Medals and Awards for 1981 Presentation of the Penrose Medal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Medals and Awards for 1981 Presentation of the Penrose Medal to John Rodgers CITATION BY STEVEN S. ORIEL Cordilleran thrust-belt students, both in Canada and in the United States have emphasized during the past decade or so that Some of you may remember that John Rodgers served as a crystalline basement generally is not involved in the tight foreland Medal citationist in 1963. At that time, John recalled that he and deformation. That concept, of course, was deftly illuminated in fellow graduate students attended the 1938 Fiftieth Anniversary 1949 by John Rodgers, who, while acknowledging his debt to John banquet of the Society, in happy anonymity away from this uncom- L. Rich, defined the thin-skinned and thick-skinned attributes of fortable spotlight, and amused themselves by exchanging remarks both Appalachian tectonic analyses and the geologists who study about the speakers. The Penrose Medalist's response that year different parts of that beast. Other contributions by John have included a generous dose of advice for the youngsters on how they, included emphasis on the significance of the internal metamorphic too, might build exalted careers and perhaps some day earn the belt, definition of the history of orogeny, and attempts to define the Medal. John concluded his citation preface with the statement: "I early continental margin. don't intend to repeat that advice (it's pretty obvious it never did me John is a frequent and active participant in conferences and any good). ." All of which establishes that John's crystal ball is field trips, not only in the Appalachians, but in mountain belts no less clouded than yours or mine. throughout the world. His incisive observations are invariably con- If that advice was not entirely heeded, how then did John structive. His discussions, like his monumental book, The Tectonics Rodgers come to merit a place among our distinguished company of the Appalachians, reflect a spirit of inquiry and search for truth. of Penrose Medalists? John's own words, in his citation for Medalist Bill Rubey, apply John has earned an enviable reputation as a pre-eminent earth most eloquently to himself: scientist, as a great teacher, as a distinguished and gifted editor, as an accomplished pianist, as a proficient linguist, as a historian, He isn't out to proclaim triumphantly that he has at last found the theory and as a raconteur. that explains all the facts; he's out to find out what those facts really are and The stories about John are legion, but one concerning his then diffidently to suggest that perhaps such or such a theory will help to explain them. linguistic ability may be appropriate. His students have always been in awe of his ability to stay abreast of the international literature, ... he recognizes the proper role of the theoretician: to do his part with all whatever the language. But one student with an inquiring mind the rest in obtaining, analyzing, and evaluating the facts and in building asked a prominent French geologist how John's spoken French partial hypotheses and temporary explanations that will further our com- served him in discussions during a sabbatical in Paris. The response mon goal, the gradual construction of a more nearly perfect theory. was, "Hearing John speak French gives one courage to try English." So much for his French; I do not know about his German, Russian, It seems particularly appropriate and timely that the Society Chinese, and Greek. again chose this year to honor a teacher. Discussions in the hallways But few have ever tried to play the piano after John had dem- indicate that earth-scence education has seldom been in greater onstrated his virtuosity. And very few of his more distinguished jeopardy. Classrooms are being abandoned in the scramble for students have chosen to pursue work in the Appalachians; most higher salaries, yet the demand for earth scientists has never been have moved on to other mountain systems of the world. greater (which obviously presents industry with a responsibility that John's outstanding contributions to an understanding of the it has yet to address adequately). John is not only a dedicated Appalachian Mountain System are known to almost everyone in teacher, but also an enthusiastic and inspired one. And his personal this room. Not only has he looked at, poked at, and worked on demands are few: all he needs is a little travel money, some white details of local geology from Newfoundland to Alabama, but he has socks, a wide necktie, and a Resident's suite at one of the Yale stimulated many studies by others. Allegations that he simply fol- colleges with sufficient room for a grand piano. He has served lowed a family tradition begun in the previous century by the longer as a Resident-Fellow at Branford College than anyone else at Rodgers brothers are unfounded; his association with the Appal- Yale, where he continues to welcome wide-ranging discussions with achians began in 1933 when he attended a Cornell University field undergraduates, whatever their interests. camp in Pennsylvania, after his interest in geology had been kindled Among the first graduate courses that John taught at Yale was at the Albany Academy and at the New York State Museum in one on stratigraphy. It consisted of a delightful series of discussions Albany. He worked in Vermont for his master's thesis and in east- of sedimentation and stratigraphic principles. Each discussion ern Tennessee for his Ph.D., and has been studying field relations seemed fresh and relaxed, indeed even undirected. Yet when that ever since. Rumor has it that he may even complete a geologic map class prepared for the final exam, those who had taken extensive of Connecticut, but E-An Zen is not betting on it. notes recognized that they had the first beautifully organized and Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 93, p. 357-369, 7 figs., April 1982. 357 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/93/4/369/3419646/i0016-7606-93-4-369.pdf by guest on 24 September 2021 358 MEDALS AND AWARDS FOR 19131 completed draft of an outstanding book on stratigraphy, later pub- coming when needed by staff members. He did make waves, lished as the classic textbook, Principles of Stratigraphy, by Dun- though. Whenever he traveled on Society business, accommoda- bar and Rodgers. Incidentally, John is also very skillful in tions had to be found adequate to house not only him but also a defending a doctoral dissertation—he did a superb job in defending grand piano—a piano that had to be found and rented at his mine! expense. John's students have always known of his enthusiasm and skill Among John's outstanding contributions to our profession has as a teacher and of the stimulation he evokes. Some of this stimulus been his steady and con tinuing commitment for more than 30 years has even spilled over into some obscure Ivy-league institutions and to editing Silliman's Journal, the American Journal of Science. into more field-oriented schools from Blacksburg to Tallahassee. Coincidentally, he has also occupied the Benjamin Silliman chair in Many students at these universities have benefited from his interest geology at Yale since 1962. As has been acknowledged by others, and comments, especially at meetings. every issue of AJS bears the stamp of his critical mind, insistence on John further serves his profession and his nation in one other quality, relish for controversy, and enthusiasm for diversity. The important way: he instills in his students, mainly by his own exam- AJS "John Rodgers volume," published in 1975 while he was on ple, a sense of the responsibilities of good citizenship. He has served sabbatical, remains must-reading for anyone interested in tectonics not only this Society, but other local and international groups, in and mountain ranges. Other journals have much to learn from his numerous ways. So, too, have many of his students. Not because of dedicated and able stewardship. old school ties, but because of our obligations as members of our Despite John's enviable accomplishments, he perennially dis- several communities—to serve, rather than to covet titles. plays an interest in people and concern for them. Controversy is The GSA staff recalls John's term as President of the Society in hardly shunned, but there is never rancor. 1970 as not only productive but tranquil. What a tribute to his The selection of this year's Medalist is singularly appropriate, leadership! His advice, support, and guidance were always forth- for John is the kind of scientist for whom the Medal was intended. RESPONSE BY JOHN RODGERS The Penrose Medal has been something important for me ever since I was in college. In 1934, when I was just a junior geology major at Cornell University, I went to my first GSA meeting and witnessed for the first time the award of the Penrose Medal, when it was only seven years old. It made a deep impression on me. I've been to a large majority of the GSA meetings since then, and at most of them I've witnessed the award of the Medal, as, one after another, many of the great geologists of my young years were honored. Several of those occasions were, like the first one, out- standing moments in my life. So the Penrose Medal became for me a symbol of the geologists I most looked up to. But now, this time, I'm not a witness any more, I'm the one standing here. I tell you, it's scary, to be judged by the standards set by all the geologists who have been Medalists in the past, to have to ask myself soberly whether I measure up to the qualifications that Penrose spelled out for the medal he established.