DOCSLIB.ORG

Final Thesis Shahram Rafieian Koupaei.Pdf

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Final Thesis Shahram Rafieian Koupaei.Pdf Bangor University DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Dissociation, unconscious and social theory : towards an embodied relational sociology Rafieian Koupaei, Shahram Award date: 2015 Awarding institution: Bangor University Link to publication General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal ? Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 29. Sep. 2021 Dissociation, unconscious and social theory towards an embodied relational sociology Thesis submitted for examination for: PhD in Sociology and Social Policy Shahram Rafieian koupaei School of Social Sciences Bangor University 2015 I hereby declare that (i) the thesis is not one for which a degree has been or will be conferred by any other university or institution; (ii) the thesis is not one for which a degree has already been conferred by this University; (iii) the work for the thesis is my own work and that, where material submitted by me for another degree or work undertaken by me as part of a research group has been incorporated into the thesis, the extent of the work thus incorporated has been clearly indicated. (iv) the composition of the thesis is my own work. Shahram Rafieian koupaei I agree to deposit an electronic copy of my thesis (the Work) in the Bangor University (BU) Institutional Digital Repository, the British Library ETHOS system, and/or in any other repository authorized for use by Bangor University and where necessary have gained the required permissions for the use of third party material. Shahram Rafieian koupaei i Abstract The recent attention which has been paid in sociology to the role of embodiment, intersubjectivity and reflexivity has resulted in the development of new social theories which aim to provide better explanations of structure and agency interactions and the dynamics of self and identity formation. In the process of the development of these theories, social theorists have often communicated with other relevant disciplines such as social psychology and psychoanalysis. Clearly, new developments in these related disciplines are likely to have relevance for micro-sociological theories. The aim of this project is to further develop modern micro-sociological theories in the light of new ideas in social psychology and recent understandings in psychoanalysis. Drawing on the ideas of relational psychoanalysis and relational sociology I have tried to define a dynamic unconscious in social theory and a fluid conceptualization of self and identity by applying the concept of dissociation as the key mechanism for shifting between different self-states. Also, based on the theories of Pierre Bourdieu, Anthony Giddens and Margaret Archer, the relationship between reflexivity and habitus is explored, different levels of reflexivity and various forms of consciousness are considered, and these interactions are further investigated using the two examples of sports training and hypnotic involuntariness. Using hypnosis as a model, the development of social self and embodied agency is explored in depth in this context. Furthermore, as a real-life example, the role of subjectivity, relationality and embodiment in doctor-patient relationships is investigated using findings in the research fields of hypnosis and placebo. In conclusion, based on the conceptualization made in this research, the place of two consciousness modalities (discursive and practical) and forms of unconscious (psychological and psychoanalytical) is clarified. Finally, the implications of this categorization for understanding core concepts such as agency, self and identity are explored and some suggestions are made for the further development and application of the theories explored in this project. ii Acknowledgements My deepest gratitude to Professor Howard Davis who supervised this dissertation and whose insightful questions, constructive criticisms and comments supported my work. Without his encouragement and help this research would never have been completed. I would like to express my deepest appreciation to my wife Sima for providing help and support in completing this difficult task. I am very grateful to my parents for their encouragement throughout my academic life. Also I thank my wife’s parents for their support. I dedicate this work to my wife and her parents, my parents and also to Homa, Nasrin and Bahram. This work would not have been possible without the 125th Anniversary Research Scholarship awarded by Bangor University (2012-2015). iii Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction .......................................................................................................... 1 Thesis Overview ........................................................................................................... 9 Chapter 2: Self, Identity and the Relational Approach in Sociology and Psychoanalysis .. 19 Relational sociology and relational psychoanalysis ................................................... 22 Peirce, human subjectivity and the unconscious ........................................................ 26 Dialogical unconscious ............................................................................................... 35 Body and embodiment ................................................................................................ 37 Discussion and concluding remarks ........................................................................... 39 Chapter 3: Recovering the value of the concepts of dissociation and unconscious for social theory ................................................................................................................................... 41 Dissociation and the relational context ....................................................................... 43 Self and dynamics of identity formation ..................................................................... 50 Self states, Erving Goffman’s dramaturgy and Judith Butler’s performativity .......... 57 Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 60 Chapter 4: Habitus and Psychological Automatism ............................................................ 62 The concept of habitus ................................................................................................ 63 Psychological origins of habitus ................................................................................. 66 Psychological automatism .......................................................................................... 69 Psychological unconscious and social life .................................................................. 72 Automatism, agency and determinism ........................................................................ 75 Habitus and psychological automatism ...................................................................... 76 Conclusion .................................................................................................................. 81 Chapter 5: Dissociation, reflexivity and habitus ................................................................. 83 iv Theories of reflexivity in modern social theory ......................................................... 84 Habitus, reflexivity and unconscious ......................................................................... 86 Dissociative theory of mind ....................................................................................... 89 Habitus and internal conversation .............................................................................. 95 Conclusion ................................................................................................................ 102 Chapter 6: A sociological analysis of hypnosis: development of social self and phenomenology of agency ................................................................................................ 104 The nature of hypnosis ............................................................................................. 106 Hypnosis and development of social self ................................................................. 108 Goffman’s dramaturgy and Turner’s anthropology of performance ........................ 110 Acting, embodiment and alteration of consciousness .............................................. 112 Phenomenology of volition and social agency ......................................................... 113 Agency and embodied self-reflexivity ..................................................................... 118 Culture, role taking, rituals and alteration of consciousness .................................... 120 Summary and concluding remarks ........................................................................... 121 Chapter 7: Hypnosis, placebo and performance: recovering the relational aspects of medicine ...........................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Adult Learner: a Neglected Species. INSTITUTION American Society for Training and Development, Madison, Wis
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 084 368 CE 000 509 AUTHOR Knowles, Malcolm TITLE The Adult Learner: A Neglected Species. INSTITUTION American Society for Training and Development, Madison, Wis. PUB DATE Apr 73 NOTE 207p. AVAILABLE FROM Gulf Publishing Company, P.O. Box 2608, Houston, TX 77001 ($7.95) EDRS PRICE MF-$0.65 HC Not Available from EDRS. DESCRIPTORS *Adult Education; *Adult Learning; Behavior Patterns; *Human Resources; Individual Development; Learning Characteristics; Learning Experience; Learning Motivation; *Learning Theories; Manpower Development; Organizational Development; Teaching Models; *Teaching Techniques; Training ABSTRACT Traditional theories of learning and the teaching practices resulting from them are reviewed. Most theories of adult learning are based on research into the learning of children, which in turn is founded upon theories of animal learning. These theories, formulated under laboratory conditions, are artificial at best--and not complex enough to apply to adult human beings. Emerging theories of adult learning, however, are Lased on the unique characteristics of adults as learners and result in differentiated educational practices. Human resource development (BED) is based on many of these newer theories and serves as a guideline for action. Knowles' andragogical theory is based on four assumptions which differ from those of pedagogy: (1) changes in self-concept,(2) the role of experience, (3) readiness to learn, and (4) orientation to learning. As a guideline for developing programs and for selecting andtraining teachers, the andragogical model of HRD is very applicab?e. Among the appendixes are "Is It Skinner or Nothing" and "An Approach to a Differential Psychology of the Adult Potential." There is a eleven-page bibliography.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Psychology
    The Psych 101 Series James C. Kaufman, PhD, Series Editor Department of Educational Psychology University of Connecticut David C. Devonis, PhD, received his doctorate in the history of psychology from the University of New Hampshire’s erstwhile pro- gram in that subject in 1989 with a thesis on the history of conscious pleasure in modern American psychology. Since then he has taught vir- tually every course in the psychology curriculum in his academic odys- sey from the University of Redlands in Redlands, California, and the now-closed Teikyo Marycrest University (formerly Marycrest College in Davenport, Iowa) to—for the past 17 years—Graceland University in Lamoni, Iowa, alma mater of Bruce Jenner and, more famously for the history of psychology, of Noble H. Kelly (1901–1997), eminent con- tributor to psychology’s infrastructure through his many years of ser- vice to the American Board of Examiners in Professional Psychology. Dr. Devonis has been a member of Cheiron: The International Society for the History of Behavioral and Social Sciences since 1990, a con- tributor to many of its activities, and its treasurer for the past 10 years. Currently he is on the editorial board of the American Psychological Association journal History of Psychology and is, with Wade Pickren, coeditor and compiler of the online bibliography History of Psychology in the Oxford Bibliographies Online series. History of Psychology 101 David C. Devonis, PhD Copyright © 2014 Springer Publishing Company, LLC All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or trans- mitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior permission of Springer Publishing Company, LLC, or authorization through payment of the appropriate fees to the Copyright Clearance Cen- ter, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600, [email protected] or on the Web at www.copyright.com.
    [Show full text]
  • TANREND 2015/2016 Elektív És Fakultatív Tárgyak
    Pécsi Tudományegyetem Általános Orvostudományi Kar ÁLTALÁNOS ORVOS SZAK TANREND 2015/2016 Elektív és fakultatív tárgyak PTE ÁOK Általános orvos szak – Elektív és fakultatív modul - tantárgyleírások - 2015/2016-os tanév 1. szemeszter OOE-AKF _____ Alapfogalmak és közlési funkciók az angol orvosi szaknyelvben ________________________________ 8 OOE-BFA _____ A biofizika fizikai alapjai ______________________________________________________________ 10 OOE-BO1 _____ Biofizika szemináriumok 1. ____________________________________________________________ 12 OOE-ELH _____ Elhízás - a modern kor „járványa” _______________________________________________________ 13 OOE-ESO _____ Egészség-szociológia _________________________________________________________________ 15 OOE-IKG _____ Interkulturelle Kommunikation in Gesundheitsberufen _______________________________________ 17 OOE-JNK _____ Jelnyelvi kommunikáció az orvosi praxisban ______________________________________________ 19 OOE-KRM ____ Krisenmanagement bei Studium um Arbeit im Bereich Medizin _______________________________ 21 OOE-MS1 _____ Molekuláris sejtbiológiai kísérletek I. ____________________________________________________ 23 OOE-N06 _____ Orvosi terminológia __________________________________________________________________ 25 OOE-ORE _____ Orvosi rehabilitáció a gyakorlatban ______________________________________________________ 27 OOE-SMA _____ Szakszövegalkotás és szaknyelvi műfajok az angol orvosi szaknyelvben _________________________ 29 OOE-SSS _____ Sprache, Spracherwerb,
    [Show full text]
  • The Persuaders: Nonbehavioristic Psychologists
    The Persuaders 271 high as well when the community is persuaded to change and it accepts a successful Persuader as a guide for some time. Practically all the "great names" in the history of science can be viewed as successful Persuaders. This chapter presents two apparently successful Persuaders and two relatively unsuccessful ones. At any one time there are probably many The Persuaders: unsuccessful Persuaders in a scientific community. They may be said to represent the seeds of potential change; but most of these seeds fall Nonbehavioristic Psychologists on arid ground. The chances of success for any Persuader is small. Yet without the presence of such people, the scientific community would be Whoso would be a man must be a non-conformist. -RALPH WALDOEMERSON left with no coherent program of development when its current course faltered. Timing is a critical ingredient in the process of successful persua- ~ion.In psychology as elsewhere, a receptive audience is one that has almost arrived at the same conclusion by itself. Thus, Plans and the Struc- Although behaviorism unquestionably dominated scientific psychology ture ofBehiuiio~,by George A. Miller, Eugene Galanter, and Karl Pribram, until well into the 1950s, there were numerous cross-currents even in had a significant impact on the cognitive revolution, in part because it the heyday of behaviorism. I have already pointed to social psychology appeared in 1960, just as many psychologists were preparing to think as one field in which many of the major developments in the cognitive more cognitively. Had it bee$ published five years earlier, it would have framework were foreshadowed (Chapter 4).
    [Show full text]
  • PCS AP Psych 0280
    A Planned Course of Study for Advanced Placement Psychology ASHS Course # 0280 Abington School District Abington, Pennsylvania September, 2016 a. Objectives Students will demonstrate the appropriate level of proficiency in each of the following areas: History and Approaches • Recognize how philosophical and physiological perspectives shaped the development of psychological thought . • Describe and compare different theoretical approaches in explaining behavior: — structuralism, functionalism, and behaviorism in the early years; — Gestalt, psychoanalytic/psychodynamic, and humanism emerging later; — evolutionary, biological, cognitive, and biopsychosocial as more contemporary approaches . • Recognize the strengths and limitations of applying theories to explain behavior . • Distinguish the different domains of psychology (e .g ., biological, clinical, cognitive, counseling, developmental, educational, experimental, human factors, industrial–organizational, personality, psychometric, social) . • Identify major historical figures in psychology (e .g ., Mary Whiton Calkins, Charles Darwin, Dorothea Dix, Sigmund Freud, G . Stanley Hall, William James, Ivan Pavlov, Jean Piaget, Carl Rogers, B . F . Skinner, Margaret Floy Washburn, John B . Watson, Wilhelm Wundt) Research Methods • Differentiate types of research (e .g ., experiments, correlational studies, survey research, naturalistic observations, case studies) with regard to purpose, strengths, and weaknesses . • Describe how research design drives the reasonable conclusions that can be
    [Show full text]
  • Thinking About Trance Over a Century: the Making of a Set of Impasses
    Thinking about Trance Over a Century: The Making of a Set of Impasses The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Harrington, Anne. 2016. Thinking about Trance Over a Century: The Making of a Set of Impasses. In Hypnosis and meditation: Towards an integrative science of conscious planes, eds. Michael Lifshitz and Amir Raz. New York: Oxford University Press. Published Version https://global.oup.com/academic/product/hypnosis-and- meditation-9780198759102?cc=us&lang=en&# Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:33439060 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Open Access Policy Articles, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#OAP Part 2 Philosophical, historical, and cultural perspectives Chapter 2 Thinking about trance over a century The making of a set of impasses Anne Harrington Abstract Despite differences in methods and (usually) goals, both hypnosis and meditation involve an unusual state of awareness, generally known as “trance.” Yet, the idea of trance, as an object of scholarly and scientific study, turns out to have been marked, historically, by confusion and controversy. Is trance one thing or many things? A regression to a pathological, primitive state or ascent to an elevated state? Noisy or quiet? Biological or social? Meditation researchers, hypnosis researchers, and anthropologists (interested in phenomena like shamanism and spirit possession) have all, historically, struggled with questions like these in surprisingly similar ways.
    [Show full text]
  • NATURE APRIL 30, 1966 Vot..210
    456 NATURE APRIL 30, 1966 Vot..210 Studies on the Piriform Lobe noses, attitudes to hypnosis and responses to various By F. Valverde. Pp. vii+l31. (Cambridge, Mass.: personality inventories. Although some significant corre­ Harvard University Press; London: Oxford University lations do emerge, they are insufficient to characterize Press, 1965.) 60s. net. the hypnotizable person clearly. One of the final chapters is written by the wife of the author, who makes some lobe', Dr. Valverde ITHIN the term 'piriform very interesting inferences from clinical case studies. W includes the olfactory bulb, parolfactory structures, The presentation of these susceptibility scales is the together with their pro­ piriform cortex and amygdala, central point of the book. However, it also provides a j ection systems. The first part of this work consists of comprehensive and up-to-date review of present-day in various parts of the several experiments with lesions knowledge on this ill-understood subject. It is a valuable degeneration stained by the forebrain and the resulting book not only to those concerned with the more academic Nauta m ethod. The second part comprises Golgi studies aspects of psychology, but also to those who make use of of the relevant areas. hypnosis in the clinical field. A considerable amount of Attempting, as it does, to provide comprehensive space is given to statistical procedures, which does tend of central olfactory con­ coverage of the whole system to make it heavy reading for those not specifically in­ achieves considerable nexions, Dr. Valverde's monograph terested in this aspect, but a brief and succinct summary is unity of purpose, although there are inevitably many given at the end of each chapter.
    [Show full text]
  • AP Psychology Curriculum
    AP Psychology Curriculum Course Description: Advanced Placement Psychology is the equivalent of a college introductory psychology course. This is a rigorous and demanding course, intended to provide the scope and level of accomplishment expected in a college/university setting. The curriculum for this course places a heavy emphasis on essential readings, writing assignments, independent projects, and frequent tests intended to prepare students for the AP Exam. The instructor's role is to facilitate your drive and accomplishment by structuring learning situations and selecting learning tools to help you attain your goals: a successful score on the AP Psychology Exam, an enrichment of your life through the acquisition of psychological knowledge, and enjoyment of the course. Scope and Sequence: Timeframe Unit Instructional Topics 1-3 Class Periods History & Topic 1: Philosophical and Historical Development as Approaches Psychology as a Science Topic 2: Contemporary Viewpoints of Analyzing Behavior 3-5 Class Periods Memory Topic 1: Physiological Bases of Memory Topic 2: Psychological Stems and Bases of Memory Topic 3: Scientific Contributions to Understanding Memory 3-5 Class Periods Research Topic 1: Research Methodologies Methods and Topic 2: Statistical Analyzes Statistics Topic 3: Ethical Issues of Research 6-7 Class Periods Social Topic 1: Social Cognition Topic 2: Social Influence Topic 3: Group Behavior and Influences Topic 4: Antisocial Behavior Topic 5: Prosocial Behavior 7-8 Class Periods Biopsychology Topic 1: Neuroscience Topic
    [Show full text]
  • Psychologues Américains
    Psychologues américains A G (suite) M (suite) • Robert Abelson • Gustave M. Gilbert • Christina Maslach • Gordon Willard • Carol Gilligan • Abraham Maslow Allport • Stephen Gilligan • David McClelland • Richard Alpert • Daniel Goleman • Phil McGraw • Dan Ariely • Thomas Gordon • Albert Mehrabian • Solomon Asch • Temple Grandin • Stanley Milgram • Blake Ashforth • Clare Graves • Geoffrey Miller • David Ausubel • Joy Paul Guilford (psychologue) • Moubarak Awad • George Armitage H Miller B • Theodore Millon • G. Stanley Hall • James Baldwin • Daria Halprin N (psychologue) • Harry Harlow • Theodore Barber • Alan Hartman • Ulric Neisser • Gregory Bateson • Torey Hayden • Richard Noll • Diana Baumrind • Frederick Herzberg • Alex Bavelas • Ernest Hilgard O • Don Beck • James Hillman • Benjamin Bloom • Allan Hobson • James Olds • Edwin Garrigues • John L. Holland Boring • John Henry Holland P • Loretta Bradley • Evelyn Hooker • Nathaniel Branden • Carl Hovland • Baron Perlman • Urie Bronfenbrenner • Clark Leonard Hull • Walter Pitts • Joyce Brothers • Jerome Bruner J R • David Buss • Howard Buten • William James • Joseph Banks Rhine • Kay Redfield Jamison • Kenneth Ring C • Irving Janis • Judith Rodin • Arthur Janov • Carl Rogers • John Bissell Carroll • Joseph Jastrow • Milton Rokeach • James McKeen Cattell • Julian Jaynes • Eleanor Rosch • Raymond Cattell • Arthur Jensen • Marshall Rosenberg • Cary Cherniss • Frank Rosenblatt • Robert Cialdini K • Robert Rosenthal • Mary Cover Jones • Julian Rotter • Lee Cronbach • Daniel Kahneman • Paul Rozin
    [Show full text]
  • Behavioral Sciences” Label Jefferson D
    ARTICLE A “Not Particularly Felicitous” Phrase: A History of the “Behavioral Sciences” Label Jefferson D. Pooley [email protected] Abstract The article reconstructs the history of the "behavioral sciences" label, from scattered interwar use through to the decisive embrace of the newly prominent Ford Foundation in the early Cold War. The rapid uptake of the label, the article concludes, was the result of the Ford Foundation’s 1951 decision to name its social science unit the “Behavioral Sciences Program” (BSP). With Ford’s en- couragement, the term was widely adopted by quantitative social scientists eager to tap the founda- tion’s social science funds. The label’s newness and its link to the gigantic foundation’s initiative generated much suspicion and resistance as well. Keywords Behavioral sciences, Ford Foundation, Cold War There are few behavioral scientists today. But as recently as the 1950s and 1960s, self-identified “behavioral scientists” occupied the elite ranks of American social science. The rapid uptake of the label was the result of the Ford Foundation’s 1951 decision to name its social science unit the “Be- havioral Sciences Program” (BSP). With Ford’s encouragement, the term was widely adopted by quantitative social scientists eager to tap the foundation’s social science funds. The label’s newness and its link to the gigantic foundation’s initiative generated much suspicion and resistance as well. This paper reconstructs the label’s career from scattered interwar use through to Ford’s embrace. Existing histories trace the term back to psychologist James Grier Miller’s Committee on the Be- havioral Sciences at the University of Chicago.
    [Show full text]
  • The General Psychologist
    A Publication of the Society WILLIAM JAMES BOOK AWARD for General Psychology Division One The Blank Slate of the American Psychological Association by Steven Pinker, Harvard University INSIDE THIS ISSUE Steven Pinker is the Johnstone Family Professor in the Department of Psychology at de Waal: The Most Bipolar Ape Harvard University. For his book, The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Na- ..........................9 ture, the Society for General Psychology awarded Dr. Pinker the William James Book Award for 2003. The following essay, based on his invited address at the 2005 APA con- Koltko-Rivera: Worldviews vention, draws on material in the book. .........................11 Sternberg: Still Hope of Unity .........................15 uman nature is a topic of perennial interest, because every- Bitterman: Conditioning one has a theory of human nature. All of us have to anticipate ........................16 Hhow people will react to their surroundings, and that means that we all need theories, implicit or explicit, about what makes Mentoring people tick. .........................17 So much depends on our theory of human nature. In our private lives we use it to win friends and influence people, to manage our A Word from Our President relationships, to bring up our children, to control our own behavior. .........................18 Its assumptions about learning guide our policies in education; its Steven Pinker 2006 Convention Program assumptions about motivation guide our policies in law and poli- .........................19 tics. And because the theory of human nature delineates what we can achieve easily, what we can achieve only with effort and sacrifice, and what we cannot achieve at all, it’s tied to Announcements our values: what we think we can reasonably strive for as individuals and as a society.
    [Show full text]
  • Talking the Hype out of Hypnosis and a Look at Its Entrancing Use in Pain
    CuFwentEamments” EUGENE GARFIELD INSTITUTE FOR SCIENTIFIC INFORMATION* 3501 MARK ET ST, PHILADELPHIA, PA 191C4 Taking the Hype Out of Hypnosis and a Look at Its Entrancing Use in Pain Control Number 3 Januarv ,, 19, 1987 In the most hackneyed depictions of hyp- Chinese, Egyptians, and Gre&s.2 There nosis on television and in the movies, the are even rdlusions in the Bible to activities hypnotic subject is invariably shown star- that are hypnotic in character. Historical ac- ing at a swinging pocket watch or pendu- counts of hypnotism in the modem era gen- lum while repeating the instructions of the erally begin with Franz Anton Mesmer hypnotist in a halting monotone. Once the (1734-18 15), an Austrian physician whose “trance” is broken through a snap of the name survives in the word “mesmerize. ” fingers or some other hypnotically suggested Mesmer is most often associated with the signal, the subject awakens, fully if uncon- theory of “animal magnetism. ” As dis- sciously prepared to perform whatever deed cussed by Henri F. Ellenberger, Universi- the hypnotist has directed. Other popular no- ty of Montreal, Canada, in 7?seDiscovery tions surrounding hypnotism no doubt de- of the Unconscious, the theory involved the rive from entertainers known as stage hyp- existence of a subtle physical fluid that sup- notists, who induce volunteers from their au- posedly filled the universe and connected hu- diences to engage in comic or ribald behav- mans, the earth, and the heavenly bodies. ior for the amusement of the others. Believing that disease originated from an These distorted, inaccurate views do not imbalance of this magnetic fluid in the do justice to the serious discipline of clini- human body, Mesmer maintained that cal hypnosis.
    [Show full text]