Indigenous tree and shrub species for soil fertility improvement in Galessa and Jeldu areas, Western Shewa,

Kindu Mekonnen, Gerhard Glatzel and Monika Sieghardt

Institute of Forest Ecology, UNI BOKU, Peter-Jordan Strasse 82, A-1190, Vienna, Austria. Email: [email protected]

Abstract A study was conducted from 2004 to 2006 to identify and prioritise indigenous species for soil fertility improvement, and to assess soil properties, nutrient concentration and other quality characteristics of green biomass of indigenous tree and shrub species. The most preferred species for soil fertility improvement in Galessa-Jeldu areas were Senecio gigas, Hagenia abyssinica, Dombeya torrida and Buddleja polystachya. The foliage and flower bud of S. gigas contained a higher P and K content. H. abyssinica had less lignin content in its foliage and flower bud. The variation among species for soluble phenolics in the foliage was from 10 to 169 mg g-1 and in the flower bud from 9 to 234 mg g-1. The soil pH values under H. abyssinica and S. gigas were >6.34. The soil organic C content at 0-15cm depth was higher under H. abyssinica than under B. polystachya. Similarly, the soil under H. abyssinica and S. gigas had a high content of K at the 0-15cm depth. The contents of organic C, N, P, K, Ca and Mg showed a decreasing pattern from the top to the lower soil depths and from the closest to the distant horizontal positions. The soil under the vicinity of H. abysinica, S. gigas and Chamaecytisus palmensis contained a substantial amount of soil nutrients. Hence, the three species should be tested in farmlands and other land-use types of the high altitude areas, where soil erosion and soil depletion are critical problems.

95 1. Introduction and prioritise indigenous species for soil Soil degradation, poor crop productivity fertility improvement and (b) to assess and limited vegetation diversity are soil properties, nutrient concentration major problems in high altitude (> 2900) and other quality characteristics of green Galessa-Jeldu areas (German et al. 2005). biomass of indigenous tree and shrub The local people utilise both indigenous species. and introduced practices to manage soil degradation problems. Trees can potentially improve soils through numerous 2. Materials and methods processes, including maintenance or The study area is situated in the upper increase of soil organic matter, uptake of plateaus of and Jeldu weredas nutrients from below the reach of crop (districts) of western Shewa zone, roots, biological N-fixation, reduced loss region, Ethiopia (Figure 1). The altitude of of nutrients by erosion and leaching, the study area ranges from 2900 to 3200m. increased water infiltration and storage, Barley is the most dominant crop, followed improved soil-physical properties, reduced by potato and enset (Ensete ventricosum). soil acidity and improved soil-biological The soil is characterised as Haplic Luvisol. activity (Young 1997). The chemical and physical properties of the soil are shown in Table 1. The use of green biomass of tree and shrub species is one of the traditional Two weredas (districts) and four kebeles practices that are currently in use in the (lower administrative units in the Galessa-Jeldu areas to improve soil fertility government structure) in the highlands and thereby increase crop productivity. of central Ethiopia were considered for This type of approach helps to sustain the study. Accessibility and diversity of agricultural productivity in tropical regions soil improving species were given much where the use of mineral fertilisers is attention for the selection of the study area. limited. Green biomass of trees and Tree and shrub species growing location shrubs can be classified into high quality, and composition were investigated through intermediate-high quality, intermediate- direct observation, as well as group and low quality and low quality (Palm et al. individual discussions approaches. The 2001). A high quality green biomass farmers’ tree species preference criteria for contains N >25mg g-1, lignin <150mg soil fertility improvement were identified g-1 and soluble phenolics <40mg g-1; and prioritised through group discussion. intermediate-high quality green biomass A total of 150 farmers (respondents) contains N >25mg g-1, lignin >150 mg g-1 participated for questionnaire survey or soluble phenolics >40 mg g-1; and low (Roothaert and Franzel 2001, Thapa et al. quality green biomass contains N <25 mg 1997, Morrison et al. 1996, Mayr 1996). g-1, lignin >150 mg g-1 or soluble phenolics >40 mg g-1. The capacity of the high Senecio gigas Vatke (basionym: Solanecio quality biomass to supply N is high and gigas (Vatke) C.Jeffrey; Kew Bull. 41(4): immediate. The low quality green biomass 923 (1986)), Hagenia abyssinica (Bruce) has a low direct nutrient effect and a high J.F. Gmel., Dombeya torrida (J.F. Gmel.) indirect mulching effect (Kumar et al. P. Bamps, Buddleja polystachya Fres. and 2003). Chamaecytisus palmensis (Christ) Bisby & K. Nicholls were included in the soil and Studies on soil properties under indigenous plant sampling scheme. Chamaecytisus species and nutrient concentration of palmensis (tree lucerne) was recently green biomass of trees are limited in the introduced an exotic N-fixing woody species. high altitude areas. A study was conducted A transect approach was considered for in Galessa - Jeldu areas (a) to identify soil sampling. Sampling locations were 75,

96 150 and 225cm distances (position) at both method (Olsen and Sommers 1982). sides from the base of each marked tree or Exchangeable element contents (K+, Ca2+, shrub species (Power et al. 2003, WEZEL Mg2+, Mn2+ and Al3+) were extracted from

2000, Hailu et al. 2000). Sampling depths air-dried samples with 0.1M NH4OAc at were 0-15, 15-30 and 30-50cm (Kindu et pH 7.0. The elements in the extracts were al. 1997). A total of 135 composite soil determined using a simultaneous ICP- samples were collected under the four OES. indigenous and one exotic tree and shrub species attributed as soil improvers. Soil A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) samples collected from similar depths and was carried out on CP, mineral composition, positions were thoroughly mixed to obtain ADF, NDF, ADL, condensed tannins and composite samples. IVDMD using SAS (SAS institute 1999). Significance between means was tested A total of 30 composite foliage and flower using the Least Significant Difference bud samples were collected from S. gigas, (LSD). H. abyssinica, D. torrida, B. polystachya and C. palmensis. Sub-samples were collected from all samples for water content 3. Results and discussion determination. The fresh mass of each sub-sample was immediately recorded 3.1. Tree and shrub species in the field. All foliage, stem and flower identified and ranked for soil fertility bud samples and sub-samples were oven- improvement dried at 80oC for 24 hours. The dry-mass Farmers identified more than 15 tree and of the sub-samples was recorded and the shrub species that they believe potential moisture percentage was calculated. for improving soil fertility (Table 2). The tree and shrub species located mainly The total N content of the foliage and flower around homesteads and in forests. About bud was determined by Kjeldahl digestion 92% of the farmers need to plant more using Na2SO4 and CuSO4 as catalysts. indigenous soil improving trees around Oven dried foliage and flower bud samples homesteads for better management and were extracted with a mixture of HNO3 protection purposes. Farmers ranked the and HClO4. The total P, K, Ca, Mg and S existing indigenous tree and shrub species content of the extracts were determined for soil fertility improvement based on by the use of a simultaneous ICP-OES their own criteria (Table 3). They also (Inductively Coupled Plasma – Optical considered change of soil colour, status of Emission Spectroscopy) with axial plasma soil moisture, crop growth and yield, and (Perkin Elmer, OPTIMA 3000 XL). soil structure as indictor for soil fertility improvement near or under the canopy or The soil pH was determined in 1:3 soil hedge of tree and shrub species. The most suspensions in deionised water for active preferred species for the farmers include: acidity, using a potentiometric pH-meter S. gigas, H. abyssinica and D. torrida (ÖNORM L1083 2005). Organic carbon (Table 4). was determined by C/S-Element analyzer LECO S/C 444, using oven-dry samples. Dry combustion at 1400oC in pure O2 3.2. Green biomass nutrient atmosphere and infrared detection of concentration and other quality evolved CO2 was applied (ÖNORM L1080, characteristics 2005). Total N was determined by the The macronutrients content in foliage Semi-micro-Kjeldahl procedure, using the and flower bud differed depending on the air-dry samples (ÖNORM L1082 2005). species. The content of N in the foliage of Available P was determined by the Olsen H. abyssinica was comparatively lower than

97 the N content of the other tree and shrub H. abyssinica is higher by 23.25, 24.53 and species (Figure 2). Similarly, C. palmensis 21.03mg g-1 than under B. polystachya in had a low N content in its flower bud as the closest, midst and distant positions, compared to the other four tree and shrub respectively (Table 6). Similarly, the species. Senecio gigas showed a higher P difference in soil N at the 0-15cm depth and K content in its foliage and flower bud. is 1.85, 2.27 and 1.83mg g-1. The content The high content of P, K and S in S. gigas of soil P has the following order in the top may be traced back to the scavenging of 0-15cm soil depth of the closest and midst these nutrients in a large soil volume and horizontal positions: H. abyssinica > S. their accumulation in the aboveground gigas > C. palmensis > D. torrida > B. organs. According to Garrity and Mercado polystachya (Table 7). The contents of K (1994), members of the Asteraceae family, vary significantly at the 0-15cm soil depth to which S. gigas belongs, are effective of the three horizontal positions. The soil nutrient scavengers. under H. abyssinica and S. gigas has a high content of soil K at the 0-15cm depth Hagenia abyssinica had less lignin content in all three horizontal positions. in its foliage and flower bud as compared to other species (Table 5). The lignin content The high content of OC, N, P and K under of H. abyssinica, D. torrida and S. gigas the vicinity of H. abyssinica as compared to was lower in the foliage than in the flower B. polystachya can be associated with the bud. On the other hand, B. polystachya fact that the former has a more efficient and C. plamensis had more lignin content nutrient cycling power than the latter. in their flower bud than in the foliage. H. abyssinica constantly sheds a high The lignin contents of the foliage of most amount of leaves and provides the soil in of our tree and shrub species are below its vicinity with mulch and green manure. the critical level of 150mg g-1 dry matter. Kindu et al. (2006) reported the presence Lignin content above 150mg g-1 impairs of a high amount of litter deposition under the decomposition of tree foliages, since 64 months old H. abyssinica and Grevillea lignin protects the cellulose in the cell robusta on Nitisols of central Ethiopia. D. wall from microbial attack (Chesson 1997, torrida and S. gigas shed a substantial Palm and Rowland 1997). amount of leaves, even though their leaf shedding pattern is not as regular as that The content of lignin and soluble phenolics of H. abyssinica. in the foliage and flower bud differed from species to species. The variation Soil pH, organic C, N, P and depicted a among species for soluble phenolics in the decreasing pattern from the 0-15 to the foliage is from 10 to 169mg g-1 and in the 30-50cm soil depths and from the closest flower bud from 9 to 234mg g-1 (Table 5). to the midst and distant positions under According to Constantinides and Fownes most of the tree and shrub species. An (1994), the soluble phenolics content of improvement of soil nutrients by various green foliage of tree and shrub species tree and shrub species in topsoil and close can reach as high as 100mg g-1. Soluble to the tree stems has been reported earlier phenolics content > 30 to 40mg g-1 results (Abebe et al. 2001, Ashagrie et al. 1999, in the immobilization of N (Palm 1995). Gindaba et al. 2005, Hailu et al. 2000).

3.3. Soil properties under the 4. Conclusions indigenous tree and shrub species Indigenous species in general and S. gigas The soil pH values under H. abyssinica and in particular showed superiority in terms S. gigas are above 6.34 (Figure 3). At the of the amount of macronutrients in the 0-15cm depth, the soil OC content under foliage and flower bud. The exotic species

98 had a reasonable amount of soluble Garrity D.P. and Mercado A.R. (1994) Nitrogen phenolics in the foliage. Based on the fixation capacity in the component species content of N, lignin and soluble phenolics, of contour hedgerows: how important? indigenous species have intermediate to Agrofor Syst, 27: pp. 241-258. high quality foliage and flower bud whereas exotic species have high quality foliage German L.A., Berhane K. and Kindu M. (2005) and flower bud for managing soil fertility. Watershed management to counter farming The soil under the vicinity of H. abyssinica systems decline: toward a demand-driven, and S. gigas contains a substantial systems-oriented research agenda. amount of nutrients. This is an indication Agricultural Research & Extension Network of the species’ potential to improve the Network Paper No. 145. fertility of soils. H. abyssinica, S. gigas and C. palmensis can play a great role Gindaba J., Rozanov A. and Negash L. (2005) in farmlands and other land-use types of Trees on farms and their contribution to the high altitude areas, where soil erosion soil fertility parameters in Badessa, eastern and soil depletion are critical problems. Ethiopia. Biol Fertil Soils, 42: pp. 66–71. Hence, further research is urgently needed to evaluate the performance of Hailu T., Negash L. and Olsson M. (2000) Millettia S. gigas, H. abyssinica and C. palmensis ferruginea from southern Ethiopia: impacts outside homesteads of the high altitude on fertility and growth of maize. Agrofor agroecologies. Syst, 48: pp. 9-24.

References Kindu M., Buresh R.J. and Jama B. (1997) Root and inorganic nitrogen distributions in Abebe Y., Fissaha I. and Olsson M. (2001) sesbania fallow, natural fallow and maize Contribution of indigenous trees to soil fields.Plant soil, 188: pp. 319–327. properties: the case of scattered trees of Cordia africana Lam. in croplands of Kindu M., Glatze G., Tadesse Y. and Yosef A. western Oromia. Ethiop J Nat Resour, 3: (2006) Tree species screened on Nitisols pp. 245–270. of central Ethiopia: biomass production, nutrient contents and effect on soil nitrogen. Ashagrie Y., Mamo T. and Olsson M. (1999) J Trop For Sci, 18: pp. 173-180. Changes in some soil chemical properties under scattered Croton macrostachyus Kumar P., Tarafdar J.C., Panwar J. and Kathju S. trees in the traditional agroforestry system (2003) A rapid method for assessment of in northwestern Ethiopia. Ethiop J Nat plant residue quality. J Plant Nutr Soil Sc, Resour, 1: pp. 215–233. 166: pp. 662-666.

Chesson, A. (1997) Plant Degradation Mayr, A. (1996) Evaluation of indigenous fodder by Ruminants: Parallels with Litter trees and shrubs in different agro-ecological Decomposition in Soils. In: Cadisch G. and zones of western Kenya. Msc Thesis. Institut Giller K.E. (eds) Driven by Nature: Plant für Pflanzenbau und Pflanzenzüchtung. Litter Quality and Decomposition. CAB Universität für Bodenkultur, Vienna, International, Wallingford, UK: pp. 47–66. Austria: p. 104.

Constantinides M. and Fownes .J.H. (1994a) Morrison B.J., Gold M.A. and Lantagne D.O. N mineralization from leaves and litter of (1996) Incorporating indigenous knowledge tropical plants: relationship to nitrogen, of fodder trees into small-scale silvopastoral lignin and soluble polyphenol concentrations. systems in Jamaica. Agrofor Syst, 34: pp. Soil Biol Biochem, 26: pp. 49–55. 101-117.

99 Olsen S.R. and Sommers L.E. (1982) Phosphorus. Thapa B., Walker D.H. and Sinclair F.L. (1997) In: Page A.L. (ed): Methods of soil analysis; Indigenous knowledge of the feeding value Part 2: Chemical and microbiological of tree fodder. Anim Feed Sci Tech, 67: properties. Am Soc Agron, Soil Sci Soc Am, pp.97-l 14. Madison, WI., USA: pp. 403–430. Wezel A. (2000) Scattered shrubs in pearl millet fields in semiarid Niger: effect on millet ÖNORM L1080 (2005) Chemical analysis of soils; production. Agrofor Syst, 48: pp. 219– determination of humus by dry combustion 228. of carbon. Austrian Standards Institute. Young A. (1997) Agroforestry for soil manage- ment. CAB International, Wallingford, UK ÖNORM L1082 (2005) Chemical analysis of soils; and ICRAF, Nairobi, Kenya. determination of total nitrogen. Austrian Standards Institute.

ÖNORM L1083 (2005) Chemical analysis of soils; determination of acidity (pH value). Austrian Standards Institute.

Palm, C.A. (1995) Contribution of agroforestry trees to nutrient requirements in intercropped plants. Agrofor Syst, 30: pp. 105–124.

Palm C.A. and Rowland A.P. (1997) A Minimum Dataset for Characterization of Plant Quality for Decomposition. In: Cadisch G. and Giller K.E. (eds) Driven by Nature: Plant Litter Quality and Decomposition. CAB International, Wallingford, UK: pp. 379–392.

Palm C.A., Giller K.E., Mafongoya P.L. and Swift M.J. 2001. Management of organic matter in the tropics: translating theory into practice. Nutr Cycl Agroecosys, 61: pp.63-75.

Power I.L., Thorrold B.S. and Balks M.R. (2003) Soil properties and nitrogen availability in silvopastoral plantings of Acacia melanoxylon in north Island, New Zealand. Agrofor Syst, 57: pp. 225–237.

Roothaert R. L. and Franzel S. (2001) Farmers’ preferences and use of local fodder trees and shrubs in Kenya. Agrofor Syst, 52: pp.239–252.

SAS Institute (1999) SAS/STAT User’s Guide, Version 8. SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA.

100 Gin de Beret M eta R o bi

A da a B erg a

St ud y Are a Eje re B ak o T ib e W e lm er a C he lia Am b o

Tiku r D a w o Illu Ale m Ga na W en ch i B ec ho N on no To lle Am e ya Welis on a G orro K ok ir Kersana Kondelt

Gin d e Be re t

M e ta R o bi Ada a Ber ga Study Area Ej er e Bak o T ib e W e lm e r a Che li a Amb o YA# dd isA b ab a Ti ku r D a w o Illu Al em G a na D a no W e n ch i Non n o A m e ya Bec h o T o lle W e li so n a Ker sa n a G o rr o Kon d el t

LEGEND Stud y Area Oromya Region Ethio pia

400 0 400 800 Kilometers

Figure 1: Location map of the study area.

Table 1: Some physical and chemical properties of the soil in the study area. Table 1. Some physical and chemical properties of the soil in the study area.

Depth pH OC Tot. N Av. P Sand Silt Clay -1 -1 -1 (cm) (H2O) (mg g ) (mg g ) (mg g ) (%) (%) (%) 0-1 .2 .20 . 0.0 12  1 1-0 .1 1.20 1.1 0.01 11  2 0-12 . . 0. 0.021   2 12-10 . 2.02 0.1 0.022 2   Tot. N - total N, OC - organic C, Av. P - available P

101 TableTable 2:2. Soil improving tree tree and and shrub shrub species species identified identified in Galessa- in Galessa-Jeldu Jeldu areas. areas.

Species Local names Family names Dombeya torrida (J.F. Gmel.) P. Bamps Danisa Sterculiaceae Hagenia abyssinica (Bruce) J.F. Gmel. Heto Rosaceae Buddleja polystachya Fres. Anfari Loganiaceae Rubus apetalus Poir. Gora/Yedega Injore Rosaceae Rubus pinnatus Willd. Gura/ Yedega Injore Rosaceae Vernonia auriculifera Hiern. Chochinga Asteraceae Maytenus senegalensis (Lam.) Exell. Kombolcha Celastraceae Myrica salicifolia Hochst. ex A. Rich. Reji Myricaceae Juniperus procera Hochst. ex Endl. Gatira Cupressaceae Phytolacca dodecandra L’ Her Indode Phytolaccaceae Urtica simensis Hochst. ex steud. Dobi (sama) Urticaceae Schefflera abyssinica (Hochst. ex A. Rich.) Harms Luke Araliaceae Senecio gigas Vatke Osolie Asteraceae Kalanchoe deficiens (Forsk) Asch. & Schweinf. Bosokie Crassulaceae Dracaena steudneri Schweinf. ex. Lankuso/Hareg Agavaceae Trichilia roka (Forsk.) Chiov. Anona Meliaceae Leonotis ocymifolia (Burm.f.) M.Iwarsson Bokolu Lamiaceae

Table 3: Criteria used by farmers to evaluate indigenous tree and shrub species for soil fertility improvement in Galessa-Jeldu areas of western Shewa.

Table . Criteria used by farmers to evaluate indigenous tree and shrub species for soil fertility improvement in Galessa-Jeldu areas of western Shewa. Number of Criteria respondentsa Score Rank Fertility related criteria b Regular leaf shedding 1  1 Fast decomposition of leaves 1 1 2 Fast growth 120 22  Easy propagation 11 20  Production of high biomass 1   Note: a Number of respondents who identified the criteria. Sample size was 10 households. b If a farmer selected the criteria first, it received a value of ; if second, a value of ; if third, a value of ; if fourth, a value of 2 and if fifth, a value of 1. Score is sums of individual farmer value given to the respective criteria.

102 Table 4: Indigenous tree and shrub species ranked for soil fertility improvement based on farmers’ criteria in the Galessa-Jeldu areas of central Ethiopia.

Table 5: Lignin and soluble phenolics composition of foliage and flower budTable in . five Lignin tree and and soluble shrub phenolics species. composition of foliage and flower bud in five tree and shrub species.

H. abyss- D. B. polyst- C. palm- S. Foliage inica torrida achya ensis gigas SEM Lignin c 100bc 1a 12ba 0bc 12. Soluble 1a b 2b 10c b 1.1 Flower bud Lignin d 1a 11b dc 10c 12. Soluble 2a 1c 1c c b 2.1 Lignin and soluble phenolics are in mg g-1 dry matter. SEM - Standard error of the means (n = 1). Means with different letters within a row are significantly different (p <0.0).

103 44.4 7.0 N in foliage N in flower bud P in foliage P in flower bud 38.9 6.0 33.3 5.0 ) )

-1 27.8 -1 4.0 22.2 3.0 16.7 N (mg g P (mg g 11.1 2.0 5.6 1.0 0.0 0.0 C. C. H. H. B. B. S. gigas S. gigas D. torrida D. torrida palmensis palmensis abyssinica abyssinica polystachya polystachya

70.0 26.3 60.0 K in foliage K in flower bud Ca in foliage ) 21.0 -1 50.0 ) Ca in flower bud -1 40.0 15.8

K (mg g 30.0 10.5 20.0 Ca ( mg g 10.0 5.3 0.0 0.0 C. H. C. H. B. B. S. gigas S. gigas D. torrida D. torrida palmensis palmensis abyssinica abyssinica polystachya polystachya

4.0 S in foliage 3.5 Mg in foliage Mg in flower bud 4.2 S in flower bud 3.6 )

-1 3.0

) 3.1 2.5 -1 2.6 2.0 2.1

Mg(mg g 1.5 1.6 S ( mg g 1.0 1.0 0.5 0.5 0.0 0.0 C. C. H. H. B. B. S. gigas S. gigas D. torrida palmensis D. torrida abyssinica palmensis abyssinica polystachya polystachya

Figure 2: FigureTrends 2. Trendsof macronutrients of macronutrients in in the the foliage and and flower flower buds of buds five treeof andfive shrub tree species. and shrub species. ErrorError barsbars are are SEM SEM with with n=1. n=15.

104 8 B. polystachya C. palmensis D. torrida (a) H. abyssinica S. gigas 7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0 0-15 15-30 30-50

8 7 (b) 6 O) 2 5 4

Soil pH (H 3 2 1 0 0-15 15-30 30-50

8 (c) 7

6

5

4

3

2

1

0 0-15 15-30 30-50

Soil depth (cm)

Figure . Trends of soil pH at (a)  cm position (b) 10 cm Figure 3:position Trends andof soil (c) 22pH atcm (a) position 75cm from position the stem (b) of 150cm five position and (c) 225cm position from the stem of five species. Error bars are SEM withspecies. n=15. Error bars are SEM with n=1.

105 Table 6: Total N, organic C and pH at different depths and positions from five tree and shrub species.

Table 7: Exchangeable cations at different depths and positions from five tree and shrub species.

106