Why Are We Looking at That? Mid-Century and Modern Architecture in South Carolina
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mid-Century and Modern Architecture in South Carolina South Carolina Department of Archives and History State Historic Preservation Office 8301 Parklane Road Columbia, South Carolina 29223-4905 http://scdah.sc.gov http://shpo.sc.gov Eric Emerson, Director, State Historic Preservation Officer Elizabeth M. Johnson, Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer Cover image: Robert J. Harte Law Building (late-1950s), Aiken, SC Mid-Century and Modern Architecture in South Carolina Contents Why Are We Looking at That? ............................................ 1 Civil Rights Resources ................................................. 11 Why We Are Looking at That .............................................. 1 Characteristics .......................................................... 12 What Is Modern? ................................................................ 3 Cold War, Military and Nuclear Energy What to Look for – Resource Types .................................. 4 Facilities ....................................................................... 12 Corporate, Commercial and Industrial Characteristics .......................................................... 13 Buildings ......................................................................... 4 Residential .................................................................. 13 Characteristics ............................................................. 5 Characteristics .......................................................... 15 Schools and Universities, Churches and Modern Vernacular Architecture ................................. 16 Civic Buildings ................................................................. 5 Characteristics .......................................................... 16 Characteristics ............................................................. 8 Don’t Be Fooled ............................................................... 16 Recreation and Tourism-related New Material World ......................................................... 17 Resources ....................................................................... 8 Methodology: Assessing a Modern Characteristics ............................................................. 9 Resource ......................................................................... 18 Transportation: Passenger Terminals; Conclusions ..................................................................... 19 Bridges; Parkways and Scenic Byways; Acknowledgements .......................................................... 20 Interstate Highways ........................................................ 9 Endnotes .......................................................................... 21 Characteristics .......................................................... 10 Selected Bibliography and Websites ............................... 22 Signs and Signage Structures ..................................... 11 Characteristics .......................................................... 11 Page 3 Page i Page ii Why Are We Mid-Century and Modern Architecture in South Carolina Why Are We Looking at That? I remember when that was built. You wouldn’t believe the How can you possibly consider that to be an historic wonderful historic building they tore down to build that. We structure? I just don’t understand what is so important should tear that down and put a public park on the site. about that building. Why We Are Looking at That History tells a story. Architecture, planned landscapes, art, “To be considered eligible, (for National Register listing) a fashion, music, and archaeology all contribute to that story. property must meet the National Register Criteria for Preserving, or at least documenting these resources, helps Evaluation. This involves examining the property’s age, tell the story and helps us recall and understand history, integrity, and significance. ourselves, and where we may be heading. § Age and Integrity. Is the property old enough to be In general, we recognize the considered historic (generally at value of preserving or least 50 years old) and does it rehabilitating “historic still look much the way it did in resources,” and recognizing the past? them with local historic § Significance. Is the property designation, or listing in the associated with events, National Register of Historic Several drycleaners with saw-toothed awnings, such as activities, or developments that Places. this one in West Columbia, SC, were built in the Midlands during the 1960s and 1970s. were important in the past? With Looking at That? Page 1 the lives of people who were important in the past? Vietnam, the Civil Rights Movement, walking on the moon, With significant architectural history, landscape history, Elvis and the Beatles, disco, the rise of the mini skirt, and engineering achievements? Does it have the potential the fall of segregation. to yield information through archeological investigation Ironically, many Mid-Century and post World War II projects about our past?” 1 involved demolition of historically significant resources. The Resources that meet the first eligibility criteria of “Age” and fight against urban blight and the popularity of urban are now approximately 50 years old may be categorized as renewal projects in the 1950s and 1960s often conflicted “Mid-Century” buildings or resources. Perhaps they fall into with historic preservation interests. Now, those Mid-Century the designation of “Modern Architecture,” or are part of the urban renewal projects and post-war resources are “Modern Movement.” They may also be referred to as historically significant. Many are now facing demolition to elements of our “recent make way for the current past.” If they meet the latest and greatest act of requirements of integrity progress. Some might think and significance, the that is poetic justice. resources may warrant Some resources have taken listing in the National on significance for their Register. association with social Although many of us have issues and changes in the grown up with these United States and in South Carolina. Acknowledging buildings and other cultural resources, they may now the presence of these social also deserve our issues may be unpleasant, consideration as historic but they are part of our resources. The mid- history and heritage and twentieth century was a associated resources period of tremendous Poole Agricultural Center – P&AS Building (1955) Clemson should be preserved. University, Clemson, SC. growth and technological Aesop taught us that development. Much of the “familiarity breeds growth and many of the technological advancements were contempt.” One aspect that makes Modern Architecture directly and indirectly related to World War II. Mid-Century unique is that many of us can remember when specific technological advances had a strong impact on the resources were constructed – and what was torn down to architecture of the period. make room – unlike older resources that were contemporary Social changes during the 1940s, 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s to previous generations. We have to get past our familiarity also had a big impact on built resources. These decades with these resources and consider how they may be § Laurel St. (1958), Columbia, SC. included World War II, post-war prosperity, the baby boom, significant. § Devine St. (mid-late 1950s), Columbia, the Korean Conflict, the ‘summer of love,’ the War in SC. Note the similarities with the cover photograph. § Millwood Ave. (1954), Columbia, SC. Page 2 Why Are We What Is Modern? Terms referring to architecture from the 1950s through the and perhaps are a natural growth from the developments of 1970s are still in flux. It may take time for terms to become the Industrial Revolution. accepted within the architecture and The Modern Movement is preservation communities and new characterized by an abundance of terms reflecting stylistic elements large expanses of glass. Structural are likely to become the norm. In elements, such as steel columns, the past, stylistic designations have beams and trusses, were become associated with particular expressed architecturally rather time periods. Modern Architecture than being enclosed in other will likely become an umbrella term, finishes. Architectural and much like “Victorian Architecture” engineering innovations were (mid- to late-19th century), which celebrated. Poured-in-place can be further broken down into 3135 Millwood Drive, Columbia, SC. concrete became architecturally styles such as Queen Anne, Italianate, Romanesque, etc. fashionable. Marble and granite were relegated to finishes As early as the 1950s, the earliest examples of “Postmodern as veneers without molding or ornament, rather than carved Architecture” were constructed. By the 1970s Post- into columns, entablatures, or moldings. modernism had become a full-fledged movement, first in the Some Terms United States, and then in Europe. Postmodern architecture returns to the historical embellishments and Mid-Century – refers to the mid-twentieth century, from ornamentation found in earlier architectural styles with approximately the late 1940s to late 1950s or early 1960s. detailing such as molded cornices, pediments, columns with Modern Architecture – Modern with a capital ‘M’ is often bases and capitals, etc. 2 distinguished from modern with a lower case ‘m.’ Modern According to Vincent Scully, Jr.: Architecture (capital M) is typically associated with styles supposedly having no historical antecedent or style that is a “Modern architecture