The Ethos of Conspiracy Argument : "Character" As Persuader in Conspiracy Rhetoric

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Ethos of Conspiracy Argument : University of Louisville ThinkIR: The University of Louisville's Institutional Repository Electronic Theses and Dissertations 5-2014 The ethos of conspiracy argument : "character" as persuader in conspiracy rhetoric. Michael James Sobiech University of Louisville Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.library.louisville.edu/etd Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Sobiech, Michael James, "The ethos of conspiracy argument : "character" as persuader in conspiracy rhetoric." (2014). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 1359. https://doi.org/10.18297/etd/1359 This Doctoral Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by ThinkIR: The University of Louisville's Institutional Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ThinkIR: The University of Louisville's Institutional Repository. This title appears here courtesy of the author, who has retained all other copyrights. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE ETHOS OF CONSPIRACY ARGUMENT: “CHARACTER” AS PERSUADER IN CONSPIRACY RHETORIC By Michael James Sobiech B.S., Indiana University, 1988 M.A., Western Kentucky University, 2008 A Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of the College of Arts and Sciences of the University of Louisville in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of English University of Louisville Louisville, Kentucky May 2014 Copyright 2014 by Michael James Sobiech All rights reserved THE ETHOS OF CONSPIRACY ARGUMENT: “CHARACTER” AS PERSUADER IN CONSPIRACY RHETORIC By Michael James Sobiech B.S., Indiana University, 1988 M.A., Western Kentucky University, 2008 A Dissertation Approved on April 14, 2014 by the following dissertation committee _______________________________ Debra Journet Dissertation Director _______________________________ Bronwyn Williams _______________________________ Carol Mattingly _______________________________ Susan Griffin _______________________________ Marilyn Cooper ii DEDICATION To my parents, Margaret and Andrew Sobiech. I am thankful that God let me be your son. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This is not a perfect dissertation, but it has been made so much better by the help of so many. A very special thanks to my wonderful director, Debra Journet, who has been helping graduate students through the challenges of dissertations for over twenty years. I am so thankful that she took me on as one of her last students. Thank you to all the members of my committee, Debra Journet, Bronwyn Williams, Carol Mattingly, Susan Griffin, and Marilyn Cooper. Although I can be verbose (see the following dissertation), I am at a loss to adequately state how much I appreciate all your time, insight, encouragement, support, and help throughout this long project. Had I done it by myself, it would have been an utter wreck—picture the Hindenburg landing on the deck of the Titanic. I hope, some day, to emulate your qualities in my own teaching and research. Thank you to all those at Western Kentucky University who helped set me on this path through their help in my receiving my MA, including Dale Rigby, who served as the director for my thesis, and Jane Olmsted, who helped me get a start in studying conspiracy rhetoric by letting me teach a class on conspiracy theories and pop culture. Thank you to the University of Louisville’s libraries, in particular the Interlibrary Loan department and Robert Detmering—both have been invaluable in doing this project. Thank you, also, to Joanna Wolfe (for whom I worked as an assistant director of composition), Susan Griffin (for whom I worked as a research assistant), and Joanne Webb (for whom I worked as an editorial assistant at the Henry James Review). iv Thank you to Karen Kopelson and Susan Ryan, who have been so helpful to me (and so many others) during their time as the director of graduate studies, and thank you to Beth Boehm, who has served as the dean of graduate studies. Thank you to Linda Baldwin and the English department staff. Thank you to my students here at the University of Louisville. And thank you to my friends here at school, upon whom I could always depend in so many ways during the beautiful slogfest that is graduate school. This is not an exhaustive list, but special thanks to Chris Alexander, Lisa Arnold, Nancy Bou Ayash, Alicia Brazeau, Laura Detmering, Jason Dietz, Matthew Dowell, Harley and Gabi Ferris, Lauren Hall, Becky Hallman, Brittany Kelley, Carrie Byars Kilfoil, Tika Lamsai, Brice and Abby Nordquist, Rodrigo Martini Paula, Kathryn Perry, Caleb Pittman, Melissa Ratliff, Vanessa and Mike Sohan, Ryan Trauman, Simon Sangpukdee, Stephanie Weaver, Ben Wetherbee, Matthew Wiles, and Caroline Wilkinson. I would also like to thank my church family here in Louisville, in particular Larry and Joan Coffey, Paul and Wilma Earnhart, Brock and Brittany Henry, Mark and Teresa McCrary, and the members of the Wednesday night supper club. Additionally, thanks to David and Ann Moses of Nashville, Tennessee. And finally, a special thanks to my siblings, nieces, and nephews: Steve, Kathleen, Helen, Joseph, and John Paul Sobiech; Mary Ann, Brad, Drew, and Erin Barrett; Paul, Karin (McGowan), Anya, Eli, Ian, and Mila Sobiech. One of God’s best gifts is taking those whom parents have to separate on long car rides and turning them into friends you wouldn’t want to live without—and I have been so blessed. v ABSTRACT THE ETHOS OF CONSPIRACY ARGUMENT: “CHARACTER” AS PERSUADER IN CONSPIRACY RHETORIC Michael James Sobiech April 14, 2014 Conspiracy theory has, as Timothy Melley states in Empire of Conspiracy (2000), “animated our political culture from the early Republican period to the present, at times powerfully swaying popular opinion” (vii). Though it has attracted attention from a wide range of disciplines, conspiracy theory has not received significant notice within rhetoric and composition. My dissertation adds to the interdisciplinary body of scholarship concerning conspiracy theory by examining it as rhetoric, focusing on how the construction of a conspiracy proponent’s ethos/character affects the persuasiveness of a conspiracy theory. I argue that ethos construction plays a much more significant role in conspiracy persuasion than typically considered. In “The Paranoid Style in American Politics” (1964), Richard Hofstadter describes the importance played by “the figure of the renegade from the enemy cause” (such as an ex-Mormon or ex-nun) in American conspiracy argument. This dissertation examines the ethos of one prominent “renegade”— Charles Chiniquy (1809-1899), an ex-Catholic priest whose conspiracy charges were extensively used by anti-Catholics during America’s Gilded Age and into the twenty-first century. I use as a case study Chiniquy’s 1885 autobiography Fifty Years in the Church of Rome, in which he claims that President Lincoln spoke with him about the Catholic Church’s covert working for the Confederacy and the Church’s desire to assassinate Lincoln. With Lincoln as witness, Chiniquy’s conspiracy was widely circulated to promote anti-Catholicism. vi Belief in Chiniquy’s tale about the dead president ultimately depended on belief in the ex-priest; thus, my dissertation uses Chiniquy’s ethos construction as a means of examining the role ethos plays in persuading people to accept extreme claims. Chapter One reviews scholarship concerning ethos, anti-Catholicism, conspiracy rhetoric, and Chiniquy, my dissertation’s principal historical and theoretical approaches. Chapter Two explores how Fifty Years constructs ethos for Chiniquy. Chapter Three examines how the purported Catholic plot against the president and the Union were constructed in Fifty Years to support an anti-Catholic message, concentrating on three themes which have implications concerning ethos in conspiracy narratives. And Chapter Four describes the reception of Chiniquy’s conspiracy from the Gilded Age to the age of the World Wide Web. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE DEDICATION ................................................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .................................................................................................. iv ABSTRACT ....................................................................................................................... vi INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER ONE: ETHOS, CONSPIRACY ARGUMENT, ANTI-CATHOLICISM, AND CHARLES CHINIQUY: A REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE .............................. 8 Ethos ........................................................................................................................ 9 Anti-Catholicism ................................................................................................... 28 Conspiracy Theory ................................................................................................ 54 Charles Chiniquy ................................................................................................... 67 Endnotes ................................................................................................................ 83 CHAPTER TWO: THE ETHOS OF A RENEGADE: CHINIQUY’S SELF CONSTRUCTION IN FIFTY YEARS IN THE CHURCH OF ROME ............................. 88 External Ethos Via Printed Paratext .....................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Study of John Galsworthy's Justice As a Realistic Exposure of the English
    ==================================================================== Language in India www.languageinindia.com ISSN 1930-2940 Vol. 19:5 May 2019 India’s Higher Education Authority UGC Approved List of Journals Serial Number 49042 ==================================================================== Study of John Galsworthy’s Justice as a Realistic Exposure of the English Society Kailas Vijayrao Karnewar, M.A., NET College Road, Snehnagar, Vasmath Dist.- Hingoli. Pin- 431512 [email protected] ================================================================== Abstract John Galsworthy was an English playwright of 20th century. Alike G. B. Shaw he used drama as a vehicle for assigning communal criticism in each of his plays, he uncovered some social illness or other. John Galsworthy’s conception of drama is grounded on realism and general sense of morals. He supposed that drama is a noteworthy art form and capable of inspiring the attention and conveying consciousness of honorable ideologies in human life. Being a law graduate he was conscious of the severe restriction of a legalistic approach to men and matters. Galsworthy also becomes victim of rigid law and rigid society, since he was not married to his lover, Ada. In Justice he exposes all evil of the society like rigid divorce law, rigidity of society, solitary confinement and injustice done to prisoner. Galsworthy presented it by using naturalistic technique. Therefore, basic aim of this paper is to study the ills of English society which caused the demise of the main character Falder. Keywords: John Galsworthy, Justice, Realistic, English society, naturalistic technique, rigid law Introduction John Galsworthy is the best eminent problem writer and novelist in the 20th century. Like Bernard Shaw and his forerunner Ibsen, Galsworthy also presented some boiling problems or other in all his plays.
    [Show full text]
  • Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism Cosmopolitan Reflections
    Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism Cosmopolitan Reflections David Hirsh Department of Sociology, Goldsmiths, University of London, New Cross, London SE14 6NW, UK The Working Papers Series is intended to initiate discussion, debate and discourse on a wide variety of issues as it pertains to the analysis of antisemitism, and to further the study of this subject matter. Please feel free to submit papers to the ISGAP working paper series. Contact the ISGAP Coordinator or the Editor of the Working Paper Series, Charles Asher Small. Working Paper Hirsh 2007 ISSN: 1940-610X © Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy ISGAP 165 East 56th Street, Second floor New York, NY 10022 United States Office Telephone: 212-230-1840 www.isgap.org ABSTRACT This paper aims to disentangle the difficult relationship between anti-Zionism and antisemitism. On one side, antisemitism appears as a pressing contemporary problem, intimately connected to an intensification of hostility to Israel. Opposing accounts downplay the fact of antisemitism and tend to treat the charge as an instrumental attempt to de-legitimize criticism of Israel. I address the central relationship both conceptually and through a number of empirical case studies which lie in the disputed territory between criticism and demonization. The paper focuses on current debates in the British public sphere and in particular on the campaign to boycott Israeli academia. Sociologically the paper seeks to develop a cosmopolitan framework to confront the methodological nationalism of both Zionism and anti-Zionism. It does not assume that exaggerated hostility to Israel is caused by underlying antisemitism but it explores the possibility that antisemitism may be an effect even of some antiracist forms of anti- Zionism.
    [Show full text]
  • Written Proof: Vatican/Jesuit Conspiracy Against USA + World
    Written Proof: Vatican/Jesuit conspiracy against USA + world Written Proof (of the Vatican/Jesuit conspiracy against USA + the whole world) https://www.RestoreMBI.com/written-proof.htm https://www.RestoreMBI.com/written-proof.pdf Hello fellow followers of Christ and prayer partners, This is a #RedAlert. What you are about to see is #written #proof from #Catholic #quotes of a very large #conspiracy. The #Vatican has planned to take over the #United #States of #America and #rule it, and the #world through the USA. And they plan to ruin it like they did to #Europe. And the Catholic leaders say they must kill/murder those who reject or oppose their #lawyers and “#doctrines”. #Chiniquy risked his life to tell you what they said, and yes they killed/murdered him for exposing their evil and crimes. But each of us can stop them. Watch for anyone who got Catholic or Jesuit training and oppose everything they do. Starting with the Catholic/Jesuit Supreme Court, and Jesuit Donald Trump, and including the Senate and House representatives, and all of their lawyers. Their Catholic or Jesuit training helps them look like us and sound like us, while they destroy good things from their inside positions. A man named Charles Chiniquy, was a contemporary of DL Moody and later became a friend of DL Moody and of Abraham Lincoln. Chiniquy was a Vatican “priest” for 50 years, but turned against the Vatican after the start of the USA Civil War. Chiniquy kept clashing against the leadership until God helped him to finally see that he needed to leave the Vatican system.
    [Show full text]
  • The True Mary Todd Lincoln ALSO by BETTY BOLES ELLISON
    The True Mary Todd Lincoln ALSO BY BETTY BOLES ELLISON The Early Laps of Stock Car Racing: A History of the Sport and Business through 1974 (McFarland, 2014) The True Mary Todd Lincoln A Biography BETTY BOLES ELLISON McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Jefferson, North Carolina LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGUING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA Ellison, Betty Boles. The true Mary Todd Lincoln : a biography / Betty Boles Ellison. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7864-7836-1 (softcover : acid free paper) ♾ ISBN 978-1-4766-1517-2 (ebook) 1. Lincoln, Mary Todd, 1818–1882. 2. Presidents’ spouses—United States— Biography. 3. Lincoln, Abraham, 1809–1865—Family. I. Title. E457.25.L55E45 2014 973.7092—dc23 [B] 2014003651 BRITISH LIBRARY CATALOGUING DATA ARE AVAILABLE © 2014 Betty Boles Ellison. All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying or recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. On the cover: Oil portrait of a twenty-year-old Mary Todd painted in 1928 by Katherine Helm, a niece of Mary Todd Lincoln and daughter of Confederate General Ben H. Helm. It is based on a daguerreotype taken in Springfield by N.H. Shepherd in 1846; a companion daguerreotype is the earliest known photograph of Lincoln (courtesy of the Abraham Lincoln Library and Museum of Lincoln Memorial University, Harrogate, Tennessee) Manufactured in the United States of America McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Box 611, Jefferson, North Carolina 28640 www.mcfarlandpub.com For Sofia E.
    [Show full text]
  • Bloomsburg Investment Group
    Bloomsburg Investment Group Equity Analysis The Procter & Gamble Company (PG) Analyst: Gerrick Hardy, Class of 2021 Trevor Luzi, Mackenzie Gross, Class of 2022 Bloomsburg Investment Group Opinion: After our group's thorough analysis, we believe it is in the best interest of the group if our holding in Procter & Gamble (PG) is partially liquidated. Although our group remains bullish about the company, we think taking some profits from PG's recent run-up and allocating funds elsewhere in the sector would be most beneficial. While the company has provided strong organic growth in each of the two previous quarters, a number of headwinds remain in the way which will likely restrict future growth. A stronger U.S. Dollar has essentially offset the organic revenue growth, and the rise in transportation costs and commodity prices has and will likely continue to squeeze the margins of PG. With consumer tastes trending towards less expensive generic brands, customers may not respond favorably to recent price increases of some of Procter & Gamble’s largest brands. Our sector believes PG is currently trading at a premium that will not be satisfied with future growth. Despite all of this, we are still bullish because of the high dividend yield that the company has increased for 62 consecutive years, wide array of brand offerings, and brand loyalty and recognition, among other factors. Considering cross-current risks that exist in the macroeconomic environment and the potential of an upcoming recession or economic downturn, Procter & Gamble will continue to provide stable growth and hedge our portfolio. Corporate Summary: Corporate Details: Name Procter & Gamble Co The Procter & Gamble Company, founded in 1837, is Ticker PG a global manufacturer and distributor of household Domicile United States goods.
    [Show full text]
  • Charmin Sensitive BHG Award Release 4.19.11
    The Procter & Gamble News Release Company One P&G Plaza Cincinnati, OH 45202 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CHARMIN SENSITIVE VOTED BEST NEW BATHROOM TISSUE BY CONSUMERS Award Announced in June Issue of Better Homes and Gardens on Newsstands Today CINCINNATI, OH (May 2, 2011) – Procter & Gamble’s [NYSE: PG] Charmin Sensitive® has been voted the best new bathroom tissue in 2011* in the June issue of Better Homes and Gardens, on newsstands today. The third annual Best New Product Awards issue highlights 42 winning consumer products in the categories of health and beauty, food, and household care – which is where Charmin Sensitive is featured. “It's great to hear the product has been so well received by consumers," said Hailee Hoffman, Brand Manager for Charmin Sensitive. "Being voted the best new bathroom tissue lets us know that this product delivers a level of quality and comfort for consumers. Each roll contains a touch of soothing lotion with aloe and vitamin E, providing a gentle and comfortable clean." Winning products were selected as part of an extensive BrandSpark International/Better Homes and Gardens American Shopper Study, which surveyed more than 50,000 consumers. To determine the winners, the survey included key questions about individual product appeal and intent to repurchase among shoppers who had actually purchased the product. Each of the 42 product categories had between three and five products from at least two different manufacturers. In order to win, the product had to have the highest combined score on product appeal and re-purchase intent among those who had previously purchased the product.
    [Show full text]
  • Bible Believers' Bulletin
    BIBLE BELIEVERS’ BULLETIN September 2017 Page 1 Bible Believers’ Bulletin Vol. 41 No. 9 “Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth” (John 17:17) September 2017 Today’s Bold Talk Radio “Christians” By Brian Donovan should be particularly noticed as it is Contrary to the right-wing, conser- in the context of one of the favorite vative, Republican, “Christian” move- misapplied verses used by politicians ment’s rhetoric, America is not now, trying to sucker Christians for their nor ever has been, a Christian nation. votes today (verse 14 “If my people, Bible believers know that the Lord which are called by my name, shall has lumped all nations together as humble themselves…”). “a drop of a bucket” (Isaiah 40:15) In their self-righteousness, the and that includes the USA. The only Jews must be reminded that they exception to that rule is the nation of were not chosen because they were Israel, which stands out as the “apple” better than the Gentile nations (Deu- of the Lord’s eye (Deuteronomy teronomy 9:4-5), but simply because 32:10) and she enjoys the singular of the oath that the Lord swore to distinction of being His special people keep to their fathers (Deuteronomy that are not Americans (Psalm 125:1- 7:6-8). It is amazing how upset the 2), as a special nation that is not American Laodicean Christians get America (II Samuel 7:23), with a spe- when this is taught and preached. cial city that is not Washington D.C. They will run to their Constitution and (Il Chronicles 6:38), and a special their Bill of Rights (one even said place that is not the White House (II that the historical fulfillment of the Chronicles 7:15).
    [Show full text]
  • View & Download the 2020 Program
    University of Colorado Colorado Springs COMMENCEMENT MAY 15, 2020 FROM THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY TO THE CLASS OF 2020 Dear Graduate: One of the greatest honors for the University of Colorado Board of Regents, the institution’s governing board, is to be part of this commencement ceremony. Your success is a success for us all. Your degree is a measure not only of an accomplishment of dedication and talent, but also notice to the world that you have the skill and discipline to contribute greatly to any endeavor you pursue. This commencement ceremony, like every University of Colorado graduation since 1935, will close with the reading of the Norlin Charge. As originally expressed by former CU President George Norlin in 1935, graduation "marks your initiation in the fullest sense of the fellowship of the University, as bearers of her torch, as centers of her influence, and as promoters of her spirit." Welcome to the ranks of CU’s alumni family, which is over 445,000 strong. Congratulations on achieving this milestone. Well done and well earned! Cordially, THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO Back Row: Linda Shoemaker, District 2 (Boulder); Lesley Smith, At Large (Boulder); Chance Hill, District 5 (Colorado Springs); John Carson, District 6 (Highlands Ranch); Glen Gallegos, Chair, District 3 (Grand Junction) Front Row: Heidi Ganahl, At Large (Superior); Sue Sharkey, District 4 (Castle Rock); John “Jack” Kroll, District 1 (Denver); Irene Griego, Vice Chair, District 7 (Lakewood) ORDER OF EXERCISES DR. CHRISTOPHER BELL, COMMENCEMENT MARSHAL UCCS MARSHAL’S CLUB MEMBER* Ceremony The National Anthem (Lyrics on page 33) .
    [Show full text]
  • Maryland Historical Magazine, 1950, Volume 45, Issue No. 1
    MARYLAND HISTORICAL MAGAZINE -. % * ,#^iPB P^jJl ?3 ^I^PQPQI H^^yjUl^^ ^_Z ^_^^.: •.. : ^ t lj^^|j|| tm *• Perry Hall, Baltimore County, Home of Harry Dorsey Gough Central Part Built 1773, Wings Added 1784 MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY BALTIMORE larch - 1950 Jft •X'-Jr t^r Jfr Jr J* A* JU J* Jj* Jl» J* Jt* ^tuiy <j» J» Jf A ^ J^ ^ A ^ A •jr J» J* *U J^ ^t* J*-JU'^ Jfr J^ J* »jnjr «jr Jujr «V Jp J(r Jfr Jr Jfr J* «jr»t JUST PUBLISHED BY THE SOCIETY HISTORY OF QUEEN ANNE'S COUNTY, MARYLAND By FREDERIC EMORY First printed in 1886-87 in the columns of the Centre- ville Observer, this authoritative history of one of the oldest counties on the Eastern Shore, has now been issued in book form. It has been carefully indexed and edited. 629 pages. Cloth binding. $7.50 per copy. By mail $7.75. Published with the assistance of the Queen Anne's County Free Library by the MARYLAND HISTORICAL SOCIETY 201 W. MONUMENT STREET BALTIMORE 1 •*••*••*•+•(•'t'+'t-T',trTTrTTTr"r'PTTTTTTTTTTrrT,f'»-,f*"r-f'J-TTT-ft-4"t"t"t"t--t-l- CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING Dftrkxr-BTKrTVTMn FRANK W. LINNEMANN BOOKBINDING 2^ Park Ave Magazines, medical books. Old books rebound PHOTOGRAPHY THE "^^^^ 213 West Monument Street, Baltimore nvr^m^xm > m» • ^•» -, _., ..-•-... „ Baltimore Photo & Blue Print Co PHOTOSTATS & BLUEPRINTS 211 East Baltimore St. Photo copying of old records, genealogical charts LE 688I and family papers. Enlargements. Coats of Arms. PLUMBING — HEATING M. NELSON BARNES Established 1909 BE.
    [Show full text]
  • The JFK Assassination and the Politics and Culture of Conspiracy Theory
    A Paranoid Style? : The JFK Assassination and the Politics and Culture of Conspiracy Theory Joseph Broadbent Degree of Masters of Arts by Research University of East Anglia School of American Studies January 2014 This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with the author and that use of any information derived there from must be in accordance with current UK Copyright Law. In addition, any quotation or extract must include full attribution. 2 Abstract This thesis analyses the phenomenon of conspiracy theory, using the assassination of President John F. Kennedy as a case study. Doubt is the root cause of conspiracy theory, stemming from both the innate biases all humans exhibit, and a traumatic experience – in this case the assassination of JFK. This thesis argues that conspiracy theories are created and take hold because of a predisposition toward conspiracy theory, a misinterpretation of a central piece of evidence, such as the Zapruder film, and agency panic, where dispossession causes one to feel as if their agency is under threat. Conspiracy theory can provide believers with many emotions which appear to the individual to not be available elsewhere, namely closure, comfort, control, and a sense of leisure. Using the assassination of JFK, this thesis examines the role of conspiracy theory in modern American society. It weighs up the benefits of conspiracy theory, such as it is an example of free speech and it can aid transparency, with the negatives: that it can possibly cause harm to its adherents and their dependants because of a belief in ends justifying the means.
    [Show full text]
  • Instrumentalising the Past: the Germanic Myth in National Socialist Context
    RJHI 1 (1) 2014 Instrumentalising the Past: The Germanic Myth in National Socialist Context Irina-Maria Manea * Abstract : In the search for an explanatory model for the present or even more, for a fundament for national identity, many old traditions were rediscovered and reutilized according to contemporary desires. In the case of Germany, a forever politically fragmented space, justifying unity was all the more important, especially beginning with the 19 th century when it had a real chance to establish itself as a state. Then, beyond nationalism and romanticism, at the dawn of the Third Reich, the myth of a unified, powerful, pure people with a tradition dating since time immemorial became almost a rule in an ideology that attempted to go back to the past and select those elements which could have ensured a historical basis for the regime. In this study, we will attempt to focus on two important aspects of this type of instrumentalisation. The focus of the discussion is mainly Tacitus’ Germania, a work which has been forever invoked in all sorts of contexts as a means to discover the ancient Germans and create a link to the modern ones, but in the same time the main beliefs in the realm of history and archaeology are underlined, so as to catch a better glimpse of how the regime has been instrumentalising and overinterpreting highly controversial facts. Keywords : Tacitus, Germania, myth, National Socialism, Germany, Kossinna, cultural-historical archaeology, ideology, totalitarianism, falsifying history During the twentieth century, Tacitus’ famous work Germania was massively instrumentalised by the Nazi regime, in order to strengthen nationalism and help Germany gain an aura of eternal glory.
    [Show full text]
  • Demons & Devils: the Moral Panic Surrounding Dungeons & Dragons
    Demons & Devils: The Moral Panic Surrounding Dungeons & Dragons, 1979-1991 by Austin Wilson Submitted to the Department of History of the University of Kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for departmental honors Approved by: David Farber, Thesis Coordinator Sheyda Jahanbani, Committee Member David Roediger, Committee Member Date Defended: 4/24/2019 1 On June 9, 1982 Irving “Bink” Pulling committed suicide by shooting himself in the chest. His distraught mother Patricia Pulling attempted to find out what had driven her son to such extreme measures. In her search for answers she laid the blame squarely on Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), in which Bink had been heavily involved. Patricia Pulling started the organization Bothered About Dungeons and Dragons (BADD) in 1983. BADD crusaded against roleplaying games like Dungeons & Dragons. As she would argue in many works that she subsequently published, including her 1989 manifesto, The Devil’s Web: Who is Stalking Your Children for Satan?, Dungeons & Dragons was a dangerous game that put the lives and moral virtues of youths at risk by serving as an entry point to the occult.1 This paper will argue that there was a moment of crisis centered around the family in the period and the broader discussion of youth entertainment which allowed for BADD to gain traction. By examining pamphlets produced by BADD and Patricia Pulling’s appearance on shows like 60 Minutes the dogma of the group can be understood. By juxtaposing other pieces of media that a parent may have seen in the same period such as the senate hearing for parental advisory labels on music and anti-drug PSAs this paper will illustrate the ways that people were primed by other panics of the period to believe that D&D could be dangerous.
    [Show full text]