CONGRESSIONAL RECORD—HOUSE July 21, 1999 a Recorded Vote Was Ordered
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
July 21, 1999 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD—HOUSE 17059 no fairness, no justice, and no protection for Danner Kilpatrick Phelps Latham Pickering Smith (WA) Davis (FL) Kleczka Pickett LaTourette Pitts Souder any of the other fundamental freedoms of ex- Davis (IL) Kucinich Pomeroy Lazio Pombo Spence pression. DeFazio LaFalce Price (NC) Leach Porter Stearns In November 1995, a U.S. citizen, Lori DeGette Lampson Pryce (OH) Lewis (CA) Portman Stenholm Berenson was arrested and subjected to a se- Delahunt Lantos Rahall Lewis (KY) Quinn Stump Deutsch Larson Rangel Linder Radanovich Stupak cret, hooded military tribunal in which she was Dicks Lee Rivers LoBiondo Ramstad Sununu denied due process, according to the State Dixon Levin Rodriguez Lucas (OK) Regula Sweeney Department, human rights groups and the Doggett Lewis (GA) Rothman Manzullo Reynolds Talent United Nations Commission on Human Rights. Dooley Lipinski Roybal-Allard McCollum Riley Tancredo Doyle Lofgren Rush McCrery Roemer Tauzin She was convicted of treason and given a life Edwards Lowey Sabo McHugh Rogan Taylor (MS) sentence without parole for allegedly being a Engel Lucas (KY) Salmon McInnis Rogers Taylor (NC) leader of a terrorist group. Lori has proclaimed English Luther Sanchez McIntosh Rohrabacher Terry Eshoo Maloney (CT) Sanders McKeon Ros-Lehtinen Thomas her innocence to these charges and in a letter Menendez Roukema Thornberry Etheridge Maloney (NY) Sandlin Metcalf Royce Thune to the human rights community, has de- Evans Markey Sawyer Mica Ryan (WI) Tiahrt nounced violence and terrorism. Farr Martinez Scarborough Miller (FL) Ryun (KS) Toomey Fattah Mascara Schakowsky Lori has continuously been denied the op- Miller, Gary Sanford Traficant Filner Matsui Scott portunity to speak with human rights groups Ford McCarthy (MO) Minge Saxton Upton Serrano Mollohan Schaffer Visclosky and the media. She has been held under hor- Frost McCarthy (NY) Sherman Gejdenson McGovern Moran (KS) Sensenbrenner Vitter rendous prison conditions in the Peruvian Sherwood Murtha Sessions Walden Gephardt McIntyre Skelton Andes and we are all very concerned with her Gonzalez McKinney Myrick Shadegg Walsh failing health. Lori has been subjected to long Slaughter Nethercutt Shaw Wamp Gordon McNulty Spratt Green (TX) Meehan Ney Shays Watkins periods of isolation which have been cited by Stabenow Gutierrez Meek (FL) Northup Shimkus Watts (OK) Amnesty International as cruel, inhumane and Stark Hall (OH) Meeks (NY) Norwood Shows Weldon (FL) Strickland degrading treatment, in violation of Article 5 of Hastings (FL) Millender- Nussle Shuster Weldon (PA) Tanner the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Hilliard McDonald Oxley Simpson Weller Tauscher Dennis Jett, the U.S. Ambassador to Peru, Hinchey Miller, George Packard Sisisky Wicker Hinojosa Mink Thompson (CA) Paul Skeen Wise has publicly stated that Lori Berenson has Hobson Moakley Thompson (MS) Pease Smith (MI) Wolf been singled out and treated badly simply be- Hoeffel Moore Thurman Peterson (MN) Smith (NJ) Young (AK) cause she is a U.S. citizen. The Peruvian mili- Holden Moran (VA) Tierney Petri Smith (TX) Young (FL) Turner tary tribunal that convicted Lori was in secret. Holt Morella ANSWERED ‘‘PRESENT’’—5 Hooley Nadler Udall (CO) Additionally, the Peruvian government has Horn Napolitano Udall (NM) Barrett (WI) Reyes Wilson never demonstrated any significant evidence Hoyer Neal Velazquez Hill (IN) Snyder Vento against Lori because it does not exist. Mean- Inslee Oberstar NOT VOTING—5 Jackson (IL) Obey Waters while, Lori has continued to proclaim her inno- Jackson-Lee Olver Watt (NC) Chenoweth McDermott Towns cence. (TX) Ortiz Waxman Kennedy Peterson (PA) Mr. Chairman, if we are to carry out the full Jefferson Ose Weiner Wexler b 1544 intent of Title 22 U.S.C. section 1732, by Johnson (CT) Owens Johnson, E.B. Pallone Weygand which Congress has given the President the Jones (OH) Pascrell Whitfield Messrs. SHOWS, WELDON of Florida, authority, short of war, to gain the release of Kaptur Pastor Woolsey BENTSEN and WISE and Mrs. BONO a U.S. citizen who has been wrongly incarcer- Kelly Payne Wu changed their vote from ‘‘aye’’ to ‘‘no.’’ ated abroad, then we must do all that we can Kildee Pelosi Wynn Mrs. KELLY, Mr. HOBSON, Mr. do to bring Lori home. NOES—234 ENGLISH and Ms. KAPTUR changed their vote from ‘‘no’’ to ‘‘aye.’’ The CHAIRMAN pro tempore (Mr. Ackerman Condit Goodlatte HASTINGS of Washington). The question Aderholt Cook Goodling So the amendment was rejected. is on the amendment offered by the Archer Cooksey Goss The result of the vote was announced gentlewoman from California (Ms. WA- Armey Cox Graham as above recorded. Bachus Cramer Granger TERS). Baker Crane Green (WI) f The question was taken; and the Ballenger Cubin Greenwood Chairman pro tempore announced that Barcia Cunningham Gutknecht ANNOUNCEMENT BY THE Barr Davis (VA) Hall (TX) CHAIRMAN PRO TEMPORE the noes appeared to have it. Barrett (NE) Deal Hansen RECORDED VOTE Bartlett DeLauro Hastings (WA) The CHAIRMAN pro tempore (Mr. Ms. WATERS. Mr. Chairman, I de- Barton DeLay Hayes HASTINGS of Washington). Pursuant to Bass DeMint Hayworth House Resolution 247, the Chair an- mand a recorded vote. Bateman Diaz-Balart Hefley A recorded vote was ordered. Bentsen Dickey Herger nounces he will reduce to a minimum Bereuter Dingell Hill (MT) of 5 minutes the period of time within The CHAIRMAN pro tempore. This Biggert Doolittle Hilleary which a vote by electronic device will will be a 15-minute vote followed by a Bilbray Dreier Hoekstra be taken on each amendment on which 5-minute vote on the Bilbray amend- Bilirakis Duncan Hostettler the Chair has postponed further pro- ment. Bliley Dunn Houghton Blunt Ehlers Hulshof ceedings. The vote was taken by electronic de- Boehlert Ehrlich Hunter AMENDMENT NO. 33 OFFERED BY BILBRAY vice, and there were—ayes 189, noes 234, Boehner Emerson Hutchinson answered ‘‘present’’ 5, not voting 5, as Bonilla Everett Hyde The CHAIRMAN pro tempore. The follows: Bono Ewing Isakson pending business is the demand for a Brady (TX) Fletcher Istook recorded vote on amendment No. 33 of- [Roll No. 326] Bryant Foley Jenkins Burr Forbes John fered by the gentleman from California AYES—189 Burton Fossella Johnson, Sam (Mr. BILBRAY) on which further pro- Abercrombie Blumenauer Capuano Buyer Fowler Jones (NC) ceedings were postponed and on which Allen Bonior Cardin Calvert Frank (MA) Kanjorski Andrews Borski Carson Camp Franks (NJ) Kasich the ayes prevailed by voice vote. Baird Boswell Clay Canady Frelinghuysen Kind (WI) The Clerk will redesignate the Baldacci Boucher Clayton Cannon Gallegly King (NY) amendment. Baldwin Boyd Clement Castle Ganske Kingston Becerra Brady (PA) Clyburn Chabot Gekas Klink The Clerk redesignated the amend- Berkley Brown (FL) Conyers Chambliss Gibbons Knollenberg ment. Berman Brown (OH) Costello Coble Gilchrest Kolbe RECORDED VOTE Berry Callahan Coyne Coburn Gillmor Kuykendall Bishop Campbell Crowley Collins Gilman LaHood The CHAIRMAN pro tempore. A re- Blagojevich Capps Cummings Combest Goode Largent corded vote has been demanded. VerDate mar 24 2004 13:12 Apr 21, 2004 Jkt 069102 PO 00000 Frm 00044 Fmt 0688 Sfmt 0634 E:\BR99\H21JY9.001 H21JY9 17060 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD—HOUSE July 21, 1999 A recorded vote was ordered. Meehan Rahall Stark TITLE VIII—GULF WAR VETERANS’ IRAQI Meek (FL) Ramstad Stearns CLAIMS PROTECTION The CHAIRMAN pro tempore. This Meeks (NY) Rangel Stenholm will be a 5-minute vote. Menendez Regula Strickland SEC. 801. SHORT TITLE. The vote was taken by electronic de- Metcalf Reyes Stump This title may be cited as the ‘‘Gulf War vice, and there were—ayes 427, noes 0, Mica Reynolds Stupak Veterans’ Iraqi Claims Protection Act of Millender- Riley Sununu 1999’’. not voting 6, as follows: McDonald Rivers Sweeney SEC. 802. ADJUDICATION OF CLAIMS. Miller (FL) Rodriguez Talent [Roll No. 327] (a) CLAIMS AGAINST IRAQ.—The United Miller, Gary Roemer Tancredo AYES—427 Miller, George Rogan Tanner States Commission is authorized to receive Abercrombie Danner Hobson Minge Rogers Tauscher and determine the validity and amounts of Ackerman Davis (FL) Hoeffel Mink Rohrabacher Tauzin any claims by nationals of the United States Aderholt Davis (IL) Hoekstra Moakley Ros-Lehtinen Taylor (MS) against the Government of Iraq. Such claims Allen Davis (VA) Holden Mollohan Rothman Taylor (NC) must be submitted to the United States Andrews Deal Holt Moore Roukema Terry Commission within the period specified by Archer DeFazio Hooley Moran (KS) Roybal-Allard Thomas such Commission by notice published in the Armey DeGette Horn Moran (VA) Royce Thompson (CA) Bachus Delahunt Hostettler Morella Rush Thompson (MS) Federal Register. The United States Com- Baird DeLauro Houghton Murtha Ryan (WI) Thornberry mission shall certify to each claimant the Baker DeLay Hoyer Myrick Ryun (KS) Thune amount determined by the Commission to be Baldacci DeMint Hulshof Nadler Sabo Thurman payable on the claim under this title. Baldwin Deutsch Hunter Napolitano Salmon Tiahrt (b) DECISION RULES.—In deciding claims Ballenger Diaz-Balart Hutchinson Neal Sanchez Tierney under subsection (a), the United States Com- Barcia Dickey Hyde Nethercutt Sanders Toomey mission shall apply, in the following order— Barr Dicks Inslee Ney Sandlin Traficant (1) applicable substantive law, including Barrett (NE) Dingell Isakson Northup Sanford Turner Barrett (WI) Dixon Istook Norwood Sawyer Udall (CO) international law; and Bartlett Doggett Jackson (IL) Nussle Saxton Udall (NM) (2) applicable principles of justice