Appraisal Report of the Benchmark Fair Market Rental Values for the State of County of Hawaii

As of July 1, 2016

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TRANSMITTAL LETTER

TABLE OF CONTENTS 1

I. CERTIFICATION 4

II. LIMITING CONDITIONS AND ASSUMPTIONS 6

III. ASSIGNMENT AND SUMMARY 9 Purpose of Appraisal 10 Function of Report 10 Interest Appraised 10 Intended Use and User of the Report 10 Scope of Work 10 Definitions 11 Rental Categories 12 Rental Conclusions 13

IV. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS (State and County of Hawaii) 20

V. BENCHMARK PROPERTY TYPES FOR ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORTS 23 A. Spaces and Areas in Buildings 23 B. Undeveloped Lands 24 C. Parking Stalls 24 D. Aircraft Storage (Tie Downs) 25

VI. ASSUMPTIONS FOR ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORTS 26 A. Utilities 26 B. Special Conditions - Buildings 26 C. Special Conditions - Lands 26

VII. VALUATION METHODOLOGY FOR ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORTS 28

A. Building Spaces and Areas within the Airport or Adjacent to the Airport 30 1. Retail Rental Market Considerations 31 2. Office Rental Market Considerations 31 3. Industrial Rental Market Considerations 32 4. Calculation of Benchmark Rental Values for Retail, Office, and Industrial Spaces at Small Airports 32 5. Calculation of Rental Values for T-Hangars 33

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 1

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

B. Undeveloped Lands 33 1. General 33 (a) Valuation of Improved Unpaved Industrial Land 34 (b) Calculation of Paving Cost Recovery 35 (c) Valuation of Unimproved Industrial Land 36 2. Estimating Fee Simple Land Value 36 3. Prevailing Rates of Return on Land 37 4. Final Value Adjustments by Use 38 5. Concluded Land Values for Secondary and Tertiary Airports 38

VIII. MARKET ANALYSIS – Island of Hawaii 39

IX. MARKET RENTS – Hawaii County Automobile Parking & Tie Downs 43 A. Rental Rates for Automobile Parking Stalls 43 B. Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Downs) 48

X. MARKET RENTS – Kona International Airport 50 A. Airport Description 50 B. Environs 50 C. Rental Analysis 53 Retail Space Rents 53 Office Space Rents 54 Industrial Space Rents 55 Conclusion of Rents within Terminal Building 56 Conclusion of Rents within Air Taxi Building 57 Industrial Land Rents 57 Ramp Area Rents 61 Rental Rates for T-Hangars 62 Rental Rates for Automobile Parking 63 Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Down) Areas 63 Conclusions 63 Subject Photos 66

XI. MARKET RENTS – Hilo International Airport 70 A. Airport Description 70 B. Environs 70 C. Rental Analysis 73 Retail Space Rents 73 Office Space Rents 74 Industrial Space Rents 75 Conclusion of Rents within Terminal Building 76 Conclusion of Rents within Air Taxi Building 77 Industrial Land Rents 77 Ramp Area Rents 80

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 2

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Rental Rates for T-Hangars 80 Rental Rates for Automobile Parking 81 Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Down) Areas 81 Conclusions 82 Subject Photos 85

XII. MARKET RENTS – Waimea-Kohala Airport 92 A. Airport Description 92 B. Environs 92 C. Rental Analysis 95 Industrial Land Rents 95 Ramp Area Rents 95 Rental Rates for Automobile Parking 95 Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Down) Areas 95 Conclusions 96 Subject Photos 98

XIII. MARKET RENTS – Upolu Airport 99 A. Airport Description 99 B. Environs 99 C. Rental Analysis 102 Industrial Land Rents 102 Ramp Area Rents 102 Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Down) Areas 102 Conclusions 102

Professional Qualifications

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 3

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

I. CERTIFICATION

The undersigned hereby certify that, to the best of the appraisers’ knowledge and belief:

-- The statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct.

-- The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions, and are the appraisers’ personal, impartial and unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions.

-- The appraisers have no present or prospective interest in the properties that are the subject of this report, and have no personal interest with respect to the parties involved.

-- The appraisers have no bias with respect to the properties that are the subject of this report or to the parties involved with this assignment.

-- The appraisers have not performed services, as appraisers or in any other capacity, regarding the properties that are the subject of this report within the three-year period immediately preceding acceptance of this assignment.

-- Engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or reporting predetermined results.

-- Compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the development or reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the intended use of this appraisal.

-- The analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice and the Code of Professional Ethics and the Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice of the Appraisal Institute.

-- Alan J. Conboy, MAI, SRA and Andrew B. Conboy have made an inspection of the properties that are the subject of this report.

-- Nobody provided real property appraisal assistance to the persons signing this certification.

-- As of the date of this report Alan J. Conboy, MAI, SRA has completed the continuing education program for Designated Members of the Appraisal Institute.

-- As of the date of this report, Andrew B. Conboy has completed the Standards and Ethics Education Requirement of the Appraisal Institute for Associate Members.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 4

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

II. LIMITING CONDITIONS AND ASSUMPTIONS

The conduct of any appraisal is necessarily guided by, and its results influenced by, the terms of the assignment and the assumptions which form the basis of the study. The following conditions and assumptions embodied in this report constitute the framework of the appraisers’ analysis and conclusions.

Special limiting Conditions and Assumptions

-- In accordance with an agreement between the appraisers and the client prior to the preparation of this appraisal, we have prepared an Appraisal Report. This Appraisal Report is intended to comply with the reporting requirements set forth under Standards Rule 2-2(a) of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) for an Appraisal Report. As such, it presents a discussion of the data, reasoning, and analyses that were used in the appraisal process to develop the appraisers’ opinions of value. The depth of discussion contained in this report is specific to the needs of the client and for the intended use as stated herein. The appraisers are not responsible for unauthorized use of this report.

-- The valuation is based on assumptions that have been formulated based on information and descriptions provided by the Department of Transportation, Airport Division. These assumptions are significant to the valuation or are key factors upon which the valuation depends.

-- The analysis presumes the properties will continue to be professionally and prudently managed and maintained. It is assumed that current market and economic conditions will remain relatively stable or improve over the ensuing long-term period following the date of appraisal.

-- The legality of the traditional gathering rights of native Hawaiians that could be exercised on the properties, or other native Hawaiian rights that could impact the properties, was not considered in this report. This report assumes that the “traditional gathering rights” or any other rights of “native Hawaiians” would not be exercised on the property or properties that are the subject of this report and on any comparable properties that are included in this report. If native Hawaiian rights exist on the property and not the comparable properties, it could have a negative effect on the value of the property.

General Limiting Conditions and Assumptions

-- This appraisal is based upon the present condition of the national economy and the present purchasing power of the dollar. Fuel and energy available are assumed to remain at the levels of July 2016.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 6

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

-- This report expresses the opinion of the signers on July 1, 2016, as to an effective date of value of July 1, 2016; in no way has it been contingent upon the reporting of specified values or findings.

-- The appraisers have extensive experience in the valuation of vacant and improved income-generating properties and consider themselves competent to estimate the value of the specified real property interest in the subject properties.

-- It is assumed that the subject properties are free and clear of any and all encumbrances other than those referred to herein, and no responsibility is assumed for matters of a legal nature. This report is not to be construed as rendering any opinion of title, which is assumed good and marketable. Responsible ownership and competent management of the subject properties are assumed, unless otherwise stated within the report.

-- Any maps or plot plans reproduced and included in this report are intended only for the purpose of showing spatial relationships. These maps do not necessarily represent measured surveys or measured maps, and the appraisers are not responsible for the possible existence of any topographic or surveying errors within such maps. No engineering tests were furnished, and therefore no liability is assumed for the soil conditions, bearing capacity of the subsoil or building engineering matters relating to the subject properties.

-- Information provided by informed local sources such as governmental agencies, financial institutions, realtors, buyers, sellers and others, was interpreted in the manner in which it was supplied and, whenever possible or practical, was checked and verified by secondary means. However, no responsibility is assumed for any possible misinformation contained in these sources of information.

-- The presence of hazardous wastes or toxic materials such as asbestos, urea- formaldehyde foam insulation or other potentially harmful substances may have an adverse affect on the value of a given property. The value estimates as reported herein are predicated on the assumption that there is no such hazardous material on or in the subject properties that would result in this type of loss in value. No responsibility is assumed for any potentially adverse environmental conditions or for the lack of any expertise or engineering knowledge required to discover such conditions.

-- The appraisers are not required to give testimony or appear in court because of having made this appraisal unless arrangements for the appearance and the fee for such appearance have been agreed upon by the person or corporation requiring such testimony.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 7

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

-- The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) became effective January 26, 1992. The appraisers have not completed a compliance survey or analysis of the subject properties to determine the properties’ conformity with the various ADA requirements. It is possible that a compliance survey of the properties, combined with a detailed analysis of the requirements of the ADA, may reveal the properties are not in compliance with one or more of the requirements of the Act. If the properties are not in compliance, there could be a negative impact on value. Since the appraisers have not received specific information with respect to this issue, they did not consider possible non-compliance with the requirements of ADA in estimating the values of the properties.

-- The appraisers will not disclose the contents of the appraisal report except as provided for in the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 8

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

III. ASSIGNMENT AND SUMMARY

The appraisers have completed an appraisal report estimating the benchmark fair market rental values for the County of Hawaii airport facilities.

Purpose of Appraisal

The purpose of this appraisal is to set forth the appraisers’ opinion of the fair market rental value of various areas of classification in the County of Hawaii airports, managed by the State of Hawaii Airports Division, located on the island of Hawaii.

This report updates the rates included within the Airports Division “Schedule of Rates and Charges” Procedure No. 4.5, effective January 23, 2014.

Function of Report

The State of Hawaii, Department of Transportation, Airports Division, oversees the operations at 15 airports and other properties in the State of Hawaii. The 15 airports include: Airport Tax Map Plat

City and County of Honolulu International Airport (1) 1-1-02, 03, 72, 76 (1) 9-1-13 Kawaihapai Airfield (1) 6-8-14

County of (2) 3-8-01 Airport (2) 5-2-04 (2) 4-9-02 (2) 4-3-01 (2) 6-1-01 (2) 1-3-03

County of Hawaii Kona International Airport at Keahole (3) 7-3-43 Hilo International Airport (3) 2-1-12 Waimea-Kohala Airport (3) 6-7-01 Upolu Airport (3) 5-5-06

County of (4) 3-5-01 Port Allen Airfield (4) 1-8-08

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 9

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

The function of this report is to assist the State of Hawaii, Airports Division, in establishing reasonable rates and charges for the use of facilities and services at the four County of Hawaii airports.

The report will first address the various property types and assumptions common to all State of Hawaii airport facilities followed by an analysis on the fair market rent analysis for the four airports located within the County of Hawaii. The concluded rates will be included within the State of Hawaii, Airports Division updated “Rates and Charges”.

Interest Appraised

Fee Simple Interest

Intended Use and User of the Report

The sole use of this appraisal is as an asset management tool for the State of Hawaii, Airports Division’s use in their determination of land and space rental rates in the four County of Hawaii airports.

Scope of Work

For purposes of this assignment, the appraisers developed their opinions of value based on a complete appraisal of the identified subject real property interest and have communicated the results of this complete appraisal within an Appraisal Report. To the best of the appraisers’ knowledge and ability, this appraisal has been prepared in conformance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice and the Code of Professional Ethics and Standards of Professional Practice of the Appraisal Institute.

By prior agreement with the client; this is an Appraisal Report intended to comply with the reporting requirements set forth under Standards Rule 2-2(a) of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice for an Appraisal Report. As such, it presents a discussion of the data, reasoning, and analyses that were considered in the appraisal process to develop the appraisers’ opinion of value. The depth of discussion contained in this report is specific to the needs of the client and for the intended use stated above. The appraisers are not responsible for unauthorized use of this report.

In the course of this assignment, the appraisers have undertaken a series of independent investigations and analyses in addition to relying upon selected information and data from existing office files that are updated on a recurring basis. A summary of the investigations conducted, the primary data sources utilized and the basic methodology employed in this analysis is presented in the following paragraphs.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 10

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

The description of the subject properties was based upon a physical inspection of the properties conducted as follows:

Date of Airports Division Inspection Airport or Area Representative

06/17/16 Kona International Airport Ms. Pauline Zanger

06/16/16 Hilo International Airport Ms. Tiffinie Smith

06/16/16 Upolu Airport Ms. Pauline Zanger

06/16/16 Waimea-Kohala Airport Ms. Pauline Zanger

The appraisers analyzed all of the background information on each property and its environs as revealed by their research and investigation. The appraisers also conducted an analysis of local real estate market conditions affecting the subject properties, based upon interviews with local real estate professionals and information contained within journals published by the local board of realtors.

Definitions

Fair Market Rental Value

The term fair market rental value, as used in this report, is synonymous with market rent, defined in The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, Fifth Edition, Appraisal Institute as:

“the most probable rent that a property should bring in a competitive and open market reflecting all conditions and restrictions of the specified lease agreement including term, rental adjustment and revaluation, permitted uses, use restrictions, and expense obligations; the lessee and lessor each acting prudently and knowledgeably, and assuming consummation of a lease contract as of a specified date and the passing of the leasehold from lessor to lessee under conditions whereby:

1. lessee and lessor are typically motivated; 2. both parties are well informed or well advised, and acting in what they consider their best interests; 3. a reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market; 4. the rent payment is made in terms of cash in United States dollars, and is expressed as an amount per time period consistent with the payment schedule of the lease contract; and 5. the rental amount represents the normal consideration for the property leased unaffected by special fees or concessions granted by anyone associated with the transaction.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 11

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Fee Simple Interests

Fee simple estate is defined as an absolute ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate, subject only to the limitations imposed by the governmental powers of taxation, eminent domain, police power, and escheat.

Airport-Airline Lease

Lease means a lease executed by an operator of aircraft and the state Department of Transportation under which the aircraft operator is obligated to pay airport use charges.

Large aircraft (Air Carrier)

Means aircraft: (a) larger than aircraft in the large general aviation aircraft group category; and (b) aircraft operated by commercial passenger or cargo transport air carriers holding a certificate of public convenience and necessity.

Large aircraft (General Aviation)

Means an aircraft of more than 12,500 pounds maximum certificated landing weight with a fixed wing span greater than 42 feet but less than 60 feet, or rotor wing aircraft with a rotor blade diameter of 37 feet or larger but less than 49 feet. Any larger aircraft, even if operated under FAR Part 91 or Part 135 or following Part 119, shall fall into the air carrier category.

Small aircraft (General Aviation)

Means an aircraft of 12,500 pounds or less maximum certificated landing weight with a fixed span of 42 feet or less or rotor wing aircraft with a rotor blade diameter of less than 37 feet.

Aircraft parking and storage areas

Shall mean and include any portion of a public airport, designated temporarily or permanently by the state Director of Transportation, that may be used for the parking and storing of aircraft for the servicing of aircraft with fuel, lubricants and other supplies, and for the making of minor or emergency repairs to aircraft.

Airport Rental Categories

State of Hawaii airport rental categories are summarized in Table H-1, following.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 12

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-1

CATEGORY DESCRIPTION Terminal Floor Space Open finished floor space within the terminal.

Service Counter Finished counter space or passenger, tour, greeting, etc.

Concession - Retail Sales Areas utilized by retail vendors including Duty Free, newsstand, packaged foods, etc.

Concession - Food & Areas utilized for food concessions including restaurants, cocktail lounges, Beverage snacks, etc.

Office Office space, which include floor covering, painting or wall covering, ceiling, lighting, etc. Used for administrative purposes, ticketing, reservations, crew lounge, ramp services, etc.

VIP Lounge Lounge space similar to office finished spaces used by airlines.

Ramp Office Office space, which normally includes concrete flooring, lighting, electrical outlets and painted concrete or hollow tile walls.

Warehouse and Storage Unfinished rooms and/or remnant space used for storage.

Industrial/Agricultural Land Tenant of the property operates a business related to airport use. Land may have direct access or some aircraft access to ramp and service road.

Improved Land Graded with utilities and paved road within a reasonable distance of the property line.

Unimproved Land Not graded and lacks utilities and paved road access.

Aircraft Parking Fees Rates should vary with size, i.e. small (up to 41'); large (43' to 60'); and where noncommercial or commercial.

Rental Conclusions

Table H-2 following, summarizes the benchmark fair market rental conclusions for all the County of Hawaii airport facilities, which includes the Kona International Airport, Hilo International Airport, Waimea-Kohala Airport and Upolu Airport.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 13

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS KONA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AT KEAHOLE Kona, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Terminal Floor Space (non-air carrier) $27.00 $2.25 $36.00 $3.00 Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) $27.00 $2.25 $36.00 $3.00 Concessionaire-Food & Beverage (F) $24.30 $2.03 $32.40 $2.70 VIP Lounge (F) $22.50 $1.88 $26.25 $2.19 Office (F) (non-air carrier) $18.00 $1.50 $21.00 $1.75 Storage $5.40 $0.45 $7.50 $0.63 Air Taxi Building Ticket Counter (F) $24.30 $2.03 $32.40 $2.70 Office (F) $16.20 $1.35 $18.90 $1.58 Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers $14.40 N/A $16.80 $1.40 Cargo $10.80 $0.90 $15.00 $1.25 Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved $1.19 $0.10 $1.44 $0.12 Improved Land-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17 Unimproved Land-Unpaved $0.60 $0.05 $0.72 $0.06 Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Paved (non-air carrier) $2.54 $0.21 $3.09 $0.26 Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved (non-air carrier) $1.79 $0.15 $2.16 $0.18 Open Equipment Parking-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved $1.19 $0.10 $1.44 $0.12 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17

T-Hangars Per Month Per Month Per Sqft/Mo Bldg 403-102 to 110, T-Hangars (968sf) $438.00 $726.00 $0.75 Bldg 404-105 to 112, T-Hangars (968sf) $439.00 $726.00 $0.75 Bldg 403-101 and 111, End Room (475sf) $219.00 $356.00 $0.75 Bldg 404-103 and 113, End Room (475sf) $5.40 $356.00 $0.75 T-Hangar Used as Commercial Space -- -- $1.25 Automobile Parking Covered-Paved Parking Per Month $80.00 Per Month $85.00 Uncovered-Paved Parking Per Month $52.00 Per Month $55.00 Aircraft Storage Charges Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $96.00 Per Month $144.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $20.00 Per Day $20.00 Per Month $136.00 Per Month $208.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 14

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 Kona International Airport at Keahole Special Properties Kona, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Concluded Rents Map Bldg Tenant Area Use Condition Sqft/ Mo. Sqft/ Year

AOA2 106 Civil Air Patrol 2,912 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 109 Tiares 500 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 110 Aero Sleek 240 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 111 Tropic Bird 320 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 112 Delta 440 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 113 Securitas 935 Trailer Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 006-103 Hawaii Air Ventures 1,157 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 347 Old ARFF Building 6,064 Office Fair $0.90 $10.80

AOA3 001-107 JTB Building 10,300 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 15

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS HILO INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT Hilo, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Terminal Floor Space (non-air carrier) $25.20 $2.10 $27.00 $2.25 Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) $25.20 $2.10 $27.00 $2.25 Concessionaire-Food & Beverage (F) $22.70 $1.89 $24.30 $2.03 VIP Lounge (F) $18.00 $1.50 $19.50 $1.63 Office (F) (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $15.60 $1.30 Storage-Second Floor (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $4.80 $0.40 Ramp Office (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $15.60 $1.30 Remnant Storage (non-air carrier) $4.20 $0.35 $4.80 $0.40 Air Taxi Building Ticket Counter (F) $22.70 $1.89 $24.30 $2.03 Office (F) $13.00 $1.08 $14.00 $1.17 Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers $11.50 $0.96 $12.50 $1.04 Cargo Building 139 (Office) $15.60 $1.30 Cargo Building 139 (Warehouse) $9.60 $0.80 Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved $1.10 $0.09 $0.94 $0.08 Improved Land-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13 Unimproved Land-Unpaved $0.55 $0.05 $0.47 $0.04 Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved (non-air carrier) $1.65 $0.14 $1.41 $0.12 Open Equipment Parking-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved $1.10 $0.09 $0.94 $0.08 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13

T-Hangars Per Month Per Month Per Sqft/Mo Bldg. 414-104 to 111, T-Hangar (Large) (1,249 sf) $435.00 $600.00 $0.48 Bldg. 402 & 403-102 to 105, T-Hangar (Small) (844 sf) $285.00 $405.00 $0.48 Bldg 402 & 403-101 and 106, End Room (Small) (176 sf) $60.00 $84.00 $0.48 Bldg 414-112, End Room (Large) (580 sf) $194.00 $278.00 $0.48 Bldg 414-101, End Room (Small) (421 sf) $142.00 $202.00 $0.48 T-Hangar Used as Commercial Space -- -- $0.80 Automobile Parking Covered-Paved Parking Per Month $80.00 Per Month $85.00 Uncovered-Paved Parking Per Month $52.00 Per Month $55.00 Aircraft Storage Charges Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $96.00 Per Month $144.00 Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $20.00 Per Day $20.00 Per Month $136.00 Per Month $208.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 16

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 Hilo International Airport Special Properties Hilo, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Concluded Rent Tenant Area Use Condition Sqft/Mo Sqft/Year

Map AOA1

Bldg 133 Old Hangar 2,640 Hangar Poor $0.30 $3.60

Bldg 132 Aloha Cargo Building 5,250 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 111 Aloha Cargo 5,009 Hangar Poor $0.40 $4.80

Map AOA2

Bldg 101 Cargo Building 15,453 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 104 Commodity Forwarders 192 Trailer Good $1.00 $12.00

Bldg 109 Aloha Air Cargo 3,562 Hangar Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 110 Fedex Cargo 4,898 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 302 Old Control Tower 2,775 Office (1st Floor) Good $1.00 $12.00 Office (2nd Floor) Fair $0.70 $8.40 Office (3rd Floor) Poor $0.35 $4.20

Bldg 303 Old Overseas Terminal 23,697 Office Poor $0.30 $3.60

Map AOA5 (NEW)

Bldg 207 Space 007-101C 1,571 Office Good $1.30 $15.60

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 17

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS WAIMEA-KOHALA AIRPORT Waimea, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) Per Sq.Ft. $6.75 $0.56 $10.50 $0.88 Office (F) Per Sq.Ft. $4.50 $0.38 $5.25 $0.44

Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers Per Sq.Ft. $3.60 N/A $4.20 $0.35 Hangar - Building 105 Per Sq.Ft. N/A N/A $3.75 $0.31

Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Improved Land-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Unimproved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.15 $0.01 $0.18 $0.02

Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.63 $0.05 $0.78 $0.07 Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.45 $0.04 $0.54 $0.05 Open Equipment Parking-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04

Automobile Parking Uncovered Paved Parking Per Month $39.00 Per Month $41.00

Aircraft Storage Charges (Tie Downs) Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $5.00 Per Day $5.00 Per Month $24.00 Per Month $54.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $34.00 Per Month $78.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 18

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-2 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS UPOLU AIRPORT Upolu, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers Per Sq.Ft. $3.60 $0.30 $4.20 $0.35

Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Improved Land-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Unimproved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.15 $0.01 $0.18 $0.02

Aircraft Storage Charges (Tie Downs) Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $5.00 Per Day $5.00 Per Month $24.00 Per Month $54.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $34.00 Per Month $78.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 19

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

IV. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS – STATE AND COUNTY OF HAWAII

This section summarizes the macro-economic trends and forces affecting the State of Hawaii and the County of Hawaii. Data was provided by the State of Hawaii Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), Hawaii Tourism Authority (HTA), Hospitality Advisors LLC and the Economic Research Organization at the University of Hawaii (UHERO). It addresses historical and projected trends in population, employment, and unemployment. Additionally, it describes historical trends of the state’s personal income, construction, tourism and its economic outlook. The following paragraphs briefly summarize the historical and projected trends.

Population -- According to the Economic Research Organization at the University of Hawaii (UHERO), the resident population of the State of Hawaii was 1,431,600 in 2015 and 1,420,300 in 2014. The County of Hawaii resident population was 196,400 in 2015 and 194,000 in 2014. The State of Hawaii Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT) is forecasting the resident population for the entire State to grow to 1,455,000 by 2017, 1,468,000 by 2018 and 1,481,000 by 2019.

Income -- The real personal income of the State for 2015 was $54,231,000,000 and $52,346,000,000 for 2014, an increase of 3.6 percent. Real personal income data reported for the County of Hawaii for 2014 was $2,628,700,000. Real personal income growth for the State of Hawaii is projected to increase $55,857,000,000 in 2016, $57,610,000,000 in 2017, $59,367,000,000 and $61,124,000,000 in 2018.

Employment -- The civilian labor force for the State for 2015 was 676,300 and 89,100 for the County of Hawaii. The entire state in 2015 had an unemployment rate of 3.7 percent, which is down from the rate of 4.4 percent compared to 2014. The County of Hawaii in 2015 had an unemployment rate of 4.5 percent, which is down from the rate of 5.6 percent compared to 2014. The lower unemployment rates for both the State and the County of Hawaii are primarily due to the increase in the tourism and construction industries. The unemployment rate for both the State and the County of Hawaii, as of February 2016, was 3.1 and 3.8 (not seasonally adjusted) percent, respectively. These unemployment rates only count jobless individuals actively searching for work so it may overstate the actual health of the labor market.

Construction -- The construction industry for the entire state is greatly affected by the current global, national and local economic situation. The number of construction jobs, permits and value of permits has all declined since 2006 when the entire state in general and most of the counties including the City and County of Honolulu had the highest number of permits issued. Most of the increases were due in part to the robust residential market. When the economy began to weaken, potential projects from private developers and individuals were put on hiatus.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 20

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

The State and all of the counties have recovered from a weak housing market which has weighed heavy on new home construction. The value of statewide private building permits increased 19.6 percent and increased 67.5 percent for residential building permits in 2015 over permits issued in 2014. UHERO’s most recent forecast for construction is projecting the construction sector to continue to improve for 2016 due to an improvement in the home resale market, low mortgage interest rates and limited supply of housing units. A weakening in government and military contracts and work will be offset by the proposed rail project which will add to the potential ramp up the sector. Recent announcements of high-rise condominiums in the Honolulu & Kakaako areas, increased movement in shopping center development in West Oahu and resort-related development statewide will help to increase real non-residential building permits through 2016 and for the next several years.

Tourism -- Tourism is the primary industry for the entire State of Hawaii, and the driving force for economic stability. The success of tourism stimulates the progress of all markets in all of the counties. Total visitor arrivals, hotel occupancy rates and average daily room rates (ADR) had all been on the decline for the most part since the latter part of 2006 for both the State and the County of Hawaii. The industry stabilized in 2009 and started to improve in 2010. UHERO is now reporting that the industry is posting impressive rates of growth in total visitor arrivals, visitor days, visitor expenditures and visitor accommodations.

The Hawaii Tourism Authority (HTA) is reporting that tourism achieved its fourth consecutive year of record for both visitor arrivals and expenditures in 2015. There were 8,649,357 visitors to the State in 2015 or 4.1 percent more than the 8,300,000 in 2014. Visitors spent a record $15.2 billion in 2015 which was an increase of 2.3 percent from $14.8 billion in 2014. Arrivals from the U.S. West increased 7.1 percent (3,518,472 visitors) from 2014 while U.S. East arrivals increased by 3.1 percent to 1,788,573 visitors from 2014. Japanese arrivals decreased 0.8 percent to 1,499,167 visitors in 2014. Canadian arrivals totaled 517,238 visitors, a decrease of 1.4 percent from 2014. In contrast, the HTA is reporting strong growth in arrivals from other small visitor markets including Australia and New Zealand (397,704 or + 7.2 percent), Korea and China (378,444 or +2.7 percent), Europe (143,435 or +3.0 percent). Latin America declined (27,806 or -7.6 percent). 2016 is starting off strong and the State of Hawaii DBEDT is projecting visitor arrivals to increase 1.7 percent in 2017 and 2018 and visitor expenditures to increase 4.1 percent for both 2017 and 2018.

The Hawaii Hotel Flash Report for Year-End 2015 indicated that the average room revenue (REVPAR) for the State increased to $192.22, or by 6.3 percent, in 2015 in comparison with $180.83 in 2014. The average daily room rate (ADR) in 2015 was $243.93 for the State, a 3.9 percent increase from $234.85 in 2014. The average room revenue (REVPAR) for the Big Island increased to $151.05, or by 8.2% in 2015 in comparison with $139.55 in 2014. The average daily room rate (ADR) in 2015 for the Big Island was $230.26, a 0.5% decrease from $231.43 in 2014. The average room

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 21

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

revenue (REVPAR) for the State increased to $218.33, or by 3.6 percent, in February 2016 in comparison with $210.70 in February 2015. The average room revenue (REVPAR) for the Big Island increased to $195.11, or by 2.0 percent, in February 2016 in comparison with $191.24 in February 2015. The average daily room rate (ADR) in February 2016 was $261.16 for the State and $249.50 for the Big Island, an increase and decrease of 2.9 and 1.6 percent, respectively, over February 2015. The 2015 occupancy for the State increased to 78.8 percent from 77.0 percent in 2014. The 2015 occupancy for the Big Island increased to 65.6 percent from 60.3 percent in 2014. The monthly occupancy in February 2016 was 83.6 percent for the State and 78.2 percent for the Big Island, an increase of 0.7 and 3.7 percent, respectively, over February 2015.

Residential Real Estate -- UHERO reported the median sales prices of single-family units on the Big Island for 2015 was $329,300 compared to $316,600 for 2014. The median sales prices of condominium units on the Big Island decreased to $272,700 from $283,400 one year earlier. Single-family sales increased 6.7 percent from 1,885 units to 2,012 units and condominium sales were up by 1.9 percent from 646 units to 658 units.

Summary – UHERO latest State forecast (February 26, 2016) is reporting that the economic outlook for the State is positive especially in regards to tourism and construction. The current expansion remains strong as indicated by the strong labor market and increases in personal income. 2015 performed better than anticipated and the momentum will continue into 2016. Growth in tourism set records in 2015, even with a weak Japanese visitor market, with record occupancy rates on Oahu and above 70.0% on the neighbor islands (per Hospitality Advisors LLC). UHERO is projecting visitor arrivals to ease up a little in 2016 to a 1.5% growth following the 4.0% growth exhibited in 2015. The labor market is much healthier than it was a couple of years ago and is projected to grow approximately 1.5% per annum for the next couple of years and dropping to approximately 1.0% for the latter part of the decade. Construction activity is strong on all islands and is projected to expand for several more years with minimal growth in the latter part of the decade. Inflation remains low primarily due to declining oil prices however is projected to increase to 3% in 2017 as rising housing costs and wages begin to affect local prices.

External global challenges including, but not limited to, a surging dollar, China’s slowing economy, the effects of el nino on agriculture, the refugee crisis, terror attacks in the West and abroad and the Fed’s recent shift to higher interest rates are potential risks to both the national and State economies. These adverse developments have the potential to cause a sustained decline in consumer confidence erasing all of the growth experienced so far since 2012 and projected for the next several years.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 22

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

V. BENCHMARK PROPERTY TYPES FOR ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORTS

The benchmark property types within the Hawaii State Airport facilities are categorized into four groups:

Spaces and Areas in Buildings Main Terminal Buildings Commuter Terminal Buildings Air Taxi Buildings Hangars Cargo

Lands within the Airport or Adjacent to the Airport Industrial Uses (Improved, Unimproved, Paved and Unpaved) Agricultural Uses

Parking (Open/Covered)

Aircraft Storage (Tie Downs)

General characteristics of the spaces and areas in each category are outlined under the following subheadings.

A. Spaces and Areas in Buildings

The buildings spaces and areas within the Hawaii State Airport facilities cover a wide range of uses that directly or indirectly support airport operations. They include:

Non-Air Carrier

Terminal Floor Space Service Counters VIP Lounge Office Storage

Air Carrier

Rates for rental of Terminal Space for Air Carriers are established according to the January 1, 2008 First Amendment Lease Extension to the “Airport-Airline Lease”.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 23

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Other Spaces

Concession - Retail Sales Concession – Food and Beverage Sales Warehouse - Cargo (Open/Covered) Warehouse - Industrial Warehouse - Office Shed Reefer (Cold Storage) Revetment /Bunker Baseyard - Office, Service Bay, Maintenance Shop Hangar Shed Office Trailer Aviation Hangars T-Hangars

B. Industrial Lands

The majority of the undeveloped lands that are a part of the Hawaii State Airport Facilities are comprised of “improved” land for the following uses:

Industrial Agricultural (Where Applicable)

Undeveloped improved lands have direct access to the airport ramp. Improved lands are graded with utilities and paved road access within a reasonable distance of the property line. The undeveloped lands for each use type are differentiated based on whether they are paved or unpaved.

Some airports also have “unimproved” industrial land, which is land that is not graded and that lacks utilities and paved road access.

C. Parking Stalls

All airports, with the exception of the Upolu on the island of Hawaii and Port Allen Airfield on the island of Kauai, include parking stalls that are available for rent on a monthly basis. The parking stalls include:

Covered Uncovered, both paved and unpaved

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 24

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

D. Aircraft Storage (Tie Downs)

General aviation aircraft storage includes uncovered tie-down areas for small and large aircraft. The small aircraft tie-down storage areas can accommodate aircraft with a wing-span up to 42 feet. By contrast, the large aircraft tie-down storage areas can accommodate aircraft with a wing-span from 43 feet to 60 feet.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 25

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

VI. ASSUMPTIONS COMMON TO ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORT RENTS

The following conditions are deemed by the Department of Transportation, Airports Division to be common to all airports.

A. Utilities

Rents within all terminal buildings for all airports excluding Kalaeloa, Upolu and Port Allen are subject to the following:

(1) Janitorial services are not included in stated rental rates.

(2) Water for ordinary use is furnished.

(3) Electricity and air-conditioning services are extra.

B. Special Conditions - Buildings

Rents within all buildings other than terminal buildings for all airports excluding Kapalua, Hana, Upolu and Port Allen are subject to the following:

(1) Minimum rental shall be twenty-five dollars ($25.00) per month regardless of use, size or location of space rented.

(2) Special charges shall be assessed for special equipment or machinery in any building structure.

(3) Tenants shall pay for all utilities, utility services and other services which they may require, unless otherwise provided.

(4) Janitorial services are not included in rental rates. (Applicable to Honolulu International only)

C. Special Conditions - Lands

The following conditions are common to rentals on industrial lands.

(1) Minimal rental shall be $15.00 per month regardless of the use, size, or location of the area rented. (Rate for Honolulu International is $25.00)

(2) Improved land is graded and utilities and paved access road are within a reasonable distance from property line.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 26

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

(3) Unimproved land is not graded and lacks utilities and paved access road. For unimproved land at all airports, discount improved, unpaved rates by 25 to 50 percent depending on distance to utilities and paved access road.

(4) Utility connections and charges at tenant’s sole cost and expense.

(5) Adjustments for location, size and poor shape must be considered for specific sites at all airports.

(6) Size discounts for the rental of a contiguous parcel of industrial land included under a single contract upon its commencement may be applied towards the appropriate land rate in accordance with the schedule shown below. Leased premises that have been enlarged in land area due to subsequent amendments to the contract do not qualify the lessee for such discounts to be applied to the entire leased premises.

Size of Parcel Discount 2 to 2.999 acres 4.0% 3 to 3.999 acres 8.0 4 or more acres 12.0

(7) Size discounts for the rental of a contiguous parcel of agricultural land included under a single contract upon its commencement may be applied towards the appropriate land rate in accordance with the schedule shown below. Leased premises that have been enlarged in land area due to subsequent amendments to the contract do not qualify the lessee for such discounts to be applied to the entire leased premises.

Size of Parcel Discount 5 to 9.999 acres 2.0% 10 to 19.999 acres 4.0 20 or more acres 8.0

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 27

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

VII. VALUATION METHODOLOGY FOR ALL HAWAII STATE AIRPORTS

This report addresses the fair market rental value of various classifications of space within County of Hawaii airport facilities. The analysis is similar to the methodology utilized for all State of Hawaii airport facilities. The methodology utilized herein incorporates the Direct Comparison Approach.

Given the many differences when comparing one airport to another, the appraisers have concentrated their investigation into current Hawaii rental rates of “off airport” office, retail and industrial space within close proximity to the subject County of Hawaii airports. This information was used to estimate rental rates for the various space classifications of the subject airports. Studies were made utilizing rental surveys of similar uses, i.e., retail, office and industrial, off the airport but within close proximity. While a comparison of this type provides support, its use as a primary method for a special purpose property might result in rental rates toward the low end of the property’s potential rent. It is difficult to quantify the adjustment between on and off airport property. The motivations of lessees and the characteristics of the properties are vastly different. Special purpose properties similar to the subject airports typically reflect a much higher overall construction cost. As such, using rental information reflected solely by off airport properties would probably result in a low side rental rate.

The following paragraphs represent a summary of the various valuation methods and terminology which is common to the State of Hawaii airports. The County of Hawaii airports will be analyzed in more detail later in Chapters IX (Kona), X (Hilo), XI (Waimea-Kohala) and XII (Upolu), covering each airport.

Valuation Method

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark spaces and areas within the various Hawaii State airport facilities are estimated using recognized appraisal principles and based on analyses of the local “off airport” rental market for each airport.

The fair market rental value for each benchmark space is estimated using the direct market comparison approach. The market comparison approach assumes that the rent within an airport property relates directly to the rents of comparable, competitive “off airport” properties. The approach assumes that the rent of a property tends to be set by the rent that would be paid to acquire a substitute property of equal utility and desirability.

The benchmark property types within the Hawaii State airport facilities are categorized into four groups:

 Spaces and areas in buildings within the Airport or adjacent to the Airport  Lands within the Airport or adjacent to the Airport

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 28

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

 Parking stalls  Aircraft Storage

Additionally, for valuation purposes, the Hawaii State airport facilities were further categorized into three classifications as follows:

Primary Airports Honolulu International Airport Kahului Airport Kona International Airport at Keahole Hilo International Airport Lihue Airport

Secondary Airports Kapalua Molokai Lanai

Tertiary Airports Kalaeloa Airport Kawaihapai Airfield Kalaupapa Airport Hana Airport Waimea-Kohala Airport Upolu Airport Port Allen Airfield

The estimated values in the primary airport areas generally increase with airport activity. For example, the Honolulu International Airport has the highest level of passenger enplanements and cargo of the airports in the State. As expected, the respective values are also the highest. The relationship between passenger activity and cargo at the primary, secondary, and tertiary airport areas is shown in the following tabulation:

Activity Levels (2015) (1) Cargo Airport Passengers (U.S. Tons) Primary Honolulu 19,869,707 413,401 Kahului 6,678,772 31,217 Kona 3,070,772 19,564 Lihue 2,820,998 18,194 Hilo 1,324,596 20,222

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 29

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Secondary Molokai 242,157 1,055 Lanai 78,638 885 Kapalua 62,228 1,293

Tertiary Hana 3,826 0 Kalaupapa 12,297 111 Waimea-Kohala 10,255 0 Kawaihapai 0 0 Upolu 0 0 Port Allen 0 0 _____ (1) Department of Transportation - Airports Division Calendar Year January – December 2015.

The valuation methodology for each of the property types is further described in the following subsections.

A. Building Spaces and Areas within the Airport or Adjacent to the Airport

The benchmark building spaces and areas within the Hawaii State airport facilities can be categorized by the manner in which they are used.

The first category is comprised of those areas and spaces that are used by airport travelers. The second category includes those support areas which facilitate efficient airport operations that are used by airport personnel; this category includes both office and non-office uses. A third category includes warehouse and storage spaces.

Based on the similarities in use, the benchmark building spaces and areas are grouped according to the relevant “off airport” markets that provide the basis for establishing the fair rental values.

Retail Office Warehouse Rental Market Rental Market Rental Market Terminal floor space VIP Lounge Warehouse Area Concession space Office space Storage Hangars Cargo area Reefer, Shed

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark building spaces and areas within the airport facilities are estimated based on:

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 30

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

 Recent rents for retail, office, and industrial spaces and other functionally similar uses within relevant “off airport” market areas around each airport.  Discussions with leasing agents.

1. Retail Rental Market Considerations

The rental rates for the typical benchmark finished retail-related spaces at the five major airports (Honolulu, Kahului, Hilo, Kona and Lihue) within the State are based on the current rent levels for retail space in the respective competitive “off airport” market areas throughout the State.

Additionally, retail-related spaces in the following areas are judged to be inferior in physical condition or accessibility to the typical retail-related spaces at the respective airports:

 Honolulu - Commuter Terminal  Kahului - Commuter Terminal  Hilo - Air Taxi Building  Kona - Air Taxi Building  Lihue - Commuter Terminal

2. Office Rental Market Considerations

The rental rates for the typical benchmark finished office spaces at the five major airports (Honolulu, Kahului, Hilo, Kona and Lihue) within the State are based on the current rent levels for the office space in the respective competitive “off airport” market areas throughout the State.

Additionally, office spaces in the following areas are inferior in physical condition or accessibility to the typical office spaces at the respective airports:

 Honolulu - Commuter Terminal  Kahului - Commuter Terminal  Hilo - Air Taxi Building  Kona - Air Taxi Building  Lihue - Commuter Terminal

Trailer rents in all airports are based on the indicated general office base rate discounted by 20 percent.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 31

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

3. Industrial Rental Market Considerations

The fair market rental rates for the typical benchmark warehouse and storage spaces at the five major airports (Honolulu, Kahului, Hilo, Kona and Lihue) and Kalaeloa are based on the current rent levels for industrial warehouse and storage space in the respective competitive “off airport” market areas in close proximity to the airports.

Rents for areas in sheds, quonsets, bunkers and remnant storage are generally estimated to be 50 percent of the associated warehouse rent in each airport area.

4. Calculation of Benchmark Rental Values For Retail, Office and Industrial Spaces at Secondary and Tertiary Airports

Sufficient market data is not available to accurately estimate the rents in the vicinity of the smaller airports by direct comparison. As a result, the benchmark rents for the retail, office and industrial type spaces at these airports are estimated by comparison to rates established for the five major primary airports.

The secondary and tertiary airports should have a defined correlation with the primary airports in order to have a consistent rental structure now and in future years. There is insufficient or inconclusive market data available in similar “off-airport” markets of secondary airports to establish rents for the office and retail-related spaces, or to estimate the market rates for the benchmark improved, unpaved industrial lands. Therefore, there should be consistent, established relationship between the primary airports and the smaller airports.

The following rate structure utilized in the analysis for the secondary and tertiary airports is based upon the rates and charges determined for the primary airports:

Primary Airports Base Secondary Airports 60% of Base Tertiary Airports 25% of Base

The intent of this rate structure is to address the following:

Secondary Airports - Services the outlying areas of the community or island and is an integral mode of transportation. It is used by both residents and visitors and is the principal means of travel between islands; however, airport

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 32

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

infrastructure and population characteristics of the community or island present an obstacle to aircraft service.

Tertiary Airports - Services the outlying areas of the community or island and is not widely used due to limited facilities or service. The tertiary classification reflects (1) limited or non-existent terminal facilities; (2) limited or non-existent hangar facilities; (3) limited or non-existent terminal floor space for concessions/passenger service areas; (4) limited or non-existent infrastructure support facilities; and (5) limited use and demand.

5. Calculation of Rental Rates For T-Hangars

Hangar spaces (T-Hangars and End Rooms) are available for rent at the following airports:

 Honolulu International Airport  Kalaeloa Airport  Kawaihapai Airfield  Kahului Airport  Kona International Airport  Hilo International Airport  Lihue Airport

Historically, the rental rates for hangar space are estimated to be equivalent to the rental rates for warehouse space, with a downward adjustment associated with the characteristics and limited use of the space.

B. Undeveloped Lands

1. General

The majority of the undeveloped lands that are a part of the Hawaii State Airport facilities are comprised of “improved” land for industrial uses. These lands have direct access to the airport ramp.

These “improved” industrial lands are graded with utilities and paved road access within a reasonable distance of the property line. The lands are further differentiated based on whether they are paved or unpaved.

Some airports also have “unimproved” industrial land, which is not graded and lacks utilities and paved road access. Kalaeloa Airport and Kawaihapai Airfield on the island of Oahu and the Kona International Airport on the island of Hawaii are the only airports with unimproved land for industrial use.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 33

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Kahului Airport on the island of Maui is the only airport that has improved and unimproved land for Agricultural use.

(a) Valuation of Improved-Unpaved Industrial Land

The fair market rental rates for the industrial improved-unpaved lands are based on one of two methods (1) the product of the underlying fee simple land value and the prevailing land rate of return or (2) the direct comparison of market land rental rates. In the first method, the fee simple land value within each primary airport complex is estimated by comparison to sales of industrial sites in nearby “off airport” competitive neighborhoods. The land rate of return is estimated based on a review of rates of return from leases of industrial lands and interviews with major land owners. In the second method, actual industrial land rents based on the agreements of land owner and lessee are utilized.

Sufficient “off airport” market data exists to accurately establish the market rents of the fee simple interest of the industrial improved- unpaved lands in the following primary airport areas:

Primary Airport Areas:  Honolulu  Kahului  Kona  Hilo  Lihue

By contrast, there is limited or insufficient market data to accurately estimate the market rates for the benchmark improved-unpaved industrial/commercial lands in the secondary airports in the following areas:

Secondary Airport Areas  Kapalua  Molokai  Lanai

Tertiary Airports  Kalaeloa  Kawaihapi  Kalaupapa  Hana  Waimea-Kohala  Upolu

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 34

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

 Port Allen

The approach to estimate the market rates for the benchmark improved, unpaved industrial lands at the primary airports is outlined as follows:

1. Research general neighborhoods of the benchmark properties for sales or leases of comparable “off airport” industrial properties.

2. Select the most comparable property transactions and confirm the transactions through interviews and recorded documents.

3. Estimate the most appropriate units of comparison after reviewing the various price indicators from the comparable transactions.

4. Analyze the comparable unit price indicators and adjust the unit price indicators to the selected benchmark properties for factors influencing land value.

5. Weight the adjusted unit price indicators based on their reliability.

6. Reconcile the weighted unit price indicators and estimate the land value or land rent of the selected benchmark industrial improved- unpaved lands at the primary airports.

The selected “off airport” transactions that have occurred recently on the various islands are considered similar in physical characteristics and share similar highest and best uses to the benchmark airport designated industrial/commercial properties. As a result, the transactions provide a reliable basis for estimating the market rents for the subject airport industrial classified properties.

The estimated land rents for the benchmark properties in the secondary and tertiary airport areas is based on the 60 percent and 25 percent relationship discussed earlier for retail, office, and industrial space rents.

(b) Calculation of Paving Cost Recovery

The fair market rent for the benchmark industrial improved-unpaved properties are estimated as the product of the fee simple land value and the current prevailing land rate of return or actual market rents per square foot data.

The fair market rents for the benchmark industrial improved-paved properties are based on the market rents for the improved-unpaved

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 35

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

properties with an adjustment for the amortized cost of the paving over their remaining useful lives. Estimated costs for the paving typically found on the paved industrial properties vary by island location.

The base course is estimated to have an indefinite life. By contrast, the useful life of the asphalt-concrete paving is about 10 years. For the purposes of this analysis, the asphalt-concrete paving is estimated to have an effective age of 10.0 years.

Using a discount rate of 5.00 percent, about 150 basis points above the prime lending rate, the annual amount to amortize the paving cost over the remaining useful life is shown in H-3 following.

Table H-3 Paving Costs Useful Life (Yrs) Annual Recovery Paving Base Base Discount County 2" Asph 4" Base Total Paving Course Rate Paving Base Total Honolulu $3.22 $1.65 $4.87 10 30 5.00% $0.42 $0.11 $0.53 Maui $3.53 $1.81 $5.34 10 30 5.00% $0.46 $0.12 $0.58 Hawaii $3.76 $1.93 $5.69 10 30 5.00% $0.49 $0.13 $0.62 Kauai $4.15 $2.13 $6.28 10 30 5.00% $0.54 $0.14 $0.68

(c) Valuation of Unimproved Industrial Land

All airports also have “unimproved” industrial land, which is land that is not graded and that lacks utilities and paved road access. Rates for unimproved lands are discounted from improved, unpaved rates by 25 percent to 50 percent, depending on the distance to paved access and utilities.

2. Estimating Fee Simple Land Values

The same methodology is utilized in the analysis of each primary airport property within each county.

The sales comparison approach is the most common technique for valuing land and is the preferred method when comparable land transactions are available. It is generally considered to be the most reliable approach and was considered the primary method to value the airport lands. Based on the principle of substitution, this method estimates the land rent or value of the land according to prices generally obtained for “off airport” properties with similar locational characteristics and zoning classifications in the surrounding or neighboring areas

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 36

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

The unit land value or unit land rent indications of selected “off airport” transactions is adjusted relative to the subject airport property to compensate for various comparative factors including, terms of sale, market conditions, location, access, physical characteristics and size in order to yield a fee simple unit land value indication or land rent for the subject airport sites.

Common to all land adjustments is the following exception.

(a) Size Adjustment -- A size adjustment is usually considered to compensate for the fact that larger parcels usually tend to reflect lower unit prices while smaller parcels usually reflect higher unit prices. A size curve was not used due to the undetermined size of the subject airport sites.

3. Prevailing Rates of Return on Land

The fair market rental rates of return for the industrial lands surrounding the various airports are based on the product of the underlying fee simple industrial land value and the prevailing land rate of return for “off airport” industrial land.

A survey undertaken of major land owners in Hawaii as well as property managers of major trusts, disclosed that renegotiated ground lease rents have typically been based on fee simple land values consistent with the underlying zoning and highest and best use of the site multiplied by the prevailing market rate of return or contract rate. Rates generally range between 1.0 to 2.0 percent per annum for agricultural uses and up to 4.0 percent for residential uses. Rates for industrial and commercial properties generally range between 6.0 to 8.0 percent per annum. The rates at the lower end of the range typically reflect contract rates contained in older leases. The majority of newer lease rents for industrial and commercial properties are based on a rate of return of 8.0 percent per annum.

Based on the available information, the prospective annual fair market rent for the primary airports, except Hilo, is calculated by applying an 8.0 percent rate of return to the estimated value indication.

Based on the results of research and interviews, it is the appraisers’ opinion that an appropriate annual market rate of return on land for Hilo properties is 6.0 percent of the unencumbered fee simple land value.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 37

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

4. Final Value Adjustments by Use

Rates for unimproved lands within the primary airport areas are discounted from improved, unpaved rates by 25 percent to 50 percent, depending on the distance to paved access and utilities.

5. Concluded Land Values for Secondary and Tertiary Airports

Rental for lands within secondary and tertiary airports was based on the 60 percent and 25 percent relationship of the airport to the primary base airport with the exception of the Kawaihapai Airfield which is 50 percent of Kalaeloa Airport. The relationship of the secondary and tertiary land values to their respective base land value is as follows.

Kalaeloa (Base) Kawaihapai (50%)

Kahului (Base) Molokai (60%) Lanai (60%) Kapalua (60%) Hana (25%)

Kona (Base) Waimea-Kohala (25%) Upolu (25%)

Lihue (Base) Port Allen (25%)

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 38

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

VIII. MARKET ANALYSIS-ISLAND OF HAWAII

This section of the report presents a brief overview of the industrial, office and retail markets for the island of Hawaii. The primary intent of this market analysis is to provide a general assessment of prevailing rental rates, operating expenses and vacancy levels within the local marketplace.

The CoStar 1st Quarter 2016 Industrial, Office and Retail Reports were utilized in the market analysis. The Industrial Report includes all industrial building types including warehouse, flex, distribution, manufacturing, showroom and service buildings, in both single-tenant and multi-tenant buildings, including owner-occupied buildings. The Office Report includes all office building types (Class A, B & C) including office, office condominium, office loft, medical, all classes and all sizes, both multi-tenant and single- tenant buildings, including owner-occupied buildings. The Retail Report includes malls, power centers, shopping centers and specialty centers.

As demonstrated in the 1st Quarter 2016 Industrial Report prepared by the CoStar Group, 5,630,810 square feet of industrial space is located on the Big Island consisting of 5,167,203 square feet of warehouse space and 463,607 square feet of flex space. Flex space is a blended space with at least half of the space consisting of office space and maybe some showroom space. The survey indicated that the entire Big Island industrial market posted 12,296 square feet of positive absorption with most of the gain consisting of warehouse space at 11,314 square feet. The average net asking rent for warehouse space was $0.79 per square foot per month and $0.89 per square foot per month for the flex market. Average vacancy rates for the Big Island industrial market were 1.8 percent for the warehouse market and 1.4 percent for the flex market.

Flex Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption DeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 0 0 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 5 85,362 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.26 Kailua-Kona 5 156,189 5,704 5,704 3.7% 0 0 0 $1.03 Kona/West Big Island 7 222,056 667 667 0.3% 982 0 0 $0.75 Totals 17 463,607 6,371 6,371 1.4% 982 0 0 $0.89

Warehouse Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption DeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 1 13,004 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 221 2,805,623 9,730 9,984 0.4% 1,000 0 0 $0.83 Kailua-Kona 38 740,613 18,976 18,976 2.6% 2,129 0 0 $0.71 Kona/West Big Island 75 1,607,963 61,359 61,359 3.8% 8,185 0 0 $0.84 Totals 335 5,167,203 90,065 90,319 1.8% 11,314 0 0 $0.79

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 39

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Total Industrial Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption DeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 1 13,004 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 226 2,890,985 9,730 9,984 0.3% 1,000 0 0 $0.82 Kailua-Kona 43 896,802 24,680 24,680 2.8% 2,129 0 0 $0.88 Kona/West Big Island 82 1,830,019 62,026 62,026 3.4% 9,167 0 0 $0.83 Totals 352 5,630,810 96,436 96,690 1.7% 12,296 0 0 $0.84

As demonstrated in the 1st Quarter 2016 Office Report prepared by the CoStar Group, there is 2,183,437 square feet of office space on the Big Island consisting of 790,831 square feet of Class B office space and 1,392,606 square feet of Class C office space. The survey indicated that the entire Big Island office market posted 8,191 square feet of negative absorption with most of the negative absorption consisting of Class C office space with both Class A and C office buildings posting negative absorption.

Office Class B Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % AbsorptionDeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 2 25,432 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 17 428,354 6,938 6,938 1.6% (720) 0 0 $2.48 Kailua-Kona 9 123,759 16,933 16,933 13.7% 1,418 0 0 $2.52 Kona/West Big Island 7 213,286 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Totals 35 790,831 23,871 23,871 3.0% 698 0 0 $2.50

Class C Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % AbsorptionDeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 36 291,635 2,437 2,437 0.8% 1,186 0 0 $1.94 Hilo/East Big Island 64 639,660 14,322 14,322 2.2% (10,075) 0 0 $1.97 Kailua-Kona 14 279,773 18,604 19,401 6.9% 0 0 0 $2.61 Kona/West Big Island 18 181,538 14,479 14,479 8.0% 0 0 0 $1.43 Totals 132 1,392,606 49,842 50,639 3.6% (8,889) 0 0 $1.98

Total Office Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total RBA Direct SF Total SF Vac % AbsorptionDeliveriesConst SF Rates Downtown Hilo 38 317,067 2,437 2,437 0.8% 1,186 0 0 $1.94 Hilo/East Big Island 81 1,068,014 21,260 21,260 2.0% (10,795) 0 0 $2.32 Kailua-Kona 23 403,532 35,537 36,334 9.0% 1,418 0 0 $2.57 Kona/West Big Island 25 394,824 14,479 14,479 3.7% 0 0 0 $1.43 Totals 167 2,183,437 73,713 74,510 3.4% (8,191) 0 0 $2.07

The average gross asking rent for office space was $2.50 per square foot per month for Class B office space and $1.98 per square foot per month for Class C office space. Average vacancy rates for the Big Island office market were 3.0 and 3.6 percent for Class B and C office spaces, respectively.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 40

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

As demonstrated in the 1st Quarter 2016 Retail Report prepared by the CoStar Group, 7,989,769 square feet of retail space is located on the Big Island consisting of 5,248,226 square feet of general retail space, 645,381 square feet of mall space and 2,096,162 square feet of shopping center space. The survey indicated that the entire Big Island retail market posted 52,651 square feet of positive absorption with most of the absorption consisting of general retail space at 24,886 square feet. The average net asking rent for general retail space was $1.41 per square foot per month, $2.00 per square foot per month for mall space and $2.01 per square foot per month for shopping center space. The total retail market indicated an average net asking rent of $1.67 per square foot per month. Average vacancy rates for the Big Island retail market were 2.1 percent for the general retail market, 2.7 percent for the mall space market and 5.0 percent for the shopping center market. The total retail market indicated an average vacancy rate of 3.4 percent.

Retail General Retail Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total GLA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption Deliveries Const SF Rates Downtown Hilo 107 804,703 23,298 23,298 2.9% 23,970 0 0 $1.17 Hilo/East Big Island 189 2,053,308 20,875 20,875 1.0% 2,600 0 9,960 $1.07 Kailua-Kona 47 1,070,294 50,484 50,484 4.7% 316 0 0 $1.39 Kona/West Big Island 80 1,319,921 11,482 13,136 1.0% (2,000) 0 0 $1.98 Totals 423 5,248,226 106,139 107,793 2.1% 24,886 0 9,960 $1.41

Mall Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Ctrs Total GLA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption Deliveries Const SF Rates Downtown Hilo 0 0 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 1 510,381 0 39,385 7.7% 0 0 0 $2.00 Kailua-Kona 0 0 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Kona/West Big Island 1 135,000 17,685 17,685 13.1% 4,964 0 0 $0.00 Totals 2 645,381 17,685 57,070 2.7% 4,964 0 0 $2.00

Shopping Center Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Ctrs Total GLA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption Deliveries Const SF Rates Downtown Hilo 0 0 0 0 0.0% 0 0 0 $0.00 Hilo/East Big Island 7 727,075 39,863 39,863 5.5% 16,590 0 0 $1.32 Kailua-Kona 13 517,115 32,198 32,198 6.2% 158 0 0 $2.20 Kona/West Big Island 10 851,972 32,054 32,054 3.8% 6,053 0 0 $2.51 Totals 30 2,096,162 104,115 104,115 5.0% 22,801 0 0 $2.01

Total Retail Submarket Statistics First Quarter 2016 Existing Inventory Vacancy YTD Net YTD Under Quoted Market # Blds Total GLA Direct SF Total SF Vac % Absorption Deliveries Const SF Rates Downtown Hilo 107 804,703 23,298 23,298 2.9% 23,970 0 0 $1.17 Hilo/East Big Island 215 3,290,764 60,738 100,123 3.0% 19,190 0 9,960 $1.50 Kailua-Kona 75 1,587,409 82,682 82,682 5.2% 474 0 0 $1.71 Kona/West Big Island 93 2,306,893 61,221 62,875 2.7% 9,017 0 0 $2.30 Totals 490 7,989,769 227,939 268,978 3.4% 52,651 0 9,960 $1.67

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 41

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Current Industrial, Office and Retail Markets

The CoStar survey indicated that the Big Island industrial market currently has 107,987 square of available space or an average vacancy rate of 1.92 percent for both warehouse and flex space. The average net asking rent for warehouse space is $0.78 per square foot per month.

The Big Island office submarket contains 64,807 square feet or 2.97 percent of vacant space. The average gross asking rent for office space is $2.13 per square foot per month.

The Big Island retail submarket contains 300,641 square feet or 3.76 percent of vacant space. The average net asking rent for retail space is $1.56 per square foot per.

CoStar is projecting that market rents for industrial space will remain stable and decline for both office space and retail space. Vacancy rates for the industrial, office and retail markets for the Big Island are projected to increase.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 42

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

IX. MARKET RENTS – County of Hawaii Automobile Parking & Tie Downs

The following provides an analysis of the County of Hawaii Automobile parking rates and aircraft storage (Tie-Down) rates

A. Rental Rates for Automobile Parking Stalls

All of the Hawaii airports, with the exception of the Upolu Airport and Port Allen Airfield, include parking stalls that are available for rent on a monthly basis. The parking stalls include:

 Covered  Uncovered, both paved and unpaved

Monthly rates for parking stalls vary by demand. The demand for monthly parking within the Hawaii State Airport facilities is estimated to be higher at those airports with higher levels of activity and lower at those airports with lower levels of activity.

The Honolulu International Airport is considered a high level activity airport. Other airports with mid-levels of activity (medium demand areas) measured in terms of passenger enplanements and cargo levels, include:

 Kahului Airport  Hilo International Airport  Kona International Airport  Lihue Airport

The level of activity at these airports is judged to support a similar level of demand for monthly parking as that found in high demand areas but at a reduced rate.

By contrast, low activity levels are judged to result in low demand areas for monthly parking at the following airports:

 Kalaeloa Airport  Kawaihapai Aifield  Kapalua Airport  Hana Airport   Lanai Airport  Waimea-Kohala Airport

Current monthly parking rates in competitive “off airport” market areas in the City and County of Honolulu, County of Maui and County of Hawaii are included in Table H-4.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 43

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-4 COMPARABLE PARKING RENT SURVEY Oahu and Neighbor Islands

Monthly Rate Building Location/Address Unreserved Reserved City and County of Honolulu Covered Parking Downtown Central Business District Bishop Square 1003 Bishop Street $260.00 $415.00 Pacific Guardian Center 733/737 Bishop Street 227.00 457.00 City Financial Tower 201 Merchant Street 235.00 345.00 TOPA Financial Center 700 Bishop Street 210.00 320.00 Executive Center 1088 Bishop Street 240.00 360.00 Bishop Place 1132 Bishop Street 230.00 395.00 Harbor Square 700 Richards Street 250.00 425.00

Outside Fringe Area 215 N. King Street 215 N. King Street 110.00 155.00 Dole Office Building 680 Iwilei Road 150.00 -- former Gentry Pacific Center 560 N. Nimitz Highway 100.00 -- Liliha Professional Building 1520 Liliha Street 120.00 225.00 Airport Trade Center 550 Paiea Street 105.00 --

Uncovered Paved Parking Open Lot 181 Aloha Tower Drive 125.00 175.00 Open Lot 600 Queen Street 170.00 -- Open Lot 888 Nuuanu Avenue 220.00 340.00 County of Maui Covered Parking One Main Plaza 2200 Main Street 70.00 Maui Realty Suites 1885 Main Street 50.00

Uncovered Paved Parking Wells Professional Center 2127 Wells Street 50.00 Diamond Parking - Kihei 2575 S. Kihei Road 50.00 Diamond Parking - Paia 120 Hana Highway 100.00 Diamond Parking - Lahaina Various 50.00 to 80.00 County of Hawaii KONA Uncovered Paved Parking Diamond Parking 75-148 Alii Drive 85.00 Diamond Parking 75-5719 Alii Drive 65.00 Diamond Parking 75-5770 Alii Drive 100.00 Diamond Parking 75-5669 Alii Drive 65.00

HILO Uncovered Paved Parking Open Lot Aupuni Street 51.04 New Kaikoo Building 100 Pauahi Street 25.00 Open Lot Waianuenue Avenue 25.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 44

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

The current rental structure within the State of Hawaii airport facilities are summarized in Table H-5.

Table H-5 CURRENT 2014 AIRPORT PARKING RENTAL RATES State of Hawaii Airports

Monthly Parking Rate Type of Uncovered Demand Covered Paved Unpaved City & County of Honolulu Honolulu International Airport High $150.00 $98.00 $88.00 Kalaeloa Airport Low $39.00 Kawaihapai Airfield Low $39.00

County of Maui Kahului Airport Medium $80.00 $52.00 Kapalua Airport Low $39.00 $35.00 Lanai Airport Low $39.00 $35.00 Molokai Airport Low $39.00 $35.00 Hana Airport Low $39.00 County of Hawaii Hilo International Airport Medium $80.00 $52.00 Kona International Airport Medium $80.00 $52.00 Waimea-Kohala Airport Low $39.00 Upolu Airport N/A County of Kauai Lihue Airport Medium $80.00 $52.00 Port Allen Airfield N/A

(1) Benchmark Rental Rates for Automobile Parking Stalls in the State of Hawaii Airports

Monthly rates for unreserved covered parking stalls in downtown Honolulu cluster between $210.00 and $260.00. Parking rates outside the fringe area, which is on the periphery of downtown Honolulu, range from $105.00 to $120.00 per month.

The Honolulu International Airport is considered to be a high-demand area for parking. However, the demand level is judged to be lower than found in downtown Honolulu. As a result, the parking rate is considered to be at the lower end of the observed rental range.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 45

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Based on the comparable data, the monthly rental rate for a paved, covered parking stall at the Honolulu International Airport, a high-demand area, is estimated at about $170.00.

Current 2014 parking rates for uncovered parking stalls at the Honolulu International Airport are 35 percent lower than the rate for covered stalls. Utilizing the current differential results in a monthly rental rate for a paved uncovered parking stall about $110.00.

Rental Rate for Paved-Uncovered Parking Stalls Paved-Covered Stall $170.00 Adjustment to Uncovered x .65 Paved-Uncovered Stall $110.00

Rental rates for unpaved-uncovered parking facilities were not available. To the parking stall user, the disutility associated with a parking stall in an unpaved lot is judged to be relatively low compared to the same stall in a paved lot. For this analysis, the adjustment from a paved parking rate to an unpaved parking rate is estimated at -10 percent. As a result, the monthly rental rate for an unpaved-uncovered parking stall is estimated to be about $99.00.

Rental Rate for Unpaved, Uncovered Parking Stalls Paved-Uncovered Stall $110.00 Adjustment to Unpaved -10 % Unpaved-Uncovered Stall $99.00

Rental rates for uncovered parking stalls in low demand areas on Oahu are estimated at a reduced rate of 40 percent from the medium demand areas.

Rental Rate for Paved, Uncovered Parking Stalls Paved-Uncovered Stall $110.00 Adjustment to Unpaved -40 % Unpaved-Uncovered Stall $66.00

(2) Rental Rates for Parking Stalls on the Neighbor Islands

Medium Demand Airports

As seen in Table H-4, the monthly covered parking rates in medium-demand areas on the neighbor islands range from about $50.00 to $100.00 per stall. Based on the comparable data, the monthly rental rate for a covered parking stall in medium-demand areas within the Hawaii State Airport facilities on the

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 46

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

neighbor islands is estimated at about $85.00. From the market data, uncovered paved parking is estimated at $55.00.

Low Demand Airports

Rental rates for covered parking stalls in low demand areas were estimated at a reduced rate of 25 percent from the medium demand areas.

Rental Rate for Paved-Uncovered Parking Stalls

Paved-Uncovered Stall (Medium Demand) $55.00 Adjustment to Low Demand -25 % Paved-Uncovered Stall (Low Demand) $41.00

The adjustment from a paved-uncovered parking rate to an unpaved- uncovered parking rate is estimated at -10 percent. As a result, the monthly rental rate for an unpaved-uncovered parking stall is estimated to be about $37.00.

Rental Rate for an Unpaved-Uncovered Parking Stall Paved-Uncovered Stall $41.00 Adjustment to Unpaved -10 % Unpaved-Uncovered Stall $37.00

(3) Concluded Automobile Parking Rates (County of Hawaii)

Based on the preceding analysis, the estimated fair market rental rates for the benchmark parking stalls within the County of Hawaii airport facilities as of July 1, 2016 are presented in Table H-6.

Table H-6 PROPOSED AIRPORT PARKING RENTAL RATES County of Hawaii Airports Monthly Parking Rate Type of Uncovered Airports Demand Covered Paved Unpaved Hilo International Airport Medium $85.00 $55.00 Kona International Airport Medium $85.00 $55.00 Waimea-Kohala Airport Low $41.00 Upolu Airport N/A

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 47

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

B. Estimated Rental Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie-Down)

Rental rates for aircraft storage areas (Tie Down) are estimated separately from the individual Hawaii airports analysis since the basic market data is extracted from areas outside of the State of Hawaii. It is felt that the data is basically common to all Hawaii airports and not related to the specific airports environs.

General aviation aircraft storage includes uncovered tie-down areas for small (single & twin engine) and large aircraft. The small aircraft tie-down storage areas can accommodate aircraft with a wing-span of up to 42 feet. By contrast, the large aircraft tie-down storage areas can accommodate aircraft with a wing-span from 43 feet to 60 feet.

As seen in Table H-7 monthly rates for small aircraft storage at eleven general aviation smaller “secondary” airports on the mainland United States ranged from $50 to $140 and averaged about $90. Similarly, monthly rates for large aircraft at some of these airports ranged from $108 to $225. Excluding the extremes, the comparable mainland data supports a monthly rent for small aircraft of about $90.00 and for large aircraft storage of about $130.00.

Table H-7 COMPARABLE AIRCRAFT (TIE DOWN) STORAGE RATES Various Mainland Airports

Small Aircraft Large Aircraft Airport (Daily) Monthly (Daily) Monthly California Airports Santa Monica Municipal, Santa Monica $16.68 $113.41 $33.36 $170.12 Redding Municipal, Redding 71.00 112.00 Santa Barbara Airport 116.00 Lompoc Airfield, Lompoc 85.00 Hayward Executive, East Bay-SFO 8.00 75.00 12-22 108-216 John Wayne Airport, Irvine 140.00 169.00 Napa County Airport, Napa 15.00 100.00 15.00+ 225.00+ Torrance Airport, Torrance 15.00 105.44 Washington Airports Harvey Field, Snohomish 5.00 60.00 Olympia Airport, Olympia 10.00 85.70 Bellingham Airport, Bellingham 50.00 100.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 48

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Based on the observed data, the monthly rental rates for small and large aircraft storage at the smaller secondary Hawaii airports (Kapalua, Molokai, Lanai) are estimated to be $90.00 and $130.00, respectively.

Considering the current relationship, the monthly rental rate at the Hawaii major airports is estimated to be 60 percent higher than those rates at the smaller secondary airports. As a result, monthly rental rates for small and large aircraft storage at the Hawaii major airports is estimated to be $144.00 and $208.00, respectively.

Similarly, the current relationship of monthly rental rates at the Hawaii tertiary airports are estimated to be 40 percent lower than those rates at the smaller secondary airports. As a result, monthly rental rates for small and large aircraft storage at the Hawaii tertiary airports are estimated to be $54.00 and $78.00, respectively.

The transient overnight daily rental rates at the selected mainland general aviation airports ranged between $5.00 and $15.00 for small aircraft and $10.00 to $20.00 for large aircraft. The transient overnight daily rates for Hawaii airports are forecast at $10.00 and $20.00 for small and large aircraft, respectively, at the major airports. The transient overnight daily rates for Hawaii airports are forecast at $5.00 and $10.00 for small and large aircraft, respectively, at the secondary and tertiary airports.

Based on these considerations, the current and proposed fair market rental rates for the aircraft storage areas within the County of Hawaii airport facilities are shown in Table H-8.

Table H-8 PROPOSED AIRCRAFT TIE DOWN STORAGE RATES County of Hawaii Airports CURRENT 2014 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Hilo International Airport $10.00 $96.00 $20.00 $136.00 Kona International Airport $10.00 $96.00 $20.00 $136.00 Waimea-Kohala Airport $5.00 $24.00 $10.00 $34.00 Upolu Airport $5.00 $24.00 $10.00 $34.00 PROPOSED 2016 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Hilo International Airport $10.00 $144.00 $20.00 $208.00 Kona International Airport $10.00 $144.00 $20.00 $208.00 Waimea-Kohala Airport $5.00 $54.00 $10.00 $78.00 Upolu Airport $5.00 $54.00 $10.00 $78.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 49

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

X. KONA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AT KEAHOLE (KOA)

A. Airport Description

Kona International Airport at Keahole occupies 3,348 acres of land about seven miles northwest of Kailua-Kona on the island of Hawaii. The airport accommodates domestic overseas, international, interisland, commuter/air taxi, and general aviation activities. It has an 11,000-foot and a complex of facilities at the eastern edge of the airfield for arriving and departing passengers, air cargo and mail, airport support and general aviation operations. These facilities are served by an access roadway extending from the Queen Kaahumanu Highway. At the passenger terminals, the access roadway forms a one-way loop enclosing public parking and rental car check-in facilities. An additional complex of facilities, used primarily by rental car agencies, general maintenance, and storage is located along the airport access roadway, midway between the passenger terminals and the highway. General aviation, cargo, and related facilities are located on the south of the passenger terminals and the access roadway.

B. Environs

The Kona International Airport at Keahole is located along the western, or makai, side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway, in the Keahole area of the North Kona District of the Island of Hawaii. The entrance to the property from Queen Kaahumanu Highway is located just north of the entrance to the Kaloko Light Industrial Park.

The North Kona and South Kona Districts and the North Kohala and South Kohala Districts of the Island of Hawaii comprise the general region commonly referred to as West Hawaii. Over the past two decades, West Hawaii has gradually evolved from its former rural, agricultural profile to more of an increasingly urban environment. The majority of its residential communities and urban activities are concentrated within the lower elevation, coastal area. A large majority of the residential growth and most of the centralized commercial and industrial activities are located within the North Kona District, in relative proximity to Kailua Village, which is also referred to as Kailua-Kona.

The subject airport is located within the established, Kailua-to-Keahole urban area, approximately eight miles north of Kailua-Kona.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 50

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 51

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 52

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

C. Rental Analysis

(1) Space Rents

The fair market rental rates for the typical benchmark warehouse, finished office and retail related spaces at the Kona International Airport are based on the current “off airport” rent levels for warehouse, office and retail space in the Kailua-Kona competitive market area.

(a) Retail Space Rents

The results of our market rent survey for “off airport” retail rents are presented within Table H-9.

Table H-9 COMPARABLE RETAIL RENT SURVEY Kailua-Kona, Hawaii

Lease Lease Area in Monthly Rent Per SqFt Start Term Location Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) Hotel King Kamehameha 602 $3.00 - - Jun-14 2

Kona Marketplace I & II 891 $2.59 $1.19 $3.78 Mar-15 4

75-5805 Alii Drive 525 $4.51 - - Jan-15 3

Henry Street Landing 990-1,800 $3.00 $0.60 $3.60 Asking 3

Alii Sunset Plaza 630-2,880 $2.75 $1.04 $3.79 Asking 3

King Kamehameha Mall 372-1,152 $2.00 $1.05 $3.05 Asking 3

As demonstrated in this schedule, actual retail net space rents range basically from $2.59 to $4.51 per square foot per month with asking gross rents ranging from $3.05 to $3.79 per square foot. Based on conversations with various brokers and leasing agents, base rents can vary depending on the size of space, quality and location. Currently monthly common area maintenance (CAM) expenses on a square foot basis generally range from $0.60 to $1.19 depending on the expense items paid individually by each tenant. In most cases the upper end rents represent spaces with excellent street frontage exposure and smaller space. Leasing concessions were found to be negotiable depending on the strength and desirability of the tenant and term of the negotiated lease.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 53

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate a benchmark retail market rent for “off airport” retail type space ranging from $2.75 to $3.50 per square foot per month.

(b) Office Space Rents

The results of the market rent survey for “off airport” office rents are presented within Table H-10.

Table H-10 COMPARABLE OFFICE SPACE RENT SURVEY Kailua-Kona, Hawaii

Floor Area in Monthly Rent Per SqFt Lease Term Location Level Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) Lanihau Professional Center 2nd 679 $1.50 - - Apr-16 - 75-5591 Palani Road 2nd 563 $1.55 - - Dec-15 2 2nd 1,225 $1.50 - - May-15 - 2nd 1,839 $1.65 - - Asking - Holomua Center 1st 600 $2.14 - - May-15 3 Palani Court 1st 180 $1.35 $0.96 $2.31 Mar-15 1 74-5620 Palani Road 1st 1,544 $1.25 $0.96 $2.21 Asking - 2nd 1,830 $1.25 $0.96 $2.21 Asking - Kuakini Tower 1st 1,503 $1.49 $1.73 $3.22 Mar-15 2 75-5722 Kuakini Highway 1st-2nd 490-944 $1.25 $1.73 $2.98 Asking 3

Kamanu Center 2nd 3,263 $1.75 - - Mar-14 3 75-1000 Henry Street 2nd 1,208-2,332 $2.00 $0.90 $2.90 Asking - Kamanu Center II 2nd-3rd 1,000-6,000 $1.75 $0.60 $2.35 Asking - 73-5590 Kauhola Street 1st 900 $1.78 $0.19 $1.97 Asking 3 Central Kona Center 1st 1,406-3,456 $1.25 $0.82 $2.07 Asking 3 Paa Pono Building 2nd 758-1,817 $1.25 $0.79 $2.04 Asking 3

As demonstrated in this schedule, actual office space rents range from $1.50 to $2.14 per square foot per month with asking net rents ranging from $1.25 to $1.78 per square foot. Similarly, actual gross rents range from $2.31 to $3.22 per square foot with asking gross rents ranging from $1.97 to $2.98 per square foot. Based on conversations with various brokers and leasing agents, base rents can vary depending on the size of space, quality and location. Currently monthly common area maintenance (CAM) expenses on a square foot basis generally range from $0.60 to $1.73 depending on the expense items paid individually by each tenant. There does not seem to be much of a difference for upper floor rents as compared to ground floor rents. Leasing concessions were found to be

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 54

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

negotiable depending on the strength and desirability of the tenant and term of the negotiated lease.

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate “off airport” benchmark office space at $1.50 to $2.00 per square foot per month for office space.

(c) Industrial Space Rents

Table H-11 presents a summary of the results of the “off airport” market rent survey of the Kona Industrial Subdivision and Kaloko Light Industrial Subdivision.

Table H-11 COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL FLEX AND WAREHOUSE SPACE RENT SURVEY Kailua-Kona, Hawaii Type of Area in Monthly Rent Per SqFt Lease Term Location Space Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) Hansen Warehouse Flex Whse 10,426 $1.25 $0.39 $1.64 May-14 5 73-4164 Hulikoa Drive Flex Whse 2,930 $1.30 $0.39 $1.69 Asking 3 APB Kona II Building Flex Whse 8,000 $1.00 $0.23 $1.23 Dec-14 5 73-4080 Hulikoa Drive Flex Whse 267-1,395 $1.00-$1.25 0.23 $1.23-$1.48 Asking 3 74-5552 & 74-5546 Kaiwi St. Flex Whse 3,500 $1.50 $0.42 $1.92 Asking - Kuakini Center Flex Whse 480-960 $1.10-$1.45 $0.76 $1.86-$2.21 Asking - 74-5563 Kaiwi Street APB Kona I Building Flex Whse 1,250-3,633 $1.00-$1.10 $0.27 $1.27-$1.37 Asking 3 73-4273 Hulikoa Drive Kaahumanu Plaza Flex Whse 627-3,282 $1.45 $0.58 $2.03 Asking 3 74-5467 Kaiwi Street

Based on the research, actual monthly warehouse rents Hulikoa industrial area generally ranged from $1.00 to $1.25 per square foot per month on a net basis with actual gross rents ranging from $1.23 to $1.64. Market rents for smaller-sized, finished warehouse space tend to be at the high end of this range. Additional monthly rent was in the form of CAM (Common Area Maintenance) recoveries ranging from $0.23 to $0.76 per square foot per month. Tenant lease terms typically range from three to five years in duration with provisions for step-up increases averaging three percent per year. The Kaloko Light Industrial subdivision is also a highly desirable area due to the drawing power of Costco and Home Depot are located within this park.

The Kona Industrial Subdivision is becoming more of a quasi-retail area with asking rents for warehouse space ranging from $1.10 to $1.45 per

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 55

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

square foot per month. CAM expenses range from $0.42 to $0.76 per square foot per month. The CAM expenses in this development are higher because of its leasehold status and portions of or all of the ground rent is passed through to the tenants.

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate “off airport” benchmark industrial space at $1.10 to $1.35 per square foot per month.

(d) Conclusion of Rents within Terminal Building

Numerous projects were surveyed in order to ascertain the “off airport” market rent for areas classified under the category of retail, office and industrial space in the Kona area. In each case, each of the property types surveyed is located within close proximity to the Kona International Airport. The retail and office product is primarily situated within the Kailua Town area. The industrial properties presented for comparison purposes are generally located in the Kailua Town and Hulikoa area, nearby the airport.

For the most part, the retail projects tend to support a range in retail rent from $2.75 to $3.50 per square foot per month, net, or $33.00 to $42.00 per square foot per year. Similarly, office projects tend to support a range of $1.50 to $2.00 per square foot per month or $18.00 to $24.00 per square foot per annum. One might conclude that similar space within the terminal might fall toward the upper end of the market.

A variety of industrial properties were researched for direct comparison purposes. While the overall range in rent varies from $1.00 to $1.50 per square foot per month net, the most representative range approximates $1.10 to $1.35 per square foot per month, or $13.20 to $16.20 per square foot per year. Typically speaking, the highest rent comparisons are those buildings that are best suited for flex warehouse use. In the case of industrial properties, size seems to have less influence on the ultimate rental rate. Moreover, office build-out appears to have little impact on overall rent as well. Lease terms generally range from three to five years. Most agreements provide for rent adjustments during the term, either annual CPI or periodic fixed increases. Tenant improvements are marginal.

Overall market softness over the years has resulted in artificially low rental rates for the Kona retail and office market. Given the special purpose nature of the subject property, coupled with its inherent amenities, higher rental rates would not be judged unreasonable, in the appraisers’ opinion.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 56

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

With respect to industrial space the comparisons are judged a reasonable indication of potential rent. However, properties in and around an airport that are suitable for airfreight use typically generate slightly higher rental rates when compared to standard industrial space. As such, it is reasonable to assume that such space on the airport might generate a slight premium in comparison.

Therefore, in light of the foregoing, the appraisers estimate the following rental rates for each classification of subject space via direct comparison with off-airport properties of somewhat similar use characteristics.

Rent/ Rent/ Category of Space Mo./S.F. Year/S.F. Retail $3.00 $36.00 Office 1.75 21.00 Warehouse 1.25 15.00

Given the difficulty in comparing off-airport property to on-airport property, this direct comparison approach will probably reveal the low end of the potential range in rent for the subject terminal since a return on cost of construction would probably result in higher required rents. While it should be supported in the marketplace that on-airport property generates higher rents when compared to similar property off-airport, the actual adjustment is not always clear.

From the indicated “benchmark” indications for the three basic space categories additional judgmental adjustments were made to reflect airport passenger use. A downward adjustment of 10 percent was made for concessionaire – food and beverage space as compared to concessionaire - retail sales space. An upward adjustment of 25 percent was made for VIP Lounge space as compared to general office space.

(e) Conclusion of Rents within Air Taxi Building

Rents within the Air Taxi Building were considered similar by category as the Main Terminal Building but reflecting a ten percent discount for quality of construction.

(2) Industrial Land Rents

The fair market rental rates for the various industrial lands within the airport are based on off-airport land data. The analysis first estimates the land rent for a benchmark improved-unpaved land by direct comparison with the off-

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 57

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

airport data. The fair market rents for improved-paved and unimproved are calculated as percentages of the benchmark improved-unpaved conclusion.

(a) Calculation of Industrial Improved-Unpaved Land Rent

This section of the report presents a brief overview of the Kailua-Kona industrial “off airport” land market which includes the Kaloko Light Industrial Subdivision, Kaloko Business Park and the Kaloko Commercial Center. These areas represent fee simple properties. The intent of this market analysis is to provide a meaningful assessment of the unit land values within the Kona International Airport’s immediate “off airport” area. The Kaloko area was employed as a basis for estimating industrial land rents for the Kona International Airport.

Market Data

Of the transactions disclosed by our investigation, five fee simple land sales were analyzed to establish a value index for the subject airport’s improved-unpaved land. These transactions are detailed following and analyzed in Table H-12.

Table H-12 COMPARABLE FEE SIMPLE LAND TRANSACTIONS ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE Kona International Airport North Kona, Island of Hawaii

Transaction Number Subject 1 2 3 4 5 Third Division, Tax Map Key Kona Intl. Airport 7-3-51-68 7-3-51-85 7-3-51-114 7-3-51-127 7-3-51-51 Subdivision Kaloko Kaloko Kaloko Kaloko Kaloko Lot Location Interior Interior Interior Interior Interior Land Area - Square Feet 43,749 50,879 52,490 51,836 87,128 Zoning MCX-1A ML-1A MCX-1A MCX-1A ML-1A

Transaction Date 07-Apr-15 08-May-15 22-Jun-15 23-Jul-15 30-Dec-15 Instrument/Financing Deed Deed Deed Deed Deed Indicated Price $800,000 $830,000 $787,347 $731,808 $1,800,000 Indicated Price Per Sq.Ft. $18.29 $16.31 $15.00 $14.12 $20.66 Terms of Sale Adjustment 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Adjusted Price $18.29 $16.31 $15.00 $14.12 $20.66 Market Conditions Adjustment 1.03 1.03 1.03 1.03 1.01 Market Conditions Adjusted Unit Value $18.84 $16.80 $15.45 $14.54 $20.87 Adjustments (%) Location 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% Physical Characteristics 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% Net Adjustments (%) 5% 5% 5% 5% 5%

Adjusted Unit Value $19.78 $17.64 $16.22 $15.27 $21.91 Size Adjustment 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Size Adjusted Unit Value $19.78 $17.64 $16.22 $15.27 $21.91 Weighting Factor 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 Product $3.96 $3.53 $3.24 $3.05 $4.38

Range of Values $15.27 to $21.91 per sq.ft. Mean Unit Value $18.16 per square foot Weighted Unit Value $18.16 per square foot Concluded Unit Value $18.00 per square foot

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 58

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Transaction Number 1 represents the fee simple purchase of a 43,749 square foot MCX-1A, Industrial Commercial Mixed Use District zoned vacant site located at 73-5601 Olowalu Street in the Kaloko Business Park area which is located on the mauka side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway. This sale occurred on April 7 2015 and recorded on April 13, 2015 in Document 55810164. The indicated sales price was $800,000 or $18.29 per square foot. The previous sale of this property was on July 21, 2011 for $630,00 or $14.40 per square foot indicating a compound rate of increase of approximately six percent.

Transaction Number 2 represents the fee simple purchase of a 50,879 square foot ML-1A, Limited Industrial District zoned vacant site located along Kauhola Street in the Kaloko Business Park area which is located on the mauka side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway. This sale occurred on May 8 7 2015 and recorded on May 29, 2015 in Document 56270095. The indicated sales price was $830,000 or $16.31 per square foot.

Transaction Number 3 represents the fee simple purchase of a 52,490 square foot MCX-1A, Industrial Commercial Mixed Use District zoned vacant site located along Kamanu Street in the Kaloko Commercial Center area which is located on the mauka side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway. This sale occurred on June 22, 2015 and recorded on June 30, 2015 in Document 56590432. The indicated sales price was $787,347 or $15.00 per square foot.

Transaction Number 4 represents the fee simple purchase of a 51,836 square foot MCX-1A, Industrial Commercial Mixed Use District zoned vacant site located along Kamanu Street in the Kaloko Commercial Center area which is located on the mauka side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway. This sale occurred on July 23, 2015 and recorded on July 31, 2015 in Document 56900133. The indicated sales price was $731,808 or $14.12 per square foot.

Transaction Number 5 represents the fee simple purchase of an 87,128 square foot ML-1A, Limited Industrial District zoned vacant site located at 73-5588 Lawehana Street in the Kaloko Light Industrial Subdivision area which is located on the mauka side of Queen Kaahumanu Highway. This sale occurred on December 30, 2015 and recorded on December 30, 2015 in Document 58420519. The indicated sales price was $1,800,000 or $20.66 per square foot.

Adjustments

Each transaction was adjusted for various comparative factors including

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 59

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

terms of sale, market conditions, location and physical Characteristics.

Terms of Sale -- Comparable “off airport” transactions were analyzed as to economic and financing conditions (terms of sale) to reflect the impact of non-institutional methods of financing or the advent of low financing costs due to favorable exchange rates and foreign financing. Down payment, interest rates and loan terms were considered in the cash equivalency analysis. All transactions were considered to be cash equivalent transactions thus no adjustments were required for terms of sale.

Market Conditions -- This factor is used to adjust historical property transactions to the effective date of appraisal. From around the beginning of 2008, prevailing market conditions would characterize the overall Hawaii real estate market in general terms as being in a down cycle. The frequency of industrial land transactions began to decline at the end of 2009 in the Kailua-Kona area and started prices started to stabilize towards the end of 2011. From early January 2010 through December 2012, the market was considered to be in a stabilized condition. After January 1, 2013, a positive three percent annual adjustment was made all the comparables to reflect the strengthening in the industrial/commercial markets.

Location -- The location adjustment considered the relative location of the comparables to the subject as to potential development desirability and exposure. All transactions are considered relatively equal to the subject airport lands and therefore require no adjustments.

Physical Characteristics -- The physical characteristics adjustment considered the shape, topography and utility factors of the comparables in terms of development potential as compared to the subject. All the comparable transactions were considered inferior based on the level developable terrain of the airport compared to the sloping terrain of the Kaloko industrial subdivision and adjusted upward five percent.

Conclusion Fee Simple Improved-Unpaved Land Value -- The adjusted unit values ranged from $15.27 to $21.91 per square foot with a mean unit value of $18.16 per square foot. Based on the market data in Table H-7, the appraisers conclude a market land value for a comparable area within the Kona International Airport of $18.00 per square foot.

Rent Conclusion Improved-Unpaved Land -- Applying a 8.0 percent market rate of return indicates an indicated fair market annual rent for industrial improved-unpaved land of $1.44 per square foot.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 60

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Fee Simple Improved-Unpaved Land Value $18.00 Market Rate of Return x .08 Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $ 1.44

(b) Calculation of Industrial Improved-Paved Land Rents

The market rents for the benchmark industrial improved-paved land are based on the market rents for the improved-unpaved industrial properties with an adjustment for the amortized cost of the paving over their remaining useful lives.

Adding $0.62 for the estimated annual recovery for paving estimated earlier in Table H-3 results in an annual rent for industrial improved-paved land of $2.06.

Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $1.44 Add Annual Rent for Paving .62 Annual Rent Improved-Paved Land $2.06

(c) Calculation of Industrial Unimproved Land Rents

The Kona International Airport also has industrial unimproved land, which is land that is not graded and lacks utilities and paved road access. Rates for unimproved industrial lands are discounted from improved, unpaved rates by 25 percent to 50 percent, depending on the distance to paved access and utilities.

Considering the distance from utilities and paved road access and the associated cost, the fair market rental rate for the industrial unimproved- unpaved lands are estimated discounted 50 percent from the industrial improved-unpaved land rate.

Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $1.44 Discount Factor x .50 Annual Rent Unimproved-Unpaved Land $0.72

(d) Ramp Area Rents

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark open (uncovered) ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be similar to the annual rent estimated for the industrial paved and unpaved improved lands.

Based on the relationship between covered and uncovered parking stalls, the fair market rental rates for the covered ramp equipment parking areas

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 61

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

are estimated to be 50 percent higher than the rental rates for the paved open areas.

(3) Rental Rates for T-Hangar Spaces

Hangar spaces (T-Hangars and End Rooms) are available for rent at the following airports within the County of Hawaii:

 Kona International Airport  Hilo International Airport

Historically, the rental rates for hangar space are estimated to be equivalent to the rental rates for warehouse space, with a downward adjustment associated with the characteristics and limited use of the space.

As detailed earlier, the concluded 2016 benchmark rents for warehouse space was estimated based on an analysis of current industrial warehouse rents as follows: Current Whse Rent Per SqFt Airport Monthly Annually Kona $1.25 $15.00

Based on the characteristics and limited use of the space a discount rate of 40 percent was considered reasonable. Application of the 40 percent discount rate results in the following benchmark hangar rate.

Monthly Monthly Warehouse Hangar Airport Rate Discount Rate Kona $1.25 40% $0.75

Table H-13 summarizes existing 2014 Hawaii Airport T-Hangar and End room rents compared to our projected 2016 rental rates.

Table H-13 PROPOSED RENTAL RATES FOR T-HANGAR SPACES Hangars and End Rooms Kona International Airport 2014 2016 2016 Actual 2014 2016 Estimated Projected Rent Monthly Whse Area Warehouse Use Per Monthly Type of Space Rent Rent (Sqft) Rent Adjust. Sq. Ft. Total Building 400 T-Hangar $438.00 $0.90 968 $1.25 -40% $0.75 $726.00 Building 400 End Room $219.00 $0.90 475 $1.25 -40% $0.75 $356.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 62

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Commercial use of the space, other than plane storage and maintenance, is at the non-discounted rate of $1.25 per square foot.

(4) Concluded Automobile Parking Rates

Parking rates were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-4, H-5 and H-6). The conclusions in Table H-6 are as follows.

PROPOSED AIRPORT PARKING RENTAL RATES

Monthly Parking Rate Type of Uncovered Airports Demand Covered Paved Unpaved Kona International Airport Medium $85.00 $55.00

(5) Concluded Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie Down) Areas

Tie-down rents were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-7 and H-8). The conclusions in Table H-8 are as follows.

PROPOSED AIRCRAFT TIE DOWN STORAGE RATES

CURRENT 2014 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Kona International Airport $10.00 $96.00 $20.00 $136.00

PROPOSED 2016 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Kona International Airport $10.00 $144.00 $20.00 $208.00

6) Rental Conclusions for Kona International Airport

Table H-14 summarizes rent projections for the designated terminal buildings, industrial lands, ramp areas, plane hangars, automobile parking and aircraft storage within the Kona International Airport facility.

7) Rental Conclusions for Special Properties- Kona International Airport

Table H-15 summarizes the rent projections for the designated Kona Special Properties.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 63

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-14 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS KONA INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT AT KEAHOLE Kona, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Terminal Floor Space (non-air carrier) $27.00 $2.25 $36.00 $3.00 Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) $27.00 $2.25 $36.00 $3.00 Concessionaire-Food & Beverage (F) $24.30 $2.03 $32.40 $2.70 VIP Lounge (F) $22.50 $1.88 $26.25 $2.19 Office (F) (non-air carrier) $18.00 $1.50 $21.00 $1.75 Storage $5.40 $0.45 $7.50 $0.63 Air Taxi Building Ticket Counter (F) $24.30 $2.03 $32.40 $2.70 Office (F) $16.20 $1.35 $18.90 $1.58 Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers $14.40 N/A $16.80 $1.40 Cargo $10.80 $0.90 $15.00 $1.25 Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved $1.19 $0.10 $1.44 $0.12 Improved Land-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17 Unimproved Land-Unpaved $0.60 $0.05 $0.72 $0.06 Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Paved (non-air carrier) $2.54 $0.21 $3.09 $0.26 Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved (non-air carrier) $1.79 $0.15 $2.16 $0.18 Open Equipment Parking-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved $1.19 $0.10 $1.44 $0.12 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved $1.69 $0.14 $2.06 $0.17

T-Hangars Per Month Per Month Per Sqft/Mo Bldg 403-102 to 110, T-Hangars (968sf) $438.00 $726.00 $0.75 Bldg 404-105 to 112, T-Hangars (968sf) $439.00 $726.00 $0.75 Bldg 403-101 and 111, End Room (475sf) $219.00 $356.00 $0.75 Bldg 404-103 and 113, End Room (475sf) $5.40 $356.00 $0.75 T-Hangar Used as Commercial Space -- -- $1.25 Automobile Parking Covered-Paved Parking Per Month $80.00 Per Month $85.00 Uncovered-Paved Parking Per Month $52.00 Per Month $55.00 Aircraft Storage Charges Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $96.00 Per Month $144.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $20.00 Per Day $20.00 Per Month $136.00 Per Month $208.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 64

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-15 Kona International Airport at Keahole Special Properties Kona, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Concluded Rents Map Bldg Tenant Area Use Condition Sqft/ Mo. Sqft/ Year

AOA2 106 Civil Air Patrol 2,912 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 109 Tiares 500 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 110 Aero Sleek 240 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 111 Tropic Bird 320 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 112 Delta 440 Trailer Fair $1.30 $15.60

AOA2 113 Securitas 935 Trailer Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 006-103 Hawaii Air Ventures 1,157 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

AOA2 347 Old ARFF Building 6,064 Office Fair $0.90 $10.80

AOA3 001-107 JTB Building 10,300 Office Good $1.75 $21.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 65

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Kona-Terminal Floor Space

Kona-Concessionaire, Food & Beverage

Kona-Concessionaire, Retail

Kona- VIP Lounge

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 66

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Kona - Air Taxi Building

Kona - Building 001-107 JTB

Kona - Building 006-103 Old Hawaii Air Ventures

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 67

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Kona - Cargo Building 103

Kona - Cargo Building 104

Kona - Building 106 Civil Air Patrol

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 68

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Kona - Building113 Securitas

Kona - Building 347 Old ARFF Building

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 69

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

X. HILO INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT (ITO)

A. Airport Description

Hilo International Airport occupies 1,247 acres about two miles east of Hilo, on the eastern shore of the island of Hawaii. The airport’s primary runway (8-26) is 9,800 feet long and is used principally for air carrier operations. Crosswind Runway 3-21 is 5,600 feet long and is used mainly for general aviation operations. The passenger terminal complex, including commuter facilities, is at the southern edge of the airport and is served by an access roadway from Kekuanaoa Avenue, between the passenger terminal complex and the crosswind runway to the west. General aviation facilities are located along the eastern edge of the crosswind runway also served by the terminal access roadway. A parking apron for transient military aircraft is provided at the western edge of the runway.

B. Environs

The Hilo International Airport is located within the City of Hilo, in the South Hilo District of the Island of Hawaii. The South Hilo District is located on the eastern or windward side of the Island of Hawaii

Historically, the South Hilo District and the City of Hilo have represented the dominant areas of urban development and population for the entire Island of Hawaii. More recently, however, the Kona and Kohala Districts have grown increasingly less dependent upon the Hilo area. As such, the present role of the South Hilo District and the City of Hilo as a major regional urban center is somewhat more limited to primarily the East Hawaii region. The City of Hilo, however, remains the County seat and is the location of all major government activity. Hilo’s deep-draft harbor facilities and its airport function as primary transportation gateways to the Island of Hawaii.

The airport’s immediate neighborhood is the Kaei Hana I Industrial Subdivision. This light industrial subdivision is situated in proximity to the Kanoelehua Industrial Area and the Prince Kuhio Plaza/Waiakea Center retail district. The Kaei Hana I Industrial Subdivision and Kanoelehua Industrial Area are located south of the airport along either side of Kanoelehua Avenue. The combination of these two developments represents the principal industrial district within the greater Hilo area. Properties located within this area are typically zoned for either industrial or commercial use, and the large majority of land in the area is owned by the State of Hawaii, under the administration and management of either the Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) or the Department of Hawaiian Homes Lands (DHHL).

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 70

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 71

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 72

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

C. Rental Analysis

(1) Space Rents

The fair market rental rates for the typical benchmark warehouse, finished office and retail related spaces at the Hilo International Airport are based on the current “off airport” rent levels for office and retail space in the Hilo competitive market area.

Throughout the greater Hilo area, the depth of leasing demand in both the commercial and industrial markets is comparatively shallow. Lack of widespread commercial growth in the marketplace tends to be more a function of the local economy and the absence of a strong economic base. Without a strong, driving economic force capable of generating and sustaining its growth, Hilo’s commercial and industrial sectors are likely to continue to be populated by a collection of small-scale support services and entrepreneurial enterprises.

a) Retail Space Rents

The results of our market rent survey for “off airport” retail rents are presented within Table H-16.

Table H-16 COMPARABLE RETAIL RENT SURVEY Hilo, Hawaii Area in Monthly Rent Per SqFt Lease Term Location Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) Waiakea Square Warehouse 2,240 $1.86 - - Mar-15 4 1142 Ainaola Drive 2,148 $1.39 - - Mar-16 4 Kinoole Building 4,447 $2.00 $0.20 $2.20 Asking - Holomua Center 1,641 $2.00 $0.56 $2.56 Asking 3 Waiakea Square 1,466-1,611 $1.25 $0.53 $1.78 Asking 3 Lau Building 832-1,002 $1.25 $0.25 $1.50 Asking 3 Kaikodo Building 65-2,880 - - $2.25 Asking 3 S. Hata Building 470-1,489 $2.25 $1.04 $3.29 Asking 3

As demonstrated in this schedule, actual net retail space rents range from $1.39 to $1.86 per square foot per month with asking net rents ranging from$1.25 to $2.25 per square foot. Asking monthly gross rents range from $1.50 to $3.29 per square foot. Based on conversations with various brokers and leasing agents, base rents can vary depending on the size of space, quality and location. Currently the basic monthly common area

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 73

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

maintenance (CAM) expenses on a square foot basis ranging from $0.20 to $1.04 depending on the expense items paid individually by each tenant. Leasing concessions were found to be negotiable depending on the strength and desirability of the tenant and term of the negotiated lease.

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate a benchmark retail market rent for “off airport” retail type space at $2.25 per square foot per month.

b) Office Space Rents

The results of our market rent survey for “off airport” office rents are presented within Table H-17.

Table H-17 COMPARABLE OFFICE SPACE RENT SURVEY Hilo, Hawaii

Floor Area in Monthly Rent Lease Term Location Level Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) Shiraishi Building 2nd 700 $1.20 - - Aug-15 3 116 Hualalai St. Hilo Plaza 1st 2,500 $1.00 - - May-15 5 180 Kinoole Street Hilo Lagoon Centre 2nd 616 $0.90 $1.03 $1.93 Apr-15 2 101 Aupuni Street PH 616-746 $1.28-$1.30 $1.03 $2.31-$2.33 Asking 3

586 Kanoelehua Avenue 2nd 780 $1.00 - - Asking 3

Malama Market Center 1st 709 $1.00 $1.19 $2.19 Asking - 15-2662 Pahoa Village Road

Hawaii Business Center 1st 828 $1.25 $1.05 $2.30 Asking - 99 Aupuni Street

As demonstrated in this schedule, actual office net space rents range from $0.90 to $1.20 per square foot per month with asking net rents ranging from $1.00 to $1.30 per square foot per month. Asking gross rents range from $2.19 to $2.30 per square foot. Based on conversations with various brokers and leasing agents, base rents can vary depending on the size of space, quality and location. Currently, monthly common area maintenance (CAM) expenses on a square foot basis is generally ranges from $1.03 to $1.19 depending on the expense items paid individually by each tenant. There does not seem to be much of a difference for upper floor rents as compared to ground floor rents. Leasing concessions were found to be

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 74

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

negotiable depending on the strength and desirability of the tenant and term of the negotiated lease.

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate “off airport” benchmark office space at $1.30 per square foot per month.

c) Industrial Space Rents

The results of our market rent survey for “off airport” industrial space rents are presented within Table H-18.

Table H-18 COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL WAREHOUSE SPACE RENT SURVEY Hilo, Hawaii

Area in Monthly Rent Per SqFt Lease Term Location Sq. Ft. Net CAM Gross Date (Years) 860 Piilani Street 1,875 $0.65 - - Mar-14 3 60 Kuhio Street 4,500 $0.75 $0.13 $0.88 Aug-14 3 22,030 $0.60 $0.13 $0.73 Asking -

555 Kalanianaole Ave. 10,000-12,000 1.00 $0.13 $1.13 Asking - 871 Iolani Street 6,000 $0.65 - - Asking -

113 Kuawa Street 6,000 $1.00 - - Asking -

Based on research and investigation, it is the appraiser’s opinion that industrial leasing market conditions within the greater Hilo area are best characterized as mixed. Depending upon the quality of the particular property involved and the quality/type of tenant(s) under lease, market leasing conditions among individual properties can vary greatly, from relatively positive to relatively negative.

As indicated by the market data presented in Table H-18, actual industrial rent levels currently range from $0.65 to $0.75 per square foot of rentable floor area per month, on a net rent basis with asking net rents ranging from $0.60 to $1.00 per square foot. Asking gross rents range from $0.73 to $1.13 per square foot.

Based on the market data, the appraisers estimate “off airport” benchmark industrial space at $0.80 per square foot per month.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 75

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

d) Conclusion of Rents within Terminal Building

Numerous projects were surveyed in order to ascertain the “off airport” market rent for areas classified under the category of retail, office and industrial space in the Hilo area. In each case, each of the property types surveyed is located within close proximity to the Hilo International Airport. The retail and office product is primarily situated within the Waiakea area. The industrial properties presented for comparison purposes are generally located in the area, nearby the airport.

Overall market softness over the years has resulted in artificially low rental rates for the Hilo retail, office and industrial market. Given the special purpose nature of the subject property, coupled with its inherent amenities, higher rental rates would not be judged unreasonable, in the appraiser’s opinion.

Therefore, in light of the foregoing, the appraisers estimate the following rental rates for each classification of subject space via direct comparison with off-airport properties of somewhat similar use characteristics.

Rent/ Rent/ Category of Space Mo./S.F. Year/S.F. Retail $2.25 $27.00 Office 1.30 15.60 Warehouse 0.80 9.60

Given the difficulty in comparing off-airport property to on-airport property, this direct comparison approach will probably reveal the low end of the potential range in rent for the subject terminal since a return on cost of construction would probably result in higher required rents. While it should be supported in the marketplace that on-airport property generates higher rents when compared to similar property off-airport, the actual adjustment is not always clear.

From the indicated “benchmark” indications for the three basic space categories additional judgmental adjustments were made to reflect airport passenger use. A downward adjustment of 10 percent was made for concessionaire – food and beverage space as compared to concessionaire - retail sales space. An upward adjustment of 25 percent was made for VIP Lounge space as compared to general office space.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 76

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

e) Conclusion of Rents within Air Taxi Building

Rents within the Air Taxi Building were considered similar by category as the Main Terminal Building but reflecting a ten percent discount for quality of construction.

(2) Industrial Land Rents

a) Industrial Improved-Unpaved Land Rents

The following presents a brief overview of the Hilo industrial “off airport” land market. The intent of this market analysis is to provide a meaningful assessment of the unit land values within the Hilo International Airport’s immediate “off airport” area. The “off airport” industrial zoned land transactions were employed as a basis for estimating industrial land rents for the Hilo International Airport.

From the market data disclosed by research, four land transactions were selected as primary comparables for use in our detailed comparative analyses of the industrial use airport properties. The comparative adjustment schedule is presented within Table H-19.

Table H-19 COMPARABLE LAND TRANSACTIONS ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE Hilo International Airport Hilo, Hawaii

Transaction Number Subject 1 2 3 Third Division, Tax Map Key Hilo Intl. Airport 2-2-37-79 2-3-36-90 2-2-35-34 Address/Street Frontage 809 Leilani Street 383 Lanikaula Street 513 Kalanikoa Street Neighborhood Location Waiakea Houselots Waiakea Houselots Waiakea Houselots Land Area (Square Feet) 19,452 22,500 22,300 Zoning MG-1a, Industrial MCX-20, Ind/Com Mixed MCX-20, Ind/Com Mixed

Transaction Date May-12 May-14 May-15 Instrument/Financing Deed Deed Deed Indicated Price $325,000 $287,000 $347,900 Terms of Sale Adjustment 1.00 1.00 1.00 Adjusted Price/Value $325,000 $287,000 $347,900 Indicated Fee Price Per Sq. Ft. $16.71 $12.76 $15.60 Market Conditions Adjustment 1.00 1.00 1.00 Market Conditions Adjusted Unit Value $16.71 $12.76 $15.60

Adjustments (%) Location 0% 0% 0% Physical Characteristics 0% 0% 0% Net Adjustments (%) 0% 0% 0%

Adjusted Unit Value Before Size $16.71 $12.76 $15.60 Size Adjustment Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 Size Adjusted Unit Value $16.71 $12.76 $15.60

Range of Unit Values $12.76 to $16.71 per sqft Mean Unit Value $15.02 per sqft Median Unit Value $15.60 per sqft Concluded Unit Value $15.60 per sqft Source: Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd., June 2016. 8246Hilo-Land

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 77

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Market Data

Transaction Number 1 is the fee simple purchase of a 22,300 square-foot site, zoned MCX-20 Mixed Use Commercial-Industrial District, and located on Kalanikoa Street located in Hilo. The recorded sale date was May 27, 2015, and the unadjusted purchase price of $347,900 equates to an average unit land value indication of $15.60 per square foot.

Transaction Number 2 is the fee simple purchase of an unimproved, 19,452 square-foot site, zoned MG-1a General Industrial District, and located on Leilani Street just east of Kanoelehua Avenue in Hilo. The recorded sale date was May 15, 2012, and the unadjusted purchase price of $325,000 equates to an average unit land value indication of $16.71 per square foot.

Transaction Number 3 is the fee simple purchase of an unimproved, 22,500 square-foot site, zoned MCX-20 Mixed Use Commercial-Industrial District, and located at the intersection of Lanikaula and Hinano Streets in Hilo. The recorded sale date was May 5, 2014, and the unadjusted purchase price of $287,000 equates to an average unit land value indication of $12.76 per square foot.

Adjustments

As shown in Table H-19, the unit land value indications of each selected transaction was adjusted relative to the Hilo Airport sites to compensate for various comparative factors including, terms of sale, market conditions, location and physical characteristics in order to yield a fee simple unit land value indication for the subject airport lands. A final adjustment for size differential was not required.

Terms of Sale -- Comparable “off airport” transactions were analyzed as to economic and financing conditions (terms of sale) to reflect the impact of non-institutional methods of financing or the advent of low financing costs due to favorable exchange rates and foreign financing. Down payment, interest rates and loan terms were considered in the cash equivalency analysis. All transactions were considered to be cash equivalent transactions thus no adjustments were required for terms of sale.

Market Conditions -- The adjustment for market conditions (time) considers changes in the real estate market price levels between the date of each comparable and the effective date of the appraisal. From around the beginning of 2008, market conditions would characterize the overall

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 78

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hawaii real estate market in general terms as being in a down cycle as the market, for the most part, had transitioned to a buyer’s market. Subsequent to December 2010, the market can be classified as stable. The comparable transactions occurred between 2012 and 2015 and require no adjustment for market conditions.

Location -- The location adjustment considered the relative location of the comparables to the subject as to potential development desirability and exposure. All transactions are considered relatively equal to the subject airport lands and therefore require no adjustments.

Physical Characteristics -- The physical characteristics adjustment considered the shape, topography and utility factors of the comparables in terms of development potential as compared to the subject. All the comparable transactions were considered inferior based on the level developable terrain of the airport compared to the sloping terrain of the Kaloko industrial subdivision and adjusted upward five percent.

Conclusion Fee Simple Improved-Unpaved Land Value - Based on the market data in Table H-19 the appraiser concludes a market land value for a comparable area within the Hilo International Airport of $15.60 per square foot.

Rent Conclusion Improved-Unpaved Industrial Land - Applying a 6.0 percent market rate of return indicates an indicated fair market annual rent for industrial improved-unpaved land of $0.94 per square foot.

Fee Simple Improved-Unpaved Land Value $15.60 Market Rate of Return x .06 Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $ 0.94

b) Calculation of Industrial Improved-Paved Land Rents

The market rents for the benchmark industrial improved-paved properties are based on the market rents for the industrial improved-unpaved land with an adjustment for the amortized cost of the paving over their remaining useful lives.

Adding $0.62 for the estimated annual recovery for paving estimated earlier in Table H-3 results in an annual rent for industrial improved- paved land of $1.56.

Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $0.94 Add Annual Recovery for Paving .62

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 79

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Annual Rent Improved-Paved Land $1.56

c) Calculation of Industrial Unimproved Land Rents

The Hilo International Airport also has industrial unimproved land, which is land that is not graded and that lacks utilities and paved road access. Rates for unimproved industrial lands are to be discounted from improved- unpaved rates by 25 percent to 50 percent, depending on the distance to paved access and utilities.

Considering the distance from utilities and paved road access and the associated cost, the fair market rental rate for the industrial unimproved lands are discounted 50 percent from the industrial improved-unpaved land rate.

Annual Rent Improved-Unpaved Land $0.94 Discount Factor x .50 Annual Rent Unimproved-Unpaved Land $0.47

d) Concluded Ramp Area Rents

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark open (uncovered) ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be similar to the annual rent estimated for the industrial improved paved and unpaved lands.

Based on the relationship between covered and uncovered parking stalls, the fair market rental rates for the covered ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be 50 percent higher than the rental values for the paved open areas.

(3) Concluded Rental Rates for T-Hangar Spaces

The rental rates for hangar space are estimated to be equivalent to the rental rates for warehouse space, with a downward adjustment associated with the characteristics and limited use of the space.

As detailed earlier, the concluded 2016 benchmark rents for warehouse space was estimated based on an analysis of current industrial warehouse rents as follows: Current Whse Rent Per SqFt Airport Monthly Annually Hilo $0.80 $9.60

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 80

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Based on the characteristics and limited use of the space, a discount rate of 40 percent was considered reasonable. Application of the 40 percent discount rate results in the following benchmark hangar rate.

Monthly Monthly Warehouse Hangar Airport Rate Discount Rate Hilo $0.80 40% $0.48

Table H-20 summarizes existing 2014 Hawaii Airport T-Hangar and End room rents compared to our projected 2016 rental rates.

Table H-20 PROPOSED RENTAL RATES FOR T-HANGAR SPACES T-Hangars and End Rooms Hilo International Airport 2014 2016 2016 Actual 2014 2016 Estimated Projected Rent Monthly Whse Area Warehouse Use Per Monthly Type of Space Rent Rent (Sqft) Rent Adjust. Sq. Ft. Total Bldg 414 T-Hangars $435.00 $0.70 1,249 $0.80 -40% $0.48 $600.00 Bldg 402 and 403 T-Hangars $285.00 $0.70 844 $0.80 -40% $0.48 $405.00 Bldg 402 & 403 End Room $60.00 $0.70 176 $0.80 -40% $0.48 $84.00 Bldg 414-112 Large End Rooms $194.00 $0.70 580 $0.80 -40% $0.48 $278.00 Bldg 414-112 Small End Rooms $142.00 $0.70 421 $0.80 -40% $0.48 $202.00

Commercial use of the space, other than plane storage and maintenance, is at the non-discounted rate of $0.80 per square foot.

(4) Concluded Automobile Parking Rates

Parking rates were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-4, H-5 and H-6). The conclusions in Table H-6 are as follows.

PROPOSED AIRPORT PARKING RENTAL RATES Monthly Parking Rate Type of Uncovered Airports Demand Covered Paved Unpaved Hilo International Airport Medium $85.00 $55.00

(5) Concluded Rates for Aircraft Storage (Tie Down) Areas

Tie-down rents were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-7 and H-8). The conclusions in Table H-8 are as follows.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 81

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

PROPOSED AIRCRAFT TIE DOWN STORAGE RATES

CURRENT 2014 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Hilo International Airport $10.00 $96.00 $20.00 $136.00

PROPOSED 2016 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Hilo International Airport $10.00 $144.00 $20.00 $208.00

(6) Rental Conclusions for Hilo International Airport

Table H-21 summarizes rent projections for the designated terminal buildings, industrial lands, ramp areas, plane hangars, automobile parking and aircraft storage within the Hilo International Airport facility.

(7) Rental Conclusions Hilo International Special Properties

Table H-22 summarizes the rent projections for the designated Hilo special properties.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 82

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-21 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS HILO INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT Hilo, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Terminal Floor Space (non-air carrier) $25.20 $2.10 $27.00 $2.25 Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) $25.20 $2.10 $27.00 $2.25 Concessionaire-Food & Beverage (F) $22.70 $1.89 $24.30 $2.03 VIP Lounge (F) $18.00 $1.50 $19.50 $1.63 Office (F) (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $15.60 $1.30 Storage-Second Floor (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $4.80 $0.40 Ramp Office (non-air carrier) $14.40 $1.20 $15.60 $1.30 Remnant Storage (non-air carrier) $4.20 $0.35 $4.80 $0.40 Air Taxi Building Ticket Counter (F) $22.70 $1.89 $24.30 $2.03 Office (F) $13.00 $1.08 $14.00 $1.17 Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers $11.50 $0.96 $12.50 $1.04 Cargo Building 139 (Office) $15.60 $1.30 Cargo Building 139 (Warehouse) $9.60 $0.80 Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved $1.10 $0.09 $0.94 $0.08 Improved Land-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13 Unimproved Land-Unpaved $0.55 $0.05 $0.47 $0.04 Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved (non-air carrier) $1.65 $0.14 $1.41 $0.12 Open Equipment Parking-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved $1.10 $0.09 $0.94 $0.08 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved $1.60 $0.13 $1.56 $0.13

T-Hangars Per Month Per Month Per Sqft/Mo Bldg. 414-104 to 111, T-Hangar (Large) (1,249 sf) $435.00 $600.00 $0.48 Bldg. 402 & 403-102 to 105, T-Hangar (Small) (844 sf) $285.00 $405.00 $0.48 Bldg 402 & 403-101 and 106, End Room (Small) (176 sf) $60.00 $84.00 $0.48 Bldg 414-112, End Room (Large) (580 sf) $194.00 $278.00 $0.48 Bldg 414-101, End Room (Small) (421 sf) $142.00 $202.00 $0.48 T-Hangar Used as Commercial Space -- -- $0.80 Automobile Parking Covered-Paved Parking Per Month $80.00 Per Month $85.00 Uncovered-Paved Parking Per Month $52.00 Per Month $55.00 Aircraft Storage Charges Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $96.00 Per Month $144.00 Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $20.00 Per Day $20.00 Per Month $136.00 Per Month $208.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 83

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-22 Hilo International Airport Special Properties Hilo, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Concluded Rent Tenant Area Use Condition Sqft/Mo Sqft/Year

Map AOA1

Bldg 133 Old Hangar 2,640 Hangar Poor $0.30 $3.60

Bldg 132 Aloha Cargo Building 5,250 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 111 Aloha Cargo 5,009 Hangar Poor $0.40 $4.80

Map AOA2

Bldg 101 Cargo Building 15,453 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 104 Commodity Forwarders 192 Trailer Good $1.00 $12.00

Bldg 109 Aloha Air Cargo 3,562 Hangar Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 110 Fedex Cargo 4,898 Warehouse Good $0.80 $9.60

Bldg 302 Old Control Tower 2,775 Office (1st Floor) Good $1.00 $12.00 Office (2nd Floor) Fair $0.70 $8.40 Office (3rd Floor) Poor $0.35 $4.20

Bldg 303 Old Overseas Terminal 23,697 Office Poor $0.30 $3.60

Map AOA5 (NEW)

Bldg 207 Space 007-101C 1,571 Office Good $1.30 $15.60

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 84

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo Terminal-Service Counters

Hilo Terminal-Concessionaire F & B

Hilo Terminal-Sales/Retail

Hilo Terminal-VIP Lounge

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 85

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - Air Taxi Building

Hilo - Air Taxi Building Ticket Counter

Hilo - Building 207 (007101C) Field Office (Wesley Segawa)

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 86

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - New Cargo Building 139

Hilo - New Cargo Building 139

Hilo - T-Hanger New Building 414-104 to 111

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 87

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - Building 402 and 403 Old T-Hangars

Hilo -Building 133 (Old Hangar)

Hilo -Building 132 Aloha Cargo

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 88

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - Buliding 111 Aloha Cargo

Hilo - Buliding 110 Fedex Cargo

Hilo - Buliding 109 Aloha Air Cargo Maintenance

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 89

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - Building 101 Cargo Building

Hilo - Building 303 Old Overseas Terminal

Hilo - Building 302 Old Admin & Control Tower

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 90

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hilo - Building 302, Second Floor

Hilo - Building 302, 2nd Floor

Hilo - Building 302, 3rd Floor

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 91

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

XII. WAIMEA-KOHALA AIRPORT (MUE)

A. Airport Description

Waimea-Kohala Airport occupies 90 acres on the island of Hawaii, one mile south of the town of Kamuela. The airport has a single runway, without taxiways and an aircraft parking apron at the west end of the runway serving the passenger terminal and general aviation facilities. No fueling or airport traffic control tower facilities are provided. An aircraft rescue and fire fighting facility shares space in the airport maintenance facility. Vehicular access to the terminal and other facilities is provided by a short connecting roadway extending from the Mamalahoa Highway.

B. Environs

The Waimea Airport is located in the town of Waimea, which is also commonly referred to as Kamuela, in the South Kohala District of the Island of Hawaii.

The South Kohala District encompasses approximately 272 square miles and in combination with the neighboring North Kohala District comprises roughly ten percent of the total land area of the entire Island of Hawaii.

The local economy of the South Kohala District is divided into three sub-regions: the leeward coastal area, with its resort developments; the Kawaihae Deep-Draft Harbor area, noted primarily for its importance as an overseas transportation terminal with related freight storage and light industrial activities; and the greater Waimea Town area, which represents the dominant residential, commercial and civic center for all of South Kohala.

The large-scale resort development concentrated within the leeward coastal area has established itself as the primary driving force behind South Kohala's economy.

Waimea Town has evolved into a more diverse mix of private ownership and individual development interests. Waimea is considered a very attractive and desirable residential area, and most of the recent real estate developments have been relatively upscale in nature. The steady attraction and influx of new businesses and residents to the greater Waimea area has resulted in increased urbanization and real estate values.

Much of the existing commercial development within the Honokaa, side of Waimea Town is retail oriented. A good portion of the relatively newer commercial development on the western side of Waimea Town, in the direction of Kawaihae, is more office oriented.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 92

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 93

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 94

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

C. Rental Analysis

Rents for the retail, office, and industrial type spaces within the terminal building and Building 105 were based on 25 percent of the base rents estimated for the Kona Airport.

Industrial Land Rents

Rents for industrial lands classified as “Improved-Unpaved,” Improved-Paved,” and “Unimproved” were based on 25 percent of the base rents estimated for the Kona Airport.

Ramp Area Rents

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark open (uncovered) ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be similar to the annual rent estimated for the paved and unpaved improved industrial lands.

Based on the relationship between covered and uncovered parking stalls, the fair market rental rates for the covered ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be 50 percent higher than the rental values for the paved open areas.

Automobile Parking

Parking rates were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-4, H-5 and H-6). The conclusions in Table 6 are as follows.

PROPOSED AIRPORT PARKING RENTAL RATES Monthly Parking Rate Type of Uncovered Airports Demand Covered Paved Unpaved Waimea-Kohala Airport Low $41.00

Aircraft Storage (Tie Down)

Tie-down rents were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-7 and H-8). The conclusions in Table H-8 are as follows.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 95

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

PROPOSED AIRCRAFT TIE DOWN STORAGE RATES CURRENT 2014 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Waimea-Kohala Airport $5.00 $24.00 $10.00 $34.00 PROPOSED 2016 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Waimea-Kohala Airport $5.00 $54.00 $10.00 $78.00

Rental Conclusions for Waimea-Kohala Airport

Table H-23 summarizes rent projections for the designated terminal building, industrial lands, ramp areas, automobile parking and aircraft storage within the Waimea-Kohala Airport facility.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 96

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-23 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS WAIMEA-KOHALA AIRPORT Waimea, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Per Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Main Terminal Building Concessionaire-Sales-Retail (F) Per Sq.Ft. $6.75 $0.56 $10.50 $0.88 Office (F) Per Sq.Ft. $4.50 $0.38 $5.25 $0.44

Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers Per Sq.Ft. $3.60 N/A $4.20 $0.35 Hangar - Building 105 Per Sq.Ft. N/A N/A $3.75 $0.31

Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Improved Land-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Unimproved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.15 $0.01 $0.18 $0.02

Ramp Area Covered Equipment Parking-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.63 $0.05 $0.78 $0.07 Covered Equipment Parking-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.45 $0.04 $0.54 $0.05 Open Equipment Parking-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Open Equipment Parking-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Open Equipment Maintenance-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04

Automobile Parking Uncovered Paved Parking Per Month $39.00 Per Month $41.00

Aircraft Storage Charges (Tie Downs) Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $5.00 Per Day $5.00 Per Month $24.00 Per Month $54.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $34.00 Per Month $78.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 97

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Waimea-Kohala Building 105 - Hangar

Waimea-Kohala Office

Waimea-Kohala Concessionaire Retail

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 98

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

XII. UPOLU AIRPORT (UPP)

A. Airport Description

Upolu Airport is at the northern tip of the island of Hawaii, three miles from the town of Hawi. This general aviation airport, occupying 84 acres, has a single runway (without taxiways) and two aircraft parking areas south of the runway. The east parking area support passenger terminal operations and the west parking area provides tie down facilities for general aviation aircraft. The airport does not have a control tower, aircraft rescue and fire-fighting facilities, or discrete air cargo facilities. Access to the airport is provided by one-lane roadways off of Akoni Pule Highway.

B. Environs

The Upolu Airport is located within or nearby Hawi Village, in the North Kohala District of the Island of Hawaii.

North Kohala is the northernmost district of the Island of Hawaii and corresponds to the northern tip of the Island from Honokea Stream on its eastern, or windward, side around Upolu Point to Kaiopae Point on its western, or leeward, side. The North Kohala District is dominated geographically by the Kohala Mountains, which rise to the 5,000-foot elevation and create the divergent climatic conditions that exist between the District's predominantly cooler and wetter windward side and its hotter and drier leeward coast.

The emphasis on development within the greater Kohala region is directed more towards the neighboring South Kohala District than North Kohala. The South Kohala coastal area from Kawaihae to Anaehoomalu has developed into one of the State's major resort destinations. The successful development of these resorts has strengthened and diversified the overall regional economy and created additional employment opportunities for the residents of North Kohala.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 99

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 100

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 101

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

C. Rental Analysis

Concluded Industrial Land Rents

Rents for industrial lands classified as “Improved-Unpaved,” “Improved-Paved,” “Unimproved” were based on 25 percent of the base rents estimated for the Kona Airport.

Concluded Ramp Area Rents

The fair market rental rates for the benchmark open (uncovered) ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be similar to the annual rent estimated for the paved and unpaved improved industrial lands.

Based on the relationship between covered and uncovered parking stalls, the fair market rental rates for the covered ramp equipment parking areas are estimated to be 50 percent higher than the rental values for the paved open areas.

Concluded Aircraft Storage (Tie Down)

Tie-down rents were estimated earlier in Chapter IX (Tables H-7 and H-8). The conclusions in Table H-8 are as follows.

PROPOSED AIRCRAFT TIE DOWN STORAGE RATES

CURRENT 2014 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Upolu Airport $5.00 $24.00 $10.00 $34.00

PROPOSED 2016 AIRCRAFT STORAGE RATES Small Aircraft Storage Large Aircraft Storage Airport Daily Monthly Daily Monthly Upolu Airport $5.00 $54.00 $10.00 $78.00

Rental Conclusions for Upolu Airport

Table H-24 summarizes rent projections for the designated industrial lands, ramp areas and aircraft storage within the Upolu Airport facility.

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 102

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Table H-24 RENTAL CONCLUSIONS UPOLU AIRPORT Upolu, Island of Hawaii, Hawaii

Current (Per Sqft) Proposed (Sqft) Category Per Annum Per Month Per Annum Per Month

Rental of Buildings other than Passenger Terminal Trailers Per Sq.Ft. $3.60 $0.30 $4.20 $0.35

Rental of Industrial Lands Improved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.30 $0.03 $0.36 $0.03 Improved Land-Paved Per Sq.Ft. $0.42 $0.04 $0.52 $0.04 Unimproved Land-Unpaved Per Sq.Ft. $0.15 $0.01 $0.18 $0.02

Aircraft Storage Charges (Tie Downs) Small general aviation aircraft (46' x 32' or smaller) Per Day $5.00 Per Day $5.00 Per Month $24.00 Per Month $54.00

Large general aviation aircraft (47' x 33' or larger) Per Day $10.00 Per Day $10.00 Per Month $34.00 Per Month $78.00

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 103

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 104

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 105

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 106

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 107

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 108

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 109

County of Hawaii Airports APPRAISAL REPORT

Hastings, Conboy & Associates, Ltd. Page 110