<<

Tradition and the Avant-Garde in Moreau's

Lyn Bolen

In Moreau's 1876 Salome Dancing before remained nebulous- it was her mother who was held Herod (Figure I), Salome, with left arm extended and hold­ responsible for John's death.• Veneration of John again ing a lotus blossom in her right hand, glides forward on soared during the Crusades. During this period a fusion of pointed toes in the fateful that will result in the the characters of and Salome arose, which with beheading of . The multi-layered jewel few exceptions was to persist until the nineteenth century.' encrusted garments trailing behind her contribute to the After the year IOOO, the theme again begins to appear fre­ other-worldly, demonic power of this hypnotic dance. We quently in illuminated manuscripts and stained glass win­ are mere spectators of the performance as are the other dows and mosaics, always to stress the evil nature of the characters in the scene. Herod, dwarfed by his ornate physical in contrast to John's spirituality. For example, throne, the executioner with veiled face on his left, the Salome appears in a victory dance with the head of John kneeling lyre player hidden behind Salome's veils, and the Baptist in a mosaic in San Marco, Venice and in an Herodias, Salome's mothe,; peering from behind the column upside-down frenzied dance in the Cathedral of Rouen.• on the left, are all subjugated by the powerful presence of The upside"

35 I The Spiritual in Art: Abslraet Painting 189(H98S, Exhibition Oltalog. 18 Lydia Gasman. '"192r' Semina.r. Uni\-crsity of Virginia. Spring 19$5. Los Angtlies, Los Angtles County . NO\-ember 23, 1986-March 8. 1987; Chicago, Museum of Contemporary Art, April 17-JuJy 19, 19 Louis E. Backman. Religious Dontn in the Christian Church and ,n 1987; The Hague. Gemeentemuseum, September 1-Jfo\-ember 22. 1987 Popular Mtdicirn,, trans. E. Oas....cn (Westport, CT: Greenwood Prts:s. (New York: TilC Abbeville Press. 1987). Sec chapters one: and two. Publ;.hers, 1952) 19. 2 Helen Grace Z.agona. Th, Lrgtnd of Salome and lhe Principle of Art 20 Back.man 32. for An'.t So.ke (: Librairie Minard, 1960) 16. Aavius Josephus 21 Wal1cr Sorrell. Do.nu in ilS nme (Garden City, NY: Anchor Prcs:s. does not, ho~-ever. connect John the &ptiSt's de.a.th with Hcrodias or 1981) 297-343. Salome. According 10 this account John is put to death because Herod feam:I that he might incite a rcbcUion. 22 Ivor Guest, The Dancer's Hm'.tage: A Shorr History of Ballet (London: The Dancing limes. 1960) 47-53. Thc faet that only two ballets suni,'Cd 3 Zagona 20, A church built in AlcxaDdria during the founh century from au that "-ere produced at the Paris Opera between 1871 and 1m dedicated to John the Baptist tcstili~ to his growing promiOC'noc~ (and these survi,'Cd larg(ly because of their music) tcsti~ to the stag• 4 Zagon., 20. nant state of the classical balkt during the late nineteenth century. S Zagona 20. 23 StCphanc MallamlC, '"Ballets~ (188~1897). What is Dance?. eds. Roger Copeland and Mal'$hall Cohen (Oxford Uni\'CrSily Press, 1983) 111·1 IS. 6 Zagona 21. For a penetrating examination of MaJlarmC's writings on the dance. $Ct Deirdre Priddin, The Art of rht Done~ In Frmch Uttratu" (London: 7 Gerard de Cbampeaux. le Monde des Symboks. Jrd ed. (Paris: Zodi• Acl>m and Charles Black, 1952) 54-81. aq ue. 1980) :163. 24 Julius Kaplan. ~ An of Gus10,~ Mo,reou 1htt>r)', Style. and Contem 8 Nancy L Pressly and Eric Bradford Stocker, Salome: la !Mlk dame (Ann Arbor. Michigan: UM I Research PtfiS. 1972) 62. Moreau u.w,J sons ~rel (San Antonio Museum of M. 1983) 9. the Parisian Libraries and also owned Owen Jones· Grammar of 9 Joris-Karl Huysmans. Agolns1 Nature, trans. Roben Bald.Ck (New 0,nomenr (1865). an encyclopedia of ornamentation from around tile York: Penguin Books, 1959. orig. 1884) 6S. world. 10 Mario Prat. 1M Romantic Agc>ny. trans. Angus David.son (Cleve.land, 25 Kaplan 62. Morea.u formulated this idea on the basis of richJy deco- OH and New York. NY: Meridian Books. The World Publishing Co., rated early Rcnai.ssanoc altarpieces. 1956) 206. This book is the locus ckwi(UJ for lhc fem~ fatale idea. 26 Kaplan 63. Praz traces the dc\'tlopment of the idea of the woman as the "'ftame that bums and aur.i.ets." and ics myriad treatments in the nineteenth 27 Kaplan 59. century. 28 Kaplan 63. 11 Pra1. 202. Sec also Chara Bauddaire, Tht Flowers of Evil. ~ -lectcd 29 Kaplan 60. and edited by Marthicl and Jackson Mathews (Norfolk. CT: New Directions. 19SS) 262. The woman in the following poem coincides 30 Kaplan 66. rtmark.ably with the Salome of Morcau's Salome Dancing IN/ort Herod. 31 Kaplan 66.

A\'CC scs \'(Cements ondoyanu et nacres. 32 Kaplan 65. MCmc quand cUe marchc on croirait qu'eUe dansc. 33 Kaplan 63. Comme ces kmgs serpents que lcs jongleurs sacrtS Au bout de leurs batons agitent en cacknoc. 34 "'Ephesus,• Encyrlopattlia /Jriuanica Micropaedia, 15th ed .• 12 vob .• 4:Sl&-19. T. J. Wood conducced excavation., in Ephesus for the British Comme le sable mome ct l'antr des deserts, Museum from 186)...1814. lnscnsiblC$ tous deux a l'humainc soutrranoe. Comme les longs l'Cseaux de la houlc des mcrs. 35 Kaplan 63. Elk sc dC'.,.doppc nee indifference. • 36 A. A. Jafarey Tehran and Rawalpindi.. '"Mithra. Lord of the-Lands.· $es yeux polis sont faits de mil1Cmux chsnnanu. Mi'1hraic S1udks. ed. John H. Hinnells, 2 vols. (MaDChcstcr University Et dans oote natu.rc etrange et symbolique P1CS$. 1975) 1:54. Ou range inviolC se lllCle au sphinx antique. 37 Kaplan 65. OU tout n'est qu'or. acier. lumi(rt ct d.iamants. Respkndit 8 jamais. com me un astre inutile. l8 JuJius Kaplan, '"Gusta,-c Moreau's Jupilcr and Semc.le. .. Arr Quorrerly, La froide majcstC: de la femme s1C:.rile. 33 (l970):4C». In boch Salome paintings Moreau de.a.ls with the: inferior• ity of ean.hly love and its nocu,ary destruction i.n order to acNCvc the 12 Zagona 40. Dhinc. IJ Ragnar von Holten. '"Le dC\-eloppcmem du pe,sonnage de Salome 39 Dore Ashton. ""Gusta,-c Moreau; / GUJ.taw M0rtou/ a tra..-ers les dessins de Gustave More-au."' L'Otil Ju.Jy-Augu.« Rodolphe BreJdin, Exhibition Qualog. New York., The Museum ol 1961:72. . Oceembcr 4, 1961-Febroal")' 4. 1962: Chicago. The An Institute of Chicago, March 2, 1962--April IS. 1962 (Garden City. New 14 Jean and Jose Pierre Paladilhe, Gus1ow Moreau (New York: York: Doubleday & Co., Inc., 1961) 114. Pnieger Publishers, 1972) 80. 40 Daniel Grojno.... 1k:i. "'Salome l'art et !'argent,"' L'Heme HUJ'$1ttOn.t eds. IS Curt Sachs, World Hisrory of Dance. trans. Bessie Schonberg Pierre Brunel and Andre Guyaux (Paris: Editions de L'Hemc. 1985) (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 1937, rpt. 1965) 242. 166-169. Also set Li!Jian B. Lawler. The Dance in Ancient Grette (Midd)e,. town. CT: WcslC')1tn Unh-enit)' Press. 1918) 74-76. 41 HuysmaM 66. 42 2,gona 70. 16 Sachs 242. uwler 77-19. 43 Z.gona41. 17 Elaine Pagels. The Gnos.tic Gospels (New York: Random House. 1979) 74. The tCX.l reads: 44 Pierre-Louis Math.ieu. Gustave Moreau Aqua~llt'S (Scuil: Office du Livre S. A., Fribourg. 1981) 40. Soc for Mal.lartnc's Cantique de $aim To the Universe belongs the dancer. Jton (1885). He who does not danoe d~ not know what happens. Now U )'OU follow my dance. sec youtSClf in Me Jc su.is comme aux ,-crti:bres who am speaking. S'cmployer des tC:nebrcs You who dance. consider what I do. for yours is this Toutes dans un frisson passion of Man which I am to suffer... A1\uti$$0n 36 Et ma tele surgie 46 Guillaume Apollinaire, '"La Danseuse," (1902) ~.,.n eompli1~, -... Solitaire vigie Guilloum~ Apoflimtire, ed. Michel De<:audin 2 vols, (Paris: Andre Bal­ Oans lcs vols uiomphaux land et Jacques Lecat J965) 1:141-143; also sec Cuillaume Apollinaire, Deccue rau.x "Salome• (1~1906) A/cools (1913), !rans. Aooc Hyde Gree! (Bc,kc­ Comme rupture rranche lcy: Unh'Crsity of California Press. 196S) 90-91. Plu10I rcfoulc ou uanche Les anciens des8ccords 47 P..ssly IS. A\•CC le corps.. 45 Pressly 16. In 1908 in New York. 24 SaJomcs u1crc dancing on the suigc 48 Lind.a Dalrymple: Henderson. -Mysticism, Romanticism, and the F<>urth at the same time! The term "Salomania.. was C\'Cn coined to describe Dimension,"' The Spiritual In A.rt: Absuaet Pa1itring /89()./985 (New the public's fascination with the theme. Yo.-k: Abbc,illc Press, l9U) 222.

·igurt I detail. Figure I. Gustave Moreau, Salome Dancing before Herod, 1876, Armand Hammer Foundation, Los Angeles. See cover reproduction.

J8 ' • •

f I I Figure 2. Andrea Pisano, Dance ofSalome, Beheading of the Baptist, Baptist's Head Brought to Herod. Presentation of the Baptist's Head to Herod/as, 1336. South Doors of the Baptistery, Florence. (Plates 20-23 in The Sculpture of Andrea and Nino Pisano, by Anita Fiderer Mostkowitz. England: Cambridge University Press, 1986.)

19 Figure 3. Donatello (Donato di Niccolo), Feast of Herod, 1425, Baptismal Font, Cathedral, Siena. (Plate 27 in Donatello, by Maud Cruuwell. London: Methuen & Co. Ltd ., 1911.)

40 Figure 4. Fra Filippo Lippi, Feast of Herod (detail), 1452-66, Cathedral, Prato. (Alinari/ Art Resource, New York.) 41 Figure 5. Peter Paul Rubens. Feast of Her

1/

Figure 7. Gustave Moreau, sketches for Salome Dancing before Herod, Musee Gustave Moreau, Paris. (Plates 62-64 in Gustave Moreau oder Dos Unbehagen in der Natur. by Peter Hahlbrock. Berlin West: Rembrandt Verlag. 1976.)

.'

I , I

I

r - / ' • I 44 Figure 8. Gustave Moreau, The Apparition, 1876; Cabinet des Dcssins, Louvre, Paris.

,s Figure 9. Aubrey Beardsley, Salome with the Head of John the Baptist and Herodias with the Head of John the Baptist, 1894, illustrations for 's Salome. (Harry Ransom Human­ ities Research Center Art Collection, University of Texas at Austin.) , I

~y =- t-~ ' \ . ~ ~..,,l--~~ -

~ I ,.,,,, # - ~ --...... ::::.""- "' --.... i \ - - \ ( - , . • J

\l\ ) I..'ll.

Figure 10. Pablo Picasso, Salome, 1905, Bayly Art Museum at the University of Virginia, CharlotteSvilJe.