PORTFOLIO www.el-ts.ru Contents
ETS Group 4
Completed projects Designing 6 Energy system development planning 26 Industrial safety and energy audit 36 Consulting 46 ETS Project
ETS-Project was set up by a group of inspired, highly qualified specialists who were then employed Services at a branch of Energosetproekt research institute, Gorky, during the reform of JSC «United energy systems of Russia». In its early years ETS-Project mostly specialized in designing power transmission lines and electrical substations of high and ultrahigh voltage, devising schemes of power systems development in European Russia, the Urals and Siberia. As the company matured, it got more diversified by adding a few more relevant companies into its structure. At present ETS-Project provides second-to-none engineering services of any complexity in the field of electricity, including those facilities which can be referred to as unique, extremely dangerous and technically complex; it also provides solutions to a wide range of research, design and engineering tasks.
Each direction of the company’s performance has its own clear boundaries, whereas the Design and survey works for 6-10 kV, 35-750 kV power grid facilities company’s unique experience and overall capabilities allow it to solve the complete range of customers’ tasks. °°Integrated design of power grid facilities. By now ETS-Project employees have completed more than 300 projects both in Russia and °°Land tenure, legal relations and engineering surveys. abroad. °°Development of perspective schemes for power systems and facilities of large consumers. °°Авторский надзор. °°Development of heat and gas supply schemes. Our customers include the largest Russian and foreign companies: PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system, PJSC IDGC of Centre and Volga region, PJSC Russian grids, PJSC °°Research into industrial safety and in-depth inspection of buildings and constructions. Consulting Moscow electric power grids, JSC Concern Rosenergoatom, PJSC IDGC of the North-West, services. PJSC RusHydro, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Power grid company of Bangladesh, Ltd., Department °°Energy audit and development of energy effective and energy saving programs. of fuel and energy, Moscow, Department of fuel and energy and tariff regulation, Vologda region °°Cost optimization in purchasing energy resources for large consumers. and others. °°Market research based on benchmarking. °°Justification of investments in construction. °°Drone-aided aerial photographing with subsequent image processing. °°3D models of terrain and objects. °°Remote land sensing. °°Orthophoto mapping. °°Air monitoring. °°Delivery of equipment and materials. °°Supply of electric power equipment, cable and wire products. °°Supply of equipment and materials for construction. °°Supply of lighting and boiler equipment.
( ! Design PJSC Federal grid company of united energy PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system - North-West system - Siberia 500 kV «Yenisei» substation with 500 kV/220 kV overhead power lines «Petrozavodsk-Tikhvin Liteyniy» 330 kV overhead power transmission line
Region: Krasnoyarsk region Region: Republic of Karelia, Leningrad
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity. Region Market segment: electricity transmission and distribution
Deadlines: 2011-2017 Deadlines: 2016-2018
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
Construction of 500 kV substation with 500 kV/220 kV outgoing lines. Construction of 330 kV «Petrozavodsk-Tikhvin-Liteiny» overhead line with its further connection to 330 kV switchgear of 330 kV «Petrozavodsk substation», By launching new 1602 MVa substation, Krasnoyarsk region will receive a second 330 kV Tikhvin-Liteiny» substation. Completion of the second 330 kV overhead line large 500 kV grid power centre. It will be able to compensate for power shortage (Petrozavodsk-Tikhvin-Liteiny) which connects power systems of the Republic of in Krasnoyarsk energy hub and to connect new consumers to the grid. Karelia and Saint-Petersburg and Leningrad Region should ensure:
Transmitting electrical power from Kolskaya NPP; SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: Improving reliability of power supply to consumers in the Republic of Karelia and 500 kV outdoor switchgear and 4 500 kV/8 220 kV transmission lines were Leningrad Region; completed: Increasing electricity transit capacity from power system of Murmansk region • The 500 kV overhead power line connects a few regions of Russia (from power system to the power system of Saint-Petersburg and Leningrad region. west to east, the line from Krasnoyarsk hydroelectric station also joins the substation). SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: • 220 kV overhead power line forms a ring between the city substations to transmit electricity to enterprises and residential areas in Krasnoyarsk. Distinctive features of the project include:
Its distinctive features include: 330 kV overhead power lines running through territories of two subjects of the Russian Federation. The largest substation in the Krasnoyarsk power system. Use of compacted wires. The estimated seismic activity in the region is 7 points. Total length is over 300 km. 2nd type soil settlement at the construction site.
Construction was completed in 3 stages. RESULT:
RESULT: At present, engineering and land surveys have been completed. The following works The company has completed a full range of engineering surveys which were used for developing design and project documentation. The are underway: company also supervised the construction process to ensure the best results possible. Engineering and geological surveys;
The Yenisei substation was successfully completed and launched. Engineering-ecological surveys;
Engineering and hydro-meteorological surveys.
8 9 PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – POWER GRID OF BANGLADESH LTD. North-West Examination of the national energy system of the Republic of Bangladesh to work out Modernization of existing emergency control system at Leningradskaya 750 kV necessary measures to connect Ruppur NPP to it. substation, Chudovo 330 kV substation and Pskov 330 kV substation
Region: Leningrad Region, Pskov Region, Novgorod Region, Vologda Region, Tver Region: Republic of Bangladesh Region Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids. Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Deadlines: 2016 Deadlines: 2016-2017
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
Calculation of current power modes and short-circuit currents in power system of Development of documentation to upgrade existing emergency control system as the Republic of Bangladesh to select the most optimal power supply scheme for part of BRELL infrastructure (power systems of Belarus, Russia, Estonia, Latvia, power units No. 1 and No. 2 at Ruppur NPP, as well as to determine parameters Lithuania). Setting tasks for the plant to produce emergency control equipment for of pre-set electric power and switching equipment and wires for 400 and 230 kV substations of PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system - North-West power lines. and Center.
Calculation of static and dynamic stability of generators installed at Ruppur NPP to determine the basic principles on which the system and local emergency control must be developed.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
Distinctive features of the project include: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
International contract. Distinctive features of the project include:
The project in question (completion, transfer of the results obtained to the customer with their subsequent presentation) was completed Development of documentation for the facilities included in the BRELL ring. under extremely tight deadlines (6 months since signing the contract). The project in question (completion, transfer of the results obtained to the customer with their subsequent presentation) was completed Development of documentation with its presentation were done in English. under extremely tight deadlines (1 month only since signing the contract).
RESULT: RESULT:
There has been proposed and accepted a new power supply scheme for units No. 1 and No. 2, Ruppur NPP, which has never been There has been developed documentation on detailed design and costs estimates which enabled the purchase and delivery of emergency considered before by the customer as part of the strategy of developing electric power grids in the Republic of Bangladesh. control equipment to the facilities of PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system - North-West and Center.
To improve reliability and quality of electricity, additional recommendations were also given concerning changes into principles of managing high-voltage power grids in the Republic of Bangladesh.
10 11 PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system - Russian grids, Moscow region Center. 220 kV cable line «Thermal power station -23 - Elokhovskaya No.1, No.2» 500 kV Zagorskaya storage power station - Yartsevo overhead power transmission line with reconstruction of 500 kV Yartsevo substation.
Region: Moscow Region: Moscow region
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity
Deadlines: 2014-2016 Deadlines: 2011-2012
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
Construction of a two-circuit 220 kV cable line from the thermal power station to Overall reconstruction of the existing 220 kV substation with its expansion and Elokhovskaya substation with increased transmission capacity. upgrade to 500 kV, as well as the construction of two 64 km long 500 kV lines.
Their implementation will enable power transmission from Zagorskaya storage power station -2 and significantly increase the reliability of power supply to SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: consumers in Moscow region. The total length of the cable line as planned is 10,805 m, including the part which The reconstructed 500 Kv Yartsevo substation will become part of the second 500 was done by open laying method - 5,905 m; kV power ring around Moscow. Length of horizontally drilled part is 4,900 m;
Laying 645 m 220 kV cable into the existing cable collector of the thermal power SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: station 23 - substation «Metrostroevskaya 1.2». Distinctive features of the object include: Distinctive features of the project include: Difficult conditions of reconstruction. Construction of 110-220 kV outdoor Designing cable lines for Central and Eastern administrative districts of Moscow switchgear was possible only after incoming 220 kV overhead power line was raised and placed on 84m high supports. Thus, the construction, in fact, was carried out which are heavily flooded with other communication lines. under the overhead power lines which required extra accuracy and care.
Obtaining approvals from more than 50 supervising organizations. The 500Kv line runs 1200 m through Zagorskoye water reservoir with uneasy coastal areas that significantly increased the difficulty of the work done. Laying technically complex sections of the cable line by the method of horizontal directional drilling.
RESULT:
RESULT: The new generation 500 kV Yartsevo substation has been equipped with the state-of-the art electrical equipment and advanced digital automation and control systems. This has resulted in a significant increase (over five times) in its power output (1,538.3 MW). Detailed design and project documentation was developed. The main technical solutions include five different options for laying cable lines.
The results were approved of by the customer. At present author supervision is underway.
12 13 PJSC Federal grid company of united energy PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system - Volga. system - North-West. Large 220 kV Pechora Hydro electric station – Ukhta - Mikun overhead power Reconstruction of 220 kV Saratovskaya HPP-Kubra overhead line transmission line crossing the Pechora River
Region: Republic of Komi Region: Saratov region
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity
Deadlines: 2013 Deadlines: 2011-2012
TARGET: PROJECT GOALS: Development of a project for a large 220 kV power transmission line crossing the Pechora River. Reconstruction of a 220 kV «Saratovskaya Hydro electric station - Kubra» overhead power line by replacing supports in each span; wires and cables; insulation and linear fittings; repairing of existing supports and foundations. SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
The overhead power lines rest on two towers: two of which being AT73M and SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: AT69M types and another two being K330-1M+5 type. Terminal tower No. 1 and transition anchor No. 2 are located on the high shore, transition anchor No. 3 and To enable safe replacement of existing wires for 500/64 type to increase terminal No. 4 are located on a low flooded bank. Transition scheme: K-A-A-K. The transmission capacity of overhead line, a connection to the 220 kV Vozrozhdenie span length is 1307 m. substation was fully reconstructed.
The project used a special high-temperature ACS 548-A20SA wire manufactured by PSB220-1 reinforced concrete supports with a modified B36-1 crosshead Lumpi-Berndorf. Its improved characteristics increased resistance to temperatures and SBIG220-11 two-stand reinforced concrete supports were installed as and allowed to meet strict requirements for sagging booms. intermediate single-circuit supports. To protect the 220 kV overhead power line over the Pechora river against direct lightning strikes, two lightning protection cables were suspended: ACS 537 2C OKGT-type cable and ACS 548-A20SA cable in the transition span. The ACS 537 2C cable is a high-temperature wire with built-in fiber-optic cable.
RESULT:
As a result of reconstructing the 220 kV Saratovskaya HES - Syzran overhead line from Saratov hydro station to the border of Saratov region and connection to 220 kV Vozrozhdenie substation, new reinforced concrete intermediate supports were installed in each span of the RESULT: existing overhead line. The supports are of SSGP220-11 type and have two stands with horizontal arrangement of wires which allowed to reduce the traverse installation height by 1 meter. The distance between phases and the distance between ropes on the support is identical The large 220 kV overhead power transmission line over the Pechora river near Krasnyi Yar in the Komi Republic has been successfully to the distance on existing metal supports. completed. Overhead transmission lines supports rest on unified tower rests series 3.407-115 release 2. For anchoring anchor-angle supports in the Most of the Komi and Arkhangelsk power systems are made up of 110-220 kV power lines. The recently constructed 220 kV Pechora ground, FS2-A-48 and F5-A-48 type tower rests with four 48 mm anchor bolts are used. Hydroelectric station –Ukhta - Mikun overhead line will perform as the key transmission line of Komienergo-Arkhenergo.
14 15 PJSC Federal grid company of united energy Branch of Rosenergoatom Concern JSC system – Volga. Incoming power transmission lines to 220 kV Diesel substation Kursk nuclear power plant. External power supply to Kursk NPP-2 construction site. 330/10 kV Substation
Region: Nizhny Novgorod Region Region: Kursk region
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids
Deadlines: 2013-2014 Deadlines: 2015
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
Incoming power transmission lines to 220 kV Diesel substation to connect 345 To design a 330/10Kv substation for reliable power supply of the Kursk NPP-2 MW electric power generation facilities under construction to the existing power construction site. grid facilities of JSC GAZ.
THE SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: To ensure timely and secure delivery of power to energy consuming facilities located Reconstruction of 220 kV Nizhegorodskaya-Zarechnaya overhead power on the Kursk NPP-2 construction site: transmission line by dividing it into two overhead power transmission lines: • a new 330 kV switchgear was built on the territory of the 3rd construction • 220 kV «Zarechnaya-Diesel» overhead transmission line. stage of Kursk NPP.
• 220 kV “Nizhny Novgorod-Diesel» overhead transmission line. • two 330/10/10 kV transformers each having capacity of 25 MVA and connected to the new 330 kV switchgear on the territory of the 3rd stage of Reconstruction of 220 kV «Luch-Nagornaya» overhead power lines to 220 kV the Kursk NPP were installed to provide power for 10 kV sheltered switchgear «Diesel» substation by dividing it into two overhead power lines: on the construction site. • 220 kV «Luch-Diesel» overhead transmission line. • 10 kV sheltered switchgear on the 3rd stage was built as part of a new 330 • 220 kV Nagornaya-Diesel» high-voltage line. kV outdoor switchgear. The existing 330 kV overhead power lines were connected to the new 330 kV Distinctive features of the project include: switchgear by making a new 330 kV overhead power line of the KNPP 1-3 I circuit Together with standard metal lattice-anchor-angle supports the project uses unique 220 kV multi-faceted support, which was tailor-made from the 330 kV outdoor switchgear of the Kursk NPP to the new 330 kV outdoor by Valmont. This support rests on individual screw-based foundations. switchgear.
Construction of 330 kV overhead power line of KNPP 1-3 II circuit by using the existing 330 kV overhead power line section of 5TR. RESULT: Reconstruction of a cell at 330 kV outdoor switchgear, Kursk NPP with installation The implementation of the project will ensure 220 kV power output into the grid as well as guarantee reliable and stable operation of power of a gas-insulated switch for connecting new 330 kV overhead line of KNPP 1-3 grids. II circuit.
RESULT:
The full range of engineering surveys was carried out, detailed design and project documentation was developed. The works were completed and accepted by the customer.
16 17 Rosenergoatom Concern OJSC Rosenergoatom Concern JSC
Development of design documentation for reconstruction of 330 kV outdoor Support center for data processing and storage, JSC Rosenergoatom. switchgear at the Leningrad NPP. Construction of 330 kV metal-enclosed gas-insulated switchgear.
Region: Leningrad Region Region: Tver region
Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids
Deadlines: 2013 Deadlines: 2014-2015
PROJECT GOALS:
The Leningrad NPP is located 80 km west of St. Petersburg on the southern coast of the Gulf of Finland, the Baltic Sea. The plant includes Construction of a data processing and storage centre which will include: 4 power units each having power of 1000 MW. An administrative building. Units 1 and 2 are part of the first stage of the LNPP, while Units 3 and 4 are part of the second stage of the LNPP. Design works on Five data centre buildings. Leningrad NPP-2 began in 2005. A checkpoint building.
A BKTP 10/0,4 kV 2x630 kVa module-type concrete transformer substation. PROJECT GOALS: Six refueling sites with underground tanks for diesel fuel. To develop design documentation to reconstruct the 330 kV outdoor switchgear at Leningrad NPP which will ensure uninterruptible and reliable operation of LNPP-1 during an increase in short-circuit currents in the grid caused by the launch of power units of the Leningrad A sewage pumping station. NPP-2. Wastewater treatment facilities.
Parking lots and roads.
JSC Rosenergoatom Concern is one of the largest companies in Russian power SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: industry which manages all nuclear power plants in Russia. 330 kV switchgear was designed as metal-enclosed gas-insulated switchgear which boasts a few competitive advantages, namely: Data center consumers receive electricity from the new 110/10 kV substation powered by two 110 kV cable lines from the existing 330 switchgear significantly reduces the space Multifunctionality in one case: busbars, Higher reliability and resistance to kV Vostok substation. circuit breakers, disconnectors with environmental impacts. which it occupies which, in its turn, makes grounding switches, current transformers its expansion far easier and simpler. Absence of electric and magnetic fields. are placed close to each other which SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: significantly reduces the size and increases Safety and convenience of operation, easy the reliability of the switchgear. installation and dismantling. Distinctive features of the facility include:
Improved explosion and fire safety. The use of the metal-enclosed gas-insulated Construction of two 2 km-long 110 kV lines.
The project was completed in three stages.
RESULT: RESULT:
Implementation of the project will ensure commissioning of the Leningrad NPP-2 and improve the reliability of power supply to the Leningrad As part of the project a full range of engineering surveys was carried out, design documentation was developed. The project was approved NPP-1. by state expertise authorities.
18 19 Northwest branch of JSC «Oboronenergo» Kaliningrad branch of JSC Oboronenergo.
Additional equipment of quayside facilities, object «931», code 2/46-358 Equipment of the 7054th airbase in Chkalovsk, Kaliningrad region, remote facilities DPRM-90, DPRM-270
Region: Murmansk region Region: Kaliningrad region
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity
Deadlines: 2014-2016 Deadlines: 2015-2016
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To design facilities to improve reliability of power supply to the berthing front where Design and survey works as part of technological connection of power receiving the Northern Navy is based, thus improving national defense in the North. devices of «Equipment of the 7054th Airbase in Chkalovsk, Kaliningrad Region», remote facilities DPRM-90, DPRM-270 (code КОР/4-13/2)» for Kaliningrad branch, JSC «Oboronenergo». SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: The range of the work done includes: Distinctive features of the facility include: Development of the main technical solutions. The facilities to be designed are located in the Far North of Russia. Engineering research. The construction is carried out on very rough terrain with height differences varying Development of design documentation. 18.1 to 131.0 m. Expertise of design documentation and engineering survey materials. Estimated wind class for overhead line structures - VI. The facilities are located in Kaliningrad region, Chkalovsk settlement, on the The territory is a rocky ground of XI category. territory of a military airbase. Preparation of a land survey and a project of territory planning with subsequent public discussion.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: RESULT: Distinctive features of the facility are: At different stages of the project: In accordance with the Resolution issued by the Government of the Russian Federation dated January 27, 2015 No. 98-r, which key A full range of engineering surveys was carried out. message is to encourage faster import substitution, it was proposed to supply as much equipment from domestic producers as possible.
150/35/6 kV PS29 substation was expanded by adding two external 150 Kv metal-enclosed gas-insulated switchgears. To increase reliability and decrease operational expenses 10 Kv cable made from sewed polyethylene was used.
1.2 km 150 Kv cable lines were designed.
A 150/35 kV sheltered substation with 2x40 MVA power transformers was designed. The 150 kV switchgear was implemented in the form of 150 kV metal-enclosed gas-insulated switchgear cells manufactured by Sieyuan.
Five 35 kV cable-air lines resting on many-sided steel supports which can meet requirements for 110 kV lines. The total length of the line is 35 km.
Two closed-type 35/6 kV substations with 2x25 MVA and 2x16 MVA power transformers were designed.
20 21 Branch of JSC Engineering and construction LUKOIL-Nizhegorodnefteorgsintez, Ltd center, United energy system - Siberia Main step-down substation No. 4 of catalytic cracking facilities, 110 kV Development and approval of the planning project, the project of land survey for 500 Kv Voskhod-Vityaz overhead transmission line.
Region: Nizhny Novgorod Region, Kstovo Region: Omsk and Tyumen Regions
Market segment: Refining industry Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity
Deadlines: 2012 Deadlines: 2017
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To ensure reliable power supply to first category consumers on catalytic cracking Development of planning documentation to enable subsequent commissioning of facilities-2, LUKOIL-Nizhegorodnefteorgsintez, Ltd. facilities.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
To increase maximum possible output consumed by the facilities belonging to Collection and analysis of initial documentation. LUKOIL-Nizhegorodnefteorgsintez and to connect the newly designed and existing Development of spatial planning documentation. facilities of the enterprise, a main step-down substation No. 4 for catalytic cracking facilities, 110 kV, was built. Obtaining approvals for the documentation from local and state authorities.
In addition, the automated system for measuring electricity consumption at Seeking approval for planning documentation from the Ministry of Energy of the LUKOIL-Nizhegorodnefteorgsintez, Ltd was upgraded to meet the requirements of Russian Federation. ATS company. Distinctive features of the project are:
Facilities of federal significance. RESULT: The length of the 500 kV overhead power line is 342.5 km. The external 110 kV metal-enclosed gas-insulated switchgear was designed to feed 2x63 MVA transformers. The 110 kV outdoor switchgear of Novogorkovskaya The project was approved in 2 entities of the Russian Federation, 9 municipal thermal power station was reconstructed. 110 Kv air cable lines were designed areas, 27 rural settlements. with installation of transition points.
To connect newly designed and existing facilities, a 6 kV switchgear was designed as RESULT: part of the main step-down substation No. 4, which is connected to the substation main control unit located in a modular building. Documentation on territory panning was developed as part of the planning and land surveying project.
22 23 JSC Rosenergoatom Concern Federal state enterprise «Mayak»
Power delivery scheme of Nizhny Novgorod NPP Scheme of power output for Mayak nuclear power plant facilities.
Region: Nizhny Novgorod region Region: Chelyabinsk Region
Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids Market segment: nuclear power, high voltage power grids
Deadlines: 2012 Deadlines: 2015
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To select and justify the right power delivery scheme for the Nizhny Novgorod NPP, Selection and justification of the power output scheme for a nuclear power plant of taking into account the construction of power units, as well as the order according the “Mayak” reactor facilities. to which power grid equipment will be installed at the Nizhny Novgorod NPP.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
Структура установленной мощности в Нижегородской энергосистеме в 2013, 2022, 2023 и 2028 гг. Calculations of electricity and power flow distribution in the power grids of the Sverdlovsk and Chelyabinsk regions, calculations of static and dynamic stability, the main solutions for equipping electrical networks with relay protection, emergency SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: control schemes, and communication devices for several options of power output scheme. For Mid-Volga United energy system by distinguishing Nizhny Novgorod power system and for United energy system, Center by distinguishing Vladimir power system:
The current power-electricity balance was Calculations of standard and the heaviest plant were calculated. RESULT: analyzed. (post-emergency) repair modes were made, Additional measures for reactive power Increase in energy efficiency during the disposal of nuclear waste. taking into account regulatory disturbances. Characteristics of existing grids with 110 kV compensation were suggested. and higher voltages located within the zone Short-circuit currents were calculated The volume of power grid construction and of influence of Nizhny Novgorod NPP were for the network circuit on buses of Nizhny assessment of necessary capital investments determined. Novgorod NPP and in the adjacent network. into the NPP of Nizhny Novgorod were also The main indicators (power consumption, The analysis of reactive power balance was estimated. modes and structure of power consumption carried out taking into account the sequence for every particular year when each unit in which units of Nizhny Novgorod NPP will be will be commissioned with a forecast up to commissioned. 2030) were determined. Static stability and dynamic stability of the Different power supply schemes were suggested.
24 25 Energy system development planning Department of fuel and energy resources, Moscow Department of fuel and energy resources, Moscow.
General scheme of power supply for Moscow for a period up to 2030 Scheme and program of electric power industry development in Moscow in 2014-2019, 2015-2020, 2016-2021, 2017-2022, 2018-2023.
Region: Moscow Region: Moscow
Market segment: regional administrations Market segment: regional administrations
Deadlines: 2016-2017 Deadlines: 2014-2018
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To ensure consolidation and consistency of decisions made as part of updating To plan the development of the grid infrastructure and generating capacities to schemes for main subsystems of the city’s energy supply (heat, electricity and gas meet the mid-term demand for electricity, to create favorable conditions for supply), as well as coordination of key activities in terms of timeframes. attracting investments into efficient and well-balanced energy infrastructure to ensure socio-economic development and environmentally responsible use of energy and energy resources in Moscow. SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
The General Scheme coordinates the implementation of decisions to develop the capital’s fuel and energy sector, which were made and justified as part of the development of industry-specific schemes and programs to devise heating, gas and electricity supply systems. RESULT:
There was worked out a systematic approach to plan the development of the city’s Findings and recommendations from the «Schemes and programs to develop electric power Industry of Moscow» have laid the basis for: energy supply infrastructure to meet the demands of urban consumers for fuel and energy resources. coordination in developing energy and industrial coordination to develop network investors and consumers of electric power. complexes, transport infrastructure, infrastructure and generating capacities; The General Scheme harmonizes the above mentioned measures to ensure steady programs (schemes) of territorial planning, development of fuel and energy subsystems of the city by searching for the optimal rendering information support to assist reliable and efficient power and heat supply solution for the energy supply system as a whole. In this case, the maximum Moscow executive authorities develop a to Moscow consumers; cumulative technical effect acts as a criterion of the optimal solution corresponding policy in electric power industry, as well as to the current limitations of the tariff and regulatory plan. coordination to develop the main and other entities representing commercial and distribution network infrastructure; technological infrastructure of the industry,
RESULT: On behalf of the Department of fuel and energy resources of Moscow, I would like to express my gratitude for your dedicated service The results of the implementation of the General Scheme of Moscow power supply until 2030 include the following: and contribution in developing Moscow energy system. Your staff have demonstrated strong skills and professionalism, as well as a responsible attitude to business, attention and passion to meet the customer’s wishes and demands. Urban fuel and energy facilities will be able Structural and functional reliability of gas, Energy efficiency of the energy supply system to meet the forecasted demand for fuel and heat and power supply systems will improve. as a whole will increase. The Department of fuel and energy sector of Moscow wishes you and your team success in further projects and hopes for future energy in 2015-2030. cooperation. The Scheme will enable technological Electric, thermal, gas transportation and connection to the networks of the relevant gas distribution networks possess sufficient subsystems. 22.01.2016 Deputy Head S.V. Korolev capacity to cope with predicted peak loads.
28 29 Ministry of Transport, Energy and Communications of the Ministry of housing, fuel and energy infrastructure, Nizhny Republic of Dagestan. Novgorod Region Scheme and program of electric power industry development in the Republic of Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Nizhny Novgorod Region, Dagestan for 2017-2021. 2013-2017 with a forecast up to 2022.
Region: Republic of Dagestan. Region: Nizhny Novgorod Region
Market segment: regional administrations. Market segment: regional administrations
Deadlines: 2016-2017. Deadlines: 2012
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To develop proposals for development of grid infrastructure and generating A program to develop grid infrastructure and generating facilities in Nizhny capacities to meet mid-term demand for electricity, to create favorable conditions Novgorod Region power system is needed to meet long-term and mid-term demand for attracting investment to the Republic of Dagestan. for electricity and heat, to create favorable conditions for attracting investment needed to create an efficient and well-balanced energy infrastructure that will ensure socio-economic development and environmentally responsible use of energy SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: and energy resources.
Analysis of peculiarities and challenges of the electric power industry in the Republic of Dagestan. Assessment of power balance and modes.
A forecast was made concerning the key directions the electric power industry of the Republic of Dagestan is likely to develop in 2017-2021. The forecast was made on the basis of:
forecasts of electricity and power consumption, calculations of the electricity RESULT: system’s operational modes; Findings and recommendations from the Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Nizhny Novgorod Region, 2013-2017 analysis of performance and proposals to develop power generation and power with a forecast up to 2022 have laid the basis for: grids, including external connections to the power system with voltage of 110 kV and higher; • coordinating the development of the main power industry entities, as well as for the consumers in Nizhny Novgorod region; and distribution network infrastructure; subsequent design of energy facilities; assessment of both capital investments needed and the amount of construction • coordinating non-state and state and installation works to implement these options into the energy system. • finding the right balance between • coordinating the development of grid investment decisions. electricity generation and consumption in infrastructure and generating capacities; Nizhny Novgorod region power system by • coordinating development of energy preventing local shortages of electricity and industrial facilities, transport generation and power and possible infrastructure, as well as programs limitations on power transmission in (schemes) of territorial planning, reliable On behalf of the Ministry of Transport, Energy and Communications of the Republic of Dagestan, I would like to express my gratitude electric grids; and efficient power and heat supply to to ETS-Project, Ltd. for the Scheme and Program of Development of the Electric Power Industry in the Republic of Dagestan for • creating an info base for development 2017-2021. programs (investment programs) of We are fully satisfied with the quality of the work done and would like to highlight the staff’s professionalism and responsible attitude to work.
29.05.2017 First Deputy Minister A. Arslanov
30 31 Department of housing and communal services, Vladimir Ministry of energy and housing infrastructure, Samara region Region Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Samara region, Development a scheme and program for long-term development of electric power 2014-2018. industry in Vladimir region in 2015-2020.
Region: Samara region Region: Vladimir region
Market segment: regional administrations Market segment: regional administrations
Deadlines: 2013 Deadlines: 2014
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To plan the development of grid infrastructure and generating facilities to meet To plan the development of grids infrastructure and generating facilities to meet mid-term demand for electricity, to create favorable conditions for attracting mid-term demand for electricity, to create favorable conditions for attracting investments to create an efficient and well-balanced energy infrastructure that investment needed to create an efficient and well-balanced energy infrastructure ensures socio-economic development and environmentally responsible use of to ensure socio-economic development and environmentally responsible use of energy and energy resources in Samara region. energy and energy resources in Vladimir region.
To create conditions to ensure a long-term power generation balance.
To prevent predicted shortages in electricity and power in power system of Vladimir SOLUTIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION: region in the most effective ways.
Analysis of peculiarities and challenges of the electric power industry in Samara region. Assessment of power balance and modes.
A forecast was made concerning the key directions the electric power industry in Samara region is likely to develop in 2014-2018. The forecast was made on the basis of:
Forecasts of electricity and capacity consumption, heat loads.
Calculations and analysis of power system operational modes.
Development of generation and heat sources. RESULT:
Development of power grid facilities. Findings and recommendations which can be found in the Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Vladimir region, 2015-2020 serve the basis for: Assessment of capital investments needed and the amount of construction and installation works to implement these options into the ensuring compatibility between the program coordinating the development of mainline infrastructure and generating capacities; energy system and scheme to develop electric power electricity and power and limitations on coordinating non-state and state investment industry in Vladimir region and investment transmission distribution grid infrastructure; decisions. programs suggested by electric power finding the right balance between electricity RESULT: and scheme to develop electric power regional authorities to devise a policy in the industry players; industry in Samara Region and investment field of electric power industry; generation and consumption in Nizhny Findings and recommendations which can programs suggested by electric power coordinating the development of energy Novgorod region power system by preventing be found in the 2014-2018 Scheme and industry players; ensuring coordination between plans for and industrial facilities and transport local shortages of electricity generation and program to develop electric power industry development of fuel and energy, industrial infrastructure, as well as territorial planning power and possible limitations on power in Samara region serve the basis for creating an info base for development facilities, transport infrastructure and programs (schemes), reliable and efficient transmission in electric grids; implementing an action plan for the 2018 programs (investment programs) for power territorial planning programs (schemes) in electricity and heat supply to consumers in coordinating the development of grid FIFA World Cup with a particular focus on industry entities, as well as for further Samara region. Vladimir region; developing adjacent neighborhoods, namely: design of power facilities;
ensuring compatibility between the program rendering information support to Samara
32 33 Department of Fuel and Energy, Vologda region Fuel and energy committee, Leningrad region
Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Vologda region, Scheme and program to develop electric power industry in Leningrad region, 2014-2018, 2017-2021. 2017-2021.
Region: Vologda region Region: Leningrad region
Market segment: regional administrations Market segment: regional administrations
Deadlines: 2013, 2015 respectively Deadlines: 2016-2017
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To develop energy strategy for Vologda region. To suggest proposals for development of grid infrastructure and generating facilities to meet long- and mid-term demand for electricity and power, to create favorable To suggest proposals for development of grid infrastructure and generating facilities conditions for attracting investment into construction of generating facilities. to meet long-term and mid-term demand for electricity and power.
To create favorable conditions for attracting investments into construction of electric power facilities. SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION To make a forecast on the development of power industry for the period given to Analysis of peculiarities and challenges in the electric power industry in Leningrad region. Assessment of power balance and modes. ensure reliable and safe performance of power supply system in Vologda region. To coordinate development of generation facilities and power grid facilities in Vologda power system for a five-year period. A forecast outlining the main directions of development of electric power industry in Leningrad region in 2017-2021 focuses on:
To coordinate development of distribution and main power grids across the power system for a five-year period to ensure reliable long-term forecasts of electricity, power and heat consumption; performance. development of generation and heat sources; To coordinate regional social and economic development plans, fuel and energy development schemes and programs. forecast of energy sector development in Leningrad region based on renewable energy sources; To render Information support for local authorities to develop electric power industry policies, as well as for entities engaged in the commercial and technological infrastructure of electric power industry, consumers and investors. assessment of balance (electricity and power); calculations and analysis of energy system modes in Leningrad region up to 2022;
RESULT: development of power grid facilities;
The schemes and programs to develop electric power industry in Vologda region can be used as: assessment of capital investments and construction and installation works needed to implement these options into the energy system
The basis for developing schemes of power output for regional electric stations and external power supply schemes for electricity consumers.
The basis for developing investment programs for the owners of electric power equipment. On behalf of Fuel and Gas committee, Leningrad region, I would like to express my gratitude to ETS-Project, Ltd, for devising the scheme The basis for investment proposals concerning construction of generating facilities on the premises of the energy system. and program to develop electric power industry in Leningrad region, 2017-2021.
We are fully satisfied with the quality of work done and would like to highlight the staff’s strong professional skills and competence in dealing with these tasks.
20.06.2017 Industrial safety and energy audit.
34 35 Industrial safety and energy audit LUKOIL-Nizhegorodnefteorgsintez, Ltd. JSC Lenenergo
Examination of industrial safety of technical condition of flyovers Overall inspection of buildings and constructions of substation and transformer substation, JSC «LENENERGO”, «Suburban Power Distribution Networks” branch with a service life of over 25 years.
Region: Nizhny Novgorod Region, Kstovo Region: Leningrad Region.
Market segment: Refining industry Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity.
Deadlines: 2013 Deadlines: 2011, 2012.
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To examine industrial safety of technical condition of flyovers (TK1, TK3, TK4, TK5) To examine buildings and constructions in-depth to reveal dangerous defects and with the registration of the resulting conclusions in Rostechnadzor, as part of the damages, to assess their technical condition and determine conditions enabling investment project «Expansion of tank farms for oil and oil products storage» their further safe operation with issuing as-built documentation.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
Examination of industrial safety of flyovers followed these stages: The following tasks were performed as part of this project:
Analysis of technical documentation. Analysis of design, as-built and operational documentation on constructions and buildings. General inspection of the facility. Detailed (instrumental) examination of constructions Assessment of conditions of the constructions in question. Verifying calculations for bearing elements of buildings. Technical inspection, measurement and making photos. Making pictures with examination results.
RESULT:
Determination of strength of construction materials by applying a non-destructive method.
Checking metal wall thickness.
Processing obtained results by making verification calculations of load-bearing constructions.
Drawing up a conclusion.
Volzhsko-Okskiy department of Federal Service for Ecological, Technological and Nuclear Supervision approved of the results concerning industrial safety of flyovers.
38 39 Interregional grids and communications of PJSC Moscow grids company North-West, PJSC Inspection of buildings and facilities, PJSC M grids company Overall examination of buildings and constructions of Interregional grids and communications, North-West branches: Karelenergo, Pskovenergo, Arkhenergo, Vologdaenergo
Region: Moscow Region, Moscow, Russia. Region: Republic of Karelia, Pskov, Arkhangelsk and Vologda regions
Market segment: transmission and distribution of heat energy. Market segment: electricity transmission and distribution
Deadlines: 2013, 2015, 2016, 2017 Deadlines: 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To inspect in-depth the condition of buildings at PJSC Moscow grids company with To determine the current value of controlled parameters referring to operating issuing technical certificates for them. condition, suitability and operability of construction elements of buildings and constructions.
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
The project solved the following tasks: SOLUTIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION: General inspection of buildings with a focus Determination of current characteristics Paper processing and analysis of the results The project was completed in the following stages: on revealing dangerous defects, damage of materials used in main load-bearing and verification calculations. and deformations, identifying buildings in constructions and their elements. Analysis of causes leading to defects and Getting familiarized with building and Measuring the necessary geometric Analysis of causes of defects and damages in dangerous condition, suggesting urgent Measuring environmental parameters during damages in constructions. constructions; parameters of buildings and constructions by constructions. measures to be taken. technological processes in buildings and employing geodetic devices. Developing plans Drawing up the final document with Determining their size and space on the basis Measuring geometrical parameters of constructions. with indication of bearing constructions, recommendations and conclusions based on of engineering and geological surveys. buildings, constructions, their elements and cross sections, photographic material. Verification calculation of bearing capacity the results of the inspection. nodes by using geodetic devices. Examining buildings and constructions visually of constructions based on the results of the Instrumental detection of defects and to identify defects and damages with taking Engineering and geological surveys. inspection. damages. necessary measurements to eliminate them. Measuring aftercontraction of buildings. Identification of vertical and horizontal deviations of constructions with drawing up Instrumental determination of parameters deviation charts. of defects and damages, including dynamic parameters. Examination of technical condition of RESULT: ventilation systems. Overall examination of 86 substation buildings, 713 sheltered transformer substations, transformer substations and switchgear buildings, RESULT: 130 industrial and administrative buildings, 12 substations (110 kV and 35 kV), as well as 4 overhead power lines (110 kV) with a total length of 13.72 km. All facilities are located in Karelia, Pskov, Arkhangelsk and Vologda regions. In-depth examination of 775 buildings and constructions, including central heating stations, thermal cameras, pavilions, channels. There were made technical conclusions based on the results of the examination and recommendations how to ensure the required strength The conclusion is issued for every construction and includes both the findings which are based on the results of the inspection and and deformability of constructions with the recommended sequence of works to be done. supported by verification calculations of bearing capacity of constructions and recommendations on how to ensure the required strength and deformability of constructions.
40 41 JSC Telecomnefteprodukt PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga
Inspection and assessment of technical condition of «MRR-60», «Unzha» antenna Monitoring and management of electricity quality. supports
Region: Kurgan, Chelyabinsk, Penza regions Region: Samara, Penza, Ulyanovsk, Saratov, Nizhny Novgorod region, the Republic of Mari El, the Chuvash republic, the Republic of Mordovia. Market segment: transportation of oil products Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity. Deadlines: 2014 Deadlines: 2011, 2012.
PROJECT GOALS: PROJECT GOALS:
To examine and assess technical condition of «MRR-60», «Unzha» antenna supports. To create a unified multilevel information and measuring system for monitoring the quality of electricity in terms of its compliance with standards, which, in its turn, will guarantee compliance with the requirements of quality of electricity in United national grid system.
The power quality monitoring system is designed to ensure observability of operation modes in United national grid system in terms of parameters applied to power quality indicators from the level of grid control centers of PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga. SOLUTIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
The project was completed in the following stages: As part of design and survey works «Electricity quality monitoring and management» for PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga in 2011-2013 were completed the following tasks: Examination and evaluation of technical protection of the mast and rope weavers, Drawing up a visual inspection report and condition of the above-ground part of the paintwork of metal constructions, the a defects list based on the results of the Instrumental inspection of substations. Measurement of electricity quality at 62 substations of PJSC Federal grid company of united energy foundations, above-ground part of anchors, antennae and RF feeder fasteners. inspection. system – Volga in 204 check points by using modern quality control devices - Resource-UF2M-3T. condition of joints of support sections, Geodetic control of support position. Calculating the antenna support load capacity Pre-design inspection of substations. General inspection, inspection of secondary measuring circuits of CTs and VTs, operating current condition of bolted joints. taking into account detected defects. circuits, external communication channels of substations, own needs. Measurement of lightning protection Examination and assessment of technical resistance of antenna supports. Drawing up a defects list. Development of design and project documentation. The developed system of monitoring and management of electric power quality of PJSC condition of struts, struts and shafts of Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga includes four levels of data collection and processing: the support, supporting units of the shaft, Measurement of tension in rope weavers. individual grid elements, stairs, hatches and Measurement of quality of electric power at substations (86 500-220 kV substations). platforms, welded joints and metal close Visual inspection of constructions and their Hard- and software designed for collecting data about quality of electric power at the substation. to seams, rope weavers and mechanical connections. parts, fence of the top platform, lightning Hard- and software designed for collecting data about quality of electric power in branches of PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system.
Specially designed automated workplace in PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system. RESULT: RESULT: The report suggested recommendations how to eliminate identified defects and ensure safe operation of the facility. The system of monitoring and management of electric power quality at substations belonging to the branch of JSC PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga is a multilevel information and measuring system designed to automate measurements of electric power parameters, including electric power quality indicators, processing, accumulation and storage of results, as well as to have them available for control and analysis.
42 43 Oboronenergo JSC
Technical inspection of buildings and constructions of transformer substations, Energy inspection of enterprises and organizations distribution substations and electric substations of JSC Oboronenergo.
Region: Central, Urals, Southern, North-Western, Siberian, Far Eastern, Volga, North Caucasus Federal Districts Region: Nizhny Novgorod Region
Market segment: electricity transmission and distribution Market segment: other companies
Deadlines: 2014, 2015 Deadlines: 2011-2017
PROJECT GOALS: GOALS OF THE PROJECT:
Performance of technical inspection of buildings and constructions of transformer The basis for the work is the Federal Law of the Russian Federation of 23.11.2009 substations, distribution points and substations of JSC Oboronenergo. № 261-FZ «On energy saving» about the mandatory energy inspection of organizations which are listed in Article 16 of the Federal Law in hand.
SOLUTIONS AND IMPLEMENTATION: SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
The project was split into the following stages: Energy inspection was carried out in:
Analysis of available technical documentation. with indication of load-bearing structures, Performing verification calculations of «Nizhnovenergo, PJSC Federal grid company of united energy system – Volga and Center, brief description - 61 buildings. sections, photomaterials. load-bearing building structures. General inspection with a focus on revealing JSC «Sanatorium Avtomobilist» (Nizhny Novgorod region, Borsky district), brief description - 10 buildings, 7 vehicles. constructions with dangerous defects, Measurement of deviations of the building Development of the main conclusions and LLC Heat energy company (Pavlovo, Nizhny Novgorod region), brief description - 6 buildings, 4 vehicles. damages and deformations, especially the walls from the vertical. recommendations, making a conclusion ones in an emergency condition, with issuing (report). Instrumental inspection of defects and an action plan to prevent it from happening. damages. RESULT: Assessment of working environment of Specification of actual loads and impacts. facilities (possible temperature impacts, Department for civil defense, emergencies and fire safety, Nizhny Novgorod region (Nizhny Novgorod), brief description - 8 branches, 91 buildings, 246 vehicles. compliance with the conditions to ensure Assessment of the quality of applied spatial rigidity and stability). structural materials and their compounds. JSC Bateltrans - 5 branches.
Measurements of the required geometric Processing the results of the inspection JSC GosNiMash - (Nizhny Novgorod region, Dzerzhinsk), brief description - 3 production sites, 40 buildings, 44 vehicles. parameters of the building, including the with the compilation of a list of defects and use of geodetic devices. Execution of plans damages. «Oil handling terminal «Astrakhansky» LUKOIL-Trans, Ltd. (Astrakhan region, Ikryaninsky district, Ilyinka settlement), brief description - 19 buildings.
RESULT: LUKOIL-KNT, Ltd (Kaliningrad region, Svetly), brief description - 4 industrial sites, 19 buildings, 9 vehicles.
Technical examination of 816 buildings and structures of transformer substations, distribution points with the preparation of reports on Results of energy audits allowed to assess the efficiency of oil and energy resources, understand reasons behind its wrong use, discover the technical condition of building structures and certificates of technical examination. A distinctive feature of this project was the need to where oil and energy resources can be saved, propose technical and organizational energy-saving solutions and measures with a focus on coordinate technical inspection certificates in the territorial bodies of Rostechnadzor. forecasted savings in physical and monetary terms, the cost of their implementation, the expected economic effect of their implementation. After completing the energy inspection, a set of documentation examined by self-regulatory organization and approved by the Ministry of Energy was submitted to the customers.
44 45 Consulting Russian grids, Moscow region PJSC RusHydro
Conducting a technological and price audit of the adjustment project of PJSC Development of recommendations to update energy saving and energy efficiency “Moscow electric grids” long-term investment program for the period of 2018-2022 program of PJSC RusHydro and reports on the implementation of the investment program
Region: all regions of the Russian Federation Region: all regionsof the Russian Federation
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: electricity and heat generation and sales
Deadlines: 2017-2018 Deadlines: 2016-2017
GOALS OF THE PROJECT: GOALS OF THE PROJECT:
Assessment of how the project of adjustment of the long-term investment program Rendering assistance in updating the program in the field of energy saving and complies with the requirements of federal legislation in terms of investment energy efficiency of PJSC RusHydro for the period up to 2020. activity, namely:
°Assessing the necessity and sufficiency of investment projects due to be implemented and technological and design solutions to meet the target and planned values of quantitative indicators of the investment program, as well as to ensure the implementation of the Customer’s activities in the field of electric power industry;
Making sure that price and (or) cost indicators of investment projects are in line SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: with Russian legal requirements; In order to achieve the goals, a comparative analysis (benchmarking) of PJSC RusHydro’s hydro power stations and storage power Devising proposals to introduce amendments to the project for adjusting long-term stations was carried out based on key indicators listed in energy saving and energy efficiency improvement programs as prescribed by the methodology developed by the Russian Ministry of Energy to set goals within key performance indicators (KPIs).
PJSC RusHydro’s performance indicators were compared with its Russian and foreign counterparts’ in terms of key indicators given in energy saving and energy efficiency programs as prescribed by the methodology developed by the Russian Ministry of Energy for investment program with a focus of the list of investment projects to be implemented within its framework. organizations with a state’s stake in their capital, organizations engaged in regulated activities in the field of electric power industry and Developing technical and design solutions and (or) terms of implementation of the investment projects to: heat supply, namely, heat production in the combined heat and power generation mode.
Decreasing costs required for implementing investment program as a whole and individual investment projects;
Improving indicators characterizing energy and economic efficiency of services provided, on conditions target indicators and planned values RESULT: of quantitative indicators are met. Assessment of the economic profitability of PJSC RusHydro’s energy saving and energy efficiency improvement program for the period up to 2020, taking into account the requirements of the regulatory documents of the Ministry of Energy of Russia and PJSC RusHydro, as well as their prioritization. RESULT: Recommendations on unifying PJSC RusHydro’s corporate standards 04.02.75-2011 «Hydroelectric power plants. Energy efficiency and The technological and price audit of the project of adjustment of the long-term investment program of PJSC «Moscow electric grids», as energy saving. Basic requirements» with the requirements issued by the Ministry of Energy of Russia. well as reports on the implementation of the investment program served the basis for: International benchmarking of hydro power stations and storage power stations of PJSC RusHydro with selection of direct analogues which Meeting the obligation to comply with the directive issued by the Government of the Russian Federation dated 16.03.2017 № 1752p-P13; have close technical characteristics and operating conditions. Making the investment program and reports on its implementation meet legal requirements;
Obtaining recommendations on improving the investment program and reports on its implementation;
Taking into account the identified problems while developing future investment programs and reports on their implementation.
48 49 PricewaterhouseCoopers Rosmix LLC
Benchmarking of operational efficiency of PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – Development of a trade model for Tereshkovo gas turbine power plant federal grid company» structural units
Region: all regionsof the Russian Federation Region: Moscow
Market segment: transmission and distribution of electricity Market segment: production and sales of electricity and heat
Deadlines: 2014-2015 Sales period: 2013
GOALS OF THE PROJECT: The Tereshkovo gas turbine power plant is a player both on the wholesale electricity and power market and the regional heat supply market. Its electric capacity is 184 Develop a benchmarking methodology to measure operational efficiency at PJSC MW, heat capacity is 150 Gcal/h. «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company» structural units, as well as technical and methodological expertise of the project results.
The project was implemented together with PriceWaterhouseCoopers (hereinafter OBJECTIVE PROJECT OBJECTIVES: - PWC), the ETS –project group was invited to the project as the main technical Determination of economically viable level of prices and tariffs for the main products expert. of gas turbine power plant with a focus on the payback of the project.
Preparation of an opinion on the possibility of classifying GTPPs as objects with the SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: capacity supplied in the forced mode.
Expert support of detailing the process model of PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company» grid companies’ operations and the list of key performance indicators (KPIs). SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION:
Development of hypotheses how factors can influence KPIs to specify regression models. A trading model of the plant was prepared, which allows for modeling its operation under the conditions of operation on the wholesale electricity and power market and the regional heat market under the specified parameters. Development of proposals on benchmarking methodology in terms of normalization of operating costs of PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company». As part of the scenarios were made:
Preparation of expert conclusions as part of the development of a benchmarking methodology in case of any disagreements between PWC • Forecast of sales volumes for the main products of the plant (electricity, power, heat, technological connection services to switchgear and divisions of PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company». of the plant).
• Forecast of prices and tariffs for the main products: electricity, capacity (competitive power takeoff, forced mode calculation), heat energy, switchgear connection services. RESULT: • Forecast of costs, including fuel costs, taking into account the performed forecast of fuel prices. A methodology for assessing the efficiency of PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company» backbone networks has been developed and implemented.
The developed methodology was tested in the company’s backbone networks.
Target indicators were set for PJSC «United energy systems of Russia – federal grid company», potential for efficiency increase was discovered. The methodology for implementation of the efficiency monitoring system on a permanent basis (the system of long-term efficiency assessment) was developed.
50 51 энергия без границ
Administration of Starominskiy District PJSC InterRAO
Assessment of investment attractiveness and analysis of the investment project for construction of a gas engine generator plant in Analysis of benchmarking methods used by leading Russian and foreign power companies with a holding structure to improve the efficiency Starominsky District, Krasnodar Region of their energy facilities
Region: Starominskiy District, Krasnodar Territory Region: all regionsof the Russian Federation
Market segment: regional administrations Market segment: production and sales of electricity and heat
Deadlines: 2014 Deadlines: 2014
GOALS OF THE PROJECT: GOALS OF THE PROJECT:
Develop a concept for construction of a gas engine generator plant in Starominsky Analysis of domestic and foreign benchmarking methods. district of Krasnodar Region, which includes Research of the best practices of power plants, boiler-houses and heat networks. Determination of prerequisites for the construction of a gas engine generator plant in Starominsky district, Krasnodar region. SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: Analysis of the current and future situation of electricity, heat and gas supply in Starominsky district, Krasnodar region. To solve these ambitious tasks the techniques applied by leading Russian and foreign electric power companies with holding structure were examined to increase Determination of production and technical and economic performance of the plant. efficiency of power generating facilities; possibility of using state reporting to Financial and economic analysis of the project and assessment of its efficiency obtain well-structured initial data was examined.
A comparative analyses of data from US power plants was done. As part of it, a method of obtaining target for individual production units was proposed. The RESULT: analysis also discovered some recommendations issued by associations to set The project analyzed conditions of generating stations on the wholesale and retail electricity (power) market which determine their targets for the indicators used in their benchmarking methods. participation in trading electricity and heat (power). RESULT: Parameters of the power plant necessary to ensure payback of the project and to cover the deficit of energy resources in the area are determined. Foreign experience was studied on the example of the most cited energy corporations.
A preliminary summary of the estimated construction cost of the power plant was carried out. The list of performance indicators required for benchmarking was made up.
Calculation of the sensitivity of the project efficiency to changes in its main parameters is made. Requirements for initial data set.
As a result, the project developed materials required for applying for external financing in a foreign bank. The project summarizes domestic and foreign experience in implementing technical solutions to achieve best practice.
52 53 Department of fuel and energy resources of PJSC Russian energy company - East Moscow Development of a preliminary feasibility study to construct Chaun-Bilibino thermal Analysis of performance and prospects of fuel and energy sector development in power plant. Moscow
Region: Chukchi Autonomous district Region: Moscow
Market segment: production and sales of electricity and heat Market segment: regional administrations
Deadlines: 2017 Deadlines: 2013-2014
SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: GOALS OF THE PROJECT:
Distinctive features of the project are: To assist development of network infrastructure and generating facilities in Moscow to meet the long- and mid-term demand for electricity (power) and heat, to create stable and favorable conditions for attracting investments to create an GOALS OF THE PROJECT: efficient and balanced energy infrastructure, to implement a well-balanced tariff policy, which will ensure sustainable socio-economic development of the region and To develop a proposal for the construction of a thermal power plant which is needed environmentally responsible use of energy and energy resources to cover increasing loads in Chaun-Bilibinsky energy hub, as well as to analyze economic efficiency of the developed options for the construction of thermal To develop fuel and energy balance in Moscow in 2013, which serves as a basis power plants, taking into account the impact which the new thermal power might for the development of program and schematic documents in the fuel and energy heave heat tariffs on the construction site and electricity prices in Chaun-Bilibinsky complex and other sectors of economy in Moscow which is of top importance for energy hub. the analysis of results after the implementation of the energy saving program in Moscow. SOLUTION AND IMPLEMENTATION: Analysis of fuel and energy sector in Moscow in 2013 Distinctive features of the project are
Liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) is used as the main and reserve fuel in the thermal power plant in question. Any other types of fuel different from these were not considered.
RESULT:
RESULT: Systematization of key information concerning the performance of fuel and energy sector in Moscow.
There were developed twelve options of thermal power plant construction depending on external conditions. For each option a thorough Assessment of functional reliability and directions for its development. analysis of its economic efficiency was carried out by applying Uniform Scenario Conditions from PJSC Russian energy company - East for the period of 2016-2041 on the basis of the tariff-balance model by determining the impact of each option on heat energy on construction site and electricity in Chaun-Bilibino energy hub. In addition, for each option were developed economically justified tariffs for heat and electricity, indicators of financial and economic efficiency of the project (NPV, PI, IRR, PBP, DPBP), the amount of subsidies from federal and regional budgets to ensure sales of electricity at economically justified tariffs.
54 55 JSC «Energocomplex»
Development of scheme of power supply of networks with voltage 110 kV and higher in Troitskiy and Novomoskovskiy administrative districts in Moscow
Region: Moscow Market segment: electricity transmission and distribution Contacts Deadlines: 2014
GOALS OF THE PROJECT:
To develop main technical solutions of grids with 110 kV and higher voltage to ensure power supply to new consumers in the expandable part of Moscow in line Tel : +7 987 540 37 11 with the main technical solutions for development of adjacent power facilities by E-mail : [email protected] taking into account the dynamics of changes in power consumption and plans for the development of the electric power industry of Moscow region until 2025.
RESULT:
The scheme of power supply of grids with voltage 110 kV and higher for these areas in Moscow is a fundamental document to coordinate plans on development of heat supply systems, gas supply and generation facilities with power grid complex in the expanding part of Moscow. At the same time, the work performed is the first independent project which aim is to offer a complex approach to issues of power supply on new territories of the capital.
56 PORTFOLIO www.el-ts.ru