The Orthodox Conception of the Hereafter: Saʿd Al-Dīn Al-Taftāzānī’S (D

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Orthodox Conception of the Hereafter: Saʿd Al-Dīn Al-Taftāzānī’S (D CHAPTER 21 The Orthodox Conception of the Hereafter: Saʿd al-Dīn al-Taftāzānī’s (d. 793/1390) Examination of Some Muʿtazilī and Philosophical Objections Thomas Würtz 1 Introduction Belief in life after death is an integral part of Islam. This dogma was proclaimed by Muḥammad and soon gave rise to a controversy with his opponents in Mecca. It is also considered an integral part of some final judgment as known from Christianity, followed by an afterlife in a paradise garden or in hellfire. This second existence is also connected with an idea of justice, because dwell- ing in paradise or hell is considered the result of human behavior during one’s first, earthly existence. In the early history of Islamic theology (ʿilm al-kalām) it seemed to be uncontested; the second creation and the bodily existence of human beings in the hereafter were seen as being within the capability of an almighty God. In the emerging debates between the Muʿtazila and the Ashʿarī school in the ninth and tenth centuries some eschatological matters were discussed, as we see later, but the existence of paradise and hellfire and their material character were not called into question. The situation changed after the arrival of Greek philosophy in Muslim thought and the discussion thereof. Islamic eschatology was now challenged by the ideas of the Islamic philosophers, especially al-Fārābī (d. 339/950) and Ibn Sīnā (d. 428/1037), who considered the path to the hereafter as a spiri- tual resurrection instead of a second material creation. Theologians rejected this idea, the belief in the eternity of the material world, and the view that knowledge logically demonstrated is more true than revealed knowledge in the holy book. Nevertheless, the argumentation established by al-Fārābī and Ibn Sīnā deeply influenced the theology of that time: The logical method of argumentation came to be fully accepted in the Ashʿarī school from the time of al-Ghazālī.1 Also in their terminology, the late Islamic theologians followed the conception of Ibn Sīnā’s metaphysics, which is based on the difference between what is necessary and what is possible. God himself is described as 1 Rudolph, Neubewertung der Logik 73–5. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���7 | doi ��.��63/9789004333�54_0�� The Orthodox Conception of the Hereafter 469 necessarily existing (al-wājib al-wujūd) in contrast to all other created things, which are possibly existing (al-mumkin al-wujūd).2 In the end, the Ashʿarī posi- tion came to be widely accepted and seemed, from an outside perspective, to be victorious over that of the philosophers, although the internal philosophi- cal influence on Islamic theology (ʿilm al-kalām) cannot be denied. In the later kalām-theology of the seventh/thirteenth century, which is under consideration here, the discussion of eternal destiny becomes mingled with older debates involving questions not based on philosophical challenges, but rather consisting of debates between the Muʿtazila and the Ashʿarī school.3 Against this background, in what follows I show how the renowned scholar Saʿd al-Dīn al-Taftāzānī (722–93/1322–90) presents the Ashʿarī conception of the hereafter. Like his predecessors al-Bayḍāwī (d. 716/1316) and al-Ījī (d. 756/1355), he refutes the philosophical and theological objections. But on examination of the details of his theological argumentation, we find several instances of the influence of medieval Islamic philosophy. This may be shown in the analysis of the Arabic term for resurrection, the above-mentioned question of bodily or spiritual resurrection, and the question of whether paradise and hell should be considered as already created abodes existing alongside our earthly world or as subjects of creation at doomsday. Another question of interest deals with the value of the repentance of one’s sins as counterbalancing misdeeds in the final judgment. Before doing so, we should have a short look at the author and his work. 2 Taftāzānī and Sharḥ al-Maqāṣid Saʿd al-Dīn al-Taftāzānī was well known for the breadth of his learning, which covered mainly theology, rhetoric, and law.4 He was born in Taftāzān in 722/1322 as the descendant of a family well established in scholarship for several generations. His grandfather Fakhr al-Dīn was a judge (qāḍī). After his education he started teaching at several courts in the northeast part of what is now Iran and Afghanistan. Later on, he lived in Khwārazm, but when this town was seized by the conqueror Tīmūr (d. 807/1405), he joined the group of famous scholars living at Tīmūr’s court in Samarqand, although he refused Tīmūr’s first invitation, because he was planning a journey to the Hijaz5 – most 2 Madelung, At-Taftāzānī und die Philosophie 231. 3 Fakhry, History 203–5. 4 Madelung, Saʿd al-Dīn al-Taftāzānī 95. 5 Khwāndmīr, Tārīkh-i ḥabīb iii, 545..
Recommended publications
  • Fazlallah Astarabadi and the Hurufis
    prelims.046 17/12/2004 4:58 PM Page i MAKERS of the MUSLIM WORLD Fazlallah Astarabadi and The Hurufis “Shahzad Bashir is to be commended for producing a remarkably accessible work on a complex subject; his explanations are models of lucidity and brevity.” PROFESSOR DEVIN DEWEESE, INDIANA UNIVERSITY prelims.046 14/12/2004 1:37 PM Page ii SELECTION OF TITLES IN THE MAKERS OF THE MUSLIM WORLD SERIES Series editor: Patricia Crone, Institute for Advanced Study,Princeton ‘Abd al-Malik, Chase F.Robinson Abd al-Rahman III, Maribel Fierro Abu Nuwas, Philip Kennedy Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Christopher Melchert Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi, Usha Sanyal Al-Ma’mun, Michael Cooperson Al-Mutanabbi, Margaret Larkin Amir Khusraw, Sunil Sharma El Hajj Beshir Agha, Jane Hathaway Fazlallah Astarabadi and the Hurufis, Shazad Bashir Ibn ‘Arabi,William C. Chittick Ibn Fudi,Ahmad Dallal Ikhwan al-Safa, Godefroid de Callatay Shaykh Mufid,Tamima Bayhom-Daou For current information and details of other books in the series, please visit www.oneworld-publications.com/ subjects/makers-of-muslim-world.htm prelims.046 14/12/2004 1:37 PM Page iii MAKERS of the MUSLIM WORLD Fazlallah Astarabadi and The Hurufis SHAHZAD BASHIR prelims.046 14/12/2004 1:37 PM Page iv FAZLALLAH ASTARABADI AND THE HURUFIS Oneworld Publications (Sales and editorial) 185 Banbury Road Oxford OX2 7AR England www.oneworld-publications.com © Shahzad Bashir 2005 All rights reserved Copyright under Berne Convention A CIP record for this title is available from the British Library ISBN 1–85168–385–2 Typeset by Jayvee,
    [Show full text]
  • Islam in Process—Historical and Civilizational Perspectives Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam Volume 7
    Islam in Process—Historical and Civilizational Perspectives Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam Volume 7 2006-12-06 16-23-03 --- Projekt: T491.gli.arnason.yearbook7 / Dokument: FAX ID 00fb133402603594|(S. 1 ) T00_01 Schmutztitel.p 133402603618 Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam Edited by Georg Stauth and Armando Salvatore The Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam investigates the making of Islam into an important component of modern society and cultural globalization. Sociology is, by common consent, the most ambitious advocate of modern society. In other words, it undertakes to develop an understanding of modern existence in terms of breakthroughs from ancient cosmological cultures to ordered and plural civic life based on the gradual subsiding of communal life. Thus, within this undertaking, the sociological project of modernity figures as the cultural machine that dislodges the rationale of social being from local, communal, hierarchic contexts into the logic of individualism and social differentiation. The conventional wisdom of sociology has been challenged by post-modern debate, abolishing this dichotomous evolutionism while embracing a more heterogeneous view of coexistence and exchange between local cultures and modern institutions. Islam, however, is often described as a different cultural machine for the holistic reproduction of pre-modern religion, and Muslims are seen as community-bound social actors embodying a powerful potential for the rejec- tion of and opposition to Western modernity. Sociologists insist on looking for social differentiation and cultural differ- ences. However, their concepts remain evolutionist and inherently tied to the cultural machine of modernity. The Yearbook of the Sociology of Islam takes these antinomies and contradic- tions as a challenge.
    [Show full text]
  • Martyrdom in Christianity and Islam Martyrdom 1Fl Christianity and Islam
    33 MartyrdomMartyrdom 1fl in ChristianityChristianity andand Islam MAHMOUDMAHMOTJD M. M. AYOUBAYOUB nneue ofof methe most important marks of a person's faith faith oror commitmentcommitment toto OV a religiousa religious ideology ideology i.sis hishis readinessreadiness to to defenddefend thatthat faithfaith with life itself ifif necessary. Examples Examples of of such such heroic heroic sacrifice sacrifice or or martyrdom martyrdom abound abound in in bornboth ancientancient and contemporary society.society, InIn ancientancient times, the heroicheroic indifference of suchsuch menmen asas thethe StoicStoic philosopher, philosopher, Epktetus, Epictetus, to to torrure torture and and death death inin thethe affirmation of aa noblenoble idealideal earnedearned them the honor of martyrs; their example and ideal of total indifference to passionspassions and worldlyworldly life provided a model for earlyearly ChristianChristian martyrs. InIn ourour own time,time, such menmen as Che Guaverra andand his legendary comrade Tanya havehave beenbeen regardedregarded asas martyrsmartyrs andand even saints by somesome CatholicCatholic leftistleftist priests.priests. MartyrdomMartyrdom hashas beenbeen oneone of the most power-power­ ful instruments in thethe establishmentestablishment andand propagationpropagation ofof a a faithfaith oror ideology,ideology, and hencehence ofof aa newnew socialsocial order. In thisthis essay wewe shallshall examineexamine thethe philosophyphilosophy of of martyrdom martyrdom andand the role of martyrs inin Christianity
    [Show full text]
  • Practices of Islamic State (ISIS) in the Context of Islamic Eschatology
    Practices of Islamic State (ISIS) in the Context of Islamic Eschatology Andrey Chuprygin, Senior Lecturer, School of Asian Studies, National Research University “Higher School of Economics”, 101000, 20, Myasnitskaya str., Moscow, Russian Federation, E-mail: [email protected] Andrey Kudelin, Phd, Department of World History, Peoples’ Friendship University, 117198, Moscow Miklukho- Maklaya str. 6, E-mail: [email protected] Valeriy Matrosov, Graduate, School of Asian Studies, National Research University “Higher School of Economics”, Master Student, Faculty of Asian and African Studies, Saint Petersburg State University, 199034, 7-9, Universitetskaya nab., St. Petersburg, Russia, E-mail: [email protected] Abstract The History has shown once again, that one cannot fight something that one does not understand. In modern warfare both the military and the ideological fronts are at the same level of intensity, as the victory always depends not only on battlefield triumphs, but also on enlisting new adherents and holding to the old ones. And after two years of heroic fight of the “Obama Alliance” against IS in Syria and Iraq there is a clear indication, that Caliph Ibrahim (Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi) is winning on both fronts. The main goal of this article is an attempt to explain reasons underlying the success of ISIS leadership, that allowed the Islamists not only to evade the “degrade and destroy” strategy of the coalition, but also to build a new state, in the light of the context of Islamic eschatological concepts. To reach this goal, we strive to not only understand the perspectives of this newly- founded state and possible forecasts for its sustainability, but also to look into the reasons of IS attractiveness for large groups of people from a variety of countries and regions, through the lens of Islamic eschatology.
    [Show full text]
  • Inside the Jihadi Mind Understanding Ideology and Propaganda
    Inside the Jihadi Mind Understanding Ideology and Propaganda EMMA EL-BADAWY MILO COMERFORD PETER WELBY 1 2 Contents Executive Summary 5 Policy Recommendations 9 Introduction 13 Framework for Analysis Values 23 Objectives 35 Conduct 45 Group Identity 53 Scripture and Scholarship How Jihadi Groups Use the Quran and Hadith 63 How Jihadi Groups Make Use of / Reject Scholarship 67 Appendices Methodology 70 Glossary 74 Acknowledgements 76 Note This report was first published in October 2015. The research was carried by the Centre on Religion & Geopolitics. The work of the Centre on Religion & Geopolitics is now carried out by the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change. 3 4 1.0 Executive Summary This report identifies what ideology is shared by ISIS, Jabhat al- Nusra, and al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninusla, as revealed in their propaganda, in order to inform effective counter-narratives. The ideology of global extremism can only be countered if it is first understood. This combination of theology and political objectives needs to be uprooted through rigorous scrutiny, and sustained intellectual confrontation. After the 9/11 attacks, Osama Bin Laden’s al- Qaeda had approximately 300 militants. ISIS alone has, at a low estimate, 31,000 fighters across Syria 55 and Iraq. Understanding how ideology has driven this Salafi-jihadism is a vital motivating force for extremist phenomenon is essential to containing and defeating violence, and therefore must be countered in order to violent extremism. curb the threat. But violent ideologies do not operate in a vacuum. AIM OF THE REPORT SUMMARY EXECUTIVE A fire requires oxygen to grow.
    [Show full text]
  • Introducing Hell in Islamic Studies
    CHAPTER � Introducing Hell in Islamic Studies Christian Lange In regard to the afterlife, scholars of Islam in the West have demonstrated a remarkably irenic temper, preferring to give far more attention to paradise than to hell. The Islamic hell, for the most part, has been viewed as no more than the mirror image of paradise, an ugly reflection of the beauties and the joys in heaven. Consequently, it has been considered a phenomenon of secondary logical and ontological order, as well as interest. The few general overviews of Islamic eschatology largely bypass the infernal regions,1 and the dedicated studies of the Islamic paradise, of which there are a fair number,2 cannot be said to be paralleled by the same number of scholarly forays into the Islamic hell.3 While the entry on paradise in the second edition of the Encyclopaedia of Islam (1954–2005) counts eleven columns in the printed edition, its entry 1 The most widely cited studies of this kind are Smith/Haddad, Islamic understanding, and El-Saleh, La vie future, each of whom pays much less attention to hell than to paradise. Also shorter overviews tend in this direction. See, for example, the classic study by Meier, The ultimate origin; or the stimulating essay by Reinhart, The here and the hereafter. 2 Al-Azmeh, Rhetoric for the senses; Lange, Paradise in the Islamic religious imagination; Lohlker/Nowak, Das islamische Paradies; MacDonald, Islamic eschatology—VI; Raven, A Kitāb al-ʿAẓama; Rosenthal, Reflections on love; Schimmel, The celestial garden. See also the numerous studies of aspects of paradise in the Quran, for example Horovitz, Das koranische Paradies; Jenkinson, Rivers of paradise; Lange, The discovery of paradise; Neuwirth, Reclaiming paradise lost; O’Shaughnessy, Eschatological themes, 76–107; Tubach, Schönheiten; Wendell, The denizens of paradise.
    [Show full text]
  • False Prophets? Ontological Conflicts and Religion-Making in An
    CHAPTER 4 False Prophets? Ontological Con!icts and Religion-Making in an Indonesian Court Kari Telle INTRODUCTION Since 1998, when Indonesians embarked on a process of democratiza- tion after more than three decades of authoritarian rule, there has been a sharp rise in accusations of “insults to Islam” and ensuing prosecutions of blasphemy. This chapter examines a blasphemy trial on the island of Lombok in 2010, in which an elderly Muslim farmer from East Lombok was accused of being a “false prophet” ( nabi palsu ) and taken to court. In court, Pak Abdullah alias Amaq Bakri testi#ed that he had visited heaven on several occasions, including the highest seventh level. 1 Yet it was the claim that he had received revelations from the Angel Gabriel, a key #g- ure in the Islamic tradition, that court of#cials and religious authorities found particularly troubling. Besides challenging mainstream under- standings of prophesy in Sunni Islam, local authorities worried that other Muslims might be misled to assume that divinity might crop up anywhere K. Telle ( ) Chr. Michelsen Institute, Bergen, Norway © The Author(s) 2016 89 B.E. Bertelsen, S. Bendixsen (eds.), Critical Anthropological Engagements in Human Alterity and Difference , DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-40475-2_4 90 K. TELLE and within anyone. While the prosecutor demanded a one-and-a-half year sentence, the judges on the District Court ruled that a one-year prison sentence was suf#cient since the accused was of an advanced age, did not have a prior criminal record, and declared himself willing “to return to the true Islamic teachings” 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Professor James Winston Morris Department of Theology Boston College E-Mail: [email protected] Office Telephone: 617-552-0571 Many of Prof
    1 Professor James Winston Morris Department of Theology Boston College e-mail: [email protected] Office telephone: 617-552-0571 Many of Prof. Morris’s articles and reviews, and some older books, are now freely available in searchable and downloadable .pdf format at http://dcollections.bc.edu/james_morris PREVIOUS ACADEMIC POSITIONS: 2006-present Boston College, Professor, Department of Theology. 1999-2006 University of Exeter, Professor, Sharjah Chair of Islamic Studies and Director of Graduate Studies and Research, Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies. 1989-99: Oberlin College: Assoc. Professor, Department of Religion. 1988-89: Temple University: Asst. Professor, Department of Religion. 1987-88: Princeton University: Visiting Professor, Department of Religion and Department of Near Eastern Studies. 1981-87: Institute of Ismaili Studies, Paris/London (joint graduate program in London with McGill University, Institute of Islamic Studies): Professor, Department of Graduate Studies and Research. EDUCATION AND ACADEMIC HONORS: HARVARD UNIVERSITY PH.D, NEAR EASTERN LANGUAGES CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS AND CIVILIZATIONS, 1980 Major field: Islamic philosophy and theology; minor fields: classical philosophy, Arabic language and literature, Persian language and literature, . Fellowships: Danforth Graduate Fellowship (1971-1978); Whiting Foundation Dissertation Fellowship (1978-1979); foreign research fellowships (details below). UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO B.A., CIVILIZATIONAL CHICAGO, ILLINOIS STUDIES, 1971 Awards and Fellowships: University Scholar;
    [Show full text]
  • Secrecy in Isma¨Ili Tradition and in the Mystical Thought of Ibn Al-¨Arabi
    SECRECY IN ISMA¨ILI TRADITION AND IN THE MYSTICAL THOUGHT OF IBN AL-¨ARABI BY MICHAEL EBSTEIN1 Secrecy plays an important role in human culture in general and in religious traditions in particular. The desire to conceal beliefs and doc- trines, for whatever reasons, is universal; it is manifested in various reli- gions and philosophical traditions in the ancient world, from Hellenistic and Roman times, to the medieval period, to the modern era2. In Islam, secrecy and the different aspects related to it are characteristic of both the Shi¨ite tradition and Sunnite mysticism. The aim of this article is twofold: first, to elucidate some of the main features and functions of secrecy in Shi¨ism and Sunnite mysticism, primarily in the Isma¨ili tradition and in the mystical thought of Ibn al-¨Arabi; and secondly, to underscore possible links and affinities between Andalusian mysticism — here represented mainly by Ibn al-¨Arabi — and Isma¨ili doctrines. The importance of these links and affinities for the study of the history of Islamic thought and especially that of Islamic mysticism and esotericism will be discussed in the con- cluding paragraph of this article. 1 The following article is based on my doctoral thesis, «Philosophy, Mysticism and Esotericism: Isma¨ili Thought and Andalusian Mysticism», currently being written under the supervision of Prof. Meir Bar-Asher and Prof. Sara Sviri from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. I wish to thank them both for their important comments on this article and for their assistance throughout my work. 2 See K. W. Bolle (ed.), Secrecy in Religions, Leiden: Brill, 1987; H.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mahdi Wears Armani
    The Mahdi wears Armani wears Mahdi The The prolific Turkish author Harun Yahya attracted international attention after thousands of unsolicited copies of his large-format and lavishly illustrated book Atlas of Creation were sent free of charge from Istanbul, Turkey, to schools, universities and state leaders worldwide in 2007. This book stunt drew attention to Islamic creationism as a growing phenomenon, and to Harun Yahya as its most prominent proponent globally. Harun Yahya is allegedly the pen name of the Turkish author and preacher Adnan Oktar. Behind the brand name “Harun Yahya”, a highly prosperous religious enterprise is in operation, devoted not merely to the debunking of Darwinism, but THE also to the promotion of Islam. Backed by his supporters, Oktar channels vast financial resources into producing numerous books, dvds, websites and lately also television shows promoting his message. MAHDI The aim of this dissertation is to shed light on the Harun Yahya enterprise by examining selected texts published in the framework of the enterprise. It describes, WEARS analyzes and contextualizes four key themes in the works of Harun Yahya, namely conspiracy theories, nationalism/neo-Ottomanism, creationism and apocalypticism/ Mahdism. The dissertation traces the development of the enterprise from a religious ArMANI community emerging in Turkey in the mid-1980s to a global da‘wa enterprise, and examines the way in which its discourse has changed over time. The dissertation’s point of departure is the notion that the Harun Yahya enterprise and the ideas it promotes must primarily be understood within the Turkish context from which it emerged. Drawing on analytical frameworks from social movement theory and rhetorical analysis as well as contemporary perspectives on Islamic da‘wa and activism, the study approaches Harun Yahya as a religious entrepreneur seeking market shares in the contemporary market for Islamic proselytism by adopting and adapting popular discourses both in the Turkish and global contexts.
    [Show full text]
  • Information to Users
    INFORMATION TO USERS This manuscript has been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may be from any type of computer printer. The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleedthrough, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the-deletion. Oversize materials (e.g., maps, drawings, charts) are reproduced by sectioning the original, beginning at the upper left-hand comer and continuing from left to right in equal sections with small overlaps. Photographs included in the original manuscript have been reproduced xerographically in this copy. Higher quality 6” x 9” black and white photographic prints are available for any photographs or illustrations appearing in this copy for an additional charge. Contact UMI directly to order. ProQuest Information and Leaming 300 North Zeeb Road, Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 USA 800-521-0600 UMI* ESCHATOLOGY AS POLITICS, ESCHATOLOGY AS THEORY: MODERN SUNNI ARAB MAHDISM IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Timothy R. Furnish, M.A.R. The Ohio State University 2001 Dissertation Committee: Approved by Professor Jane Hathaway, Adviser Professor Sam Meier viser Professor Joseph Zeidan " Department of Histdry UMI Number: 3011060 UMI UMI Microform 3011060 Copyright 2001 by Bell & Howell Information and Leaming Company.
    [Show full text]
  • Qurʾānic Hermeneutics with Reference to Narratives: a Study in Classical Exegetical Traditions
    Qurʾānic Hermeneutics with Reference to Narratives: A Study in Classical Exegetical Traditions Submitted by Khaled Troudi, to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Arab and Islamic Studies, July 2011 This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this dissertation which is not my own work has been identified and that no material has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by or any other University. (Signature)…………………………………………………………………….. i ACKNOWLEDGMENT First, I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the members and staff of the Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies at the University of Exeter for their encouragement and guidance. I would also like to express my gratitude to all my advisors for their teaching and patience, and in particular, to Dr. Jamal Barzinji from the International Institute of Islamic Thought who shared my curiosity about religion and helped me in some of the most provoking discussions and discourses. My sincere thanks are also extended to the members of my PhD Thesis Committee Professor ―Abd al-Ḥalīm from SOAS and Professor Robert Gleave from the Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies at the University of Exeter for their guidance and patience. Special thanks to my advisor, teacher and friend, Dr. Sajjad Rizvi to whom I am eternally grateful, as words cannot express my heartfelt gratitude. Dr. Rizvi taught me how to understand serious scholarship and the amount of work that is required for such an endeavor.
    [Show full text]