The Cognition of Harmonic Tonality in Microtonal Scales

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Cognition of Harmonic Tonality in Microtonal Scales WESTERN SYDNEY UNIVERSITY DOCTORAL THESIS The Cognition of Harmonic Tonality in Microtonal Scales Author: Supervisors: Lillian M. Hearne Dr. Andrew J. Milne Prof. Roger T. Dean A thesis submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Music Cognition and Action Group The MARCS Institute 2020 i Acknowledgements First, I acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land upon which I completed my studies: The Darug, Tharawal (also historically referred to as Dharawal), and Eora peoples, and pay my respects to Elders past, present, and future. I would next like to acknowledge the guidance and help of my supervisors An- drew Milne and Roger Dean, who were a pleasure to work with. They were always available to talk when in the office and responded to emails and returned comments on drafts very promptly, and I never felt left in the dark. I’d also like to thank my colleagues from the lab for their help and advice and for their participation in my experiments. My colleague and housemate Ian Colley deserves a special mention here, for participating in every one of my experiments and providing valuable advice with using Max and R as well as in completing a PhD in general. My other housemates Rémi Marchand and Juan A. M. Fuentes and my ex-housemate Patrick Blown also deserve acknowledgement for their help with MATLAB and LaTeX, and my colleague Patti Nijhuis and my mum, Sonja Hearne for listening to my venting about computer issues and such. I’d also like to thank the technical team at MARCS for their help and patience with these issues, and the admin staff for their support throughout. I’d like to acknowledge the members of my musical ensembles Helix Quartet, Cone of Confusion, The Lancer Band, Sydney Harmony and St Mary’s Cathedral Choir who participated in multiple of my experiments; everyone at MARCS, or in AMPS, SMPC, ICMPC and MCM, who watched my presentations and asked ques- tions or discussed my work afterwards; to Marcus Pearce and Psyche Loui and the students in their labs for having me discuss my work with them; and to Paul Erlich, Margo Schulter, Jacob Barton, Juhani Nuorvala, Mike Battaglia, Kite Giedraitis and other mentors and contemporaries in The Xenharmonic Alliance. I’d like to thank my friends John Nicholls, for proofreading one of my papers, and Rachel Singer, for proofreading my papers and thesis; my girlfriend Indigo Ter- ayama for providing helpful distraction in the final week before submission (and continued support and encouragement in the months following); and everyone I’ve spoken to who asked about my research and let me get into any sort of detail! Finally, I’d like to thank Carol Krumhansl and Emery Schubert for their helpful reviews of this thesis. ii Statement of Authenticity The work presented in this thesis is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, original except as acknowledged in the text. I hereby declare that I have not submitted this material, either in full or in part, for a degree at this or any other institution Signed: iii Contents Acknowledgements i Statement of Authenticity ii Abstract xvi 1 Background 1 1.1 Introduction . .1 1.1.1 Tonality and Scale . .1 1.1.2 Thesis Summary . .3 1.2 Background . .4 1.2.1 Sound, spectrum, pitch and tuning . .4 1.2.2 Consonance and Affinity . .7 1.2.3 Probe Tone Experiments . 10 The context: presence or absence of tonal cues . 13 The dependent variable: participant ratings . 15 Participants: musicians or non-musicians . 16 1.2.4 Probe Chord Experiments . 16 Chord type and inversion . 20 Tension and stability . 21 1.2.5 The cognition of music in novel/microtonal tuning systems . 23 2 Experiments 1 & 2 – Tones 26 2.1 Introduction . 26 2.2 Overview of the Experiments and Models . 27 2.2.1 Experimental design . 27 2.2.2 Hypotheses . 29 Experiment 1 . 29 Experiment 2 . 30 iv 2.2.3 Analysis . 31 Bayesian ordinal mixed effects models . 31 Test for tonal hierarchies . 33 Comparison of fit and stability ratings (H1) . 34 Descriptive model . 34 Testing H2 & 3 with Bayesian ordinal mixed effects models . 35 Exploratory analysis . 39 2.3 Experiment 1: Diatonic, Harmonic Minor, Jazz Minor . 39 2.3.1 Method . 40 Participants . 40 Stimulus . 40 Procedure . 41 2.3.2 Results . 42 Test for tonal hierarchies . 42 Comparison of fit and stability ratings . 43 Descriptive model . 45 H2&3: Model 2.1 . 47 Exploratory analysis . 49 2.3.3 Discussion . 52 2.4 Experiment 2: Less familiar scales . 52 2.4.1 Method . 53 Participants . 54 2.4.2 Results . 54 Test for tonal hierarchies . 54 Comparison of fit and stability . 55 Descriptive model . 55 H2&3: Model 2.2 . 59 Combined analysis: Model 2.3 . 61 Exploratory analysis . 63 2.4.3 Discussion . 64 2.5 Conclusion . 65 3 Experiments 1 & 2 – Triads 67 3.1 Introduction . 67 3.2 Overview of the Experiments and Models . 68 v 3.2.1 Hypotheses . 68 Experiment 1 . 68 Experiment 2 . 68 3.2.2 Analysis . 69 Test for tonal hierarchies . 70 Comparison of fit and stability ratings (H1) . 70 Descriptive model . 71 Testing H2 & 3 with Bayesian ordinal mixed effects models . 71 Exploratory analyses . 74 3.3 Experiment 1: Diatonic, Harmonic Minor, Jazz Minor . 74 3.3.1 Method . 75 3.3.2 Results . 76 Test for tonal hierarchies . 77 Comparison of fit and stability ratings . 77 Descriptive model . 79 H2&3: Model 3.1 . 81 Exploratory analysis . 86 3.3.3 Discussion . 88 3.4 Experiment 2: Less familiar scales . 89 3.4.1 Method . 89 Participants . 90 3.4.2 Results . 90 Test for tonal hierarchies . 90 Comparison of fit and stability . 91 Descriptive model . 91 H2&3: Model 3.2 . 92 Combined analysis: Model 3.3 . 96 Exploratory analysis . 98 3.4.3 Discussion . 101 3.5 Conclusion . 102 4 Experiment 3: Intrinsic stability of the triads of 22-TET 104 4.1 Introduction . 104 4.2 22-TET . 105 4.3 Hypothesis . 108 vi 4.4 Method . 108 4.4.1 Participants . 108 4.4.2 Stimuli and Procedure . 109 4.5 Analysis . 109 4.6 Results . 112 4.6.1 Descriptive analysis . 112 4.6.2 Hypothesis test . 113 4.6.3 Bayesian ordinal mixed effects regression model . 115 4.7 Discussion / Conclusion . 123 5 Distributional Analysis of n-dimensional Feature Space for 7-note Scales in 22-TET 125 5.1 Introduction . 125 5.2 Definitions . 126 5.3 Review . 127 5.3.1 Redundancy . 128 5.3.2 Coherence and Evenness . 131 5.3.3 R-ad entropy . 133 5.3.4 Generator complexity . 133 5.3.5 Consonance . 134 5.3.6 Tetrachordality . 134 5.4 Analysis . ..
Recommended publications
  • James Clerk Maxwell
    James Clerk Maxwell JAMES CLERK MAXWELL Perspectives on his Life and Work Edited by raymond flood mark mccartney and andrew whitaker 3 3 Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP, United Kingdom Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries c Oxford University Press 2014 The moral rights of the authors have been asserted First Edition published in 2014 Impression: 1 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this work in any other form and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press 198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Control Number: 2013942195 ISBN 978–0–19–966437–5 Printed and bound by CPI Group (UK) Ltd, Croydon, CR0 4YY Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and for information only.
    [Show full text]
  • Computational Methods for Tonality-Based Style Analysis of Classical Music Audio Recordings
    Fakult¨at fur¨ Elektrotechnik und Informationstechnik Computational Methods for Tonality-Based Style Analysis of Classical Music Audio Recordings Christof Weiß geboren am 16.07.1986 in Regensburg Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doktoringenieur (Dr.-Ing.) Angefertigt im: Fachgebiet Elektronische Medientechnik Institut fur¨ Medientechnik Fakult¨at fur¨ Elektrotechnik und Informationstechnik Gutachter: Prof. Dr.-Ing. Dr. rer. nat. h. c. mult. Karlheinz Brandenburg Prof. Dr. rer. nat. Meinard Muller¨ Prof. Dr. phil. Wolfgang Auhagen Tag der Einreichung: 25.11.2016 Tag der wissenschaftlichen Aussprache: 03.04.2017 urn:nbn:de:gbv:ilm1-2017000293 iii Acknowledgements This thesis could not exist without the help of many people. I am very grateful to everybody who supported me during the work on my PhD. First of all, I want to thank Prof. Karlheinz Brandenburg for supervising my thesis but also, for the opportunity to work within a great team and a nice working enviroment at Fraunhofer IDMT in Ilmenau. I also want to mention my colleagues of the Metadata department for having such a friendly atmosphere including motivating scientific discussions, musical activity, and more. In particular, I want to thank all members of the Semantic Music Technologies group for the nice group climate and for helping with many things in research and beyond. Especially|thank you Alex, Ronny, Christian, Uwe, Estefan´ıa, Patrick, Daniel, Ania, Christian, Anna, Sascha, and Jakob for not only having a prolific working time in Ilmenau but also making friends there. Furthermore, I want to thank several students at TU Ilmenau who worked with me on my topic. Special thanks go to Prof.
    [Show full text]
  • Unified Music Theories for General Equal-Temperament Systems
    Unified Music Theories for General Equal-Temperament Systems Brandon Tingyeh Wu Research Assistant, Research Center for Information Technology Innovation, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan ABSTRACT Why are white and black piano keys in an octave arranged as they are today? This article examines the relations between abstract algebra and key signature, scales, degrees, and keyboard configurations in general equal-temperament systems. Without confining the study to the twelve-tone equal-temperament (12-TET) system, we propose a set of basic axioms based on musical observations. The axioms may lead to scales that are reasonable both mathematically and musically in any equal- temperament system. We reexamine the mathematical understandings and interpretations of ideas in classical music theory, such as the circle of fifths, enharmonic equivalent, degrees such as the dominant and the subdominant, and the leading tone, and endow them with meaning outside of the 12-TET system. In the process of deriving scales, we create various kinds of sequences to describe facts in music theory, and we name these sequences systematically and unambiguously with the aim to facilitate future research. - 1 - 1. INTRODUCTION Keyboard configuration and combinatorics The concept of key signatures is based on keyboard-like instruments, such as the piano. If all twelve keys in an octave were white, accidentals and key signatures would be meaningless. Therefore, the arrangement of black and white keys is of crucial importance, and keyboard configuration directly affects scales, degrees, key signatures, and even music theory. To debate the key configuration of the twelve- tone equal-temperament (12-TET) system is of little value because the piano keyboard arrangement is considered the foundation of almost all classical music theories.
    [Show full text]
  • Electrophonic Musical Instruments
    G10H CPC COOPERATIVE PATENT CLASSIFICATION G PHYSICS (NOTES omitted) INSTRUMENTS G10 MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS; ACOUSTICS (NOTES omitted) G10H ELECTROPHONIC MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS (electronic circuits in general H03) NOTE This subclass covers musical instruments in which individual notes are constituted as electric oscillations under the control of a performer and the oscillations are converted to sound-vibrations by a loud-speaker or equivalent instrument. WARNING In this subclass non-limiting references (in the sense of paragraph 39 of the Guide to the IPC) may still be displayed in the scheme. 1/00 Details of electrophonic musical instruments 1/053 . during execution only {(voice controlled (keyboards applicable also to other musical instruments G10H 5/005)} instruments G10B, G10C; arrangements for producing 1/0535 . {by switches incorporating a mechanical a reverberation or echo sound G10K 15/08) vibrator, the envelope of the mechanical 1/0008 . {Associated control or indicating means (teaching vibration being used as modulating signal} of music per se G09B 15/00)} 1/055 . by switches with variable impedance 1/0016 . {Means for indicating which keys, frets or strings elements are to be actuated, e.g. using lights or leds} 1/0551 . {using variable capacitors} 1/0025 . {Automatic or semi-automatic music 1/0553 . {using optical or light-responsive means} composition, e.g. producing random music, 1/0555 . {using magnetic or electromagnetic applying rules from music theory or modifying a means} musical piece (automatically producing a series of 1/0556 . {using piezo-electric means} tones G10H 1/26)} 1/0558 . {using variable resistors} 1/0033 . {Recording/reproducing or transmission of 1/057 . by envelope-forming circuits music for electrophonic musical instruments (of 1/0575 .
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Just Intonation Primer
    THE JUST INTONATION PPRIRIMMEERR An introduction to the theory and practice of Just Intonation by David B. Doty Uncommon Practice — a CD of original music in Just Intonation by David B. Doty This CD contains seven compositions in Just Intonation in diverse styles — ranging from short “fractured pop tunes” to extended orchestral movements — realized by means of MIDI technology. My principal objectives in creating this music were twofold: to explore some of the novel possibilities offered by Just Intonation and to make emotionally and intellectually satisfying music. I believe I have achieved both of these goals to a significant degree. ——David B. Doty The selections on this CD pro­­cess—about synthesis, decisions. This is definitely detected in certain struc- were composed between sampling, and MIDI, about not experimental music, in tures and styles of elabora- approximately 1984 and Just Intonation, and about the Cageian sense—I am tion. More prominent are 1995 and recorded in 1998. what compositional styles more interested in result styles of polyphony from the All of them use some form and techniques are suited (aesthetic response) than Western European Middle of Just Intonation. This to various just tunings. process. Ages and Renaissance, method of tuning is com- Taken collectively, there It is tonal music (with a garage rock from the 1960s, mendable for its inherent is no conventional name lowercase t), music in which Balkan instrumental dance beauty, its variety, and its for the music that resulted hierarchic relations of tones music, the ancient Japanese long history (it is as old from this process, other are important and in which court music gagaku, Greek as civilization).
    [Show full text]
  • Serial Music and Other New Trends in Western Art Music of the 20Th Century
    Serial Music and other new trends in Western Art Music of the 20th century In the 20th Century composers of Western Art Music experimented in the same way that artists did. The result was that things like melody, pitch, rhythm and time were used very differently to make up music. Whole tone music, atonal music, bitonal music, microtonal music, serial music and minimalist music were some of the different types of new music that were a result of this experimentation. Minimalist music is discussed on a separate page. Atonal music and Bitonal music Atonal music is music where the composer has experimented with pitch and melody to the point where there is no home note in the music. Bitonal music is when the composer uses 2 different key signatures (ie 2 different home notes), in two different parts, at the same time. Whole tone music Whole tone music is based on the whole tone scale. This is a scale made up of whole tones only, eg. C D E F# G# A# C. Melodies built on the whole tone scale sound hazy or misty. The chords (harmonies) built on the whole tone scale are also unconventional and colourful (different) sounding. A composer who used the whole tone scale quite a lot was Debussy. He is also known for being influenced by Indonesian Gamelan music (see the page on Minimalism for an explanation of Gamelan). Debussy’s use of pedal points (like a drone – the same note is held or continually repeated while other parts change) and ostinato give his music the ‘cyclical’ feeling created by repetition in Gamelan music.
    [Show full text]
  • 21-Asis Aktualios Muzikos Festivalis GAIDA 21Th Contemporary Music Festival
    GAIDA 21-asis aktualios muzikos festivalis GAIDA 21th Contemporary Music festival 2011 m. spalio 21–29 d., Vilnius 21–29 October, 2011, Vilnius Festivalio viešbutis Globėjai: 21-asis tarptautinis šiuolaikinės muzikos festivalis GAIDA 21th International Contemporary Music Festival Pagrindiniai informaciniai rėmėjai: MINIMAL | MAXIMAL • Festivalio tema – minimalizmas ir maksimalizmas muzikoje: bandymas Informaciniai rėmėjai: pažvelgti į skirtingus muzikos polius • Vienos didžiausių šiuolaikinės muzikos asmenybių platesnis kūrybos pristatymas – portretas: kompozitorius vizionierius Iannis Xenakis • Pirmą kartą Lietuvoje – iškiliausio XX a. pabaigos lenkų simfoninio kūrinio, Henryko Mikołajaus Góreckio III simfonijos, atlikimas • Dėmesys tikriems šiuolaikinės muzikos atlikimo lyderiams iš Prancūzijos, Vokietijos ir Italijos Partneriai ir rėmėjai: • Intriguojantys audiovizualiniai projektai – originalios skirtingų menų sąveikos ir netikėti sprendimai • Keletas potėpių M. K. Čiurlioniui, pažymint kompozitoriaus 100-ąsias mirties metines • Naujų kūrinių užsakymai ir geriausi Lietuvos bei užsienio atlikėjai: simfoniniai orkestrai, ansambliai, solistai Festivalis GAIDA yra europinio naujosios muzikos kūrybos ir sklaidos tinklo Réseau Varése, remiamo Europos Komisijos programos Kultūra, narys. The GAIDA Festival is a member of the Réseau Varése, European network Rengėjai: for the creation and promotion of new music, subsidized by the Culture Programme of the European Commission. TURINYS / CONTENT Programa / Programme.......................................................................................2
    [Show full text]
  • HSK 6 Vocabulary List
    HSK 6 Vocabulary List No Chinese Pinyin English HSK 1 呵 ā to scold in a loud voice; to yawn HSK6 to suffer from; to endure; to tide over (a 2 挨 āi HSK6 difficult period); to delay to love sth too much to part with it (idiom); 3 爱不释手 àibùshìshǒu HSK6 to fondle admiringly 4 爱戴 àidài to love and respect; love and respect HSK6 5 暧昧 àimèi vague; ambiguous; equivocal; dubious HSK6 hey; ow; ouch; interjection of pain or 6 哎哟 āiyō HSK6 surprise 7 癌症 áizhèng cancer HSK6 8 昂贵 ángguì expensive; costly HSK6 law case; legal case; judicial case; 9 案件 ànjiàn HSK6 CL:宗[zong1],樁|桩[zhuang1],起[qi3] 10 安居乐业 ānjūlèyè live in peace and work happily (idiom) HSK6 11 案例 ànlì case (law); CL:個|个[ge4] HSK6 12 按摩 ànmó massage HSK6 13 安宁 ānníng peaceful; tranquil; calm; composed HSK6 14 暗示 ànshì to hint; to suggest; suggestion; a hint HSK6 15 安详 ānxiáng serene HSK6 find a place for; help settle down; arrange 16 安置 ānzhì HSK6 for; to get into bed; placement (of cooking) to boil for a long time; to 17 熬 áo HSK6 endure; to suffer 18 奥秘 àomì profound; deep; a mystery HSK6 bumpy; uneven; slotted and tabbed joint; 19 凹凸 āotú HSK6 crenelation to hold on to; to cling to; to dig up; to rake; 20 扒 bā to push aside; to climb; to pull out; to strip HSK6 off 21 疤 bā scar HSK6 to be eager for; to long for; to look forward 22 巴不得 bābudé HSK6 to the Way of the Hegemon, abbr.
    [Show full text]
  • Notes on the Tunings We Microtonalists Inhabit a Very Different Musical Universe from That of Most "Normal" Musicians
    Notes on the Tunings We microtonalists inhabit a very different musical universe from that of most "normal" musicians. To a normal musician, the line between dissonance and consonance is clear-cut, and all of the chords in his/her musical vocabulary unambiguously fit into one category or another, as dictated by common practice music theory. But when we abandon the grid of 12-tone equal temperament, our ideas about consonance and dissonance become a lot more complex—we encounter chords that don't sound anything like those of the common practice, and thus don't obviously fit into either category. We are also forced to find new ways of organizing pitches, which lead to new forms of harmonic "functionality" that are quite unexplored. Since these new harmonic structures are so unlike those of the common practice, we might feel as though we are lost in a strange world, with neither map nor compass—save for our trusty ears, that is. To date, there exists nothing that I would call "microtonal music theory"—no one has yet written anything meant to guide composition in microtonal tuning systems. However, there is a great abundance, a plethora even, of what I'll call "tuning theory"—theory describing how to select tunings for the making of music. It is all based, to a greater or lesser degree, on the practice of Just intonation, which involves tuning intervals to exact simple-integer frequency ratios, for the purpose of producing harmony that is smooth, fused, and beatless. This sort of tuning theory has in many ways remained unchanged since the ancient Greeks, who discovered the "special" properties of simple-integer rational intervals by playing with string lengths on their monochords (and other instruments).
    [Show full text]
  • Scale Essentials for Bass Guitar Course Breakdown
    Scale Essentials For Bass Guitar Course Breakdown Volume 1: Scale Fundamentals Lesson 1-0 Introduction In this lesson we look ahead to the Scale Essentials course and the topics we’ll be covering in volume 1 Lesson 1-1 Scale Basics What scales are and how we use them in our music. This includes a look at everything from musical keys to melodies, bass lines and chords. Lesson 1-2 The Major Scale Let’s look at the most common scale in general use: The Major Scale. We’ll look at its construction and how to play it on the bass. Lesson 1-3 Scale Degrees & Intervals Intervals are the building blocks of music and the key to understanding everything that follows in this course Lesson 1-4 Abbreviated Scale Notation Describing scales in terms of complete intervals can be a little long-winded. In this lesson we look at a method for abbreviating the intervals within a scale. Lesson 1-5 Cycle Of Fourths The cycle of fourths is not only essential to understanding key signatures but is also a great system for practicing scales in every key Lesson 1-6 Technique Scales are a common resource for working on your bass technique. In this lesson we deep dive into both left and right hand technique Lesson 1-7 Keys & Tonality Let’s look at the theory behind keys, the tonal system and how scales fit into all of this Lesson 1-8 Triads Chords and chord tones will feature throughout this course so let’s take a look at the chord we use as our basic foundation: The Triad Lesson 1-9 Seventh Chords After working on triads, we can add another note into the mix and create a set of Seventh Chords Lesson 1-10 Chords Of The Major Key Now we understand the basics of chord construction we can generate a set of chords from our Major Scale.
    [Show full text]
  • Collective Difference: the Pan-American Association of Composers and Pan- American Ideology in Music, 1925-1945 Stephanie N
    Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2009 Collective Difference: The Pan-American Association of Composers and Pan- American Ideology in Music, 1925-1945 Stephanie N. Stallings Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MUSIC COLLECTIVE DIFFERENCE: THE PAN-AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF COMPOSERS AND PAN-AMERICAN IDEOLOGY IN MUSIC, 1925-1945 By STEPHANIE N. STALLINGS A Dissertation submitted to the College of Music in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Summer Semester, 2009 Copyright © 2009 Stephanie N. Stallings All Rights Reserved The members of the Committee approve the Dissertation of Stephanie N. Stallings defended on April 20, 2009. ______________________________ Denise Von Glahn Professor Directing Dissertation ______________________________ Evan Jones Outside Committee Member ______________________________ Charles Brewer Committee Member ______________________________ Douglass Seaton Committee Member The Graduate School has verified and approved the above named committee members. ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my warmest thanks to my dissertation advisor, Denise Von Glahn. Without her excellent guidance, steadfast moral support, thoughtfulness, and creativity, this dissertation never would have come to fruition. I am also grateful to the rest of my dissertation committee, Charles Brewer, Evan Jones, and Douglass Seaton, for their wisdom. Similarly, each member of the Musicology faculty at Florida State University has provided me with a different model for scholarly excellence in “capital M Musicology.” The FSU Society for Musicology has been a wonderful support system throughout my tenure at Florida State.
    [Show full text]
  • Tuning: at the Grcssroads
    WendyGarloo ?O. Box1024 Tuning:At the New YorkCit, New York 10276USA Grcssroads lntrodrciion planned the construction of instruments that per- formed within the new "tunitrg of choice," and all The arena o{ musical scales and tuning has cer_ publishedpapers or books demonstretingthe supe- tainly not been a quiet place to be for the past thlee dority of their new scales in at least some way over hundred yeals. But it might iust as well have beenif €qual temperament.The tradition has continued we iudge by the results: the same 12V2 equally with Yunik and Swi{t {1980),Blackwood (1982),and temperedscale established then as the best avail- the presentauthor (Milano 1986),and shows no able tuning compromise, by J. S. Bach and many sign of slowing down despite the apparent apathy otheis lHelrnholtz 1954j Apel 1972),remains to with which the musical mainstream has regularly this day essentially the only scale heard in Westem grceted eech new proposal. music. That monopoly crossesall musical styles, of course therc's a perf€ctly reasonable explana- {rom the most contemporary of jazz and av^rf,t' tion lor the mainstream's evident preferetrce to rc- "rut-bound" gardeclassical, and musical masteeieces from the main when by now there are at least past, to the latest technopop rock with fancy s)'n- a dozen clearly better-sounding ways to tune our thesizers,and everwvherein between.Instruments scales,i{ only for at least part of the time: it re' ol the symphonyorchestra a((empr with varyirrg quires a lot of effort ol several kinds. I'm typing this deSreesof successto live up ro lhe 100-centsemi manuscript using a Dvorak keyboard (lor the ffrst tone, even though many would find it inherently far time!), and I assureyou it's not easyto unlearn the easierto do otherwise: the stdngs to "lapse" into QWERTY habits of a lifetime, even though I can Pythagoieen tuning, the brass into several keys of akeady feel the actual superiodty of this unloved lust irtonation lBarbour 1953).And th€se easily but demonstrablv better kevboard.
    [Show full text]