MIGRANTES
COURT OF CATANIA
ITALY
“The Crystal Scale of Justice” Edinburgh, 27th october 2017 DISEMBARKATIO N AND ASYLUM 170.100 181.436 DATA IN ITALY 153.842 105.456
93.000 averag e
61.000 42.925
4.348 13.200
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 [July] APULIA
CAMPANIA
SARDINIA
CALABRIA
63,51% italian Sicily as Italy’s main disembarkatio n disembarkation site. ITALIANITALIAN ASYLUM ASYLUM DECISIONS DECISIONS (TERRITORIAL COMMISSIONS) (TERRITORIAL COMMISSIONS)
80000
60000 Denial 93 % Appealable judgments 40000
Humanitarian protection 20000
Subsidiary protection
0 FULL protection 2013 2014 2015 2016 NEW 3.230 PROCEEDING S REGISTERED EFFECTS ON JUDICIAL 2.386 SYSTEM Court of Catania/1 1.628
NEW + PROCEEDINGS 514% REGISTERED [compared to 2013] 526
AVERAGE 244 PROCEEDINGS REGISTERED per month [2016] 2013 2014 2015 2016 Year 6568 EFFECTS ON JUDICIAL
SYSTEM 4586 Court of Catania/2
2132 PENDING + 470% PROCEEDINGS [compared to 2013] 1113 1153
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 MIGRANTES
COURT OF CATANIA
An institutional, social and professional network aimed at granting rights effectively THE INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK
The project is a result of a three-way collaboration among: - the European Social Fund, managed by the sicilian region in 2015 (2007-2013 \ 2014- 2020 ESF - Pillar VII “Institutional Capacity” -); - in partnership with FormezPA - and the involvement of University of Catania NETWORK POINTS
PREFECTURE HOTSPOT TERRITORIAL COURT COURT OF COMMISSION APPEAL
DISEMBARKATION DAILY FIRST APPRAISAL FIRST APPEAL SECOND APPEAL MANAGEMENT MANAGEMENT
Stakeholders in asylum procedures flux SETTING UP THE NETWORK - organisation & management
• Double analysis focused on critical management issues • Double flow monitoring TERRITORIAL COURT OF COURT OF activities COMMISSION CATANIA APPEAL
• Best practice dissemination • National working group to improve information technology NATIONAL COURT OF MINISTRY ASYLUM tools CATANIA OF JUSTICE COMMISSION • New statistics tools
• Internships for international relations’ students • Multidisciplinary teams COURT OF UNIVERSITY supporting the Judges’ work CATANIA OF CATANIA SETTING UP the NETWORK- training
COURT OF COURT OF TERRITORIAL COURT OF SUPERIOR CATANIA CATANIA COMMISSION CATANIA SCHOOL FOR Ministry of THE JUDICIARY Interior
CATANIA UNIVERSITY BAR OF CATANIA ASSOCIATION
• Work group to • Informative seminars and • Creation of improve discussion forums for specific courses documentation magistrates and internship provided in the students proceeding files OUR RESULTS
PROCEEDINGS DISPOSED PROCEEDINGS 1248 + 86% DISPOSED [2016 compared to 2015]
668 -66 % DISPOSITION TIME [2016] 609 566
+ 168 % CLEARANCE RATE [2015 compared to the end of 2016]
2013 2014 2015 2016 OUR RESULTS/2
COSTS SAVED SUPPORT to € PER YEAR TASK judge studing 70.000 [official FORCE activities notification]
EXTENSION of Creation of a CASE computerised TASK court FLOW workflow to FORCE database with territorial information commission sheets of COI The project, started in 2015 thanks to then-President of the Court of Catania, Mr. Bruno Di Marco, to date is managed by: • Mr. Francesco MANNINO, President of the Court of Catania • Mr. Mariano SCIACCA, Migrantes project Coordinator - President Fifth Civil Department • Mr. Gianni DI PIETRO, President First Civil Department - Migrants • Ms. Raffaela FINOCCHIARO, organizational analyst for Cisia Catania – Ministry of Justice • Mr. Calogero COMMANDATORE, Judge of the Court of Catania • Mr. Cristiana COSENTINO, Judge First Civil Department of the Court of Catania • Ms. Viviana DI GESU, Judge First Civil Department of the Court of Catania • Ms. Mariapaola SABATINO, Judge First Civil Department of the Court of Catania • Ms. Agata PORTO, Managing Director First Civil Department
Consulents and external partners: • dott.sssa Annapina CUCCURULLO, FormezPA; • dott. Giuseppina VALENTI, viceprefect territorial Commission of Catania; • dott.ssa Chiara ARMENIA, viceprefect territorial Commission of Siracuse and Ragusa • dott. Simone ROSSI, organizational analyst FormezPA; • dott.ssa Arianna TONIOLO, organizational analyst FormezPA; • Dott. Fulvio VENTURA, organizational analyst FormezPA • Prof.ssa Francesca LONGO, University of Catania – Faculty of political and social sciences; • Prof.ssa Stefania PANEBIANCO, University of Catania – Faculty of political and social sciences; • Dott.ssa Loredana GRANATA - Faculty of political and social sciences; • Trainers of department – Faculty of political and social sciences WORK WITH US