DOCSLIB.ORG

Central Valleys Railway Package Final Evaluation: Final Report

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Central Valleys Railway Package Final Evaluation: Final Report SOCIAL RESEARCH NUMBER: 05/2018 PUBLICATION DATE: 25/01/2018 Central Valleys Railway Package Final Evaluation: Final Report © Crown Copyright Digital ISBN 978-1-78903-403-5 Central Valleys Railway Package Final Evaluation: Final Report AECOM Full Research Report: AECOM (2018). Central Valleys Railway Package Final Evaluation: Final Report. Cardiff: Welsh Government. GSR report number 05/2018 Available at: http://gov.wales/statistics-and-research/evaluation-central- valleys-railway-package/?lang=en Views expressed in this report are those of the researcher and not necessarily those of the Welsh Government For further information please contact: Joanne Corke Social Research and Information Division Knowledge and Analytical Services Welsh Government Cathays Park Cardiff CF10 3NQ Tel: 0300 025 1138 Email: [email protected] Table of contents List of tables ........................................................................................................................... 3 List of Figures ........................................................................................................................ 3 Glossary ................................................................................................................................. 4 Executive Summary ............................................................................................................... 5 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 5 Key findings ........................................................................................................................... 5 Recommendations ................................................................................................................. 7 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................. 11 Evaluation Scope ................................................................................................................. 11 Process Evaluation .............................................................................................................. 12 Interviewees ......................................................................................................................... 14 Impact Evaluation ................................................................................................................ 15 2. Project Overview ..................................................................................................... 16 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 16 Objectives ............................................................................................................................ 16 Project Inputs ....................................................................................................................... 16 Project Outputs .................................................................................................................... 16 Anticipated Project Results .................................................................................................. 17 3. Finance ................................................................................................................... 19 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 19 Planned Costs...................................................................................................................... 19 Outturn Costs ....................................................................................................................... 21 Barriers and Constraints - Reasons for cost variations ........................................................ 22 Cost Management ................................................................................................................ 22 Lessons for future projects ................................................................................................... 23 4. Schedule/Programme .............................................................................................. 25 Planned Timescales ............................................................................................................. 25 Actual Timescales ................................................................................................................ 27 Barriers and Constraints ...................................................................................................... 29 Lessons for future projects ................................................................................................... 30 5. Stakeholder Engagement ........................................................................................ 31 Barriers and Constraints ...................................................................................................... 32 Lessons for future projects ................................................................................................... 34 6. Risk Management ................................................................................................... 35 1 Planned Approach to Risk Management .............................................................................. 35 Materialisation of Risks ........................................................................................................ 38 Lessons for future projects ................................................................................................... 39 7. Project Management ............................................................................................... 41 Project Team........................................................................................................................ 41 Programme Management Board .......................................................................................... 42 WEFO Rail Programme Board ............................................................................................. 46 Effectiveness of Monitoring and Evaluation Activities .......................................................... 47 Equal Opportunities Monitoring ............................................................................................ 49 Lessons for future projects ................................................................................................... 50 8. Energlyn Impact Assessment .................................................................................. 51 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 51 Objectives of the schemes ................................................................................................... 51 Gross/Net passenger kilometres .......................................................................................... 53 Improved reliability, customer satisfaction, comfort and convenience.................................. 56 Reduction in car demand ..................................................................................................... 58 Jobs Created........................................................................................................................ 58 Enhanced Access to jobs/education .................................................................................... 59 Business Accessibility .......................................................................................................... 61 Attribution of Results to CVR Project ................................................................................... 61 9. Cross-Cutting Themes ............................................................................................ 64 Equal Opportunities ............................................................................................................. 64 Environmental Sustainability ................................................................................................ 66 Value for Money ................................................................................................................... 66 10. Conclusions ............................................................................................................. 67 11. Recommendations .................................................................................................. 69 Finance ................................................................................................................................ 69 Schedule/Programme .......................................................................................................... 69 Stakeholder Engagement .................................................................................................... 69 Risk Management ................................................................................................................ 70 Programme Management .................................................................................................... 70 Annex A – Passenger Survey Results ................................................................................. 72 Annex B – Technical Review of Business Case................................................................... 76 2 List of tables Table 2.1 WEFO Objectives ...............................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • RAIL INFRASTRUCTURE and IMPROVED PASSENGER SERVICE COMMITTEE INTERIM REPORT March 2006
    RAIL INFRASTRUCTURE AND IMPROVED PASSENGER SERVICE COMMITTEE INTERIM REPORT March 2006 RAIL INFRASTRUCTURE AND IMPROVED PASSENGER SERVICE COMMITTEE INTERIM REPORT March 2006 If you would like further copies of this report or a version in the following formats (large print, Braille, audio cassette or compact disk), please contact: Leanne Hatcher Rail Infrastructure and Improved Passenger Services Committee National Assembly for Wales Cardiff Bay CF99 1NA Tel: 029 2089 8429 E-mail: [email protected] Committee Members John Marek AM (Chair) Wrexham Leighton Andrews AM Rhondda Eleanor Burnham AM North Wales Rosemary Butler AM Newport West Janet Davies AM South Wales West Lisa Francis AM Mid & West Wales Carl Sargeant AM Alyn & Deeside Secretariat Chris Reading Committee Clerk Sarah Bartlett Deputy Clerk Leanne Hatcher Team Support Contents Page Number 1. Introduction 1 2. Roles and Responsibilities 2 3. Strategic Planning 8 4. Key Issues 9 5. What happens next? 14 Annexes 1. Schedule of Committee Papers 2. Verbatim Record of Committee Meetings 3. Consultation Letter 4. Schedule of Organisations Consulted 5. Summary of Consultation Responses 6. Structure of Welsh Rail Passenger Industry 7. Map of Rail Network 1. Introduction Background 1.1 The committee was established, in accordance with Standing Order 8.1, by a motion (NDM2735) that was approved by plenary on 6 December 2005. This motion set parameters for committee membership, terms of reference and various other matters; including the requirement to report to the National Assembly by the end of March and to terminate on 19 May 2006. 1.2 The committee held its inaugural meeting on 1 February 2006 to agree various procedural matters, including the election of the Chair.
    [Show full text]
  • Rail Station Usage in Wales, 2018-19
    Rail station usage in Wales, 2018-19 19 February 2020 SB 5/2020 About this bulletin Summary This bulletin reports on There was a 9.4 per cent increase in the number of station entries and exits the usage of rail stations in Wales in 2018-19 compared with the previous year, the largest year on in Wales. Information year percentage increase since 2007-08. (Table 1). covers stations in Wales from 2004-05 to 2018-19 A number of factors are likely to have contributed to this increase. During this and the UK for 2018-19. period the Wales and Borders rail franchise changed from Arriva Trains The bulletin is based on Wales to Transport for Wales (TfW), although TfW did not make any the annual station usage significant timetable changes until after 2018-19. report published by the Most of the largest increases in 2018-19 occurred in South East Wales, Office of Rail and Road especially on the City Line in Cardiff, and at stations on the Valleys Line close (ORR). This report to or in Cardiff. Between the year ending March 2018 and March 2019, the includes a spreadsheet level of employment in Cardiff increased by over 13,000 people. which gives estimated The number of station entries and exits in Wales has risen every year since station entries and station 2004-05, and by 75 per cent over that period. exits based on ticket sales for each station on Cardiff Central remains the busiest station in Wales with 25 per cent of all the UK rail network.
    [Show full text]
  • Wales Network Specification: March 2017 Network Rail – Network Specification: Wales 02 Wales
    Delivering a better railway for a better Britain Network Specification 2017 Wales Network Specification: March 2017 Network Rail – Network Specification: Wales 02 Wales Incorporating Strategic Routes: L: Wales and This Network Specification describes the Wales Route in its There are also a number of other supporting documents that Borders geographical context and provides a summary of the infrastructure present specific strategies including: that is available for passenger and freight operators. It identifies Scenarios and Long Distance Forecasts – published in June 2009. the key markets for passenger and freight services by Strategic • The document considers how demand for long distance rail Route Sections (SRS). The SRSs cover specific sections of the route services, both passenger and freight, might be impacted by four and are published as appendices to this document. They describe in alternative future scenarios greater detail the current and future requirements of each SRS to inform both internal and external stakeholders of our future • Electrification Strategy – published October 2009 presents a strategy. strategy for further electrification of the network. Work is ongoing to refresh the Strategy in the light of committed Control This Network Specification draws upon the supporting evidence Period 5 electrification schemes, the ‘Electric Spine’ development from the Route Utilisation Strategy (RUS) process which informs the project and the formation of a ‘Task Force’ to consider further strategy to 2019, and the emerging findings from the Long Term electrification opportunities across the North of England. Planning Process (LTPP) which looks ahead 10 and 30 years. Stations – published in August 2011. This strategy considered the As part of the LTPP, four Market Studies have been established, • pedestrian capacity of stations on the network.
    [Show full text]
  • Route Utilisation Strategy November 2008  Foreword
    Wales Route Utilisation Strategy November 2008 2 Foreword I am delighted to present Network Rail’s Route Principally this is in south Wales, where capacity Utilisation Strategy (RUS) for Wales. This use is at its highest. This is a result of a growth covers the entire rail network in Wales, as well in the number of trains serving Cardiff and the as some parts of the network in the English building of a number of new stations. On this border counties. part of the network, in the most populous part of the country, the RUS builds on the successful This network is extensive and diverse. past introduction of more services and the There are main line links from Wales into selective growth of the network. England, a long-distance line along the border connecting north and south Wales, a busy A major programme to renew signalling urban passenger network serving Cardiff, and equipment in the Newport and Cardiff areas branches traversing sparsely populated rural will take place in the next five to seven years, areas. Some parts of the network are subject and much of the work described in this to fluctuating demand according to the time of strategy to enhance the network is planned year, most notably on the Cambrian Coast and in conjunction with this signalling work to in the Conwy Valley. increase cost-effectiveness. The High Level Output Specification (HLOS), published in The context in which this RUS has been July 2007, contained a specific requirement to produced, as has often been the case with increase seating capacity into Cardiff during other RUSs, is one of growing demand for the morning peak.
    [Show full text]
  • Environment and Sustainability Scrutiny Committee – for Information
    11.02.20 ENVIRONMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY SCRUTINY COMMITTEE – FOR INFORMATION SUBJECT: WELL-BEING OBJECTIVE 4 – 6 MONTH PROGRESS UPDATE REPORT BY: INTERIM CORPORATE DIRECTOR – COMMUNITIES 1. PURPOSE OF REPORT 1.1 This report is for information only and gives a progress update of the first six months of 2019/20 against Wellbeing Objective 4 ‘Promote a modern, integrated and sustainable transport system that increases opportunity, promotes prosperity and minimises the adverse impacts on the environment’. 2. SUMMARY 2.1 The Well-being Objectives are set for five years 2018-2023. This is the 6 month update of 2019/20 progress of the Well-being objective 4. 2.2 This Well-being Objective has 6 outcomes (as listed in 5.1 below). Reviewing the outcomes at this stage of the 5-year plan the objective is judged to be progressing well. 3. RECOMMENDATIONS 3.1 Members are requested to note the content of the report and to note that progress is being made at the 6 month stage of 2019/20 of the 2018-2023 Well-being Objective assessment. 4. REASONS FOR THE RECOMMENDATIONS 4.1 That members are informed and have the opportunity to call the objective to the agenda in having assurance that the Council is working towards delivering the objectives within its Corporate Plan 2018-2023. 5. THE REPORT 5.1 Well-being Objective 4 has 6 outcomes which are:- 5.1.1 Work with the delivery of the South East Wales Metro, aiming for the Valley Lines Electrification programme as part of the delivery of the wider South East Wales Metro scheme.
    [Show full text]
  • SB 58/2013 Rail Station Usage in Wales 2011-12
    SB 58/2013 11 June 2013 Rail Station Usage in Wales 2011-12 This Statistical Bulletin reports on the usage of rail stations in Wales. Information covers each station in Wales for the past three financial years, from 2009-10 to 2011-12, and for Wales and the UK as a whole back to 2004-05. The bulletin is based on the annual station usage report that is published by the Office of Rail Regulation (ORR). As part of this report the ORR publish a spreadsheet which lists the estimated station entries and station exits for each station on the UK rail network. Key results The total number of station entries/exits in Welsh stations has risen every year since 2004-05. Cardiff Central remains the busiest station in Wales with around one quarter of all station entries/exits. Rail station usage in Wales accounts for around 2 per cent of the UK total. Chart 1: Station entries/exits in Wales, 2004-05 to 2011-12 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 Station entries/exits (millions) 100 50 0 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 • In 2011-12 there were 218 rail stations in Wales (Table 3); • There was an increase of 2.6 per cent in the number of station entries/exits in Wales in 2011-12 compared with 2010-11, the smallest year on year growth since 2005-06 (Table 2). • Of the 20 busiest stations in Wales, 11 are part of the Valley Lines network, not including Cardiff Central and Cardiff Queen Street (Table 1).
    [Show full text]
  • A Cardiff Capital Region Metro: Impact Study: Metro Interventions Appraisal Report
    Report to the Minister for Economy, Science and Transport Merthyr Ebbw Hirwaun Tydfil Rhymney Tredegar Vale Brynmawr Abergavenny Aberdare Treherbert Abertillery Pontypool Bargoed Blackwood Newbridge Abercynon Cwmbran Pontypridd Ystrad Mynach Cross Keys Porth Maesteg Talbot Green Taffs Well Caerphilly Caerleon Pontyclun Cardiff Gate North West Heath Bridgend Cardiff Severn Queen Tunnel Ely Mill Street Newport Junction Porthcawl St Llanwern Chepstow Mellons Culverhouse Cross Pill Cardiff Cardiff Bay Bristol Airport Sports Village Cardiff Central Barry Penarth Porth Teigr A Cardiff Capital Region Metro: Impact Study: Metro Interventions Appraisal Report October 2013 Metro Interventions Appraisal Report FINAL Report | September 2013 Project No: CS/060195 Doc Ref: CS/060195 Rev: Client: Welsh Government Issue Date: September 2013 Metro Interventions Appraisal Report: FINAL Report Name Signature Date Author Michelle North-Jones 30/09/2013 Checker David McCallum 30/09/2013 Approver David McCallum 30/09/2013 Issue Record Rev Date Description/Comments Author/Prepared by: Approved for Issue by: “The report shall be for the private and confidential use of the clients for whom the report is undertaken and should not be reproduced in whole or in part or relied upon by third parties for any use whatsoever without the express written authority of the Consultant’ Metro Interventions Appraisal Report: FINAL Report September 2013 CONTENTS 1. Introduction 1 1.1 Context 1.2 Report Purpose and Structure 2. Appraisal Methodology 3 2.1. Modal Interventions 2.2 Appraisal Criteria 2.3 Intervention Assessment 3. Appraisal Results and Recommended Interventions Packages 10 3.1 Appraisal Results by Intervention Category 3.2 Intervention Packages 3.3 Quick Wins 4.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter52 November 2010
    SARPA Newsletter 52 Page 1 Northbound Cambrian at Barmouth, 30th August 2010. Photo: Richard Bull Chairman’s Message..................................................................................................3 News in Brief...............................................................................................................5 Provisional meeting schedule for 2010-11..................................................................7 Chairman’s travels, it can be done - Part 2.................................................................8 Aberystwyth arrivals and departures - summer - 1951.............................................10 The view from Milepost 62 with the Brigadier.............................................................13 Websites...................................................................................................................15 Useful addresses......................................................................................................16 Officers of the Association........................................................................................16 Page 2 SARPA Newsletter 52 This is the quarterly newsletter of the Shrewsbury to Aberystwyth Rail Passenger Association. Contributions are welcomed from members and non-members about the mid Wales rail scene. Views expressed in it are those of contributors and not necessarily representative of the Association as a whole. Information provided is published in good faith, but the Association cannot accept responsibility for any
    [Show full text]
  • Welsh Route Study March 2016 Contents March 2016 Network Rail – Welsh Route Study 02
    Long Term Planning Process Welsh Route Study March 2016 Contents March 2016 Network Rail – Welsh Route Study 02 Foreword 03 Executive summary 04 Chapter 1 – Strategic Planning Process 06 Chapter 2 – The starting point for the Welsh Route Study 10 Chapter 3 - Consultation responses 17 Chapter 4 – Future demand for rail services - capacity and connectivity 22 Chapter 5 – Conditional Outputs - future capacity and connectivity 29 Chapter 6 – Choices for funders to 2024 49 Chapter 7 – Longer term strategy to 2043 69 Appendix A – Appraisal Results 109 Appendix B – Mapping of choices for funders to Conditional Outputs 124 Appendix C – Stakeholder aspirations 127 Appendix D – Rolling Stock characteristics 140 Appendix E – Interoperability requirements 141 Glossary 145 Foreword March 2016 Network Rail – Welsh Route Study 03 We are delighted to present this Route Study which sets out the The opportunity for the Digital Railway to address capacity strategic vision for the railway in Wales between 2019 and 2043. constraints and to improve customer experience is central to the planning approach we have adopted. It is an evidence based study that considers demand entirely within the Wales Route and also between Wales and other parts of Great This Route Study has been developed collaboratively with the Britain. railway industry, with funders and with stakeholders. We would like to thank all those involved in the exercise, which has been extensive, The railway in Wales has seen a decade of unprecedented growth, and which reflects the high level of interest in the railway in Wales. with almost 50 per cent more passenger journeys made to, from We are also grateful to the people and the organisations who took and within Wales since 2006, and our forecasts suggest that the time to respond to the Draft for Consultation published in passenger growth levels will continue to be strong during the next March 2015.
    [Show full text]
  • Community Review 2013 Review of the Community Boundary And
    Community Review 2013 Review of the Community Boundary And Electoral Arrangements Within The City And County of Cardiff DRAFT PROPOSALS –APPENDIX G SUMMARY OF SUBMISISONS From Community Councillor Peter Bradbury Caerau Cardiff Council Councillor for Caerau Submission Summary: No Change: Can I state that I believe that in my ward no changes are necessary, indeed I believe an extra councillor could be needed soon with an electorate of over 7500. From Community Councillor Elaine Simmons Caerau Cardiff Council Councillor for Caerau Submission Summary: No change: Supports the view of the previous submission. From Community As Individual Roath Submission Summary: No change. From Community As Individual Rhiwbina Submission Summary: No change: My 3 councillors are already dealing with queries, problems representing 6,800 plus constituents, enlarging or extending existing boundaries would mean a less efficient service - watered down responses, etc. We also have geographical boundaries ie Eastern Ave. -East. Wenallt Mountain North. Page | 95 Community Review 2013 Review of the Community Boundary And Electoral Arrangements Within The City And County of Cardiff DRAFT PROPOSALS –APPENDIX G From Community Councillor Ed Bridges Gabalfa Cardiff Council Councillor for Gabalfa Cathays Submission Summary: Recommendation 1 - Creation of a new community of Talybont based on Talybont North halls and Talybont South halls in Gabalfa ward and Talybont Court falls within Cathays ward. This change would, …, logically join up one holistic community into the same polling district, ward and constituency and prevent a great deal of confusion. Recommendation 2 - renaming the Gabalfa community as Maindy Currently, very few people who live in Gabalfa ward say that they live in Gabalfa - most erroneously believe they are residents of Cathays, Mynachdy, Heath or Maindy, as these are the historical postal addresses for the constituent parts of the ward.
    [Show full text]
  • South Wales Metro
    South Wales Metro Status, Challenges & Opportunities For Rail Futures 18 May 2019 Mark Barry Professor of Practice in Connectivity Cardiff University School of Geography and Planning M&G Barry Consulting Please note: This presentation is based entirely on the views of Prof Mark Barry based on his knowledge and/or material already in the public domain and does not represent in any way the views, thoughts, intentions, plans, policies or strategies of Welsh Government, Transport for Wales , Cardiff University or any other organisation. Mark Barry, Professor of Practice in Connectivity (part time) at Cardiff University’s School of Geography and Planning I have been working on #southwalesmetro since 2010 Led its development for Welsh Ministers 2013-2015 Now working with Welsh Government to develop the case for further investment in Welsh Rail https://beta.gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2018-12/the-rail-network-in-wales-case-for-investment.pdf https://swalesmetroprof.blog/2018/12/12/wales-rail-network-the-case-for-investment/ Rail Futures: Metro Challenge and Opportunties No Status, Mark Barry May 2019 What I’ll try and cover today > A little history… > Strategic context > 2015 Metro Vision > What’s happening now > Wider challenges and opportunities o Climate Change o Economic Development o Transit Oriented Development o Extendibility & TOD > The Case for Rail Investment Rail Futures: Metro Challenge and Opportunties No Status, Mark Barry May 2019 Why Metro...(from my 2012,13,14 etc…presentations) >Connecting more people, to more places >Enabling development & regeneration. >Modal shift & lower CO2. To address issues of economic inactivity, deprivation and poverty And deliver a sustainable, economically dynamic city region of 1.6 M people.
    [Show full text]
  • New Transport for Wales Trains Being Built
    New Transport for Wales trains being built December 1, 2020 Work is continuing on the construction of Transport for Wales’ new trains for the Wales and Borders rail network and the South Wales Metro despite the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. TfW is investing £800 million into new trains and tram-trains to totally transform the customer experience throughout their Wales and Borders network. Work has been progressing with industry partners CAF and Stadler to design and build the new trains that will operate on 95% of their rail services. Significant progress has been made on the Class 398 tram-trains and work has begun on the Class 231 trains. Both are being built by Stadler for the South Wales Metro. Alongside these, the Class 197 Civity trains being built for use on other Wales and Borders routes are currently being assembled at CAF’s factory in Llanwern. James Price, Transport for Wales CEO, said: “It’s great to see progress on our brand-new trains. I’m delighted our partners at CAF and Stadler have been able to progress with assembly despite the challenging situation we find ourselves in. “COVID-19 will continue to present challenges but we’ve been able to move forward and this month and we’ve now seen huge progress on our trains, at our Taff’s Well Depot as well as successful delivery of track transformation work on the Aberdare line. “TfW is continuing to deliver on our transformational plans and these faster, more efficient trains are fundamental to improving journey times, service frequency and our sustainability goals.” TfW is also in the process of carrying out testing of the Class 769 trains on the Cardiff to Rhymney line.
    [Show full text]