Pius V and the Rise of the Roman Inquisition

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Pius V and the Rise of the Roman Inquisition chapter 3 Between the Prince and the Pope: Pius v and the Rise of the Roman Inquisition When cardinal- inquisitor Michele Ghislieri became Pope Pius v in January 1566 senior Jesuits predicted that, as pope, he would prioritise the work of the Roman Inquisition. Just days after the conclave closed, Superior General Francesco Bor- ja wrote that ‘matters of Reform and the Inquisition [would] come first’ under a Ghislieri pope.1 Others in Rome agreed. In a letter of March 1566, the Venetian ambassador to the Holy See claimed that ‘matters of religion would be the most favoured’ by Pius, ‘and particularly of the Inquisition’.2 Another Italian writer told the Archbishop of Santa Severina, Giulio Antonio Santoro, that Pius v’s pontifi- cate would herald a return to the inquisitorial severity of his mentor, Pope Paul iv (1555– 9). ‘To Rome, to Rome, what awaits you?’ he asked, ‘come happily, God has revived Paul iv there’.3 Pius v soon corroborated these predictions. As pope, he established the Roman Inquisition as a stable institution, building permanent headquarters for the congregation at a cost of more than 50,000 scudi.4 In 1568, he publicly executed Paul iv’s enemy Pietro Carnesecchi, the Florentine nobleman who had escaped condemnation for heresy at Paul’s death in 1559.5 In 1570, Pius established the Congregation of the Index, re- imposing Paul iv’s rigorous cen- sorship of heretical books and reversing the more moderate guidelines set by 1 arsi, Epistolae Generalium Italiae 66, f.122r. 2 Paolo Tiepolo in Fabio Mutinelli, Storia arcana e aneddotica d’Italia, raccontata dai veneti ambasciatori (Venice: Pietro Naratovich, 1855– 6), vol. 1, p.38. 3 Marcantonio Fiorenzo to Giulio Antonio Santoro, 9 January 1566, published in G. Cugnoni (ed.), Autobiografia di monsignor G. Antonio Santori, cardinale di Santa Severina in Archivio della Società romana di storia patria, 12 (1889), p. 339. 4 David Coffin, Pirro Ligorio: The Renaissance Artist, Architect, and Antiquarian (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press), p.77 and Ludwig von Pastor, Frederick Ignatius Antrobus and Ralph Francis Kerr (eds), The History of the Popes from the close of the Middle Ages drawn from the secret archives of the Vatican and other original sources; from the Ger- man of late Ludwig Pastor (London: Kegan, Paul, Trench, Trübner and Co., 1874–1928), 40 vols, vol.17, p.288. 5 On the case of Pietro Carnesecchi see, Firpo and Marcatto (eds), I processi inquisitoriali di Pietro Carnesecchi. © Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2020 | DOI:10.1163/9789004413832_005 94 chapter 3 his own predecessor Pius iv.6 He also re- appointed Scipione Rebiba, Francisco Pacheco and Gian Francesco Gambara, cardinal- inquisitors who had been loy- al servants of Paul iv and who had been sacked by the more lenient Pius iv.7 Some feared that Pius v’s inquisition would be even harsher than that of his mentor. A witness at the trial of Count Niccolò Orsini claimed that ‘at the time of Pope Paul [iv] … [Orsini] never went to mass’.8 It seemed that the count was not so afraid of Carafa. Under Pius v, however, it was said that Orsini was terrified about the potential consequences of his past transgressions.9 If Pius v was to take a similar or even harsher approach to that of Paul iv it was very bad news for the Society’s privilege to absolve heresy. Paul iv had tried to negate the Jesuits’ privilege, issuing a brief that required all confessors, including Jesuits, to refuse absolutions until penitent-heretics had visited the Holy Office, though the Jesuits do not appear to have been held to this.10 Doc- uments produced to defend the privilege in the 1580s suggest that Pius v fol- lowed the example of his mentor. The papers list concessions of the privilege from Julius iii’s pontificate onwards. Some fall silent after the concession of Pius v’s predecessor, Pius iv, before moving on to the concessions of his suc- cessor, Gregory xiii, suggesting that Pius failed to re- concede the power.11 An- other list notes that Pius v did concede the privilege, before stating that Greg- ory xiii granted the same but ‘also in Italy’.12 This wording implies that Pius v only confirmed the privilege for northern Europe and that Gregory extended it to Italy to restore the power to the same level as the Jesuits had previously 6 Romeo, L’Inquisizione nell’Italia moderna, p.19. On the Index and its congregation see Fragnito, Church, censorship and culture in early modern Italy; Fragnito, La Bibbia al rogo and Vittorio Frajese, Nascita dell’Indice. La censura ecclesiastica dal Rinascimento alla Controriforma (Brescia: Morcelliana, 2006). 7 The decision is recorded at acdf, Sant’Uffico Decreta, 1565– 7, f.35r. See also, Bonora, ‘L’In- quisizione e papato tra Pio IV e Pio V’ in Guasco and Torre (eds), Pio V nella società e nella politica del suo tempo, pp.54– 55 and Santarelli, ‘Dinamiche interne della Congregazione di Sant’Uffizio’, p.12. 8 acdf, Stanza Storica R- 2- m, f.226v. Fosi, Papal Justice. p.96. 9 Fosi, Papal Justice. p.96. 10 On Paul’s brief in the context of papal edicts on confession and the inquisition see Brambilla, Alle origini del Sant’Uffizio, pp.406– 409. On the brief’s effects see Prosperi, Tribunali della coscienza, pp.231– 3. Romeo argues that there is no evidence that the Jesuits were held to this rule in his Ricerche su confessione, p.44. A letter by Laínez in January 1559 confirms this: arsi, Epistolae Generalium Italiae 61, 381v. 11 See, for example, a record from the last years of the sixteenth century: ‘Absolvendi ab haeresi et lectione librorum prohibitorum … Idem Pius 4 X. Martii 1561 … Absolvendi ab haeresi. Gregor[io] ult[im]o Martii 1573’.arsi, Institutum 185 – I, f.313v. 12 ‘Absolvendi ab haeresi andc Pius Quintus die 12 Maii 1568. Absolvendi ab haeresi etiam in Italia. Greg[ori]o Ult[im]o Martii 1573’. acdf, Stanza Storica I- 5- B, ff.45r- v..
Recommended publications
  • Pope St. Pius V: Pope of the Rosary Pope St
    Did you know . Pope St. Pius V: Pope of the Rosary Pope St. Pius V is one of the foremost leaders of the Catholic Reformation. He was born Antonio Ghislieri in Bosco, Italy, to a poor family; he worked as a shepherd until the age of fourteen when he joined the Dominicans, and was ordained in 1528. He studied at Bologna and Genoa, and then taught theology and philosophy for sixteen years. He was known for his long hours of prayer and fasting, and his holy speech. Due to his reputation for holiness and his great intelligence, he rose to a number of prominent positions in the Church, including Inquisitor and bishop. When Pope Pius IV died in 1565, he was unanimously elected Pope and took the name Pope Pius V. As pope, Pius was a great reformer and saw as his main objective the full implementation of the decrees of the Council of Trent. He also supported the foreign missions and worked for the reform of the clergy. He published the Roman Catechism, the revised Roman Breviary, and the Roman Missal; he also declared Thomas Aquinas a Doctor of the Church, commanded a new edition of the works of Thomas Aquinas, and created a commission to revise the Vulgate. Pope Pius V was especially known for his devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary and for being a great promoter of the Holy Rosary. He was given the title of “The Pope of the Rosary” for issuing a papal bull, Consueverunt Romani Pontifices, in which he secured the uniformity of the Holy Rosary for recitation throughout the Catholic Church and for establishing the feast of Our Lady of the Holy Rosary.
    [Show full text]
  • Mt. St. Michael CATHOLIC DOCTRINE CLASS
    Mt. St. Michael CATHOLIC DOCTRINE CLASS “A Study of Tumultuous Times – Part II” By Frs. Dominic & Francisco Radecki, CMRI ALL AUDIO RECORDINGS AND STUDY SHEETS OF ALL CLASSES MAY BE DOWNLOADED FROM http://tinyurl.com/TumultTimes January 16, 2018 Part C – The Tridentine Latin Mass and the New Mass, pre-Vatican II changes by John XXIII: St. Joseph’s name in the Canon, suppression of Last Gospel, introducing the vernacular into the Liturgy, changes in church architecture, pp. 387-394 A. Outstanding Resources 1. Quo Primum of Pope St. Pius V, July 14, 1570 2. Letter of Cardinals Ottaviani and Bacci to Paul VI, September 25, 1969, called the famous “Ottaviani Intervention,” easily obtained by a simple Internet search 3. Work of Human Hands, by Fr. Anthony Cekada, 2010, obtainable from www.sggresources.org, called “the definitive traditionalist critique of the New Mass” 4. Tumultuous Times, by Frs. Dominic & Francisco Radecki, CMRI, 2004, obtainable from Mary Immaculate Queen Center. B. Can the Mass ever be changed? 1. The essence of it was established by Jesus Christ, and no one, not even a Pope, can change what was thus divinely established. 2. Though a Pope cannot change the substance of the Mass, he can change the accidents, or non-essentials, of the Mass a. This is how the Mass developed organically through the centuries. b. True Popes have also made incidental changes to the Mass, e.g. the Holy Week changes of Pope Pius XII in 1955. 3. Quo Primum was the strongest Papal statement that no one, not even a Cardinal, could authorize changes in the Mass.
    [Show full text]
  • 005-Santa Susanna
    (005/11) Santa Susanna Santa Susanna is an 15th century monastic and titular church. It is on the Piazza San Bernardo, on the Via XX Settembre just north-west of the Piazza della Repubblica and its metro station in the rione Trevi. The dedication is to St Susanna, and the full official title is Santa Susanna alle Terme di Diocleziano. (1) History A church at Santa Susanna commemorates the place where, according to St. Jerome, a young Christian woman was martyred for refusing to worship Rome's pagan gods. Around the year 290 Susanna was residing with her father, Christian presbyter Gabinus, right next door to her saintly uncle Pope Caius (283-296), and in the shadows of the Emperor Diocletian's (284-305) immense baths. After refusing to break a vow of virginity to marry her insistent suitor Maximianus Galerius (none other than the Emperor's adopted son and heir), Susanna also balked at offering a pagan sacrifice, and was beheaded in her own home. The church of Santa Susanna is one of the oldest titles of Rome. The first Christian place of worship was built here in the 4th century. It was probably the titulus of Pope Caius (283-296). The early Christian church was built on the remains of three Roman villas, and was located immediately outside the fence of the Baths of Diocletian and close to the Servian walls. (8) First church By tradition, the church was built in 330, and named San Caio after the owner of the first chapel. In 590, the church was rededicated to St Susan because of her growing popularity.
    [Show full text]
  • SAINTS Hnip-²À
    SAINTS hnip-²À {InkvXphnsâ amXrI ASp-¯-\p-I-cn¨v kzÀ¤ k½m-\-¯n\v AÀl-cm-Ip-¶-h-sc-bmWv ‘hnip-²À’ (Saints) F¶p hnfn- ¡p-¶-Xv. {InkvXp-hn-epÅ hn-izm-k-¯n\pw Ahn-Sps¯ BZÀi-§Ä¡pw th−n Poh³t]mepw _en -I-gn-¨n-«pÅ ss{IkvX-h-sc-bmWv k` càkm-£n-I-fmbn (Martyr) _lp-am-\n-¡p-¶-Xv. 1 St. Alphonsa hn. AÂt^m³km Native Place Kudamaloor, Kerala, India Date of Birth 1910 August 19 Died on 1946 July 28 Feast day July 28 First official Indian Saint - The first person of Indian origin canonized as a saint by the Catholic Church and the first canonized saint of the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church, Beautified on 8th Feb 1986 at Kottayam by Pope John Paul II and Canonised on 12th October 2008 at Vatican City by Pope Benedict XVI. (First name of St. Alphonsa - Annamkutty, Parents-Joseph and Mary Muttathupadathu, School education Arpookara, Muttuchura, Vazhappally and Changanacherry. Nun in Clares convent at Bharananganam) 2 St. Agnes (Agnes of Rome) hn. Bákv Native Place Rome Year of Birth 290 / 291 / 292 Died in 304 Feast day January 21 She is one of seven women, excluding the Blessed Virgin, commemorated by name in the Canon of the Mass. She is the patron saint of chastity, gardeners, girls, engaged couples, rape victims, and virgins. 3 St. Albert of Jerusalem hn. BÂ_À«v Native Place Parma, Italy Year of Birth 1149 Died on 1214 September 25 Feast day September 25 Albert was the bishop of Bobbio.
    [Show full text]
  • ST. JOHN XXIII PARIS H 1 Arcade Street ● West Seneca, New York 14224 Office Hours: 9:00Am - 2:00Pm (M-F) (716) 823-1090 ● Rev
    ST. JOHN XXIII PARIS H 1 Arcade Street ● West Seneca, New York 14224 Office Hours: 9:00am - 2:00pm (M-F) (716) 823-1090 ● www.stjohn23.com Rev. John E. Stanton, Pastor Rev. Msgr. Kevin T. O’Neill Jennifer Lang, Director of Faith Formation Kathy Skomski, Administrative Assistant Toni Drzewiecki, Administrative Assistant Bill Fay, Director of Music Bill Morris, Buildings & Grounds April 26, 2020 Masses: Sat. 4:00pm (Vigil), Sun. 8:30am & 10:30am Weekday: 8:30am (M-F) Reconciliation: Sat. 3:00pm Week of April 26, 2020 ST. JOHN XXIII PARISH Stewardship in Faith: From the Desk of Fr. John For the week of April 19, 2020: No Collection Once again I offer a warm virtual welcome to our Pa- rishioners — I really miss you! Keep in mind that eve- Help Us! With no Sunday Mass, we ry Sunday of Easter is unique and builds upon the pri- were not able to take up a collection. or week. On this Third Sunday of Easter, we celebrate the Would you kindly mail it to our Par- fact that we are called to be witnesses to the Resurrection — ish? As you know, our collection in our manner of speaking and conducting ourselves. In es- revenue is down overall, and without regular sence, radiating the saving power and joy of God. In a time contributions we will experience problems with of social distancing, we can still model what it means to fol- bills. Please prayerfully consider increasing low the Lord — by the way we use the true gift of Easter, Resurrection, in our interactions with those we love.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Issue of the Shepherd's Flock Report!
    Special Issue of the Shepherd’s Flock Report! Teachable Moment…..Election of a pope! Inside this special Issue are Background information for catechists and activities for our students. Who is the Pope? ACTIVITY—Qualities of a Pope. The title pope, once used with far greater lati- Have the students talk about what the qualities tude (see below, section V), is at present em- of a good selection of pope should possess. ployed solely to denote the Bishop of Rome, Make a list of the things thy name. who, in virtue of his position as successor of After a few minutes read the story of the God St. Peter, is the chief pastor of the whole Shepherd and or the 23rd Psalm. (both are on Church, the Vicar of Christ upon earth. the next page) Explain the meaning of scriptures. Besides the bishopric of the Roman Dio- cese, certain other dignities are held by the Jesus is the shepherd who cares for all people. pope as well as the supreme and universal The Pope is the shepherd of the flock on earth pastorate: he is Archbishop of the Roman We are that flock. Province, Primate of Italy and the adjacent What other qualities of the pope should we islands, and sole Patriarch of the Western add to the list. Then hang the list in the hall- Church. The Church's doctrine as to the way . The list can be done on butcher paper pope was authoritatively declared in the Vatican Council in the Constitution "Pastor that is in the closet in room 6.
    [Show full text]
  • What's New Archive 2012
    What’s New? What’s New Archive What’s New Archive 2012 12/22/12 – New or revised RJMI works: RJMI books: Apostate Antipope Pius IX from at Least March 17, 1856 (This book replaced the RJMI article “Pius IX Denied the Salvation Dogma and Lost His Office.” I also added a section titled “Suspicion of being a Freemason”) Heresy and Heretics RJMI articles: Banned from Office for Simony or Secret Formal Heresy Cajetan’s and Bellarmine’s Heresies on Formal Heretics and Loss of Papal Office Fallible Vatican Council of 1870, The Good-without-Grace Heresy Taught by Aquinas and Popes History of the Solemn and the Ordinary Magisterium Popes Do Not Always Condemn Their Predecessors’ Crimes Popes, Antipopes, Possible Antipopes, and Presumed Antipopes Putative Officeholders and Laws Articles by Non-Catholics: The Washington Monument’s Stone from Rome and Masonic Consecration Corrections: 1) Not only public formal heretics but also occult formal heretics are banned from holding offices in the Catholic Church. This is based upon the solemn and the ordinary magisterium basic dogma that all formal heretics, even occult (secret) ones, are not members of the Catholic Church and thus not Catholic. As a result of this basic dogma, it is a solemn and an ordinary magisterium deeper dogma that all formal heretics, even secret ones, cannot hold offices in the Catholic Church because they are not members of the Catholic Church and not Catholic and thus cannot have power or rights over Catholics, which was taught by the unanimous consensus of the Church Fathers and solemnly defined by Paul IV in 1559 in his Bull Cum ex Apostolatus Officio.
    [Show full text]
  • Regnum Christi
    Saint Francis Exchange The Newsletter and Bulletin of the Oratory of Saint Francis of Assisi APRIL 2018 – PACHALTIDE incorruption; and this mortal death, we shall be also in the LETTER FROM must put on immortality. And likeness of His Resurrection. THE MONSIGNOR when this mortal hath put on (Roman 6:1 – 5).This is the joy OR a Now I make known immortality, then shall come to of Easter! pass the saying that is written: It has been a while since unto you, brethren, the Death is swallowed up in I have been able to get the Gospel which I preached to victory. O death, where is thy latest edition of this newsletter you, which also you have victory? O death, where is thy to you all and I am grateful for sting? Now the sting of death is your patience. Quite a bit has received, and wherein you sin: and the power of sin is the happened since we began Holy stand; By which also you are law. But thanks be to God, who Lent: there was the twentieth saved, if you hold fast after hath given us the victory anniversary of the Priestly what manner I preached unto through our Lord Jesus Christ (I Ordination of the Reverend Corinthians 15:51-57). Father Matthew P. Howard, you, unless you have believed Holy Week and Easter, and, in vain. For I delivered unto alas, the passing of long-time you first of all, which I also parishioner Mr. William D. Schiermeyer. received: how that Christ died The world seems in for our sins, according to the more conflict; poor Francis of scriptures: And that He was NewRome losing his mind, or at least his faith (if he even has buried, and that He rose again it to lose).
    [Show full text]
  • Pius X Opposed WWI - Buried at St
    Pius X Opposed WWI - Buried at St. Peter's Basilica This is the Presentation Chapel, within Saint Peter's Basilica, and its alter. It is dedicated to Pope Pius X who is buried under the alter. From the Guide to St. Peter's Basilica, we learn more about this interesting place: Before this altar was dedicated to St. Pius X, it was known as the altar of the Presentation of the Virgin Mary in the Temple. She is portrayed as a little girl joyfully going up the steps to the temple with her parents Anne and Joachim. This event is magnificently depicted in mosaic by Romanelli to drawings by the painter Carlo Maratta. Below the altar, is a crystal coffin containing the body of St. Pius X (1904-1914), "pauper et dives, mitis et humilis corde” ["poor and rich, meek and lowly of heart"]. The body is dressed in pontifical robes, while the face and hands are covered with silver. The world greatly admired his wisdom and firm government. He helped restore Christian life by issuing wise laws on the religious education of children, youths and adults. His catechism gives clear answers to many religious questions. He allowed young children to take Communion, promoted the practice of daily communion as a source of virtue and holiness, he reformed the liturgy in the Missal and Breviary as well as sacred music and Gregorian chant. He fought against and condemned modernism which is still the cause of many evils. He was, however, unable to convince the reigning monarch and heads of state of his era to avoid the conflict that would shed blood throughout Europe for four long years.
    [Show full text]
  • The Roman Missal and Its Historical Development Sister Marie A
    6 • roMaN MissaL February 25, 2011 The Roman Missal And Its Historical Development Sister Marie A. Leonard, O.S.B., Director of O ce of Lay Ministry he Church throughout its history has used many contained all the texts that were used in the Mass at that Order of the Mass and the General Instruction. Unlike the liturgical books, such as Book of Blessings, Rite of time: rubrics, prayers, reading, and antiphons. Its use was Roman Missal of Pius V, this did not contain the scripture Anointing and Pastoral Care of the Sick, Rite of mandated for all Roman Rite Catholic dioceses. An exception readings, which were now in a separate book called the TMarriage, Liturgy of the Hours, etc. Two of the most familiar was made for religious orders and diocese whose liturgies were Lectionary. In 1970, both books were published and the are the Sacramentatry and the Lectionary. On Sun- Vatican approved the rst English translation of days, there is an additional lectionary, the Book of the Order of the Mass for use in the United States. the Gospels. e Lectionary contains the scriptural Key Events On Feb. 4, 1974, the Vatican approved the English readings, responsorial psalms and verse before the translation of the Sacramentary for the United gospels for weekdays, Sundays, and special days. States. The Roman Missal contains the prescribed prayers and is book is the companion of the Sacramentary, A second edition of the Missale Romanum, which a somewhat larger book which includes, among instructions for the celebration of Mass in the Roman included new prayers and rubrics, was issued in other things, the General Introduction to the Ro- Catholic Church.
    [Show full text]
  • Pope St. Pius V
    Pope St. Pius V Michele Ghislieri OP Lived 1504-1572 Pope 1566-1572 Historical Background Council of Trent Protestant and the Counter Reformation Reformation Good and bad The Empire, the popes French and other political Nepotism intrigue Politics of Europe Emerging Western Capitalism and world colonisation. Holy Roman Empire (based in the Kingdom of Germany) Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor 1519-1556 Ferdinand I, Holy Roman Emperor 1558-1564 Maximillian II, Holy Roman Emperor 1564-1576 France Medieval Popes The Counts of Tuscolo and Segni, the Medici dynasty of Florence, the Borgia dynasty of Jativa, etc., etc. 16 noble Italian families. Nepotism. Sequence of canonised popes Pope St. Gregory VII, 1073-1085 Pope St. Pius V, 1566-1572 Pope St. Pius X, 1903-1914 The Protestant Reformation (The new) St. Peter’s Basilica Selling of indulgences (Pope Leo X, 1513-1521) Martin Luther’s 95 theses, 1517 Council of Trent (1545 to 1563) Martin Luther Pope Leo X The Council of Trent The embodiment of the Counter-Reformation 1545-1563 Pope Paul III: 1545–47 Pope Julius III: 1551–52 Pope Marcellus II (short papacy) Pope Paul IV (no interest) Pope Pius IV: 1562–63 Trent: Northern Italy Early life Bosco Born Antonio Ghislieri Michele Ghislieri OP Cardinal Michele Alessandrino Pope Pius V Early Dominican years “The most powerful aid we can bring to this study is the practice of earnest prayer. The more closely the mind is united to God, the richer will be the stores of light that follow its researches.” Professor of theology. Prior of Vigevano, Soncino and then Alba.
    [Show full text]
  • English Jesuit Paper
    Carolyn Vinnicombe Recusancy and Regicide: The Flawed Strategy of the Jesuit Mission in Elizabethan England In pursuing their goals of reviving the religious zeal of the English Catholic community by converting them to religious opposition in the later sixteenth and earlier seventeenth centuries, the drivers of the Jesuit mission in England, under the guidance of the Jesuit Robert Persons, failed. They did so not because Catholic doctrine lacked appeal in protestant Elizabethan England, but because their conversion strategy was wholly unsuited to the political realities of the times. Instead, the aggregate efects of the Church’s clerical infighting over the issues of conformity and disputation as a conversion device, failure to understand the practical needs of the average Catholic, and Person’s ill-fated political plotting polarized the English against the Jesuits and created a religious and political environment so toxic that it cannibalized the mission’s own conversion eforts. Though the Jesuits saw later success with the publication of their non-polemic spiritual texts, they never succeeded in gaining back the ground they lost as a result of their catastrophic early strategy. I The issue of conformity to the Elizabethan Settlement of 1569 presented a dilemma without an absolute solution for the English Catholic community. When Pope Pius V’s Regans in Excelsis of 1570, excommunicated the queen, and prompted her regime to mandate attendance at protestant services, it left English Catholics floundering to find traction on the plane of religious devotion. Could they still call themselves Catholics if they yielded to the state and attended protestant services, but maintained Catholicism in their hearts, or were only those who defied the state and refused to attend services worthy of the “Catholic” label and, indeed, salvation? This was a question for which neither the laity nor the Church had a clear answer.
    [Show full text]