A History of the University of Illinois British Brass Band, 1981 to the Present
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A HISTORY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS BRITISH BRASS BAND, 1981 TO THE PRESENT BY MAUREEN V. REAGAN DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Musical Arts in Music with a concentration in Performance and Literature in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Mark Moore, Chair Associate Professor Christina Bashford, Director of Research Professor Erik Lund Professor Jeffrey Magee ABSTRACT On November 15, 1981, the University of Illinois British Brass Band performed its first concert, conducted by University of Illinois Assistant Director of Bands James Curnow. The ensemble’s antecedents lay in the brass bands established in Victorian England that were populated by members of the working classes, while its 1980s founding occurred in the national context of an increase in British-style brass band activity in the United States that included the formation of the North American Brass Band Association, dedicated to fostering the British-style brass band movement in the US and Canada. Several key factors contributed to the success and longevity of the University of Illinois British Brass Band, including certain characteristics of the University of Illinois Bands program and the institutional support given to the ensemble. Through analysis and synthesis of personal interviews and archival research, this dissertation reveals the identity of the ensemble as modeled on the traditional British brass band and its typical sound and repertoire, modified by the University of Illinois British Brass Band’s own solutions for particular musical and logistical demands. Providing a significant educational experience for its players (as well as its conductors) and filling an important role in the ensemble offerings of the University of Illinois Bands program, the University of Illinois British Brass Band also represented the University of Illinois statewide by way of its periodic tours and propagated the British-style brass band performance idiom through its more than 90 known performances before its hiatus began in 2011. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am deeply aware of and grateful for the many people who gave of their time and knowledge to help make this dissertation a reality. Director of Research Christina Bashford struck a wonderful balance by keeping me constantly reaching for better thinking, deeper meaning, and clearer writing while also, through her steadfast encouragement and teaching, helping me believe I could achieve those goals. Committee members Erik Lund, Jeffrey Magee, and Mark Moore gave freely of their enthusiasm, time, expertise, and support over this many-year journey. Past conductors of the University of Illinois British Brass Band James Curnow, John Cody Birdwell, James Hile, and Peter J. Griffin generously conversed and corresponded with me and brought insights that would not otherwise have been revealed. Faculty and staff of the Sousa Archives and Center for American Music, University Archives, University Bands, and the Music and Performing Arts Library at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign unfailingly provided ideas and assistance; thank you in particular to Scott Schwartz, Katie Nichols, Ellen Swain, Anna Trammell, Nancy Taylor, William Buss, Joy McClaugherty, Barry Houser, and Stephen Peterson. Locally and across the globe, members of the music community such as David Bilger, Amy Schumaker Bliss, Joel Collier, Paul Droste, Graham Duncan, Connie Fairchild, Chris Helme, Diana Droste Herak, Gavin Holman, James Keene, Angela Kindig, Lori Melchi, Vincent Novaro, Kevin Stees, Will Sugg, Mark Taylor, and Eric Wilson responded kindly and graciously to requests for information. Mike Ross and Krannert Center colleagues encouraged and supported me every step of the way, making the pursuit of my doctorate possible; I gained energy from countless friends and associates who simply, but meaningfully, inquired of me how my studies were progressing; and my family constantly inspired me. I am grateful beyond description to my husband, Bruce Zimmerman, for his love and wise iii counsel—as well as for keeping us supplied with warm food, clean laundry, and good humor throughout this long and amazing adventure. November 15, 2018 iv DEDICATION For Bruce, who encouraged me to begin, to continue, and to finish, and to do so with joy v PREFACE My experience earning a doctorate at the University of Illinois has been rich and satisfying, and this project has provided a wonderful finish to it. As a member of the University of Illinois British Brass Band from fall of 1986 through spring of 1990, I did not know a great deal about the brass band tradition, but I knew I loved playing the music and was grateful for the musicianship of the ensemble’s conductors and the inspiring skill of its members. I certainly did not know as I left the group and began a career in arts administration that almost thirty years later I would circle around to devote many hundreds of hours to research about the ensemble. As I sought a dissertation topic, several ideas presented themselves, usually emerging by way of conversations with my husband, but the notion of researching the University of Illinois British Brass Band persisted beyond others. Relevant to my focus on euphonium performance because of the magnificent opportunities brass band repertoire presents to euphonium players (though not only to them), the topic also provided a chance to research a University of Illinois initiative and thus make a small return to the institution that has provided me the opportunity not only for fulfilling employment but for continuing education, both formal and informal. In addition, and in another never-expected circular path, the project gave me the opportunity to reconnect with James Curnow, with whom I was fortunate to study at a young age and who along with other teachers such as Dave Peterson, Ron Makeever, Robert Gray, Fritz Kaenzig, and Micky Moore shaped my conception of, ability with, and enthusiasm for the euphonium. I am grateful to have had the chance to collect, compile, and discuss information from diverse sources, some of which presented itself at the most opportune times, such as a wonderful supply of otherwise unlocatable programs supplied by Connie Fairchild. Gathering this information into one document and its supporting structures (such as a performance database) honors the effort vi given and music made over the band’s thirty years, provides the foundation for this dissertation, and makes previously scattered and hidden data useful for future researchers. Whether read by alumni of the band or by those who are performing research on brass banding, the group’s conductors or members, or other topics, I hope that this dissertation both answers and raises questions, motivates further inquiries, and perhaps inspires fond memories. Maureen Reagan [email protected] Champaign-Urbana, Illinois December 19, 2018 vii TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 1 CHAPTER 2: ORIGIN, TRADITION, AND EVOLUTION OF BRITISH BRASS BANDS, CA. 1840 TO 1980 .............................................................................................................................. 13 CHAPTER 3: THE FOUNDING OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS BRITISH BRASS BAND .................................................................................................................................... 41 CHAPTER 4: LOGISTICS, PROCEDURES, AND PERFORMANCES, 1985 TO 2011...71 CHAPTER 5: REPERTOIRE ......................................................................................................... 90 CHAPTER 6: BRITISHNESS AND THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS BRITISH BRASS BAND .................................................................................................................................. 124 CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION ...................................................................................................... 148 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................................ 161 APPENDIX A: KNOWN PERFORMANCES ......................................................................... 165 APPENDIX B: KNOWN REPERTOIRE ................................................................................. 179 APPENDIX C: KNOWN PERSONNEL .................................................................................. 191 APPENDIX D: KNOWN RECORDINGS ............................................................................... 206 APPENDIX E: FANFARE FOR N.A.B.B.A. ........................................................................... 217 viii CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION This dissertation explores the history of the British Brass Band at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, first looking into the band’s British antecedents, then examining the ensemble’s logistics, repertoire, national context, distinctive sound, and ideology from its founding in 1981 through its hiatus beginning in 2011. This group, one of multiple ensembles offered through the University of Illinois band program, was only the fourth British-style brass band to be established at an American college or university, and it stands second among British-style brass bands sponsored by American colleges or universities in its number of active years, according to a 2016 study by Mark Amdahl