1989 the Namibian

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

1989 the Namibian BUY THE NAMIBAIN - PUT YO.- NEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS! Bringing Africa South Tuesday April 25 TWO SIDE DID MEET despite official denials by SWATF that they had met with Plan leaders BY GWEN LISTER DESPITE an official denial from the SWA Territory- Force that a meeting took place on April 18 between officers of the South African Defence Force and Swapo ofrlCials, including two commanders 0( the People's Liberation Army of Namibia (PLAN), it bas been established that Major General Willie Meyer led the South African delegation which included other prominent military men and Mr Carl von Hirschberg of the office of the Administrator General The meeting was also confirmed by a spokesman from the South African Department of Foreign Affairs. The Namibian yesterday published fused to medi8le between South Africa • front-page report which quoted and Swapo any longer, in view of the Swapo Information Secretary, Mr broken promises, and had encour­ Hidipo Hamutenya, as saying that aged the two sides to talk to one the meeting between Swapo and the another. South Africans had been prompted The meeting which took place on by the present state of deadlock April 18 on the Namibian border concerning the implementation of with Angola, Mr Hamutenya added, had been attended by two PLAN commanders ~ Mr Nahas Angula, Swapo Education Secretary. The meeting, at which Swapo had spelled out its 'bottom line' , had given the South Africans an ultimatum: either they decided to fight, or they decided to allow the Swapo combatants \Ul­ hiMcred return to Angola. The meeting of 'April 18, he added', had 'set thi agenda for a meeting of the Joint Military Monitoring Commission on April 20. '. Subsequent to this meeting, South African Foreign Affairs Minister, Pik Bocha, had announced that fran 1~ on Wednesday, South African secu­ rity forces would be confmed to base in order to allow Swapo fighters 1.ttIJIJf . " unhindered return to Angola dur­ Mr Hidipo Hamutenya ing the period in question" . The SWA TF yesterday strongly the MO\Ult Etjo Accord. denied that the reported meeting had The accord, agreed to by South taken place.. The spokesman described Mr J Josef with pieces of the shotgun he Africa, Cuba and Angola earlier this The Namibian's report as "nonsense at a local gun dealer. month, effectively provided for a and clearly purposeful disinforma­ ceasc:frre in terms of which Swapo tion aimed at repairing Swapo's badly­ canbatants in Namibia would be given damaged international image" . "free passage" back to 'Angola. Mr However it has since been estab­ Hamutenya said that South African lished that Map' Genenl Willie Meya led the delegation, which included The case of the had reneged on its commitment to the MO\Ult Etjo agreement; had es­ Mr Carl von Hirschberg of the-office tablished "interrogation" centres for of the Administrator General, Briga­ Swapo fighters, rather than the prom­ dier Serfontein, Officer Command­ ised "free passage" , and had further ing Sector 10, a certain Commandant "shot 18 Swapo fighters in the baclc" Bosler of the JMMC, a Major broken shotgun when they tried k> cross baclc to Angola. Vasaliwo, and another Commandant, ACCOIumg toMr Hamulenyd, ooth believed to be from the intelligence PEOPLE don't usuaUy expect to find goods that they have left for repairs to be sawed up into st>veral the Cubans and Angolans had re- or security section of the SADF. pieces and to be totally destroyed. But this is what Mr J Josef of Oshikuku said happened to a shot gun STOP PRESS .. : STOP PRESS ... STOP PRESS ... STOP he had left for repair at a local gun dealer. The barrel of Mr Josef shotgun thrown out. gun for repairs they had told him that Plan chief's broadcast exploded when it was frred and in ' Two union officials who took up the gun was damaged beyond repair. October last year he took it to The Mr Josef's case told the owner of the Mr Lamprecht said that they could Gun Shop in Gobabis road to have it shop, Mr Joof Lamprecht, that the not destroy a weapon unless they had played from Casspirs repaired. shotgun didn't not belong to him and been given instructiions to do so by a Residents of Oshakatl and Ondangwa were woken late last night by the The elderly Mr Josef bought a new that he must give it back to Mr Josef. customer, In cases were a weapon vob ofSwapo's Secretary olDefence, Peter Mweslhange, being broadcast shotgun from The Gmt Shop in March The two union officials allege that was unrepairable he had to fill in on from security force Cassplrs. of this year. However, when he re­ Mr Lamprecht had offered to pay Mr official form with the name "Can­ Sc>ura!s saki the People's Uberadon Army of Namibia (Plan) commander turned to collect his old shotg\Ul, Josef R50 for his shotgun as a gesture cellation of Licence To Possess Fire­ was calling on Swapo combatants to return to Angola. which he thought had ~ repaired of goodwill but that the owner of the arm" which then had to be handed to The broadcast was played continuously through loud speakers attached he was told that he was no longer the shotgun had refused this offer. The the police. to the Cassplrs. The message also reportedly repeated South Africa's owner of the shotgun, \Ulion officials further claim that the He said that once such a form had undertaking to conftne Its security forces to base for 60 hours as from He was told that he had traded the shotg\Ul was destroyed in their pre­ been ftlled in and handed to the po­ 16hOO on Wednesday. old shotgun in for the new one which cence, and that the peices minus the lice the law did not allow him to give Some residents seemed uncertain about the authentidty of the broadcast he bought in March, but he denies trigger mechanism were given to Mr the weapon to the former owner. but said the volee appeared to be that of the Plan chief. that he had ever agreed to trade the Josef, with the advice that he could Mr Lamprecht said that he had Spokesman for the omce of the Administrator-General, Mr Gerhard old shotg\Ul in for a new one. go and give them to his children to always tried to look after his black Rom, said in Windhoek that tape recorded messages by Plan commanders He alleged that he was pushed out play with, customers because 95% of his cus­ calling for the withdrawal were handed over by Angolan officials to of the shop and that an employee of Approached for comment Mr tomers were bl~k and that he could their South African counter.parts at noon yesterday ready for broadcast, The Gun Shop threatened that if he Lamprecht of The Gun Shop aid that not afford to upset them. starting at 6pm. ever returned to the shop he would be when Mr Josef had brought his shot- I ' 2 Tuesday April 25 1989 THE NAMIBIAN A blow(pipe) to SA-UK relations AFRICAN REVIEW MALAWI UNDER WATER - THOUSANDS LEFT HOMELESS "South Africa is to tbe loyalist paramilitaries wbat Libya is to tbe IRA," said Peter Barry, a former foreign minister of tbe Irisb FRESH noods in nortbern Malawi destroyed the bomes of tens of tbousands of people and brougbt tbe Republic. total number left bomeless by freak rains to more than 200 000. He was responding to scandal deto­ advanced Starstreak missile, which Many of some 20 000 people in few days. that the floods, two earth tremors and nated when a South African diplomat is made by Short Brothers. one northern district took refuge on Crops of com, rice and beans were a cyclone caused damage estimated in Paris was trapped in the act of The affair is certain to negate any makeshiftplatforrns which they built washed away in Karonga and live- at about 42 million dollars. buying a stolen British missile from diplomatic advantage gained by South on the roofs of their flooded houses, stock was drowned, Banda said. At first, the Malawi Red Cross Northern Irish protestant extremists. Africa after the clashes in northern the State Disaster 'Preparedness Last month, the government said diverted relief food to flood victims Payment, it is believed, would have Namibia this month. It threatens to Committee said yesterday. that 115 000 people, mainly in south- that was intended to replace local coosisted of South African-made arms. embarrass British Prime Minister "People have not fled from the em provinces, were left homeless cassava crops destroyed by pests. British Foreign Secretary Sir Margaret Thatcher severely, since floods as in other areas, but have after torrential rain in January and Banda said the Disaster Prepared­ Geoffrey Howe summoned the South she has for the past ten years de­ adapted quite ingeniously," commit- February caused widespread flood- ness Committee was still assessing African ambassador, Mr Peter Rae fended South Africa from interna­ tee spokesman William Banda said. ing. Those floodwaters destroyed the full extent of the latest flooding Killen, to discuss the matter. British tional sanctions proposals. He said that government officials roads, crops, bridges and rail lines. in the north. Ambassador Sir Robin Renwick also Said Mr Kevin McNamara, the and Red Cross and aid agency repre- The government appealed for 28 Southem districts of Tanzania have raised the issue in Pretoria. British Labour Party's spokesman sentatives visited the worst affected million dollars in foreign aid to pay been affected by the flooding, and in South African Minister of Foreign on Northern Ireland: "It makes (Mrs province of Karonga, bordering neigh- for emergency repairs and relief food.
Recommended publications
  • Swapo and the Churches: an International Scandal
    SWAPO AND THE CHURCHES: AN INTERNATIONAL SCANDAL Paul Trewhela 'Swapo has the right to protect her people from those who are collaborating with the enemy...Yours in Jesus Christ.' — Dr Abisai Shejavali, General Secretary of the Council of Churches in Namibia. The illegal occupation of Namibia has been facilitated by Namibians who have collaborated with South Africa and have been traitors to the cause of a free Namibia. Yet SWAPO is willing to accommodate these people in a free Namibia and forgive their misguided behaviour.' — Report of the World Council of Churches, May 1988. 'So it goes' — Kurt Vonnegut, Slaughterhouse-Five. The Problems of the Text On 14 November 1989, Pluto Press published Church and Liberation in Namibia (CALIN), edited by Peter Katjavivi, Per Frostin and Kaire Mbuende. The book contains a number of documents on the relation between the churches and political conditions in Namibia, from 1958 to 1988, with individual essays by each of the editors and three others. David Theo Goldberg, assistant professor at the School of Justice Studies at Arizona State University, has described the book as 'crucial for anyone wanting to com­ prehend the role of the church in the promotion and realization of Namibian independence'. (Southern African Review of Books, Jan/Febl991) Goldberg's review is characteristic of the ignorance combined with tunnel vision of the international liberal/left establishment relating to southern Africa. The book in fact makes it impossible to comprehend the role of the churches in one of the most important episodes in the recent history of southern Africa: the cycle of wholesale arrests, torture, imprisonment and murder of Swapo members on the orders of their own leaders, dating from at least 1976 until the release of survivors in May 1989.
    [Show full text]
  • Namibia and Angola: Analysis of a Symbiotic Relationship Hidipo Hamutenya*
    Namibia and Angola: Analysis of a symbiotic relationship Hidipo Hamutenya* Introduction Namibia and Angola have much in common, but, at the same time, they differ greatly. For example, both countries fought colonial oppression and are now independent; however, one went through civil war, while the other had no such experience. Other similarities include the fact that the former military groups (Angola’s Movimiento Popular para la Liberacão de Angola, or MPLA, and Namibia’s South West Africa People’s Organisation, or SWAPO) are now in power in both countries. At one time, the two political movements shared a common ideological platform and lent each other support during their respective liberation struggles. The two countries are also neighbours, with a 1,376-km common border that extends from the Atlantic Ocean in the east to the Zambezi River in the west. Families and communities on both sides of the international boundary share resources, communicate, trade and engage in other types of exchange. All these facts point to a relationship between the two countries that goes back many decades, and continues strongly today. What defines this relationship and what are the crucial elements that keep it going? Angola lies on the Atlantic coast of south-western Africa. It is richly endowed with natural resources and measures approximately 1,246,700 km2 in land surface area. Populated with more than 14 million people, Angola was a former Portuguese colony. Portuguese explorers first came to Angola in 1483. Their conquest and exploitation became concrete when Paulo Dias de Novais erected a colonial settlement in Luanda in 1575.
    [Show full text]
  • Onetouch 4.0 Sanned Documents
    Confidential NAMIBIAN REVIEW: MARCH 2005 Confidential A BRIEF POLITICAL OVERVIEW AND CURRENT ASSESSMENT OF DIAMOND DEVELOPMENTS IN NAMIBIA 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The recent elections in Namibia saw the ruling South West African Peoples Organisation (Swapo) swept back into power with the same number of seats as the previous election in 1999. With the new presidential candidate Hifikepunye Lukas Pohamba only being inaugurated on 24 March, continuity of policy on all levels is more or less expected, given the fact that Pohamba was hand-chosen by outgoing president Sam Nujoma to replace him. Potential rivals for the Swapo presidency were dealt with in the months leading up to the elections. This included specifically Hidipo Hamutenya, once one of Swapo's favourite sons, who was unceremoniously dumped as foreign minister by Nujoma in May 2004 just days before the Swapo Congress to choose Nujoma's successor. Though defeated, Hamutenya's background and support base in amongst people _ who were part of Swapo's Peoples Uberation Army of Namibia (Plan), will ensure that he emerges once again as Pohamba's chief challenger for the position in five years time. The opposition remains weak and in general disarray with the once powerful Democratic Turnhalle Alliance (DTA) , having lost nearly half the parliamentary seats it had prior to the last elections. As far as developments on the diamond front are concerned the report makes the following broad points: • Continuity in the government's diamond policy can be expected under Pohamba. • Lev Leviev has been the driving force behind changes in Namibia's mining legislation in 1999 and further changes being contemplated for the near future.
    [Show full text]
  • National Archives of Namibia Findaid 2/55
    National Archives of Namibia Findaid 2/55 Findaid 2/55 A.0555 Namibia Refugee Project 1981-1990 Compiled by Brigitte Lau, March 1996 Revised and updated by Werner Hillebrecht, August 2012 National Archives of Namibia Findaid 2/55: A.0555 Namibia Refugee Project Compiled by Brigitte Lau, March 1996 2nd ed., revised and updated by Werner Hillebrecht, August 2012 © National Archives of Namibia, 2012 Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike CC BY-NC-SA Republic of Namibia Ministry of Education, Arts and Culture National Archives of Namibia P/Bag 13250 Windhoek Namibia Tel. +264–61–2935211 (switchboard), 2935210 or 2935222 (reading room) Fax +264–61–2935207 [email protected] ii Findaid 2/55 Namibia Refugee Project A.0555 Contents Introduction iv About the second edition v 1 Administration 6 2 Solidarity and related agencies 6 3 Donations, fundraising and related matters 7 4 Training and scholarships 7 5 Namibian organisations 8 6 Projects and project administration 8 7 Draft/products: Literacy Campaign 9 7 a SWAPO Literacy Campaign 10 8 Teaching English 10 9 Namibian Literacy Project 10 10 General information packs 11 11 Conferences / Meetings 11 12 Audiovisual and other records 11 13 Items returned from Archives Library 12 14 Bulletin board 13 15 Telexes 13 16 Annual and other reports 13 List of items transferred to Archives Library 16 List of catalogued photographs 20 iii Findaid 2/55 Namibia Refugee Project A.0555 Private Accession A.0555 Namibia Refugee Project Introduction The Namibia Refugee Project (NRP) The NRP was established in 1981 by a group of exile solidarity workers, many of them Namibians, in close co-operation with SWAPO.
    [Show full text]
  • Tribute by H. E. Dr. Sam Nujoma, Founding President
    TRIBUTE BY H. E. DR. SAM NUJOMA, FOUNDING PRESIDENT AND FATHER OF THE NAMIBIAN NATION, ON THE OCCASION OF THE STATE FUNERAL IN HONOUR OF THE LATE HONOURABLE DR THEO-BEN GURIRAB 20 JULY 2018 PARLIAMENT GARDEN WINDHOEK, KHOMAS REGION Check Against Delivery 0 | Page Directors of Proceedings; Madam Joan Guriras, the Children and the Entire Bereaved Family of the Late Comrade Dr. Theo-Ben Gurirab; Your Excellency Dr. Hage Geingob, President of the Republic of Namibia and Madam Monica Geingos, First Lady; Your Excellency Dr. Hifikepunye Pohamba, Former President of the Republic of Namibia and Madam Penexupifo Pohamba, Former First Lady; Your Excellency Comrade Nangolo Mbumba, Vice President of the Republic of Namibia and Madam Mbumba; Your Excellency, Dr Nickey Iyambo, Former Vice President of the Republic of Namibia and Madam Iyambo; Right Honourable, Dr Saara Kuugongelwa –Amadhila, Prime Minister of the Republic of Namibia and Comrade Amadhila; Honourable Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of International Relations and Cooperation and Retired Lieutenant General Ndaitwah; Honourable Professor Peter Katjavivi, Speaker of the National Assembly and Madam Katjavivi; Honourable Margaret Mensah-Williams, Chairperson of the National Council and Mr Williams; Honourable Peter Shivute, Chief Justice and Judge Shivute; Honourable Ministers and Deputy Ministers; Honourable Members of Parliament; Comrade Sofia Shaningwa, Secretary General of SWAPO Party; Honourable McHenry Venaani, Leader of the Official Opposition; Honourable
    [Show full text]
  • Memory Sites
    WAR, MEMORY, MYTH AND HISTORY MEMORY SITES Journal Cas Novak HIS220 – Winter 2018 Table of Contents GREECE.....................................................................................................................................8 Battle of Thermopylae.............................................................................................................8 Site......................................................................................................................................8 Date....................................................................................................................................8 Location..............................................................................................................................8 Combatants........................................................................................................................8 Purpose..............................................................................................................................8 As A Site of History.............................................................................................................9 Interesting Facts About the Site.......................................................................................10 As A Site of Memory.........................................................................................................10 As A Site of Contested Memory........................................................................................15 Your Concluding
    [Show full text]
  • Constitution of Namibia
    This publication contains: the full text of the Constitution of Namibia including its three amending acts and amendment annotations; the musical notes and lyrics of the Namibian National Anthem and the lyrics of the Anthem of the African Union; information on Namibia’s National Flag, other state fl ags, the National Coat of Arms and the National Seal; the texts of UN Resolution 435 and the 1982 Constitutional Principles; explanatory notes on some controversial parts of the Constitution, such as land The Constitution of the Republic Namibia expropriation, the death penalty and affi rmative action. The Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS) has worked in Namibia for almost 30 years for the free and peaceful promotion of democracy, with freedom, justice The Constitution of the and solidarity as the basic principles underlying our work. We support people to live self-determined lives in freedom and dignity, and encourage them to lend a hand in shaping the future along these lines. Republic of Namibia Through the publication of this annotated edition of the Namibian Constitution, KAS would like to promote Namibian citizens’ knowledge and awareness of (Annotated Edition) of their basic democratic rights and duties. We hope that in this way a kind of ‘constitutional patriotism’ can develop that will empower us to master the challenges of our society in the spirit of solidarity and justice while respecting democratic rules. The Namibia Scientifi c Society was founded in 1925 as a forum for scientists and researchers in the country, with the objective of providing the Namibian population with access to knowledge and information.
    [Show full text]
  • Constitution of Namibia
    This publication contains: the full text of the Constitution of Namibia including its three amending acts and amendment annotations; the musical notes and lyrics of the Namibian National Anthem and the lyrics of the Anthem of the African Union; information on Namibia’s National Flag, other state fl ags, the National Coat of Arms and the National Seal; the texts of UN Resolution 435 and the 1982 Constitutional Principles; explanatory notes on some controversial parts of the Constitution, such as land The Constitution of the Republic Namibia expropriation, the death penalty and affi rmative action. The Konrad Adenauer Stiftung (KAS) has worked in Namibia for almost 30 years for the free and peaceful promotion of democracy, with freedom, justice The Constitution of the and solidarity as the basic principles underlying our work. We support people to live self-determined lives in freedom and dignity, and encourage them to lend a hand in shaping the future along these lines. Republic of Namibia Through the publication of this annotated edition of the Namibian Constitution, KAS would like to promote Namibian citizens’ knowledge and awareness of (Annotated Edition) of their basic democratic rights and duties. We hope that in this way a kind of ‘constitutional patriotism’ can develop that will empower us to master the challenges of our society in the spirit of solidarity and justice while respecting democratic rules. The Namibia Scientifi c Society was founded in 1925 as a forum for scientists and researchers in the country, with the objective of providing the Namibian population with access to knowledge and information.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Here
    Institute for PPRublic olicy esearch 14 Nachtigal Street PO Box 86058 Eros Windhoek Namibia Tel: +264 61 240514/5 Fax: +264 61 240516 [email protected] www.ippr.org.na IPPR Opinion No. 14, April 2004 The Men Who Would Be President Graham Hopwood1 On Saturday 3 April 2004, the Swapo Party Central Committee announced the names of three candidates for the party’s presidential nomination for elections due on 14-15 November 2004. Delegates to Swapo’s Extraordinary Congress, set for 28-29 May, will have the chance to choose between Foreign Affairs Minister Hidipo Hamutenya, Higher Education Minister Nahas Angula and Lands Minister Hifikepunye Pohamba. Considering Swapo’s dominance at previous elections (President Sam Nujoma won 77% support in the 1999 election), the candidate who triumphs at the May congress will be seen as a shoo-in to replace Nujoma when he stands down on 21 March 2005. This opinion paper profiles the three candidates in an attempt to encourage debate about their track records and qualities in the run-up to the Congress. Hifikepunye Pohamba “In May 1962, I called a meeting and told those present that I needed two volunteers to go on a mission to carry out political mass mobilisation inside Namibia. Comrades Lucas Hifikepunye Pohamba and Eliader Muatale … volunteered first. When Hidipo Hamutenya put up his hand I told him he was still too young and I wanted him to go for study.” Sam Nujoma in his autobiography ‘Where Others Wavered’, p.125, Panaf, 2001. “I don’t have personal successes. My life has been one of collectiveness with others.” Hifikepunye Pohamba quoted in New Era, 16-19 April 2004 When President Sam Nujoma recommended Hifikepunye Pohamba as a presidential candidate, he was once again reaffirming his trust in his most loyal lieutenant.
    [Show full text]
  • AC Vol 43 No 25
    www.africa-confidential.com 20 December 2002 Vol 43 No 25 AFRICA CONFIDENTIAL MOZAMBIQUE 2 KENYA/ZIMBABWE A flood of mud The trial of the alleged murderers The big men look to the future of journalist Carlos Cardoso has As President Moi prepares to retire, his fellow septuagenarian thrown the spotlight on President President Mugabe continues the battle for power Chissano’s son and much of the Holding their collective breath, Kenyans expect a new government by the new year and the peaceable Maputo elite. This is helping presidential hopeful Armando retirement of their leader of 24 years, 78-year-old Daniel arap Toroitich Moi. Zimbabweans are in the Guebuza to distance himself from midst of their country’s worst economic crisis since the liberation war and face the determination of Chissano’s failures and to form an another 78-year-old, Robert Gabriel Mugabe, to remain in power until the third chimurenga (the war alliance with his former Renamo against invaders) has been completed. A decade ago, the possibility that Moi would hand over power to enemy, Raul Domingos. an opposition leader after multi-party elections looked remote. Zimbabwe has proved more predictable: few doubted that Mugabe would seize white farms and ruthlessly suppress dissent if an opposition party CÔTE D’IVOIRE 3 gained political ground. Economic collapse and corruption may prove to be the most dangerous of Moi’s legacies, storing up A new front opens mass social unrest as his successors battle to reform the threadbare public services and create jobs. Much As West African mediation efforts will depend on the energy of Kenya’s business class, increasingly marginalised during the Moi years by falter, France is stepping up its a cabal of commission agents which drove productive investment away.
    [Show full text]
  • Society of Advocates of Namibia, Namibian
    SOCIETY OF ADVOCATES OF NAMIBIA (Member of the International Bar Association) 1st Floor P 0 Box 1323 Namlex Chambers WINDHOEK 333 Independence Avenue NAMIBIA WINDHOEK NAMIBIA International Code +264 61 Tel: 231 151 Fax: 230 162 [email protected] PRESS RELEASE BY THE SOCIETY OF ADVOCATES OF NAMIBIA (“THE SOCIETY”) The Society of Advocates of Namibia ("the Society") has noted certain public criticisms of judgments and judges of the High Court of Namibia ("the Court"). This is an unfortunate trend, moreover where such criticism is neither accurate nor fair, and in circumstances where, as the Society has already stated in an earlier press-release, the judiciary cannot enter into public controversy and cannot reply to criticism levelled in this manner. Two recent publications are of concern to the Society. The first publication relates to an interview published in the Namibian newspaper on 24 June 2011. Mr Hidipo Hamutenya was reported as stating of and concerning a judgement of the Court, and referring to the Judge President of the Court, that - We look at the judgment of Damaseb and we conclude it was a political outcome and not a legal one. We are not surprised. The connection between Damaseb and SWAPO is well known. He may try to be impartial but how impartial can you be when your own party is being challenged? Bar Council: R Heathcote, SC (President); R Tötemeyer, SC (Vice-President); D Obbes (Secretary-General); J Schickerling (Treasurer); CE van der Westhuizen (Vice Secretary-General); G Dicks; AW Corbett; E Schimming-Chase www.namibianbar.org The aforementioned statement is of a serious nature, crosses the bounds of reasonable criticism of a judgment and judge of the Court and is contemptuous.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 General Overview This Is a Troublesome Mss. the 5 Chapters
    1 General Overview This is a troublesome mss. The 5 chapters by outside contributors are all basically sound and publishable. (There are detailed questions and some gaps). So too is the chapter on policing. Chapter 4 is somewhat problematic because it fails to inquire what claims to contact with 'masses' young 'dissidents' had, why they didn't get majority support at either internal congress and how a national election when North/Grootfontein/Otavi-Tsumeb/Oranjemund with majority of members couldn't have participated could be seen as democratic. Chapter 10 has some problems - including defining all extant democracies as pseudo while offering no alternative guidelines. Most flow from problems in Chapters 3, 4. It does not seem fully consistent with Chapter 9. Chapter 1 is a disingenuous hatchet job. (Invitation to a lynching?) In fact it is not a fair summary of main text especially of 5 non-editor chapters and policing. Chapter 3 is a rather unscrupulous case for the prosecution not a serious investigation. Evidence cited can very readily be used to support a quite different analysis. It is very hard not to believe the co-editors decided conclusions before they did research. Even evidence cited fits other frames just as well. Interestingly outside authors and co-editor on topic off main 'authoritarian to the core/watch Hawala rise again' theme come to rather different conclusions/general picture. While several chapters cite interviews with SWAPO/ex-SWAPO people it seems no contributor has any experience working with SWAPO or observing internal functioning. This is a handicap. Both co-editors expected to get posts in Namibia and did not.
    [Show full text]