Jeanne Wier and the Nevada Historical Society, 1904-1950
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles “We Seek to Be Patient”: Jeanne Wier and the Nevada Historical Society, 1904-1950 A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Information Studies by Su Kim Chung 2015 © Copyright 2015 by Su Kim Chung ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION “We Seek to Be Patient:” Jeanne Wier and the Nevada Historical Society, 1904-1950 by Su Kim Chung Doctor of Philosophy in Information Studies University of California, Los Angeles, 2015 Professor Mary Niles Maack, Chair This dissertation focuses on Jeanne Wier and the years she was active in shaping the Nevada Historical Society (NHS), 1904-1950. It is the story of the institution as it unfolded over four decades, but more broadly, it considers how Wier shaped what Amanda Laugesen has framed as the idea of “public historical culture” in the state of Nevada. This culture not only included the collection of documents and books to provide a basis for research, but also the collection of relics for a museum that sought to be a showplace of Nevada’s history for her citizens. It includes the means by which the NHS performed outreach to make Nevada’s history a viable part of the community through anniversaries and celebrations and its efforts at preserving historic sites. The study considers the tension that arose in Wier’s attempts to have the NHS fulfill these different roles and the challenges that she faced in obtaining financial, governmental and community support for the institution. An important consideration of the ii dissertation is its evaluation of how successful Wier was in achieving the goals of the NHS regarding its mission of developing a historical consciousness within the state and its citizenry. In defining success, the study considers the general volume and frequency of collection donations to the Society as well as the research it supported and the historical papers it published. When possible, the study considers quantitative data such the number of patrons that visited the Society, the number of people attending events and lectures, and the amount of financial support obtained from the legislature and via private funding. Moving beyond numbers, an assessment of her legacy at the NHS must also consider the collections she gathered over the years. Questions of collecting focus and in particular, an exploration of whose history was collected also form part of the study. iii The dissertation of Su Kim Chung is approved. Stephen Aron Anne Gilliland Jonathan Furner Mary Niles Maack, Committee Chair University of California, Los Angeles 2015 iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION........................................................................................ii COMMITTEE PAGE......................................................................................................................iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................................ v LIST OF IMAGES ......................................................................................................................... ix ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .............................................................................................................. x VITA ............................................................................................................................................ xiii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND RESEARCH QUESTIONS ............................................ 1 Content and Scope ...................................................................................................................... 5 Theoretical Framework ............................................................................................................. 10 The New Western History .................................................................................................... 10 Western Women’s History .................................................................................................... 14 Research Questions ................................................................................................................... 18 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW ..................................................................................... 21 Historical Societies and Historical Consciousness ................................................................... 21 Historical Societies and Cultural Heritage in the West and Nevada ........................................ 27 Literature on Women in Nevada ............................................................................................... 32 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 36 CHAPTER 3: HISTORICAL SOCIETY BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT ......................... 38 Early Historical Societies in the US from 1791-1860 .............................................................. 38 Historical Societies Move West ................................................................................................ 47 Some Western Historical Societies after the Civil War ............................................................ 50 CHAPTER 4: JEANNE WIER .................................................................................................... 55 Family and Early Life ............................................................................................................... 55 Early Education ......................................................................................................................... 59 Moving West ............................................................................................................................. 63 Stanford Years .......................................................................................................................... 65 Arrival in Nevada ...................................................................................................................... 72 Early Life in Reno ..................................................................................................................... 80 CHAPTER 5: FOUNDING & EARLY YEARS: 1904-1909 ..................................................... 83 Early Twentieth-Century Nevada ............................................................................................. 83 Founding of the Nevada Historical Society .............................................................................. 85 v Wier’s First Speech: The Mission of the State Historical Society ........................................... 96 The Lean Years: 1905-1906 ................................................................................................... 102 State Funding At Last ............................................................................................................. 107 Annual Meetings and Early Supporters of the Society ........................................................... 110 Collecting Trips to Remember – Southern and Central Nevada 1908 ................................... 117 Accounting for the Society – The First Biennial Report ........................................................ 127 Progress Deferred – The Legislative Funding Debacle of 1909 ............................................. 137 Building Struggles .................................................................................................................. 146 CHAPTER 6: A BUILDING FOR SOCIETYAND ITS COLLECTIONS: 1910-1918 ........... 152 Nevada in the Progressive Age ............................................................................................... 152 The Great Building Saga ......................................................................................................... 153 Documenting Nevada: Books, Papers, Artifacts and Monuments .......................................... 172 Collecting 1910-1911 .......................................................................................................... 173 Collecting 1912-1914 .......................................................................................................... 180 Collecting 1915-1916 .......................................................................................................... 191 The Society and Collecting in Wartime .................................................................................. 199 Crafting a History of the War ................................................................................................. 204 Post-War Challenges ............................................................................................................... 206 CHAPTER 7: OUTREACH: CRAFTING A PUBLIC ROLE FOR THE SOCIETY: 1910-1918 ..................................................................................................................................................... 208 Speeches of Significance ........................................................................................................ 208 “The Work of the Western State Historical Society as Illustrated by Nevada” .................. 211 Herbert Bolton and “The Obligation of Nevada Toward the Writing of Her Own History” ............................................................................................................................................. 219 The Historical Pageants – “My Own Nevada, I Am Proud of Thee” ..................................... 228 Raising