Insect Enemies of Birch
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INSECT ENEMIES OF BIRCH by JAMES G. CONKLIN, Chairman, Department of Entomology, University of New Hampshire, Durham, N.H. ATIVE BIRCHES are subject to attack were killed in plots in the open or under N by insects at all stages of growth from partial canopy. Godman and Krefting (1960) the germinating seedling to the mature found that insects caused little damage to tree. All parts of the tree - roots, stem, yellow birch in upper Michigan. Graham and branches, foliage, and even the developing and Knight ( 1965) caution against too com seed - may be utilized as feeding sites by placent an attitude toward insect pests of insects of one kind or another. seedlings but indicate that applied control An enumeration of the many insects re measures are rarely necessary except in forest corded in the literature as feeders on birch nurseries. might be impressive in numbers but would Beyond the seedling stage, the birches contribute little to this symposium. Rather, it in common with other hardwoods-are fed would seem more appropriate to consider a upon by an almost endless variety of insects. few representative kinds of insects that are By far the great majority occurring on yellow responsible for particular types of injury, to or paper birch are scarcely known outside the indicate their relative importance and the field of taxonomy. Some, because of their fre need for control. quent occurrence in outbreak form or because Much of the literature dealing with insect of obviously destructive feeding habits, have damage to tree seedlings emphasizes damage long occupied the attention of workers in to conifers, and especially to seedlings in forest entomology and timber improvement. forest nurseries. Insect damage to seedling Root-feeding insects ordinarily cause little hardwoods appears to have attracted relatively damage to birch saplings or to the older little attention on the part of research workers trees. The extensive root system is able to up to the present. tolerate without serious effect the feeding of Under natural conditions birch seedlings the relatively limited population of under may be destroyed by such root-feeding insects ground insects. as white grubs, weevil larvae, and wireworms, The birch canopy provides a particularly or by above-ground feeders such as cutworms attractive feeding ground for a large array or miscellaneous other stem or leaf feeders. of insects. Some, having a piercing beak or At this early stage of growth a seedling may proboscis, suck the sap from the leaves. be killed by the activity of a single insect, Others, having mandibulate mouth parts, but insect damage to birch seedlings is rarely mine within the leaf tissues, or devour the reported. This may be accounted for by the entire leaf structure. fact that the suspect insects normally occur in The sap-sucking relatively small numbers under forest condi insects belong to two major groups, tions and have limited mobility during their the Hemiptera and the Homop tera. The Hemiptera larval feeding stages, or it may be that the are represented especially by the lace bugs (Tingidae) loss of a small percentage of seedlings is more and the plant or Jess taken for granted. bugs (Miridae) . A number of species of lace bugs are known to feed on birch. They some Linteau (1948) found that insects were times occur in great numbers, and because of responsible for a mortality of about 9 percent their sedentary habits are readily observed. of yellow birch seedlings. Nearly all of the The young nymphs feed on the underside of injury was attributed to the spring canker the leaves, the adults on either surface. Al worm, Paleacrita vernata (Peck), and occurred though they will feed on trees of all sizes, under conditions of full canopy. No seedlings they seem to prefer saplings and pole-sized 151 trees (Graham and Knight 1965). Drake growth is not likely to become evident until ( 1922) studied the birch tingid Corythuca the following year. pallipes Parshley in the Cranberry Lake area At least three species of leaf-mining saw in New York, and concluded that it was the flies occur commonly on birch. Probably the most injurious leaf feeder on yellow birch in most widely observed is Fenusa pusilla (Lep.). that vicinity. Year after year this species is likely to be It prefers gray Little information is available on the mirid abundant over wide areas. white birch plant bugs that feed on birch. So far as birch, although it does attack within the known they overwinter as adults and lay their also. The birch leaf miner appears may eggs in the leaf veins or stems. Under forest first expanding leaves in the spring and in some areas, conditions the plant bugs occur in relatively have two grenerations and, biology small numbers and are not considered to be three complete generations a year. The detail by Friend important pests of trees. of this species was reported in ( 1927, 1933). The leafhoppers that occur on birches have The birch leaf-mining sawfly Heterarthrus attracted only a limited amount of research memoratus (Fallen) shows a preference for attention even though certain species are paper birch. In severely infested trees there sometimes numerous over wide areas. Varty may be noticeable killing of top branches, (1963, 1964) indicated that the species feed annual growth is reduced, and the quality of ing on birch occur chiefly in the genera the wood may be inferior (Craighead 1950). Oncopsis and Eryth1·oneura. The biologies and The species has a single generation annually, host-relationships of the leafhoppers of forest but because it is parthenogenetic it is capable trees warrant careful study since a number of of rapidly developing very large populations. species belonging to that family are known vectors of important plant diseases. A third species, Profenusa thomsoni (Konow), prefers paper and yellow birch. aphids often appear on Foliage-infesting In the past it has been confused with other extensive areas and in great birches over species found on birch. Recent studies by of species as well as abundance. In variety Martin (1960) show that the adults begin to they are the dominant group of individuals appear about the middle of July, and larval insects. Birch aphids do not kill sap-sucking feeding is most evident in August and Sep and Knight 1965) and trees directly (Graham tember. Males are unknown, indicating that in a given locality may fluctu their abundance the species is parthenogenetic. Martin con year to year. Under conditions ate greatly from sidered that this sawfly causes little or no populations they interfere of heavy aphid noticeable injury to birch because of the late the normal functioning of the foliage and with ness of the larval feeding period. thus weaken the trees. The typical defoliators are the insects that Investigations of birch aphids, largely of a devour the entire leaf, or most of it. The survey nature, have been carried on in the more important kinds on birch are the larvae Maritime provinces of New Brunswick by of Lepidoptera, such as the forest tent cater Varty (1 963, 1964) and in Quebec by Qued pillar, Malacosoma disstria Hbn., and the nau (1966). saddled prominent, Heterocampa guttivitta and Among the chewing insects of birch foliage (Walk.). The larvae of certain sawflies, leaf the birch skeletonizer, Bttcmlatrix canadensi certain Coleoptera, mostly chrysomelid numer sella Chambers, periodically appears over ex beetles and their larvae, are sometimes tensive areas in outbreak numbers, causing ous enough to cause noticeable defoliation. complete defoliation (Simpson 1932). The The forest tent caterpillar is perhaps the tiny moths are most numerous in July, and the best known and most important of the defolia young larvae start off as miners within the tors attacking birch, even though its most leaf. After 3 or 4 weeks they emerge from spectacular outbreaks are ordinarily associated their mines and after molting feed for another with other hardwoods (Anderson 1944, Craig 3 or 4 weeks on the underside of the leaves head 1950, Graham and Knight 1965, Red as skeletonizers, eating only the softer leaf mond 1957 ). Studies in Minnesota by Hodson tissues. Since defoliation by this species occurs (1941) and in Ontario by Sippel! late in the growing season, its effect on {1962) indicate that major outbreaks have 152 occurred in the past about every 10 years, but attention on the bronze birch borer, which was the interval is not consistent. The last major then appearing in unprecedented numbers in outbreak in New Hampshire occurred over the affected stands. The fact that many young 30 years ago. birches were being attacked by the borer led to some speculation as to whether the insect Barter and Cameron ( 1955) studied the was solely responsible for death of the trees. effects of forest tent caterpillar defoliation on aspen and paper birch. They found that radial Early studies of the dieback problem by growth in paper birch was reduced 22, 68, Balch and Prebble (1940) indicated that in and 86 percent compared with 23, 87, and 52 some areas previous defoliation of birch stands percent defoliation in the 3 consecutive years in 1927 and 1928 had weakened the trees, of the outbreak. Growth retardation following thus favoring an increase in borer activity. defoliation was more pronounced on birch Haw bolt and Skolko ( 1948) noted that many than on aspen even though defoliation of yellow birches were already in advanced stages birch was less and occurred later in the sea of decline without having been attacked by son. They reported that 21 percent of the the borer. The findings of these and other birch had died since the start of the outbreak, investigators of the problem were reviewed by largely as a result of bronze birch borer attaak Redmond ( 195 7).