Stage II Key Issues and Options Evaluation July 2008 2 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Strategic Review and Implementation Plan for the Cotswold Water Park Stage II Key Issues and Options Evaluation July 2008 2 1 Photo1 ©R H Bewley Photo2 ©istockphoto.com/asiseeit Cotswold Water Park Key Issues and Options Evaluation COTSWOLD WATER PARK REVISED STAGE II REPORT KEY ISSUES AND OPTIONS EVALUATION July 2008 Final Rev Date Details Prepared by Reviewed by Approved by 01 20/11/2007 CWP Strategic Barry Woodfin Ross Calladine Malcolm George Review Principal Tourism Tourism Consultant Technical Director Consultant 02 05/12/2007 CWP Strategic Barry Woodfin Ross Calladine Malcolm George Review Principal Tourism Tourism Consultant Technical Director Consultant 03 14/01/2008 CWP Strategic Barry Woodfin Ross Calladine Malcolm George Review Principal Tourism Tourism Consultant Technical Director Consultant 04 03/06/2008 CWP Strategic Barry Woodfin Ross Calladine Malcolm George Review Principal Tourism Tourism Consultant Technical Director Consultant 06 02/07/2008 CWP Strategic Barry Woodfin Emma Paton Malcolm George Review Principal Tourism Project Coordinator Technical Director Consultant Signed: ………………………….. …………………………… …………………………… Scott Wilson 3-4 Foxcombe Court Wyndyke Furlong Abingdon Business Park Abingdon This document has been prepared in accordance with the scope of Scott Wilson's Oxfordshire appointment with its client and is subject to the terms of that appointment. It is addressed OX14 1DZ to and for the sole and confidential use and reliance of Scott Wilson's client. Scott Wilson accepts no liability for any use of this document other than by its client and only for the purposes for which it was prepared and provided. No person other than the client may copy (in whole or in part) use or rely on the contents of this document, without the prior Tel: +44 1235 468700 written permission of the Company Secretary of Scott Wilson Ltd. Any advice, opinions, Fax: +44 1235 468701 or recommendations within this document should be read and relied upon only in the context of the document as a whole. The contents of this document do not provide legal or tax advice or opinion. © Scott Wilson Ltd 2008 www.scottwilson.com Cotswold Water Park Key Issues and Options Evaluation Table of Contents 1 Introduction......................................................................................... 1 Overview of Stage I Study Approach ............................................................................... 1 Stage II Study Requirements ........................................................................................... 1 2 Exploration of the Key Issues............................................................. 4 Mineral Extraction............................................................................................................. 4 Hydrology ......................................................................................................................... 6 Landscape, Community and Settlements......................................................................... 8 Transport, Infrastructure and Utilities ............................................................................. 10 Biodiversity ..................................................................................................................... 14 Leisure and Recreation .................................................................................................. 18 Sport............................................................................................................................... 22 Tourism .......................................................................................................................... 25 Agriculture ...................................................................................................................... 32 Heritage.......................................................................................................................... 35 The Arts.......................................................................................................................... 38 Planning ......................................................................................................................... 39 Aerodrome Safeguarding ............................................................................................... 41 Summary and Driver Prioritisation.................................................................................. 42 3 Options Appraisal ............................................................................. 44 4 The Preferred Option........................................................................ 56 The Key Findings from the Options Appraisal................................................................ 56 The Preferred Option...................................................................................................... 57 5 Management and Governance......................................................... 58 Status of the proposals within the LDF........................................................................... 58 CWP Administration ....................................................................................................... 59 CWP Status.................................................................................................................... 60 Tourism Destination Management Plans........................................................................ 62 CWP Boundary adjustments .......................................................................................... 63 Cotswold Water Park Key Issues and Options Evaluation 1 Introduction 1.1 The Cotswold Water Park Joint Committee requires a strategic review and implementation plan to guide the future development of the Cotswold Water Park (CWP) that is founded on a clear, robust and evidenced based framework for delivering an achievable vision. Overview of Stage I Study Approach 1.2 An extensive research and consultation programme has been undertaken by Scott Wilson through Stage I of the work programme, culminating in the production of a series of Technical Reports on the identified key drivers and related issues: Technical Report 1: Settlements and Transportation Technical Report 2: Biodiversity, Nature and Conservation Technical Report 3: Sand and Gravel Extraction Technical Report 4a: Leisure, Recreation and Sport Technical Report 4b: Tourism Technical Report 5: Agriculture Technical Report 6: Hydrology Technical Report 7: Heritage Technical Report 8: Landscape Technical Report 9: Planning and Policy 1.3 These reports present the technical baseline in relation to the current position of the CWP, and the evidence upon which discussion on future development options can be considered. These documents are supported by a dedicated Geographical Information System (GIS) programme devised by Scott Wilson to capture and record salient data. The GIS system can be accessed via the web-link: http://www.waterpark.org/society/cwp_master_plan.html Stage II Study Requirements 1.4 The following report represents Stage II of a three-stage work programme. This document details the issues that have been identified in the Stage I process. This in turn leads to the formulation of options representing the various interests in the CWP. These options will be evaluated in order to select a preferred option that can be used to guide the preparation of the vision. CWP_Stage II_FinalReport(MASTER 020708).doc July 2008 1 Cotswold Water Park Key Issues and Options Evaluation Study Approach 1.5 During Stage II of the work programme, Scott Wilson has sought to enter into discussions with key stakeholders and potential partners in the CWP to obtain an in depth appreciation of the issues identified during Stage I. The organisations consulted include: The Cotswold Water Park Villages Society The Cricklade Country Way Project The Cotswold Canal Partnership British Waterways The Co-operative Group (Co-op Group) Wiltshire Wildlife Trust (WWT) Gloucestershire Wildlife Trust (GWT) The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB) Sport England Natural England Thames Water Environment Agency Gloucestershire and Wiltshire Minerals Planning Authorities Individual minerals operators 1.6 The discussions have been supplemented by workshops held with the full CWP Joint Committee and with representatives of local residents and local businesses. The list of attendees is included in Appendix A. The aim of the workshops was to discuss key issues and future aims and aspirations for the CWP from a local stakeholder perspective with the key points used to inform the priorities for consideration in the options. 1.7 The consultation and feedback identified priorities, potential benefits and conflicts that have proved invaluable to the overall process. Report Structure 1.8 The following report brings together the Stage I Technical Reports and the consultation programme. The findings of these investigations will be outlined in the following structure: Review of the interrelationship between the issues. Identification of the emerging options for development. Presentation of a rationalised basis for a ‘preferred option’. Analysis of the governance and management issues. 1.9 This information will be used to inform Stage III of the study programme. CWP_Stage II_FinalReport(MASTER 020708).doc July 2008 2 Cotswold Water Park Key Issues and Options Evaluation 1.10 This report is accompanied by maps that represent the principal issues graphically and to visually demonstrate the