Marital Satisfaction of Couples in Heterosexual Relationships Where There Are Differences in Spirituality
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MARITAL SATISFACTION OF COUPLES IN HETEROSEXUAL RELATIONSHIPS WHERE THERE ARE DIFFERENCES IN SPIRITUALITY A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of Antioch University New England In partial fulfillment for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY by Collins Ifeanyichukwu Anaeche ORCID Scholar No. 0000-0003-2497-6705 December 2020 MARITAL SATISFACTION OF COUPLES IN HETEROSEXUAL RELATIONSHIPS WHERE THERE ARE DIFFERENCES IN SPIRITUALITY This dissertation, by Collins Ifeanyichukwu Anaeche, has been approved by the committee members signed below who recommend that it be accepted by the faculty of Antioch University New England in partial fulfillment of requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Dissertation Committee: Denzel Jones, PhD, Chairperson Kevin Lynes, PhD Norja E. Cunningham, PhD Lucille Byno, PhD ii Copyright © 2020 by Collins I. Anaeche All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT MARITAL SATISFACTION OF COUPLES IN HETEROSEXUAL RELATIONSHIPS WHERE THERE ARE DIFFERENCES IN SPIRITUALITY Collins Ifeanyichukwu Anaeche Antioch University New England Keene, NH As the dynamics of the United States’ social landscape shifts in relation to the diversity of culture, ethnicity, values, and traditions, and as religion and spirituality have become highly diverse and fluid, diversity in spirituality has received limited attention in the field of marriage and family therapy. Utilizing an interpretative phenomenological analysis, this qualitative investigation explores common meanings and experiences of emotional intimacy of couples in heterosexual relationships where there are differences in spirituality. Overall, the results of this investigation demonstrate that in situations where heterosexual couples who display differences in spirituality attentively attuned to their individual and relational needs, their emotional intimacy satisfaction was enhanced; in situations where couples’ attentiveness to their spirituality and religious differences was undermined, their individual needs suffered, and their emotional intimacy was impeded. Furthermore, this study shows that it is not so much the differences in the contents of spiritual beliefs between spouses in married relationships that determine the direction of their emotional intimacy satisfaction but their shared or divergent values on spirituality. Clinical implications for therapists are provided alongside study limitations and recommendations for future research. This dissertation is available in open access at AURA, http://aura.antioch.edu/ and OhioLINK ETD Center, https://etd.ohiolink.edu Keywords: marital satisfaction, marital dissatisfaction, couples, heterosexual relationships, differences, spirituality, religion, religiosity, multidimensional systems, treatment, emotional intimacy, interpretative phenomenological analysis, IPA, qualitative research, shared values, respect, spouse, open communication, providing support, marital expectations, sharing, spiritual practice, connection, guides life, distant feeling, family of origin, multi-faith, married, attitude, therapy, relational attunement, gender dynamics, parenting, training, therapists, cumulative effects, marital experiences, intersectionality, self-of-the-therapist, couple dynamics. iv Dedication I would like to dedicate this dissertation to my late grandmother, Maryrose O. Anaeche. Grandma, though you did not live to see me become the first in the Anaeche family to obtain a doctorate degree, I trust you are celebrating the milestone with me and the family from heaven. Continue to rest in the eternal peace with God and keep watch over us. Your undying love continues to inspire us, and I will forever love you and cherish my memory of you. v Acknowledgements Without the support of so many, I would not have been able to complete this work. My highest thanks to Almighty God whose grace and presence sustains me and gives meaning and purpose in my life. My deep gratitude to my parents Simon E. Anaeche and Enderline N. Anaeche for their unyielding love and unflinching support all through my entire life. To my siblings; and in fact, all my natural family members, I thank you for the different ways, through which you encourage and inspire me. I am profoundly grateful to my dissertation chair Dr. Denzel L. Jones for his guidance and assistance throughout the research process. I would also like to express my gratitude to the other members of my committee: Dr. Kevin P. Lyness, Dr. Norja E. Cunningham, and Dr. Lucille H. Byno for their patience, understanding, and the feedback that they provided at various levels of this dissertation. I equally thank all my teachers and professors, both past and present, for the various ways in which they positively impacted my life and professional development. I specially thank Dr. William M. Boylin, whose great work with me as a clinical supervisor, during my masters training program at Central Connecticut State University, has positively influenced my approach to therapy. Thank you too, Professor Chimezie A. B. Osigweh for guiding and encouraging me to pursue my dream of earning doctoral degree in the field of psychology. Also, I would like to express my appreciation to all my friends who have supported me throughout the research process and my life in general. Thank you Rev. Dr. Emmanuel I. Ihemedu, and Rev. Dr. Paschal O. Ezeihuoma for your friendship and care. To Ebere Onwuama, Mr. David and Mrs. Lori Humbarger, Mr. Charles and Mrs. Judith Abaidoo, and all my numerous well-wishers and colleagues, I remain grateful for your love and support. vi Table of Contents List of Tables ................................................................................................................................. xi Chapter 1 - Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1 Chapter 2 – Literature Review ........................................................................................................ 3 Spirituality in Multidimensional Systems ................................................................................... 3 Spirituality and Religion ............................................................................................................. 5 Religion and Spirituality in the United States ......................................................................... 7 Religion and Spirituality in Treatment .................................................................................... 8 Marital Satisfaction ..................................................................................................................... 9 Emotional Intimacy and Marital Satisfaction ........................................................................ 10 Other Factors Linked to Marital Satisfaction and Dissatisfaction ......................................... 12 Religiosity and Spirituality vis-à-vis Marital Satisfaction ........................................................ 17 The Present Study...................................................................................................................... 18 Chapter 3 - Methodology .............................................................................................................. 20 Research Design ........................................................................................................................ 20 Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis ............................................................................ 21 Sampling Procedure and Recruitment ....................................................................................... 23 Data Collection Methods ........................................................................................................... 24 Interviews .............................................................................................................................. 25 vii Measures ................................................................................................................................ 26 Trustworthiness and Credibility ................................................................................................ 27 Role of the Researcher and Research Reflexivity ..................................................................... 27 Researcher Background and Biases .......................................................................................... 28 Chapter 4 - Results ........................................................................................................................ 31 Participants ................................................................................................................................ 31 IPA Data Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 33 Themes ...................................................................................................................................... 34 Continuing Commitment to Love Spouse in a Long-Term, Loving Marital Relationship ... 36 Intimacy through Sharing of Spiritual Practices of the Spouse ............................................. 53 Raising Children as a Multi-Faith Married Couple ............................................................... 69 Chapter 5 – Discussion ................................................................................................................. 73 Continuing Commitment to Love Spouse in a Long-term, Loving Marital Relationship .......