan as an Immediate Relative USCIS Form I-600 Department of Homeland Security OMB No. 1615-0028 U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Expires 12/31/2021 What Is the Purpose of Form I-600? U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) uses the information provided on Form I-600, Petition to Classify Orphan as an Immediate Relative, to determine whether a child who has been or will be adopted by a U.S. citizen (and spouse, if married) can be classified as an orphan for an immediate relative immigrant visa. Who May File Form I-600? If you are a U.S. citizen, you (and your spouse, if married) may file Form I-600 for an unmarried child if: 1. You file the Form I-600 before the child’s 16th birthday (or before the child’s 18th birthday in some cases, as discussed in these Instructions); 2. The child’s adoption is not governed by the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption (Hague Adoption Convention); 3. The child qualifies as an orphan, as defined in the Immigration and NationalityAct (INA) section 101(b)(1)(F); and 4. You (and your spouse, if married) either: A. Have adopted the child outside the United States and the adoption order is final; or B. Have obtained legal custody of the child for emigration and adoption in the United States and will adopt the child in the United States after the child enters the country with a visa. To qualify as an adoption for immigration purposes, the adoption must, according to the laws where it takes place, establish a permanent legal parent-child relationship between the child and you (and your spouse, if married), as well as terminate the legal parent-child relationship between the child and any former parent(s).
    [Show full text]
  • Au Pair Childcare, of Course. It's More Flexible Than
    Choosing Au pair childcare, of course. It’s more flexible than daycare and more theaffordable than right a nanny. childcare 11 important questions to ask yourself before making a decision. CULTURALCARE.COM © COPYRIGHT 2018, CULTURAL CARE AU PAIR Finding the right childcare provider for your children is a big decision. You want quality childcare that stimulates and nurtures your children, gives you peace of mind and doesn’t break the bank. We’ve listed the types of options that are available as well as 11 questions to ask yourself to help determine which one is the best fit for you. We recommend staying open to options you may never have considered before— you might be surprised to discover what kind of childcare works best for your family! Here are the childcare options widely available to American families: Center-based daycare Family daycare Au pair Childcare provided by a Childcare provided by A young adult from overseas who state-regulated center in a individuals in the providers’ own joins a family for up to two years group setting; individual home; required to have a state to provide childcare; all Cultural childcare workers’ education and health and safety license. Care au pairs are screened, training requirements vary by trained and American Heart setting and state. Association-certified in adult and pediatric CPR/AED and First Aid. Nanny Nanny share Family coverage An individual who cares for An individual who cares for Childcare provided by a family children in a family; may or children from more than one member like a grandparent or may not be formally trained.
    [Show full text]
  • Nanny and Au Pair Fact Sheet
    Nanny and Au Pair What is a Nanny? Nannies and other home-based childcarers are employed by you to provide care for children usually in your own home. They will fit in with unusual working hours, and work part time or even live in if required. Some Nannies may also agree to do additional jobs around the house such as cooking and washing. Most Nannies will have a recognised childcare qualification or nursery nurse training but note that this is not compulsory. Nannies can be provided through agencies that will carry out their own specific checks on their staff it is advisable to check with the agency what checks they do. This may include disclosure and barring checks (previously known as criminal records checks) and may stipulate a minimum qualification requirement and regular renewal of qualifications such as first aid. You should always ask for references from previous childcare roles. What is an Au Pair? Au pairs and other home-based childcarers are employed by you to provide care for children usually in your own home. They are usually single, young women from overseas. They come to the UK to study English, live with a family and help out in the home for a maximum of five hours a day. In exchange they must have two days off, and be provided with a weekly allowance (usually around £50-£150), meals and their own room. Au pairs are not registered or usually trained to work with children so are generally considered inappropriate to care for a young baby, but can be a good option when it comes to providing affordable after-school care.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 Orphan Report
    Ք REPORT Ք HUMAN RIGHTS 2021 ORPHAN REPORT APRIL 2021 CANSU NAR www.insamer.com [email protected] www.ihh.org.tr/en APRIL 2021 REPORT 2021 Orphan Report Report Human Rights April 2021 Prepared By Cansu Nar Executive Editor Dr. Ahmet Emin Dağ Editor Mervenur Lüleci Karadere For citation: Nar, Cansu. 2021 Orphan Report, INSAMER Report, April 2021. Responsibility for the information and views set out in this publication lies entirely with the authors. ©INSAMER 2021 All rights are reserved. The use of quotations is allowed only by providing reference. Nuhun Gemisi Cover and Page Design Nurgül Ersoy Printing: Pelikan Basım Ulubatlı Hasan Caddesi No. 2 H D Blok No. 19 Başakşehir – Istanbul INSAMER is a research center of IHH Humanitarian Relief Foundation. HUMAN RIGHTS 2 iii CONTENTS Orphan and Orphanhood 1 Social Orphanhood and Child Abuse 5 State of Orphans in the World 8 Orphans as Victims of War 13 Vulnerable Child Refugees 14 Children With Real Weapons Made 16 of Iron Instead of Toys Consequences of Child Poverty 17 Child Labor 19 Babylift Operations Continue 21 The Forgotten Ones During the Coronavirus Pandemic: Child 23 Refugees Refugees and Global Child Trade 25 Importance of Education for 29 Orphans Endnotes 32 Annex - IHH Orphan Aid Activity 35 Karagümrük Mh. Kaleboyu Cd. Muhtar Muhittin Sk. No:6 PK.34091 Fatih / İstanbul - TURKEY www.insamer.com • info.insamer.com APRIL 2021 REPORT ORPHAN AND ORPHANHOOD One definition of orphan all cultures agree their parents or both. In the Islamic on is a pre-adolescent child who has lost tradition, a paternal orphan is a child who has lost a father while a mater- either of their parents or both.
    [Show full text]
  • More Care for You, and Everyone in Your Family
    Children More care for you, and Find babysitters, nannies, special needs everyone in your family caregivers, tutors, childcare centers and last-minute care. Balancing your work-life with your responsibilities at home is never easy. And although everyone’s situation is unique, there’s one thing we share. We all need a little help every now and then. With Care.com, you’ve got someone on your side—to help bring quality care to you and your family. Adults & Seniors Discover senior Finding the care you need couldn’t be easier. Simply: caregivers, companion SIGN UP BROWSE CONNECT services, special for your free thousands of with caregivers that needs caregivers, Premium Membership caregiver profi les, meet your needs, directly transportation providers and with Care.com, the view reference through Care.com housing. largest online and access messaging. Interview destination for care. background and hire the one check options. that works for you. Pe t s Search pet sitters, dog walkers, pet transportation, grooming and obedience trainers. Home & Lifestyle Access housekeepers, errand runners, house sitters and more. Visit nibri.care.com and log in with your work email address to start your Premium Membership. Care.com and “There for you” are service marks or registered service marks of Care.com, Inc © 2014 Care.com, Inc. All rights reserved. Get the most from your Care.com membership Use these tools and tips and fi nd care, fast. There’s a lot you can do with your Care.com membership. And it all starts with fi nding the perfect caregiver. Here’s how: POST A JOB—and let our caregivers know exactly what you need.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychological Characteristics of Adolescents Orphans with Different Experience of Living in a Family
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL & SCIENCE EDUCATION 2016, VOL. 11, NO. 17, 10493-10504 OPEN ACCESS Psychological Characteristics of Adolescents Orphans with Different Experience of Living in a Family Tatyana I. Shulgaa, Daria D. Savchenkoa and Evgeniya B. Filinkovaa a Moscow State Regional University, Moscow, RUSSIA ABSTRACT The complexity of settling adolescents-orphans in foster families and significant number of break-downs in these families are the problems which determine the relevance of current research. Many adolescent orphans get in social institutions repeatedly, because their psychological features lead to difficulties that their foster parents are unable to cope with. These features hereby need to be thoroughly studied. This article presents the study of psychological features of adolescents with different experiences of living in a family. Research complex of 17 psycho-diagnostic methods allowed to reveal specific differences in psychology of adolescents-orphans without experience of living in a family, compared with adolescents who live in orphan institutions, but have the experience of living in a family and with adolescents living in a family since their birth. It was found that family deprivation violates psychological development of adolescents. The violation manifests itself in the specificity of their emotional intelligence and regulatory functions, reduction of social intelligence and level of sociability, as well as in specific self-image (negative self-attitude, uncertainty, distrust of the world, particular attitude to the future and the prospects of life, etc.) and perception of the other (distorted attitude towards the family and its members, negative view of parent-child relationship and child functions, etc.). The results obtained are of interest for children psychologists and social workers.
    [Show full text]
  • Parenting and Child Care Services
    Parenting and Child Care Support. Just When You Need It. “ Finding the right daycare for my child’s needs was a stressful project. CONCERN set my mind at ease by helping me find the best option for m y f a m i l y.” Parenting is the most important job New Baby Kit you’ll ever have, and it’s also the most Education and resources for baby’s first year rewarding. But working full-time while Childcare resources and referrals trying to raise a smart, healthy, and Family day care, childcare center, nanny well-rounded child can be challenging. Adoption services CONCERN makes it simple to find the Local and National organizations help and support you need. Programs for children with special needs Support and advocacy, in-home caregivers All parents want what’s best for their children. Academic services As they grow and mature, what’s best for them Public and private schools, before and after school will change. One day you’re helping them take programs, college search, and financial aid their first steps and the next you’ll be moving them into college. CONCERN is here to help Services for at-risk or high-risk adolescents you find resources and support through every Summer care options stage of your child’s development, from bringing Sports, academic and fine arts programs them home for the first time, to their first homecoming dance, and everything in between. Tutors, mentors, and enrichment programs Call our toll free number and ask for a Parenting Call: 800.344.4222 and Childcare consultant who can assist you with every step of your child’s development.
    [Show full text]
  • “Don't Worry, It's Just a Tool”: Enacting Selectively Enforced Laws Such As
    “Don’t Worry, It’s Just a Tool”: Enacting Selectively Enforced Laws Such as Curfew Laws Targeting Only the Bad Guys Margaret Anne Cleek, John A. Youril, Michael Youril, and Richard Guarino* Volume 7 – No. 1 – Spring 2010 *Margaret A. Cleek is a Professor of Management in the College of Business Administration at California State University, Sacramento. John A. Youril is a writer and community activist with particular interest in constitutional issues and juvenile rights. Michael D. Youril is currently enrolled in law school at the University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law. Richard Guarino is an Emeritus Professor of Business Law in the College of Business, California State University Sacramento. Abstract The United States Constitution is in place to protect the rights of the citizens. Yet, the current environment leans towards the enactment of more and more laws at all levels of government which erode or eliminate those rights. It is suggested that the fear and chaos of these stressful and uncertain times results in a willingness on the part of legislators and the public that elects them to trade freedom for security. This can have disastrous consequences. Cicero (42BC) observed, “When people are willing to give up rights for security, they will, in the end, lose both.” This paper examines how laws which violate civil rights, such as curfew laws are passed by municipalities and accepted by the community with an understanding that they will only be selectively enforced against “the bad guys”. Citizens are told by law enforcement that they need such laws as a “tool” and without them they are powerless to deal with the problem population.
    [Show full text]