FORMER INMATES' PERCEPTIONS and BELIEFS ABOUT the VALUE of EARNING a HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA a DISSERTATION in Educational Leaders
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FORMER INMATES’ PERCEPTIONS AND BELIEFS ABOUT THE VALUE OF EARNING A HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA A DISSERTATION IN Educational Leadership, Policy and Foundations Education and Social Science Consortium Presented to the Faculty of the University of Missouri-Kansas City in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY by Michael Thomas B.A., Saint Leo University, 2000 M.A., Chapman University, 2005 Kansas City, Missouri 2019 © 2019 MICHAEL THOMAS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED FORMER INMATES’ PERCEPTION AND BELIEFS ABOUT THE VALUE OF EARNING A HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA Michael Thomas, Candidate for the Doctor of Education Degree University of Missouri-Kansas City, 2019 ABSTRACT Previous studies on correctional education have focused on recidivism. There is limited research from a qualitative perspective on the perceptions of education prior to incarceration. This constructivist narratological case study sought to explore the lived experiences of six former inmates, four African American and two Mexican American from a Midwest Correctional Facility who entered prison without a high school diploma and worked in Prison Industries. Data sources involved a Likert scale questionnaire, documents, and in-depth semi-structured interviews. Analysis involved descriptive statistical analysis of the Likert scale items, and content analysis for documents, and indepth interviews with narratives of the cases developed using a three-dimensional analysis process and socio- cultural analysis followed by within case and cross case analyses. Major themes were: (a) making ends meet; (b) influences within the community; (c) family dynamics; (d school environment; and (e) school-to-prison pipeline. Findings indicated that participants placed a greater value on education post incarceration. iii APPROVAL PAGE The faculty listed below, appointed by the Dean of the School of Education, have examined a dissertation titled “Former Inmates’ Perceptions and Beliefs About The Value of Earning a High School Diploma,” presented by Michael Thomas, candidate for the Doctor of Philosophy degree , and certify that in their opinion it is worthy of acceptance. Supervisory Committee Loyce Caruthers, PhD, Committee Chair Educational Leadership, Policy, & Foundations Linwood F. Tauheed Department of Economics Donna Davis, Ph.D. Division of Educational Leadership, Policy & Foundations Juan C. Gonzalez, Ph.D. California State University, Fresno Kremen School of Education and Human Development Donna Russell, Ph.D Capella University Department of Educational Psychology iv CONTENTS ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................... iii LIST OF TABLES .............................................................................................................. ix AKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................................................... x PREFACE ........................................................................................................................... xi Chapter 1. INTRODUCTION TO STUDY.........................................................................................1 Statement of the Problem. ............................................................................... 3 Purpose and Research Questions .................................................................. 11 Research Questions ........................................................................... 12 Overview of the Theoretical Framework .......................................... 13 Theoretical Framework and Literature Review ............................................ 13 Critical Race Theory ......................................................................... 15 Socio-political Foundation for Forming Dropping-out .................... 18 Correctional Education ..................................................................... 20 Prison Industries ............................................................................... 22 Overview of the Methodology ...................................................................... 25 Significance of the Study .............................................................................. 28 2. LITERATURE REVIEW ..................................................................................... 32 Critical Race Theories in Education ............................................................. 34 Critical Race Theory ......................................................................... 35 Latino Critical Race Theory ............................................................. 36 Prison Industries ............................................................................... 67 Theories and Predictors of Why Students Drop Out ........................ 68 v Latinx Students and the Phenomenon of Dropping Out ................... 72 African American Students and the Phenomenon of Dropping Out ................................................................................... 78 Correctional Education ................................................................................. 84 Correctional Studies .......................................................................... 88 Policies that Affect Correctional Education ..................................... 92 Post-Secondary Education ................................................................ 96 Post-release Employment Opportunities and Prison Stigma ............ 98 Prison Industries ......................................................................................... 103 Economic Impact of Prison Industries ............................................ 104 Types of Prison Industries .............................................................. 107 Criticisms of Prison Industries ........................................................ 109 Conclusion .................................................................................................. 107 3. METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................ 109 Research Questions ..................................................................................... 110 Rationale for Qualitative Research ............................................................. 111 Case Study ...................................................................................... 112 Narratology ..................................................................................... 114 Constructivism ................................................................................ 117 The Role of the Researcher ......................................................................... 119 The Design of the Study ............................................................................. 121 Setting ............................................................................................. 121 Sampling Procedures and Participants ............................................ 121 Data Collection ......................................................................................... 123 vi Field Notes ............................................................................................... 128 Data Analysis ........................................................................................................ 129 Analysis of Questionnaire ........................................................................ 129 Analysis of Qualitative Data .................................................................... 131 Narrative Analysis .................................................................................... 132 Within-case and Cross-case Analysis....................................................... 134 Limitations — Validity, Reliability and Ethical Considerations ........................... 135 Validity and Reliability .......................................................................... 136 Triangulation and Crystallization ........................................................... 139 Ethical Considerations ............................................................................ 140 4. FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ...................................................................... 142 Pre-Interview Questionnaire ....................................................................... 145 Participants’ Cases ...................................................................................... 147 Participant One: Harry .................................................................... 148 Participant Two: Michael ............................................................... 155 Participant Three: John ................................................................... 163 Participant Four: Bruce ................................................................... 167 Participant Five: Jesus .................................................................... 172 Participant Six: Carlos .................................................................... 178 Summary ......................................................................................... 185 Findings to the Research Questions............................................................ 186 Summary ..................................................................................................... 189 5. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................. 191 Looking Inward and Outward ....................................................................