Annex 4: Findings Per District
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands Kigali, Rwanda Evaluation of the LODA Programme to Finance Infrastructure at De-central Level FINAL REPORT (draft) ANNEX 4: FINDINGS PER DISTRICT March 2016 CDP Consultants for Development Programmes Utrecht, the Netherlands CONTENTS List of acronyms .................................................................................................................... iii 1 Gasabo District ....................................................................................................................1 1.1 Evaluated projects ........................................................................................................1 1.1.1 Nduba Sector office ...............................................................................................1 1.1.2 Nduba health centre...............................................................................................7 1.1.3 Gishaka primary school ....................................................................................... 12 2 Gicumbi District ................................................................................................................. 17 2.1 Gicumbi District profile ................................................................................................ 17 2.2 Evaluated projects ...................................................................................................... 22 2.2.1 One cow per poor family programme ................................................................... 23 2.2.2 Mukarange livestock market ................................................................................ 25 2.2.3 Construction of 9&12 YBE (103 Classrooms, 204 toilets) .................................... 28 2.2.4 Construction of 2 bridges (Yaramba) ................................................................... 38 2.2.5 Construction of bridge (Gisiza) ............................................................................. 43 2.2.6 Access to clean water in Zoko-Mutete ................................................................. 48 3 Kamonyi District ................................................................................................................ 56 3.1 Kamonyi District profile ............................................................................................... 56 3.2 Evaluated projects ...................................................................................................... 60 3.2.1 Construction of administrative building ................................................................. 61 3.2.2 Construction of Karama health centre .................................................................. 71 3.2.3 Construction of guest house ................................................................................ 81 3.2.4 Construction of fence and toilets in Runda playground ........................................ 91 3.2.5 Construction of Runda paved road ....................................................................... 96 4 Karongi District ................................................................................................................ 101 4.1 Karongi District profile ............................................................................................... 101 4.2 Evaluated projects .................................................................................................... 105 4.2.1 Construction of banana macro-propagator ......................................................... 106 4.2.2 Public lights in Karongi Town ............................................................................. 107 Street lighting connection source One pole light lamp in not illuminating 4.2.3 Construction of Agakiriro phase III 109 4.2.4 Surveillance of Construction of Youth Peace Centre phase I ............................. 118 4.2.5 School construction and rehabilitation project .................................................... 119 4.2.6 The Bwisyura market (also visited in 2013) ........................................................ 124 4.2.7 Ruragwe Sector office (visited in 2013) .............................................................. 131 5 Nyagatare District ............................................................................................................ 132 5.1 Nyagatare District profile .......................................................................................... 132 5.2 Evaluated projects .................................................................................................... 136 5.2.1 Construction of Rwempasha meeting hall .......................................................... 137 5.2.2 Rehabilitation of Rwabiharamba and Bwera valley dams ................................... 142 5.2.3 Supervision of Nyagatare modern market .......................................................... 149 5.2.4 Study of construction of Nyagatare stadium ....................................................... 157 5.2.5 Rehabilitation of Mirama-Rukomo road .............................................................. 158 i 6 Nyamasheke District........................................................................................................ 163 6.1 Nyamasheke District profile ...................................................................................... 163 6.2 Evaluated projects .................................................................................................... 169 6.2.1 IDP model village project in Cyato Sector .......................................................... 169 6.2.2 Electrification of Cyato, Rangiro, Karambi and Kanjongo Sectors ...................... 174 6.2.3 Construction and supervision of agakiriro in Kagano sector ............................... 182 6.2.4 Rehabilitation and extension of Kagarama-Ntendezi water pipeline ................... 190 7 Rwamagana District ........................................................................................................ 194 7.1 Rwamagana District Profile....................................................................................... 194 7.2 Evaluated projects .................................................................................................... 198 7.2.1 Construction of 4 Km of public light in Rwamagana Town .................................. 199 7.2.2 Completion of construction works of Ntunga maternity ward in Mwurire Sector .. 202 7.2.3 Extension and rehabilitation of Rwamagana technical secondary school ........... 209 7.2.4 Construction of integrated craft production centre in Rwamagana Town ............ 218 7.2.5 Supply and supervision of water in Cyarukamba Cyimbazi and Nkomangwa Cells ................................................................................................................................... 225 7.2.6 Cyiri market (also visited in 2013) ...................................................................... 231 7.2.7 Ntunga electricity project (also visited in 2013) .................................................. 235 7.2.8 Gahengiri health centre (also visited in 2013) .................................................... 236 7.2.9 Byimana water scheme (also visited in 2013) .................................................... 241 ii List of acronyms AI Administrative Infrastructure AL Agriculture and Livestock CB Capacity Building CDF Common Development Fund CDP Consultants for Development Programmes DAC Development Assistance Committee DDP District Development Plans EDPRS Economic Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy EI Energy Infrastructure EICV Integrated Household Living Conditions Survey EKN Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands EP Environmental Protection FDB Financial Development Budget FGD Focus Group Discussion GDP Gross Domestic Product GoR GoR HI Health Infrastructure HIMO Labour-intensive (Haute Intensité de Main-d'oeuvre) ICT Information and Communication Technology IGA Income Generating Activity LED Local Economic Development LG Local Government LODA Local Administrative Entities Development Agency M&E Monitoring and Evaluation MINALOC Ministry of Local Government MIECOFIN Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning MOI Market Oriented Infrastructure MTR Mid Term Review NCBS National Capacity Building Secretariat NGOs Non-Governmental Organisations NISR National Institute of Statistics Rwanda O&M Operation and Maintenance OH Outcome Harvesting OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development OSC One Stop Centre PA Participatory Assessment Prodocs Project documents PTA Parents Teachers Association RLDSF Rwanda Local Development Support Fund RWF Rwanda Franc (1 Euro is about RWF 840) SACCO Savings and Credit Cooperative SCI Sports, Culture and Tourism Infrastructure SI School Infrastructure SMEs Small and Medium-size Enterprises TI Transport Infrastructure ToR Terms of Reference VUP Vision 2020 Umurenge Programme WS Water and Sanitation YBE Year Basic Education iii 1 Gasabo District For six visited districts, a district profile and detailed analyses of individual projects are presented in Section 2 to 7 of this annex. Gasabo was added as a seventh district for a try-out of the evaluation questions based on the OECD/DAC criteria. All projects visited in Gasabo District were also visited during the evaluation of 2013. Only one day was spent here and in this section the analyses of the visited projects are given. 1.1 Evaluated projects 1.1.1 Nduba Sector office The Nduba Sector office was well maintained