Australia's Policy on the Israel-Palestine Peace Process: Influences and Implications
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Australia's Policy on the Israel-Palestine Peace Process: Influences and Implications Author Han Ni, Eulalia Published 2011 Thesis Type Thesis (PhD Doctorate) School School of Humanities DOI https://doi.org/10.25904/1912/895 Copyright Statement The author owns the copyright in this thesis, unless stated otherwise. Downloaded from http://hdl.handle.net/10072/367015 Griffith Research Online https://research-repository.griffith.edu.au Australia’s Policy on the Israel-Palestine Peace Process: Influences and Implications Han Ni, Eulalia BA (Hon.) School of Humanities Arts, Education & Law Group Griffith University Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2011 ABSTRACT This thesis examines Australia‘s current political response towards the Israel-Palestine peace process. It analyses the domestic factors that have the potential to shape Australia‘s foreign policy on the peace process. It also looks at what it will broadly mean for Australia should the current policy be maintained in relation to Australian values and commitment to issues of human rights and upholding international law. The domestic factors analysed in this thesis include the mass media, public opinion, lobby groups and business groups. An analysis of two Australian newspapers found that the Australian press coverage lacked depth and discussion of final status issues (the status of Jerusalem, Israeli settlements and Palestinian refugees). Relatively few articles address these issues within frames of their historical context and significance in international law. On the other hand, a national survey conducted shows that the majority of Australians identify with the Palestinian narrative, especially regarding final status issues. Moreover, Australians support their Government in adopting a policy on the conflict that is based on international law. This support, however, is not reflected in the Government‘s political response. The Australian Government supports the right for both Israelis and Palestinians to live in peace but since 2004, contradicts this stance by voting against key UN resolutions concerning the rights of Palestinians. As the media and the Australian public have had a minimal impact on the Government‘s political response, this allows other domestic forces with more specific agendas to influence policy- makers. This study finds that the pro-Israel lobby and Jewish organisations in Australia play a significant role in persuading Australian politicians to adopt a political stance that reflects the Israeli narrative. Australian politicians appear more willing to acknowledge the importance of safeguarding Israel‘s security over restoring Palestinians‘ rights. These findings have also been confirmed through extensive interviews conducted with former and present Australian diplomats and politicians from both major political parties. Australia‘s policy on the Israel-Palestine peace process will have an impact on the way the international community regards Australia. Australia prides itself as being a good international citizen which values the rule of law, justice and human rights. Voting against key UN resolutions that advocate the rights of Palestinians questions this commitment as it portrays a government that is only capable of paying lip service but not transcending its stated beliefs into actual practice. This study‘s overall finding is that certain domestic factors are able to influence foreign policy more than others depending on specific socio-political context as well as other external geopolitical dynamics. ii Statement of Originality This work has not previously been submitted for a degree or diploma in any university. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except where due reference is made in the thesis itself. .................................................... Han Ni, Eulalia 29 August 2011 iii Table of Contents Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................... vii List of Tables ............................................................................................................................. viii Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 9 Literature Review .............................................................................................................................. 12 The Making of Foreign Policy ........................................................................................................ 12 The Making of Australian Foreign Policy ...................................................................................... 13 Domestic Factors and Foreign Policy ............................................................................................ 14 Existing Studies on the Media, Public Opinion, Lobby Groups and the Israel-Palestine Conflict . 18 Limitations of the Current Study ....................................................................................................... 20 Chapter Structure ............................................................................................................................. 21 Chapter 1 - Australia and the Israel-Palestine Conflict ................................................................. 23 The Failure of the Peace Process ...................................................................................................... 24 International Law and Final Status Issues ......................................................................................... 33 Australia and the Establishment of the State of Israel ..................................................................... 35 Australia and the ‘Peaceful Settlement of the Question of Palestine’ ............................................. 39 Australia’s Policy on the Israel-Palestine Peace Process .................................................................. 42 Chapter 2 - Australia’s Place in the World ................................................................................... 50 Australia and its Place in International Politics ................................................................................. 52 Australia as a Western Country .................................................................................................... 53 Australia as a Middle Power ......................................................................................................... 55 The Australian Government, its People and their Vision of Australia .............................................. 56 Australia and Self-Determination ..................................................................................................... 58 Australia and Self-Determination in South Africa ......................................................................... 60 Australia and Self-Determination in East Timor ........................................................................... 61 A Distinct Australian Foreign Policy? ................................................................................................ 65 A Distinct Liberal/Labor Tradition of Australian Foreign Policy? ...................................................... 66 The International Environment and Australia’s Foreign Policy ........................................................ 68 The Domestic Environment and Australia’s Foreign Policy .............................................................. 70 Chapter 3 – Media Analysis ........................................................................................................ 74 Media and Society ............................................................................................................................. 74 Media and Foreign Policy .................................................................................................................. 76 Analysis ............................................................................................................................................. 78 Approach and Methodology ............................................................................................................. 81 iv Israel and Palestine ........................................................................................................................... 83 History, Context and Origins of the Conflict ..................................................................................... 89 International Law .............................................................................................................................. 92 Final Status Issues ............................................................................................................................. 94 Jerusalem ...................................................................................................................................... 95 Refugees ........................................................................................................................................ 97 Settlements ................................................................................................................................... 99 The Media’s Impact on the Australian Government’s Approach towards the Israel-Palestine Peace Process ...........................................................................................................................................