2014 13th Maharashtra Legislative Assembly [MUMBAIVOTES MLA PVP REPORT 2009-2014] The Informed Voter Project 202 Joy Apartments, 21st Road, Bandra(W), Mumbai, 400050 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................... 4 a. MLALAD funds available v/s utilization ........................................................................ 4 b. Percentage of utilization of funds ................................................................................... 4 c. Percentage of attendance in vidhan sabha .................................................................. 4 d. Questions asked in vidhan sabha .................................................................................. 4 e. Representation in various commitees ........................................................................... 4 f. Number of bills proposed ................................................................................................ 4 QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs ................................................................................................. 5 1. MLALAD FUNDS AVAILABLE v/s UTILIZATION ................................................................................ 5 2. PERCENTAGE OF UTILIZATION OF FUNDS ....................................................................................... 8 2. PERCENTAGE OF ATTENDANCE IN VIDHAN SABHA ...................................................................... 18 4. QUESTIONS ASKED IN VIDHAN SABHA.......................................................................................... 21 5. REPRESENTATION IN VARIOUS COMMITEES ................................................................................ 24 6. NUMBER OF BILLS PROPOSED ...................................................................................................... 33 QUALITATIVE DATA ON MLAs .................................................................................................. 35 1. GOPAL SHETTY .................................................................................................................. 35 2. VINOD GHOSALKAR .......................................................................................................... 37 3. PRAVIN DAREKAR ............................................................................................................. 38 4. SARDAR TARA SINGH ....................................................................................................... 39 5. MANGESH SANGLE ........................................................................................................... 40 6. SHISHIR SHINDE ................................................................................................................ 41 7. RAVINDRA WAIKAR .......................................................................................................... 42 8. RAJHANS SINGH ................................................................................................................ 44 9. RAMESH SINGH THAKUR .................................................................................................. 45 10. YOGESH SAGAR ............................................................................................................ 46 11. ASLAM SHAIKH ............................................................................................................. 48 12. SUBHASH DESAI ............................................................................................................ 50 13. BALDEV KHOSA ............................................................................................................. 52 14. ASHOK JADHAV ............................................................................................................ 53 15. SURESH SHETTY ............................................................................................................ 54 16. KRISHNA HEGDE ........................................................................................................... 57 17. NASEEM KHAN .............................................................................................................. 58 18. RAM KADAM ................................................................................................................ 60 19. PRAKASH MEHTA.......................................................................................................... 61 20. ABU AZMI...................................................................................................................... 62 21. NAWAB MALIK ............................................................................................................. 63 22. CHANDRAKANT HANDORE ........................................................................................... 64 23. MILIND KAMBLE ........................................................................................................... 65 24. KRIPASHANKAR SINGH ................................................................................................. 66 25. PRAKASH BALA SAWANT ............................................................................................. 67 26. BABA SIDDHIQUI .......................................................................................................... 68 27. VARSHA GAIKWAD ....................................................................................................... 69 28. JAGNNATH SHETTY ....................................................................................................... 71 29. NILKANTH KOLAMBKAR ............................................................................................... 72 30. NITIN SARDESAI ............................................................................................................ 73 31. SACHIN AHIR ................................................................................................................. 74 32. BALA NANDGAONKAR .................................................................................................. 76 33. MADHUKAR CHAVAN ................................................................................................... 77 34. MANGAL PRABHAT LODHA .......................................................................................... 79 35. AMIN PATEL .................................................................................................................. 81 36. ANNIE SHEKHAR ........................................................................................................... 82 INTRODUCTION MumbaiVotesMLA Promises v/s Performance Report 2009 to 2014 provides an overview of the performances of the 36 sitting MLA’s of Mumbai. The data used in the report has been collected through Right to Information Act from Vidhan Bhavan and Collector’s Office. The document contains an analysis of the following data: QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs a. MLALAD funds available v/s utilization b. Percentage of utilization of funds c. Percentage of attendance in vidhan sabha d. Questions asked in vidhan sabha e. Representation in various commitees f. Number of bills proposed QUALITATIVE DATA ON MLAs a. Promise b. Performance c. Performance (Self-Declared) Please visit http://mumbaivotes.com/ for a detailed report QUANTITATIVE DATA ON MLAs 1. MLALAD FUNDS AVAILABLE v/s UTILIZATION Funds Sr. No. MLA Name Available Fund Utilised Percentage 77500000 1 Naseem Khan 59070000 76% 77500000 2 Baba Siddique 66243313 85% 77500000 3 Sachin Ahir 72070369 93% 77500000 4 Yogesh Sagar 72808000 94% 77500000 5 Krishna Hedge 73625000 95% 77500000 6 Ashok Jadhav 75943750 98% 77500000 7 Aslam Shaikh 75875000 98% 77500000 8 Baldev Khosa 76870156 99% 77500000 9 Rajhans Singh 76599520 99% 77500000 10 Ramesh Thakur 77100000 99% 77500000 11 Ravindra Waikar 76501787 99% 77500000 12 Vinod Ghosalkar 76934485 99% 77500000 13 Amin Patel 77681909 100% 77500000 14 Chandrakant Handore 77570000 100% 77500000 15 Mangal Lodha 77523754 100% 77500000 16 Prakash Sawant 77438000 100% 77500000 17 Ram Kadam 77304000 100% 77500000 18 Subhash Desai 77476000 100% 77500000 19 Suresh Shetty 77525000 100% 77500000 20 Milind Kamble 77982946 101% 77500000 21 Nawab Malik 77950000 101% 77500000 22 Nitin Sardesai 78557983 101% 77500000 23 Abu Azmi 79415000 102% 77500000 24 Jagannath Shetty 79717199 103% 77500000 25 Madhukar Chavan 80945828 104% 77500000 26 Mangesh Sangle 80542000 104% 77500000 27 Gopal Shetty 81310000 105% 77500000 28 Annie Shekhar 82192541 106% 77500000 29 Sardar Tara Singh 82935000 107% 77500000 30 Shishir Shinde 82877000 107% 77500000 31 Kripashankar Singh 83926439 108% 77500000 32 Nilkanth Kolambkar 83799535 108% 77500000 33 Varsha Gaikwad 84246718 109% 77500000 34 Prakash Mehta 85795591 111% 77500000 35 Pravin Darekar 85800000 111% 77500000 36 Bala Nandgaonkar 88245511 114% Note: The total allocated funds under MLALAD was increased from 1 cr. in 2009 to 2 cr. in 2014. Over five years each MLA had access to 7.75 crores under MLALAD funds. Note: The government may sanction and allocate funds for a project proposal, made by the MLA, that has a budget higher than the allowed funds for that period. If the MLA spends all the allocated funds then the total funds utilized can be higher than the total funds allocated. If the money is not spent then it gets carried forward to the next year. Data Source: Collectors’ office (Mumbai Suburban and Mumbai City) Average MLALAD funds utilization (Party Wise) 108% 106% 104%