Developing Advanced Academic Degree Educational Profiles for Career Fields

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Developing Advanced Academic Degree Educational Profiles for Career Fields Air Force Institute of Technology AFIT Scholar Theses and Dissertations Student Graduate Works 3-2007 Developing Advanced Academic Degree Educational Profiles for Career Fields Katherine J. Gentil Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.afit.edu/etd Part of the Training and Development Commons, and the Vocational Education Commons Recommended Citation Gentil, Katherine J., "Developing Advanced Academic Degree Educational Profiles for Career Fields" (2007). Theses and Dissertations. 3080. https://scholar.afit.edu/etd/3080 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Graduate Works at AFIT Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of AFIT Scholar. For more information, please contact [email protected]. DEVELOPING ADVANCED ACADEMIC DEGREE EDUCATIONAL PROFILES FOR CAREER FIELDS THESIS Katherine J. Gentil, Major, USAF AFIT/GOR/ENS/07-08 DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE AIR UNIVERSITY AIR FORCE INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE ; DISTRIBUTION UNLIMITED. The views expressed in this thesis are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the United States Air Force, Department of Defense, or the United States Government. AFIT/GOR/ENS/07-08 DEVELOPING ADVANCED ACADEMIC DEGREE EDUCATIONAL PROFILES FOR CAREER FIELDS THESIS Presented to the Faculty Department of Operational Sciences Graduate School of Engineering and Management Air Force Institute of Technology Air University Air Education and Training Command In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Operations Research Katherine J. Gentil, BS, MEd Major, USAF March 2007 APPROVED FOR PUBLIC RELEASE; DISTRIBUTION UNLIMITED. AFIT/GOR/ENS/07-08 DEVELOPING ADVANCED ACADEMIC DEGREE EDUCATIONAL PROFILES FOR CAREER FIELDS Katherine J. Gentil, BS, MEd Major, USAF Approved: ____________________________________ ___ Shane A. Knighton, Major, USAF (Chairman) date ____________________________________ ___ James T. Moore, PhD (Reader) date AFIT/GOR/ENS/07-08 Abstract This research develops a career field’s educational profile through use of the decision analysis approach of value-focused thinking (VFT). VFT is used to solicit the capabilities that the career field manager (CFM) desires its officers obtain from an advanced academic program. This process generates a value hierarchy and a focused set of alternatives (degree programs). The academic programs’ content are evaluated against the hierarchy to determine how well it meets the values of the functional area. A rank- ordered list of degrees is produced and a portfolio of degrees is selected through the use of CFM-approved goal-setting criteria. The specific breakdown of the portfolio into percentages of the force that should attain each degree is then determined through the CFM’s specified relative value increments of the goal-setting criteria. The resulting effort creates a guide for CFMs to communicate to their corps on the types of degrees to earn and provides justification for fully-funded degree slots. iv AFIT/GOR/ENS/07-08 DEDICATION To my husband, daughter, and son. You are my life. v Acknowledgments Above all, I would like to thank God for carrying me through one of the most challenging situations in my life as I tried to juggle the demands of the program along with caring for and enjoying time with my family. Next, I would not have been able to complete this program without the love and support from my husband who stepped in and folded more laundry and did more dishes than any husband in history, all while simultaneously maintaining and excelling in his own career and being a great dad to our children. And to my children, you were the reason for ensuring I kept a balance in my life while pursuing this degree. Thank you for enduring my altered personality at times, providing me the proper perspective on what really matters, and giving me hugs through it all. I would like to express my sincere appreciation to my faculty advisor, Maj Shane Knighton, for his guidance and support throughout the course of this thesis effort. His insight and expertise were instrumental in directing me down the right path. Thanks to Dr. Moore for his seasoned experience, expertise, and wise eye for making my thesis a polished product. I would also like to thank my sponsor, Col Michael Gamble, Chief, Strategic Plans Division, Headquarters, United States Air Force, Directorate of Manpower and Personnel, for both the support and latitude provided to me in this endeavor. I only hope that my efforts can make a positive impact. And for my classmates, thanks for all the help on homework assignments and being a sounding board for my thoughts and cynical outlook. You all are a great bunch of officers whom I wish all the best in your future careers. Katherine J. Gentil vi Table of Contents Page Abstract .................................................................................................................. iv Dedication ....................................................................................................................v Acknowledgments........................................................................................................... vi List of Figures.................................................................................................................ix List of Tables ..................................................................................................................xi I. Introduction .............................................................................................................1 Background..............................................................................................................1 Force Development..................................................................................................2 Current Practices......................................................................................................3 Problem Statement...................................................................................................5 Research Objective ..................................................................................................5 Research Scope........................................................................................................6 II. Literature Review.....................................................................................................8 Overview..................................................................................................................8 Past Studies on Advanced Academic Degree Programs........................................10 Decision Analysis..................................................................................................17 Value-Focused Thinking........................................................................................20 Portfolio Selection – Multiple Criteria Goal Setting .............................................23 Summary................................................................................................................25 III. Methodology..........................................................................................................26 Overview................................................................................................................26 Value-Focused Thinking Model Development......................................................26 Step 1: Identify the Problem ...........................................................................27 Step 2: Develop the Hierarchy........................................................................28 Step 3: Develop Evaluation Measures ............................................................36 Step 4: Create Value Functions.......................................................................39 Step 5: Determine Hierarchy Weights ............................................................42 Step 6: Generate Alternatives .........................................................................46 Step 7: Score Alternatives...............................................................................50 Step 8: Deterministic Analysis........................................................................52 Step 9a: Multiple Criteria Determination and Portfolio Selection..................52 Step 9b: Sensitivity Analysis ..........................................................................57 vii Page IV. Results and Analysis..............................................................................................59 Overview................................................................................................................59 Results of Alternative Analysis .............................................................................59 Sensitivity Analysis for Rank-ordered Listing ......................................................64 Portfolio Selection Results.....................................................................................69 Sensitivity on Criteria for Portfolio Selection .......................................................72 Sensitivity on Means Objectives............................................................................73 V. Conclusions and Recommendations ......................................................................88 Summary of Analysis.............................................................................................88
Recommended publications
  • United States Air Force and Its Antecedents Published and Printed Unit Histories
    UNITED STATES AIR FORCE AND ITS ANTECEDENTS PUBLISHED AND PRINTED UNIT HISTORIES A BIBLIOGRAPHY EXPANDED & REVISED EDITION compiled by James T. Controvich January 2001 TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTERS User's Guide................................................................................................................................1 I. Named Commands .......................................................................................................................4 II. Numbered Air Forces ................................................................................................................ 20 III. Numbered Commands .............................................................................................................. 41 IV. Air Divisions ............................................................................................................................. 45 V. Wings ........................................................................................................................................ 49 VI. Groups ..................................................................................................................................... 69 VII. Squadrons..............................................................................................................................122 VIII. Aviation Engineers................................................................................................................ 179 IX. Womens Army Corps............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Rpioams+Ror^ £W Force. B^&O.^5^T1-H
    rpioAms+ror^ £W Force. B^&o.^5^t1-h^^ri^^f£^.4-/'<^'i HAER NO. NVT-I 38 HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD Intermountain Support Office - Denver National Park Service P.O. Box 25287 Denver, Colorado 80225-0287 HISTORIC AMERICAN ENGINEERING RECORD MALMSTROM AIR FORCE BASE, 546th MISSILE SQUADRON (MINUTEMAN III MISSILE FACILITIES) HAERNO. MT-138 Location: Malmstrom Air Force Base (MAFB) is located near the City of Great Falls, Cascade County, Montana. Its 564th Missile Squadron has five Minuteman III Missile Alert Facilities (Papa, Quebec, Romeo, Sierra and Tango) and 50 associated Launch Facilities. The Missile Alert Facilities (MAFs) are located in Pondera and Toole Counties, Montana, and their associated Launch Facilities (LFs) are in Pondera, Toole, and Chouteau Counties. Present Owner: MAFB, US Air Force (USAF) Date of Construction Constructed as a Minuteman II system in 1965-1966; converted to a Minuteman III system in 1975 Architect: Ralph M. ParsonsCompany Builder: Morrison Knudsen Company and Associates Present Use: Deactivated Minuteman III Missile Alert Facilities (MAF) and Launch Facilities (LF) Significance: The 564th is an Intercontinental Ballistic Missile (ICBM) squadron based at Malmstrom Air Force Base, Montana. The fifty Minuteman ICBMs maintained and controlled by the 564th Missile Squadron (MS) were integral components of a massive Cold War defense system developed between the early 1960s and mid-1970s. The Minuteman system was designed to protect the United States from a possible nuclear attack as well as to provide a strategic deterrence, a cornerstone of American defense policy of the era. At the peak of the program, the nation's Minuteman arsenal had a total of some 1,000 operational missiles deployed at a series of northern Air Force Bases, including 200 at Malmstrom.
    [Show full text]
  • Almanac ■ Guide to Air Force Installations Worldwide
    USAFAlmanac ■ Guide to Air Force Installations Worldwide Major Installations Note: A major installation is an Air Force Base, Air Andrews AFB, Md. 20762-5000; 10 mi. SE of 4190th Wing, Pisa, Italy; 31st Munitions Support Base, Air Guard Base, or Air Reserve Base that Washington, D. C. Phone (301) 981-1110; DSN Sqdn., Ghedi AB, Italy; 4190th Air Base Sqdn. serves as a self-supporting center for Air Force 858-1110. AMC base. Gateway to the nation’s (Provisional), San Vito dei Normanni, Italy; 496th combat, combat support, or training operations. capital and home of Air Force One. Host wing: 89th Air Base Sqdn., Morón AB, Spain; 731st Munitions Active-duty, Air National Guard (ANG), or Air Force Airlift Wing. Responsible for Presidential support Support Sqdn., Araxos AB, Greece; 603d Air Control Reserve Command (AFRC) units of wing size or and base operations; supports all branches of the Sqdn., Jacotenente, Italy; 48th Intelligence Sqdn., larger operate the installation with all land, facili- armed services, several major commands, and Rimini, Italy. One of the oldest Italian air bases, ties, and support needed to accomplish the unit federal agencies. The wing also hosts Det. 302, dating to 1911. USAF began operations in 1954. mission. There must be real property accountability AFOSI; Hq. Air Force Flight Standards Agency; Area 1,467 acres. Runway 8,596 ft. Altitude 413 through ownership of all real estate and facilities. AFOSI Academy; Air National Guard Readiness ft. Military 3,367; civilians 1,102. Payroll $156.9 Agreements with foreign governments that give Center; 113th Wing (D. C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Cold War and Beyond
    Contents Puge FOREWORD ...................... u 1947-56 ......................... 1 1957-66 ........................ 19 1967-76 ........................ 45 1977-86 ........................ 81 1987-97 ........................ 117 iii Foreword This chronology commemorates the golden anniversary of the establishment of the United States Air Force (USAF) as an independent service. Dedicated to the men and women of the USAF past, present, and future, it records significant events and achievements from 18 September 1947 through 9 April 1997. Since its establishment, the USAF has played a significant role in the events that have shaped modem history. Initially, the reassuring drone of USAF transports announced the aerial lifeline that broke the Berlin blockade, the Cold War’s first test of wills. In the tense decades that followed, the USAF deployed a strategic force of nuclear- capable intercontinental bombers and missiles that deterred open armed conflict between the United States and the Soviet Union. During the Cold War’s deadly flash points, USAF jets roared through the skies of Korea and Southeast Asia, wresting air superiority from their communist opponents and bringing air power to the support of friendly ground forces. In the great global competition for the hearts and minds of the Third World, hundreds of USAF humanitarian missions relieved victims of war, famine, and natural disaster. The Air Force performed similar disaster relief services on the home front. Over Grenada, Panama, and Libya, the USAF participated in key contingency actions that presaged post-Cold War operations. In the aftermath of the Cold War the USAF became deeply involved in constructing a new world order. As the Soviet Union disintegrated, USAF flights succored the populations of the newly independent states.
    [Show full text]
  • Usafalmanac ■ Guide to Air Force Installations Worldwide
    USAFAlmanac ■ Guide to Air Force Installations Worldwide Major Installations Note: A major installation is an Air Force Base, Air Andrews AFB, Md. 20762-5000; 10 mi. SE of port Sq., Araxos AB, Greece; Det. 1, Expeditionary Base, Air Reserve Base, or Air Guard Base that Washington. Phone (301) 981-1110; DSN 858-1110. Air Control Sq., Jacotenente, Italy. One of the old- serves as a self-supporting center for Air Force AMC base. Host: 89th Airlift Wing. Responsible for est Italian air bases, dating to 1911. USAF began combat, combat support, or training operations. Presidential support and base operations; supports operations 1954. Area 1,467 acres. Runway 8,596 Active duty, Air National Guard (ANG), or Air Force all branches of the armed services, several major ft. Altitude 413 ft. Military 3,367; civilians 1,102. Reserve Command (AFRC) units of wing size or commands, and federal agencies. Tenants: Det. Payroll $158.9 million. Housing: 619 govt.-leased larger operate the installation with all land, facili- 302, AFOSI; Air Force Flight Standards Agency; units, 34 billeting spaces, 552-bed dorm. No ties, and support needed to accomplish the unit AFOSI Academy; Air National Guard Readiness TLF, 20 VOQ, 14 VAQ. Clinic with 24-hour acute- mission. There must be real property accountability Center; 113th Wing (D.C. ANG); 459th Airlift Wing care clinic. American medical services at Sacile through ownership of all real estate and facilities. (AFRC); Naval Air Facility; Marine Aircraft Gp. 49, Hospital (20 minutes from base) with OB/GYN, Agreements with foreign governments that give Det. A; Air Force Review Boards Agency.
    [Show full text]
  • The Missile Plains: Frontline of America's Cold
    The Missile Plains: Frontline of America’s Cold War Historic Resource Study Minuteman Missile National Historic Site, South Dakota Prepared for United States Department of the Interior National Park Service Midwest Regional Office 2003 Prepared under the supervision of: Dr. Jeffrey A. Engel, Principal Investigator Authors: Mead & Hunt, Inc. Christina Slattery Mary Ebeling Erin Pogany Amy R. Squitieri Recommended: Site Manager, Minuteman Missile National Historic Site Date Superintendent, Badlands National Park Date Concurred: Chief, Cultural Resources, Midwest Region Date Associate Regional Director Date Cultural Resources and Stewardship Partnerships Approved: Regional Director Date Midwest Region Minuteman Missile National Historic Site Historic Resource Study Table of Contents List of Illustrations ................................................................................................................ iv List of Abbreviations ...........................................................................................................viii Preface....................................................................................................................................x Introduction ..........................................................................................................................xi Establishment and Purpose................................................................................................................... xi Geographic Location ............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 1966 Vietnam Combat Operations
    VIETNAM COMBAT OPERATIONS – 1966 A chronology of Allied combat operations in Vietnam 1 VIETNAM COMBAT OPERATIONS – 1966 A chronology of Allied combat operations in Vietnam Stéphane Moutin-Luyat – 2009 distribution unlimited Front cover: Slicks of the 118th AHC inserting Skysoldiers of the 173d Abn Bde near Tan Uyen, Bien Hoa Province. Operation DEXTER, 4 May 1966. (118th AHC Thunderbirds website) 2 VIETNAM COMBAT OPERATIONS – 1966 A chronology of Allied combat operations in Vietnam This volume is the second in a series of chronologies of Allied headquarters: 1st Cav Div. Task organization: 1st Bde: 2-5 combat operations conducted during the Vietnam War from Cav, 1-8 Cav, 2-8 Cav, 1-9 Cav (-), 1-12 Cav, 2-19 Art, B/2-17 1965 to 1973, interspersed with significant military events and Art, A/2-20 Art, B/6-14 Art. 2d Bde: 1-5 Cav, 2-12 Cav, 1-77 augmented with a listing of US and FWF units arrival and depar- Art. Execution: The 1st Bde launched this operation north of ture for each months. It is based on a chronology prepared for Route 19 along the Cambodian border to secure the arrival of the Vietnam Combat Operations series of scenarios for The the 3d Bde, 25th Inf Div. On 4 Jan, the 2d Bde was committed to Operational Art of War III I've been working on for more than conduct spoiling attacks 50 km west of Kontum. Results: 4 three years, completed with additional information obtained in enemy killed, 4 detained, 6 US KIA, 41 US WIA.
    [Show full text]
  • Historical Handbook of NGA Leaders
    Contents Introduction . i Leader Biographies . ii Tables National Imagery and Mapping Agency and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency Directors . 58 National Imagery and Mapping Agency and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency Deputy Directors . 59 Defense Mapping Agency Directors . 60 Defense Mapping Agency Deputy Directors . 61 Defense Mapping Agency Directors, Management and Technology . 62 National Photographic Interpretation Center Directors . 63 Central Imagery Office Directors . 64 Defense Dissemination Program Office Directors . 65 List of Acronyms . 66 Index . 68 • ii • Introduction Wisdom has it that you cannot tell the players without a program. You now have a program. We designed this Historical Handbook of National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency Leaders as a useful reference work for anyone who needs fundamental information on the leaders of the NGA. We have included those colleagues over the years who directed the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) and the component agencies and services that came together to initiate NGA-NIMA history in 1996. The NGA History Program Staff did not celebrate these individuals in this setting, although in reading any of these short biographies you will quickly realize that we have much to celebrate. Rather, this practical book is designed to permit anyone to reach back for leadership information to satisfy any personal or professional requirement from analysis, to heritage, to speechwriting, to retirement ceremonies, to report composition, and on into an endless array of possible tasks that need support in this way. We also intend to use this book to inform the public, especially young people and students, about the nature of the people who brought NGA to its present state of expertise.
    [Show full text]
  • June 1978 Vol
    /7/ NEWS LETTER Vol. 16 No. 2 SECOND AIR DIVISION ASSOCIATION June 1978 BEDTIME RAMBLINGS The bombardier came back and pow- dered the wound with sulfa, wrapped a by Jacob T. Elias (44th BG) bandage on it. The ambulance was waiting as soon as we stopped on the Why? I often wonder why. It is now not my idea of winning the war and revetment, a fast trip to the base over thirty-eight years since I left getting the Congressional Medal of medic, and then a longer trip to Shipdham-in-the-Mud, and yet, in those Honor pinned on my chest by the Pres- Wymondham where the nickel sized half-real moments before I fall asleep. ident of the USA himself. My attitude piece was removed, the smaller pieces my mind flies over the sea to that was probably noted by — (I'll be left in the leg for souvenirs. place I was happy to leave. A pot- charitable and not mention his name). A month there, living in a warm pourri of memories slowly floats My request for transfer to a combat room, clean white sheets, food served through my consciousness. People, crew was quickly approved and I on dishes, attentive nurses. Like a va- places, smells, violent scenes, rain, moved to the 68th Squadron area. A cation. except for feeling hemmed in, hoar-frost on overhead wires, muddy month later I found myself listed on useless. Restlessness grew as the ten- tires on a bicycle. the alert sheet for my first mission as sion before D-Day grew in the British Transfer to the 14th Combat Wing at waist gunner.
    [Show full text]
  • Air Force Pricelist As of 3/1/2011
    Saunders Military Insignia PO BOX 1831 Naples, FL 34106 (239) 776-7524 FAX (239) 776-7764 www.saundersinsignia.com [email protected] Air Force Pricelist as of 3/1/2011 Product # Name Style Years Price 1201 Air Force Branch Tape Patch, sew on, Black 3.00 1216 AVG Blood Chit Flying Tigers Silk 20.00 1218 Desert Storm Chit Silk 8/1990-Current 38.00 1219 Korean War Chit Silk 38.00 1301 336th Fighter Squadron USAF F-15E Fighter Color Patch 10.00 1305 F15E Fighter Weapons School Patch 10.00 1310 EB66 100 Missions Patch 9.00 1311 129th Radio Squadron Mobile Patch, subdued 3.50 1313 416th Bombardment Wing Patch 9.00 1314 353rd Combat Training Squadron Patch 6.50 1315 Air Education and Training Command InstructorPatch 6.50 1317 45th Fighter Squadron USAF Fighter Patch Color 10.00 1318 315th Special Operations Wing Patch 9.00 1321 1st Fighter Wing (English) Patch, Handmade 9.00 1326 100th Fighter Squadron USAF Fighter Patch Color 10.00 1327 302nd Fighter Squadron USAF Fighter Patch Color 23.00 1328 48th Tactical Fighter Squadron USAF Fighter Patch Color 7.50 1329 332nd Fighter Group Patch 10.00 1330 20th Fighter Wing Patch, desert subdued 7.50 1331 21st Special Operations Squadron KnifePatch 6.50 1333 Areospace Defense Command GoosebayPatch Lab 4.00 1335 60th Fighter Squadron USAF Fighter Patch Color 9.00 1336 Spectre AC130 Patch 9.00 1338 Spectre Patience Patch 8.00 1339 162nd Fighter Gp Int Patch 10.00 1341 442nd Tactical Fighter Training SquadronPatch (F111) 8.00 1342 21st Special Operations Squadron patch 7.50 1346 522nd Tactical Fighter Squadron Patch, subdued 3.00 1347 Doppler 1984 Flt.
    [Show full text]
  • MILITARY READINESS: Data and Trends for April 1995 to March 1996
    United States General Accounting Office Report to the Chairman, Committee on GAO National Security, House of Representatives August 1996 MILITARY READINESS Data and Trends for April 1995 to March 1996 GOA years 1921 - 1996 GAO/NSIAD-96-194 United States General Accounting Office GAO Washington, D.C. 20548 National Security and International Affairs Division B-272379 August 2, 1996 The Honorable Floyd Spence Chairman, Committee on National Security House of Representatives Dear Mr. Chairman: As you requested, we have updated our Military Readiness report 1 through March 31, 1996, to determine if the data show significant changes. Also, we reviewed readiness data for selected units participating in the Bosnia operation to see whether the operation has affected readiness. This report provides unclassified readiness information on the four military services. Specifically, it (1) assesses readiness trends of selected units from each service from April 1, 1995, to March 31, 1996, with particular emphasis on units that reported degraded readiness during the prior period and (2) assesses readiness trends (for the period Oct.1, 1995, to Mar. 31, 1996) for selected units that participated in the Bosnia operation. On June 26, 1996, we provided a classified briefing to the staff of the Subcommittee on Military Readiness, House Committee on National Security, on the results of our work. This letter summarizes the unclassified information presented in that briefing. Background The Status of Resources and Training System (SORTS) is the Department of Defense’s (DOD) automated reporting system that identifies the current level of selected resources and training status of a unit—that is, its ability to undertake its wartime mission.
    [Show full text]
  • 44Th Bomb Group Veterans Association
    44TH BOMB GROUP VETERANS ASSOCIATION 8 BALL TAILS Vol. 1 - Issue #4 Journal of the ft Winter 1995 44th Bomb Group Non Profit Veterans Organization Veterans Association EIN #68-0351397 "WELCOME SIGHT" A Limited Edition signed by two distinguished WWII Bomber Pilots General Leon Johnson & Major General Ramsay Potts "WELCOME SIGHT" By Robert Taylor 1000 signed & numbered, 27 1/2" x 20 1/2" B-24 Liberators of the 44th Bomb Group pass over Ely Cathedral, aesthetic role in the story of the US Air Force's war effort in England. The Cambridgeshire, after a mission to occupied Europe. Ely Cathedral, men of the 8th Air Force still fondly recall those stirring moments towering above the East Anglian flatlands, was a welcome landmark for returning from a mission, when they spotted that beautiful old monument the returning US 8th Air Force crews. rising from the flatlands of the Fen country, providing an easily recognizable This classic work by Robert Taylor pays tribute to the men of the 8th Air landmark, and thus a bearing on their home base. The Cathedral has ever Force and in particular the gallant crews of the B-24 Liberator, and the since been regarded by the gallant crews of the B-I 7's and B-24's as 'their' contribution they made to the Allies' success in World War II. Returning Cathedral. from a mission, flying over the beautiful Cambridgeshire landscape with The aircraft centered in the Robert Taylor painting is the 68th Bomb Ely Cathedral in the background, the B-24's make an imposing subject.
    [Show full text]