S N L I Volume 68 Number 2 • Summer 2009 CONTRIBUTORS Vi
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Slavic Review INTERDISCIPLINARY QUARTERLY OF RUSSIAN, EURASIAN, AND EAST EUROPEAN STUDIES volume 68 number 2 • summer 2009 CONTRIBUTORS vi ABSTRACTS viii LETTER FROM THE EDITOR xi EMOTIONAL TURN? FEELINGS IN RUSSIAN HISTORY AND CULTURE Jan Plamper, Special Section Guest Editor Introduction 229 jan plamper The Perception of Emotional Coldness in Andrei 238 Turgenev’s diaries andrei zorin Fear: Soldiers and Emotion in Early Twentieth-Century 259 Russian Military Psychology jan plamper Poetics of Disgust: To Eat and Die in Andrei Belyi’s Petersburg 284 olga matich “With a Shade of Disgust”: Affective Politics of Sexuality 308 and Class in Memoirs of the Stalinist Gulag adi kuntsman Comment 329 S william m. reddy N L i SS5106.indb5106.indb i 44/23/09/23/09 111:36:061:36:06 AAMM ARTICLES Between Ideology and Desire: Rhetoric of the Self in the Works 335 of Nikolai Chernyshevskii and Nikolai Dobroliubov konstantine klioutchkine The Covert Design of The Brothers Karamazov: 355 Alesha’s Pathology and Dialectic james l. rice Pollution and Purifi cation in the Moscow Human Rights 376 Networks of the 1960s and 1970s barbara walker FEATURED REVIEWS Paula M. Pickering, Peacebuilding in the Balkans: The View 396 from the Ground Floor (Sari Wastell) Richard Taruskin, On Russian Music (Simon Morrison) 398 BOOK REVIEWS Manfred Hildermeier, ed. Historical Concepts between Eastern 402 and Western Europe (Pavel Kolárˇ) Michal Kopecˇek, ed., Past in the Making: Historical Revisionism 403 in Central Europe after 1989 (Péter Apor) Oksana Sarkisova and Péter Apor, eds., Past for the Eyes: 405 East European Representations of Communism in Cinema and Museums after 1989 (Stefan Troebst) Desanka Schwara, Unterwegs: Reiseerfahrung zwischen 406 Heimat und Fremde in der Neuzeit (Larry Wolff) Howard N. Lupovitch, Jews at the Crossroads: Tradition and 407 Accommodation during the Golden Age of the Hungarian Nobility, 1729–1878 (Tim Cole) Robin Okey, Taming Balkan Nationalism: The Habsburg 408 “Civilizing Mission” in Bosnia, 1878–1918 (Robert J. Donia) Stefano Bottoni, Transilvania rossa: Il Communismo romeno e 410 la questione nazionale (1944 –1965); Alberto Basciani, La diffi cile unione: La Bessarabia e la Grande Romania, 1918–1940 (Florin Anghel) Armin Heinen, Rumänien, der Holocaust und die Logik der 411 Gewalt (Keith Hitchins) S N Phillip T. Rutherford, Prelude to the Final Solution: The Nazi Program 412 L for Deporting Ethnic Poles, 1939–1941 ( Jonathan Huener) ii SS5106.indb5106.indb iiii 44/23/09/23/09 111:36:071:36:07 AAMM Elazar Barkan, Elizabeth A. Cole, and Kai Struve, eds., Shared 413 History—Divided Memory: Jews and Others in Soviet-Occupied Poland, 1939–1941 (Phillip T. Rutherford) Philipp Ther, In der Mitte der Gesellschaft: Operntheater in 415 Zentraleuropa 1815–1914 (Nancy M. Wingfi eld) John Tyrrell, Janácˇek: Years of a Life. Vol. 2, (1914 –1928): 416 Tsar of the Forests (Brian Locke) Donna A. Buchanan, ed., Balkan Popular Culture and the 417 Ottoman Ecumene: Music, Image, and Regional Political Discourse (Timothy Rice) Sharon L. Wolchik and Jane L. Curry, eds., Central and 419 East European Politics: From Communism to Democracy (Andrew C. Janos) Joan DeBardeleben, ed., The Boundaries of EU Enlargement: 420 Finding a Place for Neighbours (Oliver Schmidtke) Katrina Z. S. Schwartz, Nature and National Identity after 421 Communism: Globalizing the Ethnoscape ( Joan DeBardeleben) Grigory Ioffe, Understanding Belarus and How Western 422 Foreign Policy Misses the Mark (Elena Gapova) Vadim Kukushkin, From Peasants to Labourers: Ukrainian 423 and Belarusan Immigration from the Russian Empire to Canada (Lubomyr Luciuk) Bruce Grant and Lale Yalçın-Heckmann, eds., Caucasus 424 Paradigms: Anthropologies, Histories, and the Making of a World Area (Russell Zanca) Robert Romanchuk, Byzantine Hermeneutics and Pedagogy 426 in the Russian North: Monks and Masters at the Kirillo- Belozerskii Monastery, 1397–1501 (Donald Ostrowski) John Charmley, The Princess and the Politicians: Sex, Intrigue 427 and Diplomacy, 1812– 40; Judith Lissauer Cromwell, Dorothea Lieven: A Russian Princess in London and Paris, 1785–1857; Radosław Pawel Z˙ urawski vel Grajewski, Ksie¸z˙ na Dorothea Lieven wobec Polski i Polaków ( J. M. P. McErlean) Alison K. Smith, Recipes for Russia: Food and Nationhood 429 under the Tsars (Louise McReynolds) Andreas Schönle, The Ruler in the Garden: Politics and Landscape 430 Design in Imperial Russia (Mary W. Cavender) Stella Rock, Popular Religion in Russia: “Double Belief” 431 and the Making of an Academic Myth (Chris J. Chulos) S Wendy Rosslyn, Deeds Not Words: The Origins of Women’s 433 N Philanthropy in the Russian Empire ( Joseph Bradley) L iii SS5106.indb5106.indb iiiiii 44/23/09/23/09 111:36:071:36:07 AAMM Annegret Bautz, Sozialpolitik statt Wohltätigkeit? Der 434 Konzeptionswandel städtischer Fürsorge in Sankt Petersburg von 1892 bis 1914 ( Julia Obertreis) Felix Patrikeeff and Harold Shukman, Railways and the 435 Russo-Japanese War: Transporting War (Matthew J. Payne) Sarah Badcock, Politics and the People in Revolutionary Russia: 436 A Provincial History (Michael Melancon) Hiroaki Kuromiya, The Voices of the Dead: Stalin’s Great Terror 437 in the 1930s (Wendy Goldman) G. A. Iankovskaia, Iskusstvo, denЈgi i politika: Khudozhnik v 438 gody pozdnego stalinizma (Stuart Finkel) A. M. Dubrovskii, Istorik i vlastЈ: Istoricheskaia nauka v SSSR i 440 kontseptsiia istorii feodalЈnoi Rossii v kontekste politiki i ideologii (1930 –1950-e gg.) (George Enteen) David S. Foglesong, The American Mission and the “Evil Empire”: 441 The Crusade for a “Free Russia” since 1881 (Daniela Spenser) Jan C. Behrends, Die erfundene Freundschaft: Propaganda für die 442 Sowjetunion in Polen und der DDR 1944 –1957 (Patrick Hyder Patterson) Lorenz M. Lüthi, The Sino-Soviet Split: Cold War in the Communist 443 World (Shu Guang Zhang) Edyta M. Bojanowska, Nikolai Gogol: Between Ukrainian and 444 Russian Nationalism (Lina Bernstein) Lyudmila Parts, The Chekhovian Intertext: Dialogue with a Classic 445 (Donald Rayfi eld) Gertraud Marinelli-König, Russische Kinderliteratur in der 446 Sowjetunion der Jahre 1920 –1930 (Larissa Rudova) Marcus C. Levitt and Tatyana Novikov, eds., Times of Trouble: 447 Violence in Russian Literature and Culture (Dan Healey) Rosalind Marsh, Literature, History and Identity in Post-Soviet 448 Russia, 1991–2006 (Margaret Ziolkowski) Marina Frolova-Walker, Russian Music and Nationalism: 449 From Glinka to Stalin (Mark Carroll) A. A. Kurbanovskii, Nezapnii mrak: Ocherki po arkheologii 451 vizualЈnosti (Alison Hilton) Ada Raev and Isabel Wünsche, eds., Kursschwankungen: 452 Russische Kunst im Wertesystem der europäischen Moderne ( John Milner and Eva-Viktoria Kwapil) S N William C. Brumfi eld, Velikii ustiug (Ann Kleimola) 453 L iv SS5106.indb5106.indb iivv 44/23/09/23/09 111:36:071:36:07 AAMM Axel Kaehne, Political and Social Thought in Post-Communist 454 Russia (Kathleen E. Smith) Uriel Procaccia, Russian Culture, Property Rights, and the 455 Market Economy (Kathryn Hendley) Marlen LariuelЈ [Marlène Laruelle], ed., Sovremennye 456 interpretatsii russkogo natsionalizma (Vera Tolz) Douglas W. Blum, National Identity and Globalization: Youth, 458 State, and Society in Post-Soviet Eurasia (Luke March) Linda J. Cook, Postcommunist Welfare States: Reform Politics in 459 Russia and Eastern Europe (Stephen Crowley) Gwendolyn Sasse, The Crimea Question: Identity, Transition, 460 and Confl ict (Brian Glyn Williams) Natasha Kuhrt, Russian Policy towards China and Japan: 462 The ElЈtsin and Putin Periods (Nobuo Shimotomai) COLLECTED ESSAYS 464 BOOKS RECEIVED 467 IN MEMORIAM 471 S N L v SS5106.indb5106.indb v 44/23/09/23/09 111:36:081:36:08 AAMM ABSTRACTS __________________________________________________________________ The Perception of Emotional Coldness in Andrei Turgenev’s Diaries Andrei Zorin In this article, Andrei Zorin discusses the generational shift in the tech- niques of self-analysis that occurred in Russia at the turn from the eigh- teenth to the nineteenth centuries as revealed in the diaries of Andrei Turgenev, a document that has attracted the attention of many scholars but still remains largely unpublished. Young Turgenev was infl uenced both by his upbringing in the circles of Moscow Freemasons and by the lit- erature of German Sturm und Drang and especially by the early tragedies by Friedrich Schiller. In his self-refl ections, his dramatic love story, and his attempts to translate Alexander Pope’s Eloisa to Abelard into Russian, Turgenev demonstrated his quest to resemble his favorite literary char- acters and the despair caused by his failure to meet these self-imposed standards. Both his quest and his personality as revealed in the diaries can serve as a symbol of the new emotional culture that emerged in Russia and became prevalent there throughout the Romantic age. Fear: Soldiers and Emotion in Early Twentieth-Century Russian Military Psychology Jan Plamper This article provides an analysis of the locus of fear in military psychol- ogy in late imperial Russia. After the Russo-Japanese War and the 1905 Revolution, the debate coalesced around two poles: “realists” (such as the military psychiatrist Grigorii Shumkov) argued that fear was natural, while “romantics” upheld the image of constitutionally fearless soldiers. Jan Plamper begins by identifying the advent of modern warfare (fore- shadowed by the Crimean War) and its engendering of more and different fears as a key cause for a dramatic increase in fear-talk among Russia’s sol- diers.