December 7 2018
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Israel and the Middle East News Update Friday, December 7 Headlines: • IDF: We Found Another Hezbollah Tunnel Crossing into Israel • Lebanon Condemns Israel’s Warnings to its Civilians • Resolution Condemning Hamas Fails at UN, Despite Vast Support • Trump to Replace Haley at UN with Heather Nauert • US Blocks $500 Million Arms Deal Between Israel, Croatia: Report • Push For Anti-BDS Bill Exposes Rift Among Jewish Progressives • Palestinians Plant 15 Million Trees to Seize Land • Sara Netanyahu to Be Questioned on Suspicion of Fraud Today Commentary: • Times of Israel: “Annexation – At What Cost?” - By David A. Halperin, executive director of the Israel Policy Forum • Ha’aretz: “'Nasrallah Knows Israel's DNA – and Planned to Shock Us With Hezbollah Attack Tunnels'” - By Amos Harel, military commentator at Ha’aretz S. Daniel Abraham Center for Middle East Peace 633 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, 5th Floor, Washington, DC 20004 The Hon. Robert Wexler, President ● Yoni Komorov, Editor ● Aaron Zucker, Associate Editor News Excerpts December 7, 2018 Ha’aretz IDF: We Found Another Hezbollah Tunnel Crossing Into Israel The Israeli military said Thursday afternoon that it has discovered another tunnel dug by the terror organization Hezbollah and has asked the United Nations to help efforts to destroy it. The commander of the Israeli army's Northern Command, Maj. Gen. Yoel Strick, asked the commander of United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), Maj. Gen. Stefano Del Col, on Thursday to assist in neutralizing an attack tunnel being dug from Lebanon into Israeli territory. According to an Israeli army statement, Strick demanded UNIFIL reach the tunnel from the Lebanese side of the border, "and noted that whoever enters the underground perimeter endangers his life." The tunnel, which is being dug from the village of Ramyeh crossed into Israel, but does not pose an immediate threat to residents, the statement said. See also, “IDF to UNIFIL: Neutralize additional Hezbollah tunnel” (Ynet News) Times of Israel Lebanon Condemns Israel’s Warnings to its Civilians Lebanon’s ambassador to the United Nations on Thursday accused Israel of hacking into the country’s telephone network to warn southern Lebanese citizens of imminent Israeli military activity on the border, in what was described by Beirut as “extremely serious acts.” Amal Mudallali’s letter to the UNSC came days after Israel launched Operation Northern Shield to dismantle attack tunnels it says were dug by the Hezbollah terror group. “Lebanon condemns in the the political and diplomatic campaign being waged by Israel against Lebanon, which it fears is a prelude to the launch of further attacks,” she wrote. See also, “UN force confirms presence of tunnel on Lebanon-Israel border” (Aljazeera) Times of Israel Resolution Condemning Hamas Fails at UN, Despite Vast Support The United Nations General Assembly on Thursday failed to pass a resolution condemning Hamas, serving a crushing defeat to Israel and its American ally after weeks of diplomacy. While the US-backed draft resolution got a comfortable majority of votes, it fell short of the two-thirds super-majority needed to pass. Eighty-seven countries voted in favor of the resolution, while 57 opposed it. Thirty-three countries abstained and another 23 were not present. “Today we achieved a plurality which would have been a majority if the vote had not been hijacked by a political move of procedure,” Israeli Ambassador to the UN Danny Danon said. See also, “UN rejects first attempt to condemn Hamas” (CNN) Jerusalem Post Trump to Replace Haley at UN with Heather Nauert US President Donald Trump will replace Nikki Haley, who resigned in October as UN envoy, with State Department spokesman Heather Nauert, a political novice, according to a senior administration official. The appointment of Nauert has been anticipated for weeks. Before joining the Trump administration in her inaugural role in public service, Nauert worked as a Fox News anchor, gaining Trump’s attention. She has since impressed the State Department for her professionalism and rapid education on a host of foreign policy matters. Nauert is expected to follow in the footsteps of Haley, who convinced Trump to elevate the UN ambassador position to a cabinet-level role. 2 I24 News US Blocks $500 Million Arms Deal Between Israel, Croatia: Report The United States is blocking an arms deal that would see 12 U.S.-made F-16 fighter jets being sold from Israel to Croatia, Axios reported on Thursday.The $500 million deal infuriated Washington which warned Jerusalem three weeks ago that the deal would be blocked because it had not been approved by the US before signed, Israeli officials told Axios.The officials also said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu discussed the issue with US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo earlier this week in Brussels. Pompeo reportedly said US Secretary of Defense James Mattis was the one blocking the deal. Washington accused Jerusalem of selling the F-16 fighter jets equipped with new and sophisticated Israeli made electronic systems, so as to give at an edge compared to US made fighter jets. See also, “TRUMP TRIES TO BLOCK LAW to COMPENSATE AMERICAN VICTIMS OF PA TERRORISM” (JPost) TOI Push For Anti-BDS Bill Exposes Rift Among Jewish Progressives With a US senator attempting to push controversial legislation cracking down on anti-Israel boycotts through Congress, progressive Jewish groups appear split on the merits of the proposed law. While the liberal Middle East advocacy group J Street has vehemently opposed the bill, which would make it illegal to boycott Israel, the Jewish Democratic Council of America, an advocacy wing for more mainline Jewish Democrats, is supporting its passage. The bill — called the Israel Anti-Boycott Act — would prohibit American companies from participating in Israel boycotts, including those promoted by international organizations like the United Nations. It was castigated by liberal advocacy groups and civil society groups almost immediately upon its release on First Amendment grounds. Ynet News Palestinians Plant 15 Million Trees to Seize Land The Palestinian Authority (PA) has planted millions of olive trees in the West Bank in a ploy to lay claim to land and set facts on the ground, according to an internal report by the Israeli Civil Administration (ICA). According to the report, which was written by the head of the Agriculture Department in the ICA and brought to light by the Zionist civil rights Lavi organization, the Palestinian Ministry of Agriculture has implemented a plan to take over land by planting olive trees. "According to data collected by the Palestinian ministry, the space on which the trees were planted amounts to some 975,000 dunams (241,000 acres) on which 14.7 million olive trees have been planted, 11.9 million of which bear fruit," the report said. COGAT: Report based on Palestinian data, we haven't verified it. Ha’aretz Sara Netanyahu to Be Questioned on Suspicion of Fraud Today Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's wife, Sara, is expected to be questioned under caution by the police on Friday on suspicion of fraudulently deceiving the state comptroller over the employment terms of the family's former media adviser Nir Hefetz. The case was investigated as an appendix to the Bezeq-Walla bribery case, following the testimony of state's witness and the Netanyahus' former spokesman Nir Hefetz. Attorney Dan Shimron, who was also involved in the case, is expected to testify to the police at the same time. The case started with the prime minister's request to the state comptroller, as Haaretz had reported, to arrange Hefetz's employment as the family's spokesman, after he had refused to be paid for his services. 3 Times of Israel – December 6, 2018 Annexation – At What Cost? By David A. Halperin, executive director of the Israel Policy Forum • Some bad ideas refuse to stay down. Last week Israeli Justice Minister and Jewish Home member Ayelet Shaked breathed new life into one such misguided proposal. Speaking to journalists in Jerusalem, Shaked put forth her recommendation for annexing Area C of the West Bank to Israel and siphoning off the rest of the territory in a confederation with Jordan and Gaza. She even made the bizarre suggestion that the Palestinians might accept such an arrangement sometime in the future, a comment that could only have been informed by detachment from reality or unapologetic dishonesty. • Shaked’s talking points are a reflection of the deceptively named “stability plan” marketed since 2012 by her party’s leader, Education and Diaspora Affairs Minister Naftali Bennett, which focuses on absorption of Area C by Israel. Of course, this would produce anything but stability. • Bennett’s proposal, which Shaked parroted, plays up the demography of the West Bank while ignoring geography. To wit, there is no such thing as “partial annexation,” despite what Jewish Home might say. While it is true, as pro-annexation pundits like to point out, that an overwhelming majority of Palestinians live in Areas A and B (now under Palestinian Authority administration), they fail to note that those sections of the West Bank constitute a disconnected archipelago of territorial enclaves. Merging Area C – 60 percent of West Bank land – with Israel would leave 169 foreign islands in a sea of Israeli territory, each one with its own border which Israel would have to secure. Without the PA, and as these boundaries prove difficult to secure, Areas A and B are liable to fall under effective Israeli control too. • The Palestinian Authority cannot survive Israel’s annexation of Area C, as this definitively closes the door on a future two-state solution. Perhaps that’s Bennett and Shaked’s intention. Whatever the case, they owe it to the Israeli public, as well as to Israel’s patrons in Washington, to come clean about the costs of the PA’s collapse that will follow Israeli annexation of the majority of the West Bank.