Read Book Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
VICHY FRANCE: OLD GUARD AND NEW ORDER PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Robert O. Paxton | 438 pages | 01 Sep 2001 | Columbia University Press | 9780231124690 | English | New York, United States Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order PDF Book Vichy was not coerced by Germany, but tried endlessly and unsuccessfully to make agreements with their German conquerors. Groupe Robert Laffont. User Review - Flag as inappropriate This book is scholarly and densely written in places but quite enlightening. Quite rightly, in my view, he sees the strongest case against Vichy as a moral one: using the defeat to win for various opposition groups a battle that had been lost in the last election; further dividing a country emerging from a decade of latent civil war; condoning and indeed legitimizing citizen complicity in acts such as informing that Frenchmen will never forget. Paxton 3. Instead, he focuses on fascism's political context and functional development. It was the first work to show that Vichy was not the helpless instrument of Nazi policy. Papon, who sat impassively, made clear that he has only contempt for the historian. Bibliographic information. Dec 19, Ed rated it really liked it. For many decades after the Allies invaded the beaches of Normandy, expelling the Nazi invaders, the French, ashamed of their past, clung to the myth that few French collaborated with the Nazis, that most French eagerly supported the Resistance in resisting the Nazis. If you are looking for a social history of the occupation or the impact of occupation on the everyday lives of French people, this is not the history for you. See details for additional description. The importance of reading Paxton was that it allowed me to feel that I had "been there" and had abundant reasons for my judgment. May 13, Christopher Potter rated it liked it. Paxton has focused his work on exploring models and definition of fascism. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Paxton's classic study of the aftermath of France's sudden collapse under Nazi invasion utilizes captured German archives and other contemporary materials to construct a strong and disturbing account of the Vichy period in France. But lacking anything other than a cursory understanding of the time, I gleaned much less than I had hoped. It was Vichy that fruitlessly attempted to This is a well-rounded work on the Vichy years that is at times sympathetic, but Paxton does point out how odious this regime could be. While Pierre Laval's preference for a full alliance with Hitler's Third Reich has always been well known, Paxton explores the lengths that Darlan and Petain were willing to go for a permanent, secure peace with Germany, including even possibly becoming a full co-belliger Severe indictment and explanation of the Vichy Regime This American scholar deeply researches and deftly examines the pre-disposition of many in the Vichy French Regime to become a more active ally with Germany in World War II. When Vichy fell, there followed a series of highly-publicized trials against those like Petain who were accused of high treason and collaboration against the interests of France. But I did read it all. Where once there was potential for varied forms of resistance came instead the imposition, bit by bit, of things like Nazi racial laws, the expropriation of French industry into the hands of German financiers, and an alignment of Vichy foreign policy relatively along the lines of that of Germany motivated in part by fears of the growing Gaullist movement and concerns about the possible destruction of French imperial power. Paxton's classic study of the aftermath of France's sudden collapse under Nazi invasion utilizes captured German archives and other contemporary materials to construct a strong and disturbing account of the Vichy period in France. It's detailed and heavy but it's deliberate and thorough. Papon and the deportation of Jews, illustrated the enduringly divisive legacy of Vichy and. Mar 31, Mike rated it really liked it Shelves: history , monograph. He earned a Ph. History Today. When Women Pray Hardcover T. It was the appendices or notes that actually gave me a glimpse in to why Vichy France existed and how people lived in it. To ask other readers questions about Vichy France , please sign up. Paxton, stood just a few yards from Maurice Papon, 87, an administrator in the pro-Nazi Vichy government. Once it became clear that the war would be an elongated affair, it was already too late to try and reverse course away from "collaboration" with the German occupiers. France after was one of those times. Readers also enjoyed. Original Title. Jun 16, stephanie rated it it was amazing Shelves: history-memory , wwii , modern-euro-history , would-rec. Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order Writer Of course, that would have been an easy judgment to make without reading Paxton. When Women Pray Hardcover T. The fact is that it was France and not Germany that initiated the policy of collaboration. Arno J. The book very much concentrates on the political, diplomatic and government aspects of Vichy. He earned a Ph. More Details My main gripe with this book is the complex structure — a not atypical paragraph is; "The elimination of communism followed by parliamentary socialism opened the way for these outsiders of the Left. If you are looking for a social history of the occupation or the impact of occupation on the everyday lives of French people, this is not the history for you. Did the Third Republic simply go into stasis with Marshall Petain at its head? It was the first work to show that Vichy was not the helpless instrument of Nazi policy. Severe indictment and explanation of the Vichy Regime This American scholar deeply researches and deftly examines the pre-disposition of many in the Vichy French Regime to become a more active ally with Germany in World War II. Original Title. View on timesmachine. Many of these changes were made with the assumption that Germany and the United Kingdom would come to a relatively quick peace, and so accommodations with German demands were seen as necessary. Paxton's classic study of the aftermath of France's sudden collapse under Nazi invasion utilizes captured German archives and other contemporary materials to construct a strong and disturbing account of the Vichy period in France. After the initial shock of France surprisingly quick defeat against Germany, Petain and other figures as Pierre Laval and Admiral Francois Darlan chose to offer armistice to Germany, fearing that France could potentially fall into social disorder, rather than evacuating themselves just like General de Gaulle and Fre Named after the town in which it organized its government, Vichy France was a French collaborationist with Germany, that is led by Marechal Philippe Petain during the World War II. Can you imagine writing a book with such explosive and enduring impact? Showing So humane and sensitive a historian must carry us into those years with a force and power that a more remote and magisterial writer could not achieve. Add to cart. Other Editions He served there for the remainder of his career, retiring in Always hoping that it would deliver what I wanted. Paxton's classic study of the aftermath of France's sudden collapse under Nazi invasion utilizes captured German archives and other contemporary materials to construct a strong and disturbing account of the Vichy period in France. They were very provincial men. This seminal book first published in exploded the myth that Vichy was imposed by the Nazis in the face of massive French resistance. See all 5 brand new listings. Lexington, Virginia. To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them. The importance of reading Paxton was that it allowed me to feel that I had "been there" and had abundant reasons for my judgment. Retrieved 22 January Will be clean, not soiled or stained. A great book. It was as much an extension into the future as a continuation of the past. Namespaces Article Talk. Shop for Books on Google Play Browse the world's largest eBookstore and start reading today on the web, tablet, phone, or ereader. Robert Paxton's Vichy is the most thorough going treatment I've read so far. Home Page World U. Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order Reviews Alfred A. World U. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Trivia About Vichy France: Old Did France gain anything from collaboration? Readers also enjoyed. The New York Review of Books. Paul - Bangkok, Thailand. Paxton said Mr. However, setting the record straight on collaboration is not the major purpose of his book. The other histories I've read so far treat smaller aspects of the historical record - the military defeat, the occupation of Paris etc. Intriguingly, beyond those most visibly at the top of administration, many of those civil servants lower on the rungs of power functioned in their positions unaffected by the numerous changes in governments from the Through this process, he discovers that it is not possible to box Vichy in as a one-off experiment led by Nazi-appointed sycophants. Robert O. So humane and sensitive a historian must carry us into those years with a force and power that a more remote and magisterial writer could not achieve. It makes Nemirovsky's ficti Suite Francaise is one of the best books I have ever read, in part because of the appendices which are included. It was the appendices or notes that actually gave me a glimpse in to why Vichy France existed and how people lived in it.