Local and Special Legislation in Missouri Under the Constitution of 1875 - Part I - Local and Special Legislation in Missouri Prior to Constitution of 1875
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Missouri Bulletin Law Series Volume 19 June 1920 Article 3 1920 Local and Special Legislation in Missouri under the Constitution of 1875 - Part I - Local and Special Legislation in Missouri Prior to Constitution of 1875 Roscoe E. Harper Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/ls Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, and the Legal History Commons Recommended Citation Roscoe E. Harper, Local and Special Legislation in Missouri under the Constitution of 1875 - Part I - Local and Special Legislation in Missouri Prior to Constitution of 1875, 19 Bulletin Law Series. (1920) Available at: https://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/ls/vol19/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at University of Missouri School of Law Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in University of Missouri Bulletin Law Series by an authorized editor of University of Missouri School of Law Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. LOCAL AND SPECIAL LEGISLATION IN MIS- SOURI UNDERTHE CONSTITUTION OF 1875 PART I. LOCAL AND SPECIAL LEGISLATION IN MISSOURI PRIOR TO CONSTITUTION OF 1875. Chapter I. Growth of Local and Special Legislation Under Constitution of 1820.* A. INTRODUCTION. A general or public law is an act of the legislature which lays down a universal rule affecting the entire state or relating to all the members of any given class in the state. A special law is an act which operates only upon designated members.of a class in the state, and does not affect all members of the class alike. If the members of the class thus selected out by the statute are private persons or private concerns it is called a private act. If the act singles one or more units of local government out of a general class of similar units, such as cities, townships, or coun- ties, without any reasonable basis of classification, or if it applies only to a designated locality, it is known as a local act.1 The Missouri Constitution of 18202 contained no limitations upon the power of the General Assembly to enact local and spe- cial laws. Neither was special or local legislation prohibited by .any of the other twenty-three state constitutions in operation in *This article was written by Roscoe E. Harper, who has received the degree of A. B. from the University of Missouri and is at this writing a candidate for the degrees of A. M. and LL. B. 1. For a more complete definition of general and special laws see Chapter IV, infra. 2. The Missouri Constitution of 1820 was drawn up by a constitu- tional convention assembled in St. Louis on June 12, 1820, and was .adopted by the same body on July 17 of the same year; and it was with this Constitution that Missouri was admitted into statehood August 10, 1821. For a treatise on this subject see Shoemaker, First Constitution of Missouri, and also Missouri's Struggle for Statehood, by the same author. LAW SERIES 19, MISSOURI BULLETIN 1820.3 At that time bills granting divorces, 4 relief from fines and penalties, special privileges, charters of incorporation, and local acts regulating the affairs of cities, counties and localities were frequently passed. This was recognized as a proper field for legislative activity. During the first decade of statehood, Missouri was composed of sparsely settled, agricultural communities.5 Her needs were simple and her interests few. The. common law adequately reg- ulated the ordinary affairs of those pioneer days; and the gener- al assemblies, without being overburdened, could easily satisfy all the demands for public, private, and local legislation.. So the evils of special and local legislation were not prominent and aroused little, if any, protest. The pioneer period had hardly ended when the new econom- ic, industrial, and social forces, stimulated by recent inventions, opened up highways of commerce, and started the development of the natural resources of the state.6 A more complex state life was being evolved which required more extensive regulation and more careful adjustment from time to time. Consequently 3. Missouri was the twenty-fourth state admitted into the Union. The constitutions in operation in the other states were adopted in the following years; Ala. 1819; Conn., 1818; Dela., 1792; Ga., 1798; Ill., 1818; Ind., 1816; Ky., 1799; La., 1812; Me., 1820; Md., 1776; Mass., 1780; N. H., 1792; Miss., 1817; N. J., 1776; N. Y., 1777; N. C., 1776; Ohio, 1802; Penn., 1790; R. I., 1663; S. C., 1790; Tenn., 1796; Vt., 1793; Va., 1776. Poore, Constitutions and Charters. 4. The Mississippi Constitution of 1817 required the legislature to pass on all divorces before they should be valid. "Divorces from the bonds of matrimony shall not be granted, but in cases provided for by law, by suits in chancery; provided that no decree for such divorce shall have effect until sanctioned by two-thirds of both branches of the General Assem- bly." . Section 17, Art. VI, Miss. Const. of 1817. The constitution of Alabama of 1819 had this same provision. 5. In 1820 Missouri had a population of 66,586, and was divided into ten counties. The population of St. Louis, the trading center for the vast territory lying west of the Mississippi, was only about 5,000. Viles, History of Missouri, pp. 108-119. Switzler, History of Missouri, pp. 285- 296. Ninth Census of the United States, Statistics of Population. 6. Turner, Rise of the New West (1819-1829) pp. 84-95, vol. 14 in the American Nation Series. Also vol. 16 of same series. Hart, Slavery and Abolition, pp. 33-48. Bogart, Economic History of the United States, pp. 170-185. Coman, Industrial History of United States, pp. 207, 231. Coman, Economic Beginnings of Far West, vol. II. LEGISLATION UNDER 1875 CONSTITUTION each succeeding decade had an increased output of laws bo'h public and private over the preceding decade.' Altho the number of public acts increased steadily and ap- parently in arithmetical progression the quantity of local and spe- cial legislation seemed to increase in geometrical progression. More numerous and more insistent became the interests desiring favors from the legislature. The result was that public matters before the General Assembly were smothered and obscured by a multitude of private and local acts. Opposition was aroused to such legislation which finally led to its abolition. A brief review of the character and quantity of legislation enacted by the succeeding general assemblies, operating under the Constitution of 1820, as recorded in the session acts, shows the growth of special and local legislation, and the necessity for its curtailment. B. SUCCESSIVE PERIODS OF LEGISLATIVE ACTIVITY. The time during which the Constitution of 1820, which con- tained no limitations on special and local legislation, was in oper- ation may be conveniently divided into five periods. These fiv%- periods and the quantity and kinds of legislation enacted during each are shown in the following tables: 7. An interesting review of the economic legislation of this period in the neighboring state of Iowa, which prior to 1820 was a part of Mis- souri Territory, is given in, Pollack, Ivan L., History of Economic Leg- islation in Iowa. LAW SERIES 19, MISSOURI BULLETIN LEGISLATION, PUBLIC AND LOCAL AND SPECIAL, 1820-18858 AV. No. of pages per Periods Quant. of Legis. Percent of Legis. aseby_(I~assembly (2 yrs.). Pub. pages Loc. Fri. Public Private Public ILoc.&Spec. pages I______ __ I_ _ _ 1. 1820-1831 (Ct. 368 ( 207 [ 64%9 36%' 60- 351 1820) st to 6 (275 pb. (140 spec. (No. of (No. of 34%) (46 acts) (23 acts) G. A. (Inc.) acts) & loc.acts) acts 66% acts 2. 1832-1843 -Ytb. 6250 10509 38% 62%9 1049 75 12th G. A. (600 pub. (1000 spec. (No; af (No. of (100 ac 17 acts 62%) ts) (178 acts) (Inc.) acts) &oc. acts) acts 38%) 3. 1844-1853 13th- 17th G. A. 663 2150 24% 76% 132 430 (Inc.) 4. 1854-1859 18th- 20th G. A. 540 3758 13% 87% 180 1252 (Inc.) 5. 1860-1865 21st- 23rd G. A. 462 1746 21% 79% 184 69810 (Inc.) 6. 1865-1875 (Ct. of 1865) 23rd- 1460 2000 42% 58% 324 44510 28th G. A. (Inc.) 7. 1875-1885 (Ct. of 1875) 29th- 1376 100% 275 33rd G. A. (Inc.) 8. It will be noted the number of acts and the number of pages in both of the first two periods have the same ratio and bear approximately the same per cent. Great difficulty was experienced in classification be- cause, quite frequently, the same act was both public and private. So the figures above are only an approximation but it is believed even should the error of classification be as much as 10%, the value of the deductions drawn from ihem are not materially impaired. • 9. Data on number of acts for given period. The acts were tabu- lated for first two periods only. 10. The first session of the 23rd General Assembly was held Dec. 26, 1864, under constitution of 1820; while the adjourned session of Nov. 1, 1865, was under the new constitution of 1865. For purposes of this chart one half of 23rd Assembly is classified in period 1860-1865, and one-half in period 1865-1875. LEGISLATION UNDER 1875 CONSTITUTION TABLE OF LOCAL AND SPECIAL LEGISLATION OF FIRST AND SECOND PERIODS 1820-1843 Total No. Local Relief from fines and Incorporation Period of Loc. &L penalties Spec. Acts% of Spec. No. of % of Spec. No. of % of Spec. No. of Leg. acts Leg. acts Leg.