DOCSLIB.ORG

The Performing Mother: Maternal Ethics Beyond

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Performing Mother: Maternal Ethics Beyond THE PERFORMING MOTHER: MATERNAL ETHICS BEYOND EMBODIMENT by CHARLES HICKS Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Arlington in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT ARLINGTON May 2015 Copyright © by Charles Hicks 2015 All Rights Reserved ii Acknowledgements I am indebted to the plethora of individuals that have made this work possible. My committee – Penelope Ingram, Tim Richardson, and Neill Matheson – has worked tirelessly in order to encourage the progress of this project at all stages. Penelope Ingram especially has fostered an environment of intellectual growth throughout and offered invaluable advice at all junctures. As a mentor she has surpassed all imaginable expectations and, as a scholar, has provided an exceptional and admirable model of academic prowess. The exigence of this project and my academic thought lies primarily in the three classes of hers that I was fortunate enough to attend and her work, Signifying Body offered me the opportunity to find my voice in a complex and challenging discourse. Peers and mentors from within the English Department at the University of Texas at Arlington have helped tremendously with the completion of this project. It would be remiss not acknowledge the tremendous guidance provided by Bruce Krajewski, whose insight and experience were invaluable. Bethany Shaffer provided not only kindness during my most stressful times, but encouragment that was essential. In addition, Peggy Kulesz’s support to not only this project, but my academic career in its entirety, cannot be quantified. There are few people that have had a more profoundly positive influence on my life. I owe an immense debt of gratitude to my family. My parents, Tim and Jan, have not only supported my Ph.D. work from the onset, but have served as iii ideal models of integrity and work ethic. My sister, Christine, has provided a sturdy foundation for the most difficult of times, injecting the inevitable cyniscim of any lengthy project with idealism and energy. Finally, to my partner, Skye Solmonson, who has spent countless hours reading and editing chapters. This work is as much hers as it is mine, as her support goes far beyond merely providing helpful critiques. If this project has succeeded in outlining, at the very least, the possibilities of ethical activity, it is only because I had such a wonderful muse in her. April 20, 2015 iv Abstract THE PERFORMING MOTHER: MATERNAL ETHICS BEYOND EMBODIMENT Charles Hicks, PhD The University of Texas at Arlington, 2015 Supervising Professor: Penelope Ingram The rich and diverse history of maternal thought is at once a response to the Western philosophical tradition’s relegation of the maternal to the material abject, as well as a renegotiation of the maternal body as a site of empowerment capable of destabilizing the foundations of the symbolic economy. Understanding the material and historical conditions that subject these bodies and work to construct maternity, as well as their mediating position to authentic ethical activity, reveals that maternity offers a salient schemata for, not only viewing the fundamental operations of power, but the possibilities of ethical interaction. This study focuses on, not only theoretical texts dealing with the maternal body, but in science fiction and horror works in order to highlight the possibility of discursive transcendence for non-procreative bodies achieved through performance. This project argues, initially, that the maternal body is subjected to an ideologically pervasive and historically saturated ideal of motherhood in order to produce v sanctioned forms of maternity that secure the reproduction of the very conditions and structure that legitimize their subjection. Secondly, this essay posits that discursive transcendence – meaning the possibility of signifying and identity beyond the prescribed monomaternalist ideal – can be achieved immanently through the institution of a masochistic contract and the infinite performance of the masochistic fantasy shared between mother and infant. In Chapter Four, I argue that Deleuze’s theory of masochism, derived from Leopold Sacher- Masoch’s Venus in Furs, offers an interesting framework for viewing the subjection of biologically reproductive mothers, as well as a vibrant ground for the development of a theory of maternity based on performance. Finally, in Chapter Five, I argue for a reevaluation of the way in which we conceive non- procreative maternal identity and outline how the non-reproductive body takes part in the same masochistic disavow as the biological mother, yet the result is not the creation of a new and distinct identity, but the complete dissolution of the self where the past is infinitely severed from the trajectory of the future, the previous form of the subject obliterated. vi Table of Contents Acknowledgements ................................................................................................ iii Abstract ................................................................................................................... v Chapter 1 Introduction: Maternal Embodiment and Performance .......................... 1 1.1 The Feminine and Transcendence ................................................................ 8 1.2 The Semiotic and the Abject: ...................................................................... 14 1.3 Irigaray and the Sensible Transcendental: .................................................. 29 1.4 A More Material Transcendence ................................................................ 48 1.5 From Embodiment to Performance ............................................................. 58 1.6 Scope of Study ............................................................................................ 69 Chapter 2 Transcendence Forestalled ................................................................... 74 2.1 Eros and the Past ......................................................................................... 79 2.2 Husserl and Intentionality ........................................................................... 88 2.3 Levinas and the Face ................................................................................... 96 2.4 Heideggerian Death and Levinasian Birth ................................................ 103 2.5 Hypostasis and the Psychic Life of Power ................................................ 113 2.6 The Third Party and Power ....................................................................... 122 Chapter 3 The Crystalline Image of Maternity ................................................... 149 3.1 The Monstrous Body and Maternity ......................................................... 153 3.2 Alien and Undifferentiated Being ............................................................. 165 3.3 The Phallic Mother as Ideal Projection ..................................................... 176 vii 3.4 The Genealogy of the Image ..................................................................... 194 3.5 The Crystalline Image of Maternity .......................................................... 210 Chapter 4 Maternal Performativity and the Masochistic Contract ..................... 227 4.1 Madness and Subject Formation ............................................................... 231 4.2 The Three Syntheses of Time ................................................................... 248 4.3 The Death Instinct and Masochism .......................................................... 255 4.4 Masochism and the Mother ....................................................................... 263 4.5 Maternity and Masochism ........................................................................ 273 Chapter 5 Adoptive Maternity and the Dissolution of Self ................................ 309 5.1 From Past to Future ................................................................................... 311 5.2 Adoptive Maternity and the Futural Horizon ........................................... 314 5.3 Return to Immanence ................................................................................ 328 5.4 Collective Transcendence ......................................................................... 336 References ........................................................................................................... 354 Biographical Information .................................................................................... 402 viii Chapter 1 Introduction: Maternal Embodiment and Performance In maternity what signifies is a responsibility for others, to the point of substitution for others and suffering both from the effect of persecution and from the persecuting itself in which the persecutor sinks. Maternity, which is bearing par excellence, bears even responsibility for the persecuting by the persecutor. Emmanuel Levinas Otherwise Than Being In “Performing Breastfeeding: Embodiment, Ethics and the Maternal Subject,” author Rhonda Shaw claims that “in Western culture, men and women, generally speaking, have a problem talking seriously about breastfeeding,” a prejudice that “stems from the accepted view that because breastfeeding is such an immanently somatic, in-the-body practice, it is often viewed as morally, philosophically, and politically insignificant” (100). In the article Shaw illustrates that this stereotype is derived from the association of women with the domestic sphere, along
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Camora 1.Pdf
    The Function of the Rhetoric of Maternity in the Representation of Female Sexuality, Religion, Nationality, and Race in Early Modern English Literature and Culture by Cecilia Morales A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (English Language and Literature) in the University of Michigan 2020 Doctoral Committee: Professor Michael Schoenfeldt, Chair Dr. Neeraja Aravamudan, Edward Ginsberg Center, University of Michigan Professor Peggy McCracken Professor Catherine Sanok Professor Valerie Traub Cecilia Morales [email protected] ORCID iD: 0000-0001-7428-3777 © Cecilia Morales 2020 Acknowledgements Throughout my doctoral studies, I have been fortunate to have the love and support of countless individuals, to whom I owe a great deal of gratitude. I’d like to begin by thanking my committee members. Cathy and Peggy taught me valuable lessons not only about my work but about being a thoughtful and compassionate scholar and teacher. Valerie’s reminders to always be as generous as possible when discussing the work of other scholars has kept me sane and stable in this competitive world of academia. Mike helped me, a displaced Texan, to feel at home in Michigan from our first meeting, during which we chatted about both Shakespearean scholarship and Tex Mex. Finally, the most recent addition to my committee is Neeraja Aravamudan, who I consider my most active mentor and supporter. One of the best decisions I made during graduate school was accepting an internship at the Edward Ginsberg Center, where Neeraja became my supervisor. Neeraja and the other Ginsberg staff remind me it’s possible to take my work very seriously without taking myself too seriously.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of the Relationship Between the Concept and Treatment of People with Down's Syndrome in Britain and America from 1866 to 1967
    THE HISTORY OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE CONCEPT AND TREATMENT OF PEOPLE WITH DOWN'S SYNDROME IN BRITAIN AND AMERICA FROM 1866 TO 1967. BY Lilian Serife ZihniB.Sc. P.G.C.E. FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN THE HISTORY OF MEDICINE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON 1 Abstract This thesis fills a gap in the history of mental handicap by focusing on a specific mentally handicapping condition, Down's syndrome, in Britain and America. This approach has facilitated an examination of how various scientific and social developments have actually affected a particular group of people with handicaps. The first chapter considers certain historiographical problems this research has raised. The second analyses the question of why Down's syndrome, which has certain easily identifiable characteristics associated with it, was not recognised as a distinct condition until 1866 in Britain. Subsequent chapters focus on the concept and treatment of Down's syndrome by the main nineteenth and twentieth century authorities on the disorder. The third chapter concentrates on John Langdon Down's treatment of 'Mongolian idiots' at the Royal Earlswood Asylum. The fourth chapter examines Sir Arthur Mitchell's study of 'Kalmuc idiots' in private care. The fifth considers how Down's and Mitchell's theories were developed by later investigators, with particular reference to George Shuttleworth's work. Archive materials from the Royal Albert, Royal Earlswood and Royal Scottish National Institutions are used. The sixth focuses on the late nineteenth century American concept and treatment of people with Down's syndrome through an analysis of the work of Albert Wilmarth.
    [Show full text]
  • Prenatal Care
    Prenatal ar @ftffi#a\ffiffi Provided by the Maternal and Child Health Library, Georgetown University SeeThat the Birth of Your Baby Is Registered The birth of your baby should be registered promptly and properly. This is of utmost importance and should be done within 36 hours after the baby's birth. The physician, midwife, nurse, or other attendant is required in. every State to report the birth to the local registrar, who will see that the date of birth and the child's name, together with other related facts, are made matters of perhanent record. Birth registration is necessary in order to prove the date of your child's birth and his citizenship. His right to enter school, to go to work, to inherit property, to marry, to enter the armed forces, and to hold office depend upon proof of age or citizenship or both, and this proof is most readily established by means of a birth certificate. Proof of age is also necessary in order to obtain certain benefits under the Social Security Act, such as aid to dependent children and old age and survivors insurance. If there is any doubt about whether the birth of a child has been registered,an inquiry may be sent to the State board of health where the records are filed. By making sure that the birth of every child born to them is registered, parents are protecting the fundamental rights of their children. It is suggested that the parents keep a memorandum of certain facts recorded in the birth certificate: Baby's name Father's name.
    [Show full text]
  • Movie Review – the Goddess of Pandora
    Movie Review – The Goddess of Pandora By: Richard B. Sorensen September 1, 2010 [email protected] www.richardsorensen.com www.unholygrail.net Neytiri of the Na’vi I recently watched the DVD “Collector’s Special Extended Edition” of the movie Avatar, by James Cameron. He is one of my favorite directors, having made Terminator I (which I consider to be one of the best action/adventure movies ever made), Titanic, and Aliens. Avatar is a science fiction/fantasy/adventure flick set on the planet of Pandora, a moon in the Alpha Centauri star system. In many ways this movie surpassed all of Cameron’s others in a brilliant combination of human acting, CGI effects, military battles, and a convincing love story between a human man and an alien woman. But what interested me most were the theological aspects of the movie. The goddess of Pandora is named “Eywa,” perhaps taken from “Ewha Womans University” in South Korea. As the inevitable lawsuits have piled up against Avatar, one Korean satirist wrote that even the school was trying to sue for a cut of the proceeds. 1/8 Eywa is a new age goddess, essentially a female version of the Druidical gods of the Celts; a nicer and more caring earth/nature goddess that benignly (for the most part) presides over a planet where virtually all of the life forms are somehow interconnected in a huge web of life. The people of Pandora, called the “Na’vi”, have long ponytails, and can connect with animals or plants by inserting the shaggy end into receptors on the animal or plant.
    [Show full text]
  • The-Alien-Encyclopedia-Version-8.Pdf
    1 Contents 1. Preface......................................................................................................5 2. About this book........................................................................................6 a) Using the encyclopedia: A word about Tags and the Appendices...............................................6 b) Regarding the Aliens vs. Predator universe and alternate movie scripts.....................................6 c) The writing perspective...............................................................................................................7 d) Alternate versions of Alien³ and the 1988 Aliens comics............................................................8 e) Conjecture....................................................................................................................................9 3. The A-Z..................................................................................................12 *** 0-9 ***....................................................................................................................................12 *** A ***.......................................................................................................................................13 *** B ***.......................................................................................................................................27 *** C ***.......................................................................................................................................44
    [Show full text]
  • The Pregnant Imagination, Fetal Rights, and Women's Bodies: a Historical Inquiry
    The Pregnant Imagination, Fetal Rights, and Women's Bodies: A Historical Inquiry Julia Epstein* Competing historical and cultural understandings of the human body make clear that medicine and the law construe bodily truths from differing knowledge bases. Jurists rely virtually entirely on medical testimony to analyze biological data, and medical profes- sionals are not usually conversant with the legal ramifications of their diagnoses. In early modern Europe, both physicians and jurists recognized that their respective professions were governed by different epistemological standards, a view articulated by F6lix Vicq d'Azyr (1748-1794), anatomist and secretary to the Royal Society of Medicine in France from 1776. Vicq d'Azyr noted that while lawyers were required to make unyielding decisions based on conflicting laws, customs, and decrees, physicians were permitted more latitude for uncertainty.' In the late twentieth century, Western medicine and law have become inextricably entwined as technologies have produced new ethical dilemmas facing medicolegal jurisprudence. The authority of women to voice and explain their experiences of pregnancy and childbirth before and during the eighteenth century contrasts powerfully with the twentieth century's reliance on medicolegal decisions to define these experiences. In early modern Europe, women controlled information, experience, and beliefs concerning reproduction, and women held authority over it. A woman only became officially and publicly pregnant when she felt her * The author would like to thank Robert Kieft, Reference Librarian at Haverford College, and the librarians at the Historical Collections of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia for research assistance. Estelle Cohen, Ruth Colker, Kathryn Kolbert, Linda McClain, Nigel Paneth, Reva Siegel, and M.
    [Show full text]
  • Female Scientists in Film
    FEMALE SCIENTISTS IN FILM: EMBRACING DUALITY WITH THE HEROINE’S JOURNEY by Anna Irina Sagatov A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Fine Arts in Science and Natural History Filmmaking MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY Bozeman, Montana April 2019 ©COPYRIGHT by Anna Irina Sagatov 2019 All Rights Reserved ii TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. THE PROBLEM: FILMIC DEPICTIONS OF WOMEN SCIENTISTS................................. 1 Flicker Types............................................................................................................................ 4 The Old Maid.....................................................................................................................4 The Male Woman...............................................................................................................5 The Naive Expert...............................................................................................................5 The Evil Plotter..................................................................................................................6 The Daughter or Assistant.................................................................................................6 The Lonely Heroine...........................................................................................................7 Will it Make a Difference? The Scully Effect……...................................................................8 2.ANALYSIS OF FEMALE SCIENTIST CHARACTERS........................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • UC GAIA Wagner CS5.5-Text.Indd
    Pathological Bodies The Berkeley SerieS in BriTiSh STudieS Mark Bevir and James Vernon, University of California, Berkeley, editors 1. The Peculiarities of Liberal Modernity in Imperial Britain, edited by Simon Gunn and James Vernon 2. Dilemmas of Decline: British Intellectuals and World Politics, 1945– 1975, by Ian Hall 3. The Savage Visit: New World People and Popular Imperial Culture in Britain, 1710– 1795, by Kate Fullagar 4. The Afterlife of Empire, by Jordanna Bailkin 5. Smyrna’s Ashes: Humanitarianism, Genocide, and the Birth of the Middle East, by Michelle Tusan 6. Pathological Bodies: Medicine and Political Culture, by Corinna Wagner Pathological Bodies Medicine and Political Culture Corinna Wagner Global, Area, and International Archive University of California Press Berkeley loS angeleS london The Global, Area, and International Archive (GAIA) is an initiative of the Institute of International Studies, University of California, Berkeley, in partnership with the University of California Press, the California Digital Library, and international research programs across the University of California system. University of California Press, one of the most distinguished university presses in the United States, enriches lives around the world by advancing scholarship in the humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences. Its activities are supported by the UC Press Foundation and by philanthropic contributions from individuals and institutions. For more information, visit www.ucpress.edu. University of California Press Berkeley and Los Angeles, California University of California Press, Ltd. London, England © 2013 by The Regents of the University of California Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress iSBn: 978-1938169-08-3 Manufactured in the United States of America 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of anSi/niSo z39.48– 1992 (r 1997) (Permanence of Paper).
    [Show full text]
  • Teratology Transformed: Uncertainty, Knowledge, and Cjonflict Over Environmental Etiologies of Birth Defects in Midcentury America
    Teratology Transformed: Uncertainty, Knowledge, and CJonflict over Environmental Etiologies of Birth Defects in Midcentury America TV Heather A. Dron DISSERTATION Submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in History of Health. Sciences in the GRADUATE DIVISION of the UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. SAN FRANCISCO Copyright 2016 by Heather Armstrong Dron ii Acknowledgements Portions of Chapter 1 were published in an edited volume prepared by the Western Humanities Review in 2015. iii Abstract This dissertation traces the academic institutionalization and evolving concerns of teratologists, who studied environmental causes of birth defects in midcentury America. The Teratology Society officially formed in 1960, with funds and organizational support from philanthropies such as the National Foundation (Later known as The March of Dimes Birth Defects Foundation). Teratologists, including Virginia Apgar, the well-known obstetric anesthesiologist and inventor of the Apgar Score, were soon embroiled in public concerns about pharmaceutically mediated birth defects. Teratologists acted as consultants to industry and government on pre-market reproductive toxicology testing for pharmaceuticals. However, animal tests seemed unable to clearly predict results in humans and required careful interpretation of dosage and animal species and strain responses. By the late 1960s, amidst the popular environmental movement, teratologists grappled with public claims that birth defects resulted from exposure to industrial pollutants in water or air, or from food additives, pesticides, and industrial waste or effluent. In a crowded field of professionals concerned with pharmaceutical or chemical exposures during pregnancy, teratologists proved adaptive and resilient. Despite influences from the environmental movement, teratologists at times tried to contain the substances and outcomes considered relevant and called for greater vetting of chemical claims, amidst rampant journalistic and public accusations about iatrogenic or industrial harm.
    [Show full text]
  • Alienscolonialmarines Steam
    MAN-S143-AU REDEMPTION CODE: Health Issues Use this soft ware in a well-lit room, staying a good distance away from the monitor or TV screen to not overtax your eyes. Take breaks of 10 to 20 minutes every hour, and do not play when you are ti red or short on sleep. Prolonged use or playing too close to the monitor or television screen may cause a decline in visual acuity. In rare instances, sti mulati on from strong light or fl ashing when staring at a monitor or television screen can cause temporary muscular convulsions or loss of consciousness for some people. If you experience any of these symptoms, consult a doctor before playing this game. If you experience any dizziness, nausea, or moti on-sickness while playing this game, stop the game immediately. Consult a doctor when any discomfort conti nues. Product Care Handle the game disc with care to prevent scratches or dirt on either side of the disc. Do not bend the disc or enlarge the centre hole. Clean the disc with a soft cloth, such as a lens cleaning cloth. Wipe lightly, moving in a radial patt ern outward from the centre hole towards the edge. Never clean the disc with paint thinner, benzene, or other harsh chemicals. Do not write or att ach labels to either side of the disc. Store the disc in the original case aft er playing. Do not store the disc in a hot or humid locati on. AGE RATING PEGI (Pan European Game Information) Age rating categories: For more details about PEGI visit: http://www.pegi.info 02 ALIENS: COLONIAL MARINES TAKING PLACE SEVENTEEN WEEKS AFTER THE 1986 SCIENCE FICTION MASTERPIECE, ALIENS COLONIAL MARINES IS THE VIDEOGAME CONTINUATION OF ALIENS THAT DIVES HEAD FIRST INTO THE RICH TAPESTRY THAT WAS ORIGINALLY CREATED OVER TWENTY-FIVE YEARS AGO.
    [Show full text]
  • Female Martyrdom in Alien3
    UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) Preposterous revelations: Visions of Apocalypse and martyrdom in Hollywood cinema 1980-2000 Copier, L.T. Publication date 2009 Document Version Final published version Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Copier, L. T. (2009). Preposterous revelations: Visions of Apocalypse and martyrdom in Hollywood cinema 1980-2000. General rights It is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), other than for strictly personal, individual use, unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Disclaimer/Complaints regulations If you believe that digital publication of certain material infringes any of your rights or (privacy) interests, please let the Library know, stating your reasons. In case of a legitimate complaint, the Library will make the material inaccessible and/or remove it from the website. Please Ask the Library: https://uba.uva.nl/en/contact, or a letter to: Library of the University of Amsterdam, Secretariat, Singel 425, 1012 WP Amsterdam, The Netherlands. You will be contacted as soon as possible. UvA-DARE is a service provided by the library of the University of Amsterdam (https://dare.uva.nl) Download date:30 Sep 2021 Chapter Three Muscular, Monstrous, Maternal: Female Martyrdom in ALIEN3 Observe how complex is a mother’s love for her children, which draws everything toward an emotion felt in her inmost parts… 4 Maccabees : Introduction The Book of Maccabees, from which the epigraph of this chapter is taken, is one of the earliest examples of female martyrdom in the Judeo-Christian tradition.
    [Show full text]
  • A New Look at Maternal Impressions: an Analysis of 50 Published Cases and Reports of N O Recent ~Xamplesl
    Journal ofScientific Ex~loration.Vol. 6. No. 4. DV. 353-373. 1992 0892-33 10192 I A New Look at Maternal Impressions: An Analysis of 50 Published Cases and Reports of noRecent ~xamplesl Department of Behavioral Medicine and Psychiatry, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, Virginia 22908 Key words: Maternal impressions, birth defects, paranormal processes, teratology Abstract-The idea that a pregnant woman may be so frightened by the sight of some deformity on another person that her baby will be affected by a similar de- fect is widely believed in most parts of the world today; it was also generally be- lieved in the West until the early years of this century. The skepticism that then developed may have derived from lack of an explanatory principle and not from lack of evidence for a significant correspondence between stimulus and birthmark or birth defect. The present paper summarizes the main features of 50 published cases in which an unusual stimulus to a pregnant woman was followed by the birth of a baby with unusual birthmarks or birth defects that nearly always corre- sponded closely to the stimulus the pregnant mother had received. Two recent cases that the author investigated are presented. The author concludes that in rare instances maternal impressions may indeed affect gestating babies and cause birth defects. Almost nothing is known about why such effects occur in some pregnan- cies, but only rarely, or about the implementing processes involved. These may be paranormal. Introduction and Review of Earlier Reports The belief that a shock or other strong impression in a pregnant woman can pro- duce a mark or other defect in her baby has been held for centuries; although it is less common now in Western countries, it is still widely accepted in other parts of the world.
    [Show full text]