MV Pvp Data Press Release V.08

2014

13th Maharashtra Legislative Assembly

[MUMBAIVOTES MLA PVP REPORT 2009-2014]

The Informed Voter Project 202 Joy Apartments, 21st Road, Bandra(W), Mumbai, 400050 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION ...... 4 a. MLALAD funds available v/s utilization ...... 4 b. Percentage of utilization of funds ...... 4 c. Percentage of attendance in vidhan sabha ...... 4 d. Questions asked in vidhan sabha ...... 4 e. Representation in various commitees ...... 4 f. Number of bills proposed ...... 4 QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs ...... 5 1. MLALAD FUNDS AVAILABLE v/s UTILIZATION ...... 5 2. PERCENTAGE OF UTILIZATION OF FUNDS ...... 8 2. PERCENTAGE OF ATTENDANCE IN VIDHAN SABHA ...... 18 4. QUESTIONS ASKED IN VIDHAN SABHA...... 21 5. REPRESENTATION IN VARIOUS COMMITEES ...... 24 6. NUMBER OF BILLS PROPOSED ...... 33 QUALITATIVE DATA ON MLAs ...... 35 1. GOPAL SHETTY ...... 35 2. VINOD GHOSALKAR ...... 37 3. PRAVIN DAREKAR ...... 38 4. SARDAR TARA SINGH ...... 39 5. MANGESH SANGLE ...... 40 6. SHISHIR SHINDE ...... 41 7. RAVINDRA WAIKAR ...... 42 8. RAJHANS SINGH ...... 44 9. RAMESH SINGH THAKUR ...... 45 10. YOGESH SAGAR ...... 46 11. ASLAM SHAIKH ...... 48 12. SUBHASH DESAI ...... 50 13. BALDEV KHOSA ...... 52 14. ASHOK JADHAV ...... 53 15. SURESH SHETTY ...... 54 16. KRISHNA HEGDE ...... 57 17. NASEEM KHAN ...... 58 18. RAM KADAM ...... 60 19. PRAKASH MEHTA...... 61

20. ABU AZMI...... 62 21. NAWAB MALIK ...... 63 22. CHANDRAKANT HANDORE ...... 64 23. MILIND KAMBLE ...... 65 24. KRIPASHANKAR SINGH ...... 66 25. PRAKASH BALA SAWANT ...... 67 26. BABA SIDDHIQUI ...... 68 27. VARSHA GAIKWAD ...... 69 28. JAGNNATH SHETTY ...... 71 29. NILKANTH KOLAMBKAR ...... 72 30. NITIN SARDESAI ...... 73 31. SACHIN AHIR ...... 74 32. BALA NANDGAONKAR ...... 76 33. MADHUKAR CHAVAN ...... 77 34. MANGAL PRABHAT LODHA ...... 79 35. AMIN PATEL ...... 81 36. ANNIE SHEKHAR ...... 82

INTRODUCTION

MumbaiVotesMLA Promises v/s Performance Report 2009 to 2014 provides an overview of the performances of the 36 sitting MLA’s of Mumbai. The data used in the report has been collected through Right to Information Act from Vidhan Bhavan and Collector’s Office. The document contains an analysis of the following data:

QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs

a. MLALAD funds available v/s utilization b. Percentage of utilization of funds c. Percentage of attendance in vidhan sabha d. Questions asked in vidhan sabha e. Representation in various commitees f. Number of bills proposed

QUALITATIVE DATA ON MLAs

a. Promise b. Performance c. Performance (Self-Declared)

Please visit http://mumbaivotes.com/ for a detailed report

QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs

1. MLALAD FUNDS AVAILABLE v/s UTILIZATION

Funds Sr. No. MLA Name Available Fund Utilised Percentage

77500000 1 Naseem Khan 59070000 76% 77500000 2 Baba Siddique 66243313 85% 77500000 3 Sachin Ahir 72070369 93% 77500000 4 Yogesh Sagar 72808000 94% 77500000 5 Krishna Hedge 73625000 95% 77500000 6 Ashok Jadhav 75943750 98% 77500000 7 Aslam Shaikh 75875000 98% 77500000 8 Baldev Khosa 76870156 99% 77500000 9 Rajhans Singh 76599520 99% 77500000 10 Ramesh Thakur 77100000 99% 77500000 11 Ravindra Waikar 76501787 99% 77500000 12 Vinod Ghosalkar 76934485 99% 77500000 13 Amin Patel 77681909 100% 77500000 14 Chandrakant Handore 77570000 100% 77500000 15 Mangal Lodha 77523754 100% 77500000 16 Prakash Sawant 77438000 100% 77500000 17 Ram Kadam 77304000 100% 77500000 18 Subhash Desai 77476000 100% 77500000 19 Suresh Shetty 77525000 100% 77500000 20 Milind Kamble 77982946 101% 77500000 21 Nawab Malik 77950000 101% 77500000 22 Nitin Sardesai 78557983 101% 77500000 23 Abu Azmi 79415000 102% 77500000 24 Jagannath Shetty 79717199 103%

77500000 25 Madhukar Chavan 80945828 104% 77500000 26 Mangesh Sangle 80542000 104% 77500000 27 Gopal Shetty 81310000 105% 77500000 28 Annie Shekhar 82192541 106% 77500000 29 Sardar Tara Singh 82935000 107% 77500000 30 Shishir Shinde 82877000 107% 77500000 31 Kripashankar Singh 83926439 108% 77500000 32 Nilkanth Kolambkar 83799535 108% 77500000 33 Varsha Gaikwad 84246718 109% 77500000 34 Prakash Mehta 85795591 111% 77500000 35 Pravin Darekar 85800000 111% 77500000 36 Bala Nandgaonkar 88245511 114%

Note: The total allocated funds under MLALAD was increased from 1 cr. in 2009 to 2 cr. in 2014. Over five years each MLA had access to 7.75 crores under MLALAD funds.

Note: The government may sanction and allocate funds for a project proposal, made by the MLA, that has a budget higher than the allowed funds for that period. If the MLA spends all the allocated funds then the total funds utilized can be higher than the total funds allocated. If the money is not spent then it gets carried forward to the next year.

Data Source: Collectors’ office (Mumbai Suburban and Mumbai City)

Average MLALAD funds utilization (Party Wise) 108%

106%

104% NCP INC 102% SS 100% SP 98% BJP 96% MNS 94% NCP INC SS SP BJP MNS

MLALAD Fund Available v/s Utilisation Percentage (2009-2014) 120%

100%

80%

60%

40%

20%

Amin Patel Amin

Sachin Ahir Sachin

Ram Kadam Ram

Gopal Shetty Gopal

Yogesh Sagar Yogesh

Nawab Malik Nawab

Aslam Shaikh Aslam

Baldev Khosa Baldev

Suresh Shetty Suresh

Naseem Khan Naseem

Nitin Sardesai Nitin

Rajhans Singh Rajhans

Shishir ShindeShishir

Krishna Hegde Krishna

Milind Kamble Milind

Subhash Desai Subhash

Annie Shekhar Annie

Pravin Darekar Pravin

Prakash Mehta Prakash

Abu Asim Azmi Asim Abu

Varsha Gaikwad Varsha

Ravindra Waikar Ravindra

Mangesh Sangle Mangesh

Vinod Ghosalkar Vinod

Sardar Tara Singh Tara Sardar

Madhukar Chavan Madhukar

Bala Nandgaonkar Bala

Kripashankar Singh Kripashankar

Ashok Bhau Jadhav Bhau Ashok

Prakash Bala Bala Sawant Prakash

Rameshsingh Thakur Rameshsingh

Chandrakant Handore Chandrakant

Mangal Prabhat Lodha Prabhat Mangal

Baba Zaiuddin SiddiquiZaiuddinBaba

Jagannath Achanna Shetty Achanna Jagannath Nilkanth Kalidas Kolambkar Kalidas Nilkanth

2. PERCENTAGE OF UTILIZATION OF FUNDS

Table 2.1 - Distribution of MLALAD funds by %

Community Misc. Storm Water Development - Foot issues MCGM Water Public Sl. No. MLA Supply Garden Drainage Other Roads paths Buildings Construction Toilet in Civic Related Crime Health Education Drainage Transport SWM

1 Gopal Shetty 3% 4% 6% 33% 8% 0% 0% 40% 7% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

2 Vinod Ghosalkar 10% 7% 24% 11% 20% 2% 0% 5% 20% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1%

3 Pravin Darekar 2% 0% 4% 12% 4% 6% 1% 28% 40% 1% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0%

4 Sardar Tara Singh 13% 3% 4% 15% 19% 28% 1% 7% 9% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0%

5 Mangesh Sangle 0% 0% 7% 18% 9% 8% 0% 26% 31% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

6 Shishir Shinde 0% 0% 0% 11% 0% 4% 0% 4% 81% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

7 Ravindra Waikar 8% 0% 1% 21% 1% 0% 0% 31% 39% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

8 Rajhans Singh 4% 0% 29% 13% 14% 3% 0% 4% 33% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

9 Ramesh Thakur 11% 0% 18% 13% 13% 3% 4% 9% 28% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

10 Yogesh Sagar 6% 0% 15% 26% 0% 7% 1% 10% 32% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 3%

11 Aslam Shaikh 4% 0% 50% 9% 11% 7% 0% 0% 18% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 1%

12 Subhash Desai 18% 0% 30% 18% 2% 6% 0% 10% 16% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

13 Baldev Khosa 3% 0% 0% 5% 81% 8% 1% 1% 1% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0%

14 Ashok Jadhav 21% 1% 10% 9% 6% 23% 3% 3% 21% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 3% 0% 0%

15 Suresh Shetty 11% 0% 31% 2% 6% 8% 0% 5% 34% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 3% 0% 0%

16 Krishna Hedge 8% 0% 31% 18% 18% 7% 0% 4% 15% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 17 Naseem Khan 22% 0% 8% 14% 4% 2% 0% 10% 39% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0%

18 Ram Kadam 1% 0% 6% 30% 11% 3% 0% 15% 34% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

19 Prakash Mehta 10% 1% 5% 16% 7% 6% 0% 39% 14% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 1% 1%

20 Abu Azmi 3% 0% 18% 32% 12% 2% 0% 4% 29% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0%

21 Nawab Malik 50% 0% 3% 18% 3% 0% 0% 12% 13% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

22 Chandrakant Handore 1% 0% 11% 22% 28% 6% 1% 2% 28% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

23 Milind Kamble 3% 0% 27% 21% 4% 3% 0% 6% 29% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 7% 0% 0%

24 Kripashankar Singh 6% 0% 27% 9% 16% 24% 0% 9% 9% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

25 Prakash Sawant 1% 0% 29% 25% 4% 7% 0% 4% 30% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

26 Baba Siddique 14% 2% 10% 9% 45% 3% 0% 4% 8% 1% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 2%

27 Varsha Gaikwad 9% 0% 19% 20% 3% 11% 1% 5% 31% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0%

28 Jagannath Shetty 7% 0% 50% 16% 6% 4% 0% 6% 8% 0% 0% 2% 0% 2% 0% 0% 0%

29 Nilkanth Kolambkar 19% 1% 8% 13% 4% 0% 40% 1% 6% 1% 1% 0% 0% 7% 0% 0% 0%

30 Nitin Sardesai 14% 3% 22% 12% 7% 2% 22% 6% 10% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0% 0% 0%

31 Sachin Ahir 0% 2% 5% 29% 4% 1% 43% 10% 6% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

32 Bala Nandgaonkar 3% 0% 4% 33% 0% 0% 30% 13% 14% 0% 1% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0% 0%

33 Madhukar Chavan 2% 0% 7% 12% 4% 0% 60% 9% 3% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 1% 0%

34 Mangal Lodha 2% 1% 20% 17% 15% 2% 28% 4% 8% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0% 0%

35 Amin Patel 3% 0% 4% 6% 3% 0% 80% 2% 2% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

36 Annie Shekhar 10% 2% 12% 8% 5% 1% 27% 15% 11% 0% 0% 3% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0% 8% 1% 15% 17% 11% 5% 10% 10% 21% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0% Average Spending Data Source: Collectors’ office (Mumbai Suburban and Mumbai City)

MLALAD Fund Utilisation by the MLAs from 2009-2014 100%

90% SWM 80% Public Transport Storm Water Drainage 70% Education 60% Health

50% Crime MCGM Related 40% Misc. issues in Civic 30% Toilet Construction 20% Buildings 10% Foot paths 0% Roads Community Development - Other Drainage Garden Water Supply

MLALAD Fund Utilisation by the MLAs from 2009-2014 100%

90%

80% SWM

70% Public Transport Storm Water Drainage 60% Education Health 50% Crime MCGM Related 40% Misc. issues in Civic Toilet 30% Construction

20% Buildings Foot paths 10% Community Development - Other Drainage 0% Garden Water Supply

MLALAD Average Spend (Sector wise)2009-2014 in % Storm Water Drainage 1% Garden Water Supply 1% Garden Water Supply 8% Drainage Toilet Community Development - Other 21% Roads Drainage Foot paths 15% Buildings Construction Toilet Construction Community Development - Misc. issues in Civic 10% Other 17% MCGM Related Crime Health Buildings Education 10% Foot Storm Water Drainage paths Roads 5% 11% Public Transport SWM

MLALAD funds average spend 2009-2014 ( Party Wise) 100% 90% SWM Public Transport 80% Storm Water Drainage 70% Education 60% Health 50% Crime 40% MCGM Related 30% Misc. issues in Civic 20% Toilet 10% Construction 0% Buildings BJP INC MNS NCP SP SS

Table 2.2 - Distribution of MLALAD funds by Parties in %

Wa Garde Drainag Community Roads Foot Buildin Constructio Toile Misc. MCGM Crime Health Educati Storm Public S ter n e Developmen path gs n t issue Relate on Water Transport W Su t - Other s s in d Draina M ppl Civic ge y BJP 5% 2% 15% 23% 9% 9% 6% 13% 17% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1%

INC 9% 0% 19% 12% 16% 6% 13% 5% 17% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 1% 0% 0%

MNS 3% 1% 7% 19% 5% 4% 9% 15% 35% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%

NCP 18 1% 12% 23% 4% 1% 14% 9% 16% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0% 0% % SP 3% 0% 18% 32% 12% 2% 0% 4% 29% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 0% 0%

SS 12 2% 15% 17% 8% 4% 0% 21% 22% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% %

Communit Sr MCG Storm y Misc. . Water Foot Constructi M Educati Water Public MLA Garden Drainage Developm Roads Buildings Toilet issues Crime Health SWM Total Amount Spent N Supply paths on Relat on Drainag Transport ent - in Civic o. ed e Other

1 Abu Azmi 2382450 0 14294700 25412800 9529800 1588300 0 3176600 23030350 0 0 0 0 0 794150 0 0 80209150

2 Amin Patel 2330457 0 3107276 4660915 2330457 0 62145527 1553638 1553638 0 0 776819 0 0 0 0 0 78458728

Annie 3 8219254 1643851 9863105 6575403 4109627 821925 22191986 12328881 9041180 0 0 2465776 4109627 0 0 0 0 81370616 Shekhar Ashok 4 15948188 759438 7594375 6834938 4556625 17467063 2278313 2278313 15948188 0 0 0 759438 0 2278313 0 0 76703188 Jadhav Aslam 5 3035000 0 37937500 6828750 8346250 5311250 0 0 13657500 0 0 0 0 0 758750 0 758750 76633750 Shaikh Baba 6 9274064 1324866 6624331 5961898 29809491 1987299 0 2649733 5299465 662433 0 0 0 0 1324866 0 1324866 66243313 Siddique Bala 88245 7 Nandgaonk 2647365 0 3529820 29121019 0 0 26473653 11471916 12354372 0 0 0 1764910 0 0 0 88245511 5 ar Baldev 8 2306105 0 0 3843508 62264826 6149612 768702 768702 768702 0 0 0 0 0 768702 0 0 77638858 Khosa Chandraka 9 775700 0 8532700 17065400 21719600 4654200 775700 1551400 21719600 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 76794300 nt Handore Gopal 10 2439300 3252400 4878600 26832300 6504800 0 0 32524000 5691700 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 82123100 Shetty Jagannath 11 5580204 0 39858600 12754752 4783032 3188688 0 4783032 6377376 0 0 1594344 0 1594344 0 0 0 80514371 Shetty Kripashank 12 5035586 0 22660139 7553380 13428230 20142345 0 7553380 7553380 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 83926439 ar Singh Krishna 13 5890000 0 22823750 13252500 13252500 5153750 0 2945000 11043750 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 74361250 Hedge Madhukar 14 1618917 0 5666208 9713499 3237833 0 48567497 7285125 2428375 0 0 0 0 0 1618917 809458 0 80945828 Chavan Mangal 15 1550475 775238 15504751 13179038 11628563 1550475 21706651 3100950 6201900 0 0 0 0 1550475 0 0 0 76748516 Lodha Mangesh 16 0 0 5637940 14497560 7248780 6443360 0 20940920 24968020 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 79736580 Sangle Milind 17 2339488 0 21055395 16376419 3119318 2339488 0 4678977 22615054 0 0 0 0 0 5458806 0 0 77982946 Kamble Naseem 18 12995400 0 4725600 8269800 2362800 1181400 0 5907000 23037300 0 0 0 0 0 0 590700 0 59070000 Khan Nawab 19 38975000 0 2338500 14031000 2338500 0 0 9354000 10133500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77170500 Malik Nilkanth 83799 20 15921912 837995 6703963 10893940 3351981 0 33519814 837995 5027972 837995 0 0 5865967 0 0 0 84637530 Kolambkar 5 Nitin 21 10998118 2356739 17282756 9426958 5499059 1571160 17282756 4713479 7855798 0 0 0 785580 0 0 0 0 77772403 Sardesai Prakash 22 8579559 857956 4289780 13727295 6005691 5147735 0 33460280 12011383 0 0 0 0 857956 0 857956 857956 86653547 Mehta Prakash 23 774380 0 22457020 19359500 3097520 5420660 0 3097520 23231400 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77438000 Sawant Pravin 24 1716000 0 3432000 10296000 3432000 5148000 858000 24024000 34320000 858000 0 0 0 0 858000 0 0 84942000 Darekar Rajhans 25 3063981 0 22213861 9957938 10723933 2297986 0 3063981 25277842 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 76599520 Singh Ram 26 773040 0 4638240 23191200 8503440 2319120 0 11595600 26283360 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77304000 Kadam Ramesh 27 8481000 0 13878000 10023000 10023000 2313000 3084000 6939000 21588000 0 0 1542000 0 0 0 0 0 77871000 Thakur Ravindra 28 6120143 0 765018 16065375 765018 0 0 23715554 29835697 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77266805 Waikar

29 Sachin Ahir 0 1441407 3603518 20900407 2882815 720704 30990259 7207037 4324222 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 72070369

Sardar 30 10781550 2488050 3317400 12440250 15757650 23221800 829350 5805450 7464150 0 0 0 0 0 0 829350 0 82935000 Tara Singh Shishir 31 0 0 0 9116470 0 3315080 0 3315080 67130370 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 82877000 Shinde Subhash 32 13945680 0 23242800 13945680 1549520 4648560 0 7747600 12396160 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 77476000 Desai Suresh 33 8527750 0 24032750 1550500 4651500 6202000 0 3876250 26358500 0 0 0 0 0 2325750 0 0 77525000 Shetty Varsha 34 7582205 0 16006876 16849344 2527402 9267139 842467 4212336 26116483 0 0 0 0 0 1684934 0 0 85089185 Gaikwad Vinod 35 7693449 5385414 18464276 8462793 15386897 1538690 0 3846724 15386897 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 769345 76934485 Ghosalkar Yogesh 36 4368480 0 10921200 18930080 0 5096560 728080 7280800 23298560 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2184240 72808000 Sagar

₹ 64 63 ₹ 5 86 ₹ 119 96 ₹ 129 97 ₹ 84 64 ₹ 43 39 ₹ 75 84 ₹ 80 44 ₹ 164 25 ₹ 65 ₹ 47 ₹ 1 77 ₹ 1 57 ₹ 3 23 ₹ 4 96 ₹ 1 63 Average ₹ 85 763 061 760 743 267 679 093 521 174 837 512 790 193 073 157 422 754 ₹ 17 Total ₹ 2326 70 ₹ 211 23 ₹ 4318 ₹ 4679 01 ₹ 3047 28 ₹ 1562 07 ₹ 2730 42 ₹ 2895 90 ₹ 59,13 ₹ 23 58 ₹ 63 78 ₹ 56 54 ₹ 116 ₹ 178 ₹ 30 87 ₹ 58 95 20 Spending 198 354 82 749 606 458 350 755 252 30 142 428 939 644 33 653 71 187 464 157 450 Communit MCG Storm y Misc. Water Foot Constructi M Educati Water Public Garden Drainage Developm Roads Buildings Toilet issues Crime Health SWM Supply paths on Relat on Drainag Transport ent - in Civic ed e Other

Data Source: Collectors’ office (Mumbai Suburban and Mumbai City)

₹ 7000,00,000 MLA's LAD Spending Distribution 2009-2014 (Sector wise) in Rs.

₹ 6000,00,000 Water Supply Garden Drainage ₹ 5000,00,000 Community Development - Other Roads Foot paths ₹ 4000,00,000 Buildings Construction Toilet ₹ 3000,00,000 Misc. issues in Civic MCGM Related Crime ₹ 2000,00,000 Health Education Storm Water Drainage ₹ 1000,00,000 Public Transport SWM

₹ 0 MLALAD Spending Distribution

2. PERCENTAGE OF ATTENDANCE IN VIDHAN SABHA

Sr. No MLA Name Percentage

1 Ram Kadam 56.81%

2 Kripashankar Singh 57.28%

3 Chandrakant Handore 72.30%

4 Prakash Mehta 72.77%

5 Shishir Shinde 73.24%

6 Prakash Bala Sawant 77.00%

7 Nawab Malik 81.22%

8 Rameshsingh Thakur 82.16%

9 Mangal Lodha 84.04%

10 Bala Nandgaonkar 84.51%

11 Rajhans Singh 84.98%

12 Annie Shekhar 84.98%

13 Nitin Sardesai 85.45%

14 Vinod Ghosalkar 86.38%

15 Baba Siddiqui 86.85%

16 Mangesh Sangle 87.79%

17 Abu Asim Azmi 87.79%

18 Aslam Shaikh 89.20%

19 Pravin Darekar 89.67%

20 Amin Patel 90.14%

21 Yogesh Sagar 91.08%

22 Sardar Tara Singh 91.55%

23 Baldev Khosa 91.55%

24 Subhash Desai 92.02%

25 Ravindra Waikar 92.96%

26 Nilkanth Kolambkar 93.43%

27 Madhukar Chavan 93.90%

28 Krishna Hegde 94.84%

29 Jagannath Shetty 95.31%

30 Milind Kamble 95.77% 31 Gopal Shetty 96.24%

32 Ashok Bhau Jadhav 96.24%

Data Source: Right to Information (RTI)

Average Attendance 2009-2014 (Party Wise) 90.00% 88.00%

86.00% MNS 84.00% INC 82.00% SS 80.00% BJP 78.00% SP 76.00% NCP 74.00% MNS INC SS BJP SP NCP

Percentage of Attendance MLA's 2009-2014 100.00% 90.00%

80.00% 70.00% 60.00% 50.00%

40.00% 30.00%

20.00% Percentage 10.00%

0.00%

Amin Patel Amin

Ram Kadam Ram

Gopal Shetty Gopal

NawabMalik

Yogesh Sagar Yogesh

Aslam Shaikh Aslam

Baldev Khosa Baldev

Nitin Sardesai Nitin

Rajhans Singh Rajhans

Shishir Shinde Shishir

Krishna Hegde Krishna

SubhashDesai KambleMilind

Annie Shekhar Annie

Pravin Darekar Pravin

Abu Asim Asim AbuAzmi

Prakash Mehta Prakash

Mangesh Sangle Mangesh

Vinod Ghosalkar Vinod

Ravindra WaikarRavindra

Sardar Tara Tara SardarSingh

Madhukar Chavan Madhukar

Bala Nandgaonkar Bala

KripashankarSingh

Ashok Bhau Ashok Jadhav

Prakash Bala Bala PrakashSawant

Rameshsingh Rameshsingh Thakur

ChandrakantHandore

Mangal PrabhatMangalLodha

Baba ZaiuddinBaba Siddiqui

JagannathAchannaShetty Nilkanth Kalidas NilkanthKolambkar

4. QUESTIONS ASKED IN VIDHAN SABHA

Name of the MLA Number of Questions Asked Baldev Khosa 0

Jagannath Achanna Shetty 0

Chandrakant Handore 3

Kripashankar Singh 10

Annie Shekhar 28

Baba Zaiuddin Siddiqui 142

Milind Kamble 177

Nawab Malik 202

Rameshsingh Thakur 226

Ashok Bhau Jadhav 288

Krishna Hegde 386

Prakash Mehta 486

Rajhans Singh 507

Nitin Sardesai 569

Sardar Tara Singh 693

Nilkanth Kalidas Kolambkar 815

Shishir Shinde 873

Madhukar Chavan 911

Amin Patel 919

Aslam Shaikh 925

Ram Kadam 941

Mangal Prabhat Lodha 950

Pravin Darekar 959

Prakash Bala Sawant 1045

Gopal Shetty 1059

Yogesh Sagar 1071

Abu Asim Azmi 1288

Mangesh Sangle 1298

Vinod Ghosalkar 1375

Subhash Desai 1443

Bala Nandgaonkar 1650

Ravindra Waikar 1711

Data Source: Right to Information (RTI) Number of Questions Asked by MLA's 2009-2014 1800

1600

1400

1200

1000

800

600 Number of Questions Asked

400

200

NOTE: Data of Mohd. Arif Naseem Khan (Con. No. 168), Sachin Mohan Ahir (Con. No. 162), Suresh Hiriyanna Shetty (Con. No. 166) and Varsha Gaikwad (Con. No. 178) is not included in the above chart as the said MLAs are Ministers and hence do not ask any questions to the government or raise any issues in the house. Total Number of questions asked (Party Wise) 7000

6000

5000 NCP SP 4000 BJP 3000 INC 2000 SS 1000 MNS 0 NCP SP BJP INC SS MNS

Average number of questions asked (Party Wise) 1600 1400 1200 NCP 1000 INC 800 BJP 600 MNS 400 SP 200 SS 0 NCP INC BJP MNS SP SS

5. REPRESENTATION IN VARIOUS COMMITEES

Table 5-1 - Representation of MLA's in various committees

Members Vidhan Other Absent Ex-Members Salary and Sabha Backward Sr. Members Special Public Employment Pension Estimates Allowances Request Caste No. MLA Name Committee Rights Undertaking Guarantee Related Joint Committee (Vidhan Committee Committee Scheme Joint Application Welfare Committee Sabha) Committee Committee Committee

- - - 1 Gopal Shetty 1 1 3 ------2 Vinod Ghosalkar - - - 4 - - 1 - - 3 Pravin Darekar - - - - 2 1 - 1 1 4 Rameshsingh Thakur - - - - 2 - - 1 - 5 Yogesh Sagar - - - - 2 - - - 3 6 Aslam Shaikh ------7 Ravindra Waikar - - - 2 - - - 1 - 8 Rajhans Singh - - - 1 - - - - - 9 Subhash Desai - - - 1 - - 1 1 - 10 Baldev Khosa 1 ------11 Ashok Bhau Jadhav - - 4 - -

- 2 - 12 Suresh Shetty - - - - -

1 - - 13 Sardar Tara Singh 3 ------14 Mangesh Sangle - - - - - 2 - - - 15 Shishir Shinde - - - 2 - - - - - 16 Ram Kadam ------3 - - 17 Prakash Mehta 1 ------18 Abu Asim Azmi - 1 - 1 - - - - - 19 Krishna Hegde - - 2 ------20 Arif Naseem Khan - - 3 - - - - 1 - 21 Milind Kamble ------22 Prakash Bala Sawant - - - - -

Baba Zaiuddin 2 - - 23 2 - - - - - Siddiqui - - - 24 Kripashankar Singh - - - - -

1 - - 25 Nawab Malik 1 - - - - - Chandrakant - - - 26 - - 2 - - - Handore - - - 27 Varsha Gaikwad - - - - -

Jagannath Achanna - 2 - 28 - - - - 2 - Shetty Nilkanth Kalidas - - - 29 - 1 - 2 - - Kolambkar - - - 30 Nitin Sardesai - - - 1 - - - 3 - 31 Sachin Ahir - - - - 4 -

- 1 - 32 Bala Nandgaonkar - - 1 ------33 Madhukar Chavan - - 2 - - - Mangal Prabhat - - - 34 - 4 1 - - - Lodha - - - 35 Amin Patel ------36 Annie Shekhar 1 - - - - -

Denotified and Non-Official Bills Schedule Nomadic Bylaw Minorities and motion of MLA Food Public Caste Tribes Committ Welfare adjournment Residency Arrangemen Accounts Welfare Welfare Sr. ee Committee committee Committee t Committee Committee Committee Committee No. MLA Name ------1 Gopal Shetty ------2 Vinod Ghosalkar ------3 Pravin Darekar ------4 Rameshsingh Thakur ------5 Yogesh Sagar 1 3 1 - - - - - 6 Aslam Shaikh

------7 Ravindra Waikar - - - 1 1 - - - 8 Rajhans Singh ------9 Subhash Desai 1 - 2 1 4 - - - 10 Baldev Khosa - - - - - 4 1 2 11 Ashok Bhau Jadhav ------12 Suresh Shetty - - - 1 - - - - 13 Sardar Tara Singh ------14 Mangesh Sangle ------15 Shishir Shinde ------16 Ram Kadam - - - - 1 - - - 17 Prakash Mehta - 3 ------18 Abu Asim Azmi - - - - 1 - - - 19 Krishna Hegde - - - 1 - - - - 20 Arif Naseem Khan - 3 - - - - 4 - 21 Milind Kamble

- - - 2 - - - - 22 Prakash Bala Sawant Baba Zaiuddin 1 3 ------23 Siddiqui 1 - 1 - - - - - 24 Kripashankar Singh - 3 1 1 - 1 - - 25 Nawab Malik ------2 - 26 Chandrakant Handore ------27 Varsha Gaikwad

Jagannath Achanna 2 - - 1 - - - - 28 Shetty

Nilkanth Kalidas - - - 1 - 3 - - 29 Kolambkar - - - - - 3 - - 30 Nitin Sardesai ------31 Sachin Ahir - - 4 - - 1 - - 32 Bala Nandgaonkar - - - - - 3 - - 33 Madhukar Chavan - 3 - 1 - - - - 34 Mangal Prabhat Lodha

- - - 1 2 - - - 35 Amin Patel - 3 ------36 Annie Shekhar

Table 5-1 - Representation of MLA's in various committees (contd.)

Wome Vidhan n Sched Sabha Hall Rights uled Panel and Tribes Vidhan Vidhan Document Welfar Welfar Sabha Sabha Work Maintainin e e Total years Rules Advisory g Ad-Hoc Commi Commi of Commitee Sr. Committee Committee Committee ttee ttee Experience No. ML Name - - - - - 5 1 Gopal Shetty - - - - - 4 2 Vinod Ghosalkar - - - - - 4 3 Pravin Darekar - - - - - 4 4 Rameshsingh Thakur - - - - - 3 5 Yogesh Sagar - - - - - 8 6 Aslam Shaikh - - - - - 2 7 Ravindra Waikar - - - - - 4 8 Rajhans Singh - 3 - - - 4 9 Subhash Desai - - - - - 14 10 Baldev Khosa - - - - - 11 11 Ashok Bhau Jadhav - - - - - 2 12 Suresh Shetty 3 - - - - 9 13 Sardar Tara Singh - - - - - 3 14 Mangesh Sangle - - - - - 2 15 Shishir Shinde - - - - - 0 16 Ram Kadam 1 - - - - 8 17 Prakash Mehta - - - - - 5 18 Abu Asim Azmi - - - - - 3 19 Krishna Hegde - - - - - 4 20 Arif Naseem Khan - - - - - 8 21 Milind Kamble - - - - - 2 22 Prakash Bala Sawant Baba Zaiuddin - - - - - 8 23 Siddiqui 3 1 - - - 6 24 Kripashankar Singh - - 3 - - 12 25 Nawab Malik Chandrakant - - - - - 4 26 Handore - - - 4 - 4 27 Varsha Gaikwad Jagannath Achanna - - - - - 7 28 Shetty Nilkanth Kalidas - - - - 1 8 29 Kolambkar - - - - - 4 30 Nitin Sardesai - 1 - - - 8 31 Sachin Ahir 2 3 - - 2 15 32 Bala Nandgaonkar - - - - - 6 33 Madhukar Chavan Mangal Prabhat - - - - - 9 34 Lodha - - - - - 4 35 Amin Patel - - - 8 - 12 36 Annie Shekhar

Data Source: Right to Information (RTI)

Total Years of committee experience ( Party Wise) 100 90 80

70 SP 60 NCP 50 SS 40 BJP 30 MNS 20 INC 10 0 SP NCP SS BJP MNS INC

6. NUMBER OF BILLS PROPOSED

Biils Name of the MLA Proposed Gopal Shetty 0 Vinod Ghosalkar 0 Pravin Darekar 0 Sardar Tara Singh 0 Mangesh Sangle 2 Shishir Shinde 3 Ravindra Waikar 3 Rajhans Singh 0 Rameshsingh Thakur 0 Yogesh Sagar 0 Aslam Shaikh 0 Subhash Desai 10 Baldev Khosa 0 Ashok Bhau Jadhav 0 Suresh Shetty Krishna Hegde 0 Naseem Khan Ram Kadam 0 Prakash Mehta 0 Abu Asim Azmi 0 Nawab Malik 1 Chandrakant Handore 0 Milind Kamble 0 Kripashankar Singh 0 Prakash Bala Sawant 0 Baba Zaiuddin Siddiqui 0 Varsha Gaikwad Jagannath Achanna Shetty 0 Nilkanth Kalidas Kolambkar 0 Nitin Sardesai 1 Sachin Ahir Bala Nandgaonkar 0 Madhukar Chavan 0 Mangal Prabhat Lodha 0 Amin Patel 0 Annie Shekhar 0

Data Source: Right to Information (RTI) Bills Proposed by MLA's from 2009-2014 12

0 Nitin Sardesai Nawab Malik Mangesh Sangle Shishir Shinde Ravindra Waikar Subhash Desai

Bills Proposed

Note: For all MLAs not in the above graph, the number of bills proposed from 2009 to 2014 in Vidhan Sabha is ‘Zero’.

No. of Bills Proposed 2009-2014 (Party Wise) 14

0 INC MNS NCP SS BJP

QUALITATIVE DATA ON MLAs

1. GOPAL SHETTY

Area of Work Promise Performance Sr. No Health and Sanitation 400-bed hospital to be built on a public- NIL

private partnership basis, (IE Nov 2009) Health and Sanitation Focus on bringing super specialty hospitals NIL 1 to the area. (HT April 2014) Human Resource Development Planned private college for arts, science, NIL 2 commerce and engineering, (IE Nov 2009) Power, Urban development, Transport and Construction of 60-feet road complete with Demanded that railways should connect Infrastructure storm-water drains and footpaths on both all platforms of Borivali station to the 3 sides post 2014 General Elections (MM road over-bridge and also asked for April 2014) better access from platform 8 to S V Road (TOI May 2011)

The Informed Voter Project 202 Joy Apartments, 21st Road, Bandra(W), Mumbai, 400050 Power, Urban development, Transport and NIL Contrary to the NOC given by the traffic Infrastructure department asking a roundabout at 4 Borivali to be of 3 mts diameter, he got one built exactly twice the limit. It has become a killer zone (TOI Nov 2011) Libraries and Museums Setting up of public library in Borivali West, 5 (IE Nov 2009) Miscellaneous NIL MHADA beautified Veer SavarkarUdyan with funds from BJP MLA Gopal Shetty (TOI March 2011)

Constructed four gymkhanas (IE Nov 6 2009)

Has not attended even a single of the 6 mayor's fund committee meetings (TOI Oct 2011)

2. VINOD GHOSALKAR

Performance Sr. No Area of Work Promise Launched Vasai Fresh brand in Dahisar. Over 25 centres set up across Dahisar and Borivali 1 Environment, Forests & Water resources NIL where farm products will be sold (TOI Aug 2011) Wrote to chief minister requesting him to declare mangroves in his constituency as 2 Environment, Forests & Water resources NIL protected forest and to stop construction of an 40ft road in the middle of it (MM May 2010) Crime Branch filed a charge sheet against him 3 Law, Order & Corruption NIL for outraging the modesty of corporator SheetalMhatre (MM March 2014) Was among the MLAs suspended for a year for disturbing finance minister AjitPawar 4 Law, Order & Corruption NIL when he was presenting the state budget (HT March 2011) Was among 117 activists who stopped trains 5 Law, Order & Corruption NIL and pelted stones at buses in the western suburbs (HT June 2010)

3. PRAVIN DAREKAR

Social Profile: a. The Mumbai District Bank, headed by MNS MLA PravinDarekar, will provide instant loans to women cab drivers to buy taxis, if needed (DNA Dec 2010) b. The Mumbai District Bank, which is headed by MNS MLA PravinDarekar will fund redevelopment projects to end the "builder raj" in city (DNA Nov 2010) c. The Mumbai District Central Cooperative Bank, which is headed by PravinDarekar will fund a chain of food stalls across the city (DNA Oct 2010)

Sr. No Area of Work Promise Performance Environment, Forests & Water Recreation space near Sanjay Gandhi Followed up on 14 occasions with forest officials so resources National Park by the BMC-(walking that slum dwellers/triblas in SGNP may get electricity 1 and jogging tracks, an amphitheatre and water supply (TOI March 2011) and food plazas near the park) (TOI July 2013) Law, Order & Corruption NIL Detained at Dahisar after party workers attacked a toll 2 plaza (IE Jan 2014) Law, Order & Corruption NIL Suspended for a year for uttering expletives in the 3 assembly (TOI July 2013) Law, Order & Corruption NIL Raised the issue of the alleged irregularities in the 4 redevelopment project spread across 57 acres along the Western Express Highway (TOI May 2013)

Law, Order & Corruption NIL Arrested at Borivali E after staging a street protest 5 against inflation (TOI Jun 2011)

4. SARDAR TARA SINGH

Area Promise Performance Sr. No. Environment, Forests & Water Resources Led group of Nahur residents to talk to NIL the management about soot-filled 1 smoke emitting from its chimneys (DNA Aug 2010) Environment, Forests & Water Resources NIL Started the task of planting 5 thousand 2 trees.(Navbharat Jun 2010) Law, Order & Corruption Around 90 CCTV cameras will be installed in 15 out of 90 CCTV Cameras installed in 3 Mulund (TOI Jul 2013) Mulund (TOI Jul 2013)

Law, Order & Corruption Push for amendments to make offences Pledged support for the Zero Tolerance under Sections 354 and 509 of the Indian petition against sexual harassment (TOI 4 Penal Code (IPC) non-bailable and Nov 2011) cognizable (TOI Nov 2011)

Power, Urban development, Transport and Opposing skywalk that he had 5 Infrastructure previously proposed, after Rs. 4 crore spent on it (MM Mar 2010)

5. MANGESH SANGLE

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance Urban development, Power, Promised to hold a rail-roko if Vikhroli foot- Demonstrated in support of removal of 1 Transport and Infrastructure over-bridge is not constructed (MM Nov Kanjur dumping ground (NT Oct 2012) 2010) Environment, Forests & Water NIL Filed PIL against reclamation of land by BMC 2 Resources that cause destruction of mangroves (TOI Aug 2013) Law, Order and Corruption NIL Home Minister took up his suggestion of immediately clicking photos, of those 3 booked for drunk and rash driving, by police officials (TOI Dec 2010) Law, Order and Corruption NIL Arrested for assaulting Vikhroli station 4 master over a party worker's quarrel with a booking clerk (DNA Oct 2011) Health & Sanitation NIL Led agitations on the Kanjurmarg dumping 5 site issue to put forward the health

problems faced by the residents (TOI Oct 2012)

6. SHISHIR SHINDE

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, NIL Raised the issue of funds for upgrading the electrification of areas in Transport and Infrastructure Mulund, Bhandup and parts of Kanjurmarg that had been reduced by 50% (TOI Feb 2010) 2 Human Resource Development NIL Raised question on safety measures taken for school children traveling by buses (HT April 2012) 3 Health and Sanitation NIL Announcement of rigorous implementation of PCPNDT Act by health department to curb sex determination and subsequent abortion in response to a calling attention motion by MLA ShishirShinde (TOI July 2012) 4 Housing and Poverty Allevation NIL Informed suburban Mumbai collector and the deputy police commissioner about 1000 hutments that had come up on a playground, and also removed a large number of unauthorized shanties (TOI Feb 2013) 5 Miscellaneous NIL Raised the issue of lack of washrooms for women at the railway stations (TOI July 2010)

7. RAVINDRA WAIKAR

Employment History: Active member of Shiv Sena since its foundation. Elected as Corporator in 1992, and four times thereafter. Head of Standing Committee in BMC for four consecutive terms. Head of BMC Education Committee for one term. SamparkPramukh for the party at Parbhani District. Elected to Maharashtra State Assembly from Jogeshwari (East) in 2009.

Accessibility to Citizens: Available in his office in Andheir (E) Taken up a scheme of ‘MLA at your door step’ in order to reach at different parts of his areas. Available on facebook and twitter Available every week in all the shakas.

Social Profile: Distributed Food /Sweaters/walking sticks to senior citizens in Temple as being a part of DattaramGovindWaikar Trust Taking up cleanliness drive in various societies Plantation of Trees with the Art of living Group, Religiously following up 'Moolmantra'- maintenance of greenery in Aarey colony

Encouraging Maitreyi Ladies Association to organise programme for women of different areas i.e. ShabbashVahini, For Senior citizens DilTohBaccha Hai ji, Childern Days Event Under ShivsamarthShikshanPrasarakSanstha runs Balwadi at low prices in order to provide basic pre-school level education to children of his area. Celebrating the festival of Diwali with the Adivasis / Handicap & senior citizens with sweets and gifts Distributed onions

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, NIL Pointed out to higher charges by private companies Transport and Infrastructure which led to amendment of rules by Energy Minister for better functioning of Maharashtra Electricity Regulation Corporation (HT Apr 2011)

2 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Filed a PIL alleging disproportionate distribution of funds between ruling MLAs and opposition MLAs by the Government (IE Dec 2013) 3 Human Resource NIL Raised question over bogus private schools (TOI Mar Development 2012) 4 Housing and Poverty NIL Raised the issue of inability to implement Slum Allevation Rehabilitation Act in Durga Nagar as it falls under 'No Development Zone' (Navbharat Apr 2010) 5 Environment, Forests and Promised to do justice in the incident NIL Water Resources where the funds he received for the pipeline replacement lapsed as work could not start due to objections from the Dairy Development Dept (MM Aug 2010) (In progress; Self-Declared) 6 Health and Sanitation In order to contain malaria, a team of NIL Shakha activists would help civic officials inspect construction sites (IE Jul 2010)

(Done; Self-Declared) 7 Miscellaneous Plans to initiate a chain of vegetable shops, Raised issue of the state owing Rs713 crore to BMC, where people can buy vegetables at rates against the services it offered (DNA Apr 2010) 25% lower than the market price (DNA Jul 2010) (Done; Self-Declared) 8 Miscellaneous Hawkers will be rehabilitated into BMC's NIL mall in Andheri (TOI Oct 2009) 8. RAJHANS SINGH

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, NIL Highlighted the issues of faulty materials in best buses, which have Transport and Infrastructure made a negative impact on the image of BEST among citizens. (Navbharat Jan 2011) 2 Environment, Forests and Water NIL Demanded that a stop work notice be issued to the developer for the Resources construction work where Dindoshi hills were being cut indiscriminately

(TOI Aug 2010) 3 Health and Sanitation NIL Raised the issue of incomplete cleaning of drains inspite of govenrment's assurance of 99% cleaning (Navbharat Jun 2011) 4 Housing and Poverty Alleviation NIL Started helpline to facilitate MHADA lottery process (Navbharat Apr 2011) 5 Miscellaneous NIL Raised issue of double collection of sewage tax (DNA Aug 2013)

9. RAMESH SINGH THAKUR

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance

1 Urban development, NIL Questioned the govt. on work done to ensure adherence of Power, Transport and norms by auto rickshaw drivers and to keep faulty meters in Infrastructure check. (TOI July 2011) 2 Urban development, NIL Raised the issue of illegal sand mining in Thane District (NT July Power, Transport and 2012) Infrastructure 3 Urban development, NIL Initiated to solve the problem related to Electricity, said that the Power, Transport and rates of Tata is lesser than Reliance and hence people will get Infrastructure reduced bill (NT Feb 2013) 4 Human Resource NIL Questioned the govt. on work done to address the difficulties Development faced by physically and mentally challenged people (Navbharat Apr 2010) 5 Housing and Poverty NIL Demanded increase in FSI of dilapidated buildings in Suburban Alleviation Mumbai and protection of slums made before 2000 under the Slum Rehabilitation Act. (Navbharat Apr 2010)

10. YOGESH SAGAR

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance

1 Urban development, Power, NIL Made pucca toilets in slums of R-South and converted its Transport and Infrastructure rooftops into study centres equipped with computers. (HT Mar 2014) 2 Urban development, Power, NIL As a member of public accounts committee he fought to Transport and Infrastructure reduce the toll on the Bandra-Worli sea link, (TOI Apr 2013) 3 Environment, Forests and Will propose a separate, state- Raised the issue of uneven water distribution across the city by Water Resources controlled board to ensure equal BMC (DNA Oct 2010) per capita water supply in the city (IE Nov 2009) 4 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Filed a petition seeking a direction to the government to table the Adarsh commission report and the government's action- taken report before the legislature (MM Nov 2013) 5 Health and Sanitation Promised to suspend ward officers if NIL any instances of larval breeding of mosquitoes are found (DNA Jun 2010) 6 Miscellaneous NIL Motioned to set up coastal security training school in three different parts in Maharashtra, as a result the government is now working on its implementation (TOI Jul 2013

11. ASLAM SHAIKH

Social Profile  Runs an Educational Institution by the name Ramzan Ali English High School and Jr. College since 1984 located in the Slum area of Malwani.  Chairman – Vision Foundation, an N.G.O. working for underprivileged sections of society – Regularly organises Mass Marriages, Free Wheelchairs distribution, Free Notebooks distribution and other such social works.  Started Malwani Helpline through which poor students are supported by way of Free Uniforms, Fees etc. Further provides Free Ambulance service for poor and needy people.

Accessibility to citizens  Available in Office every day except Sundays. Office is manned all the days of the week.  Visits various areas in the constituency to interact with people directly on Saturdays and Sundays.  Holds JantaDarbars at least once a month in different areas where officials like Police, Traffic Police, BMC Officials, Rationing Inspectors etc.  Active on Social Media through Email, Facebook and Whatsapp. Available on Mobile phone all the time

Other Details:  Date of Birth: 5th November, 1968  Age: 46 Years.

 Employment History: Family Business.

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, NIL Demanded to the CM, a flyover at the Marve junction, over bridges Transport and Infrastructure between Versova-Malad and Marve-Manori, and a girls hostel in western suburbs (HT Jul 2013) 2 Environment, Forests and Water Promised that ponds His efforts led to transformation of dumping grounds at Malwani, Resources in Malad West will Malad into a playground (TOI Jan 2013) be restored within a year and the open plot will be used as a playground (TOI Mar 2010) (Not Done) 3 Environment, Forests and Water Promised that he NIL Resources would put in efforts to ensure that the water yield of the ponds at Ali Talao in Malad is increased (DNA Mar 2010) (Not Done) 4 Libraries and Museums NIL Constructed News Paper Stands with sitting arrangements at various places in Malad (West). 5 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Raised the issue of financial mismanagement in sewerage department, and demanded that the guilty be punished immediately (TOI Jan 2011) 6 Human Resource Development NIL Raised the issue of difficulties faced by disabled in the legislative assembly (Navbharat Apr 2010).

12. SUBHASH DESAI

Employment History: • Colour Shop Owner; • Full time party work; • Chief Secretary of Mumbai Suburban Marathi SahityaSammelan; • Trustee of PrabodhanPrakashan& Publisher of Dainik 'Saamana', 'Marmik' Weekly & 'DopaharKaSaamana'

Accessibility to Citizens: •On phone •In office @9-11am and 8-10pm. At other times busy in meetings with BMC, MHADA, Party level meetings etc.)

Social Profile: • 1972 : Founded 'PrabodhanGoregaon' • 1973 : Shivsena Ambulance Service in Goregaon • 1977 : Chief Secretary of Mumbai Suburban Marathi SahityaSammelan • 1989 : Trustee of PrabodhanPrakashan& Publisher of Dainik 'Saamana', • 'Marmik' Weekly & 'DopaharKaSaamana' • 1991 : PrabodhanKridabhavan completed. Everyday 2500 sportsmen take advantage

• 1999 :Prabodhan Joggers Park completed. Everyday 1000 people take advantage • 2003 : Chief Initiator of Statue of ChhatrapatiShivajiMaharaj at Sahar Airport. • 2004 :Meenatai Thackeray Blood Bank established by PrabodhanGoregaon • 2004 : Chief Promoter of 'Career Fair' by PrabodhanPrakashan. Inaugurated at the hands of the President of India, Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam • 2005 : Chief Promoter of 'Ozone' - the ozonised olympic swimming pool • 2008 : Chief Promoter of Mobile Blood Collection Van • 2009 : Inauguration of Redeveloped Prabodhan Library & Study Room • 2009 : PrabodhanAushadhpedhi, Medicine Bank established by PrabodhanGoregaon

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Moved calling attention motion on different power Power, Transport and tariffs in Mumbai; led to Energy Minister announcing Infrastructure plans to introduce a Bill in the monsoon session to have a say in MERC decisions (TOI Apr 2011) 2 Urban development, Raised issue of lack of facilities for Bimbisar residents Power, Transport and which resulted in Minister of State announcing Infrastructure provision of a hospital, play ground etc. (Navbharat Apr 2011) 3 Law, Order and Promised to table evidence in assembly, proving Demand for a special assembly session to discuss the Corruption that Narayan Rane owned a benami flat in report of judicial commission that investigated the Adarsh (TOI Aug 2011) Adarsh case (TOI Jan 2014) 4 Law, Order and Served a notice to CM accusing him of breaching the Corruption privilege of the Assembly and regularising an illegal structure in Patliputra Housing Society while the Assembly was in the process of discussing the irregul arities (HT Apr 2012) 5 Housing and poverty Led a morcha and urged MHADA to redevelop 3,701 of Allevation its tenements in Mumbai (HT Sept 2012) 6 Miscellaneous Promised to ensure that UPA II will take notice of the protests in the May 31, 2012 Bharat Bandh

against the petrol price hike (TOI May 2012)(Not Done; Self-Declared) 7 Miscellaneous Assured Meru cab drivers' Union that he would support their demand for increase in fares (TOI Sept 2010)(Not Done; Self-Declared) 13. BALDEV KHOSA

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, To pay Rs. 10 lakhs in project Conveyed and attended a meeting with BMC chief to control Transport and Infrastructure pertaining to installation of CCTV property rates in the city (TOI May 2011) cameras between Bandra and Versova (TOI April 2013). 2 Urban development, Power, Contructs a new wall in Jogeshwari West which had collapsed due to Transport and Infrastructure poor materials last year ( NT June 2012) 3 Urban development, Power, NIL 1. Started the work of repairing of roads in Jogeshwari West (NT Transport and Infrastructure Sept 2012) 4 Urban development, Power, NIL Granted fund for construction of road in Jogeshwari West (NT Jan Transport and Infrastructure 2013) 5 Environment, Forests and Visited a lake in Lokhandwala Water Resources with a proposal to clean the polluted lake (TOI April 2012)(Done; TOI Sept 2013)

6 Miscellaneous NIL Demanded a plot reserved for a recreation ground in his constituency to be handed over to an NGO to maintain (HT May 2011)

14. ASHOK JADHAV

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance Performance (Self-Declared) 1 Urban development, To pay Rs. 10 lakhs in After issues raised by Ashok Jadhav Proposed Development & Power, Transport and project pertaining to ,Minister of State for Urban Development Beautification of Merkandrai Infrastructure installation of CCTV told the Assembly that in all civic Mehta Play Ground N.S.Road cameras between negligence cases, ward officers would be No.12A &ShamraoParulekar Marg, Bandra and Versova (TOI held liable for accidents causing death and Juhu, Mumbai-49. April 2013) serious injury and would be liable to pay compensation (HT April 2011) 2 Environment, Forests and Expected to demand a Took initiative to clean moss, silt and Water Resources new road in Juhu in a garbage from three natural ponds within meeting with CM to the Tata compound in Irla, Andheri (W) in discuss infrastructure an effort to conserve water bodies (MM issues (HT May 2012) May 2012) 3 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Submitted memorandum to CM demanding a probe by CID into road contracts worth Rs 5,000 crore, awarded by the civic body in the past five years. (HT Aug 2011) 4 Miscellaneous NIL Met BMC and MMRDA officials in the

matter of rehabilitation of Andheri shop owners who have suffered due to closure of their road to traffic for construction of the Versova-Andheri-Ghatkopar Metro rail corridor. (IE Oct 2010)

15. SURESH SHETTY

Social Profile  Career Guidance fair arranged every year for aspirants of competitive examination.  Coaching Classes for students of std. X & XII.  Sponsored financial assistance to needy students both School & University.

Accessibility to Citizens  Available in the Constituency office every alternate day on weekdays and full day on every Saturday & Sunday  Available on email, mobile and whatsapp  Real time response to all emails and messages within 24 hours

Other Details: Date of Birth: 2nd September,1955 Education:

 Completed schooling in Mumbai.  Commerce graduate from Mumbai University.  Post graduation Diploma in Personnel & Industrial Management.

Employment History:  Member of All India Congress Committee.  Elected to Maharashtra State Legislative Assembly for three consecutive terms—1999, 2004 and 2009.  Minister for Public Health, Family Welfare and protocol, Environment and Sports and Youth Welfare from November 2009 to November 2010  Minister of State for Medical Education, Public Health, Food and Drugs, Tourism, Mining, Sports and Youth Welfare, Higher and Technical Education, Special Assistance and Parliamentary Affairs  Minister for Public Health, Family Welfare and protocol (Current)

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Health and Sanitation Said that they are going to implement Urged the Bombay high court chief justice to expedite hearing PCPNDT Act rigorously to curb the of cases of sex determination filed under the PCPNDT Act by declining girl child ratio (TOI Aug December 2012 (TOI March 2013) 2011) 2 Health and Sanitation Said that municipal corporations of Launched RGJAY that would cover 972 surgery procedures and mega cities in the state will be asked 121 follow-up procedures. (HT Dec 2011) to conduct a fire prevention audit and review fire safety arrangements of private and government hospitals (HT Dec 2012) (Done, TOI May 2013) 3 Health and Sanitation Government will start 40 mobile Undertook a Rs.1000 crore health insurance project through clinics in the state (NT Jun 2011) which the state government plans to seek funds from the (Done; HM Oct 2011) Centre to ensure that health insurance to citizens across

Maharashtra becomes feasible (DNA Sept 2011)

4 Health and Sanitation Declared that the Rajiv Gandhi JeevandayeeArogyaYojana (RGJAY), which was functional in eight districts, will soon be implemented in 27 other districts across the state. (IE Nov 2013) 5 Health and Sanitation Said more than 11 crore people will get health care cards in three to four years under a health insurance card system (HT April 2010) 6 Environment, Forests and Held a meeting at the state secretariat to implement an action Water Resources plan in eight critically polluted clusters to intervene and improve the quality of environment and issued orders that police complaints and actions should be taken against polluting elements (HT June 2014) 7 Environment, Forests and Helped develop a neglected garden plot in Andheri 2000; Water Resources sanctioned money from his discretionary funds to develop the garden and restore the pond (TOI Nov 2009)

16. KRISHNA HEGDE

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Offered to install solar lights to resolve the issue State government directed the BMC to review the Power, Transport and of poor illumination in ward (TOI Feb 2014) proposed heritage list to identify structures and areas that Infrastructure have witnessed a change in character after efforts by Hegde (TOI Sept 2012) 2 Urban development, Agreed to join Congress MP Sanjay Nirupam in a Opposed coastal road and elevated metro rail alongwith Power, Transport and morcha to the Reliance Energy office to demand other MLAs in a meeting with CM; among other demands, Infrastructure a tariff subsidy for Mumbaikars (TOI Jan 2014) insisted that those staying on the airport periphery be rehabilitated in the same vicinity. (TOI May 2012) 3 Urban development, Promised better amenities including Flyover Presented a 32-point memorandum to BMC chief on civic Power, Transport and Bridge at Milan Subway and mobile police issues in his constituency that included protection and Infrastructure stations to local Santacruz residents (DNA Jan acquisition of open spaces (HT May 2011) 2011)

4 Urban development, Hegde said around 200 residents of CM announced in the Vidhan Sabha that pilgrimage sites Power, Transport and Jambulkarwadi in Vile Parle (East) to be will be untouched till new laws are made based on the law Infrastructure rehabilitated within 100 m of where they stay at regularising slums existing prior to 2000, after the issue present (TOI Feb 2010) was raised by Hegde (NT March 2011) 5 Urban development, Stated his intention to prioritise resolving water Wrote a letter to the SRA officials asking them to inquire Power, Transport and and traffic congestion problems, setting up into the alleged misuse of space reserved for a recreation Infrastructure citizens' groups, proper rehabilitation of all ground in Vile Parle (E) by SRA and demanded for a fresh slumdwellers and other housing issues (IE Oct survey of the project (DNA Dec 2009) 2009) 17. NASEEM KHAN

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Human Resource Informed that 1232 private minority schools in The state minorities department sanctioned Rs 5 crore Development the State will be granted 24.64 crore rupees for building five hostels for women coming from for the improvement of education (NT May minorities who want to pursue higher education (HT June 2010) (Partially Done; TOI June 2012) 2010)

2 Human Resource Informed that 45 Industrial Training Development institutions (ITIs) will be opened in the State to provide technical education to minority students (NT Jan 2010) (Partially Done; HM May 2011)

3 Health and Sanitation Promised to start district civil hospital in Ghatkopar (HM Feb 2011) 4 Miscellaneous Declared that cotton mills developments will be done through new policies (NT April 2010) 5 Miscellaneous Promised to provide the 56 cotton mills of the state a relieve of 108.77 crore interest free loan (NT Oct 2011) 6 Urban development, Power, NIL Announced a Rs. 6 crore worth project to develop 17 Transport and areas in the suburbs as tourist spots (NT Feb 2011) Infrastructure 7 Urban development, Power, NIL Appointed IIT to look for ways to prevent mud slides in Transport and case of hills that are more than three-storey high (HT July Infrastructure 2010) 8 Environment, Forests and NIL Informed that 10 crore rupees has been sanctioned for Water Resources the new pipe line scheme to resolve the drinking water problem in RamabaiAmbedkarnagar (NT Nov 2011) 9 Law, Order and Corruption NIL On the directions of Khan, the department of law and justice launched a probe into the sale, development and lease of land to muslim trusts (NT May 2011)

18. RAM KADAM

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Said that if LBS marg is not widened soon, then MNS Raised the issue of the dumping ground problems in Power, Transport and will respond to the concerned authorities in their Thane (HT 2013) Infrastructure style. (NT July 2011)

2 Human Resource Said that MNS will start protests if construction work Development starts at Ghatkopar (W) Hindustan Composite Company's land without issuing the worker's salary (NT Jan 2010) 3 Miscellaneous Promised to come together with other city MLAs to demand for the inclusion of DahiHandi in the state sports policy. (DNA July 2011) 4 Miscellaneous Will protest against the Gurunanak English School if the School administration fails to reduce the fees and fails to provide facilities to the Student within 10 days (NT July 2010) 5 Law, Order and NIL Demanded a CID inquiry against corruption in road Corruption construction in Assembly (DNA Aug 2011) 6 Health and Sanitation NIL Demanded the information of poor Patient's Medical treatment from the Hiranandani Hospital's Management (NT July 2010)

7 Housing and Poverty NIL Filed a query that came up for discussion in zero hour, Alleviation regarding 23 towers in violation of FSI norms on Palm Beach Road (TOI Aug 2011) 8 Housing and Poverty NIL Along with other MLAs demanded reconsideration of Alleviation the move to insist on a 6-m side margin for redevelopment of cessed buildings in the island city and regarding an additional 0.33 FSI in suburbs (TOI Jun 2011)

19. PRAKASH MEHTA

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Housing and Poverty Alleviation NIL Raised a Calling Attention Motion demanding stern action against Gammon-Nilkanth Realty Corporation for failing to provide houses in Vidyavihar to buyers within the required timeframe (TOI June 2011) 2 Housing and Poverty Alleviation NIL Prakash Mehta made a demand to the CM to implement the recommendations of the Afzalpurkar Committee on redevelopment of dilapidated and old buildings in the suburbs (TOI June 2011) 3 Housing and Poverty Alleviation NIL Opposed the Maharashtra Govts. proposition which makes citizens responsible for maintaining exteriors of buildings, and bars them from drying clothes in the balcony (HM March 2011)

4 Environment, Forests and Water NIL With Prakash Mehta's help, residents of Vidyavihar Complex persuaded Resources the BMC to construct a water pipeline in the complex (MM Sept 2013)

5 Miscellaneous NIL Arrested for allegedly setting a towing van on fire and rioting, after it crushed a 50-year old man (TOI Nov 2012)

20. ABU AZMI

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Environment, Forests and Water He will fiercely Raised the issue of water scarcity in his constituency during Zero Hour, Resources agitate against water stating that Mankhurd does not even have a pipeline and is suffering due scarcity in the to the ill-practices by the anti-social elements (DNA March 2011). locality (NT Jan 2011) 2 Environment, Forests and Water BMC decided to establish a pipeline in Govandi area followed by Azmi's Resources demonstration (HM Oct 2010)

3 Urban development, Power, NIL Abu Azmi highlighted the problem of dirty sewers in his area of Shivaji Transport and Infrastructure Nagar (Govandi) in the assembly (HM April 2011) 4 Miscellaneous Promised to build Wrote to the Minister of Food and Civil Supplies demanding to distribute

Malvani's number 3 free foodgrain to poor under the Annapurna scheme (NT Dec 2010) controversial Masjid Wall (NT May 2010) 5 Health and Sanitation NIL Wrote a letter to letter to BMC Additional Commissioner complaining against the deteriorating condition of Satapdi Hospital at Govandi (NT March 2010)

21. NAWAB MALIK

Accessibility to citizens: Local Offices Phone Calls Social Networks

Employment History: Business

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Human Resource Development NIL He prepared the proposal of 'Domestic Work Welfare Board' for the welfare of male and female Servants in the country (Navbharat May 2010) 2 Power, Urban development, NIL He submitted a memorandum to the CM urging him to order a CID inquiry Transport and Infrastructure into road contracts worth Rs. 5000 crore. (HT August 2011)

3 Health and Sanitation NIL Raised the issue of under-utilization of Shatabdi Hospital at Govandi since its ill-equipped. (DNA April 2011) 4 Housing and poverty alleviation NIL During a discussion in the assembly, he highlighted the situation of the poor who, despite centre allocating Rs. 6000 crore to Maharashtra, are subjected to harrassment at the hands of ration card makers and middlemen, (HumaraMahanagar Dec 2009) 5 Environment, Forests & Water NIL Met the CM to express his dismay about the delay in implementing the resources desalination project (DNA July 2010)

22. CHANDRAKANT HANDORE

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Power, Urban development, NIL Submitted a memorandum to the PM to reduce power tariffs for all Transport and Infrastructure consumers (TOI Jan 2014) 2 Housing and poverty alleviation Assured to give Popcorn and Candle Machine from his fund. (Aus 2010) 3 Miscellaneous NIL Was among the 5 MLAs suspended from the House for trying to stall the

session. (IE Dec 2011)

23. MILIND KAMBLE

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Power, Urban development, Constructed an illegal structure in the stilt parking area of a housing Transport and Infrastructure society (TOI Oct 2012)

24. KRIPASHANKAR SINGH

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Miscellaneous Promised to provide all possible He helped organise a program for inhabitants of Mankhurd help to Marwadi and Children's Home (NT Oct 2011) RajasthaniOrganisation working in the area of health, education and social work. (HM Jan 2011) 2 Miscellaneous He also demanded that a deposit of 1 crore to be made for the families of the people who died in bomb blasts.(NT July 2011) 3 Miscellaneous Ordered to start a Control room in Congress Office for the victims of serial Bomb Blasts in Mumbai. (NT July 2011)

4 Power, Urban development, Will protest against the Announced Rs. 1 crore package for developing mini seashore at Transport and Infrastructure government if legalisation of Vashi. (DNA Dec 2009) slums till year 2000 is not done. (NT Feb 2011) 5 Power, Urban development, Raised the issue of irregularities in sewer cleaning in Mumbai and Transport and Infrastructure suburbs through a calling attention motion. (HM April 2011)

25. PRAKASH BALA SAWANT

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Human Resource Development NIL His demand led to the decision of increase in the strength of teachers’ union from 6000 to 12000 by merging the private and government schools’ teachers’ unions (HamaraMahanagar Jan 2011) 2 Power, Urban development, NIL In response to his calling attention motion regarding favouritism by MERC Transport and Infrastructure and rising power tariff, Deputy CM promised to amend the Electricity Act 2003 (HT Apr 2011) 3 Environment, Forests & Water NIL In response to his calling attention motion, the Minister of State for resources Housing promised Bimbisar residents (Jogeshwari) that more recreational facilities like playgrounds etc will be provided (Navbharat April 2011) 4 Law, Order and corruption NIL Raised the issue of unbridled construction under the guise of redevelopment in the Khotachiwadi heritage precinct (TOI April 2011)

26. BABA SIDDHIQUI

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Health and Sanitation NIL In response to his efforts, CM promised a special investigation team to inquire into the case of irregularities by a private developer in the Deonar- Kanjurmarg dumping ground project (TOI Apr 2013) 2 Health and Sanitation NIL In response to his calling attention motion, govt. announced formulation of stringent laws on sale of medicinal drugs used for intoxication and creating awareness amongst pharmacuetical companies (Navbharat Apr 2011) 3 Environment, Forests NIL Raised the issue of water scarcity in his constituency in the assembly, & Water resources following which an order was passed by Minister Naseem Khan to provide extra water to the area (NT March 2011) 4 Environment, Forests NIL Gave Rs 1.18 crore for the revival of a derelict garden in his constituency & Water resources using MLALAD funds and MHADA funds for beautification scheme (TOI Dec 2011) 5 Urban development, NIL Due to his efforts, MMRDA decided to approve the changes suggested in Power, Transport and the Metro plan thereby saving 1800 families from rehabilitation (Navbharat Infrastructure Oct 2011) 6 Miscellaneous Local resdents raised the issue of NIL no invitation for objection to the installation of ‘Bat of Honour’ statue by Siddique. The statue is encroaching the walkway. He promised to look into the matter (MM Mar 2014)

27. VARSHA GAIKWAD

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Health and Sanitation Promised that state-run Cama 2.13,683 infants (aged up to 1 year) had died between Hospital would have a hi-tech linear January and September in Maharashtra, but she denied accelerator for cancer detection by that the cause was malnutrition (HT Dec 2011) year-end (TOI Apr 2010) 2 Human Resource Development Promised that the state government will provide employment training to rescued child labourers and mentally challenged children (Sep 2011) (Done; TOI 2012) 3 Human Resource Development To ensure that victims of domestic violence get relief, her department said it would immediately issue a government resolution (GR) telling officials in hospitals, police stations and state offices to understand the urgency of domestic violence cases and interpret the Act in its right essence (HT Dec 2011) 4 Law, Order and corruption Promised to look into the cause of non-deliverance of 15 guideline reports, by a court appointment

committee, for Kavdas orphanage for mentally challenged children that is responsible for exploitation of kids (MM May 2011) 5 Human Resource Development Will re-look into child policies, make Submited a proposal of 2332 crore for women and provisions for shelter homes, make anganwadiscentres (Navbharat June 2011) better health facilities available for street children and incorporate all recommendations made in TISS report (IE Dec 2013) 6 Human Resource Development Started a nutrition programme in Dharavi for pregnant women and children aged up to three years. It will also offer vocational training and placement to adult residents to increase employment generation especially among girls (HT Dec 2011)

7 Human Resource Development Her department revoked the licenses of 24 foster homes violating childcare norms in two months (TOI May 2012)

8 Human Resource Development Instrumental in lauching the ManodhairyaYojana which aims to provide Rs 2 lakh to Rs 3 lakh to victims of rape,child abuse and acid attacks. The victims would receive not only medical treatment but also legal aid, counselling and help for rehabilitation from the state government as part of the scheme (IE Dec 2013)

28. JAGNNATH SHETTY

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Health and Sanitation NIL Submitted a letter to the municipal commissioner of F/N ward regarding negligence by workers towards sanitation scheme in adopted colonies (Navbharat Jan 2011) 2 Health and Sanitation NIL In response to his question on the issue of a government hospital’s refusal to admit a pregnant woman, an independent body of doctors will be formed to inquire the matter (HamaraMahanagar Dec 2011) 3 Health and Sanitation NIL In response to his calling attention motion regarding BMC’s inability to segregate and scientifically treat municipal waste, CM stated that only 15 tonnes of the 7000metric tonnes of daily waste gets treated (HT Apr 2013) 4 Law, Order and corruption NIL His efforts led to annoucement by Minister of State for Housing that action will be initiated against middlemen involved in selling flats through illegal means in transit camps (Navbharat Apr 2011) 5 Housing and poverty alleviation NIL Raised a calling attention motion regarding the residents of dilapidated buildings and those built under Prime Minister's Grants Project (Navbharat March 2010)

29. NILKANTH KOLAMBKAR

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 NIL NIL NIL 2 NIL NIL NIL 3 NIL NIL NIL 4 NIL NIL NIL 5 NIL NIL NIL

30. NITIN SARDESAI

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, Promised to raise an issue Filed a PIL in the Bombay High Court seeking directions to the Transport and Infrastructure in assembly and with Maharashtra State Road Development Corporation (MSRDC) to MMRDA chief regarding immediately provide facilities such as patrolling, ambulances, building flyover bridge at among others, on the Mumbai-Pune Expressway (HT Feb 2014) Mahim station instead of the proposed Mahim skywalk (DNA Nov 2009) 2 Urban development, Power, Filed a PIL last year to challenge the toll collection rates, which Transport and Infrastructure allegedly violate National Highway rules (TOI Feb 2014) 3 Urban development, Power, In response to his application, the judicial bench allowed the Transport and Infrastructure completion of the renovation of the pathway at Shivaji Park (HT Jun 2010) 4 Housing and Poverty Alleviation Promised to raise the issue Demanded the cut-off date for the redevelopment of the cessed of restriction on and dilapidated buildings to be revised from 1940 to 1960 so that development of heritage more buildings can take benefit of additional FSI thereby ensuring structures proposed to be expedited city development (DNA Jul 2010) added in the expanded list (TOI Aug 2012) 5 Health and Sanitation Insisted on atleast 40 per cent reservation of beds for cancer patients in a super specialty hospital, which was initially reserved

for cancer hospital (HT Jul 2010)

31. SACHIN AHIR

Employment History:  Khatau Mill as an assistant to Welder  Union Leader

Accessibility to Citizens:  Chosen Social Media to communicate with his people (Facebook & twitter)  Has a head office in BandraMhada where he hears out his people about their problems, queries and helping them with solutions.

Social Profile:

Founded Shree SankalpPratishthan, a charitable Institution registered under the Indian trust act and founded by Sachin Ahir (Minister of State, Maharashtra & MLA of Worli Constituency). Its mission is to impact the lives of people across communities, enabling them to maximize their potential and transform their lives.

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, Promised to draft plan for the Transport and Infrastructure development of koliwada and then present it to CM (Navbharat Jan 2011)(Done; Self-Declared) 2 Environment, Forests and Water His Ministry has drafted an action plan to curb pollution and a Resources cabinet sub-committee has been formed to implement it. (DNA Mar 2010) 3 Law, Order and Corruption Real estate regulatory authority Ordered that the MHADA lottery probed should be bill to be introduced in the investigated by the Vigilance Department instead of the Vidhan Sabha during the Winter marketing director as the marketing department had Session which will help to conducted the lottery system of distribution (FPJ Aug 2011) regulate the false claims made by the builders while selling houses (Navbharat Jul 2011)(Done; Self-Declared) 4 Human Resource Development Assured senior citizens that the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act & the National Policy On Older Persons policy would be implemented within 3 months of the law departments recommendations (DNA Aug 2010)(Done; DNA April 2011)

5 Human Resource Development Government will draft new law Issued a Government Resolution making admissions to special

for senior citizens which will schools easier for handicapped persons (DNA June 2010) ensure that children don’t abandon them (HumaraMahanagar Apr 2011)(Done; DNA April 2011) 6 Health and Sanitation Has set up a state-level committee to study and prepare a report on the effects of mobile towers on public health (HT July 2010) 7 Housing and Poverty Alleviation Promised to construct and Approved the rehabilitation plan of families living in 16 handover homes to Century buildings in KonkanGrihaNirmaanMahamandal Mill labourers at the earliest (HumaraMahanagar Feb 2011) (Navbharat Dec 2011)(Done; HM March 2012)

32. BALA NANDGAONKAR

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Raised the issue of missing building files scam; led to CM's announcement of a CBI probe (TOI Jul 2013)

2 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Asked the Minister of State for Education to take strict action against the school management of St. Mary's involved in corruption (Navbharat June 2011)

3 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Raised the issue of CIDCO's role in Venus society's allotment at discounted price; led to the proposal of CID's probe in the matter (TOI Dec 2010) 4 Housing and Poverty Alleviation NIL Demanded to legalise slums constructed prior to 2000 in Mumbai (Navbharat Jun 2011) 5 Miscellaneous NIL Raised issue regarding eight production houses from the film and television industry for not paying dues (DNA March 2011)

33. MADHUKAR CHAVAN

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, Demanded that the 63 buildings built under the Prime Minister's Grant Transport and Infrastructure Project in the 1980s be redeveloped as they are in a poor condition (IE May 2012)

2 Health and Sanitation Is making a Raised the issue of milk adulteration in state and demanded strict law concerted effort to for this during Vidhan Sabha session (HM March 2011) increase milk production and reduce adulteration (Navbharat Apr 2011) 3 Health and Sanitation State government will demand death penalty for the milk adulteration (DNA Mar 2011) 4 Housing and Poverty Alleviation Raised the issue of permission given for redevelopment of Cheera Bazar without the permission of sub-tenants (HM July 2012) 5 Miscellaneous Wrote reply to a starred question in the Assembly, said the government has plans to appoint a coordination committee, comprising fishermen to address concerns. (TOI March 2013) 6 Miscellaneous At the cabinet meeting, raised the issue of funds for drought relief not being made available for employment guarantee schemes (TOI June 2012) 7 Environment, Forests and Water A committee of Resources technical experts will be set up to give a report within a month on fishing activities and may demand a ban on mega nets that catch fish in bulk. (DNA June 2011)

34. MANGAL PRABHAT LODHA

Social Profile

 Lodha Foundation organised campus connect program for guidance to students (NT Sept 2011)

Accessibility to citizens:

 Daily meeting at 9:00am with constituents at Gurukulam, Lodha Costiera, Napeansea Road  6 offices across all the wards in Malabar Hill to flag any issues constituents face and they are responded and rectified quickly.  Active on social network sites  His website has the contact details – Email and Phone number where constituents can reach in case they have any issues.  Regularly visits homes of different constituents across Malabar Hill in the evening on a regular basis.

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance Performance (Self-Declared) 1 Urban development, Plans to take a delegation Raised a calling attention motion in NIL Power, Transport and to the municipal the Assembly regarding the several Infrastructure commissioner, asking him problems that plagued the elevated to resolve the long- corridor of Metro phase 1 (MM June standing dispute over the 2014) proposed draft rules for property taxes (TOI Jan 2011)

2 Urban development, Said he will call a meeting NIL NIL Power, Transport and & ask the traffic police to Infrastructure shift their chowky that blocks the entrance to a fire station at Gowalia Tank at the cost of Rs. 4 crore rendering it unusable (MM May 2014) 3 Environment, Forests NIL Allotted 10 lakh rupees of fund for Established a "Phone KaroKachraHatao" and Water Resources the work of 'Banganga' talav from helpline for ensuring cleanup of garbage the Government (HM Nov 2009) for citizens of Malabar Hill within 24 hours 4 Environment, Forests NIL He urged the officials to rethink on NIL and Water Resources their decision to construct firestation in place of Priyadarshini park (NT Jan 2011) 5 Housing and Poverty NIL NIL Appealed in Assembly for preservation Alleviation of the heritage of chawls by modifying the FSI rules, which led to the Maharashtra Government declaring that action will be taken in this regard within 30 days

35. AMIN PATEL

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, NIL Raised the issue of the unreasonable fare's demanded by the Transport and Infrastructure Rickshaw drives of Airoli and Navi-Mumbai during the question hour (NT July 2011) 2 Law, Order and Corruption NIL Submitted the memorandum to the CM to order a CID probe into road contracts worth Rs 5,000 crore, awarded by the civic body in the past five years (HT Aug 2011) 3 Health and Sanitation NIL Sent letters to the BMC and the MSRDC about the issue of the residents of areas near JJ flyover who are suffering due to the dust on the flyover.(DNA Nov 2011) 4 Housing and Poverty Alleviation Will demand that the Demanded that all categories of cessed buildings should have an existing budgetary FSI of three (TOI July 2013) allocation for the repair of old and dilapidated buildings be doubled (TOI March 2011) 5 Housing and Poverty Alleviation Assured the residents Asked the government not to hike ready reckoner (RR) rates for that funds will be raised the coming year (TOI Oct 2013) to construct their premises destroyed by a wall collapse at Sandhurst

Road station (DNA Aug 2010)

36. ANNIE SHEKHAR

Sr.no. Area of Work Promise Performance 1 Urban development, Power, Raised the issue of lack of adequate public conveniences along the Transport and Infrastructure promenade. (TOI July 2012)

2 Environment, Forests and Water Wrote to the municipal commissioner demanding that the water Resources pipeline be replaced (HT Aug 2010) 3 Environment, Forests and Water Protested in Azad Maidan to oppose the rise in water price in Municipal Resources Budget(NT March 2012) 4 Health and Sanitation Paid a visit to a few government hospitals to investigate its condition (Navbharat Feb 2010) 5 Miscellaneous ChannelisedRs 10 lakh from MLA fund for a Vipasana Centre at the Walter D'Souza Garden near Liberty Cinema,Marine Lines (IE Dec 2010)

Data Source: Times of India, Mumbai Mirror, Hindustan Times, Indian Express, DNA, Navbharat Times, Humara Mahanagar, etc. Any self- declaration by the MLA is mentioned next to the data provided.

NOTE: To see the responses submitted by the MLAs, go to https://www.dropbox.com/sh/bu6dc3bzwuwb8cn/AABcSRrAHKweX7FJ- gIEgyTLa?n=268537023