The Land and Its People Mena.Pdf 3.71 MB
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Land and Its People Civil Society Voices Address the Crisis over Natural Resources in the Middle East/North Africa Housing and Land Rights Network Habitat International Coalition The Land and Its People: Civil Society Voices Address the Crisis over Natural Resources in the Middle East/North Africa Housing and Land Rights Network Habitat International Coalition Housing and Land Rights Network HABITAT INTERNATIONAL COALITION Coordination Office and Middle East/North Africa Program: 12 Tiba Street, Floor 2 • Muhandisin, Cairo EGYPT Tel./Fax: +20 (0)2 3478–6379 • E-mail: [email protected] / [email protected] Website: www.hlrn.org / www.hic-mena.org South Asian Regional Program: B–28, Nizamuddin East • Delhi 110013 INDIA Tel./ Fax: +91 (0)11 2435–8492 • E-mail: [email protected] Latin America Program (HIC-AL): Coalitión Internacional Habitat—México Huatusco No. 39 • Col. Roma Sur • 06760 México, D.F. MÉXICO Tel: +52 (0)55 12 15 86 • Fax: +52 (0)55 12 38 42 E-mail: [email protected] • Website: www.hic-al.org Sub-Saharan Africa Program (SSAP): c/o Mazingira Institute P.O. Box 14550 • Nairobi KENYA Tel: 254 (0)2 443–226/443–229/443–219 • Fax: +254 (0)2 444–643 E-mail: [email protected] • Website: www.mazinst.org UN Liaison Office: 8, rue Gustave Moynier • 1202 Geneva SWITZERLAND Tel./Fax: +41 (0)22 738–8167 • E-mail: [email protected] The Land and Its People: Civil Society Voices Address the Crisis over Natural Resources in the Middle East/North Africa Copyright © 2015 Housing and Land Rights Network Made possible with support from: 2 Contents Welcome ....................................................................................................................................................... 5 1. Land in the Middle East/ North Africa ................................................................................................. 7 A Regional Perspective of the Land, Joseph Schechla and Rabie Wahba ...................................................... 9 In the Long Shadow of Ottoman Land Administration, Jamal Talab al-Amleh and Joseph Schechla ........ 15 Toward Land Governance in the Middle East/North Africa Region, Willi Zimmerman .............................. 29 Water Security in the Arab Region, Aziz Latrash .......................................................................................... 45 2. Tenure Rights ...................................................................................................................................... 57 Displacement by Force of Law: Security of Tenure and Legal Lacunae in Egypt, Muhammad Abd al-Azim al-Bahay ......................................................................................................................................................... 59 Occupied Palestinian Small Farmers’ Rights to Property and Development, Ali Kadri ............................... 65 Challenges of Agricultural Cooperatives and Food Security in Egypt, Ahmed Mansour Ismail ................. 75 Real Property Rights in Libya, Mass`oud al-Karāti ....................................................................................... 81 Agrarian Reform and Its Undoing, Hasanain Kishk ...................................................................................... 87 3. Gender ................................................................................................................................................ 97 Exclusion of Women from Land and Housing: The Case of Inheritance, Saïda Garrach ............................ 99 Women’s Collective Land Rights: Laws, Customs and Violations in the Kingdom of Morocco, Raja’ al- Kassāb .......................................................................................................................................................... 103 4. Right to the City ................................................................................................................................ 107 The Arab World and Problems of Urban Growth: Toward a Regional Charter for the Right to the City, Baher Shawky .............................................................................................................................................. 109 Toward Comprehensive Interventions in Informal Settlements in Cairo, Ahmed Sedky ......................... 118 Informal Self-determination: Batn al-Baqara, Cairo, HIC-HLRN ................................................................. 126 The Right to the City: Cairo, Joseph Schechla ............................................................................................. 131 Imagining the Right to the City ine Jerusalem, Joseph Schechla ............................................................... 143 5. Corruption ......................................................................................................................................... 153 Land Dimensions of Corruption and Embezzlement in Tunisia, Ahmed Mansour Ismail ........................ 155 A Stolen Land: The Deepening Political, Security and Legitimacy Crisis in Bahrain, Akeela Ali and Joseph Schechla ....................................................................................................................................................... 161 6. Indigenous Peoples ........................................................................................................................... 165 Communal Land Rights, Identities and Conflicts in Sudan: The Nuba Question, Guma Kunda Komey ... 167 Nubian Land Rights, Manal Tibe ................................................................................................................. 179 Contours of the Land Question in Kurdistan, Sheruan Hassan and HIC-HLRN.......................................... 189 Syrian Kurds under Systematic Housing and Land Rights Violations, Sheruan Hassan and HIC-HLRN .... 199 The Forgotten Occupation: `Arab al-Aḥwāz, Adil al-Swidi and HIC-HLRN ................................................. 205 3 Amazigh People’s Rights to Their Land and Natural Resources/Azref g Wakal nnegh, various authors . 215 7. Conflict, Occupation and War .......................................................................................................... 221 The Nexus of Discrimination and Dispossession: Land and Lawfare, Joseph Schehcla............................. 223 Western Sahara: Denial of Self-determination and Human Rights, Malainin Lakhal and Mohamed Amroun ........................................................................................................................................................ 235 Cyprus Property Claims and Judgments, Joseph Schechla ......................................................................... 243 Reconstruction: The Next Struggle in Syria, HIC-HLRN .............................................................................. 251 8. Globalization ..................................................................................................................................... 257 International Investment Law and the [Human Right to] Land, Kinda Mohamedia ................................. 259 Privatizing the Land in Turkey, Cihan Uzunçarşılı Baysal and HIC-HLRN .................................................. 265 The Right to Water: International and Regional Agreements on the Tigris and Euphrates, Hazim al- Luhebe and Abbas Hasan Rahi al-Shamri ................................................................................................... 279 9. Land and Revolution ......................................................................................................................... 285 Lands of the Arab Spring, Joseph Schechla ................................................................................................. 287 Land and Transitional Justice in Yemen, HIC-HLRN .................................................................................... 293 10. Land in Constitution and Policy Reform .......................................................................................... 297 Operationalizing Food Sovereignty in the Egyptian Constitution, Basheer Saqr and Emily Mattheisen . 299 Land and Natural Resource Rights in the Constitutions of Transitional Countries: Examples for Arab Reformers, Joseph Schechla ........................................................................................................................ 305 A Constitutional Approach to Urban Egypt, Cairo Coalition ...................................................................... 319 Afterword ................................................................................................................................................. 327 Contributors ............................................................................................................................................. 329 4 Welcome The Housing and Land Rights Network of Habitat International Coalition (HIC-HLRN) warmly welcomes you to the Middle East/North Africa Land Forum. As a reader of this volume, you are joining a process that HIC-HLRN initiated in 2009 with the objective of developing further the knowledge and capacities of the region’s civil society actors as needed to advance both the research and advocacy agendas on human rights dimensions of land and natural resources. The volume under your eyes represents much of the cumulative output of the first four annual Land Forums since 2009. This volume also represents the completion of a critical diagnostic stage in the MENA region’s civil