DOCSLIB.ORG

A Bioethical Paradigm for Enhanced, Post Or Transhumans in Medicine and Biological Research

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Bioethical Paradigm for Enhanced, Post Or Transhumans in Medicine and Biological Research Duquesne University Duquesne Scholarship Collection Electronic Theses and Dissertations Summer 8-8-2020 A Bioethical Paradigm for Enhanced, Post or Transhumans in Medicine and Biological Research Roderick Williams Follow this and additional works at: https://dsc.duq.edu/etd Part of the Bioethics and Medical Ethics Commons, and the Medical Humanities Commons Recommended Citation Williams, R. (2020). A Bioethical Paradigm for Enhanced, Post or Transhumans in Medicine and Biological Research (Doctoral dissertation, Duquesne University). Retrieved from https://dsc.duq.edu/etd/1923 This One-year Embargo is brought to you for free and open access by Duquesne Scholarship Collection. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Duquesne Scholarship Collection. A BIOETHICAL PARADIGM FOR ENHANCED, POST OR TRANSHUMANS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH A Dissertation Submitted to the McAnulty College and Graduate School of Liberal Arts Duquesne University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Roderick K. Williams August 2020 Copyright by Roderick K. Williams 2020 A BIOETHICAL PARADIGM FOR ENHANCED, POST OR TRANSHUMANS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH By Roderick K. Williams Approved May 07, 2020 ________________________ ________________________ Joris Gielen, PhD Gerard Magill, PhD Director, Center for Healthcare Ethics Vernon F. Gallagher Chair for Associate Professor Healthcare Ethics Integration of Science, Theology, (Dissertation Chair) Philosophy and Law Professor of Healthcare Ethics (Committee Member) ________________________ _____________________ Joris Gielen, PhD Peter Osuji, PhD Associate Professor Assistant Professor Center for Healthcare Ethics Healthcare Ethics (Committee Member) (Committee Member) Kristine Blair, PhD Dean, McAnulty College and Graduate School of Liberal Arts Professor and Dean of McAnulty College (Dean) iii ABSTRACT A BIOETHICAL PARADIGM FOR ENHANCED, POST OR TRANSHUMANS IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH By Roderick K. Williams August 2020 Dissertation supervised by Joris Gielen In this dissertation the question addressed is the ethical protocol that should be used when enhanced, post or transhumans present themselves as patients to hospitals, or as subjects for scientific research. With the advent of the birth of four children who were genetically engineered in China to be resistant to HIV, I contend that transhumans are already here, and the prevailing Western paradigm of principlism, while good, is not adequate to the task. I explore the basic religious argument that can be used against or in favor of what I call human-directed human evolution. I show how the fears of new kinds of persons are can be traced not just to myth, but also to the genre of science fiction. I start with Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein or The Modern Prometheus, through Star-Trek’s Borg Queen, and forward to BBC America’s “Orphan Black”. The argument for moral enhancement, a concept for which Julian Savulescu argues, is examined as is Nick Bostrom’s explication of superintelligence, and his joining Savulescu’s call for an enhancement of moral values. Several technologies currently in use for genetic testing, and that iv can be used for genetic engineering will be explained. These include preimplantation genetic diagnosis and mitochondrial replacement techniques (MRT), which are used to avoid birth defects in potential offspring. CRISPR-Cas9, TALENs, cloning and haploid stem cells are the technologies that not only can be used to develop specific treatment mechanisms, but they are the mechanisms that will allow humankind to engineer new kinds of persons, thus creating transhumans. From here I address the two prevailing sides of how to proceed: precaution where we move slowly trying to ascertain and prepare for any negative eventuality, and proaction where we move directly ahead after we have done all we can to prepare but opt to adjust along the way as the need arises. The ethical argument I make for the protocol that I think must be adopted does not just come from an examination of principlism. I also incorporate concepts from Buddhism, Confucianism, Islam, Hinduism and African philosophy. I posit that two other principles are needed: Particularity and Intrinsic Personhood. v TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 1 1.1 Ethical Responsibility 2 1.1.1 Autonomy 3 1.1.2 Consent 4 1.2 Human Enhancement 6 1.2.1 Bostrom’s Superintelligence 6 1.2.2 Savulescu on Moral Enhancement 8 1.3. Transhumanism 10 1.3.1 Precautionary Principle 11 1.3.2 Proactionary Imperative 13 1.4. Designing Progeny 15 1.4.1 PGD, mtDNA 15 1.4.2 Cloning, CRISPR-Cas9, Directed Evolution 17 1.5. The Case of Alassane Case 20 1.6 Narrative of Subsequent Chapters 22 Chapter 2. The Feminine and The Other: An Introduction to Transhumanism Through Science Fiction 39 Introduction 39 2.1 Frankenstein 42 2.1.1 His Monster as Criminal and His Role in IVF Debate 43 2.1.2 His Monster as Other, and Human Rights 46 2.2 The Borg Queen 48 2.2.1The Borg Queen: Other Goddesses in Otherworlds 48 2.3. Cloning (Using “Orphan Black”) 53 2.3.1 Orphan Black and The Patenting of People 54 2.3.2 What is the Definition of Human? 56 2.4. Ethical Considerations Posed by the Subjects 57 2.4.1 Personhood 58 vi 2.4.2 Critical Race Ethics as a Template for Otherness 60 2.5. Fuller and Lipinska: The Proactionary Manifesto 63 Conclusion 66 Chapter 3: The Ethical Justification of Transhumanism 68 Introduction 68 3.1 Introduction to the History of Transhumanism 69 3.1.114th through 19th Century 69 3.1.2 20th Century 71 3.2 The Philosophical Basis for Transhumanism in Fuller and Lipinska’s Proactionary Imperative 74 3.2.1 Proaction and Precaution: The Basic Concepts 74 3.2.2 The Proactionary Imperative Considered in Light of Indebtedness and the Commonweal 76 3.3 Genetics Technology 78 3.3.1 CRISPR Cas-9 78 3.3.2 TALENS 80 3.3.3 Cloning with Emphasis on the 2013 Breakthrough 80 3.3.4 Haploid Stem Cells 82 3.4 Ethical Arguments for Caution (the precautionary principle) 83 3.4.1 Question 1: Is Humankind the Epitome of Creation 84 3.4.2 Question 2: Are we playing God? 87 3.5 Discovering What Is: An Experimental City 90 Conclusion 93 Chapter 4: Superintelligence and Moral Enhancement: Bostrom And Savulecsu and the Development of an Ethical Basis for Natural and Posthuman Interaction 95 Introduction 95 4.1. Superintelligence (Bostrom) 96 4.1.1 AI to Superintelligence Defined and Explained 97 4.1.2 Whole Brain Emulation, Biological Cognition, Brain-Computer Interface 99 vii 4.1.3 Cognitive Superpowers 102 4.2. Bostrom Interrogated 103 4.2.1 Becoming Posthuman:An Alternative Superintelligence in the Individual 104 4.2.2 Enhancements: Benefits and Tradeoffs 105 4.3. Savulescu: The Need for Moral Enhancement 108 4.3.1Common-Sense Morality, Ego and Biases Toward Our Own 108 4.3.2 The Liberal Democracy and Rights 112 4.3.3 Ultimate Harm and Destruction of The Commons 114 4.3.4 Why Moral Enhancement is Necessary, Applying the Moral Enhancement to Interaction with Post-Humans 118 Conclusion 120 Chapter 5: The Ethics of Genomics Regarding the Possibility of Designing Babies Introduction 122 5.1 Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis 123 5.1.1 PGD: The Science and Technology 123 5.1.2 Ethical Issues and PGD 126 5.2 Mitochondrial (mtDNA) Disease and Replacement Therapies 128 5.2.1 The Charlie Gard Case 128 5.2.2 Mitochondrial Disease (mtDNA) and Mitochondrial Replacement Techniques (MRT) 129 5.2.3 Ethical Considerations of Mitochondrial Replacement Techniques 131 5.3 Intentional Genetic Modification and CRISPR Technology 133 5.3.1 After PGD and MRT, CRISPR-Cas9 133 5.3.2 CRISPR-Cas9 Experimentation 135 5.4. Cloning 138 5.4.1 Cloning: History and Process 138 5.4.2Transgenic Experimentation and Development 140 5.5 Human Directed Human Evolution (Transhumanism) 142 5.5.1 An Overarching Scenario 143 viii 5.5.2 Transhumanism Definition and Discussion 144 5.5.3 Is China Moving Forward? 145 Conclusion 146 Chapter 6: An Ethical Analysis of Beneficence and Non-maleficence to Guide Emerging Medical Technology 148 Introduction 148 6.1. Non-maleficence and Beneficence: Principlism Concepts, UNESCO’s UDBHR 149 6.1.1 Nonmaleficence 150 6.1.2 Beneficence 152 6.1.3 Benefit and Harm: Article 4 of UNESCO’s UDBHR 152 6.2. Immunological Medicine, Genomic-Based Medicine and Reproductive Technology an Overview with Examples 154 6.2.1 Immunological Medicine 154 6.2.2 Genetics-Based Medicine 157 6.2.3 Reproductive Technology 159 6.3. A Discussion of the Precautionary Principle 161 6.4. Non-Western Ethical Concepts Related to Beneficence and Nonmaleficence 165 6.4.1 Ahimsa as applied to the unborn: assessing their value (Hindu/Buddhist) 165 6.4.2 The concept of Ren: Confucian Virtue Ethics Applied to Reproductive Technology 167 6.4.3 Ubuntu: Reproductive technology as a benefit to the community 170 Conclusion 175 Chapter 7: An Ethical Analysis of Justice to Avoid Exploitation of and Discrimination Against Vulnerable Populations 177 Introduction 177 7.1 Vulnerability 179 7.1.1 Definition and Dimensions 179 7.1.2 Respect for Vulnerability…: Article 8 UNESCO’s UDBHR 183 7.2. Principlism: Concept of Justice and Vulnerability 187 ix 7.2.1An Explication of Justice 188 7.2.2 Justice for the Vulnerable: Its Application to Posthumans 191 7.3. Justice and Civil Rights 195 7.3.1 Envy and The Question of Exploitation 195 7.3.2 Ensuring Justice with Health Care Policy 197 Conclusion 200 Chapter 8: The Principle of Particularity 202 Introduction 202 8.1.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 1 COPYRIGHT STATEMENT This Copy of the Thesis Has Been
    University of Plymouth PEARL https://pearl.plymouth.ac.uk 04 University of Plymouth Research Theses 01 Research Theses Main Collection 2012 Life Expansion: Toward an Artistic, Design-Based Theory of the Transhuman / Posthuman Vita-More, Natasha http://hdl.handle.net/10026.1/1182 University of Plymouth All content in PEARL is protected by copyright law. Author manuscripts are made available in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite only the published version using the details provided on the item record or document. In the absence of an open licence (e.g. Creative Commons), permissions for further reuse of content should be sought from the publisher or author. COPYRIGHT STATEMENT This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognize that its copyright rests with its author and that no quotation from the thesis and no information derived from it may be published without the author’s prior consent. 1 Life Expansion: Toward an Artistic, Design-Based Theory of the Transhuman / Posthuman by NATASHA VITA-MORE A thesis submitted to the University of Plymouth in partial fulfillment for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY School of Art & Media Faculty of Arts April 2012 2 Natasha Vita-More Life Expansion: Toward an Artistic, Design-Based Theory of the Transhuman / Posthuman The thesis’ study of life expansion proposes a framework for artistic, design-based approaches concerned with prolonging human life and sustaining personal identity. To delineate the topic: life expansion means increasing the length of time a person is alive and diversifying the matter in which a person exists.
    [Show full text]
  • Humana.Mente Complete Issue 26.Pdf
    EDITORIAL MANAGER: DUCCIO MANETTI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE Editorial EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR: SILVANO ZIPOLI CAIANI - UNIVERSITY OF MILAN VICE DIRECTOR: MARCO FENICI - UNIVERSITY OF SIENA Board INTERNATIONAL EDITORIAL BOARD JOHN BELL - UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN ONTARIO GIOVANNI BONIOLO - INSTITUTE OF MOLECULAR ONCOLOGY FOUNDATION MARIA LUISA DALLA CHIARA - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE DIMITRI D'ANDREA - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE BERNARDINO FANTINI - UNIVERSITÉ DE GENÈVE LUCIANO FLORIDI - UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD MASSIMO INGUSCIO - EUROPEAN LABORATORY FOR NON-LINEAR SPECTROSCOPY GEORGE LAKOFF - UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY PAOLO PARRINI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE ALBERTO PERUZZI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE JEAN PETITOT - CREA, CENTRE DE RECHERCHE EN ÉPISTÉMOLOGIE APPLIQUÉE CORRADO SINIGAGLIA - UNIVERSITY OF MILAN BAS C. VAN FRAASSEN - SAN FRANCISCO STATE UNIVERSITY CONSULTING EDITORS CARLO GABBANI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE ROBERTA LANFREDINI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE MARCO SALUCCI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE ELENA ACUTI - UNIVERSITY OF FLORENCE MATTEO BORRI - UNIVERSITÉ DE GENÈVE ROBERTO CIUNI - UNIVERSITY OF DELFT Editorial SCILLA BELLUCCI, LAURA BERITELLI, RICCARDO FURI, ALICE GIULIANI, STEFANO LICCIOLI, UMBERTO MAIONCHI Staff HUMANA.MENTE - QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION Fiorella Battaglia, Antonio Carnevale Epistemological and Moral Problems with Human Enhancement III PAPERS Volker Gerhardt Technology as a Medium of Ethics and Culture 1 Nikil Mukerji, Julian Nida-Rümelin Towards a Moderate Stance on Human Enhancement 17 Christopher
    [Show full text]
  • 149-Page PDF Version
    By Bradford Hatcher © 2019 Bradford Hatcher ISBN: 978-0-9824191-8-2 Download at: https://www.hermetica.info/Intervention.html or: https://www.hermetica.info/Intervention.pdf Cover Photo Credit: Found online. Appears to be a conception of an evolved Terran reptilian life form. Table of Contents Part One 5 Preface 5 Puppet Shows 7 Waldo Speaking, Part 1 11 Waldo Speaking, Part 2 17 Wilma Speaks of Spirit 24 The Eck 30 Gizmos and the Van 34 Growing Up Van 42 Some Changes are Made 49 Culling Homo Non Grata 56 Introducing the Ta 63 Terrestrial and Aquatic Ta 67 Vestan, Myco, and Raptor Ta 72 Part Two 78 Progress Report at I+20 78 Desert Colonies 80 The Final Frontier, For Now 85 The Stellar Fleet 89 Remembering Community 94 Prototypes and Lexicons 99 For the Kids 104 Cultural Evolution 112 Cultural Engineering 119 Bioengineering 124 The Commons 128 The Tour 132 Mitakuye Oyasin 137 A Partial Glossary 147 Part One It gives one a feeling of confidence to see nature still busy with experiments, still dynamic, and not through nor satisfied because a Devonian fish managed to end as a two-legged character with a straw hat. There are other things brewing and growing in the oceanic vat. It pays to know this. It pays to know that there is just as much future as there is past. The only thing that doesn't pay is to be sure of man's own part in it. There are things down there still coming ashore. Never make the mistake of thinking life is now adjusted for eternity.
    [Show full text]
  • Robert Walser, Paul Scheerbart, and Joseph Roth Vi
    Telling Technology Contesting Narratives of Progress in Modernist Literature: Robert Walser, Paul Scheerbart, and Joseph Roth Vincent Hessling Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2018 © 2018 Vincent Hessling All rights reserved ABSTRACT Telling Technology Contesting Narratives of Progress in Modernist Literature: Robert Walser, Paul Scheerbart, and Joseph Roth Vincent Hessling Telling technology explores how modernist literature makes sense of technological change by means of narration. The dissertation consists of three case studies focusing on narrative texts by Robert Walser, Paul Scheerbart, and Joseph Roth. These authors write at a time when a crisis of ‘progress,’ understood as a basic concept of history, coincides with a crisis of narra- tion in the form of anthropocentric, action-based storytelling. Through close readings of their technographic writing, the case studies investigate how the three authors develop alter- native forms of narration so as to tackle the questions posed by the sweeping technological change in their day. Along with a deeper understanding of the individual literary texts, the dissertation establishes a theoretical framework to discuss questions of modern technology and agency through the lens of narrative theory. Table of Contents ABBREVIATIONS ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS iii INTRODUCTION: Toward a Narratology of Technological Change 1 CHAPTER I: Robert Walser’s Der Gehülfe: A Zero-Grade Narrative of Progress 26 1. The Employee as a Modern Topos 26 2. The Master and the Servant: A Farce on Progress 41 3. Irony of ‘Kaleidoscopic Focalization’ 50 4. The Inventions and their Distribution 55 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Autonomia Jednostki W Międzynarodowym Prawie
    Agata Wnukiewicz-Kozłowska Wybór tematu recenzowanej monografii należy uznać za wyjątkowo trafny. Aktualność i doniosłość poznawcza podjętej problematyki, a tak- że, co ważne, również jej wartość praktyczna, nie budzą wątpliwości. Syn- tetyczny tytuł pracy jest w pełni adekwatny, dobrze oddaje jej zawartość Agata Wnukiewicz-Kozłowska i główną ideę. [...] Całość rozważań zawartych w monografii koncentruje się na uzasad- nieniu jej głównej tezy o wykształceniu się nowego rodzaju prawa, wywo- Autonomia jednostki w międzynarodowym prawie biomedycznym dzącego się z prawa międzynarodowego publicznego oraz uwzględniają- cego klasyczny kanon praw i wolności jednostki, ale charakteryzującego się istotną odrębnością przedmiotową i specyfiką podmiotową. [...] za- prezentowane w pracy bardzo szerokie uzasadnienie głównej tezy jest wyjątkowo solidne, wszechstronne i przekonywające. Zostało ono oparte Autonomia na imponującym pod względem wielkości i różnorodności materiale ze- branym i wykorzystanym przez Autorkę w toku badań. [...] poza bardzo jednostki licznymi źródłami prawa w ścisłym tego słowa znaczeniu (traktaty, akty w prawa UE, ustawy i inne akty normatywne) w pracy wykorzystano boga- te orzecznictwo sądów międzynarodowych i krajowych, różnego rodzaju międzynarodowym dokumenty, wyniki badań empirycznych, a nawet materiały publicystycz- ne. Autorka dostrzegła i uwzględniła rosnącą, choć ciągle jeszcze niedo- prawie określoną rolę soft law. To bogactwo materiału wykorzystanego w pracy biomedycznym jest jej niewątpliwą zaletą. z recenzji wydawniczej
    [Show full text]
  • 2016-2017 Report
    The Society of Fellows in the Humanities Annual Report 2016–2017 Society of Fellows Mail Code 5700 Columbia University 2960 Broadway New York, NY 10027 Phone: (212) 854-8443 Fax: (212) 662-7289 [email protected] www.societyoffellows.columbia.edu By FedEx or UPS: Society of Fellows 74 Morningside Drive Heyman Center, First Floor East Campus Residential Center Columbia University New York, NY 10027 Posters courtesy of designers Amelia Saul and Sean Boggs 2 Contents Report From The Chair 5 Special Events 31 Members of the 2016–2017 Governing Board 8 Heyman Center Events 35 • Event Highlights 36 Forty-Second Annual Fellowship Competition 9 • Public Humanities Initiative 47 Fellows in Residence 2016–2017 11 • Heyman Center Series and Workshops 50 • Benjamin Breen 12 Nietzsche 13/13 Seminar 50 • Christopher M. Florio 13 New Books in the Arts & Sciences 50 • David Gutkin 14 New Books in the Society of Fellows 54 • Heidi Hausse 15 The Program in World Philology 56 • Arden Hegele 16 • Full List of Heyman Center Events • Whitney Laemmli 17 2016–2017 57 • Max Mishler 18 • María González Pendás 19 Heyman Center Fellows 2016–2017 65 • Carmel Raz 20 Alumni Fellows News 71 Thursday Lectures Series 21 Alumni Fellows Directory 74 • Fall 2016: Fellows’ Talks 23 • Spring 2017: Shock and Reverberation 26 2016–2017 Fellows at the annual year-end Spring gathering (from left): María González Pendás (2016–2019), Arden Hegele (2016–2019), David Gutkin (2015–2017), Whitney Laemmli (2016–2019), Christopher Florio (2016–2019) Heidi Hausse (2016–2018), Max Mishler (2016–2017), and Carmel Raz (2015–2018).
    [Show full text]
  • Graduate Studies Program
    GRADUATE STUDIES PROGRAM Welcome It is our pleasure to welcome you to Singularity University. Our mission is to assemble, educate and inspire leaders who strive to understand and facilitate the development of exponentially advancing technologies in order to address humanity’s grand challenges. Singularity University’s Graduate Studies Program brings together a diverse group–the most accomplished experts in academics, business, and government together with the brightest students from across the globe–for an intense ten-week summer program. The program immerses participants in an unparalleled convergence learning environment. We also challenge our students with our 109+ Team Projects, asking them how they can positively affect the lives of a billion people within 10 years. The next few decades will see the transformation of the science and technology tools available to the world in a fashion more profound than any other time in our history. The current technology revolution moves at an exponential pace, and exponential technologies imply a future with capabilities previously unimagined. Singularity University was founded using the standpoint that with more capability comes more responsibility. Our commitment is to not only to teach, but also to act: to view the world’s Grand Challenges as opportunities to use advancing technology for the benefit of all. If you are interested in the world’s grand challenges, if you are an entrepreneur passionate about making your dreams materialize, and if you are at the top of your class then we hope you will consider applying to the Graduate Studies Program. If you are invited to participate in this highly selective program, you will experience a life-changing 10-week program and join an incredible community of thinkers and doers.
    [Show full text]
  • Top 10 Strategic Technology Trends for 2020
    Top 10 Strategic Technology Trends for 2020 Published: 21 October 2019 ID: G00432920 Analyst(s): David Cearley, Nick Jones, David Smith, Brian Burke, Arun Chandrasekaran, CK Lu Strategic technology trends have the potential both to create opportunity and to drive significant disruption. Enterprise architecture and technology innovation leaders must evaluate these top trends to determine how combinations of trends can power their innovation strategies. Key Findings ■ Strategic technology trends have significant potential to create and respond to disruption and to power both transformation and optimization initiatives. ■ Artificial intelligence (AI) is a foundational catalyst for advanced process automation and human augmentation and engagement. ■ Physical environments including factories, offices and cities will become “smart spaces” within which people will interact through multiple touchpoints and sensory channels for an increasingly ambient experience. ■ Dealing with privacy, digital ethics and security challenges generated by AI, the Internet of Things (IoT)/edge, and other evolving technologies will become critical to maintain trust and avoid legal entanglements. Recommendations Enterprise architecture and technology innovation leaders must: ■ Center their innovation efforts on people and use tools such as personas, journey maps, technology radars, and roadmaps to evaluate opportunities, challenges and time frames for adoption. ■ Build an overarching view across functional and process silos and exploit a complementary set of tools including RPA, iBPMS, DTO, application development, and AI domains that guide how the tools are used and the systems they create are integrated. ■ Embrace multiexperience and implement development platforms and design principles to support conversational, immersive and increasingly ambient experiences. ■ Establish governance principles, policies, best practices and technology architectures to increase transparency and trust regarding data and the use of AI.
    [Show full text]
  • Where's My Jet Pack?
    Where's My Jet Pack? Online Communication Practices and Media Frames of the Emergent Voluntary Cyborg Subculture By Tamara Banbury A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts In Legal Studies Faculty of Public Affairs Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario ©2019 Tamara Banbury Abstract Voluntary cyborgs embed technology into their bodies for purposes of enhancement or augmentation. These voluntary cyborgs gather in online forums and are negotiating the elements of subculture formation with varying degrees of success. The voluntary cyborg community is unusual in subculture studies due to the desire for mainstream acceptance and widespread adoption of their practices. How voluntary cyborg practices are framed in media articles can affect how cyborgian practices are viewed and ultimately, accepted or denied by those outside the voluntary cyborg subculture. Key Words: cyborg, subculture, implants, community, technology, subdermal, chips, media frames, online forums, voluntary ii Acknowledgements The process of researching and writing a thesis is not a solo endeavour, no matter how much it may feel that way at times. This thesis is no exception and if it weren’t for the advice, feedback, and support from a number of people, this thesis would still just be a dream and not a reality. I want to acknowledge the institutions and the people at those institutions who have helped fund my research over the last year — I was honoured to receive one of the coveted Joseph-Armand Bombardier Canada Graduate Scholarships for master’s students from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.
    [Show full text]
  • How Science Fiction Grapples with the Growing Power of Artificial Intelligence
    DePaul University Via Sapientiae College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences 3-2016 Artificial perspectives: how science fiction grapples with the growing power of artificial intelligence Marcus Emanuel DePaul University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/etd Recommended Citation Emanuel, Marcus, "Artificial perspectives: how science fiction grapples with the growing power of artificial intelligence" (2016). College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations. 207. https://via.library.depaul.edu/etd/207 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences at Via Sapientiae. It has been accepted for inclusion in College of Liberal Arts & Social Sciences Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Via Sapientiae. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Artificial Perspectives: How Science Fiction Grapples with the Growing Power of Artificial Intelligence A Thesis Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts March, 2016 By Marcus Emanuel Department of English College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences DePaul University Chicago, Illinois 1 Introduction In Stanley Kubrick’s 1968 film 2001: A Space Odyssey, based on the stories of Arthur C. Clarke, astronaut David Bowman, aboard the spacecraft Discovery One, struggles to shut down HAL, an artificial intelligence responsible for operating the ship. The HAL computer system has been killing astronauts one by one in an attempt to preserve its functioning and programmed mission. Bowman, in an orange spacesuit, floats into what we assume is HAL’s mainframe, armed with a variation on a ratchet key, in an attempt to power down the computer and its deadly intelligence.
    [Show full text]
  • To See the Full Programme for the Battle of Ideas 2017
    CONTENTS The Battle of Ideas is an annual festival which 2 Ticket prices and festival information 3 Why the Battle of Ideas? brings together 400-plus speakers for over 3 Registration times 100 debates over the course of the weekend, and through stand-alone satellite events held SATURDAY from September to November throughout the 4 Welcome Address UK and Europe. You can find out more about 4 Saturday Keynote Controversies 6 The Politics of the Personal these satellite events on pages 52–59. 8 Intellectual Life 10 Understanding America This brochure will help you plan and navigate your visit to 12 The New Political Landscape the festival weekend. The debates are organised by room 14 Battle for the Economy or by themed topic areas we call ‘strands’. For example, the 16 Culture Wars ‘Science and Ethics’ strand covers contemporary issues in 18 City Life medicine, genetics and space exploration. The festival is 20 Contemporary Controversies organised so that you can follow one strand throughout the day, or pick and choose debates from different strands on WEEKEND ATTRACTIONS topics that interest you. 22 Battle Specials Whatever you decide to do, with such a wide range of 23 Book Club Salons debates and discussion, we are sure there will be plenty for 24 Lunchtime Shorts everyone to think about. 25 Festival Attractions and Entertainment ESSENTIAL INFORMATION 28 Battlefields: Barbican maps 30 Saturday Timetable 31 Sunday Timetable SUNDAY 32 Sunday Keynote Controversies 34 Eye on the World 36 Debating the Past 38 Law and Order 40 Tech Futures 42 Crisis of Political Language 44 Battle for Education 46 Contemporary Controversies 48 State of the Nation 50 Science and Ethics SATELLITES 52 UK Satellite Events 56 Battle of Ideas Europe 60 Thanks BATTLEOFIDEAS.ORG.UK 1 BOI Brochure 2017 1.7.indd 1 12/10/2017 18:56 BATTLE OF IDEAS TICKETING INFORMATION The Battle of Ideas takes place at the Barbican, London, on Saturday 28 and Sunday 29 October.
    [Show full text]
  • F.3. the NEW POLITICS of ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE [Preliminary Notes]
    F.3. THE NEW POLITICS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE [preliminary notes] MAIN MEMO pp 3-14 I. Introduction II. The Infrastructure: 13 key AI organizations III. Timeline: 2005-present IV. Key Leadership V. Open Letters VI. Media Coverage VII. Interests and Strategies VIII. Books and Other Media IX. Public Opinion X. Funders and Funding of AI Advocacy XI. The AI Advocacy Movement and the Techno-Eugenics Movement XII. The Socio-Cultural-Psychological Dimension XIII. Push-Back on the Feasibility of AI+ Superintelligence XIV. Provisional Concluding Comments ATTACHMENTS pp 15-78 ADDENDA pp 79-85 APPENDICES [not included in this pdf] ENDNOTES pp 86-88 REFERENCES pp 89-92 Richard Hayes July 2018 DRAFT: NOT FOR CIRCULATION OR CITATION F.3-1 ATTACHMENTS A. Definitions, usage, brief history and comments. B. Capsule information on the 13 key AI organizations. C. Concerns raised by key sets of the 13 AI organizations. D. Current development of AI by the mainstream tech industry E. Op-Ed: Transcending Complacency on Superintelligent Machines - 19 Apr 2014. F. Agenda for the invitational “Beneficial AI” conference - San Juan, Puerto Rico, Jan 2-5, 2015. G. An Open Letter on Maximizing the Societal Benefits of AI – 11 Jan 2015. H. Partnership on Artificial Intelligence to Benefit People and Society (PAI) – roster of partners. I. Influential mainstream policy-oriented initiatives on AI: Stanford (2016); White House (2016); AI NOW (2017). J. Agenda for the “Beneficial AI 2017” conference, Asilomar, CA, Jan 2-8, 2017. K. Participants at the 2015 and 2017 AI strategy conferences in Puerto Rico and Asilomar. L. Notes on participants at the Asilomar “Beneficial AI 2017” meeting.
    [Show full text]